The #Colorado Water Conservation Board Board Outlines Next Steps for Near-Term Contribution Program

The Colorado River Basin spans seven U.S. states and is divided into Upper and Lower Basins. Lake Powell, upstream from the Grand Canyon, and Lake Mead, near Las Vegas, are the two principal reservoirs in the Colorado River water-supply system. (Bureau of Reclamation)

Here’s the release from the Colorado Water Conservation Board:

Board rules out agricultural projects for the 2027 irrigation season while directing staff to explore a more limited program

November 19, 2026, GOLDEN โ€” The Colorado Water Conservation Board (CWCB) provided direction Wednesday on the next steps for Colorado’s Near-Term Contribution Program, opting to continue working with federal and Upper Basin partners to address outstanding questions addressed to the Bureau of Reclamation while narrowing the scope of potential projects for 2027.

The Board directed staff to continue coordinating with Reclamation and the other Upper Division States and report back at its January 2027 meeting. Depending on the information and agreements available at that time, Colorado will consider a more limited program for 2027.

Under the Board’s direction, the program will not implement any agricultural projects tied to the irrigation season in Water Year 2027. This is because irrigators and producers need an early application window to plan for their irrigation season. The program may consider other types of projects that align with the Boardโ€™s priorities to provide durable benefits to water users.

โ€œAgriculture is the backbone of the West Slopeโ€™s economy and way of life. Without sufficient assurances from the federal government, itโ€™s inappropriate to rush a program this late in the season,โ€ said Lauren Ris, CWCB Director.

โ€œColorado was โ€“ and is โ€“ ready to launch a federally -funded Contribution Program, and we know that water users and the Board are excited about projects that may provide durable benefits to water users and improve agricultural resiliency,โ€ said Amy Ostdiek, Chief of the Interstate, Federal, and Water Information Section at the CWCB. โ€œBut we know from past efforts that irrigators and producers need an early application window. Given that it is now mid-November, and we still lack the necessary assurances and information from Reclamation, it seems ill-advised to consider agricultural projects for the upcoming irrigation season.โ€

โ€œWeโ€™re committed to being part of the solution and to moving projects forward that benefit water users and communities in Colorado,โ€ said Becky Mitchell, Coloradoโ€™s Commissioner to the Upper Colorado River Commission. โ€œBut we need more information before moving this forward and greater assurances from the Bureau of Reclamation. Weโ€™re not asking for flexibilities that arenโ€™t already afforded to the Lower Basin states.โ€

The Boardโ€™s decision comes as Colorado continues working with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and the other Upper Division States to resolve outstanding questions about how conserved water would be accounted for, credited, and managed within the Colorado River system.

In September, the CWCB approved Colorado’s application review process and project selection criteria for the voluntary, compensated conservation program. That approval was conditioned on an agreement that contributed water would be credited to the Upper Division States in an operationally neutral account under the Upper Divisionโ€™s control.

Since then, Colorado has completed the necessary state-level preparations to implement the program, including developing project criteria, establishing protections for participating water rights, and securing an implementation agreement with Reclamation. Additional federal guidance is still needed regarding project compensation, water accounting, and operational parameters.

In a November 10 response, Reclamation expressed continued support for pursuing the crediting of verified conserved water while noting that certain operational considerations would require broader discussions among the seven Colorado River Basin states.

“Colorado has completed the work needed on our end to prepare for this program, and we remain committed to working with our federal and Upper Basin partners to resolve the remaining questions. Our goal is to ensure that any water conserved through this program is accounted for and provides the intended benefits to the Upper Basin,” Ostdiek said.

The Near-Term Contribution Program is supported by $100 million in federal funding awarded to the Upper Colorado River Commission for efforts across the four Upper Division States: Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming. Those funds remain available through 2031.

The CWCB remains committed to exploring voluntary conservation opportunities that support Colorado water users, contribute to the resilience of the Colorado River Basin, and provide meaningful benefits for participating communities.

What Congressโ€™ bill to speed up energy projects would mean for you: The Senateโ€™s permitting reform bill would make it easier to build renewables โ€” but oil and gas infrastructure, too — Austin Corona (Grist.org) #BAAJA

Click the link to read the article on the Grist website (Austin Corona):

November 18, 2026

The largest renewable energy project ever built in the United States โ€” the sprawling SunZia wind farm and power line in New Mexico โ€” took two decades to build. Its transmission line, necessary to transport the wind power to cities in Arizona and California, faced opposition from birders, the military, and tribes. While some disputes were resolved, tribesโ€™ concerns about the projectโ€™s impacts on historic sites have remained unsettled, leading to court battles that still havenโ€™t been resolved even though the line was completed in June.

Such legal challenges commonly delay renewable energy projects and the transmission lines that carry their power to population centers. The threat of lawsuits and resistance from utilities have driven down long-distance power line construction in the United States, limiting the countryโ€™s ability to use cheap renewable energy.

The Senate passed a โ€œpermitting reformโ€ bill this week that could make it much faster and easier to build transmission lines and renewable energy projects โ€” but it casts a wide net, easing construction for almost all large infrastructure projects. Supporters of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA โ€” including clean energy companies and prominent climate-conscious senators โ€” argue the bill is necessary to clean up the power grid. Critics say it could disempower communities, tribes, and environmental groups while also speeding construction of fossil fuel infrastructure. The bill still needs to pass the House and receive the presidentโ€™s signature before becoming law.

Here are the answers to some basic questions to help you understand the bill, why itโ€™s such a big deal, and why itโ€™s so controversial.

What would this bill do?

At its heart, the bill is an effort to streamline the federal governmentโ€™s process for issuing permits for infrastructure projects, including many large-scale energy and transportation projects. Without these permits, developers canโ€™t build infrastructure on federal land, across state lines, or with certain kinds of federal funding. But companies say getting a permit, and keeping it, is a time-consuming, unpredictable, and costly process, even when their project meets all necessary environmental standards.

Thatโ€™s due in part to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, or NEPA, one of Americaโ€™s bedrock environmental laws. NEPA requires federal agencies to study the environmental, economic, and social impacts of major government actions, including many infrastructure permits. They must consider alternatives to whatโ€™s been proposed, solicit input from the public, and publish their findings. A different law called the National Historic Preservation Act requires agencies to carry out similar reviews of projectsโ€™ repercussions for historic and archaeological sites.

While NEPA doesnโ€™t explicitly hold projects to a higher environmental standard, it creates a formal process that can educate the public, inform government officials, and open pathways to better outcomes. Still, this process often becomes the source of delays. Opponents of a project can sue an agency, claiming it conducted an inadequate review, potentially forcing the government to redo parts of its analysis and halting construction in the meantime โ€” even if the agency ultimately issues the same permit after redoing the analysis. The motivations for these lawsuits can range widely, from wealthy communities trying to protect their property values to tribes defending their sovereignty and religious freedom.

The bill would speed up environmental and historic preservation reviews, narrow the potential impacts agencies must consider, restrict who can sue over them, and shorten the deadline for doing so. Supporters say that would prevent costly delays, which can be particularly consequential for land-intensive renewable energy projects. Critics say it would reduce public scrutiny and make it harder for communities and tribes to identify environmental harms, protect historic or sacred sites, and push developers toward better alternatives.

The bill would also make several changes aimed specifically at the power grid. It would give the federal government greater authority to override states that block interstate power lines and require regional grid operators to approve lines that improve reliability and affordability. Transmission construction in the United States has slowed over the last decade, even as its importance is expected to grow.

Controversially, the bill would also prevent states from using the Clean Water Act to block power lines or pipelines crossing waterways unless they directly discharge into the water. The bill would not affect the vast majority of projects built on private land within one state.

The SunZia transmission line, viewed during its construction through the San Pedro Valley, Arizona, in September 2024. This photo was taken from aboard a flight operated by Ecoflight. Austin Corona / Grist

Would this bill change my community?

Tribes, states, and local groups would have less power to stop or delay some infrastructure projects, and projects could move forward with less time for public scrutiny. That could mean more power lines crossing landscapes and greater risk that communitiesโ€™ concerns donโ€™t get adequately considered.

But experts expect the bill to lower electricity costs slightly over the next 15 years by making it easier to move cheap power between regions, while helping states meet clean energy goals. Households and businesses would likely find it easier to sell electricity from rooftop solar and batteries onto the grid.

Most data centers wouldnโ€™t see big changes because of the bill, as they are overwhelmingly constructed on private land whose development is overseen by local and state governments. (Proposals on federal lands exist, though they often involve significant legal issues that this bill would not necessarily change). The bill could accelerate the power and pipeline infrastructure that benefits data centers, but it would also require them to pay for grid upgrades they need and increase transparency around their electricity use. The bill could also make data centersโ€™ power cleaner by making it easier for them to connect to grids with clean energy, rather than building polluting, off-grid gas turbines.

Would this bill be good for the climate?

The bill would enable energy infrastructure generally, meaning fossil fuel projects could grow alongside renewables. The advantage would likely tip toward renewable energy, according to projections from some organizations, though predicting future energy markets is tricky. Some experts believe the bill would make it harder for future administrations to limit fossil fuel projects, making emissions reductions more difficult.

Rhodium Group, an economic research firm, projects natural gas pipelines would continue advancing at roughly their current pace, while renewable energy deployment would accelerate due to faster permitting and greatly expanded transmission. Rhodiumโ€™s modeling finds a modest emissions reduction even if natural gas prices drop more than renewables, with larger reductions if renewable energy becomes much cheaper than natural gas.

But arguably the billโ€™s biggest climate effect would be strengthening future clean energy initiatives: States pursuing clean electricity or electrification would have an easier time building the infrastructure they need, and future federal clean energy incentives could produce better results.

The reverse is also possible. Republicans could take advantage of faster permitting processes to speed up fossil fuel infrastructure while suppressing renewables. The bill attempts to limit presidentsโ€™ ability to discriminate among energy sources, although recent amendments slightly weakened those provisions. Some opponents worry these provisions wouldnโ€™t keep President Donald Trump from continuing to suppress wind power, while others worry they will be too successful and prevent Democratic presidents from phasing out fossil fuels.

Potential pipelines under review by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, including the Mountain Valley Pipeline. By U.S. Energy Information Administration – https://www.flickr.com/photos/eiagov/26263507089, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/67821334

Who supports the bill, and who opposes it?

Supporters include labor unions, clean and fossil energy companies, a few tribes and tribal energy advocates, centrist policy organizations, and some climate advocacy groups. Clean energy companies have been especially enthusiastic, arguing that permitting and transmission constraints have become some of the biggest obstacles to expanding renewable power.

Opponents include environmental nonprofits, dozens of tribes, rural landowners, civil rights groups, and other climate activists. Some opponents support the billโ€™s transmission provisions but argue its changes to environmental review would excessively weaken the ability of communities and tribes to scrutinize projects and seek alternatives.

That disagreement has split Democrats and the climate movement. Climate-focused Democratic senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Martin Heinrich co-wrote the bill, while Green New Deal sponsors Ed Markey and Mazie Hirono opposed it. Climate movement veterans Al Gore and Genevieve Guentherhave also opposed the current legislation, while climate scientist Zeke Hausfather and utility watchdog David Pomerantz support it.

Neither camp is monolithic, and advocates on both sides offer nuanced explanations of the trade-offs they are or arenโ€™t willing to accept. Many opponents say they support permitting reform but believe Democrats should wait until January, when they will have majorities in both houses of Congress, to negotiate stronger protections for clean energy, communities, and tribes. Some supporters counter that the country needs new clean energy infrastructure now and that there is no guarantee a better political opportunity will arrive.

Will this bill become law?

The bill passed the Senate by a vote of 62 to 33, with 15 Democrats joining all but six Republicans in approving the legislation. Though it moved quickly through the Senate, its chances are less certain in the House. The lower chamber is also controlled by Republicans, but some โ€” including House Energy and Commerce Chair Brett Guthrie of Kentucky โ€” have signaled concern over transmission provisions. The bill could also struggle if Republicans donโ€™t arrive in Washington to vote, with many staying home after losing races in the midterms.

House Democrats, including top Democrat Hakeem Jeffries of New York, have also expressed concerns about the bill. If a large group of Democrats can convince a handful of Republicans to vote against it, they might be able to defeat it.

Trump has said he supports the permitting reform effort, meaning it should become law if it makes it out of Congress. If BAAJA doesnโ€™t get signed before the new year, however, it will die, and lawmakers will have to start over if they want to pass permitting reform in the next session.

Wind turbines near Pawnee Buttes in northeastern Colorado. Photo/Allen Best

Center for Biological Diversity: Lawsuit Launched to Protect Threatened Fish in Grand Canyon — Taylor McKinnon #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Humpback Chub, Gila cypha, George Andrejko, Arizona Game And Fish Department

Click the link to read the release on the Center for Biological Diversity website (Taylor McKinnon):

November 19, 2026

The Center for Biological Diversity filed a notice today of its intent to sue two federal agencies for violating the Endangered Species Act by approving and carrying out Glen Canyon Dam and Colorado River operations that rely on voluntary, uncertain and long-stalled measures to protect threatened fish in the Grand Canyon.

Todayโ€™s notice was sent to the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.

Record low water levels and warmer temperatures at Lake Powell increase the risk of nonnative fish passing through Glen Canyon Dam. This threatens native fish downstream, including the federally threatened humpback chub and razorback sucker and their protected habitats.

โ€œThe Grand Canyon is the last stronghold for humpback chub, and we canโ€™t afford to lose this population,โ€ said Taylor McKinnon, Southwest director at the Center. โ€œInvasive fish have already decimated populations elsewhere in the Colorado River Basin. As Lake Powell declines, these imperiled fish need reliable, enforceable measures to ensure their survival and recovery in the Grand Canyon.โ€

The decline of Colorado River flows and basin-wide storage reduces options and increases risks for endangered fish and their habitat. As Lake Powell has fallen to historic low levels, more invasive fish can pass through Glen Canyon Dam and enter downstream critical habitat for native fish.

But the Bureau of Reclamation has continued to operate the dam without implementing key measures against invasive fish. That failure threatens decades of recovery for humpback chub, puts their last large population in the Grand Canyon at risk, and degrades critical habitat for this species and the razorback sucker.

A 2016 biological opinion for Glen Canyon Dam operations required the Bureau of Reclamation to โ€œpursue means of preventing the passage of deleterious invasive non-native fish through Glen Canyon Dam.โ€ A decade later, the agency has yet to put meaningful measures into place. Instead, it has studied potential solutions without taking action, while the threat to these fish has grown.

Todayโ€™s notice says the agencyโ€™s failure to act requires renewed Endangered Species Act consultation.

This annotated 1963 photo of the Glen Canyon Dam shows the minimum level of Lake Powell, below which would render the dam’s power generation components inoperable. (Bureau of Reclamation)

To curb the spread of nonnative fish, a 2024 supplement to the 2016 Glen Canyon Dam operating plan called for releasing cooler water downstream to stop their reproduction. Known as โ€œcool-mix flows,โ€ the measure redirects some water from the damโ€™s hydropower turbines through lower bypass tubes.

Although the Bureau of Reclamation has identified cool-mix flows as a proven way to limit reproduction of invasive fish downstream, the agency abandoned the measure this summer.

โ€œThis agency keeps falling back on trapping and killing invasive fish downstream instead of implementing measures that could prevent the problem in the first place,โ€ said McKinnon. โ€œThatโ€™s not a model for success. Invasive fish need to be stopped from passing through the dam. Preventative measures should be mandatory.โ€

To balance storage across the declining reservoirs, the bureauโ€™s Post-2026 Colorado River Operations decision, finalized this year, targets a Lake Powell pool elevation just 20 feet above the minimum level needed to generate hydropower. Such low levels increase the risk of invasive fish passing through the dam.

While the 2026 biological opinion includes new measures to prevent and control nonnative fish invasion elsewhere in the Grand Canyon, those measures are largely voluntary with no guarantee they will be implemented.

โ€œThe Bureau of Reclamation should have begun planning for the climate-inevitable obsolescence of Glen Canyon Dam and Lake Powell a decade ago,โ€ said McKinnon. โ€œWith that day only one or two dry winters away, thereโ€™s never been a greater need for a plan that grapples with what comes after Glen Canyon Dam while providing for the recovery of these threatened fish.โ€

Grand Canyon and Colorado River by Brian Richter

#Colorado again balks at meaningful water #conservation: State water managers say without agreement from feds, contribution program wonโ€™t include farmers and ranchers in 2027 — Heather Sackett (AspenJournalism.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

This field near Kremmling is flood irrigated. Agricultural water use is often seen as the low-hanging fruit to find water conservation since farmers and ranchers use most of the water in the Colorado River basin. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Journalism website (Heather Sackett):

November 19, 2026

Without the assurance they were looking for from federal officials, Colorado water managers have decided that a state-run conservation program wonโ€™t include agricultural water users in 2027.

The decision came at the regular meeting of the Colorado Water Conservation Board Wednesday [November 17, 2026], with the board walking back a September decision to proceed with a state-run conservation program. State officials will continue working with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and the CWCB will consider a more limited program at its January meeting.

โ€œItโ€™s too late for agricultural projects,โ€ said Taylor Hawes, who represents the Colorado River mainstem on the CWCB. โ€œPerhaps thereโ€™s just a small group of [nonagricultural] projects we could move forward to show weโ€™re doing something.โ€

By excluding farmers and ranchers, Colorado can be expected to contribute little water next year to an Upper Basin program that aims to boost levels in Lake Powell by paying water users to cut back. Utah and Wyoming officials are still moving ahead with conservation programs that include agricultural users in those states.

In September, the state water board approved the application review process and criteria for what state officials are calling Coloradoโ€™s near-term contribution program for 2027. The program aims to use $100 million from Reclamation to pay water users to temporarily cut back. The water would be saved in one of four reservoirs: Lake Powell, Flaming Gorge, Blue Mesa or Navajo.

But state officials donโ€™t want Colorado water users to cut back only to boost Lower Basin usersโ€™ supply. The CWCBโ€™s approval in September depended upon securing an agreement with Reclamation that any saved water would be โ€œoperationally neutral,โ€ meaning it would not be factored into reservoir releases to the Lower Basin (California, Arizona and Nevada). Reclamation has not given that guarantee, and with time running short for irrigators to plan for the 2027 season, state officials decided to pull the plug on agricultural projects.

โ€œWe are very late in the year at this point,โ€ said Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief with the CWCB. โ€œIt would be really challenging, I think, for a lot of agricultural water users to consider enrolling at this point without this certainty.โ€

Hay bales in a field outside of Carbondale. State officials have decided that without an agreement with the feds, a water conservation program wonโ€™t include farmers and ranchers in 2027. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Not saving so others can overuse

The amount of water released from Powell each year is based on how much water is in the reservoir. Colorado officials are concerned that if their stateโ€™s conserved water contributions bump up levels in Powell, it will trigger more water to be released downstream to be used by the Lower Basin. This could trap the system in its current cycle of overuse and prevent states from building back storage in the reservoir, which has been depleted by decades of relentless demand and climate change. If the conserved water was operationally neutral, it would not be counted in determining how much water is released each year.

Becky Mitchell, Coloradoโ€™s representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission, said at Wednesdayโ€™s meeting that the state wants to be able to โ€œsay to the water users, โ€˜Youโ€™re not just saving so that others can overuse.โ€™ I think thatโ€™s the crux of it.โ€

In a Nov. 10 letter to Upper Basin officials, Andrea Travnicek, Reclamationโ€™s assistant secretary for water and science, said the terms and conditions of how conserved water may affect reservoir operations will require a larger seven basin state conversation. (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming comprise the Upper Basin.)

โ€œThere is currently no water within the Colorado River Basin that is considered operationally neutral,โ€ the letter reads. โ€œUntil such agreements are made, reservoir operations will continue to be based upon the physical elevations.โ€

A conservation program would be open to all water-use sectors, and at least one Front Range water provider has expressed interest in participating in the 2027 program by forgoing some of the water it uses from the Colorado River basin. But in past pilot projects, all of the conserved water has come from Western Slope agriculture.

Western Slope water managers want the pain to be shared across the basin and by cities, too. And they say rural agricultural communities should not cut back just to fuel use in the Lower Basin.

โ€œLook, weโ€™re happy to participate and help Reclamation protect its facilities at Glen Canyon,โ€ Mueller said in an interview with Aspen Journalism. โ€œWeโ€™re happy to set up a pool to make sure we stay in compliance with our obligations under the compact. But no one wants to dry up productive agricultural ground or economic activity and industry or the cities in our state in order to just send water down to fill swimming pools in Scottsdale.โ€

Mueller was among Western Slope water managers who had asked state officials not to rush to start a program next year if they couldnโ€™t get guaranteed operational neutrality from Reclamation.

โ€œI think everybody would benefit by your continued thoughtful approach rather than trying to rush to get something in place,โ€ Kirsten Kurath, an attorney who represents irrigation districts in the Grand Valley, some of the biggest water users on the Colorado River in the state, told board members Wednesday. โ€œWe really would encourage you not to implement a program that does not recognize operationally neutral credit to the Upper Basin states.โ€

The Government Highline Canal flows past peach orchards in the Grand Valley. Some Grand Valley water managers said they donโ€™t want a hasty rollout to a conservation program that includes agricultural water users. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Feds still working with states

Agriculture is seen as the low-hanging fruit when it comes to water savings because it uses most of the basinโ€™s water. But traditional conservation programs that pay agricultural water users to not use water for a season have been a tough sell in Colorado. This is the second time that state officials have balked at starting a program. From 2019 to 2021, nine workgroups explored a potential temporary, voluntary, compensated program, which was then known as demand management. But the CWCB declined to implement one, shelving the issue instead.

Lake Powellโ€™s surface elevation from 1963 to Nov. 16, 2026. Source: Reservoirbench

Upper Basin water managers have maintained that any conservation in their states will be a literal drop in the bucket, doing little to boost levels in Lake Powell. Under the federally funded System Conservation Pilot Program, which ran in 2023 and 2024, the Upper Basin saved about 101,000 acre-feet at a cost of $45 million. Coloradoโ€™s share of that was about 24,300 acre-feet, a tiny fraction of Powellโ€™s storage capacity. Precipitation has a much bigger impact than any cuts the Upper Basin can make, as was clear after this fallโ€™s rainstorms and flooding across the Southwest.

โ€œLake Powell has gained about 1.3 million acre-feet over the last month and a half,โ€ Ostdiek said. โ€œAnd just to put that in context, that would be 26 yearsโ€™ worth of system conservation pilot program, based on the numbers that weโ€™ve seen previously. I think it provides a reminder that the system is largely driven by hydrology.โ€

Federal water managers say they are committed to working with the Upper Basin states toward an agreement that will account for and verify contributed water; establish a mechanism for the states to obtain credit; and establish operating rules for storage and release of saved water.

The federal government has taken over river management after the seven states that share the river failed to come to an agreement after years of tense negotiations. Two states, Nevada and Arizona, have now sued the Department of the Interior over Reclamationโ€™s operating plan, which was released in August. The plan for 2027 and 2028 lays out a basic framework for cuts in the Lower Basin and reservoir releases. But many details beyond that remain to be worked out in separate agreements between the states and Reclamation.

And more lawsuits could be a part of the basinโ€™s future. In Wednesdayโ€™s meeting, the CWCB approved increasing Coloradoโ€™s litigation fund to $10 million (from $6 million), with $4 million of that going to the Colorado River Basin, the largest allocation of any river basin in the state.

Mueller told Aspen Journalism that the CWCB probably did the right thing by postponing agricultural projects for 2027, but that itโ€™s still frustrating to not have agreement between the Upper Basin states and Reclamation on key terms, such as operational neutrality. And heโ€™s not optimistic about seven-state conversations.

โ€œIt represents some dysfunction in the governance structure thatโ€™s managing the river right now,โ€ Mueller said. โ€œI would hope that our states find a way to knock those discussions loose so that we can actually have meaningful conversations about this and some other key elements of a potential governance framework.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Roaring Fork Watershed Summit reviews water management and looks ahead — The Sopris Sun #RoaringForkRiver

Mount Sopris, Roaring Fork River in the foreground. Photo credit: Sinjin Eberle

Click the link to read the article on The Sopris Sun website (Annalise Grueter). Here’s an excerpt:

November 18, 2026

The Roaring Fork Watershed Summit was hosted by the Ruedi Water & Power Authority and the Roaring Fork Conservancy. The two organizations work on different facets of water management and advocacy in the region…

The winter of 2025-26 exacerbated the drought that started the previous summer.
A combination of lower-than-average precipitation, warmer-than-average temperatures and unusually mild nighttime temperatures combined to largely set a new minimum record for snowpack water equivalent across Colorado. As of Nov. 12,
precipitation from October and early November is tracking in the median range for the same measurement. While the autumn precipitation has downgraded Pitkin and Garfield counties to lower levels of drought โ€” most of Garfield ranked as โ€œabnormally dryโ€ and Pitkin between โ€œmoderateโ€ and โ€œextremeโ€ by the United States Drought Monitor on Nov. 10. Eagle County remains largely in โ€œexceptional drought,โ€ the highest ranking. Trends of warmer temperatures and lighter monsoon patterns across recent summers have stakeholders considering water management strategies moving forward…

Peak snowpack was approximately half the historical average, while peak runoff was between one-quarter and one-third the watershedโ€™s historical average. Other parts of Colorado experienced those peaks up to two weeks earlier than the Roaring Fork Watershed. Those early low water levels set the stage for challenges across the region…The dry winter meant that many of Coloradoโ€™s reservoirs were not full in March. Those reservoirs, like Green Mountain Reservoir in Kremmling and Ruedi Reservoir up the Fryingpan Valley, help supply water to water rights holders across the Western Slope during the summer. Green Mountain Reservoir in particular is used to ensure water needs across the region, and when full, releases a constant of 1,500 cubic feet per second (cfs) across the warmer months of the year. This year, water levels required the release rate be substantially lower, less than 10% and down to 6.4% of normal by this autumn, Pearson said. Ruedi Reservoir had to be used as a stop-gap for the lower Roaring Fork Watershed and Colorado River downstream, despite not having filled over the winter. Additional water releases from Ruedi started in August…At the Watershed Summit, Bureau of Reclamation Hydrologist Tim Miller shared that Ruedi Reservoir is 36% full as of early November.

Map of the Roaring Fork River drainage basin in western Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69290878

Is Platte River Power ambitious enough? — Allen Best (BigPivots.com)

Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

November 17, 2026

Utility said it couldnโ€™t make its 100%-by-2030 goal. Fair enough, some say. But should it set an interim goal to help spur its journey?

In December 2018, representatives of the four northern Colorado cities that collectively constitute the Platte River Power Authority approved a conditional but ambitious goal. They wanted electricity that the utility provided to be 100% emissions-free by 2030.

In October, directors of the still coal-reliant Platte River adopted a revised strategic plan. This plan maintains the goal of achieving a 100% non-carbon energy portfolio. However, it removes any date.

โ€œIโ€™ve said from the beginning that itโ€™s not if, but when, we get there. Our non-carbon goal remains unchanged,โ€ said Jason Frisbie, the general manager and CEO of Fort Collins-based Platte River, in an announcement shortly after the board decision.

โ€œAs we continue pursuing our energy transition objective, it is essential that we appropriately balance decarbonization efforts with the reliability and affordability our owner communities expect. The updated policy reflects that commitment and provides a framework for responsible decision-making as technologies, markets and customer needs evolve.โ€

Jason Frisbie, the chief executive officer of Platte River, spoke in September at the celebration of the completion of Black Hollow, the giant solar complex east of Fort Collins, within the municipality of Severance. A battery storage project is now under construction adjacent to the solar panels. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Platte River reported no dissent among board members, nor was there immediate community pushback noted in the member jurisdictions of Fort Collins, Loveland, Estes Park, and Longmont.

But some community members, including at least one former director of Platte River, contend that the new strategy falls short.

โ€œYou have to set aggressive goals or things donโ€™t happen,โ€ said Ross Cunniff, who was a Platte River board member representing Fort Collins from 2019 to 2021.

Cunniff, a member of the Fort Collins City Council from 2013 to 2021, concedes the difficulty of the arbitrary 100% emission-free goal by 2030. Still, he says, he advocated for interim goals while on the Platte River board.

โ€œIโ€™m not talking about a moonshot goal. Interim goals need to be practicable,โ€ said Cunniff. โ€œBut without having interim shorter-term plans, longer-term plans will never happen.โ€

Staff members at Platte River, he said, were driven almost exclusively by preserving reliability and affordability. โ€œThey didnโ€™t like any hint of uncertainty in their plans.โ€

The debate in northern Colorado is a microcosm of other discussions about the energy transition across the stateโ€” indeed the nation and the world. A fundamental question is whether climate change poses such an extraordinary risk that utilities and the customers they serve should accept greater risks such as potential for loss of power on hot summer evenings.

That same question of tradeoffs is part of the current debate about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. As currently written, the bill would advance permitting for transmission. Many analysts believe improved transmission is crucial to decarbonizing the grid, but even some ardent decarbonization advocates find the cost to environmental protections proposed by the bill unacceptable.

A more nuanced question has to do with costs. Keeping the lights on at nearly all times in the case of Platte River involves investment in an expensive natural gas plant. One response is that the warming climate will result in financial costs no less real and almost certainly much higher if not quite as immediate. With that realization, the calculations look entirely different.

At some level, many utilities, regulators and legislative bodies are weighing these related calculations. What are the true risks and what are the real costs? Platte River and its four members cities are not particularly unusual.

Few of those who challenge the strategic plan question the aspirations of the four member cities or the utilityโ€™s staff members to decarbonize the utility. The differences are over pace and acceptance of risk.

Other reductions in Colorado

In Colorado, only a few smaller municipal utilities, most notably those serving Aspen and Glenwood Springs, can claim to have 100% carbon-free electricity. This is achieved, at least in part, by ordering electricity from suppliers like you would organic food from a restaurant menu.

Somewhat different is Holy Cross Energy, which serves areas around Aspen, Vail and other communities downstream along the Colorado River. Through September, it was at 88% emission-free energy.

Ratcheting down emissions is harder for larger utilities who have more customers. Colorado legislators, in setting greenhouse gas reduction goals during 2019, recognized this difficulty, mandating only 80% reductions in greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 โ€” but compared to 2005 levels. By that arithmetic, some utilities will be only 70% emissions-free energy by 2030.

Bidding goodbye to coal entirely in Colorado is proving somewhat more difficult than expected two or three years ago.

Colorado Springs Utilities said it needed to keep its Ray Nixon coal plant available until 2032, and Colorado legislators during the last session agreed. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Colorado Springs Utilities said it had to keep its Ray Nixon coal plant operating until 2032, and state legislators this last session agreed. Xcel Energy in 2025 was forced to delay the retirement of Comanche 2, which had been set to close last December. It is now to remain open until at least December 2027 and possibly beyond. The delay appears to be at least partly a response to the unreliability of another coal unit, Comanche 3.

For that matter, even those utilities such as Holy Cross that want to be 100% by 2030 acknowledge that an emissions-free electrical grid is still decades away. Holy Cross CEO Bryan Hannegan said at a forum in Vail several years ago that he expects natural gas will be part of Coloradoโ€™s electricity even at mid-century.

Several Colorado utilities have recently completed or are planning natural gas units. That includes Platte River.

Coal remains a large part of Platte Riverโ€™s operation. On some recent nights in early November, it has produced nearly two-thirds of the electricity consumed by the four municipalities. Platte River operates Rawhide, a coal plant 20 miles north of Fort Collins that was commissioned in 1984.

In 2020,Platte River announced plans to close the coal plant before 2030, and that has not changed. It also has minority ownership of two of the coal-burning units at Craig scheduled to close in 2028.

In preparing to leave coal behind, Platte River recently added solar and is adding storage, too. At Black Hollow Sun, located east of Fort Collins, on the edge of Severance, Platte River has rights to the projectโ€™s 257 megawatts. Planning on that project began in 2019, and the second phase was only completed in September.

Work is now underway adjacent to Black Hollow on 100 megawatts of storage that will be capable of being discharged across four-hour periods.

At the Black Hollow ribbon-cutting, Frisbie said he is confident Platte River will get โ€œwell in excess of 80% non-carbon energyโ€ by 2030 while maintaining affordability and reliability.

Reliability looms large

Reliability, particularly, looms large in the thinking of Platte River, as it does in every single utility in America. The utility, in announcing its new strategic plan, pointed to survey results that showed reliability was the top priority for 93% of residential customers and 97% of commercial customers. Affordability was also a leading concern.

โ€œReliability and affordability โ€” and then green as long as it doesnโ€™t sacrifice those,โ€ said Gary Hall, the mayor of Estes Park and chair of the board of directors at Platte River in an e-mail shared with Big Pivots. โ€œAnd weโ€™ll stay on that path.โ€

To ensure reliability, Platte River plans to expand its capacity to burn natural gas as necessary to fill in the gaps of renewables. It already has two gas plants, with a combined capacity of 388 megawatts, adjacent to the existing Rawhide coal plant. Now, it is installing โ€œfive aeroderivative turbines with jet-engine style technology.โ€

โ€œItโ€™s not a gas plant,โ€ a Platte River communications officer admonished Big Pivots, suggesting a sensitivity to the matter.

Environmental advocates hotly contested the proposal in hearings before Larimer County in 2025. They worried about contributions to northern Coloradoโ€™s notorious ozone pollution.

Platte River Power has gas-fired units and solar panels adjacent to its Rawhide coal-fired plant. Photo/Platte River Power Authority

The Larimer County Planning Commission voted 5-4 to recommend approval of the 1041 land-use permit. In April 2025, the county commissioners, with final authority, were unanimous, 3-0.

โ€œThe new gas turbines are NOT needed in the first place, because PRPA already has 388 megawatts of gas turbines, which are more than enough โ€˜insuranceโ€™ until more renewables and storage can be built,โ€ insisted Kevin Cross of the Northern Colorado Alliance for a Livable Future in a November 2025 posting.

By then, the issue was whether the Colorado Air Quality Control Commission would issue a permit. It did so in April 2026. Two residents, from Longmont and Fort Collins, in May challenged that permit, reported the Loveland Reporter-Herald, alleging the state regulators improperly allowed the gas plant to avoid a stricter federal environmental review process.

Costs estimated in December 2024 at $352.9 million had ballooned to $623 million by October 2025, according to the Fort Collins Coloradoan.

Platte River emphasizes the flexibility of the 200-megawatts of gas-fueled generating capacity to meet peaks in demand. GE Vernova, the manufacturer, says it can โ€œguarantee 90% base load within 10 minutes, while reducing fuel burn and start up emissions.โ€ That fast start โ€” more traditional gas technology can take between 10 and 30 minutes and coal plants can take 18 hours โ€” complements renewable generation. Too, the aeroderivative turbines produce fewer emissions than coal or โ€œexisting frame (gas) units.โ€

In other words, if youโ€™re going to burn fossil fuels, this causes fewest emissions and backs up renewables.

Construction, according to Platte Riverโ€™s website, is to start in 2026. In October, Frisbie called it โ€œthe most critical and the most important project in Platte Riverโ€™s history.โ€

Just exactly where is Platte River on its journey to emission-free electricity? Platte River provides real-time breakdowns of its energy sources but no monthly tally, unlike Holy Cross Energy. It does provide an annual report.

In 2025, fossil fuels remained a major part of electrical production for Platte River. The utilityโ€™s annual report said coal provided 41.2% of the electricity and natural gas 2.6%. But coal and gas may have been sources for electricity purchased from other sources, or 26.8% of the total electricity.

Renewables โ€” wind (14.9%), hydropower (9.6%) and solar (4.9%) โ€” were responsible for 29.4%. That compares with the 32% that Durango-based La Plata Electric reports as its power source on an annualized basis.

Looking ahead, Platte River has no immediate plans for more solar, according to a spokeswoman, but is โ€œactively negotiating next steps for an additional wind project.โ€ The utilityโ€™s integrated resource plan (page 111) had said that southeastern Wyoming and eastern Colorado were the likely sources. Transmission constraints would limit new wind to 200 megawatts of capacity from Wyoming, while eastern Colorado wind costs would be encumbered by charges for use of transmission lines by others.

Conditions of 2018 resolution

Platte Riverโ€™s directors adopted their 100% by 2030 goal in December 2018, a time of heady ambition in Colorado. Jared Polis had been elected governor the prior month after running on a platform of 100% renewables. Xcel Energy then announced it was committed to getting out of carbon by 2050.

Boulder resident and solar entrepreneur Ron Sinton at the time told Polis that a more advisable goal was 90% to 95% given the cost and difficulties of 100%. Polis, he said, responded that President John Kennedy did not set a goal of 90% of the way to the moon.

The resolution by Platte Riverโ€™s directors was heavily conditioned. It said advances must occur in the โ€œnear termโ€ in nine areas to enable realization of that 2030 goal. For example, it said an organized regional market must exist with Platte River as an active participant.

That regional market arrived on April 1 in the form of Southwest Power Poolโ€™s Western market, including Platte River. That launch has been somewhat less than smooth as evident in SPPโ€™s call for Tri-State to crank up a retired coal unit at Craig. Coloradoโ€™s hottest summer record almost certainly played a role. Beyond that, some participants believe the SPP market, to be effective, needs more participants than it has in Colorado and two other states.

Transmission remains a question mark as Platte River and other utilities seek to decarbonize their power supplies, which requires better access to renewable sources across broad areas. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Among other advancements, the 2018 resolution said that battery storage performance must mature and the costs must decline. Plus, end-user storage must be available.

Battery storage was incipient in 2018. Just weeks before Platte Riverโ€™s directors met, Coloradoโ€™s first utility-scale battery had debuted behind the United Power office along I-25, between Longmont and Firestone. Now, perhaps 1,000 megawatts of battery storage are spread across Colorado with much more planned.

Still absent, though, is longer-duration storage. Xcel plans a 100-hour iron-air pilot project at Pueblo. Federal funding was assumed, and after a hiccup with the change in presidential administrations, that funding was assured several months ago. Xcel now expects the Form Energy storage to be available in late 2027 or early 2028.

As for Platte River, its 2024 integrated resource plan (page 110) said Platte River is planning for 10 megawatts of long duration storage by 2030 and assumes the technology will be available for commercial applications by 2035.

In an e-mail, a Platte River staff member pointed out that the 2024 plan had concluded that 760 megawatts of new renewable energy proposed in the optimal new carbon portfolio would require a three-pronged approach to dispatchable capacity:

  • Building out virtual power plants, or VPPs, within the owner communities. VPPs are networks of of small, distributed energy resources (DERs) such as rooftop solar installations, home batteries, and electric vehicle that are coordinated to work together to enhance efficiency on the power grid.
  • Implementing both short and long-term energy storage when commercially viable; and
  • Using the aeroderivative gas units. The 2024 plan suggested the gas units would be used at only 20% of capacity.

Benefit of the doubt

Platte Riverโ€™s strategic plan adopted in October seems to have provoked exasperation among some residents who want to complete the decarbonization journey โ€” soon. A more common response has been the argument for interim goals, mile markers on the journey.

Peter Eberle, of the Colorado Renewable Energy Society, said he and others understand that getting to 100% by 2030 is impossible. โ€œNo argument there,โ€ he said. Reliability matters.

Given the uncertainties that make Platte Riverโ€™s staff uncomfortable, Eberle is inclined to give Platte River the benefit of the doubt.

One of those uncertainties is what will happen on the federal front. The Trump administration has thrown obstacles in the path of new wind projects, even those in Colorado. It has also blocked the retirement of coal plants, including one unit at Craig. It also made noise about blocking retirement of a unit at Pueblo.

See: โ€œIs Colorado project a victim of Trump ire?โ€ Big Pivots, July 26, 2026)

โ€œImplications of Michigan case for Craig coal unitโ€ Big Pivots, Sept. 26, 2026)

The Southwest Power Pool is not fully on its feet. Platte River still needs to get familiar with how the Black Hollow solar installation works during all seasons. And improved transmission โ€” considered by many to be crucial to get to decarbonization beyond 90% โ€” remains a question mark.

However, given where Xcel expects to be by 2030 โ€” it says it will achieve an 80% reduction from 2005 levels โ€” and the statement of Frisbie at the Black Hollow celebration that Platte River expects to be above 80%, an interim goal would seem to be acceptable, said Eberle.

Platte River plans for the worst. That puts reliability at the top, followed closely by affordability. As for the environmental leg of this three-legged stool, it always has been just a little shorter.

โ€œThey are moving at the pace that is probably uncomfortable for them,โ€ said Eberle,โ€ but not fast enough for some of us in the community.”

Historic Southwest Flooding Doesnโ€™t Fix the #ColoradoRiverโ€™s Problems: Recent storms boosted reservoir levels, but not enough to change the river’s long-term outlook — Jennifer Pitt (Audubon.org) #COriver #aridification

Belted Kingfisher. Photo: Jerry amEnde/Audubon Photography Awards

Click the link to read the article on the Audubon website (Jennifer Pitt):

November 12, 2026

In recent weeks, powerful storms battered the Four Corners region. The San Juan River reached some of its highest flows on record, and the Animas and Dolores rivers each logged their fifth-highest levels. Families in Pagosa Springs, Colo., in Bluff, Utah, and Navajo Nation communities now face months of recovery. Though for some observers, there was at least some hope: after years of drought, perhaps all that water would provide a meaningful boost to replenish Colorado River reservoirs, recharge aquifers, and benefit some wildlife habitat.

The gain is small compared to the Colorado River’s deficit. Some of that floodwater reached the Colorado River system. Lake Powell has risen since October 1 by about 19 feet, a gain of roughly one million acre-feet of water. Every drop counts, but Powell holds roughly 24 million acre-feet when full and is still nearly three-quarters empty. Powell and Lake Mead, the systemโ€™s two largest reservoirs, each hold less water today than at this time last year. Meanwhile, water users in Arizona, California, Nevada and Mexico face significant supply reductions in 2027 under new federal guidelines designed to stabilize reservoir storage.

Whiplash is the new normal. Colorado River flows have always varied from year to year. That variability hits hardest when reservoirs are depleted, and it affects water users who depend on unregulated streamflow. Scientists expect a warming climate to bring more intense storms while drying the basin over the long term. And despite strong El Niรฑo conditions this year, history suggests they are not a reliable predictor of above-average Colorado River flows. After last winterโ€™s near-record-low runoff, a second poor snow year would further stress reservoirs that remain well below capacity. It would pose a serious challenge for Lake Powell, which is dangerously close to the elevations where water can no longer pass through Glen Canyon Dam. That impact would cascade downstream to Lake Mead, triggering larger supply reductions and pushing the reservoir closer to its own crisis.

Whatโ€™s needed now. The storms caused devastating damage. They also added modestly to the riverโ€™s supply, but this is a reprieve, not a rescue. The storms are not a reason to stop working on the Colorado River crisisโ€”they are a sign that we urgently need to make progress. Federal and state managers must keep working toward durable, basin-wide demand reductions and a negotiated, consensus agreement on sharing water shortages and managing the river, one that avoids a court-imposed outcome. Congress can also help affected communities by responding to a $2 billion request made by more than 100 Colorado River stakeholdersโ€”including irrigation districts, municipal water providers, Tribes, and conservation NGOs, including Audubonโ€”to fund projects that help people and birds by building resilience to both drought and intense storms. These investments include floodplain restoration, forest health, and water conservation and reuse projects that can replenish reservoirs, strengthen communities’ resilience to drought and flooding, and support bird habitat across the Colorado River Basin.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

West Slope Water Summit: Climate, legal disputes and economics pressure Colorado River and local ag — The #Montrose Press

Screenshot of Blue Mesa Reservoir July 2026 from the West Slope Water Summit presentatiion by the Colorado River District.

Click the link to read the article (and check out the slide show) on The Montrose Press website (Katharhynn Heidelberg). Here’s an excerpt:

November 15, 2026

Andy Mueller stood before an at-capacity room Nov. 13 to deliver the facts: The Westโ€™s population is booming; climate change is reality; there is no magic button to replenish the Colorado River to feed faucets and crops โ€” and a new legal fight over the 100-plus-year-old compact governing its use is looming. Mueller, the general manager of the Colorado River District, updated those attending Montrose Countyโ€™s West Slope Water Summit on the brewing dispute between the Upper Basin states (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming) and Lower Basin states (California, Arizona and Nevada), which have long tussled over whether the Colorado River Compact mandates the apportionments agreed to in 1922 regardless of current hydrology. The states, having failed to resolve their central disputes, could now find themselves in a showdown before the United States Supreme Court…

โ€œWe have a looming legal fight with the Lower Basin. Do we owe a delivery obligation of 75 million or 82.5 million (acre feet) over 10 years, or is that language in the compact just that we shall not cause that river to be depleted below that amount? Itโ€™s not us. Itโ€™s a natural circumstance thatโ€™s being caused by warming temperatures and so itโ€™s not our fault. Itโ€™s the riverโ€™s fault. That is an argument that weโ€™re likely to have, unfortunately, at the Supreme Court,โ€ Mueller said…

Amid the dayโ€™s detailed discussions of lawsuits, compact history and weather patterns, a central question cast its shadow over the entire summit: If we canโ€™t control how much water Mother Nature provides, what can we do to conserve and store more?

Gunnison Tunnel via the National Park Service

โ€œIt seems to me like the biggest bang for the buck in the state of Colorado is to modernize the delivery systems,โ€ State Sen. Marc Catlin, R-Montrose, said, during the summitโ€™s expert panel discussion…โ€œEvery system in the Uncompahgre (Valley) was built in 1912 โ€” itโ€™s still earth and lime canals. Water users have gone about piping a lot of these sites and those kinds of things, but if the state of Colorado is serious about saving water, they need to come to the table with dollars that will help secure savings of water on these irrigation systems. We can continue to talk about it, but until something like that happens, individual agricultural users are not going to be able to generate enough saved water to make a difference.โ€

Catlin said itโ€™s critical to cast an eye on the future, but to act now…A farm is for many like a 401k retirement fund โ€” and the average age of a farmer is about 64, he noted. โ€œHow do we step in when the time comes that you cannot continue to farm, or you canโ€™t afford to farm? What are you supposed to do with those farms rather than sell them?โ€ Catlin asked. The buyer could likely be a speculator instead of another farmer, he said. โ€œWhat will that do to our communities? Thereโ€™s a lot of questions that are going to need to be answered in regards to this. Do communities think farmland is a valuable enough commodity to purchase it the way on the Front Range, (where) they buy open space? โ€ฆ All over the Western Slope, we have to think about it, because things are changing.โ€

The risk is real, Catlin also said. โ€œWe canโ€™t expect the climate to change back to something we knew when we were kids. So weโ€™re going to have to think about how we address these kinds of things.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

NEWSWIRE: President Trump doubles down on public land attacks (and transfers). Plus the latest on data centers, trail-based economies, regulatory capture, and more — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Bikepackers near the border of Glen Canyon Recreation Area and Bears Ears National Monument in October. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

November 13, 2026

๐ŸŒต PUBLIC LANDS ๐ŸŒฒ

One might expect the Trump administration to be humbled by its monumental loss in the midterm elections, to heed the votersโ€™ call and change course on its war on Iran, its arbitrary inflation-driving tariffs, its blatant money-grubbing corruption, its ICE goon squads, and on its crusade to convert public land into an ATM for oil and gas, mining, and now tech corporations.

Alas, this is no ordinary or commonsensical regime. Instead of tempering itself, itโ€™s doubling down on its unpopular and destructive policies, as those who govern by spite are inclined to do.

This week, for example, the Interior Department released its 2026-2030 strategic plan, which again emphasizes its commitment to achieving โ€œAmerican Energy Dominanceโ€โ€” as long as its of the fossil fuel kind โ€” and opening more lands to mining, grazing, geothermal development, and timber harvesting.

It wouldnโ€™t only do this through leasing, permitting, and granting rights of way, but also โ€œland exchanges and direct transfer of lands in support of reliable energy production and transport.โ€ Furthermore: โ€œThe Department will work to decrease the size of the federal estate by offering to states, localities and Tribes the opportunity to purchase federal lands.โ€

Yes, you read that right: Interior Secretary Doug Burgum wants to turn public lands over to corporations to make it easier for them to drill or build pipelines on them, and it wants to sell other lands to states, counties, and tribal nations because theyโ€™ve deemed the โ€œfederal estateโ€ to be too large. Never mind that previous efforts to transfer public lands out of public hands have been met with broad and intense opposition from across the political spectrum.

Of course, a strategic plan is merely a wish-list, a broad road map of what the administration would like to do. And Burgum has in the past indicated he planned to transfer public lands for housing, yet never followed up on it, perhaps due to the backlash to Sen. Mike Leeโ€™s attempts to do the same through legislation.

Meanwhile, Interior is taking very real actions to undermine stewardship of public lands in quieter, yet consequential ways. Most recently, it announced plans to streamline and weaken the Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s land-use planning process to โ€œcut unnecessary red tape.โ€

Some of the most significant proposed changes concern Areas of Critical Environmental Concern, or ACECs, which are public lands that require special management attention to โ€œprevent irreparable damageโ€ to historic, cultural, or scenic values, wildlife, or other natural systems and processes. Chacoโ€™s Great North Road, which passes through the heavily drilled San Juan Basin oil and gas field, is protected by an ACEC, for example.

Interior proposes eliminating the requirement that ACECs be identified in a draft land-use plan, that proposed ACEC designations be published in the Federal Register, and that they be subjected to an associated 60-day comment period. The new rule would also limit the scope of the protected areas, by requiring that ACECs โ€œshall encompass the smallest area of public lands necessary to protect and prevent irreparable damage of the relevant and important values.โ€

Additional proposed land-use planning changes include:

  • To remove the requirement that the BLM prepare an environmental impact statement when it develops or revises a land-use plan.
  • To bar appeals of land-use plan decisions via the Office of Hearings and Appeals, giving the Interior Department the final say.
  • To remove rules requiring the BLM publish notice in the Federal Register and open a 30-day public review period at the beginning of the planning process, and eliminate the 90-day public comment period requirement. Instead, the BLM would determine โ€œpublic participation that is appropriate to the areas and people involved in the specific planning process.โ€
  • To require all protests to be submitted electronically.

The BLM is accepting public comments on the proposed changes until Nov. Jan. 11, 2027. More information can be found and comments submitted at the Federal Register.

**

On a similarly egregious note, Sen. Mike Lee, MAGA-UT, has taken steps to set up a Senate vote to revoke the Bears Ears National Monument management plan via the Congressional Review Act.

While the Trump administration illegally shrunk the national monument by about 90% this summer, the previous management plan, which pertains to grazing, recreation, and resource management, is still in place. It was developed under the Biden administration in collaboration with the Bears Ears inter-tribal coalition.

Now Lee looks to get rid of the plan, and to bar the agencies from developing a similar one in the future, potentially weakening protections of what remains of the national monument, or even a restored one if and when a court or future administration reverses Trumpโ€™s shrinkage.

**

The U.S. Forest Service publishes proposed new public lands grazing rules in the Federal Register that would eliminate public input into permit decisions, open additional lands for grazing, allow some permittees to establish their own benchmarks for forest health, and expands eligibility requirements for grazing permits. Comments will be accepted until Dec. 14. (Federal Register, Western Watersheds Project)

**

The Bureau of Land Management seeks public input on 38 proposed oil and gas lease parcels covering 65,900 acres in northwest Colorado to be auctioned in March 2027. There are two blocks of parcels, one west of the Little Snake River, the other east of the Illinois River. Comments will be accepted until Dec. 10. (BLM)

๐Ÿ“ REGULATORY CAPTURE CHRONICLES ๐ŸฆŠ

Environmental Protection Agency Administrator Lee Zeldin moved last month to rescind Biden-era regulations aimed at reducing methane and other greenhouse gas emissions from oil and gas facilities.

The rules, finally finalized in 2024, phased out flaring on new wells; required leak-detection surveys on a monthly, bimonthly, or quarterly basis (depending on type and size of facility); and required even low-producing wells to pipe associated gases to market or use them to replace other fuels onsite if at all possible. The rules also allowed the EPA to โ€œleverage data collected by certified third parties to identify and address โ€˜super emittingโ€™ sources.โ€

The rules not only cut climate-warming emissions, but also reduced pollutants that endangered the health of people living near oil and gas wells and other infrastructure. Plus, they slashed waste, which ultimately reduced energy prices, by pushing operators to market the methane as natural gas rather than venting or flaring it.

Zeldinโ€™s proposal would bring back flaring, rescind the third-party โ€œsuper emitterโ€ monitoring program, and give operators more leeway in monitoring for leaks and other problems.

The proposed changes are open to public comment until Dec. 16. Submit comments here.

**

Meanwhile, data show that EPA enforcement actions relating to oil and gas facilities and operators in New Mexico, especially the busy Permian Basin, have dropped off considerably during the first two years of the Trump administration, perhaps due to staffing reductions, an ideological shift in agency leadership, or both. โ€œEPAโ€™s lack of enforcement in the Permian Basin makes it more difficult to protect New Mexicansโ€™ air quality,โ€ Drew Goretzka, New Mexico Environment Department spokesman, told Capital & Main. (Capital & Main)

๐Ÿ”‹ENERGY/ECONOMIC TRANSITIONS ๐Ÿ”Œ

Dinรฉ advocates and mountain bikers work to establish a trail-based economy on the Navajo Nation, but must overcome thorny access issues to realize its full potential. โ€œAs Indigenous communities, we can grow our trails because we see a lot of the trail population. If you look on Strava or these different trail maps,โ€ said Navajo Mountain Bike Festival founder MT Garcia, โ€œthere are tons of trails that are highlighted all around the reservation, but the reservation is this dark spot.โ€ (Tรณ Nizhรณnรญ รnรญ, Yazh Trailz)

**

Gallup, New Mexicoโ€™s city council approves Convalt Energyโ€™s proposed Golden Eagle solar cell manufacturing facility on 622 acres within city limits. The two-year construction process is slated to begin in January and the facility is expected to employ 900 people when it is operational. (KRQE)

๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ

Elon Muskโ€™s firm SpaceXAI proposes a massive data center complex on the Willcox Playa dry lakebed in southeastern Arizona adjacent to the Apache coal, gas, and solar power plant, which has a generating capacity of 626 megawatts. Plans call for the nine-data-center complex to use 6 gigawatts (or 6,000 MW) of power when fully built out, which would make it the largest such facility in the world so far. SpaceXAI plans to invest $3.6 billion on power infrastructure and would begin construction in March 2027 if land-use approvals are granted. (Data Center Dynamics, Arizona Daily Star)

**

Outgoing Alaska Gov. Mike Dunleavy moves to lease a square mile of state land to STAK Energy for a giant gas-fired plant designed to power proposed data centers.The lease hasnโ€™t formally been issued, the developer would still need numerous permits to proceed, and Governor-elect Jonathan Kreis-Tomkins, a Democrat, called for a moratorium on new data centers on the campaign trail. (Anchorage Press)

**

Documents show advanced chipmaker firm TSMCโ€™s fabrication facility in north Phoenix would use about 1,900 megawatts of energy at full buildout, or enough to power some 300,000 homes. The facility also uses about 4.75 million gallons of municipal water daily. (KJZZ, AZ Family)

**

Arizona Public Service officials expect the utilityโ€™s overall electricity sales to double by 2041 due to rising demand from new data centers and the chipmaking industry, and plans to bring 2,000 megawatts of new solar, 2,500 MW of energy storage, and 4,000 MW of gas generation online in the next decade along with extending the life of its Four Corners coal power plant in northwestern New Mexico until 2038. (Utility Dive)

**

Google proposes a data center near Cheyenne, Wyoming, with a possible capacity of 2,700 megawatts. It would power the facility with natural gas fuel cells and gas-fired turbines and will โ€œseek to capture the associatedโ€ carbon dioxide emissions and store them at Tallgrass Energyโ€™s Eastern Wyoming Sequestration Hub. Google says it will pay for 100% of the power it uses, and will utilize an air-cooled system โ€œto minimize strain on local water resources.โ€ (Data Center Dynamics)


๐Ÿ‘ฉ๐Ÿฝโ€๐Ÿ”ฌ SCIENCE! ๐Ÿงซ

Iโ€™ve often written here about how the Lisbon Valley in southeastern Utah has a long history of mining, for copper, uranium (Charlie Steenโ€™s Mi Vida Mine was here), oil and gas, and now lithium. A recent study1 finds that mining has been happening here for far, far longer โ€” like 1,400 years longer โ€” than I suspected.

Archaeological evidence shows that Ancestral Puebloans used a blue-green mineral called azurite as a pigment for painting baskets, ceramics, wooden objects, and for body paint. Caches of azurite spheres have also been documented at numerous Puebloan sites and in burials dating back to the Basketmaker III period (500-750 AD). A new study, Spheres of Blue: Isotopic evidence for the provenance of azurite in the Ancestral Pueblo world, uses isotope tracing to determine from where the Pueblo people may have obtained the azurite.

Their conclusion: Much of the azurite found in the ancient sites probably came from the Lisbon Valley and possibly from a specific site near the Blue Crystal Mine, where evidence of ancient mining has been documented, with other samples likely coming from the Zuni Mountains in New Mexico. โ€œGiven the isotopic homogeneity of the spheres (especially in Pb isotope space) and their recovery from widely distributed archaeological sites,โ€ the authors write, โ€œwe suggest it is possible that Lisbon Valley was the sole source of azurite spheres in the Ancestral Pueblo world during the Basketmaker III period.โ€

Locations of azurite sources (red diamonds) and archaeological sites (blue circles) where azurite was found.

๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

The Abajo Mountains with snow and alpenglow peek out from behind Cedar Mesa in October. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

1 Kari L. Schleher, Alyson M. Thibodeau, Ryan Mathur, Jonathan Till. Spheres of Blue: Isotopic evidence for the provenance of azurite in the Ancestral Pueblo world. Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, Volume 76, Part A, 2026.

Conservation Programs in the #ColoradoRiverโ€™s Upper Basin Inch Forward, Despite Thorny Questions — Jake Bolster (InsideClimateNews.org) #COriver #aridification

A group of visitors walks down the boat ramp at Williams Fork Reservoir on July 20, 2026. The ramp was closed this summer due to low water levels caused by drought. Photo credit: Denver Water.

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Jake Bolster):

November 13, 2026

Four upriver states are planning to use $100 million in federal grants to do the work. But itโ€™s unclear whether the federal government will bank the water for them.

New voluntary water conservation programs in the Upper Colorado River Basin appear on track after the 320th meeting of the Upper Colorado River Commission concluded this week. But Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, Wyoming and the federal government have yet to agree on how any conserved water would be credited and stored.

These questions, experts say, may not come with easy answers.

This June, the federal Bureau of Reclamation put $100 million on the table for the four states in the Upper Basin to fund their own voluntary water conservation programs, which usually entails paying ranchers and farmers to use less water. Overuse and drought-diminished flows on the Colorado River threaten the water supply of roughly 40 million people, 30 tribes, seven states and Mexico.

Most Upper Basin states are planning to implement programs in 2027 (Utah already has one running), and their success could be crucial to the statesโ€™ assertion that they should only have to ease the pressure on the Colorado River through voluntary measures. This fall, the federal government implemented new mandatory reductions on the Lower Basin, and Nevada, later joined by Arizona, sued over the potential for even deeper cuts.

โ€œItโ€™s โ€ฆ important to recognize, and I say this in a positive way, a complimentary way, the audacious ambition of attempting to put this together in the time frame that we have,โ€ Wayne Pullan, the Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s Upper Colorado Basin regional director, told negotiators from the Upper Basin states at the virtual meeting.

Colorado made it clear that its program can only move forward with an agreement from Reclamation that conserved water would remain under the stateโ€™s jurisdiction.

From left, Interstate Section Chief at the CWCB Amy Ostdiek, Colorado representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission Becky Mitchell and State Engineer Jason Ullmann, speak on a panel at Colorado Water Congress on Aug. 20 in Steamboat Springs. State officials are rolling out a water conservation program that would pay water users to temporarily cut back. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

โ€œWe really need to get some credit for the upper division states through a program like this,โ€ said Amy Ostdiek of the Colorado Water Conservation Board, who presented the stateโ€™s conservation program. โ€œWhat that means in Colorado is seeing that that water is treated as operationally neutral, and not simply passed downstream.โ€

โ€œOperationally neutralโ€ water is conserved by one state and stored in federal reservoirs for future use by that state. Arizona, California and Nevada, the Lower Basin states, have banked water in Lake Mead, the largest reservoir in the United States, with the option to withdraw it for future use. But the Interior secretary is the legal water master in the Lower Basin and has the ability to allocate surplus water there. The secretary does not play the same role in the Upper Basin.

Green River Basin

Pullan said that Reclamation is โ€œable and willingโ€ to keep working on how the government would credit and handle water conserved by the Upper Basin. Some observers wondered how the Upper Basinโ€™s condition would sit with the federal government, which built and financed the dams that store the water.

โ€œThey donโ€™t like to turn over the keys of the car to the states,โ€ said James Eklund, a partner at Taft Law and Coloradoโ€™s Colorado River negotiator from 2013 to 2019.

The Lower Basin would also need to agree that water conserved in the Upper Basin could be stored for the upstream statesโ€™ use, something Kathryn Sorensen, director of research for Arizona State Universityโ€™s Kyl Center for Water Policy, had a hard time envisioning.

The Lower Basin states โ€œwould expect some sort of quid pro quo for that type of arrangement,โ€ she said.

The Upper and Lower basin negotiators from each of the seven Colorado River states had years to agree on new guidelines for the federal government to implement. After they missed several deadlines, Reclamation implemented its own new operating plan this year, and the states appear no closer to an agreement.

The possibility of one of the seven basin states suing another before the Supreme Court looms over the basin.

Various conservation programs in the Upper Basin are in different phases of development. Utahโ€™s program saved about 5,500 acre feet of water in 2025, Amy Haas, executive director of the Colorado River Authority in Utah, announced at the meeting.

One acre foot of water can supply anywhere from three to six homes for a year, depending on the regionโ€™s climate and urban density.

New Mexico and Wyoming made their programs compatible with other funding sources, like state appropriations or grants from nonprofits, should they become available, state representatives said.

The Upper Basin uses less water than the Lower Basin, which recently reined in its consumption after years of drawing more water than it was allocated, though it has plans to divert yet more water from the river. In its operating guidelines released this summer, Reclamation modeled up to 200,000 acre feet of voluntary conservation annually in the Upper Basinโ€”if hydrology allows.

Eklund, who attended the virtual meeting, said itโ€™s disappointing the seven basin states still canโ€™t agree on a solution to the problems plaguing the Colorado River. โ€œIf this system collapses, it doesnโ€™t really matter what weโ€™re legally entitled to,โ€ he said.

โ€œIf Phoenix sneezes, the Upper Basin catches a cold,โ€ he added. โ€œWeโ€™re very, very connected economically to each other, and if we donโ€™t start governing the system like weโ€™re all part of one country and not seven different sovereign countries, then weโ€™re A: only going to have ourselves to blame, and B: weโ€™re not going to like the results.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#GlobalWarming Remains Unchecked, Experts Warn at UNโ€™s COP31 Climate Summit — Bob Berwyn (InsideClimateNews.org) #ClimateChange

Greta Thunberg from her Facebook page.

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Bob Berwyn):

November 12, 2026

Current climate and energy policies will have devastating consequences for ecosystems and communities worldwide, new reports show.

Amid upbeat green-tech pep talks and notices for happy hours at the annual United Nations COP31 climate change conference on Thursday, two new reports offered a stark reminder of how far the world remains from containing global warming.

Climate Action Tracker, a nonprofit group that analyzes climate policies, found that the planet is still on track to warm nearly 5 degrees Fahrenheit by 2100, a rise that would devastate coral reefs, disrupt agriculture and forests and melt most of the worldโ€™s ice. In a separate bulletin, the European Unionโ€™s Copernicus climate change service reported that global warming has accelerated significantly since the 2015 Paris climate agreement.

When the Paris agreement was adopted, the average global temperature was projected to surpass the pactโ€™s long-term threshold of 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit above the preindustrial average around 2045. After another decade of global climate summits, warming is now projected to cross that benchmark as soon as 2029, according to Copernicus.

โ€œThis striking change suggests that global warming has accelerated in recent years,โ€ the EU scientists wrote. Even without understanding every aspect of the recent rapid global temperature increase, โ€œIt is clear that the ever-growing concentrations of greenhouse gases emitted by human activity in the atmosphere remain the main driver of this trend.โ€

The current level of warming has already triggered deadly and destructive floods, wildfires and catastrophic glacier collapses, said Swedish activist Greta Thunberg, who is attending the U.N. โ€œConferences of the Partiesโ€ climate talks, for the first time since 2021.

โ€œThe climate crisis is a matter of life and death,โ€ she said. โ€œThe actions from those in power here are completely detached from reality. As we speak, we are losing priceless lives, ecosystems and species that we will never get back.โ€

Sarah Heck, a climate policy analyst with Climate Analytics, an international climate science and policy institute, said governments have failed to meaningfully improve the outlook for end-of-century warming.

โ€œOur message is a stark one,โ€ Heck said. โ€œCollective government action on climate change has stalled for the fifth consecutive year.โ€ Efforts to speed up the shift away from fossil fuels have been negated by new oil and gas drilling projects and governments that are โ€œdelaying, weakening or rolling back their climate policies.โ€

Even under the most optimistic scenario, assuming full implementation of existing policies and promises, global temperatures would rise 3.4 degrees Fahrenheit above preindustrial levels by 2100, an increase climate scientists consider extremely dangerous.

While there has been progress on developing renewable energy sources, the โ€œbrutal truth is that these positive developments have not yet added up to bend the curve fast enough,โ€ said Niklas Hรถhne, a researcher with The New Climate Institute. Developing new oil and gas projects is a bit like discovering your food is burning and then turning up the stove instead of turning it off, he added.

Getting into the specifics of the current negotiations at COP31 surrounding global renewable goals, he noted that conference co-hosts Turkey and Australia have so far opposed including the word โ€œcleanโ€ in connection with electrification targets.

โ€œItโ€™s very hard to understand, and the only explanation I can think of is their interest in fossil fuels,โ€ Hรถhne said.

Australia is one of the worldโ€™s biggest coal exporters, and Turkey is a major coal consumer, with its power sector still highly dependent on the most climate-damaging fossil fuel. Even as they host this yearโ€™s climate conference, neither country has offered any specific plans to transition away from fossil fuels.

Bill Hare, the CEO of Climate Analytics, called out wealthy, developed countries for their lack of leadership on climate action, noting that European Union Commission President Ursula von der Leyen failed to mention anything about transitioning away from fossil fuels during her speech this week at COP31.

โ€œGovernments โ€ฆ at this COP have a stark choice,โ€ Hare said. If they continue supporting fossil fuels, โ€œit would consign humanity and our ecosystems to insurmountable economic damage and irretrievable loss.โ€

Greta Thunberg via Twitter

428.59 parts per million (ppm) CO2 in air 14-Nov-2026keelingcurve.ucsd.edu

— The Keeling Curve (@keelingcurve.bsky.social) 2026-11-15T17:14:41.457Z

Romancing the River โ€“ #ColoradoRiver โ€˜Mathologyโ€™ — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com) #COriver #aridification

An unauthorized 1981 tour of the canal for the Central Arizona Project (CAP) โ€“ no one was around to ask permission, so I had to climb over a fence to get into it. Credit: George Sibley

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

November 10, 2026

The image above is yours truly, in an unauthorized 1981 tour of the canal for the Central Arizona Project (CAP) โ€“ no one was around to ask permission, so I had to climb over a fence to get into it. I was working with film auteur and friend, Len Aitken from Boulder, on a film about the Colorado River based on an article I had written for Harperโ€™s in 1977.

Throughout the film Len used narrative backgrounds, like this one, that showed the massive magnitude of these efforts to, as it were, โ€˜make the Colorado River vision concrete.โ€™ This 3,000 cubic-feet-per-second canal runs 250-some miles, from water backed up behind Parker Dam on the Colorado River (downstream from Hoover Dam) through empty desert to the Phoenix metropolitan area, and then, in smaller size, another hundred miles to Tucson.

With leaves and desert dirt blown in, it looks a little desolate; it was still under construction when we shot the film in 1981, and didnโ€™t start to carry water until 1985; the CAP was declared complete in 1993. But today, Arizonans fear that the desolated look here might be the look of the futureโ€ฆ. And therein lie some stories โ€“ ironic for sure, but also tragic, if your definition of tragedy is โ€˜knowledge gained too late to prevent the unfolding of misfortune that could have been avoided had the knowledge been gained before acting.โ€™ Climate change. American political shifts. And the ever-unfolding tragedy of our overwhelming success as a swarming species.

Last post I said we would begin exploring how the waters of a desert river might be more equitably distributed among users. I will get to that eventually. But right now current events along the Colorado River are unfolding and being reported with no sense of the currents flowing into and through themโ€ฆ. Some backgrounding, the rest of the story, is needed โ€“ if only for a morbid laugh or two.

Underlying these stories is the mythology of the desert conquered, a mythology embraced nationally: that technology, science and rationality would overcome and correct the irregularities and shortfalls of nature. This mythology had begun to show cracks by the time that big ditch was completed;  the Central Arizona Project was the mythologyโ€™s last hurrah in the Colorado River Basin.

When I last wrote here, the Bureau of Reclamation had just rolled out a ten-year management plan to try to save the Colorado River system โ€“ mainly to prevent the two big storage reservoirs, Mead and Powell, from dropping to the dead-pool stage when water cannot be moved past the big dams. In order to be able to continue releasing water from the storage dams,  the Bureau finds it necessary to reduce the amount of water theyโ€™ve been releasing this century.

Accordingly, the Bureau announced in their ten-year plan โ€“ an adaptive plan to be revised as needed every two years โ€“ that 1.2 million acre-feet of cuts must be made in the first two-year segment, the 2027 and 2028 water years, all of it from the three states below Hoover Dam. And given the dour reality that the riverโ€™s flow will continue diminishing as the ambient temperatures rise, the Bureauโ€™s ten-year goal is a total reduction among all users of at least three million acre-feet of consumptive use by 2035, to build up some semblance of carry-over storage in the system.

Nevada then had filed a lawsuit against the Department of Interior/Bureau of Reclamation over the cuts in water delivery proposed. And since then, both the State of Arizona and the Central Arizona Project Board have โ€˜intervenedโ€™ (joined) in the lawsuit.

The lawsuit claims that the Bureau is relying on the three Lower Basin states to carry the entire burden of the consequences of an ongoing quarter-century drought. The plaintiffs want the Bureau to impose cuts on the four Upper Basin states too, or at the very least to adhere to the โ€˜Law of the Riverโ€™ built on the 1922 Colorado River Compact, requiring the Upper Basin states to โ€“ well, to continue doing what they have been doing for a century: making sure enough water gets past the Lee Ferry division point to meet the Lower Basinโ€™s Compact share and the Mexican treaty allotment.

Irony begins with the State of Arizona asking the Bureau to adhere to the letter of the Colorado River Compact; Arizona had refused to ratify the Compact in 1922 โ€“ probably understandably. The original Compact objective had been to insure Californiaโ€™s rapid development would leave enough water in the river for the other six basin states; the Compact they came up with protected half of the riverโ€™s water for the four Upper Basin states, but left Arizona and Nevada, as it were, โ€˜in the cage with the 800-pound Bear State.โ€™

Arizona Navy photo via California State University

In 1934, when the Bureau of Reclamation began construction of Parker Dam, below Hoover Dam (also still in construction), Arizona went on the offensive with California. The purpose of Parker Dam was to back up water for Californiaโ€™s pumping station for its massive 250-mile Colorado River Aqueduct to Los Angeles and San Diego. So Arizonaโ€™s governor sent the National Guard out to stop construction. This quickly devolved into a Keystone Cops comedy. A boat to confront the workers with an order to desist started to sink, and the construction workers rescued the Guardsmen and redeposited them on the Arizona bank, then went back to work and the National Guardsmen slunk back home.

Arizona finally signed the Compact in 1944, to get status to sue California over Compact issues โ€“ a semi-successful suit in which the Supreme Court, after ten years of analysis by โ€˜water masters,โ€™ granted Arizona full use of the Gila River without charging its million-plus acre-feet against Arizonaโ€™s 2.8 million acre-foot โ€˜mainstemโ€™ Compact allotment. But the court also mandated the allotting of water to several of the 22 First People tribes in Arizona and ordered negotiations to commence for providing water for other tribes โ€“ a responsibility bypassed in the original Compact.

But Arizonaโ€™s main problem with Californiaโ€™s Colorado Aqueduct was probably mostly their desire for an aqueduct like that for central Arizona โ€“ envy may be the largest root of irrational antagony.

โ€˜Central Arizonaโ€™ is a region of relatively mellow desert river valleys โ€“ the Verde flowing in from the north off the Colorado Plateau, the Salt flowing out of canyons off the Mogollon Rim, and the Gila flowing up from the south off the Rim. The three desert rivers accumulate around a million acre-feet of upland water in a good year, which originally flowed off across the deserts as the Gila River, to a confluence with the Colorado River at Yuma. But by World War II, all three tributaries were so fully used in Central Arizona that water would only flow to Yuma in a big water year.

When Carl Hayden was elected to the Senate in 1926, after a decade as a central Arizona Representative, he had epitomized the mythology and the vision of a huge water project to bring water from the Colorado River to the upper Gila valleys. In the period of growth after World War II, he made it his opus magnum, with the people of Arizona returning him to office for seven terms until finally in 1968, after numerous defeats, the Colorado River Basin Project Act was passed, with the CAP its main focus. Carl Hayden, 90 years old, could finally resign at the end of his seventh term.

The Central Arizona Project canal carries water through Phoenix in 2019. The project’s former general manager, Ted Cooke, was recently nominated to run the top federal agency for the Colorado River. Those who have worked with Cooke described him as a qualified expert. Ted Wood/The Water Desk

Compromises had been made to the simple purity of his vision, however. In order to get Arizonaโ€™s old nemesis California reluctantly on board for the vote, the bill had to specify that the CAPโ€™s water right would be junior to other existing water rights in the Basin โ€“ thus running roughshod over the original Compact commissionโ€™s desire to allot to each state water to develop on its own schedule, independent of other statesโ€™ appropriative seniority.

By the 1960s, the surface water in the valleys was exhausted, and farmers and developers both had been pumping groundwater to the extent that emptied aquifers were beginning to collapse, causing surface subsidence. So the state was ordered by Interior to come up with a groundwater management plan before construction would start on the CAP. The state created a Department of Water Resources, and in 1980 adopted a Groundwater Management Plan with โ€˜Active Management Areasโ€™ in the parts to be served by the CAP (basically the Phoenix-Tucson corridor); those areas were to be brought into โ€˜safe yieldโ€™ balance where withdrawals from the ground would be matched by CAP water plus existing surface supplies by 2025. Unfortunately, so many existing users were โ€˜grandfatheredโ€™ and exempted from restrictions that it was impossible to meet the 2025 goal of โ€˜safe yieldโ€™ in those AMAs by their target 2025. A quarter century of drought and the onset of climate change have not helped.

They also did something that could be regarded as wasteful, if not just stupid. The CAP base allotment from the Colorado River was just under a million acre-feet, but there was surplus water in the river system that was not yet being used by the Upper Basin states โ€“ and California had already, back in the 1930s, built its aqueduct to carry twice as much as its 500,000 acre-feet allotment, โ€˜borrowingโ€™ some of that surplus until it was needed by others. And if California could do that, why couldnโ€™t Arizona? And the Bureau, avatar of the desert mythology and blessed with a bad head for numbers, went along with it.

So the ditch Iโ€™m standing in was built to carry half again more water than its legal allotment. They advertised the proposed project as carrying a 50-year average of 1.2 maf. But that is what we night call โ€˜mathologyโ€™ โ€“ manipulating numbers to better serve a mythology. That deceptive โ€˜averageโ€™ began with projected deliveries of 1.55 maf in 1985, gradually decreasing to deliveries of 0.984 maf by 2035. So one of the fastest growing areas in the nation would have a declining water supply to grow on, and a canal eventually only 60 percent full โ€“ unless they could find some more water. Maybe from the Columbia River! But Oregon Senator Jackson cut that idea off, inserting in the CR Basin Project Act a ban on even discussing that for 25 years. Nonetheless, ideas of bringing in water from some other mythic river with a โ€˜surplusโ€™ still float around.

A final Arizona short story from the 1970s that foretold the future of the desert mythology. In 1977 โ€“ a complete newbie in Colorado River matters working on an article for Harperโ€™s about the river โ€“ I did a cold call at the office of Wes Steiner, Arizonaโ€™s head water engineer then. I was told that he wasnโ€™t in; he was down at (some auditorium) at an open Water Commission work session about the proposed distribution of municipal CAP water when it was actually built.

I went down to that meeting, and basically watched the death throes of the desert conquest mythology. The Commission had 500,000 uncommitted acre-feet to meet requests for over two million requested for approved or pending developments. The way it resolved the problem was by giving everyone something โ€“ allotments ranging from 3 percent to 100 percent of their requests, with the average around 25 to 30 percent. The engineers were candid in saying that most of the developments would probably outgrow their issue of CAP water, and rather quickly.

As recently as 2021, even though there was no more โ€˜surplusโ€™ water in the Colorado River Basin, the CAP deliveries were still in the 1.3-1.4 maf range; the Bureau, faithful to the mythology, was allowing its diminishing Mead storage to be drawn down to support the mythology.

In 2003 Congress passed a โ€˜Colorado River Quantification Settlement Facilitation Actโ€™ which politely ordered California to stop using borrowed water and bring its Colorado River use down to its Compact allotment of 4.4 maf, which California has been working to do. And nature is now forcing the Bureau to do the same thing to the CAP; from 2022 to the present, CAP deliveries have dropped abruptly to under a million acre-feet. The biggest cuts in the Active Management Areas have been to agriculture โ€“ which just means that the grandfathered farmers will go back to pumping more groundwater, further undermining groundwater management.

And that is basically where Arizona stands today, as it lashes out to sue someone else for its troubles. The CAP will take a large cut in its allotment this year, and probably more cuts within the ten year plan โ€“ not because they lost a lawsuit, but because the river system will just not have enough water to deliver what their โ€˜mathologyโ€™ decreed for them.

The structural deficit refers to the consumption by Lower Basin states of more water than enters Lake Mead each year. The deficit, which includes losses from evaporation, is estimated at 1.2 million acre-feet a year. (Image: Central Arizona Project circa 2019)

But it should be noted that these initial Bureau cuts only take care of the โ€˜structural deficit,โ€™ which was the Bureau allowing the Lower Basin States to continue considering their system losses (evaporation and bank losses) and their half of the Mexican obligation as covered by โ€˜surplus,โ€™ even though the mythic surplus disappeared when the CAP went online in the late 1980s and Upper Basin kept increasing. Conservatively, the Bureau released more than a million acre-feet per year for three decades that should have been deducted from the allotments to the Lower Basin states since the beginning of the whole river project (as they are for the Upper Basin states). Those 30-plus million acre-foot releases are where the storage base disappeared; climate-change and drought are only contributing factors.

One hopes that all of this will come out when the Supremesโ€™ water master digs in. But Arizona and all the states would probably do better if instead they all just held a cremation for the old river mythology (and the mathology of its misbegotten Compact), and set about enacting a new mythology in which they all transcend state boundaries and work together on sharing out the use and maintenance of a one still beautiful, diminishing, desert river and its mountain waters that run through them all.


NOTE: Anyone interested can see Len Aitkenโ€™s 1981 film โ€˜โ€™The River in the Desertโ€™ by clicking here. Itโ€™s a little fuzzy because it was transposed from film (remember film?), and there are a few things I wish Iโ€™d said better. But much of it has stood the test of time pretty well.

Iโ€™ve also included the 1977 Harperโ€™s essay, โ€˜The Desert Empireโ€™ โ€“ ditto on standing the test of time.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Why Shoshone water rights matter to Mesa County

Shoshone hydroelectric plant penstocks. Photo credit: Mesa County

Click the link to read the release on the Mesa County website

November 10, 2026

The Colorado River supports farms, businesses, recreation, wildlife and communities across Mesa County. Some of the river’s flow is influenced by water rights held by the Shoshone Hydroelectric Plant in Glenwood Canyon, nearly 90 miles upstream from the Grand Valley.

Mesa County has committed $1 million toward a proposed purchase of those rights and is participating in a water court case that could shape how they are used in the future.

The Shoshone plant holds two water rights that together allow it to use up to 1,408 cubic feet of water per second when the rights are available.

In Colorado, older water rights have priority over newer ones. When a senior right is in priority and calls for the water, some upstream users with junior rights may have to reduce their diversions so water can reach the senior right.

The plant uses the water to generate electricity and then returns it to the river. The water is not consumed, but goes back into the river after making power. Its historic rights have helped support downstream river uses, including in the Grand Valley.

The Shoshone rights are tied primarily to generating electricity. If the plant permanently stops operating, the river’s historic benefits from the rights could be at risk.

The Colorado River District has agreed to buy the water rights from Public Service Company of Colorado, an Xcel Energy subsidiary. The purchase agreement is referred to as the $99 million transaction. If the sale goes through, Xcel would continue operating the plant and lease the rights from the River District while the plant remains in operation.

The River District, the Colorado Water Conservation Board and Public Service Company are asking the Water Court to add instream flow as an authorized use when the rights are not being used to generate power. Instream flow is water that stays in a river to support the natural environment.

The proposed instream flow use applies to a roughly two-mile stretch between the Shoshone diversion dam and the plant’s discharge outlets. The application does not ask for a new water right or for instream flow use downstream of that stretch.

The case is pending in the Colorado Water Court. The court must determine how the rights have historically been used, including how often they called for water and how much water was involved. It must also determine what limits and safeguards are needed to prevent harm to other water rights.

In January 2026, the County filed a statement of opposition in support of the application. That filing makes the County a party to the case so it can support the proposed change while advocating for safeguards that protect local water users.

No final court decision has been made. A trial is scheduled for July 2028. The purchase has not closed and current hydropower operations continue. The purchase also depends on other steps, including securing the required funding and receiving Colorado Public Utilities Commission approval.

The County’s interest is tied to the river’s importance to Mesa County’s economy and quality of life.

Mesa County will continue to participate in the case and share updates as the process moves forward.

Bicycling the Colorado National Monument, Grand Valley in the distance via Colorado.com

U.S. Senate votes to proceed with permitting reform debate (BAAJA) — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

A tiny house that ended up in Junction Creek after early November torrential rains turned the normally modest-sized stream into a raging monster that crushed bridges, wrecked roads, ripped the foundations from under homes, tore up hundreds of large trees, jumped its banks and turned a Durango street into a river, and left tons of thick, dense, muck in its wake. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

November 9, 2026

๐Ÿ”ญ OVERSIGHT (or lack thereof) ๐Ÿ‘ฎ๐Ÿผ

The U.S. Senate just voted today to proceed with debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, aimed at streamlining and accelerating federal environmental reviews and permitting for major projects.

The legislation has opened a nasty rift within the environmental movement, one that was not soothed by the billโ€™s sponsorโ€™s recent amendment attempting to address concerns. In recent days, opposition has mounted, with even Al Gore coming out against the legislation as itโ€™s currently written. Meanwhile, President Donald Trump urged the billโ€™s passage in a social media post, calling it a โ€œBIG WIN for U.S. ENERGY INDEPENDENCE and DOMINANCE.โ€

After the bill was first introduced, many climate hawks, Abundance adherents, and clean energy industry leaders threw their weight behind the bill, saying it is necessary to rapidly decarbonize the power grid and address the climate crisis. But more traditional green groups, tribal nations, and historic preservation advocates have pushed back hard on the legislationโ€™s provisions that weaken bedrock environmental laws and the National Historic Preservation Act.

While the legislation likely would make it easier and quicker to build solar and wind projects and the transmission needed to ferry that energy from where itโ€™s generated to where itโ€™s needed, it would do the same for fossil fuel projects, such as natural gas or oil pipelines. It would also bar a future administration from nixing a project that a previous administration authorized. This would have blocked the Trump administration from cancelling permitted wind projects, but also would have kept the Biden administration from axing the Keystone XL pipeline.

As more of these details have emerged, prominent clean energy advocates, such as Bill McKibben, and climate activists, including Al Gore, have come out in opposition to the legislation. A major concern is that the Trump administration would use the reforms to push through destructive energy projects.

At its core, the legislation tweaks major laws, including the Endangered Species Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, and the Clean Water Act, and even the 1872 General Mining Law in ways that not only accelerate permitting timelines for major projects, but also makes it more difficult for tribes, states, advocacy groups, and the general public to stop or force changes to the proposed development.

I wrote about some of this for High Country News last week.

In May of 2023, the Biden administrationโ€™s Bureau of Land Management issued a final approval to Pattern Energy to construct its long-planned SunZia transmission line, which was designed to carry wind power from eastern New Mexico to a major grid hub in the Phoenix area, where it could then be transmitted across the Southwest. Clean energy advocates lauded the move, since it would enable Southwestern states to tame the solar โ€œduck curveโ€ โ€” or fill in the power gap left when the sun goes down โ€” with wind power rather than natural gas generation, thus reducing the gridโ€™s carbon footprint.

But SunZia was also held up as a prime example for why permitting reform for these kinds of projects is necessary. The approval came after 17 years of review by various federal agencies, and after a previous 2015 BLM approval was scrapped and the project sent back to the drawing board after New Mexico regulators balked due to potential impacts to migratory birds. The climate crisis needs to be addressed now, advocates said, and there wasnโ€™t time for these clean energy-enabling projects to wade through the bureaucracy for a decade or more โ€” only to be potentially blocked by a post-approval lawsuit. They called on Congress to clear a path through the morass of red tape to speed up such projects.

The call was heeded in September, when a group of Republican and Democratic senators, including public lands champion Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-NM) and hard right Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT), introduced the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, aimed at streamlining and accelerating federal environmental reviews and permitting for major projects. Groups as disparate as Americans for a Clean Energy Grid and the American Petroleum Institute got together to support the legislation in concert with the Abundance movement and climate hawks. The Breakthrough Instituteโ€™s Marc Levitt called it โ€œa heroic breakthrough for permitting reform โ€ฆ that opens the door to a new era of climate policy, infrastructure, and long-term price stabilization.โ€ The NRDC praised the billโ€™s transmission-related provisions, saying the red-tape-slashing policies, which the Columbia Center on Global Energy Policy estimates would cut the average transmission permitting timeline by 96 months, โ€œare an essential component of accelerating the electrification and decarbonization of the power sector and achieving greenhouse gas reduction targets.โ€

Yet one personโ€™s red tape is another personโ€™s environmental safeguards. In order to achieve its goal of accelerating transmission and other energy projects, the legislation takes aim at bedrock environmental laws such as the National Environmental Policy Act, the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act, and the National Historic Protection Act. And to get Republicans on board, the billโ€™s provisions had to be extended to apply not just to clean energy projects, but also fossil fuel ones. To more ecology-minded green groups, tribal nations, and more progressive federal lawmakers, the gutting of these laws goes too far, and could result in damage to communities, landscapes, and cultural sites. Western Environmental Law Centerโ€™s Erik Schlenker-Goodrich called the bill a โ€œturd grenade.โ€ Even the NRDC called these provisions โ€œdeeply flawed,โ€ and vowed to get them changed before the bill goes to a vote on Nov. 9.

Hereโ€™s a rundown of some of the more significant changes under the proposed bill, and what they might mean:

National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)

NEPA, signed into law in 1970, requires federal agencies to consider the potential environmental impacts of major federal developments through environmental impact statements (EIS) or environmental analyses (EA). It is considered the bedrock environmental law, is most often blamed for project delays and would be subject to the most significant changes under BAAJA. Those include:

  • While the 2023 Fiscal Responsibility Act put a two-year time limit on completion of an EIS and one year for an EA, it did not set a limit for a final decision. BAAJA would require the lead NEPA agency to issue a decision within 45 days of the EISโ€™s completion, and also speed up federal authorizations for other participating agencies. If the agencies failed to meet the deadline, the lead officers on the review would essentially be tied to their desks until the analysis was completed. This would significantly accelerate timelines, as the median completion time for an EIS is currently about 4.5 years.
  • BAAJA would limit organizationsโ€™ ability to file lawsuits against NEPA decisions and for what reasons, and sets a higher bar for who has โ€œstandingโ€ to bring such a suit. It also significantly shortens the statute of limitations for lawsuits, and would skip district courts and go straight to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, potentially putting plaintiffs at a disadvantage.
  • A court would not be allowed to put an injunction on a project based only on a violation of NEPA or the National Historical Protection Act (NHPA). This means construction could go forward โ€” and the environmental, human health or cultural impact realized โ€” even while a lawsuit was pending. And even if a court rules against the agency and finds it has violated NEPA, it will merely send the EIS or EA back to the agency and ask for fixes, not vacate the approval, meaning, again, that development could continue along with its impacts.
  • BAAJA would exempt from NEPA: projects already subjected to state or tribal reviews; repair, maintenance, replacement, upgrading, rebuilding, or modification of electricity transmission or distribution lines or substations and natural gas facilities; energy storage projects if built โ€œat or nearโ€ a transmission line.

โ€œIn short, BAAJA would pull NEPAโ€™s principal teethโ€”the possibility of a court order blocking a project for violating NEPA,โ€ writes Michael B. Gerrard, Andrew Sabin Professor of Professional Practice at Columbia Law School.

National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA)

Congress passed NHPA in 1966 to protect historic, cultural and archaeological sites, and requires the jurisdictional agency to determine whether a proposed development might affect historic properties. If so, it triggers Section 106 of the law, often called โ€œidentify and avoid,โ€ which requires the agency to consult with tribal nations or other potential stakeholders to identify potentially affected properties, and to work to avoid, minimize or mitigate adverse effects on those properties. Section 106 is often the only thing standing between a bulldozer blade and an ancient pueblo or other cultural site. Changes under BAAJA include:

  • The bill would require that Section 106 reviews are finished by the deadline for the NEPA EIS or EA, potentially significantly shortening the timeline for tribal consultation and cultural inventories and archaeological surveys, which can take years for major projects such as pipelines or transmission lines. Also, if a tribal historic preservation officer misses the deadline, they could be penalized and the tribal nation could lose federal funding.
  • BAAJA would raise the threshold for triggering Section 106 reviews, effectively limiting the scope of and exempting some projects from the analyses, while also removing the requirement that tribal nations be consulted before identifying a historic property (they would only be consulted after the determination). That, in turn, would limit tribal nationsโ€™ involvement in reviews of proposed developments that may adversely affect their lands or cultural sites.
  • As with NEPA, the bill would block courts from issuing injunctions or vacating approvals for proposed projects, even if the court finds against the agency.
Native land loss 1776 to 1930. Credit: Alvin Chang/Ranjani Chakraborty

The National Congress of American Indians, along with other tribal organizations, in an Oct. 9 letter, called on the legislationโ€™s sponsors to withdraw Title III โ€” the section concerning NHPA โ€” from the bill altogether, saying these provisions are โ€œin deep conflict with federal trust and treaty obligations to engage sovereign Tribal Nations in government-to-government Tribal consultation and to protect our irreplaceable cultural heritage. โ€ฆ Tribal Nations should not be forced to bear the brunt of these cultural and spiritual harms so the nation can further develop and transport its energy resources. We have already sacrificed the majority of our lands and natural resourcesโ€”oftentimes through force or coercionโ€”upon which the United States has become the world power it is today.โ€

Clean Water Act:

When a pipeline, transmission line or other project crosses over, under or otherwise affects a jurisdictional body of water, the Clean Water Actโ€™s Section 401 requires that the development be certified by the relevant states or tribal nations to protect water quality. States and tribes have used this authority to block projects or to push the developers to reroute them or redesign them to mitigate impacts. BAAJA would:

  • Limit Section 401 powers by narrowly defining the kinds of water quality impacts that could trigger a stateโ€™s or tribal nationโ€™s denial. It puts the burden of proof on the state or tribe to show that the proposed project would harm water quality regardless of modifications or mitigation.
  • Curtail the amount of time the Environmental Protection Agency has to veto Army Corps of Engineers Clean Water Act permits for major projects. The EPA used this veto power to halt the Pebble Mine in Alaska. By shortening the time frame, it would preclude a new administration from blocking a project approved under a previous one.

Endangered Species Act (ESA)

BAAJA would:

  • Reduce the Fish and Wildlife Services ESA consultation time limit from 90 days to 60 days.
  • Exempt activities within rights of way of certain federally funded highways from the ESA, and allow states to take over the consultation process. This would create inconsistency from state to state, sometimes even for the same project, and could imperil endangered species in states that are hostile to environmental protections.
  • Hamper judicial review via tighter timelines and sending any lawsuits straight to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals.

General Mining Law

This is not an environmental protection law. Itโ€™s quite the opposite, actually, having allowed mining companies to ravage public lands since 1872. However, in 2022 a federal judge blocked the proposed Rosemont copper mine in Arizona from dumping tailings and waste rock on public land on which it had staked mining claims.

The Rosemont Decision, as it has come to be known, relied on a provision in the law that says a mining claim is not valid unless the claimant proves it contains valuable minerals, and therefore cannot be used for those purposes. The exception are a type of claim called mill sites, which are no larger than five acres and intended to be used for mills or other mining-support facilities (including waste disposal), must be non-contiguous with the mineral claims, and to which the valuable mineral requirement does not apply. A mine is usually limited to just one mill site.

BAAJA would allow a mining firm to stake as many mill sites as โ€œreasonably necessary for its operations โ€ฆ and โ€ฆ use or occupy public land in accordance with approved plan of operations.โ€ This would effectively nullify the Rosemont Decision and allow large mining companies to claim hundreds or even thousands of acres of public land for waste disposal and storage.

Project Certainty

BAAJA would block a president from cancelling energy projects approved by a previous administration by prohibiting โ€œany new action that would revoke, rescind, withdraw, terminate, suspend, amend, or alter a Federal authorization or permit in effect on or after Sept. 16, 2026, or take any other action to interfere with or prevent the construction or operation at full capacity of a project that has secured all necessary Federal authorizations.โ€

This is clearly aimed at the Trump administrationโ€™s penchant for cancelling onshore and offshore wind projects and solar projects on public land. But it also would have prevented the Biden administration, for example, from cancelling the contested Keystone XL pipeline on his first days in the Oval Office.

Also, the provision barring an agency from taking โ€œany other actionโ€ to prevent โ€œoperation at full capacityโ€ could be used to block regulators from enforcing pollution limits, worker safety rules and human health and safety protections.

Is Permitting Reform Really Necessary?

The aforementioned SunZia project is certainly a good example of how long the NEPA process can take. But it also demonstrates how the currently arduous permitting path can improve a project and yet still not be rigorous enough to protect important cultural and environmental sites. In New Mexico, for example, conservationists and state officials were able to use the process to push the developers to reroute the path to avoid harming migratory bird flyways, garnering the project โ€” and the process โ€” Audubon Southwestโ€™s endorsement as a case study of how permitting works.

But in Arizona, when Indigenous nations and conservation groups tried to get SunZia to reroute the line away from the fragile, biodiverse San Pedro River Valley to protect birds and other wildlife along with culturally significant sites, Arizona regulators shrugged them off โ€” not surprisingly, since they tend to be more amenable to such projects and less responsive to environmental concerns than their New Mexican counterparts.

So when Arizona regulators unanimously approved the project in November 2022, they removed any incentive for SunZia to reroute the line in Arizona the way it did in New Mexico. The BLMโ€™s preferred route remained alongside the San Pedro River, despite the objections of tribal nations and conservationists. An ensuing lawsuit continues to work its way through the courts, but has failed to stop or pause construction โ€” even under the current, more rigorous permitting regime.

Now the San Pedro River faces another challenge: A proposed natural gas pipeline called Desert Southwest, which would carry methane from the Permian Basin to Arizona, passing right through the Pedro River Valley north of Tucson. Under the current permitting regime, the project would be subjected to rigorous NEPA and National Historic Preservation Act reviews, while tribes and states would have more say under the Clean Water Act. But if the permitting reform legislation becomes law, the project could be exempted from these reviews, meant to protect people and places, altogether.


โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Iโ€™ll be doing a big overview/data dump/historical context dispatch on the Four Corners flooding in a dispatch later this week. But for now, here are a few images I captured while traveling around the region, gazing with awe and dismay at the destruction inflicted.

Overturned tanks at an oil and gas facility near Montezuma Creek, Utah. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
Wrecked Forest Service road in the Junction Creek drainage near Durango. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
A bridge used to cross Hermosa Creek just beyond the pictured gate. It was carried away by the flooding. Jonathan P. Thompson photo

#Nevada Judge Could Dictate Wyoming’s Future Share Of #ColoradoRiver Water — Cowboy State Daily #COriver #aridification

Wyoming State Engineer Brandon Gebhart, left, and state water attorney Chris Brown updated lawmakers on Friday about escalating tensions over Colorado River water rights. (Courtesy Wyoming Legislative Service Office)

Click the link to read the article on the Cowboy State Daily website (Mark Heinz). Here’s an excerpt:

November 6, 2026

As Nevada and Arizona prepare for a federal court battle with the U.S. Department of the Interior over dwindling water supplies from the Colorado River, state officials are warning legislators that Wyoming could be impacted by the fight. State Engineerย Brandon Gebhardt represents Wyoming on the Upper Colorado River Commission. On Friday in Casper, he told the Legislatureโ€™s Select Water Committee that the commission hadnโ€™t yet decided whether the four Upper Basin states will intervene in the court battle.

Water committee co-chair Rep. Martha Lawley, R-Worland, said the potential effects of the federal court battle involving Nevada on Wyoming canโ€™t be taken lightly.

โ€œWe could end up in a situation where a federal court in the state of Nevada could be taking over the (water) management. Really, the job of the Bureau of Reclamation,โ€ she said.

Gebhardt was joined in updating the committee by Chris Brown, supervising attorney general for the water section in the Wyoming Attorney Generalโ€™s Office. At one point, Lawley asked Brown if her assessment of the situation was accurate.

โ€œMadame Chair, from my personal perspective, you are on target,โ€ Brown responded.

Brown at one point suggested that tensions over the Colorado River could end up before the Supreme Court.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

New bill slashes tribesโ€™ role in projects that impact ancestral sites, water and wildlife: Native nations have come out against a Senate permitting reform bill, Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 (BAAJA) — Anna V. Smith (High Country News)

Art inspired by three landscapes experiencing threats of mining: Mount Taylor, New Mexico, Fajada Butte, New Mexico and Devils Tower, Wyoming. Marty Two Bulls, Jr./High Country News

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Anna V. Smith):

November 5, 2026

In 2024, a subsidiary of the mining company Energy Fuels revived its plans to open the Roca Honda Uranium Mine in New Mexico near Mount Taylor, a place of cultural significance to at least 30 Native nations. The company had received expedited permitting under the Trump administration last year, and in mid-September, the Forest Service announced that it would begin to analyze the mineโ€™s potential impacts under the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA.

That process includes tribal consultation, which is critical to upholding tribesโ€™ ability to protect cultural landscapes, wildlife and water, would change dramatically under the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, a permitting reform bill introduced by Western Republican and Democratic senators, including Sens. Martin Heinrich, D-N.M., and Mike Lee, R-Utah. The Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources is expected to vote on it after Congress returns on Nov. 9.

The legislation is sweeping in its proposed changes, affecting core environmental laws well beyond NEPA, like the Endangered Species Act, Clean Water Act and National Historic Preservation Act. The permitting reform is meant to speed up industryโ€™ s ability to build mines, wind turbines, solar arrays, data centers, pipelines and more on federal lands. It has drawn fierce opposition from Native leaders and organizations, who argue that the increased speed comes at the cost of tribal sovereignty, and that they were not consulted before it was introduced.

Mt. Taylor and La Jara Mesa, where Laramide Resources is hoping to build a major uranium mine. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Mount Taylor in New Mexico and the greater Chaco landscape in Colorado, Arizona and Utah are among the many places that would be impacted by such legislation. โ€œMany of these places are outside our reservations. Federal law is how we have a voice when a mine, a pipeline or a transmission line is proposed that impacts our cultural resources, our sacred sites and our communities directly,โ€ said Acoma Pueblo Gov. Charles Riley at a national conference of tribal leaders in October. โ€œThis bill would take away most of that.โ€

If the legislation passes, a federal agency could choose not to consult with tribal nations about cultural sites at risk of being damaged by projects like the Roca Honda Mine โ€” a project that the Acoma Pueblo does not oppose, though the Navajo Nation and Isleta Pueblo do. General Counsel for the Acoma Pueblo, Aaron Sims, wrote in an email that the tribeโ€™s position comes as the result of a settlement, where the company made major concessions and changed the project. Timelines for reviewing complex documents would be shortened, and federal agencies would only be required to consider the impact of mining activities on federal land, even if a project covers both state and private lands, as the Roca Honda Mine does. In all, the legislation further distances tribes from federal decision-making on their ancestral lands and limits their options should a proposed project violate their rights.

โ€œThis is one of those extreme, existential threats thatโ€™s in front of us right now,โ€ said Mark Macarro (Pechanga), president of the National Congress of American Indians, at the organizationโ€™s conference. If senators donโ€™t make dramatic changes ahead of the November vote, Macarro said, โ€œthis bill needs to be killed.โ€

TRIBAL LEADERS AND ORGANIZATIONS ARE RAISING ALARM about proposed changes to Section 106 in the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), which currently requires federal agencies to consult with a tribe if a project could impact a cultural site. The proposed alterations are expansive: Tribal consultation would become optional and the scope of what would trigger it would narrow, while cultural sites would not need to be considered at all if they werenโ€™t formally identified before a review process commences.

The proposed changes are โ€œa direct assault on tribal sovereignty,โ€ said Ira Matt (Sรฉliลก), executive director for Indigenous Diplomacy and Federal Relations for the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers. The organization, along with the National Congress of American Indians and others, has called for senators to remove the NHPA section from the bill entirely.

According to Matt, the legislation would restrict how tribes define and protect their cultural heritage and undermine their rights to participate in decisions that affect their histories and futures. โ€œIt also places wholly unqualified federal agencies in the position of making decisions about our sacred places while threatening to assume control over tribal preservation programs developed to reflect each tribal nationโ€™s unique knowledge and lifeways,โ€ Matt said โ€œThese are not simply changes to a permitting process. They are deliberate attempts to undermine tribal self-determination.โ€

The Section 106 process is currently โ€œone of the most powerful toolsโ€ tribes have to inform federal decision-making, said Wesley Furlong, a senior staff attorney at the Native American Rights Fund who specializes in Section 106 reviews. State and tribal staff go through hundreds of thousands of Section 106 reviews every year, and many of those conclude without any changes needing to be made to a project. At other times, the reviews give tribes a chance to tell federal agencies how a project could damage sacred sites and cultural landscapes, many which are not on any federal agencyโ€™s radar. Even then, however, a review doesnโ€™t ensure that a place will be protected, and tribes cannot expect a specific result.

Furlong said the portion of the proposed bill involving Section 106 is a โ€œtotal dumpster fire and an absolute hatchet jobโ€ that clearly did not involve anyone familiar with tribes or the existing consultation process. Native nations are being โ€œforced to take the brunt of this โ€˜compromise.โ€™ Itโ€™s permitting reform at the expense of Indian County, tribal rights, and tribal resources.โ€

The importance โ€” and inadequacy โ€” of Section 106 for tribal nations was on display during the permitting process for the 550-mile-long SunZia Southwest Transmission Project, which would funnel wind energy from New Mexico to California. In 2024, tribal nations sued over the lack of tribal consultation. Last year, courts agreed and ordered the Bureau of Land Management to re-do consultation for the project, enabling tribes to mitigate possible harm to cultural sites in the San Pedro Valley in Arizona, though most of the transmission line has already been built.

AS WRITTEN, TRIBAL ADVOCATES worry that the bill could also limit federal agenciesโ€™ consideration of Indigenous knowledge by changing the definitions of the information that agencies must consider under the Endangered Species Act. It also shortens comment timelines and limits tribesโ€™ ability to pursue NEPA violations through the courts, and it lessens federal agenciesโ€™ mandate to incorporate as much relevant scientific information in their decision-making as possible. This could have on-the-ground effects in places like New Mexico, since the Forest Service would not have to incorporate any research published after it began its environmental impact statement for the Roca Honda Mine.

Tribes often need to bring up their own data or information about the impacts of a project after federal analysis has begun, said Daniel Cordalis (Navajo Nation) a staff attorney at the Native American Rights Fund who focuses on tribal water rights. When Cordalis was working on the Klamath River, tribal nations had to challenge the federal data that governed the flow of water and affected salmonโ€™s survival. Across the Western U.S., tribes are experts in fisheries science, forestry and hydrology, and their data may well differ from the federal governmentโ€™s. โ€œTribes often have the best scientists doing a lot of this work,โ€ said Cordalis. But rather than acknowledge tribesโ€™ knowledge and scientific research, the bill includes no โ€œrecognition of the role of another sovereign government whose rights and resources may be at stake.โ€

Tribes often need to bring up their own data or information about the impacts of a project after federal analysis has begun, said Daniel Cordalis (Navajo Nation) a staff attorney at the Native American Rights Fund who focuses on tribal water rights. When Cordalis was working on the Klamath River, tribal nations had to challenge the federal data that governed the flow of water and affected salmonโ€™s survival. Across the Western U.S., tribes are experts in fisheries science, forestry and hydrology, and their data may well differ from the federal governmentโ€™s. โ€œTribes often have the best scientists doing a lot of this work,โ€ said Cordalis. But rather than acknowledge tribesโ€™ knowledge and scientific research, the bill includes no โ€œrecognition of the role of another sovereign government whose rights and resources may be at stake.โ€

These changes could mean that tribal nations are not adequately included or considered in large-scale federal projects. And under a provision in the legislation called โ€œproject certainty,โ€ it would be much harder for the federal government to change or revoke a permit once a mine, solar array or wind project has one. That is exactly what the Biden administration did to halt the Keystone XL pipeline in 2021, after it was permitted under the first Trump administration despite the objections of numerous Native nations. Similarly, the Trump administration has sought to stop Biden-era offshore wind projects.

U.S. Senator Martin Heinrich. Credit: https://www.heinrich.senate.gov/contact

As of early November, tribal leaders along with environmental, archaeological and community organizations were still seeking to make changes to the bill and encouraging people to contact their senators to voice their concerns before the Senate votes on Nov. 9.

In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for Sen. Heinrich said that the senator doesnโ€™t believe the bill as written hurts tribal consultation, and that the bill โ€œdefends against the Trump administrationโ€™s efforts to make all Tribal consultation discretionary and eliminate consultation altogether on cultural landscapes. All of this means stronger Tribal consultation protections, lower utility bills, more good-paying jobs, and a path toward unlocking our clean energy future.โ€

Tribal nations already have very few laws at their disposal to protect ancestral lands or culturally important wildlife, or water, and the proposed legislation chips away at all of them, Cordalis said. โ€œThe positive and the real good things that tribes have been able to protect over the years โ€” probably wouldnโ€™t be able to have been protected under this.โ€

Native land loss 1776 to 1930. Credit: Alvin Chang/Ranjani Chakraborty

How protection of public land shapes political strategies in the Americanย West

An aerial view of a rocky landscape showing layers of sediment, evidence of erosion and tall peaks.
Parts of the Grand Staircase National Monument were removed from federal protection under the Trump administration, opening the way for mining and drilling. David McNew/Getty Images

Erika Allen Wolters, Oregon State University and Monica Hubbard, Boise State University

Public lands are intricately woven into the fabric of America. Years of data confirms that a majority of Americans, regardless of their political beliefs, want public lands to remain in federal hands โ€“ though not everyone agrees on how exactly those lands should be managed. And while itโ€™s not clear that public lands were a crucial factor in the 2026 midterm election results, survey data suggests that it is an important issue in deciding whom to vote for.

Federal conservation efforts began in the late 1800s, with Yellowstone becoming the first national park in 1872. Today, 640 million acres, nearly 30% of the countryโ€™s land area, are administered by the federal government for a wide range of purposes, including conservation, forestry, grazing and energy production. These lands are held in trust by the federal government for the American people.

In our studies of the politics of the American West, where the vast majority of U.S. public lands are located, we are seeing efforts to make voters aware of candidatesโ€™ views on land protection and to use grassroots political tactics to influence management decisions.

People stand on a staircase holding signs promoting public land and wilderness.
In 2017, moves to privatize public land sparked major protests, including in the Montana State Capitol. William Campbell/Corbis via Getty Images

Land transfers

Protesting government efforts to turn turn public spaces into private property, or to allow development on public land, are key ways people show the value they place on public lands.

In 2017, at the start of Donald Trumpโ€™s first term as president, U.S. Rep. Jason Chaffetz, a Utah Republican, proposed that the federal government transfer land to individual states. The states, underfunded and understaffed to manage the land themselves, would likely have sold the land to private interests. The response created the #KeepItPublic social media campaign and mobilized conservation groups against the bill. Land Tawney, president of Backcountry Hunters and Anglers, said, โ€œOnce that bill was introduced, the hornetโ€™s nest was kicked.โ€ Chaffetz pulled the bill and left Congress five months later.

And in 2025, after Trump returned to the White House, U.S. Sen. Mike Lee, a Utah Republican, proposed that Congress require the U.S. Bureau of Land Management and the U.S. Forest Service to sell between 2.2 million to 3.3 million acres of public land in 11 Western states. He said the land sale would help โ€œaddress local housing needs.โ€

But conservation groups and other Western lawmakers, including fellow Republican U.S. Sen. Tim Sheehy and Republican U.S. Rep. Ryan Zinke, also of Montana, declared the proposal a โ€œthreat to the Montana way of lifeโ€ and forced Lee to withdraw the proposal.

Public land management

There isnโ€™t available evidence to suggest that voters choose members of Congress based solely on their views or action about the management of public lands.

But elected officials often swiftly distance themselves from or outright oppose efforts to modify or eliminate public land protections. That response signals they believe their land protection stances play a role in how the public views them.

For example, Trump administration efforts to reduce Bears Ears National Monument and to swap a parcel in Yosemite National Park with a private developer met with opposition from both parties in Congress.

However, that opposition is not always successful at preventing development or natural resource extraction on public lands. In March and April 2026, both houses of Congress passed a resolution supporting mining near the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness in Minnesota, despite public outcry about the potential pollution of a vast wilderness.

Two people paddle a canoe across water toward a rocky tree-lined shore.
Protests in support of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness have not stopped a nearby mining proposal. Anthony Souffle/The Minnesota Star Tribune via Getty Images

Public lands in election politics

In 2026, two new groups emerged to call attention to threats to public lands. Protect Wyoming and PAC for Public Lands in Idaho both formed specifically to compile and publicize elected officialsโ€™ public lands voting records, especially when those votes affect peopleโ€™s rights to hunt, fish and enjoy the outdoors.

These groups may be able to tap into core land protection values broadly shared by many voters across the political spectrum. That could put more direct and consistent pressure on politicians to protect public lands.

Political headwinds

The Trump administration has moved to limit people from mobilizing in support of public lands.

For instance, Trumpโ€™s Jan. 20, 2025, executive order declaring a โ€œnational energy emergencyโ€ has led the Department of the Interior to accelerate its review of proposals for oil and gas drilling, production and refining, and mining, along with other energy-related natural resource development.

A process that used to take one to two years has been reduced to no more than a month. That provides less time for people to review documents, understand what they say and decide how they feel about the proposals. However, 15 states are now suing the Trump administration, saying that fast-tracking violates federal law and seeking court orders to restore the previous process.

And in January 2026, the White House Council on Environmental Quality revised the rules around public comments on proposed federal land management actions. Government agencies are required under the National Environmental Policy Act to give the public a chance to comment on rule changes. It is the primary way the public can raise objections, question the thoroughness of the options, or to provide other evidence to help inform policy. The council significantly shortened, or in some cases eliminated, the time period during which the public may submit comments โ€“ though that decision has also been challenged in court, saying the Administrative Procedure Act requires the original amount of public comment.

A person stands next to an open area of land.
A data center proposal initially meant for private land near Boulder City, Nevada, was moved to nearby federal land in the face of public opposition. AP Photo/John Locher

Retaining the public trust

How the government handles data center development may shed further light on the political power of public lands. Back in July 2025, Trump issued an executive order seeking to โ€œutilize federally owned land and resources for the expeditious and orderly development of data centers.โ€

In fall 2026, media outlets and advocacy groups called attention to efforts to develop data centers on public lands, including at least 17 computing campuses in six states.

Nearly two-thirds of Americans oppose data centers being built in their communities. Some politicians have questioned the deals on federal land.

These centers were on the minds of voters in the midterm elections, nowhere more than in the Nevada gubernatorial race, where the Democratic challenger won on a platform to oppose projects on federal land. Voter discontent may not stop the Trump administration from moving forward, but it all but guarantees that data centers on public lands will be an issue in the 2028 general election. The degree to which the opposition gains political momentum could be another indicator of how the American public will act to continue to demand that public lands remain in public hands.

Erika Allen Wolters, Associate Professor of Political Science, Oregon State University and Monica Hubbard, Professor of Public Policy and Administration, Boise State University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

How this #ColoradoRiver disaster can be averted: Brad Udall remains hopeful a settlement will be negotiated but warns that huge changes will be needed in response to #ClimateChange — Allen Best (BigPivots.com) #COriver #aridification

Brad Udall. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

November 3, 2026

Brad Udall remains hopeful a settlement will be negotiated but warns that huge changes will be needed in response to climate change. Might prior appropriation be one of them?

Colorado State Universityโ€™s Brad Udall makes the case that the Colorado River Basin is the worldโ€™s first place where climate change is โ€œforcing a complete redo of water management.โ€

The climate change component of that statement seems unassailable. Flows in the Colorado River have declined 21% this century. A river that averaged 15.2 million acre-feet in flows during the 20thcentury has fallen to 12.2 million acre-feet in the 21st. It has further tapered off to 10 million acre-feet in the last few years.

Temperature increases of 3.3 degrees Fahrenheit since 1970 explain much of that decline. A one- degree Fahrenheit rise in temperature results in 5% loss due to increased evaporation. โ€œHot drought,โ€ the phrase Udall favors, will only worsen, he says, as the process he and others call aridification will continue to worsen. Temperatures, said Udall at a recent forum, can continue to rise.

โ€œThe latest science tells us that the rate of warming has almost doubled. And the fossil fuel industry is showing no signs of exit or no signs of transformation to some other business model that doesnโ€™t involve polluting the Earth,โ€ he said.

Existing greenhouse gas emissions will, he added, continue to incrementally heat the Earth into the 22nd century even if humanity can reduce greenhouse gas emissions to zero.

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

As for the water management redo, itโ€™s still early. Colorado River runoff has been in decline for the last quarter-century. California and Arizona, the two lower-basin states with great thirst, were able to live off water banked in the two giant reservoirs, Mead and Powell, for many of those years. Only as the storage has ratcheted down to dangerously low levels have meaningful reductions in use begun, some only temporary in nature but others permanent.

The two states plus Nevada last year used about 6.8 million acre-feet from the river, less than the 7.5 million apportioned them the Colorado River Compact of 1922 and far less than the 8.5 million acre-feet they had averaged for several decades.

Upper-basin states had also been allotted 7.5 million acre-feet by the 1922 compact, but they have never come close to using that much water. Lacking the certainty of large upstream reservoirs, they have used about 4.5 million acre-feet.

Big cuts ahead

But big changes necessarily lie ahead, certainly for the lower-basin states but also Colorado and the other upper-basin states, Udall said in in a recent 90-minute plus presentation called โ€œDancing with Deadpool: a 27-Year-Long Colorado River Crisis.โ€ The forum in Jefferson County was sponsored by the Colorado Renewable Energy Society and New Energy Colorado.

โ€œWe gotta get rid of those old agreements,โ€ said Udall, the senior water and climate research scientist/scholar at Colorado Water Center.

โ€œWe in the Upper Basin must share this risk and not increase our use. The Lower Basin needs to plan on bigger cuts, more than 3 million acre-feet,โ€ he said, citing a paper he co-authored called โ€œWhat will it take to stabilize the Colorado River?โ€ that was published in 2022 in Science. In addition, he wrote a related paper along with New Mexicoโ€™s John Fleck that iin 2021 was published in Science.

โ€œAg has to bear the brunt of the cuts, because theyโ€™re 75% of the use, but M and I have to help,โ€ he said, referring to agriculture, municipal and industrial.

Strong disagreements exist between the two basins, upper and lower, beyond a general agreement to cut 1.2 million acre-feet in use. โ€œThe lower Basin really wants the Upper Basin to share, maybe on the order of 200,000 acre-feet a year, maybe 5%. And the Upper Basin says no way, and until recently has said weโ€™re going to even increase our use. โ€œ

Native America in the Colorado River Basin. Credit: USBR

Amidst all this, the claims of the 30 or so tribes in the basin need to be resolved. A 1907 Supreme Court ruling found that when the U.S. government ordered Native Americans onto reservations that it guaranteed them the water necessary to be farmers. They control about 25% of the water with some claims, importantly those of the Navajo Nation, still in question. โ€œTribal water is a really big deal,โ€ said Udall.

And Arizona, he said, with two-thirds of tribes, has a disproportionate burden of figuring out how to satisfy rights of the tribes while making everything else work reasonably well, too.

Arizona, he emphasized, is โ€œcentral to the problem and central to the solution.โ€ The Central Arizona Project will necessarily get less water, but it will not be zero, he added.

As for the unprecedented low river flows โ€” and unprecedented high temperatures โ€” of the 2025-26 water year, he predicted โ€œit wonโ€™t be the last time we see this. When it comes back, itโ€™ll be worse.โ€

As Udall spoke those words, it was raining hard in Coloradoโ€™s San Juan Mountains, water that helped raise the water levels of Lake Powell by about 15 feet going into November compared to a mid-September low. Still, Powell was little more than 25% full. The Colorado River problems go far deeper than can be solved by even an extraordinary storm cycle.

โ€œTrue,โ€ said Kathryn Sorensen, director of research at Arizona State Universityโ€™s Kyle Center for Water Research, responding to a New York Times story posted today,  โ€œbut theyโ€™ve helped pull us from the brink at Lake Powell, doubling or perhaps tripling the amount of realistically accessible storage there.โ€

Prior appropriation

Many analyists have concluded that the doctrine of prior appropriation, the legal structure for determining who gets how much water and when, must be modified. It is commonly called first in time, first in right.

The lower basin has roughly 100 diversions, nearly all very large and many of them administered through use of federal infrastructure. There, this principle is less important than in the upper basin, which has thousands and thousands of diversions, many small. Even so, it is the basic principle that allows California a bigger ladle for the Colorado River than Arizona. Arizona got in line as a result of federal legislation in 1968, the Colorado River Basin Project Act.

That law stipulated that water for the Central Arizona Project would be subordinate to Californiaโ€™s 4.4 million acre-foot annual allocation in case of  shortage.

Prior appropriation โ€œdoesnโ€™t really fit with the 21st century,โ€ said Udall. He described it as a โ€œwinner take allโ€ legal system developed in the 18th century by the farmers and miners who were the first colonists of Colorado and other parts of the West.

โ€œYou know, first in time makes first in right,โ€ he explained. โ€œAnd I argue all the time that 4-year-olds around the globe discover this rule every day. โ€˜Itโ€™s mine. I was here first.โ€™ And most parents step in and say, โ€˜No, no, you need to share that.โ€™ Thatโ€™s the system we have. And some people now own vastly expensive water rights because of this, and weโ€™re not going to overturn it.โ€

The doctrine did, he conceded, make sense in the 20th century. โ€œIf you were a junior water right holder, you could actually develop resilience and firm that water right by building storage, so that in really big years youโ€™d capture some water. And then, in the low years, when you werenโ€™t entitled to any water, youโ€™d use your storage to make up that deficient. Well, in a climate change world, that strategy now becomes next to impossible to deal with. Because we donโ€™t have these big years to fill up your reservoirs.โ€

The doctrine is โ€œembedded in how the Colorado River works, including the Central Arizona Project and its junior status to California,โ€ he continued. โ€œAgricultural rights are generally senior to cities, and โ€ฆ this creates problems because you end up potentially with a situation where Denver could get called out by agricultural water rights on the West Slopeโ€ of Colorado, especially those ag rights with appropriation dates prior to the Colorado River Compact.

โ€œIโ€™ve been arguing that we canโ€™t have 1,500 farmers depriving 20 million people in California and 7 million in Arizona and 2 million in Nevada and 2 million in Colorado with these senior rights,โ€ he said.

In 2010, working with Jonathan Overpeck, a researcher then affiliated with the University of Arizona (and now Michigan), Udall had begun to warn of dry times ahead. In a paper published in 2017 by Water Resources Research called โ€œThe twenty-first century Colorado River hot drought and implications for the future,โ€ they predicted 20% losses in river flows by mid-century and 35% by end of century. Those, they said, were conservative estimates.

The backstory is that for nearly a century the Colorado River Basin states โ€” importantly abetted by the federal treasury โ€” had created the infrastructure that assumed far more water even than what optimistically was assumed by the Colorado River Compact of 1922.

Deep family history

Udall brings to the Colorado River discussion perspectives informed by his unusual circumstances.

โ€œIโ€™m a great -great grandson of John D. Lee, the founder of Leeโ€™s Ferry,โ€ Brad at his presentation on Oct. 22. โ€œYou might think thatโ€™s kind of special. Turns out Lee had 21 wives, and thereโ€™s a chance he had 800,000 descendants, which might in fact be part of the problem right now.โ€

A long-time resident of Colorado, Brad grew up in Arizona, the son of Morris Udall, who represented Arizona in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1961 to 1991. His uncle Stewart Udall had represented the same district before becoming the secretary of Interior in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations from 1961 to 1969.

In other words, Udallโ€™s relatives were involved in creating at least some of the agreement infrastructure that now looks ill-advised. That includes the Central Arizona Project, which delivers Colorado River water via a system of canals and pipes that pumps water up 3,000 feet in elevation and across 336 miles to Phoenix, Tucson and farms between. Even then, during the debate in the 1960s, Mo Udall and other supporters realized the Colorado River would not have sufficient water. They were betting that water could be imported, such as from the Snake River in Wyomingโ€™s Jackson Hole. That never flew.

Alex Hager, formerly a reporter in Colorado for Greeley-based KUNC, probed the history in a story for KZJJ in Arizona title โ€œArizonaโ€™s lifeline to the Colorado River is drying up. Were warnings from history ignored?โ€

โ€œI think Stewart and Mo sort of blew it on some of this,โ€ Brad told Hager. But he also counseled some compassion. They had grown up on a farm in Arizona during the Great Depression. By the time they came to power after World War II, an era of booming national optimism may have colored their political thinking.

โ€œThe 1968 idea was we could build our way out of anything,โ€ Brad said. โ€œWe could engineer our way out of every crisis. Weโ€™re smart. Weโ€™re rich. The worldโ€™s our oyster.โ€

Udall gives many slide shows, each building on the last one. The best of them need at least an hour to deliver, because the story is that complicated. This was the third presentation by Udall heard this year by this writer. Unlike some others, though, this audience consisted of people most attentive to the energy transition. To his credit, Udall was able to craft his presentation in a way that did not require vast knowledge of the arcane world of water. He did this without sacrificing details.

Udall sees himself as a truth-teller with an unpleasant message. โ€œAs a scientist, I kind of feel like itโ€™s my job to tell people how it is. And if I can tell it with a little humor and a smile on my face, even if itโ€™s a tough message, maybe theyโ€™ll hear that message,โ€ he said.

The truth he sought to share was the need for great changes in how this declining source of water is shared by 40 million people โ€” changes necessary very, very soon. Those changes will likely include Colorado and other headwaters states, probably an agreement to conservation measures that reduce use by 2% to 5%.

Important, he said, will be better accounting of volumes of use in the upper-basin states. Lacking hard numbers, itโ€™s hard to judge equities. The counter argument has been that Colorado, in particular, has so many small users that this accounting poses an extremely difficult challenge.

What also must be noted is that Udallโ€™s critique inevitably is easier to deliver than setting out a precise outline of what this new future must entail. That, of course, likely would have required another hour or more.

โ€œI still think weโ€™ll get a negotiated solution,โ€ he said as he wrapped up his presentation. But then he added an asterisk, referencing the lawsuit filed by first Nevada in August, then joined by Arizona in October, challenging the federal governmentโ€™s order for cuts in water use. โ€œAlthough every day these lawsuits continue I get more depressed,โ€ he added.

After Udallโ€™s presentation, in the cafeteria where munchies were delivered, I heard one listener who suggested that Phil Weiser, when governor, might consider making Udall the representative of Colorado on the Upper Colorado River Commission. That is not a rap against Becky Mitchell, the current representative, who by all accounts has represented Colorado well in the difficult discussions. It is, though, an interesting idea.

You can watch/listen to Udallโ€™s presentation (and see his slides).
In late October, 100 people turned out at the Unitarian Church between Wheat Ridge and Golden to hear Brad Udall share his thought and knowledge about the Colorado River.

Following are a few more highlights:

Fuzziness of 1922 compact

The 1922 compact has several fuzzy components, most troubling being what was meant in Article 3D, the non-depletion clause, which says the upper basin states โ€œwill not causeโ€ the flows at Lee Ferry to drop below 75 million acre-feet across every rolling 10-year average.

โ€œIn the 20th century, there was only one way for that number to fall below 75 million. acre-feet, and that was if the basin used the water. But in the 21st century, we have a second way for those flows to fall below 75 million acre-feet, which is climate change, of course, and no one knows what this (delivery obligation) means,โ€ said Udall.

Too, the compact โ€œtotally excluded tribal water rights, despite a critically important Supreme Court decree in 1908 (Winters Doctrine), saying that tribes were entitled to water.โ€

As for the abundance of annual flows in the river, โ€œThey actually thought in 1922 that they were going to come back in 1962 and allocate a whole bunch of water because they hadnโ€™t allocated all of it.โ€

On deadpan

โ€œThere would be real harm if we hit deadpool. I mean, there would be a lot of people hurt. You hit Deadpool, you turn control of these reservoirs over to Mother Nature, away from us, and thatโ€™s a fundamental mistake.โ€

Getting into the mess

โ€œWeโ€™ve made a whole bunch of mistakes through time,โ€ he said. โ€œWe allocated water permanently. We assumed too much water. And there are a whole bunch of unrealistic policies. We now have a solution in sight for the next two years, but it will not be enough. And litigation (Nevada and now Arizona suing the federal government) just announced clouds what might really happen.โ€

Musical chairs

While the compact apportioned 7.5 million acre-feet to the upper basins states, they have never used more than 5.5 million acre-feet and mostly have stuck to around 4.5 million ace-feet.

โ€œThey feel like theyโ€™re still entitled to it, but itโ€™s also a little bit of a game of musical chairs, right? I mean, the music stopped here, and because you never grew into that, itโ€™s really hard to figure out how you possibly can use more given the facts on the ground., Weโ€™re sitting on a 2 million acre-feet per year imbalance.โ€

An acre-foot

An acre-foot is 325,000 gallons of water, enough for 10 people for a year. In the upper basin, a farmer might put one or two acre-feet of water on top of a field to get a crop of hay in the summer. In Arizona and California, where itโ€™s hot, they might put 10 feet on top of their field to get 10 different cuttings of alfalfa.

A high desert thunderstorm lights up the sky behind Glen Canyon Dam — Photo USBR

The big reservoirs

In January 2000, Powell and Mead were about 95% full, with 47 million acre-feet. In August 2026, they were 24% full.

No analog

Our high-flow years on Colorado River are now half as frequent, and our low-flow years are about two and a half times as common. โ€œThe take-home here is that thereโ€™s no analog in the 20th century to what weโ€™re seeing now,โ€ he said.

Colorado, the headwaters

Of the water that originates in Colorado, 90% flows out of the state.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

DOGE cuts cost tribes $470M, gutting funding for climate projects — Joseph Lee (Grist.org)

The city of Kotzebue is seen from an MH-60 Jayhawk helicopter forward deployed to Kotzebue from Air Station Kodiak, July 17, 2013. The Coast Guard and its federal, state, local and tribal partners held a workshop and exercise in Kotzebue July 10 to test the agencies’ ability to respond to a mass rescue operation on Alaska’s northwest coast. (U.S. Coast Guard photo by Petty Officer 1st Class Shawn Eggert)

“This story was originally published by Grist. Sign up for Grist’s weekly newsletter here.”

Every year, Kotzebue, a small city in northwest Alaska, has a three-month window to receive all the diesel fuel it will use throughout the following year. It sits on a gravel spit that juts into Kotzebue Sound just north of the Arctic Circle, and is accessible only by air and sea. Ice keeps freight barges from reaching it for most of the year.

The community relies on diesel for 75 percent of its power, and residents put about 20 percent of their income toward buying it. Thatโ€™s more than three times the average energy burden for low-income households nationwide.

โ€œWeโ€™re pretty much at the mercy of world markets,โ€ Chad Nordlum, who is the energy project manager for the Native Village of Kotzebue, told Grist. โ€œRight now, with the Iran war going on, the diesel prices are very high and weโ€™re locked in to much higher prices than weโ€™ve had in the past. Thereโ€™s really nothing the community can do about diesel prices, but what we can do is produce our own energy.โ€

Thatโ€™s why Nordlum was so excited about a $20 million grant from the Environmental Protection Agency to support a wind energy project. The funding, announced in 2024, was part of a larger $150 million allocation for tribal infrastructure in Alaska. Nordlum says it would have lowered the communityโ€™s reliance on diesel to about 40 percent to 50 percent and given the tribe more control over energy and economic decisions.

But the Trump administration canceled the grant in May 2025. More than a year later, the project remains paused.

That cut was among hundreds of millions of dollars the Department of Government Efficiency pulled from Indian Country, and part of a broader pattern of funding rollbacks and underinvestment in Indigenous communities. Two new reports from the Brookings Institution show that the so-called One Big Beautiful Bill Act killed many of the funding streams established by the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, while DOGE eliminated another $468 million, about half of which was allocated for environmental and natural resources. Another 11 percent targeted agriculture. Those projects include climate resiliency plans, renewable energy projects, and jobs programs.

According to Brookings, despite historic investments flowing into Indian Country after the pandemic, a massive underinvestment in Indigenous communities continues. Not only is that a violation of the federal governmentโ€™s trust and treaty obligations to tribes, it is hindering Indigenous efforts to protect the environment and address climate change. The report authors are calling for policy changes that would ensure tribes receive funding, regardless of political winds.

Rob Maxim, who is Mashpee Wampanoag and a fellow at Brookings Metro, said climate and environmental funding is especially crucial for Indigenous communities because they are often the most severely impacted by climate change, especially after years of underinvestment.

โ€œThe actions that the Trump administration is taking are particularly significant, but itโ€™s not totally out of trend with previous administrations,โ€ he said. โ€œAnd what we wanted to show was that actually this underinvestment is kind of the default for the U.S. rather than a blip.โ€

The true aberration was the unprecedented levels of funding after the pandemic. That funding, which came under the Biden administration, included over $700 million in climate, energy, and infrastructure funding for tribes. It covered projects like development of climate action plans, food systems analysis, and more. For example, the Hopi Tribe was to receive a $25 million grant to install solar panels for 600 homes. That grant, and the entire $7 billion Solar for All program, were cut.

Maxim says that funding for Indigenous communities is a federal obligation based on treaties and other agreements with tribes and should be standard and irrevocable. โ€œThe funding that was flowing to Indian Country was not being done on the basis of race or DEI, and it was absolutely not illegal,โ€ he said. โ€œIt was aimed at the promotion of tribal sovereignty and the well-being of tribal citizens and tribal communities, and so that is, you know, an obligation that the U.S. government maintains.โ€

The White House and the EPA did respond to requests for comment.

Glencora Haskins, a senior research associate and applied research manager at Brookings Metro, said that the administration had targeted funding to tribes, with โ€œtribalโ€ being the most frequently flagged term. โ€œI think that there was a very surface-level view of what a lot of these programs were doing, rather than any deep interrogation of the types of systemic infrastructure deficits that programs were trying to fix,โ€ Haskins said.

In Native communities throughout Alaska, and around the country, energy and infrastructure needs are especially acute because of increasingly frequent and destructive storms, wildfires, and other climate-driven disasters.

Haskins and Maxim recommend that Congress pass legislation that bars the cancellation of grants and contracts for tribes, and stipulates that all funding for Indigenous nations and communities is in service of trust and treaty obligations even if it is from a program with a different stated purpose. They also call for a statutory requirement that money should flow directly to tribes rather than having them seek reimbursement from the U.S. Treasury.

In Kotzebue, Chad Nordlum hopes the political tide will turn enough to get the funding for the wind project moving. In the meantime, he is working on a smaller solar project that he hopes will help alleviate the communityโ€™s energy challenges.

โ€œOur main goals are energy security and economic development for the tribe, which is ultimately being able to invest in our own community, help make the lives of people here a little more sustainable,โ€ Nordlum said. โ€œWe want our community to continue on into the future. We have to get a handle on our energy prices and availability.โ€

This article originally appeared in Grist at https://grist.org/indigenous/doge-cuts-cost-tribes-470-million-gutting-funding-for-climate-projects/.

Arizona water agencies are in court over the #ColoradoRiver. What comes next? — KJZZ #COriver #aridification

The Colorado River’s Horseshoe Bend. Photo credit: Gert Boers/Unsplash

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

November 2, 2026

The Arizona Department of Water Resources filed a motion to intervene in Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit against the federal government. The Central Arizona Project โ€” which operates a 336-mile canal system that carries Colorado River Water to the Phoenix and Tucson areas โ€” did the same less than two weeks later. The legal moves represent an escalation in a contentious, yearslong saga over how to respond to increasingly dry conditions along a river that supplies nearly 40 million people across seven Western states…Nevadaโ€™s original lawsuit chiefly argues one thing. It says the Interior Department needs to go back and redo its plans for cutting back water use in three Colorado River states โ€” Arizona, California and Nevada, collectively known as the Lower Basin…With states at an impasse, the federal government reluctantly came up with its own plan. The Interior Department decided that the Lower Basin would have to cut back, but did not force any new cutbacks on the Upper Basin. The plan gives Interior the option to cut Colorado River supplies for Arizona, California and Nevada by up to 40% per year, with Arizona being the hardest hit. Those states were quick to call that plan unfair. Now, theyโ€™re going further and arguing that it was illegal…

Photo credit: Central Arizona Project

The lawsuit argues that federal authorities are legally obligated to consider the impact of new water management plans while drawing up required environmental paperwork. A plan that slashes so much water for millions of people and major industries, it explains, has not done enough to consider the harm of those cutbacks. Arizonaโ€™s top water official, Tom Buschatzke, said the new river plan would โ€œdevastateโ€ Arizonaโ€™s economy, and โ€œignores basic elements of the law of the riverโ€ to do so…Those agencies, alongside Nevada, are asking Interior to come up with a new cutback plan that considers that harm and spreads water cuts more evenly across the region…That ask for a redo is only part of the reason Arizona joined Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit. Between the lines of the filing, the state is making a bigger point. The Lower Basin is in this mess, the state explains, because its upstream neighbors are violating the foundational laws that have governed the river since 1922. If that doesnโ€™t change, Arizona has the ammunition it needs to take an Upper Basin state, or states, to the Supreme Court sometime soon. It is using this lawsuit to put those ideas in writing…Now, some water officials say the conditions are right to bring that bigger lawsuit. Arizona could sue a state or states in the Upper Basin for failing to deliver a legally-mandated amount of water downstream. CAP officials say the upstream states have already fallen below that amount…

Itโ€™s impossible to predict exactly how long a case over the 1922 Colorado River Compact would take to work its way through the legal process, but other water disputes can provide some hints. In Texas v. New Mexico and Colorado, a dispute over water from the Rio Grande spent 13 years in court before it was finally settled in early 2026. In 1985, Kansas sued Colorado for taking too much water from the Arkansas River. That case wasnโ€™t resolved until 2009, more than two decades after it began. A Colorado River case would be highly complex, considering the riverโ€™s connection to seven states, 30 federally recognized Native American tribes and the country of Mexico. Because of that, Eklund said, it could take even longer than two decades, a perilously long time given the record-setting low levels at the nationโ€™s largest reservoirs.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Map of the Arkansas River drainage basin. Created using USGS National Map and NASA SRTM data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=79039596
The Rio Grande Basin spans Colorado, New Mexico and Texas. Credit: Chas Chamberlin

NEWSWIRE: White Mesa Spiritual Walk; uranium hype ramping up; President Trump goes all in on public lands grazing — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Protesters walk in the 10th Annual White Mesa Ute Community Spiritual Walk and Protest on Oct. 17. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 30, 2026

On a sunny and warm October day between storms, Ute Mountain Ute Tribal Council Member Marilynn House stood before a large crowd gathered at the White Mesa Community Center for a spiritual walk to protest the effects of Energy Fuelโ€™s nearby White Mesa Uranium mill. Itโ€™s about โ€œgetting the word out about what this mill is doing to our community and our children and the people that live here,โ€ she said.

The spiritual walk, from the Ute Mountain Ute community of White Mesa to the entrance of the mill, has taken place for ten years to rally support and raise awareness of the issues surrounding the mill. It is not only built on sacred ground, but its tailings ponds have been known to leak and contaminate groundwater aquifers. The concern is that the contaminants will migrate into the communityโ€™s drinking water and culturally significant springs.

โ€œMe and my family are fighting for the mill because we care for our kids, our grandkids, we care for them โ€ฆ Theyโ€™re ruining our water, we got well water here, every time we run the water it donโ€™t smell good,โ€ said Thelma Whiskers, who, along with her daughter Yolanda Badback, founded White Mesa Concerned Community to push back on the mill.

Recording credit: Jonathan P. Thompson

The speakers โ€” and singers โ€” were emotional, impassioned, and their words and songs poignant and moving. More than a protest, it was a demonstration of solidarity with the White Mesa communityโ€™s cause.

This yearโ€™s turnout was substantial, and included members of the American Indian Movement from southern California and the Navajo Nation, as well as Havasupai tribal members who are grappling with the other side of the uranium fuel cycle. They have been pushing back on Energy Fuelsโ€™ Pinyon Plain Mine near the Grand Canyon for years. Pinyon Plain has been trucking ore to the White Mesa Mill via accident-prone highways for the last couple of years.

Copper Point in San Juan County, Utah, was right on the original boundary of Bears Ears National Monument until Trump shrunk the monument this summer. Shortly after the shrinkage, Land Survey Associates staked mining claims just below and on this side of the point on historically mined areas. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ

  • DISA Uranium considers establishing a headquarters โ€” with an associated 118 jobs โ€” in Grand Junction, Colorado, after the Colorado Economic Development Commission approves nearly $1.6 million in tax credits. The firm plans to use its patented high pressure slurry ablation method to extract uranium from historic and abandoned mine waste piles in the Four Corners Region and has signed agreements with various firms to try its technology; it is still awaiting BLM approval to use the method at a Montrose County mine. Thirty-six of the new mining claims staked in areas removed from Bears Ears National Monument were on historic mining sites with associated waste piles, leading to speculation that Disa is behind the claims. Disa did not respond to Land Desk queries concerning the matter. (Hoodline)
  • Dan Proctor, a self-employed exploration geologist from Pleasant Grove, Utah, stakes more than 40 new mining claims in areas President Donald Trump illegally removed from Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument, including several right on the boundary of the remaining monument. (Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance)
  • A new analysis finds that average arsenic levels in groundwater in the Pinyon Plain uranium mineโ€™s monitoring wells near the Grand Canyon are uncharacteristically high, again raising concerns of more widespread contamination of area aquifers. (Grand Canyon Trust, Inside Climate News)
  • Anfield Energy says the Utah Department of Environmental Quality has sent it draft copies of its proposed radioactive materials license and groundwater discharge permits necessary to restart its Shootaring Canyon uranium mill near Ticaboo. (Mining)
๐Ÿ‘ฉ๐Ÿฝโ€๐Ÿ”ฌ SCIENCE! ๐Ÿงซ
  • Utah Geological Survey paleontologists find a new species of dinosaur near Arches National Park in the Ironstone Bonebed, believed to represent the aftermath of a mass extinction event during the Jurassic-to-Cretaceous transition some 140 million years ago. (SFGate)
๐Ÿฎ GRAZING GAZETTE ๐Ÿฅฉ
  • Interior Secretary Doug Burgum issues a Secretarial Order to โ€œsupport domestic livestock production by expanding grazing opportunitiesโ€ on public lands by making vacated allotments and other lands available for grazing, expediting grazing permit renewals, reinstating inactive or suspended animal unit months, weakening regulations that โ€œunnecessarily limitโ€ grazing, and making it easier to kill predators that may threaten livestock. (Western Watersheds Project, Interior Department)
  • Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins sends a letter to U.S. Forest Service grazing permittees introducing its Ranchers First webpage and reaffirming the administrationโ€™s commitment to open more public lands to livestock operators, gut regulations, and to be the โ€œmost pro-rancher administration in history.โ€ (USDA)

Trump looks to Make America Graze Again — Jonathan P. Thompson

The West’s Sacred Cow — Jonathan P. Thompson


๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES ๐Ÿ“ˆ
  • Navajo Transitional Energy Company signs up to export $100 million worth of coal from its Spring Creek Mine in Montana to a Malaysia firm. (US Energy Department)
โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ
  • Archuleta County, Colorado, officials estimate last weekโ€™s flooding affected 800 structures, shut down 13 Forest Service roads, and rendered 150 miles of county roads impassible after the San Juan River rose 15 feet and sent some 44,238 cubic feet per second of water into Navajo Reservoir. (Colorado Sun)
  • Floodwaters in the Rio Puerco swept away and killed a woman in the San Francisco area of Socorro County, New Mexico, after heavy rains lift the waterway high above flood stage last weekend. (KKOB)
๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ
  • Peabody Energy considers building coal-fired generating plants at its mines in the Powder River Basin to power data centers to offset declining coal sales.(Cowboy State Daily)
  • Prometheus Hyperscale drops plans to build a 1,250-MW data center complex near Casper, Wyoming, amid widespread opposition to the facilities, but says it is moving forward with its $32 billion data center and power plant near Evanston. (WyoFile)
  • The Center for Western Priorities launches an interactive map tracking data center proposals on public lands that is currently tracking 35 cases on 24,000 acres in six states. (Center for Western Priorities)
๐Ÿ”‹ENERGY TRANSITION ๐Ÿ”Œ
  • Western Colorado electric cooperatives estimate that buying power from Accelergenโ€™s proposed 125-megawatt solar-plus-storage facility east of Cortez could save ratepayers $20 million, but the development has raised concerns over impacts to views and property values and the risk of battery fires. The project would use lithium-iron-phosphate batteries, which are less susceptible to thermal runaway and fires than more conventional lithium-ion batteries. (CPR)
  • Boulder, Colorado-based Scout Clean Energy proposes two huge utility-scale solar-plus-storage projects on public and private land southeast of Pyramid Lake in northern Nevada. With a combined capacity of 2,000 megawatts, they would dwarf even the largest existing arrays. (Nevada Independent)
๐Ÿ“ COMMENTARY
  • Dinรฉ leaders categorically reject President Donald Trumpโ€™s proclamations shrinking Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments,saying, โ€œNo sitting president has the right to disregard the voices, leadership and land-management practices of tribal sovereign nations, including the ones that comprise the Bears Ears Commission, or to sideline the meaningful consultation owed to the tribes who are inextricably tied to these ancestral lands.โ€ (High Country News)
๐ŸŒž ANNOUNCEMENTS ๐Ÿ˜Ž
  • The Wright-Ingraham Institute begins accepting applications for its Field Workshop 2027, a three-week advanced fellowship for graduate students and early-career practitioners from any field. The workshop will be centered in the San Luis Valley and Taos Plateau in Colorado and New Mexico. (Wright-Ingraham)
  • The Bluff Community Foundation is accepting donations to assist flood-recovery efforts for residents of Bluff and neighboring communities that were affected by the recent storms and high water. (Bluff Community Foundation)
๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ
Homes and Monument Valley. Jonathan P. thompson photo.

Arizona’s lifeline to the Colorado River is drying up. Its designers warned us decades ago — KJZZ.org

Photo credit: Central Arizona Project

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

October 28, 2026

…this tense moment and this 21st century crisis are not showing up as a complete surprise. In fact, the architects of that canal system gave explicit warnings that its position near the front of the line for cutbacks would mean lower flows in the future. The warnings they issued in the 1960s appear to have been largely ignored in the decades since, and the fingerprints of their ambition are still shaping the headlines of today…Phoenix and Tucson as we know them today wouldn’t exist without a gravity-defying, 336-mile system of canals, pipelines and pumping plants that cut through the desert, collectively known as the Central Arizona Project, or CAP. Today, water shortages threaten the expensive, improbable system, and a series of warnings about the canal’s future from the 1960s, seem prescient.

Most Wells Around the Grand Canyon With High Arsenic Levels Are at #Uranium Mine, New Analysis Shows — Wyatt Myskow (InsideClimateNews.org)

The evaporation pond at the Pinyon Plain Mine in Arizona. Credit: Blake McCord

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Wyatt Myskow):

October 28, 2026

Pinyon Plain Mine representatives argue that the toxic metal is naturally occurring, not contamination from the mining operation.

Three of four wells across the Grand Canyon region that have average arsenic levels above the Environmental Protection Agencyโ€™s standard for safe drinking water are at the site of a controversial uranium mine, a new analysis of groundwater sampling shows.

The analysis from the Grand Canyon Trust, a nonprofit advocating for protection of the canyon and the Colorado Plateau, relied on 32 years of groundwater sampling across 40 sites from the U.S. Geological Survey and the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality. The Pinyon Plain Mine, where the contaminated wells are located, lies within a national monument just nine miles away from the South Rim of the Grand Canyon.

The heightened arsenic levels at the mine site are not a coincidence, Misael Cabrera, senior vice president of environment, safety and sustainability for the mining company, Energy Fuels Resources Inc., said, as arsenic is found in highly mineralized areas, like at the Pinyon Plain Mine site.

โ€œWe donโ€™t get to choose where we put a mine,โ€ he said. โ€œNature puts the minerals in certain locations, and then if we want to harvest those minerals, we have to go to those locations.โ€

Cabrera was the director of the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality when the mine was being permitted.

It is the latest dispute in a months-long debate over the rising arsenic levels, what is increasing them and whether the contaminant is at risk of spreading throughout the region. Pinyon Plain mineโ€”located within the Baaj Nwaavjo Iโ€™tah Kukveniโ€”Ancestral Footprints of the Grand Canyon National Monument, is one of the countryโ€™s first new uranium minesdriven by a resurgence of interest in nuclear energy.

The analysis comes after ADEQ permitted Energy Fuels to raise the levels of arsenic at one of the mineโ€™s monitoring wells that require the company to issue an alert about the contamination. That decision prompted outcry from local communities and researchers.

โ€œOur opposition is not based on fear or politics,โ€ said Havasupai Tribal Chairwoman Melinda Yaiva at a press conference announcing the findings. โ€œIt is based on our responsibility as a sovereign tribal nation to protect our people, our homeland and the water that makes life in Supai (the tribeโ€™s village in the Grand Canyon) possible. Today, the immediate issue is arsenic.โ€

For years, the mineโ€™s opponents have expressed concern it would contaminate the regionโ€™s groundwater. Research from hydrologists found the shallow groundwater aquifer the mine drills into is connected to the deeper, regional aquifer. Reviews by the U.S. Geological Survey and the Environmental Protection Agency followed and found more research is needed to understand if the mine site poses a threat to the regionโ€™s water quality.

Cabrera said no data shows there is a risk for the mineโ€™s water to spread.

โ€œDespite all of the evidence that we have on record, despite all of the regulatory approvals, despite the multiple court cases, we are still being assumed to be guilty before proven innocent,โ€ he said. โ€œWe really need to reflect on that as a country if we want to be able to produce our own energy without relying so heavily on foreign sources.โ€

He likened the current situation to looking at a traffic map of Arizona, where major cities like Phoenix would have the most congestion. โ€œIn the same vein, you are going to have higher levels of mineralsโ€ like arsenic at mine sites.

Laura Crossey, an emeritus professor of earth science at the University of New Mexico, who for decades has researched the hydrogeology of the Grand Canyon, has a traffic analogy as well. Dismissing data showing the aquifers are connected and that contamination can spread is โ€œlike studying the traffic pattern of Phoenix by only looking at the side streets and ignoring the interstates that move through, that are carrying much higher volumes, much higher speeds.โ€

One monitoring well at Energy Fuelsโ€™ Pinyon Plain Mine exceeded permitted alert levels for arsenic four times since 2025, before the company applied to amend its permit to allow for higher levels of arsenic. The groundwater in the mineโ€™s sump is over 3,000 times the limit for arsenic in drinking water. At the mineโ€™s monitoring wells, the water is nearly two, three and six times the safe drinking water levels of arsenic, respectively.

โ€œThis is a kind of a failure in the monitoring program and the regulatory process, because at the present time, we donโ€™t really know why the arsenic is rising, because it hasnโ€™t been thoroughly investigated,โ€ said Brad Esser, a retired environmental radiochemistry researcher at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory.

If the mineโ€™s evaporation pond is leaking, it can be patched. If the groundwater pumping is changing the hydrologic flow, then limits can be placed on the pumping. But without a definitive study and answer to whatโ€™s causing the increasing levels of arsenic, a mitigation plan canโ€™t be put in place, he said.

Image Source: Michigan State University Extension, Water Quality Bulletin # 35, August 1991

ADEQ and the company have claimed the arsenic issue is natural, and not due to mining. They attribute the rising arsenic levels to its groundwater pumping causing a โ€œcone of depressionโ€ around the well that is drawing in water with more naturally occurring arsenic from further reaches of the aquifer.

Protesters voice their opposition to uranium hauling from the Pinyon Plain Mine in Arizona. Credit: Blake McCord

Critics have questioned that claim and said more data was needed to prove it before permitting higher arsenic alert levels. The analysis of regional arsenic levels in groundwater, they say, shows the company and ADEQโ€™s hypothesis is wrong.

โ€œIf arsenic concentrations in groundwater outside the mine are lower than inside, how can drawing low concentration outside increase the already high and increasing arsenic concentrations inside the property,โ€ asked Dave Kreamer, emeritus professor of hydrology at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. โ€œYou would think that adding cleaner water, groundwater from outside, shouldnโ€™t it dilute the high concentrations inside? Iโ€™ve been asking this question of ADEQ monthly since June 1, and have not got an answer yet.โ€

Most at risk is the Havasupai Tribe, whose reservation is in the Grand Canyon. Its only source of water is Havasu Creek, which is directly fed by the regional Redwall-Mauv aquiferโ€”the deeper regional groundwater supply.

The tribe has objected to ADEQ raising the allowable arsenic levels at the mine site, and appealed the decision. That appeal was dismissed by the agencyโ€™s appeals board, which concluded the tribe lacked standing. Yaiva said the tribe is considering what other options it has, including legal ones.

Something Havasupai children are taught at birth, Yaiva said, is that water is sacred. Havasu Creek, located on the tribeโ€™s reservation and famed for its vibrant blue-green waters, is not just a beautiful place, she said. โ€œIt is the lifeblood of our homeland.โ€

โ€œOur people drink this water,โ€ she said. โ€œWe cook with it. We grow food with it. We care for our animals with it, and depend on it every day. It is also part of our ceremonies, our traditions, and our culture, and our identity as Havasupai people. Our relationship with this water goes back generations, long before the state of Arizona existed, long before the federal government approved the uranium mining near our homeland.โ€

In addition to supporting the Havasupai people, the waters in Havasu Canyon give life to an array of animals and plants. Photo credit: Amy S. Martin via The Grand Canyon Trust

#Colorado wonโ€™t launch water-conservation program in 2027 without guarantee from feds: Officials say saved water should not be released for Lower Basin use — Heather Sackett (AspenJournalism.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Lake Powell behind Glen Canyon Dam. The Upper Basin states signed a grant implementation agreement with Reclamation to fund a voluntary contribution program, but Colorado wants assurances the saved water wonโ€™t be for Lower Basin use. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Journalism website (Heather Sackett):

October 27, 2026

Colorado water managers say a state-run conservation program planned for 2027 is in jeopardy as they wait on an agreement with federal officials.

Before they open the application period for a new conservation program, state officials want assurance from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation that conserved water they store in Lake Powell wonโ€™t just be released downstream for Lower Basin use.

In September, the state water board approved the application review process and criteria for what state officials are calling Coloradoโ€™s near-term contribution program for 2027. The program aims to use nearly $100 million in funding from Reclamation to pay water users in the Upper Basin states (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming) to voluntarily cut back.

But that approval depends upon whether Colorado can get credit for and have control over the stored water. State officials said repeatedly at an Oct. 21 meeting with the Colorado River Water Conservation District that they need assurance in writing from Reclamation that the pool of stored water must be โ€œoperationally neutralโ€ โ€” meaning it would not be factored into reservoir releases or used by the Lower Basin โ€” before they move forward with a state-run program.

Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief with the Colorado Water Conservation Board, state engineer Jason Ullmann and Becky Mitchell, the Upper Colorado River Commissionโ€™s Colorado representative, fielded questions from River District board members.

โ€œEssentially, we donโ€™t want to move forward with any of this process with opening the application window, going through all of this, unless and until we have that assurance from Reclamation that this water is not simply going to be released downstream,โ€ Ostdiek told River District board members.

From left, Interstate Section Chief at the CWCB Amy Ostdiek, Colorado representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission Becky Mitchell and State Engineer Jason Ullmann, speak on a panel at Colorado Water Congress on Aug. 20 in Steamboat Springs. State officials plan to roll out a water conservation program that would pay water users to temporarily cut back in 2027, but need federal assurances first. CREDIT:ย HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Federal officials say operational neutrality for a conservation pool in Lake Powell will require approval from the Lower Basin states (California, Arizona and Nevada). At a UCRC meeting Oct. 19, the Upper Basin states approved a grant implementation agreement, which allows Reclamation to administer the contribution program grant money to the states.

But according to a prepared statement by Wayne Pullan, Reclamationโ€™s Upper Colorado Basin regional director, the grant agreement โ€œdoes not establish any new terms for how conserved or contributed water will be credited to the system or subsequently released โ€” that will require a separate process and agreement, as well as consensus among the seven basin states.โ€

The new two-year federal operating plan for the Colorado River, which was adopted in August, calls for 1.25 million acre-feet of mandatory cuts among the Lower Basin states and annual Lake Powell releases between 6 million and 7 million acre-feet. It also includes the possibility of up to 200,000 acre-feet of Upper Basin voluntary conservation. But beyond this basic framework, many details of operations and programs are left to be hashed out in separate agreements between the states and Reclamation.

Time is running out to get a conservation agreement in place before the 2027 irrigation season. According to the timeline given by state officials, the application window was supposed to be October and November, followed by an evaluation and approval process that would have contracts with participants in place by spring. The Upper Colorado River Commission sent a letter to Reclamation officials in September saying that operational neutrality was essential to the success of a program. Officials say they have not yet received a formal response.

โ€œIโ€™m optimistic that the Upper Division states and Reclamation will develop an appropriate agreement that meets everybodyโ€™s needs,โ€ said Chuck Cullom, executive director of the UCRC. โ€œWhat I am concerned about is how timely that agreement can be developed to support 2027 programs.โ€

River District General Manager Andy Mueller said the district backs state officials and supports the decision not to open the application process without a written agreement from Reclamation. The River District protects water interests across 15 Western Slope counties. Although the conservation program would be open to anyone in the state who uses water from the Colorado River Basin, itโ€™s understood that most of the conserved water would come from Western Slope agriculture, as it has in previous pilot programs.

โ€œDonโ€™t run the program next year if you canโ€™t run it well, if you canโ€™t operate it in a way that protects the values and interests of our communities and agricultural industries,โ€ Mueller told state officials. โ€œPlease donโ€™t do it halfway. Donโ€™t do it too late. Donโ€™t let the federal governmentโ€™s refusal to act in a timely way damage the communities that these folks represent.โ€

Lake Powell as seen from the air in 2019. Colorado officials have said they need assurance from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation that water stored in Powell as part of a conservation program wonโ€™t just be sent downstream for the Lower Basin to use. CREDIT: ECOFLIGHT

Delay could mean low participation rates

Last weekโ€™s discussion came as the federal government has taken over Colorado River operations and management of the nationโ€™s biggest reservoirs after the seven states that share the river could not find agreement after years of failed negotiations.

Upper Basin water managers have long pointed fingers at their Lower Basin neighbors, saying their overuse was responsible for driving the system into crisis. They want to make sure that any water saved through conservation in the Upper Basin wonโ€™t simply be released downstream to be used by the Lower Basin. Precisely what the conserved water will be used for is still unclear and is one of the issues that remain to be figured out in an agreement between the Upper Colorado River Commission and Reclamation.

From 2019 to 2021, Colorado explored what officials called a demand management program, which would have allowed the Upper Basin states to conserve up to 500,000 acre-feet in a pool in Lake Powell. In that case, the water could have been used to help the Upper Basin states meet their water-delivery obligations to the Lower Basin under the terms of the 1922 Colorado River Compact.

But in recent years, officials have been talking about a conserved pool of water being used to boost Lake Powell levels to protect critical infrastructure and maintain the ability to produce hydropower at Glen Canyon Dam. Some experts say flexible, operationally neutral pools could protect Glen Canyon Dam infrastructure, minimize the need for large releases from upstream reservoirs and reduce the risk of litigation among the seven basin states that share the Colorado River.

โ€œReclamationโ€™s priority remains balancing water-delivery obligations and protecting critical infrastructure at Lake Powell,โ€ Pullan said at last weekโ€™s UCRC meeting. โ€œAnd protecting critical infrastructure at Lake Powell means staying above elevation 3,510.โ€

Anne Castle, a Colorado River expert and former federal representative to the UCRC, explained why the Upper and Lower basin states might have different views on operational neutrality. Under the federal guidelines for reservoir operations the amount of water released from Lake Powell each year is based on how much water is in the reservoir. When levels dip below certain thresholds, it triggers a reduction in how much is released.

โ€œThe Lower Basin doesnโ€™t want that to happen,โ€ Castle said.

If a pool of water conserved by the Upper Basin is not operationally neutral, it could bump up Lake Powell above the trigger elevations and cause more water to be released to the Lower Basin.

โ€œThe Upper Basin states are saying we want that pool to be operationally neutral so that that increase in elevation doesnโ€™t affect the releases from Powell,โ€ Castle said. โ€œReclamation has always taken the position that they canโ€™t do that on their own; the Lower Basin states would have to agree that some portion of the water in Powell doesnโ€™t count against the release requirements.โ€

Because the amount of water released from Lake Powell each year is based on how much water is in the reservoir โ€” not on the yearโ€™s snowpack or how much water flows into the reservoir โ€” more water has been released over the past 25 years than has come in, drawing it down to critically low levels.

In 2023 and 2024, the Upper Basin states participated in a federally funded conservation program, known as the System Conservation Pilot Program. Officials received criticism from water users for its hasty rollout in the fall of 2023, and the first year didnโ€™t see much participation because of the short timeline to apply and plan for the following irrigation season. This yearโ€™s delay could run the risk of a similar scenario.

โ€œOne of the painful lessons that we learned from 2023 projects is that the later you go into the fall and winter, the more difficult it is for water users to participate,โ€ Cullom said. โ€œThe longer we go in time, I would anticipate the fewer participants we will get. โ€ฆ At what point have we run out of time? Weโ€™re already later in the year than I think anybody is happy with.โ€

Even if Coloradoโ€™s program canโ€™t come together in time for the 2027 season, the Reclamation funding is good through 2031, Mitchell said, so a program could take place in a future year. She warned River District board members that if Colorado canโ€™t run the program this year, she expects criticism from water users and managers.

โ€œI want to be perfectly honest: If we canโ€™t move forward with this program, there will be pressure from within our own state,โ€ Mitchell said. โ€œBut as of right now, I donโ€™t have the assurances that I need that this water will be protected, and I think thatโ€™s an important component.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Notes From the Road: From the San Juan Basin gasfields to Grants uranium country — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Advertisement for Jayโ€™s Bar & Lounge and liquor store, a busy place during the uranium boom from 1953 to 1990. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 20, 2026

๐Ÿš™ NOTES FROM THE ROAD ๐Ÿ›ป

It only now occurs to me, six years into my half century of life and of roaming around the Four Corners Country, that the predominant autumnal color of the high desert is yellow. At least this year, when wacky weather and an altered climate have shuffled the phenological calendar, that is the case. Chamisa blooming madly, wild sunflowers dancing by the roadside, once-dusty fields turned golden by hundreds of clusters of aรฑil del muerto โ€” indigo of the dead โ€” which I am told usually bloom after the monsoons in July and August.

And there, almost as if leaping from the deep cut banks of the Rio Puerto, the dazzling shock of quivering turned leaves of a cottonwood.


Stone, fencepost, and Huerfanito Peak in the San Juan Basin. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

I spend the night in a small BLM campground in the heart of the San Juan Basin gas field. The sites are nice, it has some of the most spectacular views of any campground, and itโ€™s free โ€” subsidized by royalties from the gas wells that surround it. I used to have the place mostly to myself, but on this Thursday night it fills up. A couple of loners, like me, one guy in a converted school bus who probably lives here, at least until he gets rousted, a family, a German couple in a vanlife van (with German plates), who talk loudly enough that I can hear every word, and even understand a few. Theyโ€™re headed down to Carlsbad next.

Near Angel Peak in the San Juan Basin. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

A big yellow dump truck blazes across the gravel campground road ahead of me, trailing a cloud of dust, as it hauls a load from one side of Envirotechโ€™s land farm to the other. A land farm is where hydrocarbon-contaminated soils, like those that have been soaked by an oil or produced water spill, are taken to be reclaimed and plowed back into the land farmโ€™s โ€œfields.โ€ This one is special because Chacoโ€™s Great North Road cuts right through the hydrocarbon-soaked fields. The owner of the facility apparently has some sensitivity and appreciation for archaeology and cultural sites, and left the โ€œroadโ€ undisturbed, though it is abutted on both sides by the fields.

On this Friday morning the land farm is especially busy, my first indication that the oil and gas drilling boom in the Greater Chaco Region is back on, at least in a limited fashion. And given the number of trucks bringing in more crude-soaked soil, Iโ€™m guessing the number of spills is increasing, too.

The activity is heaviest between Nageezi and Counselors, where the highway suddenly gets busier and a higher percentage of the traffic is made up of large white trucks, tankers, and frack-sand haulers. A drilling rig juts out from behind a piรฑon and juniper studded hill near Twin Pines. A big orange sign: SAND TRUCKS.

I feel for the residents of the area, mostly Dinรฉ, who are forced to live with the noise, the dust, the danger, the pollution emanating from the wells and the rigs, and, sometimes, catastrophic โ€œincidentsโ€ that light up the night with orange flames and sully the sky with billowing black clouds of smoke.

The renewed activity brings urgency to the fight to keep the Chaco Cultural Protection Zone intact. And yet, it offers no protection for the people who live in Nageezi, Lybrook, Counselors, Twin Pines, Ojo Encino โ€ฆ


Outside Cuba, four hikers. Walking sticks, nice backpacks, incongruent. Then I remember the sign back at the store: Welcome Continental Divide Trail Hikers. It makes sense.

Handwritten sign along the road to Pueblo Pintado: No Dumping Trash or Dogs.

A hundred yards later a herd of goats in tight formation, brilliant white fur, shiny black fur, munching roadside chamisa.

Further on, an array of solar panels splayed out across the landscape, black and glimmering.

Building, Grants, New Mexico. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

The urban architecture of Grants and Milan, two central New Mexico towns separated only by a couple hundred yards of liminal space, seems haunted by ghosts.Not in the supernatural or the ghost town sort of way. No, these ghosts are more of an economic sort, ones that linger in the streetscapes and the townsโ€™ strange layout.

Grants, especially, is imbued with the specter of Route 66, of the glorious time when people made their way slowly across the country in those big olโ€™ American cars, stopping every couple hundred miles to eat dinner, have a few cocktails, stay the night, maybe even get dressed up and going dancing.

But thereโ€™s also what came next: The three-decade-long uranium boom that was ignited when a Navajo man named Paddy Martinez found a chunk of uranium ore near his home out beyond Ambrosia Lake in 1953. Grantsโ€™ population jumped from about 2,200 in 1950, to over 10,000 in 1960, to more than 11,000 in 1980, the boomโ€™s peak. That growth is apparent in the architecture and the layout of the town, especially in where and how it sprawled away from the Route 66 thoroughfare and the interstate in a northeasterly direction. That probably made some sort of sense when it happened, as thatโ€™s where there was room for the town to grow. But now it seems odd to have to drive out to the fringe, beyond the defunct carpet and furniture place, to go to the grocery store. The strip mall across the street seems especially out of place.


Thoughts on boomtown architecture — Jonathan P. Thompson


Of course, thereโ€™s a much more consequential shadow from those times clouding the neighborhoods and residents of Grants and Milan, namely the toxic wraith of the uranium industry itself. Just outside Milan, 22 million tons of uranium mill tailings, remnants of Homestakeโ€™s operations that were shuttered in 1990, sit in a mesa-like pile amid the sage and chamisa. The groundwater is indelibly contaminated and, 36 years later, cleanup continues. When I visited heavy machinery working the top of the pile kicked up huge clouds of dust. The work is potentially endless, and in recent years Homestake has turned to purchasing homes in contaminated areas to try to get out of cleanup requirements.

If youโ€™re wondering why Homestake doesnโ€™t just go belly up and whither away like so many other mining companies have done over the past 150 years, itโ€™s because somewhere along the line, Barrick Gold โ€” a multinational firm with big mines in Nevada and elsewhere โ€” acquired Homestake, along with its liabilities.

Homestakeโ€™s uranium tailings depository, which contains 22 million tons of toxic and radioactive materials. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Homestakeโ€™s pile is just one of many toxic remnants of this areaโ€™s uranium boom. The Grants Mining District includes some 85 abandoned and defunct once-producing uranium mines, including the giant and notorious Jackpile-Paguate, and four mill sites, which are now marked by tomblike tailings depositories.

One might think Homestakeโ€™s long ordeal would serve as a warning to other firms looking to mine the Grants uranium belt: Best to just stay away. But no. High uranium prices and the promise of growing demand driven by a new generation of data center-powering reactors has sparked a slew of proposals for new mining projects around here. Laramide Resources is working on permitting for its La Jara Mesa underground mine on 156 mining claims, Energy Fuels Roca Honda underground mine is moving through Forest Service permitting process, and the Grants Energy in-situ extraction project is also progressing. All are being fast-tracked by the federal government.

Mt. Taylor and La Jara Mesa, where Laramide Resources is hoping to build a major uranium mine. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

The two conventional mines would sit on public lands on the lower slopes of Mt. Taylor, or Kโ€™aweshtima in Acoma Puebloโ€™s Keres language, a volcanic cone that juts up from the sandstone mesas on the southern end of the San Juan Basin. Its prominent position on the Four Corners Countryโ€™s southern horizon has given it a significant role in Indigenous cosmologies. Some Chacoan structures are aligned with the peak and contain timbers from the mountainโ€™s slopes, it remains sacred to Acoma, Laguna, and Zuni Pueblos, and is one of the Dinรฉโ€™s four mountains that demarcate their homeland. The proposals will serve as a test of New Mexicoโ€™s designation of Mt. Taylor as a traditional cultural property. The Grants Energy ISR project is in a sage- and chamise-strewn basin near the base of Mt. Taylor.

Grants Energy proposes to discharge up to 360,000 gallons of formation water per day into the ground here for aquifer testing related to its proposed in-situ uranium extraction project. The sight is a couple of miles west of San Mateo. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

If a triangle was drawn between the three projects, somewhere near the center would be the village of San Mateo, nestled against the lower basaltic slopes of Mt. Taylor. It was once known as the Uranium Capital of the World because of its proximity to so many mines, including the Mt. Taylor underground mine, which produced nearly 700,000 tons of uranium during its short life in the late 1980s, and for which Gulf Mineral Resources Corporation dewatered three aquifers to keep its thousands of feet of workings dry.

Other than the mine, which sits a half mile from the village, and any contamination or dry wells it may have left behind, the remnants of the uranium boom arenโ€™t apparent in San Mateo, itself. The cluster of modest homes and gardens with a riot of pink cosmos and winter squash and dried out stalks of already harvested corn feel much like the northern New Mexico villages near Taos or in the Chama River Valley. Spanish colonial activity dates back to the late 1500s, though the San Mateo wasnโ€™t settled until the mid-1800s. It houses a morada, or church for the Penitente Brotherhood.

Iโ€™m sure there are plenty of people here who are rooting for the mines and their promises of hundreds of jobs and the sort of economic boost that brings more people and more strip malls, that fills up the restaurants, hotels, and bars, and awakens the dormant glory of days gone by. And who can blame them? But thereโ€™s at least as many folks, the ones whose wells are contaminated or who are sick or lost a family member to cancer or kidney disease, who not only would like to see the mining companies go elsewhere, but who wish that the previous boom never had happened.

And then there are those who just want to move on into the future, who want Grants to thrive economically, but also as a community. I saw glimmers of this: The well-manicured parks and playgrounds lining Route 66, the busy farmerโ€™s market in one of those parks on a Saturday morning, the hikers and bike packers stopping at local businesses that are helping to make Grants a stopping point along the Continental Divide Trail, and who are capitalizing on the communityโ€™s proximity to Mt. Taylor and El Malpais and El Morro national monuments.

These are the ones who donโ€™t want to be beholden to the old extractive boom bust cycle because they know that no matter how good it gets, always, always ends in abuse and then abandonment.

***

When I want to understand what life was like during the uranium boom in the Grants area, I donโ€™t look to history books or old newspapers. Rather, I read the poetry of Simon Ortiz, of Acoma Pueblo, in the Grants Mining District. Ortiz worked in the mines and mills as a young man, and many of the poems in Fight Back: For the Sake of the People, For the Sake of the Land are inspired or derived from his time in the industry and the people he worked alongside, people from Acoma, Laguna, the Navajo Nation, or white folks from Oklahoma, Texas, Louisiana, Colorado, or Montana, who had come to the area seeking jobs.

The poems are all insightful and give a visceral sense of the place and the time and what it was like to be an Indigenous person working in the uranium industry. Some pieces expose the ever present, underlying racism in the industry, while others indict the companiesโ€™ greed for profit and disregard for the workers and the land. Every one is moving and enlightening in its own way, but โ€œTo Change in a Good Way,โ€ a narrative poem centered on the friendship between Bill and Ida, an Oklahoma couple, and Pete and Mary, from Laguna Pueblo, is, to me, perhaps the most stirring and also illuminating of the bunch. I urge you to find it and read it, along with the other poems in that collection. All of these pieces can be found in Woven Stone, which is even available as an ebook.

Thereโ€™s another piece of his, โ€œIt Was That Indian,โ€ that manages to concisely capture the whole arc of the uranium boom in just a couple dozen lines. Iโ€™ve included it in its entirety here:

It Was That Indian
by Simon Ortiz

Martinez
from over by Bluewater
was the one who discovered uranium
west of Grants.
That’s what they said.
He brought that green stone
into town one afternoon in 1953,
said he found it by the railroad tracks
over by Haystack Butte.
tourist magazines did a couple spreads
on him, photographed him in kodak color,
and the Chamber of Commerce celebrated
that Navajo man,
forgot for the time being that the brothers
from Aacqu east of Grants
had killed that state patrolman,
and never mind also
that the city had a jail full of Indians.
The city fathers named
a city park after him
and some even wanted to put up a statue
of Martinez but others said
that was going too far for just an Indian
even if he was the one who started that area
into a boom

Well, later on,
when some folks began to complain
about chemical poisons flowing into the streams
from the processing mills, carwrecks on Highway 53,
lack of housing in Grants,
cave-ins at Section 33,
non-union support,
high cost of living,
and uranium radiation causing cancer,
theyโ€”the Chamber of Commerceโ€”pointed out
that it was Martinez
that Navajo Indian from over by Bluewater
who discovered uranium,
it says so in this here brochure,
he found that green stone over by Haystack
out behind his hogan;
it was that Indian who started that boom.

The San Juan structural basin is primarily in New Mexico in a corner of the Colorado Plateau. By US Geological Survey – Assessment of Undiscovered Oil and Gas Resources of the San Juan Basin Province of New Mexico and Colorado, 2002, USGS Fact Sheet FS-147-02, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5749904

#Drought conditions for Gunnison county improved going into winter — The #CrestedButte News

Colorado Drought Monitor map October 20, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on The Crested Butte News website (Katherine Nettles). Here’s an excerpt:

October 21, 2026

For the second year in a row, fall precipitation has come in heavy following an extremely dry summer season. In a county work session update on October 13, Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District (UGRWCD) senior water program manager Beverly Richards described how the wet month of September helped close out the water year with a boost of moisture to streams and soils ahead of winter. However, warm temperatures have worked against the moisture boost, and reservoir storage and overall drought conditions remain a long-term concern for water experts along the Colorado and Gunnison River Basins. Richards said September precipitation in most of Gunnison County was about 110-190% of average, and other areas of the state saw similar conditions. It was the 9th wettest in 30 years and tied with 1940 for fifth wettest in a longer historical record.

Unfortunately, despite that recent rainfall and even some snow, 100% of Gunnison County remains in severe to exceptional drought. โ€œAreas to the south like Hinsdale and Sawatch County have seen some improvement in drought conditions due to the precipitation that occurred in September,โ€ said Richards. While those southern areas saw one class of drought condition/soil moisture improvement, Gunnison County overall had one class of drought condition degradation. Richards reported that some southern areas received between three and six inches of rain during the early October precipitation events. The Upper Gunnison Basin was at 17% of the median amount of precipitation for the end of water year 2026 (which ended September 30) and temperature conditions for September were very warmโ€”the second warmest in 132 years of record for the state. Richards said that was also 5.5 degrees warmer than the 20th century average…Temperatures in early October ranged from four to six degrees above normal based on the period of record…

Stream flows have been variable across the basin, including huge increases in flow at the Lake Fork, Slate and Taylor rivers around September 29. Richards said this helped make up for the low flows in August. The Slate River flow increased 129% in seven hours, and the Taylor increased by 153% in 16 hours. โ€œSo that precipitation event really helped stream flows quite a bit,โ€ said Richards. Reservoir storage is at 47% of average for the entire basin and 33% of average for the upper basin (which includes Taylor and Blue Mesa reservoirs). Blue Mesa ended the water year at 143, 497-acre feet, which was 52% of the end of year levels in 2002, the next lowest year. Richards said Blue Mesa elevation has since declined another 1,030-acre feet and is 17% full. The current elevation of 7,413 feet is about 20 feet above the minimum power pool and 106 feet below the full pool. โ€œWe received communication on September 28 from the Bureau of Reclamation (BOR) that they were anticipating it may fall below power pool in April 2027 if conditions continue to decline,โ€ reported Richards. โ€œItโ€™s in really dire condition.โ€

Map of the Gunnison River drainage basin in Colorado, USA. Made using public domain USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69257550

NEWSWIRE: The soaking of the Southwest continues, plus a lot more — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

The La Plata Mountains in full autumnal splendor. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Jonathan posted this on BlueSky after the publication of the article below:

San Juan River downstream from Bluff hit 14,800 cfs last night, it's highest level since 2013. More rain coming today. This will boost Lake Powell's levels and give rafters a pretty fast ride! nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/ut/nwis/peak…

— Jonathan Thompson at the Land Desk (@landdesk.bsky.social) 2026-10-22T13:51:00.840Z

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website:

October 14, 2026

โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Welcome to another totally human-curated (and a bit late) edition of the Land Deskโ€™s Newswire, a weekly compendium of important news happening around the Four Corners Country and beyond. Once again, the big news is the weird weather, which includes soaking rain, snow, big rivers, and even a tornado.

The Paria River where it meets the Colorado swelled up to about 2,000 cubic feet per second two days ago, and had I stuck around Lees Ferry for an hour or so longer I might have witnessed it. Instead, I headed south and east under a constant gray sky and passing through squalls on the way.

โ€œForrest Gump Hillโ€ in Monument Valley, the place to where people travel from far far away to take a photo of themselves in the middle of the road, was as crowded โ€” and hazardous โ€” as ever. The buttes and bluffs near Montezuma and Aneth were carpeted with such green that I was disoriented, and in McElmo Canyon, where it looks like farmers will easily get another cutting of hay, the vibe was much more August monsoon than October storm.

The landscape around Aneth, Utah, is unusually verdant this October. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • Tropical Storm Rachel has brought significant moisture to a big swath of the Southwest and beyond over the last few days. Observers with the CoCoRaHSnetwork reported 24-hour rainfall totals of as much as two inches (in the Hermosa area north of Durango), bringing the Animas River through Durango up to 2,380 cubic feet per second and rising, as of noon on Oct. 14. A bit to the east of there, the Piedra River near Arboles shot up to 2,190 cfs, and Vallecito Creek has topped 1,000 cfs as I write this around noon on Oct. 14.
  • As of the morning of Oct. 14, very wet, slushy snow โ€” or, as the Germans call it, Schneeregen โ€” was falling on Dove Creek, Colorado, elevation 6,800 feet. It wasnโ€™t sticking there, yet, but folks in Silverton (9,318 feet) woke up to a dusting on the ground, marking the first SNOTEL station-detected snowpack in the Animas River watershed (a .6โ€ snow water equivalent).
  • Southwest Colorado residents reported a tornado between Tiffany and Allison, near the New Mexico border on the afternoon of Oct. 13. One Facebook poster said it hit her dadโ€™s property and damaged outbuildings, while others reported that it took out barns, ripped up fencing, and uprooted trees.
  • Social media posts show that thereโ€™s enough snow on Grand Mesa in western Colorado for some ski touring.
  • SNOTEL stations on the Upper Colorado River Basin are showing well above normal precipitation accumulation for the first two weeks of Water Year 2027.

And in other weather and climate related news โ€ฆ

The heat has once again taken its toll in the Phoenix area. The cityโ€™s fire department recorded 1,744 heat-related calls โ€” significantly more than last year โ€” between May 1 and Aug. 31, including 98 rescues from mountain trails and 14 patients that had to be hoisted by helicopter. Maricopa County has recorded 389 confirmed heat-related fatalities this summer, with another 383 under investigation. (ABC15, Maricopa County)

๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES ๐Ÿ“ˆ

  • The Bureau of Land Management moves ahead with plans to lease 113 parcels covering 126,440 acres of public land in Colorado for oil and gas drilling, despite widespread opposition. Among the land to be on the auction block in December are 5,000 acres on the Roan Plateau and several parcels in the HD Mountains and near Chimney Rock National Monument just north of the Southern Ute Indian Reservation in southwestern Colorado. The protest period ends on Nov. 8. (Aspen Daily News, BLM)
  • A New Mexico advocate laments Permian Basin oil and gas drillingโ€™s effects on residents, the landscape, and the Pecos River, calling it a โ€œbeautiful river in the middle of a hellscape.โ€ (Capital & Main)
  • An analysis finds Arizona utility Salt River Project customers could pay up to eight times more to operate the Craig coal plant under the Trump administrationโ€™s emergency orders than for solar-plus-storage resources. The plant was scheduled to shut down at the end of last year. (Energy & Policy Institute)
  • A coalition of environmental groups files a lawsuit seeking to block the Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s approval of a road construction project, aka hydrocarbon highway, in Gate Canyon in eastern Utah designed to expedite oil-hauling in the Uinta Basin. Gate Canyon feeds into the culturally significant Nine Mile Canyon. (SUWA, BLM)
๐ŸŒต PUBLIC LANDS ๐ŸŒฒ
  • A federal court temporarily blocks the Trump administrationโ€™s plans to reorganize โ€” some would say dismantle โ€” the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which included moving the Forest Service headquarters to Salt Lake City and shuttering multiple research facilities. โ€œThese forced moves were never about efficiency. They were about pushing experienced people out the door,โ€ said American Federation of Government Employees President Everett Kelley in a statement. (Politico)
  • U.S. Rep. Paul Gosar (R-Ariz.) introduces legislation that would require congressional approval for federal land withdrawals of more than 5,000 acres, including for presidential designations of national monuments under the Antiquities Act. (Navajo-Hopi Observer)
๐Ÿฆซ WILDLIFE WATCH ๐Ÿฆ…
  • The Preregrine Fund releases four more California condors into the wild at Marble Canyon in northern Arizona, bringing the areaโ€™s flock of the endangered birds up to 96. (Arizona Republic)
Condor X8, a female hatched in 2018, sits on a Navajo Bridge beam which spans Marble Canyon in northern Arizona. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • Wyoming wildlife officials say 14% of the Sublette Pronghorn Herd died over six weeks this summer, and attribute the unusually high mortality rate to malnutrition resulting from drought-parched forage. (WyoFile)

๐Ÿ›ป TRANSPORTATION ๐Ÿš‚

  • Len Necefer goes deep on the electric vehicle charging network โ€” or lack thereof โ€” on tribal nationsโ€™ land in Arizona. (All At Once by Dr. Len)

๐Ÿค‘ GENTRIFICATION JOURNAL๐Ÿ’ฐ

  • Sublette County, Wyomingโ€™s commissioners vote to eliminate a 2021 zoning change that cleared the way for billionaire Joe Rickettโ€™s proposed upscale resort in the Upper Hoback River area. (WyoFile)

๐ŸŒจ๏ธ๐Ÿฆฆ๐Ÿšฃ๐Ÿฝ WATER WATCH ๐ŸŒŠ

  • Rural Arizonans in the Prescott area are forced to haul water as regional population growth and aridification draw down groundwater levels and dry out wells. (Cronkite News)

โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ

  • The Navajo Nationโ€™s Coppermine Chapter passes a resolution โ€œunequivocallyโ€ opposing Chakana Copperโ€™s proposed Copper Mesa Project in a historically mined area near Page, Arizona; mining company executives say they wonโ€™t go forward unless the project is โ€œwholeheartedly endorsed by the community.โ€ (KJZZ, Essential Minerals)
  • Hillsboro, New Mexico, residents push back on New Mexico Copperโ€™s proposed Copper Flat mining project near the small community, with water consumption topping their list of concerns. (Searchlight New Mexico, New Mexico Copper)

๐Ÿ”ญ OVERSIGHT (or lack thereof) ๐Ÿ‘ฎ๐Ÿผ

  • Journalist and clean energy advocate Bill McKibben delves into the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or permitting reform legislation, thoroughly exploring arguments for and agains. Though he is conflicted, and agrees on many points with proponents of the bill, he ultimately comes down in opposition to the legislation because it weakens bedrock environmental laws and would benefit fossil fuels. (The Crucial Years)
  • An 18-year Interior Department veteran resigns to protest the Trump administrationโ€™s โ€œdeeply troubling assault on the rule of lawโ€ and its efforts to weaken or eviscerate environmental protections to benefit the fossil fuel industries. (Public Domain)
An outtake from John Murdockโ€™s resignation letter from the Department of the Interior. Source: Public Domain.
  • Leaked data show the Interior Department has lost nearly 10,000 permanent staffers since the Trump administration took office, with the Bureau of Land Management staff down by 45% since 2024. (Wes Silerโ€™s Newsletter)
๐Ÿ“Š ECONOMIC INDICATORS ๐Ÿ’ธ
  • Page, Arizonaโ€™s economy shows signs of a shift as the lodging, retail, restaurant, and grocery sectors fade while the construction, remote seller, amusements, and commercial leasing areas surge. (Choose Page)
๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ
  • An analysis finds about 100 data centers have driven nearly all of the increased demand on Arizona Public Serviceโ€™s power grid, and the utility is charging its entire customer base to purchase outside power to meet the growing load, prompting state Attorney General Kris Mayes to call for an investigation. (KJZZ, Abhay Padgaonkar)
  • Arizona data show that the stateโ€™s sales and use tax exemption for data centersโ€™ computer equipment cost the state $38.5 million in fiscal year 2025, up from $19.4 million in 2024. (Good Jobs First)
  • Federal data show proposals for grid-connected gas-fired power plants have nearly tripled over the last three years, largely due to data center-driven electricity demand growth. At least 12 of the facilities in the planning pipeline are in the Western U.S. (Environment America)
  • Oracle considers trucking natural gas to its Project Jupiter data center complexunder construction in southern New Mexico after the state denied its proposed gas pipeline, prompting Energy Transfer LP to reroute it. Oracle also trucks gas to one of its data centers in Salt Lake City, adding to the facilityโ€™s environmental impacts. (Searchlight New Mexico)
๐ŸŒž GOOD NEWS! ๐Ÿ˜Ž
  • The MacArthur Foundation awards Chip Thomas, aka Jetsonorama, a genius grant for his large-scale murals with social justice themes that can be found across the Southwest and on the Navajo Nation. (NPR)
  • The High Desert Museum is accepting nominations for the Jordan Schnitzer Prize of the West, a $50,000 philanthropic award for leaders tackling the American Westโ€™s most pressing environmental challenges, from water scarcity to wildfire, that is awarded annually to an individual or small group who has contributed in practice, scholarship, or policy to the regionโ€™s future, with emphasis on innovation, social impact, uncommon collaborations, and scalability. Nominations are open through Dec. 31. (High Desert Museum)
Dolores River watershed
๐Ÿ“– READING LIST ๐Ÿ“ฐ
  • Heads up Four Corners area folks: Iโ€™ll be giving a presentation on the Dolores River as part of a Dolores River Boating Advocatesโ€™ event on Friday, Nov. 6, from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. at the Powerhouse in Durango. Following a short film about Snaggletooth Rapid Iโ€™ll speak about my personal relationship with the Dolores River, its history, the way it is a sort of microcosm of the Colorado River as a whole, and about its potential futures. Iโ€™ll also throw in a funny little tale about the time I saw Ed Abbey go through Snaggletooth. Tickets are $10 โ€” which will help DRBA defray costs โ€” and seating is limited. There will also be a cash bar. Reserve your spot now: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/a-changing-dolores-river-a-conversation-with-drba-and-jonathan-thompson-tickets-2001390992334
POSTSCRIPT

Iโ€™m going to be out and about and on the road and often off grid for the next week, meaning these dispatches may come even more sporadically than this one! My apologies for any confusion or Land Desk withdrawal symptoms that may lead to.

Herd of pronghorns. Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=216046

Arizona joins Nevada to fight federal Colorado River plan: The Grand Canyon State is suing over Trump administration rules that would sharply reduce the amount of water Arizona receives from the river — Stephanie Casanova (High Country News)

The Hoover Dam impounds the Colorado River and forms Lake Mead, pictured in 2022. Arizona has joined Nevada’s lawsuit against the Trump administration’s 10-year plan for managing the drying Colorado River. Christopher Clark / U.S. Bureau of Reclamation

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Stephanie Casanova):

October 20, 2026

The Arizona Department of Water Resources filed a motion Friday to intervene in Nevadaโ€™s earlier lawsuit, claiming the federal governmentโ€™s plan for the shrinking river would โ€œdevastate Arizonaโ€™s economy,โ€ the agencyโ€™s director said in a news release.

โ€œThe Stateโ€™s towns, cities, tribes, farmers, factories, and businesses cannot survive without sufficient water from the Colorado River,โ€ attorneys for the state claim in the motion.

Nevada filed a lawsuit in late August against several federal agencies, arguing that their plan places a heavier burden on the Lower Basin states. The amount of water in the  Colorado River is dwindling because of climate change, which is reducing the amount of snow and runoff that fills reservoirs like Lake Mead and Lake Powell, and mid-20th century agreements that promised water users more water than actually exists. Because the seven states that rely on the Colorado River couldnโ€™t reach an agreement on how to manage the water, the federal issued a plan intended to better balance the amount of water in the river with the amount withdrawn.

Arizona and Nevada argue they have already taken steps to conserve water and are being unfairly targeted.

โ€œThe Lower Basin states have contributed millions of acre-feet of water toward stabilizing the river system. With more than 5.5 million acre-feet of Arizona water left in Lake Mead since 2014, no state has sacrificed more,โ€ Arizona Department of Water Resources Director Tom Buschatzke said in an Oct. 16 statement. โ€œThe US decision puts the entire burden of sacrifice on the shoulders of three states. We are joining Nevada in challenging that framework.โ€

The Colorado River is divided between Upper Basin states โ€” Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming โ€” and Lower Basin states: Arizona, Nevada and California. The 1922 Colorado River Compact allocates 7.5 million acre-feet of water annually to each of the two basins, as well as a smaller portion for parts of Mรฉxico. The U.S. states in each basin divide their shares.

An acre-foot is the equivalent of almost 326,000 gallons of water, enough water to cover a football field in roughly a foot of water. In Arizona, one acre-foot typically is enough to serve three single-family homes for a year, according to the Arizona Department of Water Resources.

California gets the largest share of Colorado River water: 4.4 million acre-feet per year, or about 27%. The stateโ€™s Lower Basin peers get smaller allocations. Arizona receives 2.8 million acre-feet, or about 17% annually. Nevada receives 300,000 acre-feet, or about 2% annually, according to Congressional reports and a California public policy analysis.

“We will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses.”

The U.S. Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s plan requires the Lower Basin states to shoulder potential cuts. For Arizona, the proposal means a reduction of 760,000 acre-feet per year โ€” about a quarter of the stateโ€™s water allocation and the largest cut among the three Lower Basin states. California would be required to cut 440,000 acre-feet per year and Nevada 50,000 acre-feet. The cuts could amount to up to 3 million acre-feet.

The federal government is not requiring cuts for Upper Basin states. Instead, the government is asking the upstream states to voluntarily contribute 200,000 acre-feet each of the two years.

โ€œArizona has always been willing to do our part to protect the Colorado River, but we will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses,” Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs said in a statement Friday.

The Department of the Interior criticized Arizonaโ€™s legal action and said the Trump Administration is working with the Basin states, tribes and water users on an agreement.

โ€œGovernor Hobbs is wrong, and itโ€™s unfortunate to see Arizona playing politics instead of working toward meaningful solutions,โ€ a spokesperson for the Department of the Interior told Arizona Luminaria in an email statement. โ€œLitigation wonโ€™t create a single additional drop of water or change the hydrologic realities facing the Colorado River Basin.โ€ [ed. emphasis mine]

In a complaint Arizona filed with its motion to join Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit, the state claims there was a flaw in the federal governmentโ€™s environmental review underpinning the decision. Every federal option considered โ€œassumed that the Upper Basin States would make no meaningful reduction in their own use, no matter how little water the River produced.

โ€œThe alternatives placed the full burden of any resulting shortfall on the Lower Basin,โ€ the complaint says.

Western water rights are prioritized according to a โ€œfirst in time, first in rightโ€ doctrine, meaning those who claimed or purchased river water first are prioritized over water users who did so later. That means Arizona’s Colorado River rights are lower priority than California’s, which were acquired earlier.

โ€œSuch reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project canal system, as well as many of our on-river communities and would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement,โ€ Buschatzke said.

Nevadaโ€™s August lawsuit came just three days after the U.S. Department of the Interior formally announced its Colorado River plan in August. In it, Nevada claims the cuts โ€œwill cause devastating environmental, socioeconomic, and health and human safety impacts to southern Nevada and its citizens.โ€

The lawsuit also claims that the federal governmentโ€™s plan violates several requirements within the Law of the River, based on a series of records that include compacts, treaties, laws and court decisions that manage the Colorado River.

Nevada Gov. Joe Lombardo welcomed Arizonaโ€™s decision to join the lawsuit, saying in a Friday statement that itโ€™s โ€œan important step in challenging a federal plan that unfairly burdens the Lower Basin and fails to require the Upper Basin to make meaningful reductions.โ€

Arizona says joining Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit would allow it to avoid filing a separate but similar lawsuit, and allow the borderlands state to represent its own interests.

โ€œArizona believes that taking this action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users,โ€ Buschatzke said.

This story was produced as part of the Western Environmental Reporting Collaborative, a partnership between Arizona Luminaria, High Country News, Report for America and local news organizations across the West.

We welcome reader letters. Email High Country News at editor@hcn.org or submit a letter to the editor. See our letters to the editor policy.

This story has been updated with comments from the U.S. Department of the Interior.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

I am still astonished that I can fill up my car with sunshine — Dan Ilic

I am still astonished that I can fill up my car with sunshine

— Dan Ilic (@danilic.bsky.social) 2026-10-20T03:29:30.906Z

#Arizona joins #ColoradoRiver fight in federal court — The Deseret News #COriver #aridification

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

Click the link to read the article on The Deseret News website (Leah Bowers). Here’s an excerpt:

October 16, 2026

Arizona Department of Water Resources Director Tom Buschatzke said the litigation pathway was never the preferred alternative. โ€œWe were not successful in coming to an equitable outcome among all seven states,โ€ he added…

The core of the departmentโ€™s decision โ€” and the source of contention between the states โ€” is how the water conservation efforts are split. The four Upper Basin states (Utah, Colorado, New Mexico and Wyoming) face no mandatory water reductions โ€” they are subject to voluntary conservation goals. The three Lower Basin states (Arizona, California and Nevada), however, could be required to cut their water usage by up to 3 million acre-feet…Even between the three Lower Basin states, the cuts are not spread evenly. Arizona is expected to accept 61% of the cuts, California 35% and Nevada 4%…

โ€œSuch reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project as well as many of our on-river communities,โ€ said Buschatzke. โ€œIt would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement. Arizona believes that taking its action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users.โ€

Arizona claims the new guidelines โ€œfailed to deliverโ€ the water that Lower Basin states are owed: โ€œLike Nevada, Arizona believes the federal governmentโ€™s new operating framework ignores basic elements of the law of the river,โ€ said Buschatzke. โ€œIt could result in cuts to the state apportionment that would devastate Arizonaโ€™s economy.โ€

[…]

A multistate compact adopted in 1922 designates 1.5 million acre-feet to Mexico, 7.5 million acre-feet to the Upper Basin states, 7.5 million acre-feet to the Lower Basin states and 1.5 million acre-feet to evapotranspiration. That totals 18 million acre-feet in the Colorado River each year. However, some experts say much of the conflict the Southwestern states live with now is due to bad math from the beginning of the law โ€” claiming there was never 18 million acre-feet of water to divide in the first place.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#Arizona moves to join #ColoradoRiver lawsuit alongside #Nevada — KJZZ #COriver #aridification

Marble Canyon. Photo credit: Western Resource Advocates

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

October 16, 2026

Arizona has filed to join a lawsuit against the federal government over its new plan for managing the Colorado River. The federal plan would cut Colorado River supplies for Arizona, California and Nevada by about 20% through 2028, and could cut them by about 40% after that. The lawsuit, originally filed by Nevada in August, argues that the plan is too harmful to water users in those states. Arizona would take the largest cuts under the new federal plan, and state officials have openly criticized it. By filing a motion to intervene in Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit, they are arguing that the federal water plan is not only unfair, but illegal.

โ€œArizona believes the federal government’s new operating framework ignores basic elements of the law of the river and could result in cuts to the state apportionment that would devastate Arizona’s economy,โ€ said Tom Buschatzke, director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources.

Tom Buschatzke. Photo credit: Arizona Department of Water Resources

The lawsuit is not the so-called โ€œnuclear optionโ€ that could bring Colorado River matters before the Supreme Court. That would likely require one state to sue another. Arizona has laid out its case to sue if it determines that upstream states are not sending a legally-required amount of water downstream, but has not yet done so…The lawsuit Arizona filed to join on Friday does something different. Nevadaโ€™s original suit claims that the federal government violated procedural laws while creating its new plans for managing water. The Bureau of Reclamation, the federal agency which operates reservoirs and dams across the West, is required to fill out a lot of paperwork alongside big decisions about water management. Within that paperwork, Reclamation has to explain how its new strategy might impact the environment, people and businesses that are connected to the river system. Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit โ€” and Arizonaโ€™s motion to join it โ€” argues that Reclamation did not do enough to consider the extent of that impact.

#Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs and ADWR Join #Nevada in Colorado River Lawsuit to Block Federal Cuts to Lower Basin Water Supplies #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

Here’s the release from Governor Hobbs’ website:

October 16, 2026

Today, Governor Katie Hobbs and the Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR) announced the State of Arizona has intervened in a lawsuit brought by Nevada against the Department of the Interior to hold the federal government accountable for failing to enforce Upper Basin water delivery obligations to Lake Mead and prevent cuts of up to 3 million acre-feet per year. In joining this lawsuit, the State will seek to preserve the two-year Lower Basin Agreement while ensuring the federal government is delivering the water to Lake Mead that belongs to Arizona and the Lower Basin states.

โ€œArizona has always been willing to do our part to protect the Colorado River, but we will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses,” said Governor Katie Hobbs. “We are drawing a line in the sand. I am taking this legal action alongside Nevada because the federal government refuses to hold the Upper Basin accountable for the water deliveries they owe Arizona, and is threatening to force draconian cuts that go well beyond the Lower Basin Agreement. While we ensure our voice is heard in court, weโ€™ll continue working alongside Nevada and California to implement the Lower Basin Agreement and prevent a devastating cut to Arizonaโ€™s Colorado River water.โ€

โ€œIntervention in the Nevada lawsuit is necessary at this time for Arizona to protect its legal rights to Colorado River water while preserving a path forward to achieving a collaborative outcome with California and Nevada to protect the Colorado River system,โ€ said ADWR Director Tom Buschatzke.

The Lower Basin Agreement is an agreement between Arizona, California and Nevada to protect the future of the Colorado River and prevent forced federal cuts that would slash the Central Arizona Projectโ€™s Colorado River allocation by 77% over the next two years. In the Agreement, Lower Basin states commit to conserve over 3.2 million acre-feet in 2027 and 2028 to stabilize the Colorado River system. Finalizing the Lower Basin Agreement remains a priority for the State of Arizona.

Joining this lawsuit ensures that Arizona can protect the Stateโ€™s interests in any legal outcome and challenge elements of the federal Final Environmental Impact Statement and Record of Decision that unlawfully fail to require deliveries from Upper Basin water reservoirs to Lake Mead. These federal decisions could result in 3 million acre-feet per year in cuts to the Lower Basin states, inflicting devastating water reductions while the Upper Basin States avoid any required conservation.

[ed. The “required conservation” argument is pipe dream. Buschatzke is fixated on the impossible because the Lower Basin has had certainty of deliveries since Hoover dam first filled, while no Upper Basin diverter has ever had that kind of certainty. He fails to acknowledge the difference between mountain rivers, with hundreds of diversions, where most of the water comes from, and desert rivers where there is little precipitation adding to streamflow. The Colorado Division of Water Resources cannot legally force diverters to bypass water and they do not have the ability to shepherd the water to Lake Powell. It is not possible to accurately measure conserved water at this time (apologies to Dr. Parshall). I think the Lower Basin legal position is very strong and they will press the advantage in court which will take a long time to resolve. Meanwhile available water continues to decline and the LB won’t come to the table to negotiate “wet water” vs. “paper water”. The combination of Climate Change and the “Law of the River” drained Mead and Powell, not Upper Basin consumptive use.]

The Colorado River Basin spans seven U.S. states and part of Mexico. Lake Powell, upstream from the Grand Canyon, and Lake Mead, near Las Vegas, are the two principal reservoirs in the Colorado River water-supply system. (Bureau of Reclamation)

The Central #Arizona Project board authorizes legal action against the federal government over #ColoradoRiver — AZCentral.com #COriver #aridification

Photo credit: Central Arizona Project

Click the link to read the article on the AZCentral website (Branson Loomis). Here’s an excerpt:

September 3, 2026

Key Points

  • The CAP board authorized legal action “if necessary” against the Interior Department over its plan to manage shortages on the Colorado River.
  • Nevada has already sued the feds over the plan, claiming that it violates the Colorado River Compact and would devastate the Las Vegas economy.
  • Arizona lawmakers have set aside money and hired a law firm to sue the federal government, but have not acted yet.

The Central Arizona Projectโ€™s board authorized its legal counsel to take legal action โ€œif necessaryโ€ against a federal plan to cut Arizonaโ€™s share of Colorado River water dramatically in coming years. Board members went into a closed executive session before the Sept. 3 vote to discuss certain โ€œoccurrencesโ€ that could trigger a lawsuit or other legal filing, and did not specify them when voting unanimously for the authorization. Board member Alexandra Arboleda introduced the motion at the meeting and prefaced it with a statement that the United States Department of the Interior’s 10-year framework for dealing with water shortage โ€œcontemplates operations that are contrary to law and devastating to the water users of the Central Arizona Project.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#Arizona Department of Water Resources Director Tom Buschatzke — Opening Statement on Arizona Filing a motion to intervene in the #Nevada Lawsuit challenging the recent federal decision governing the operation of the #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

The Central Arizona Project canal carries water through Phoenix in 2019. Ted Wood/The Water Desk

From email from ADWR:

October 16, 2026

Today the State of Arizona filed a motion to intervene in the Nevada lawsuit challenging the recent federal decision governing the operation of the Colorado River.

Like Nevada, Arizona believes the federal governmentโ€™s new operating framework ignores basic elements of the Law of the River and could result in cuts to the stateโ€™s apportionment that would devastate Arizonaโ€™s economy.

These elements go far beyond and fall outside the Lower Basin Agreement to which we are strongly committed and continue to work with Nevada and California to implement.

Our problems with the federal governmentโ€™s Record of Decision are twofold.

One: the federal governmentโ€™s plan fails to deliver the water that Arizona and our fellow Lower Basin states are owed according to the Law of the River.

Two: the federal governmentโ€™s Year 3-10 plan includes a range of โ€œsideboardsโ€ that, if triggered, could require reductions to the Lower Basin of up to 3 million acre-feet per year in priority. Such reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project canal system, as well as many of our on-river communities and would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement.

Arizona believes that taking this action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users. We are confident that our negotiations with California, Nevada and the U.S. will move forward. In fact, by taking this step we are protecting the integrity of our Agreement. By joining this litigation we can protect Arizonaโ€™s interests, whether thatโ€™s before a judge or in any settlement discussions that may ensue.

Arizonaโ€™s priority remains the completion of a Lower Basin Agreement with California, Nevada, and the U.S. to share in water reductions over the next two years and to memorialize the Intentionally Created Surplus tool. Through our participation in this litigation we will seek to assure that the agreement is implemented.

The Lower Basin states have contributed millions of acre-feet of water toward stabilizing the river system. With more than 5.5 million acre-feet of Arizona water left in Lake Mead since 2014, no state has sacrificed more. In collaboration with our Lower Basin state partners, the Lower Basin Agreement demonstrates that we are doing more. But the US decision puts the entire burden of sacrifice on the shoulders of three states. We are joining Nevada in challenging that framework.

Lake Powell critical elevations. Land Desk graphic using data from the Bureau of Reclamation.

Americans want electric cars, they just canโ€™t findย them — John Paul Helveston (TheConversation.com)

A sales lot for used electric cars has several models on display.
Prices for used electric vehicles are climbing because new models are โ€“ and are likely to remain โ€“ in short supply. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

John Paul Helveston, George Washington University

Within three months of the U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran on Feb. 28, 2026, the average price of gasoline for American drivers climbed from US$2.94 to $4.35 a gallon. If there was ever a moment for Americans to switch to electric vehicles, this was it.

From March to May 2026, in fact, sales of hybrid electric vehicles were 18% higher than over the same months in 2025.

But sales of fully electric vehicles were 16% lower from March to May 2026 compared with the same months in 2025. Some observers took that as evidence that high gas prices alone wouldnโ€™t push Americans toward fully electric cars, but that conclusion misses half the story.

I study car buyers and their preferences, and there is an important distinction between what consumers want and what they can actually buy. Sales reveal what cars people actually bought, but not necessarily what they actually wanted.

When the supply of some kinds of cars canโ€™t keep up with demand, prices rise, and thatโ€™s exactly what happened for electric vehicles in 2026.

An industry in retreat

In 2026, hybrids and all-electric vehicles faced the same jump in demand from the oil crisis. While there were plenty of hybrids available to meet that demand, the same was not true for EVs.

Hybrid production had been growing for years, led by Toyota, which sells about half of the hybrids bought in the United States. As a result, even as sales surged, hybrid inventories on dealer lots were 19% higher in March 2026 than they had been a year earlier.

However, EV production had been in retreat since the tax and spending law President Donald Trump signed in July 2025 ended federal tax credits for EVs. Buyers had been able to get up to $7,500 for new EVs and $4,000 for used ones, but that ended after Sept. 30, 2025.

Automakers responded by cutting back their EV production. General Motors laid off more than 3,400 workers at its EV and battery plants and shifted its Tennessee plant to make batteries for energy storage, not cars. Ford wrote off $19.5 billion from its EV business, ended production of the all-electric F-150 Lightning and converted a Tennessee EV plant to build gas-powered trucks.

Buyers, for their part, rushed to beat the tax credit deadline, pushing EVs to 11.3% of new vehicle sales in September 2025. But by November 2025, after the tax credits ended, their share dropped to 4.3%.

As 2026 progressed and gas prices began to rise, so did EV demand. New EV inventories declined, shrinking from about 130 days of supply in the first quarter of 2026 to 78 days by August โ€“ just two days above the supply level of gas-burning cars.

Discounts on new EV models shrank too. My analysis of online listings from marketcheck.com shows the median new EV was listed 9.8% below sticker price in February. By April, the median discount was 6.6%, and 4.7% in June. Thatโ€™s a sign that dealers saw rising demand, not inventory to clear.

A run on used electric vehicles

Before the war, prices for used electric vehicles were still drifting down in the wake of the expired used EV federal tax credit. After the war began, they climbed 13% through late June 2026. For a typical used electric vehicle, thatโ€™s about $3,500 more.

Other data sources point in the same direction. Recurrent, a company that reports on batteries and used EVs, found that the price of a used 2023 Chevrolet Bolt rose almost 20% from January to June 2026.

And inventories of used electric vehicles dropped too, with only 31 days of supply in May, 23% below the year before.

A costly misreading

None of this means the electric vehicle market is healthy. High prices and uncertain access to charging stations are real stumbling blocks for people who are thinking about buying an EV.

But the data doesnโ€™t support the claim that electric vehicle sales stalled in 2026 because Americans donโ€™t want them. Rather, the sales stalled because there werenโ€™t enough EVs available to buy โ€“ and there were plenty of hybrids as an alternative.

The distinction matters because automakers have treated a change in the policy landscape as a change in consumer demand, leading to shortages with real costs.

The average new car now sells for about $50,000 and the average new electric vehicle for about $55,000, according to Kelley Blue Book, a company that tracks car prices.

The current situation leaves drivers exposed to the volatility of oil prices with fewer alternatives. The U.S. is the worldโ€™s largest oil producer, yet a war in the Persian Gulf raised gas prices significantly in just three months. Oil trades on a global market, so American drivers pay global prices.

Seven months into the war, the pressure on drivers is still going full throttle. Oil was still above $100 a barrel in mid-October, and diesel hit a record $6.52 a gallon on Sept. 22.

Electric vehicle sales havenโ€™t caught up. Argonneโ€™s data show 86,000 of them sold in August, fewer than the 101,000 sold in May, while hybrid sales stayed above 216,000 a month all summer.

A look ahead

Rather than move to increase electric vehicle supply and make them more affordable, federal policy continues to hinder the U.S. electric vehicle sector.

The fuel economy rule released Sept. 28, 2026, loosens efficiency requirements for gas-powered vehicles and in 2028 ends a system that let automakers that beat the standards โ€“ mostly EV makers โ€“ earn credits for exceeding them and sell those to automakers that fell short. That means automakers will have fewer regulatory incentives to produce EVs going forward.

Regulators say buyers will save $1,289 on the purchase price of a new gas-powered vehicle from reduced engineering and manufacturing costs to make less efficient engines. But the same analysis estimates drivers will spend about $1,600 more on gas over the life of the car, and thatโ€™s using fuel price forecasts well below todayโ€™s prices. Economists say the administrationโ€™s math does not properly account for those fuel costs.

Workers move alongside a row of cars on an assembly line.
Chinese EV manufacturing is growing, but the U.S. market is mostly closed to those products and the companies that make them, and may get even more closed. Kevin Frayer/Getty Images

The U.S. has also effectively shut out Chinese automakers, even though nearly three-quarters of the worldโ€™s electric cars are built in China. In 2024, Chinese car buyers could choose from over 130 EV models priced under $40,000; American buyers had just four EV models under that threshold. Beyond tariffs of more than 100% on EVs made in China, a Commerce Department rule bars cars from Chinese-linked automakers starting with model year 2027, even if they are built in the U.S. A bill pending in Congress would widen the ban, blocking Chinese investment in U.S. auto factories altogether.

As long as gas stays expensive, the gap between the electric vehicles Americans want and the electric vehicles dealers can sell them is likely to remain. Decisions such as ending the tax credit, rolling back fuel economy standards and banning Chinese technology all make it harder to build them, which means Americans will continue to have fewer affordable electric vehicles to choose from.

John Paul Helveston, Associate Professor of Engineering Management and Systems Engineering, George Washington University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Coyote Gulch’s Ariya charging at the Rivian Adventure Network in Del Norte, September 14, 2026.

Romancing the River: The Real โ€˜Two Basinsโ€™ of a Desert River — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Graphic credit: The Colorado River water crisis its origin and future Jack Schmidt, Eric Kuhn, Charles Yackulic.

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

October 13, 2026

This will be my last post before what might be our last election โ€“ if our would-be tyrant doesnโ€™t succeed in stopping it entirely. I encourage my handful of readers to vote early, and then be prepared to participate in public opposition โ€“ make a big noise โ€“ to the chaos our PINO will surely try to cause if he doesnโ€™t like the outcomes.

The mainstream media (being mostly owned by billionaires) continue to try to portray this election as just another horse-race between โ€˜Democrats and Republicans.โ€™ It is not that. This election may be out last chance to salvage what the Trumpsters havenโ€™t yet undermined of our 250-year effort to work out a functional governance by, for and of the people โ€“ a representational governance, a form of democracy. At present nearly all of our supposed representatives in Congress who call themselves โ€˜Republicansโ€™ and many of those who call themselves โ€˜Democratsโ€™ are clearly โ€˜ownedโ€™ by those with the money to fund their campaigns โ€“ the oligarchs and kleptocrats who want to replace that 250-year effort with an authoritarian governance that they believe will be more โ€˜efficientโ€™ in accommodating them.

The only hope for keeping our 250-year experiment in self-governance going is to replace the sellouts with representation in the mold of Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Alexandria Octavio-Cortez and others who truly try to speak and act on behalf of us, rather than of those whom we have all helped make morbidly wealthy. And we will only be successful if it is a decisive victory for the people; one or two percent victories will be challenged and kept in chaos until โ€“ well, forever: nearly a third of the voting electorate still believe that Trump was cheated out of a 2020 election victory because Trump says so. He is determined to keep this election from being a conclusive victory against him because he knows that the only way to stay out of prison is to stay in the presidency with a compliant Congress.

So vote as if the future depended on it โ€“ because it does. We do not want to live in an oligarchic kleptocracy run by a semi-senile narcissist with his gang of thieves pillaging the people to pay for technologies of mass control, with his army of brownshirt ICE agents running rampant in our streets. If we donโ€™t come out of the election with a Congress at least partially in control of representatives of the people (not just โ€˜Democratsโ€™ โ€“ think of Fetterman), then it is all over.

Meanwhile, back on the banks of the bankrupt Colorado River system. Remembering first that the river system is not the river itself. The river itself is what it has always been: flows of water running through river-carved valleys and canyons because the surrounding land has not put those flows to use in service to living things. The flows move on to other valleys where sometimes they are put to use by plants, forests, wildlife including humans, and sometimes not, then flowing on to other valleys until they all eventually join up and get to sea level, reentering the seas from which they came. Those flows ebb and flow themselves, annually and year-to-year, at the whims of the global climate โ€“ which at this point has the human thumb on the scales pushing toward the hotter drier side.

Thatโ€™s the river; the river system is the structures for storage and distribution we have imposed over the river to even out the natural flows, annually and year-to-year, in service to human life. But the system was designed for a river half again larger than the river weโ€™ve had since the turn of the century; it is beyond rational denial that it was overbuilt for the river we now have (see the graph above), although many continue to deny it for reasons including plain desperation.

That suggestion will come in time, but first I think we need to define the current reality (which bears no resemblance to โ€˜Compact realityโ€™). The first step is to acknowledge the nature of a desert river, then try to adapt our basic thinking and planning to that.

All rivers are water that the surrounding land and its diverse inhabitants have not managed to put to โ€˜beneficial useโ€™ for the living ecologies the river runs through. That โ€˜left-overโ€™ water flows on from its home watershed to larger multiple watersheds where it either gets put to use or doesnโ€™t, and if not, it flows on even larger basins, et cetera. Hydrologists describe streams as โ€˜gainingโ€™ or โ€˜losingโ€™: a stream that adds surface and groundwater from a watershed with a high water table is a โ€˜gaining streamโ€™; a stream that gives up some of it water to a watershed with a lower water table is a โ€˜losing streamโ€™ (although I think it ought to be called a โ€˜giving streamโ€™).

Many humid-region rivers continue to collect more water from precipitation that falls on them and their surrounding land, from its headwaters all the way to its ocean estuary. A desert river, on the other hand, gets nearly all the water it will ever have from its headwaters region, with mountains or plateaus high enough to force rising air to cool and release any water vapor it carries as precipitation โ€“ mostly winter snow in the case of the Colorado River. Most of the Colorado River headwaters are in the Southern Rockies, but the Wind River Mountains in the Central Rockies generate some of the Green River tributaries, the Colorado Plateau and New Mexico highlands generate the Gila River; smaller basin-and-range mountains the Virgin River, et cetera. But the precipitation that falls on those high places generates 85-90 percent of the water that will make its way into the Colorado River; once it leaves its headwaters and flows into its desert regions, it will gain very little new precipitation.

This transition from gaining streams to losing (giving) streams happens fairly quickly in the Colorado Riverโ€™s natural basin. The majority of its water comes from highlands above ~8,000 feet elevation โ€“ about ten percent of the entire basin. In the Upper Gunnison River watersheds where I live, major Gunnison River tributaries leave the Crested Butte area at 9,000 feet elevation where the average annual precipitation is 23 inches (up to 40+ inches on upvalley); a mere 35 miles down the valley in Blue Mesa Reservoir, at 7,500 feet elevation, the average precipitation has dropped to 10-11 inches. In that short distance, the Gunnison River is already in the high deserts of the Colorado Plateau, and most of the valley below Crested Butte is under irrigation โ€“ the river already โ€˜giving.โ€™. The Gunnison River gets larger as it flows west and north to its โ€˜grand junctionโ€™ with the Colorado River, but that is due to picking up other tributaries; very little precipitation water gets added โ€“ even in the summer monsoons, according to a hydrologist working in the Upper Gunnison.

Prior to the Euro-American presence in the basin, the Colorado River ran in extremes: a flood of water while the snowpack was melting in the high headwaters, then a comparative trickle in the late summer and fall after the snowmelt ends. The flood months nurtured riparian life throughout its course, from a narrow strip in some places to broad wetlands, meadows and cottonwood โ€˜oasesโ€™ in other desert places, culminating in a lush labyrinthian delta on a dyke it had built across the Gulf of California with debris from creating the Grand Canyon through the Colorado Plateau. Whatever was left in the stream after it made its way through the delta went back into the ocean from which it had come โ€“ and one imagines there were many drier years when there was not enough water left below the delta to go into the ocean after the early summer flood finished.

We tend to make a big deal about the Colorado River no longer flowing to the ocean now due to our heavy use, but there are many desert rivers around the world that donโ€™t flow into the oceans; some forty streams flow into the Great Basin from surrounding mountains and plateaus โ€“ some of them respectable rivers like the Truckee, through Reno โ€“ and they all gradually disappear there, after nurturing riparian life (including some ranches and towns), enduring evapotranspiration, and sinking into aquifers. President Theodore Roosevelt, often called the father of American conservation, considered freshwater going unused into the ocean to be a โ€˜waste.โ€™

But understanding the nature of the desert river, and how it is different from a humid-region river like the Mississippi, offers some clues about an intelligent river system for storing and distributing the river. The vast majority of the users of the riverโ€™s water, especially the modern human users, are in the desert lands below the headwaters region โ€“ the โ€˜losingโ€™ (โ€˜givingโ€™) portion of the river: in the higher โ€˜cold desertsโ€™ above the canyon region, and the subtropical โ€˜hot desertsโ€™ below the canyons.

Healthy mountain meadows and wetlands are characteristic of healthy headwater systems and provide a variety of ecosystem services, or benefits that humans, wildlife, rivers and surrounding ecosystems rely on. The complex of wetlands and connected floodplains found in intact headwater systems can slow runoff and attenuate flood flows, creating better downstream conditions, trapping sediment to improve downstream water quality, and allowing groundwater recharge. These systems can also serve as a fire break and refuge during wildfire, can sequester carbon in the floodplain, and provide essential habitat for wildlife. Graphic by Restoration Design Group, courtesy of American Rivers

There are also water users in the headwaters region. Largest by far are the forests that ring most of the mountains, along with other plant and animal life inhabiting those mountain-forest regions. There are also humans in the headwaters, mostly in or near towns supporting mining or outdoor recreation, but what makes the most sense is to consider the human users as outliers of the โ€˜losingโ€™ basin below the headwaters โ€“ which they are, literally, producing little of what they need to live there but importing moat of it from or through the desert economy. The forests, on the other hand โ€“ as we will see โ€“ are intimately involved in the riverโ€™s water production processes, in both positive and negative ways.

These two distinctly different parts of the river suggest a more natural division of the river into two โ€˜basinsโ€™ than the political division under the Compact: the โ€˜gaining riverโ€™ and the โ€˜losing/giving river,โ€™ each to be managed toward a specific goal: for the gaining river, how to optimize the quantity of water flowing out of the headwaters; and for the losing/giving river, how to optimize the uses and minimize unnecessary losses.

This deliberately breaks up the current โ€˜two-basin divisionโ€™ โ€“ a โ€˜temporary equitable divisionโ€™ adopted in 1922 because the compact commissioners did not know enough about their the river or their own state futures to do the eight-way division (including Mexico) they had set out to do. The two-basin division was most basically an expedient way of persuading Congress that they were together in their search for an equitable division that would only become possible when there was โ€˜a greater fund of informationโ€™ that would enable those following them to do a proper division of the use of the riverโ€™s waters, but meanwhile โ€“ letโ€™s build the big dam.

Dividing the river into its โ€˜water productionโ€™ basin and its โ€˜water consumptionโ€™ basin would have the potential benefit of starting again with nearly all of the users in a single โ€˜consumptionโ€™ basin, while giving them all joint responsibility for taking care of the โ€˜water productionโ€™ basin. Itโ€™s a potential start on at least perceiving the river as a single shared responsibility, as opposed to the current perception of each state in it for its own needs and yielding as little as possible to the other states.

Thatโ€™s where weโ€™ll start next time โ€“ with the big question for the losing/giving river, the desert part of the desert river: how to get beyond Compact fantasies, and divide the use of the diminishing river we actually have among the vast multitudes of users (see the graph at the beginning). Thatโ€™s a point at which I think it would be smart to abandon the hydrologic term โ€˜losingโ€™ for a more political term โ€“ not a โ€˜losing riverโ€™ but a โ€˜giving riverโ€™ -which is what it is once it leaves the headwaters. And the challenge of โ€˜dividing the giftsโ€™ of the giving river at least starts with a more positive feel than โ€˜sharing out the lossesโ€™ from a losing riverโ€ฆ.

Meanwhile โ€“ vote! As if the future depended on it because it does. [ed. emphasis mine]

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

How Electric Buses Are Schooling Cities — Frani Halperin (H2ORadio.org)

Highland Electric Fleets will have electric school buses in over 100 cities by the end of this year, such as these shown in Jackson, MI. Many districts will deploy vehicle-to-grid technology to save schools money and support the grid. | Credit: Highland Electric Fleets

Click the link to read the article on the H2O Radio website (Frani Halperin):

October 6, 2026

When Thomas Lujan turns the ignition switch on his school bus, he doesnโ€™t hear a thing. Nothingโ€˜s wrong. In fact, everything is going just right. On this September morning, instead of driving a noisy diesel bus, heโ€™s off to collect students in one thatโ€™s electric. 

Arriving at his first stop, Lujan has high fives and a big smile for children as they board his bus. Theyโ€™re en route to the Peak To Peak Charter School, a K-12 public school in Lafayette, Colorado, north of Denver. The bus is one of four electric buses the school operatesโ€”something Lujan loves to brag about. โ€œThey’re very nice to drive. They’re very quiet. They’re limited as far as the range goes, but other than that, they’re great buses and the kids seem to like them.โ€

Four years ago, Peak To Peak Charter School made the choice to adopt electric buses because they would be more affordable, align with their values to pilot innovative technology, and support their preference not to have to store fuel on site, according to Tracey Sutton, the transportation coordinator. Most school districts that own buses have a shop and a yard where they maintain and refuel their buses. Going electric meant Peak To Peak could avoid this type of infrastructure. 

They also had a goal to reduce the amount of diesel fumes that students (as well as staff) were breathing in. Thatโ€™s an improvement not lost on the kids themselves, who say gas buses were โ€œloud and smokyโ€ and โ€œsmelled horrible.โ€ 

Thomas Lujan is a school bus driver for Peak To Peak Charter. He opened the hood of his bus to reveal not an engine but its electronics, power converters, and cooling systems. | Credit: Frani Halperin/H2O Media, Ltd.

About 30 miles to the south, Nate Cohen is hoping his students will feel the same way. He is the assistant director of transportation for the Cherry Creek School District that operates south of Denver. This month, they too added electric buses to their fleet with a goal of reducing the emissions their buses were putting into neighborhoods they serve. 

Cherry Creek Schools is counting on the new buses to reduce noise pollution. Cohen says we all know when something drives by our houses. Was it a school bus? A garbage truck? A moving van. โ€œYou know, it was something,โ€ he says, but now these buses are  โ€œjust creeping through neighborhoods.โ€ Theyโ€™re also anticipating how the quiet inside the bus will affect students. โ€œWe’ve been told and we’re excited to experience that student management issues decrease significantly because students are not having to yell over the engine, yell over all the noise.โ€


Vehicle-to-Grid (V2G)

While Cherry Creek School District is just dipping their toe into fleet electrificationโ€”adding only six buses to a fleet of more than 300โ€”they are also testing the waters of an added technology that Peak To Peak has yet to tryโ€”bidirectional charging. Thatโ€™s where power flows both ways from a utility to charge a bus or from the bus back to the utility to add to the grid.

Cherry Creek Schools took advantage of grants from Xcel Energy, a provider for the Denver metro area, to make the numbers work on bringing on EV buses. Mark Ingram, the director of transportation for Cherry Creek Schools, said a grant from Xcel โ€œpaid for the entire cost of all six electric buses. So, we got $2.4 million in rebates; each bus costs $400,000.โ€ They also got an extra $750,000 in rebates for bidirectional charging capabilities.

That helps Xcel to stabilize the grid, so it can meet demand when itโ€™s highestโ€”on weekday evenings when people are home cooking dinner, watching TV, or just having lots of lights on. โ€œIn the long term,โ€ Cohen says โ€œthat means either not having to build more power plants or the ability to take power plants offline. It just gives them a more stable approach where they can charge us during off-peak hours when they have that capacity, and then when they need additional capacity, we’re able to provide that to them.โ€

The typical day in the life of a Cherry Creek Schools bus will start with the bus โ€œwaking itself upโ€ and if itโ€™s cold, perhaps warming up the cabin while itโ€™s still connected to the grid. After a driverโ€™s inspection, itโ€™s on the road for about two hours and returns to the depot around 9:00 a.m. The bus will then charge until it leaves for the afternoon routes to take students home. After 5:00 p.m., the buses will send energy back to the grid. After the peak demand for electricity ends, the buses will perform a slow charge overnight. 

Driving Resilience

Hereโ€™s where the partnership with Xcel gets interesting. Not only are the buses able to power the grid when demand is high, but because they are batteries on wheels they could also be driven to an outage location and supply energy. 

โ€œAn average school bus might have a 200- or 250-kilowatt-hour battery pack. That’s adequate to go back up a high school gymnasium or a community center or an assisted living facility for days,โ€ says Duncan McIntyre, the CEO of Highland Electric Fleets, the company that bundled the equipment, training, and financing that allowed both Peak To Peak and Cherry Creek transition to electric buses. โ€œIf your community has 50 electric school buses, which might be cheaper to operate than 50 diesel school buses, there’s this added benefit of being able to drive them around and back up buildings,โ€ McIntyre added.

McIntyre says this so-called โ€œvehicle-to-gridโ€ technology can provide cleaner power than generators that run on diesel to keep facilities a community deems as critical, such as a hospital, functioning. He adds that buildings would need a simple retrofit to install a bidirectional charger and a smart panel to accept the power, but then you have โ€œan incredibly resilient system that can be deployed at a moment’s notice.โ€ 

Thatโ€™s an idea that has more school districts kicking the tires on EV buses as diesel prices spike and climate-driven extreme storms and wildfires affect the grid. McIntyre says โ€œEven with a natural gas heavy grid, the environmental footprint is a huge improvement. An electric motor is much more efficient at converting a unit of power into a unit of propulsion than a combustion engine. It has very few moving parts and is very efficient.โ€

If a utility has a lot of solar and wind energy, it can generate a lot of power, but it needs to be stored in batteries, so how about in a bus? McIntyre says school buses sit idle for 92 percent of the hours in a year. โ€œSo, it’s an incredible opportunity to use the batteries to integrate renewables into the grid, flatten the load curve, and reduce rates for ratepayers.โ€

Highland Electric Fleets will have a couple thousand school buses in over 100 cities by the end of this year with many of those in Colorado, something Nate Cohen of Cherry Creek Schools calls a โ€œwin for the environment, a win for our neighborhoods, and a win for students.โ€

And itโ€™s a way that electric buses are schooling cities on how to be resilient. ๐Ÿ’ง


H2O Radio stories are written by humans. We do not use AI in our journalism.

Deadpool Data Dump: #LakePowellโ€™s terrible, horrible, no good, very bad water year; Plus — Ruminating on the oil and gas infrastructure that clutters the landscape and sometimes explodes — Jonathan P. Thompson #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Land Desk graphic using data from the Bureau of Reclamation.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 9, 2026

๐Ÿ’€ DEADPOOL DATA DUMP ๐ŸŒŠ

Lake Powell, the nationโ€™s second largest reservoir, serves as a sort of barometer of the Colorado River watershedโ€™s overall health. The reservoir and river have been struggling since the great aridificationโ€™s grim onset in 2002. While the river continues to flow, barely, the 2026 Water Year, characterized by one of the worst snow droughts on record, nearly finished off the reservoir. But in the end, it was saved from dropping to โ€œde facto deadpoolโ€ by heavy rain at the beginning and end of the water year, and by larger-than-normal releases from upstream reservoirs. 

  • 4.46 million acre-feet: Total Lake Powell inflow from the Colorado, Dirty Devil, Escalante, and San Juan rivers in water year 2026. Thatโ€™s the third lowest on record, behind 2002 and 2021. This is in spite of the fact that the 2026 snowpack was far lower than those two years, and melting mountain snowpack provides about 80% of the riverโ€™s water.
  • The Colorado River Basinย experienced its warmest water year on recordย (in 131 years) in WY2026.

  • 3.72 million acre-feet. Total Lake Powell unregulated inflow in water year 2026. This is the estimate of how much water would have flowed into the reservoir without any supplementary releases from upstream reservoirs. Which is to say, the feds robbed Flaming Gorge, Navajo, and Blue Mesa of about 750,000 acre-feet to save Powell from shrinking even more. That was bad for those upstream reservoirs and the irrigators, anglers, recreational users, and communities that rely on them, and thereโ€™s no way it can be repeated if this winter is below average.
  • 6 million acre-feet: Total releases from Glen Canyon Dam in water year 2026. This is the lowest release since the very early days of the dam (in the 1960s). This means less water in the Grand Canyon and less water flowing into Lake Mead.ย 
  • 181,111 acre-feet: Estimated amount of water that evaporated from Lake Powell in water year 2026. This is equivalent to more than half of Nevadaโ€™s total annual allotment from the Colorado River.ย 
  • 1.72 million acre-feet: Lake Powellโ€™s water deficit โ€” or the difference between outflows (incl. evaporation) and inflows โ€” for water year 2026.ย 
  • 27 feet:ย Amount the surface level of the reservoir fell in water year 2026, putting it within seven feet of the level the federal governnment has chosen to โ€œdefend,โ€ meaning theyโ€™ll pull out all the stops to keep it from dropping below that (for reasons the Land Desk has gone over many times before). The late September storms brought the level back up a couple of feet.

Feds release two-year Colorado River plan, Nevada sues — Jonathan P. Thompson


Anyone who lived through the 2002 water year probably thought it couldnโ€™t possibly get any worse. Then along came 2026 and, voila! It was really, really bad โ€” at least as far as the snow goes. And snow is really important, because it provides about 80% of the Colorado Riverโ€™s flow.
But whatโ€™s this? The accumulated precipitation in 2026 was actually โ€ฆ not bad? Notice the big jumps at the very beginning of the water year (far left on the graph) and the very end.

A Colorado River glossary and primer — Jonathan P. Thompson


๐Ÿ›ข๏ธย FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIESย ๐Ÿ“ˆ

THE NEWS: Not one, but two natural gas pipelines ruptured and erupted in flames at nearly the same time on opposite sides of New Mexico. One was in the Permian Basin in Lea County, where a gas line ruptured and caught fire, killing two people. Details of the incident have not been released, nor have the names of the victims. The other was near La Boca, New Mexico, just south of the Colorado line (and can be seen in the video above). It shot flames high into the sky and ignited a wildfire.

THE CONTEXT: Several years ago, as the oil boom in the Greater Chaco Region in northwestern New Mexico was nearing its peak, I sat down in the sleek, modern headquarters of the Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s Farmington field office with two BLM officials to talk about the oil boom. Before we got down to business, one of them asked: โ€œShould we show him the scare map?โ€ 

The answer, I guess, was yes, because her colleague handed me the paper showing every well ever drilled in the San Juan Basin, with little red dots for gas, black ones for oil.

It was scary. The northern and central sections of the Basin were almost solid red; in the south and west, dense swarms of black dots strung out along the oil-bearing formations. Dark pinpricks surrounded Chaco Culture National Historical Park. Huerfano Mountain, or Dzil Naโ€™oodilii, where First Woman and First Man and then Changing Woman lived โ€” a sort of Garden of Eden in Navajo cosmology โ€” was embroidered with red and black. The BLM office we sat in, on a fine piece of real estate in the upper-class part of town, has three wells within a quarter mile, and a pumpjack grinds away right next to a golf course green down the road.

To find a stretch of land anywhere in the core of the Basin that hasnโ€™t been drilled or isnโ€™t covered by roads, tanks, pipes or some other hydrocarbon-related infrastructure is nearly impossible โ€” the infrastructure is the landscape. โ€œWeโ€™ve got so much pipeline in the ground, itโ€™s like rebar,โ€ said the official, with a tinge of glee. โ€œIf you had an earthquake, the ground wouldnโ€™t even shake.โ€

The official seemed less disturbed than simply fascinated by this fact, and also didnโ€™t seem bothered that he and his colleagues were facilitating even more infrastructure by handing out drilling permits by the dozen and clearing the way for thousands of new wells and all the roads, gathering systems, and pipelines that go with it. 

The San Juan structural basin is primarily in New Mexico. By US Geological Survey – Assessment of Undiscovered Oil and Gas Resources of the San Juan Basin Province of New Mexico and Colorado, 2002, USGS Fact Sheet FS-147-02, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5749904

I happen to be writing this at a campsite in the heart of the San Juan Basin gas field. While I can gaze out across the landscape and see nothing but beauty, including the eveningโ€™s last light on Dzil Naโ€™oodilii, I am constantly reminded of the ubiquity of the hydrocarbon infrastructure all around me. From just over a little rise comes a slightly squeaky and clanky sound of inadequately lubed bearings, and the low hum and whir of dozens of near and distant pumps and compressors and fans serenades me as I watch the stars unfurl across the big bowl of the sky. 

Thereโ€™s another map of this area thatโ€™s even scarier than the one those folks showed me. It includes oil and gas-related โ€œincidents,โ€ which is to say ruptures and spills and explosions and fires and major leaks. Those, too, are all over the map, and happen with disturbing frequency. Usually theyโ€™re not as dramatic as the two explosions, but they can be harmful: hundreds of gallons of crude oil sloshed onto the ground and into waterways or aquifers, thousands of cubic feet of methane wafting into the air and adding the potent greenhouse gas to the atmosphere.

When I watch the debate over permitting reform, or read the thoughts of the Abundance crowd, a part of me agrees with the credo of building more. The idea of a new New Deal appeals to me, if done right. Line the highways and interstates with high-voltage transmission lines to carry clean energy across the region, build utility-scale solar on reclaimed coal mines and next to old coal plants and on marginal farmland, build factories to manufacture solar panels and batteries. It would create jobs, revitalize economies, and put more clean energy onto the grid. 

Then I hear news about these explosions, look at the oil and gas incident map, and come out here and find that I canโ€™t take a picture of spectacular and sacred landscapes without a tank or well or road or drill pad showing up in it, somewhere. The Abundance folks and the proponents of the permitting reform legislation, or the Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act, want to cover the landscape and our communities with even more of this stuff. While many of them support the bill because it would expedite clean energy development, they donโ€™t mind the fact that it would do the same for natural gas and oil and petroleum pipelines. And, in the social media wars raging over this bill, they discount the concerns of environmental groups worry about the cost we pay when blindly adhering to the credo of Build More Stuff. 

It makes me want to bring these folks out here to the San Juan Basin and take a little walk across this landscape, which is so suffused with beauty, but also cluttered with the detritus of societyโ€™s urge for more, always more.


๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

Angel Peak in the San Juan Basin at sunrise. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

NEWSWIRE: Bipartisan lawmakers drop a โ€œturd grenadeโ€ of a permitting bill on the environmental movement — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification #ClimateChange

High voltage transmission lines, wind turbines, and the full moon near Winslow, Arizona. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 5, 2026

๐Ÿ”ญ OVERSIGHT ๐Ÿ‘ฎ๐Ÿผ

A bipartisan group of federal lawmakers, including Sens. Martin Heinrich (D-NM) and Mike Lee (R-UT), introduced legislation aimed at streamlining and accelerating federal environmental reviews and permitting for major projects on Sept. 30. The Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act would lower or remove regulatory hurdles for large-scale renewable and transmission projects, fossil fuel pipelines, mining projects, and other industrial projects such as data centers and accompanying power facilities.

The push for faster permitting has been in the pipeline for years, and garnered the support of the renewable energy industries and climate advocates in more recent years, after seeing huge transmission projects such as SunZia and TransWest Express languish in red tape for nearly two decades due to potential impacts to wildlife and cultural sites. The lines were purportedly designed to carry renewable energy back and forth across the West to provide whatโ€™s known as โ€œgeographical smoothingโ€ of variable solar and wind resources. These sorts of delays, according to permitting reformists, were stifling the energy transition.

Shortly after the billโ€™s details were made public, ecologically minded environmental groups raised red flags, warning that, as written, the legislation would weaken bedrock environmental laws, including the National Environmental Policy Act and Endangered Species Act, and take away the publicโ€™s power to block or force revisions to projects of all kinds, including ones that will lead to more fossil fuel burning and more greenhouse gas emissions. They pointed out that not only was the notoriously anti-environment Lee sponsoring the bill, but it also had a full-throated endorsement of the American Petroleum Institute.

This triggered a vehement, some might even say toxic, reaction from the climate hawks and Abundance adherents that support reform, and ignited a rhetorical civil war within the environmental movement on social media.

The Abundance movement supports the bill, allying itself with the petroleum and tech industries, because it would make it easier to build large clean energy facilities and the transmission needed to move it around. They are operating on the belief that building more and bigger clean energy projects is the only way to battle climate change โ€” even if it also opens the door to more fossil fuel burning. This theory assumes that the market will favor clean energy projects, even if policy favors โ€œall of the above.โ€ 

Marc Levitt, director of environmental regulatory reform for the Breakthrough Institute, called the bill a โ€œheroic breakthrough for permitting reformโ€ and โ€œa massive down payment towards the energy abundant future that Americans deserve.โ€

Opponents, however, say that pushing energy development of all kinds will not only decimate cultural and natural resources and burden humans and wildlife, but it also will not do much to solve the climate crisis if every new solar array or transmission line is matched with a new natural gas pipeline or power plant. 

โ€œThe permitting deal is a betrayal of public lands, water and wildlife, and environmental justice values that Westerners depend on for clean air and water, places to hike, hunt, and fish, and the inestimable sense of freedom the West provides us all,โ€ said Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center based in New Mexico.

The legislation also raises concerns that the Trump administration could use the legislation to further weaken environmental protections to benefit the fossil fuel, nuclear, mining, and data center industries, while still throwing up roadblocks to solar and wind development.

The Land Desk will have an analysis of the bill and how it might play out on the Land Deskโ€™s beat in the coming days.

๐Ÿ”‹ENERGY TRANSITION ๐Ÿ”Œ
  • California Gov. Gavin Newsom signs legislation allowing residents to install plug-in or balcony solarย without getting utility approval, along with a suite of other bills that should advance the energy transition. (Climate Colored Goggles)
๐Ÿ“ REGULATORY CAPTURE CHRONICLES ๐ŸฆŠ
  • The developer of a proposed pumped hydropower storage project on Black Mesa on the Navajo Nation reportedly tried to pay off, coerce, and bullyย non-profit Tรณ Nizhonรญ รnรญ into dropping its opposition to the project. The group has stood its ground.ย (KNAU)
โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ
  • Advocacy groups file a lawsuit challenging the U.S. Forest Serviceโ€™s and Fish and Wildlife Serviceโ€™s approval of South32โ€™s Hermosa mine expansion onto about 52,000 acres of federal land in the Patagonia Mountains of southern Arizona. The groups accuse the agencies of violating the Endangered Species Act by failing to adequately analyze the projects impacts on threatened wildlife. (Center for Biological Diversity)
๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES
  • Arizona Public Service and the Navajo Transitional Energy Company sign an agreement that could allow the Four Corners coal-burning power plant in northwestern New Mexico to continue operating until 2038,ย seven years later than its scheduled retirement date. APS officials say they need the facility online to meet growing data center-driven energy demand and ensure reliability as grid-battering extreme weather events increase in frequency.ย (Arizona Republic)
  • Tรณ Nizhonรญ รnรญ and San Juan Citizens Alliance file an appeal seeking to block the Interior Departmentโ€™s approval for the expansion and 110-year life extension of the No Name area of the Navajo Mine in northwestern New Mexico.ย The mine feeds the Four Corners Power Plant, which is now slated to close in 2038. โ€œItโ€™s disturbing that a federal agency could fast-track a project of this size and scope with almost no credible review, analysis or public consultation,โ€ said Nicole Horseherder, Tรณ Nizhรณnรญ รnรญโ€™s executive director. โ€œThis permit continues a legacy of corporate interests abusing our resources, tearing up our land, depleting our water and displacing Navajo citizens. Worse still, itโ€™s being done by a Navajo enterprise.โ€ย (news release)
  • State data show theย West Elk coal mine near Somerset, Colorado, is emitting potent greenhouse gas methane and other harmful compounds at nearly four times the permitted rate, spurring environmental groups to call for the mineโ€™s operator to be sanctioned and forced to use the best available technology to slow the leaks.ย (Colorado Sun)
The West Elk coal mine near Somerset in winter. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • Wyoming Gov. Mark Gordon (R) considersย legally challenging a new California law that requires a contentious proposed coal export terminal in Oakland to go through a full environmental impact reviewย prior to local agency approval, potentially stifling Wyomingโ€™s effort to send Powder River Basin overseas via a West Coast port.ย (Cowboy State Daily)
โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ
  • The recent deluges have done a real number on the roads leading into Chaco Culture National Historical Park in northwestern New Mexico.ย The south road, according to the parkโ€™s Facebook page, โ€œis still muddy and slick in places, with patches of deep standing water and wet clay.โ€ Meanwhile, โ€œthe former north road (CR 7950) has sustained catastrophic damage at Escavada Wash. This road is completely inaccessible as an entry point to the park. We expect the repair will take a long time. Please do NOT attempt to enter Chaco from the north road.โ€ย (NPS)
  • Flash flooding washes out sections of the BNSF Railwayโ€™s main line alongside the Rio Puerco near the Arizona-New Mexico border.ย The Rio Puerco lacks reliable streamflow gauges, but the Little Colorado River just downstream from its confluence with the Rio Puerco hit an astounding 6,800 cubic feet per second during the late-September storms in a place that is normally virtually dry. (Navajo Times)
๐ŸŸ COLORADO RIVER CHRONICLE ๐Ÿ’ง
  • Reduced water releases from Glen Canyon Dam diminish the Colorado Riverโ€™s flows in the Grand Canyon,ย which in turn affects recreation, river ecology, and tribal nationsโ€™ sacred places.ย (High Country News)
๐Ÿฆซ WILDLIFE WATCH ๐Ÿฆ…
  • A bear wanders into the Aspen farmers market and starts chowing down, apparently unfazed by the high prices.ย Things like this look cute, but it can end up being deadly for the bear.
๐Ÿชฆ OBITUARY ๐Ÿœ๏ธ
  • Ken Sleight, the inspiration for Seldom Seen Smith in Edward Abbeyโ€™s theย Monkey Wrench Gang, died on Oct. 2 in Moab. Sleight was a river-runner, canyon lover, and lifelong protector of and advocate for Utahโ€™s โ€œStanding Up Country.โ€ โ€œWe just lost such a wonderful person,โ€ John Weisheit, director of Living Rivers and friend and mentee of Sleightโ€™s, told The Salt Lake Tribune. โ€œWe need more Ken Sleights, not less.โ€ย (Salt Lake Tribune)
๐Ÿ“– READING ROOM ๐Ÿง

The New Yorker has again ventured into the Four Corners Country, this time with a story by Peter Hessler about the Million Dollar Highway between Silverton and Ouray, โ€œone of Americaโ€™s scariest roads.โ€ I always enjoy Hesslerโ€™s writing, whether about Cairo or Nucla, and this storyโ€™s no exception. His descriptions of the many accidents and ensuing rescues on that stretch of road are vivid and, yes, scary. And his history of the area and Otto Mears, the roadโ€™s original builder, is compelling. But I have to take issue with the framing of the story, and the headline, which is: โ€œWhy doesnโ€™t anyone want to fix one of Americaโ€™s scariest roads?โ€ To which Iโ€™d respond: Does it really need fixing?

Look, traversing Red Mountain Pass can be daunting, especially during the spring freeze-thaw cycle when rocks are dislodged from the cliffs and tumble down onto the asphalt and the Mother Clineโ€™s human-sized icicles hang perilously over the pavement.Sometimes folks tragically go over the edge. Several plow drivers have perished on the road after getting pummeled by the Riverside Slide. In 1963, Reverend Marvin Hudson and his two teenaged daughters were hit by the Riverside, swept into the gorge, and buried (oddly, Hessler leaves this story, one of the most nerve-chilling, out of the story). This problem has been largely solved by simply shutting the road when danger is high. 

So sure, the road can be dangerous and nerve-racking, but frankly, I can think of plenty of far scarier โ€” and statistically more dangerous โ€” stretches of road. Highway 550 between Albuquerque and Bloomfield is a virtual carnage factory, especially when the oil and gas fields are busy with water and oil-hauling trucks. Highway 191 between Monticello and Moab is super sketchy โ€” and deadly. Or how about I-10 in the Phoenix area, I-40 just about anywhere, or I-70 dropping from the mountains into the Coloradoโ€™s Front Range on a weekend afternoon?

Back in the late 1980s, Colorado spent about a half-billion dollars to โ€œfixโ€ I-70 through Glenwood Canyon. Now itโ€™s the site of multi-vehicle accidents, rockslides, debris flows, and not infrequent closures due to the above. So, yeah, Red Mountain Pass doesnโ€™t need fixing. People just need to slow the hell down and pay attention.


Another control day — Jonathan P. Thompson


GarCo Report: Commissioners hear updates on election, water, AI and budget — The Sopris Sun #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Shoshone Falls hydroelectric generation station back in the day via USGenWeb

Click the link to read the article on The Sopris Sun website (Amy Hadden Marsh). Here’s an excerpt:

October 7, 2026

Representatives of the Colorado River Water Conservation District (CRWCD) presented a detailed update about West Slope water, Shoshone water rights and more. Taking a look at water conservation proportionality, Lindsay DeFrates, CRWCD public information officer, later told The Sun that the CRWCD believes that proportionality is critical as the state investigates how to implement the Contribution Program, which allocates Coloradoโ€™s share of federal money awarded to the Upper Basin states to conserve water. โ€œIt will pay people to use less water,โ€ she said.ย  At Mondayโ€™s meeting, CRWCD General Manager Andy Mueller expressed concern regarding the disproportionate impact of water conservation on western Colorado agriculture. โ€œIf you donโ€™t have state laws requiring proportionality from all Colorado River users, meaning the Front Range as well, all of that water not only comes off the West Slope, it comes out of West Slope [agriculture],โ€ he said.

Coloradoโ€™s conservation goal is 100,000 acre-feet of water. โ€œIf all of that comes out of West Slope [agriculture], thatโ€™s a big hit to our local economies, to our small towns, to our agricultural industry, and it may be just the beginning of what we view as a permanent program,โ€ Mueller added. 

As for the Shoshone water rights issue, CRWCDโ€™s Strategy Chief Amy Moyer told the BOCC that the purchase price is $99 million and all but $1.6 million has been raised from the CRWCD, the federal government and state and local governments, including $3 million from Garfield County. โ€œOur plan is to continue working with communities up and down the river,โ€ Moyer said. โ€œBut we may want to sit down with you as we look to close that $1.6 million gap.โ€

Getches-Wilkinson Center: The Colorado River Upper Initial Units Take Center Stage — Eric Kuhn, Anne Castle, Jack Schmidt, Kathryn Sorensen, Katherine Tara

Flaming Gorge Dam: USBR

Click the link to read the report on the Getches-Wilkinson Center website (Eric Kuhn,*ย Anne Castle,โ€ ย Jack Schmidt,โ€กย Kathryn Sorensen,ยงย Katherine Tara**). Here’s the Introduction:

October 6, 2026

SUMMARY OF KEY POINTS

  • In 1956, Congress authorized the Upper Initial Unitsโ€”Flaming Gorge Reservoir, Navajo Reservoir, and the Aspinall Unit (UIUs)โ€”for a variety of water use purposes in the Upper Colorado River Basin, including compliance with the 1922 Colorado River Compact (1922 Compact). The historical record is clear that the primary reason these reservoirs exist is to satisfy the math of the 1922 Compact and the obligations it imposed on the Upper Division States regarding flows at Lee Ferry.
  • The size and operation of the UIUs was based on the math of the river as we understood it from the 1930s through the mid-1950s (natural flows, projected uses, and the drought of record). This math no longer works. Total water use in the Colorado River Basin has consistently exceeded the available supply since 2000. Until this fundamental problem is solved, releasing water from the UIUs only delays necessary permanent reductions in water use and provides some degree of temporary management flexibility.
  • The 1948 Upper Basin Compact contemplates delivery of a required quantity of water at Lee Ferry. Article V gives the Upper Colorado River Commission (UCRC) the authority to allocate the capacity of the UIUs between providing water for use within the Upper Division States and providing water for common benefit purposes (delivering water to Lee Ferry). The policy has always been that 100% of the capacity of Navajo Reservoir is allocated for water use in New Mexico and 100% of the capacities of Blue Mesa and Flaming Gorge Reservoirs is allocated for common benefit purposes.
  • There is no doubt that Flaming Gorge and Blue Mesa Reservoirs exist to meet a portion of the obligation of the Upper Division States under Article III of the 1922 Compact. As of October 1, 2026, the ten-year Lee Ferry flow will be about 81.2 million acre-feet (MAF), and under the Lower Division Statesโ€™ interpretation of the 1922 Compact, the Upper Division States may be in a compact deficit by 800,000 acre-feet (or more).
  • Yet over 2.0 MAF of water remains in active storage in Flaming Gorge Reservoir; more than enough water to erase the deficit and put the Upper Division states back in compact compliance as interpreted by the Lower Basin, if only for the short term.
  • The Upper Division States assert that they are in full compliance with the 1922 Compact.ยน Thus, in their view, delivering additional UIU water to Lee Ferry now would be a waste of stored water that they may need in the future. They question why yet another reservoir should be further drawn down when the Basin has not solved the fundamental problem of demand exceeding supply.
  • The stored water available in Flaming Gorge Reservoir has increased in importance to the entire basin. The Lower Division states view it as a source of water that can be delivered at Lee Ferry to supplement the releases from Lake Powell and thereby fulfill the obligations of the Upper Division States under the 1922 Compact. The Bureau of Reclamation is using Flaming Gorge as a source of water to protect critical infrastructure at Glen Canyon Dam, including hydropower generation. The Upper Division States view Flaming Gorge as a source of water for their current and future benefit; the water stored there could be used to comply with an adverse decision by a court or Special Master.
  • There remain unresolved issues concerning the use of water stored in the UIUs, with seemingly conflicting provisions in the 1948 Upper Basin Compact and the 1970 Long-Range Operating Criteria that currently govern the operation of these reservoirs. These issues could govern future releases from the UIUs but have not been explicitly addressed in the Post-2026 Record of Decision or the 2027-2028 Operating Rules.
  • The math of the 1922 Compact and its Lee Ferry flow provision, together with the directives of the Long-Range Operating Criteria, can no longer be reconciled with todayโ€™s hydrology and long-term average basin-wide consumptive use. The Basin States can argue about compliance with various conflicting provisions, but the fundamental problem is that the rules were designed for a different river. We need new operating rules that reflect the river we have today. The choice in finding these new rules is likely to be between a compromise that is painful to all parties or a zero-sum Supreme Court decision that determines who gets what little water there is and who does not.

INTRODUCTIONยฒ

The 1956 Colorado River Storage Project Act (1956 CRSPA)ยณ authorized construction of Glen Canyon Dam, which created Lake Powell, and three additional major upstream storage projects; Flaming Gorge Dam and Reservoir, Navajo Dam and Reservoir, and the Curecanti Unit (Blue Mesa, Morrow Point, and Crystal Dams and Reservoirs, now called the Aspinall Unit). The 1956 CRSPA was designed as a broad authorization for Upper Basin water development within the bounds of the 1922 Compact. The legislation authorized construction of storage dams, powerplants,โด numerous irrigation projects, and trans-basin diversions. Among the purposes of 1956 CRSPA were โ€œregulating the flow of the Colorado River, storing water for beneficial consumptive use, making it possible for the States of the Upper Basin to utilize, consistently with provisions of the Colorado River Compact, the apportionments made to and among them in the Colorado River Compact and the Upper Colorado River Basin Compact, respectively . . ..โ€โต Flaming Gorge, Navajo, and the Aspinall Unitโถ are collectively referred to as the โ€œUpper Initial Unitsโ€ (hereafter, UIUs). The three UIUsโ€™ total live storage capacity is 6.15 million acre-feet (MAF), of which 5.10 MAF is โ€œactiveโ€ storage.โท On October 1, 2026, the total live storage in the three reservoir systems was 3.47 MAF. The Appendix contains a detailed description of each of the UIUs, with information on capacity, operations, and contract obligations.

For over 60 years, the three UIUs have been storing system water and producing hydroelectric power. These reservoirs, however, previously played a relatively small role in the operation of federal reservoirs of the Colorado River Basin (Basin) as a whole. The focus of the Basinโ€™s competing interests has primarily been on operation of Glen Canyon Dam and Hoover Dam that form Lake Powell and Lake Mead, respectively. These two reservoirs are the largest in the United States and presently store approximately 66% of all the water in the 12 federal reservoirs reported in Reclamationโ€™s 24-Month Studies. During the debate and development of major policy actions for the Colorado River, such as the 1970 Coordinated Long-Range Operating Criteria,โธ 2001 Interim Surplus Guidelines,โน and the 2007 Interim Guidelines,ยนโฐ the operations of the UIUs were barely mentioned. However, as storage in Lake Powell and Lake Mead has declined, the importance of the UIUs has increased.

The Bureau of Reclamation (Reclamation) operates each of the three UIUs under separate Records of Decision (ROD). Each is operated in a manner that balances many competing interests such as: storage for 1922 Compact compliance, the delivery of stored water for Upper Basin consumptive uses, the delivery of water in fulfillment of Tribal water right settlement obligations, flood control, hydropower generation, on-reservoir recreation, downstream river recreation, sport fisheries in the reservoir and in the stream below the reservoir, and the flow needs of threatened and endangered fishes. Reclamation operates the UIUs in a transparent manner, and each has a local constituency that is closely involved in how their project is operated.

The UIU obscurity honeymoon ended in 2019 when the Upper Division States proposed what became the Drought Response Operations Agreement (DROA) as a component of their 2019 Drought Contingency Plan.ยนยน Arguably, under federal law, the Secretary of the Interior (Secretary) has broad authority to unilaterally move water from the UIUs downstream to Lake Powell. However, Reclamation took a more collaborative approach in the DROA: it was an inter-governmental agreement among the US (through Reclamation) and the states of Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming. DROA authorized releases from the UIUs to the extent necessary to achieve the stated operational objective of minimizing the risk of Lake Powell falling below a target elevation of 3525 ft, and thereby:

  • helping to ensure the Upper Division States will continue fulfilling their interstate water compact obligations while exercising their rights to develop and utilize the Upper Basinโ€™s Compact apportionment,
  • maintaining the ability to generate hydropower at Glen Canyon Dam, and
  • minimizing adverse effects on resources and infrastructure in the Upper Basin.ยนยฒ

DROA is subject to numerous constraints, including:

  • Water available in the UIU reservoirs,
  • Protection of authorized purposes of each CRSP unit (water supply, endangered species, recreation, hydropower, etc.),
  • Consultation with the Upper Division States and the Upper Colorado River Commission, and
  • Operating criteria established in the agreement and the associated Records of Decision.

In 2021, a total of 181,000 acre-feet of DROA releases were planned pursuant to the Secretaryโ€™s emergency authority: 125,000 acre-feet from Flaming Gorge, 36,000 acre-feet from Blue Mesa, and 20,000 acre-feet from Navajo. Due to dry conditions, the 20,000 acre-feet release from Navajo Reservoir was cancelled, resulting in a total release of 161,000 acre-feet.ยนยณ DROA was implemented again in 2022 pursuant to consultation and agreement with the Upper Division Statesโ€”approximately 463,000 acre-feet of water from Flaming Gorge Reservoir were released. Both releases were intended to help maintain an operational target elevation of 3525 ft in Lake Powell.ยนโด The DROA water released from Flaming Gorge Reservoir and Blue Mesa Reservoir in 2021 and 2022 was completely recovered after the moderately wet winter of 2023.ยนโต DROA includes specific provisions addressing storage recovery after a DROA release is made. DROA expires contemporaneously with the 2007 Guidelines, but operations to recover storage releases made before Oct. 1, 2026, continue for as long as necessary.ยนโถ

In response to the near-record low 2026 runoff and the unprecedented low reservoir levels in Lake Mead and Lake Powell, DROA releases were again implemented to supplement Lake Powell levels, and this time with even greater urgency and impact. To help maintain the elevation of Lake Powell above 3500 ft, on April 23, 2026, Reclamation began making additional DROA releases from Flaming Gorge Reservoir.ยนโท According to the September 2026 24-Month Study, the planned release from Flaming Gorge will total one million acre-feet between April 2026 and April 2027, but Reclamation retains the flexibility to adjust the timing and amount based on actual hydrologic conditions. Citing contractual obligations and unusually low storage, there are no planned DROA releases scheduled for 2026 from either Blue Mesa Reservoir or Navajo Reservoir.ยนโธ

As annual Colorado River Basin runoff in the 21st century is consistently lower than in the 20th century and the โ€œRatchet Effectโ€ is evident in reservoir storage basin-wide, disputes over the operation of the UIUs between the Upper Division States and Lower Division States have increased and indeed now are nearly as critical and strident as the disputes over water deliveries from Lake Powell to Lake Mead.ยนโน The Lower Division Statesโ€™ May 1, 2026, Proposal for Short-Term Operations of the Colorado River included proposed operating criteria for the UIUs that would expand their role in maintaining Lake Powell elevations and effectively subordinate the refilling of the UIUs until there is sufficient water in Lake Powell to support the delivery of 8.23 MAF per year.ยฒโฐ The stated intent is โ€œto share the benefit of improved hydrology between both basins.โ€ยฒยน On May 13th, 2026, the director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources told the Arizona Re-Consultation Committee that under Arizonaโ€™s interpretation of the Law of the River, the 1956 CRSPA specifically subordinates the delivery of contract water from the UIUs and the refilling of those reservoirs to water deliveries to the Lower Basin and Mexico under the 1922 Compact.ยฒยฒ

The Upper Division States believe the operation of the UIUs proposed by the Lower Division States is outside the scope of the Post-2026 NEPA process and cannot be incorporated into the Record of Decision as part of the 2027โ€“2028 operations plan.ยฒยณ Further, some UCRC commissioners pointed out that under the 1956 CRSPA, there are multiple purposes of the UIUs including supporting consumptive uses within the Upper Basin.ยฒโด At the 2026 Getches-Wilkinson Center Conference on the Colorado River, then-Acting Reclamation Commissioner Scott Cameron noted that Reclamation would aggressively operate the UIUs under their RODs to help manage Lake Powell levels, but added that the Secretary has, and will use, if necessary, emergency authorities to operate the UIUs outside the bounds of their RODs.ยฒโต

The Record of Decision (ROD) released on August 21, 2026, for the “Decision Framework for Colorado River Guidelines: Coordinated Operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead (2027โ€“2036)” addressed the operation of the UIUs in a general manner. The ROD states:

โ€œIn carrying out the Decision Framework, the Department will continue to coordinate the operation of Lake Powell, Lake Mead, and the Colorado River Storage Project (CRSP) Upper Initial Units โ€“ specific reservoirs above Lake Powell โ€“ pursuant to Section 602 of the Colorado River Basin Project Act of 1968 (CRBPA). Consistent with each facilityโ€™s existing ROD, the CRSP Upper Initial Units remain an operational tool available to the Secretary, when necessary, to release additional water to increase the elevation at Lake Powell to protect critical Federal infrastructure.โ€ยฒโถ

While the Decision Framework Operational Sideboards of the ROD include the โ€œPotential for maximum use of CRSP Upper Initial Units within their respective RODs to release additional water if needed to protect critical infrastructure,โ€ they also allow for greater releases than described in their respective RODs:

“The Decision Framework establishes consultation thresholds associated with critical reservoir elevations. When projected reservoir conditions approach or fall below the consultation thresholds identified in the operational sideboards, the Secretary will coordinate and consult with the Basin States, Basin Tribes and other affected parties, as appropriate, regarding additional operational actions that may be appropriate to reduce risks to critical Federal infrastructure and maintain system reliability.ยฒโท”

Further, โ€œSuch consultations may include consideration of additional reductions in water use, adjustments to coordinated reservoir operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead, use of the CRSP Upper Initial Units, or other operational actions.โ€ยฒโธ

Notably, the Decision Framework does not mention using the UIUs for making deliveries of water to Lee Ferry when there is insufficient water in Lake Powell for compliance with the 1922 Colorado River Compact (1922 Compact).

UIU storage recovery timing and amounts are not specified in the 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines,ยฒโน but Interiorโ€™s response to the Lower Basinโ€™s May 1st proposal stated that it:

“intends to refill the UIUs as soon as practicable to ensure water remains available for any additional infrastructure protection releases, while avoiding further risk to critical infrastructure during recovery operations. Based on prior operational experience, recovery operations were initiated once Lake Powell was no longer projected to continue declining. Reclamation would apply a similar approach for future UIU recovery operations and would consider actual hydrology and Basin-wide conditions before initiating recovery actions.ยณโฐ”

What is clear is that the water stored in the UIUs is an increasingly important resource coveted by the Upper Division States, the Lower Division States, Basin Tribes,ยณยน and Reclamation. It is also clear that each of these entities has a different perspective on the priorities under which the UIUs will be operated in the future. But it is important to recognize that while the water released by the UIUs in 2021, 2022, and 2026 provided critical benefits, especially for maintaining Lake Powell above target thresholds, DROA-like releases are not a solution to the Basinโ€™s fundamental problem โ€“ systematic use of more than the available water supply. The operation of the UIUs may buy time and provide additional flexibility for reservoir system management, but it does not create any new water.

The debate over the future use of the UIUs has also exposed and amplified several long-standing disputes over the interpretation of the key provisions of the Law of the River,ยณยฒ and ambiguities in the major federal legislation that authorized the construction and operation of the riverโ€™s major federal reservoirs. A primary disputed issue facing the Colorado River Basin today is how much water must flow at Lee Ferry to satisfy the Upper Division Statesโ€™ 1922 Compact obligations. As stated above, delivering water to Lee Ferry was a core purpose for both Lake Powell and the three UIUs.ยณยณ

On August 24, 2026, the state of Nevada, the Colorado River Commission of Nevada, and the Southern Nevada Water Authority filed a complaint for declaratory action and injunctive relief requesting a declaration that the ROD, Final Environmental Impact Statement, and 2027-2028 Guidelines are in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and the Law of the River.ยณโด The complaint requests an injunction halting the implementation of the ROD and Operating Guidelines. Among other arguments, the plaintiffs claim that the Secretary failed to consider the exercise of authority to operate the UIUs in compliance with the Law of the River and NEPA.

The ROD states that the UIUs will be the subject of a new DROA agreement (referred to as a โ€œframeworkโ€) that is currently being negotiated among Reclamation and the Upper Division States. This proposed agreement, drafts of which have not been released to the public, has already received criticism from the State of Arizona. If finalized, it could also be the subject of future litigation.ยณโต In the remainder of the paper, we explore the history of the UIUs from their conception to the present day to provide context and rationale for future operations.


*ย Retired General Manager, Colorado River Water Conservation District.

โ€ ย Senior Fellow, Getches-Wilkinson Center, University of Colorado Law School; former US Commissioner, Upper Colorado River Commission; former Assistant Secretary for Water and Science, US Dept. of the Interior.

โ€กย Center for Colorado River Studies, Utah State University; former Chief, Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center.

ยงย Director of Research, Kyl Center for Water Policy, Arizona State University; former Director, Phoenix Water Services.

**ย Staff Attorney, Utton Transboundary Resources Center, University of New Mexico.

1 The position of the Lower Division States is that the Upper Division States must not deplete the ten-year flow at Lee Ferry below 75 MAF PLUS deliver half of the annual treaty delivery to Mexico. The normal treaty delivery is 1.5 MAF, so the total ten-year delivery obligation could be 82.5 MAF. In recent years, under Minutes 323 and 330, the annual delivery has been less, but because these Minutes also create water that Mexico can store โ€“ calculating how much delivery the Upper Division States must share is not a simple matter. In any event, however, it appears that 81.2 MAF is less than the required 10-year flow pursuant to the Lower Division Statesโ€™ legal position.

1 The Upper Division States do not agree that their obligation to Mexico under Article III(c) of the 1922 Compact is half of the annual delivery to Mexico under the 1944 Treaty every year. For more information, see Eric Kuhn, et. al, The 1922 Compact is Now the Obvious Elephant in the Negotiating Room, Oct. 6, 2025, https://www.colorado.edu/center/gwc/media/707.

2 This paper describes the authorization of the UIUs, the events leading up to that authorization, and some of the debate that resulted in the compromises in the 1956 Colorado River Storage Project Act (1956 CRSPA). The authors recognize that there are several detailed histories of CRSPA that address different aspects of its origins and come from a different perspective. Among these are: MARC REISNER. CADILLAC DESERT: THE AMERICAN WEST AND ITS DISAPPEARING WATER (1986, Viking Press); M. HARVEY, A SYMBOL OF WILDERNESS: ECHO PARK AND THE AMERICAN CONSERVATION MOVEMENT (Univ. N.M. Press 1994, 2nd Ed. Univ. of W.A. Press, 2000). Recognizing the value and insights of these previous works, this paper seeks to place the UIUs and their origins within the context of todayโ€™s hydrology and disputes.

3 P.L. 84-485, 70 Statute 105, 43 U.S.C. ยง 620 et seq.

4 The provision of hydroelectric power and resulting revenues prompted the label โ€œcash register damโ€ to refer to projects in which the hydropower receipts finance other project construction. Long-Term Drought and Glen Canyon Dam: Potential Effects on Water Deliveries and Hydropower, Congressional Rsch. Serv., Apr. 4, 2023, at 4.

5 1956 CRSPA Preamble.

6 The three reservoirs in the Aspinall Unit are Blue Mesa, Morrow Point, and Crystal. Only Blue Mesa is operated for river regulation and storage. Future references to storage in the UIUs include Blue Mesa, Flaming Gorge and Navajo Reservoirs, but not Morrow Point and Crystal Reservoirs. A number of additional reservoirs were authorized by the 1956 CRSPA (and subsequent federal legislation) as components of participating projects. All of these reservoirs have specific project functions. Several of these reservoirs store a significant amount of water. Strawberry Reservoir, a component of the Central Utah Project, McPhee Reservoir, a component of the Dolores Project, and Fontanelle Reservoir, a component of the Seedskadee Project are three prominent examples.

7 The data sources for this paper are primarily the Hydrologic Database (HDB) and the 24-Month Studies, both maintained or prepared by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. We use โ€œlive storageโ€ to mean the amount of storage reported in the HDB or alternately, the 24-Month studies. The standard terminology for reservoirs is that live storage is the amount that can be physically withdrawn or released downstream. Active storage is the amount above the power plant penstocks (or primary outlet works for Navajo Reservoir). Inactive storage is the amount between the power plant inlets, and the low-level outlet works. Below the low-level outlet is the โ€œdead pool.โ€ In theory, live storage = active plus inactive storage. In practice, however, each reservoir has a different design and different management issues. It is possible that some live storage may not be accessible for downstream delivery and use. The figures provided for live and active storage in the UIUs do not include Crystal and Morrow Point reservoirs.

8 For more information on the 1970 Long Range Operating Criteria, see https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/pao/pdfiles/opcriter2005FRN.pdf.

9 The Colorado River Interim Surplus Criteria were adopted in 2001, but were superseded by the 2007 Interim Guidelines, see https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/surplus/pdf/Attachments/Attachment_I.pdf.

10 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Colorado River Interim Guidelines for Lower Basin Shortages and the Coordinated Operations for Lake Powell and Lake Mead, December 2007, https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/programs/strategies/RecordofDecision.pdf.

11ย U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2019 Drought Response Operations Agreement, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/dcp/droa.html.

12ย DROA, Sec. I.A.

13ย Upper Colorado River Commission (UCRC) Seventy-Third Annual Report (2022), pages 16-17.

14 UCRC Seventy-Fourth Annual Report (2023), page 15. With the DROA releases, Lake Powell reached a low of 3519.92 ft. (MSL), in early April 2023.

15 UCRC Seventy-Fifth Annual Report (2024), page 15. With an estimated natural flow of 17.3 MAF, 2023 was the third wettest year since 2000. We refer to it as a moderately wet year based on comparisons with the 20th Century record. With a natural flow of 17.3 MAF, it is about the same as the ten-year average from 1980-1989 โ€“ 17.2 MAF. USBR natural flow database, https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/NaturalFlow/index.html.

16 DROA, Sec. II.A.6.

17 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2026 Drought Response Operations Plan, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/documents/dcp/DROA/2026/uc-2026droughtresponseoperationsplan-attachmentsa-h-508-20260423.pdf. Two measures were put in place to maintain the elevation of Lake Powell above 3500 ft. The 1.0 MAF of DROA releases and a reduction of the Water Year 2026 annual release from Glen Canyon Dam from 7.5 MAF to 6.0 MAF.

18 Id.

19 For an explanation of the Ratchet Effect, see Schmidt et al., The Colorado River Water Supply Crisis in a Few Graphs: Part 1 at 8 (June 2026), https://www.colorado.edu/center/gwc/2026/06/18/colorado-river-water-supply-crisis-few-graphs-part-1.

20 Lower Division Statesโ€™ Proposal for Short-Term Operations of the Colorado River, May 1, 2026, https://www.azwater.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/2026.05.01%20LB2YearPlanFINAL.pdf.

21 Memo from John Entsminger to Andrea Travnicek, Subject: Lower Division Statesโ€™ Proposal for 2026โ€“2028 Colorado River Operations, Dated May 1, 2026.

22 AWDR presentation at the ARC Meeting May13, 2026, slide #9, https://www.azwater.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/2026.05.13%20ARC%20Meeting%20%2313%20FINAL_0.pdf.

23 Letter from UCRC Executive Director Cullom to Acting Commissioner Cullom, dated June 1, 2026, http://www.ucrcommission.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/UDS-response-to-BOR-response-to-LB-concept-June-1-2026.pdf.

24 Comments of the individual UCRC commissioners at the April 26, 2026, special meeting of the UCRC where it reluctantly approved the DROA plan.

25 Scott Cameron, Bureau of Reclamation presentation, 2026 GWC Conference, https://www.colorado.edu/center/gwc/2026/06/04/june-4-5-2026-conference-colorado-river.

26ย U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Record of Decision, Framework for Colorado River Guidelines: Coordinated Operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead (2027-2036) August 2026, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/post2026/decision-doc/P26_RecordofDecision_Final.pdf.

27ย ROD at 30.

28ย ROD at 27, 30.

29 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/post2026/decision-doc/2027-2028OperatingGuidelines_Final.pdf.

30 Department Response to Lower Division Statesโ€™ Proposal for 2027-2028 Colorado River Operations, May 28, 2026.

31 The Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, Southern Ute Indian Tribe, Jicarilla Apache Nation, and Navajo Nation each have significant and unique interests in the operation of Navajo Reservoir. The Ute Indian Tribe of the Uintah and Ouray Reservation has asserted claims to water stored in Flaming Gorge Reservoir.

32 The Law of the River is a complex set of agreements, treaties, court decisions, and regulations that govern the allocation and use of water resources in the Colorado River Basin. A Colorado River Overview: Education, Facts & Statistics, https://coloradoriver.com/statistics-facts/.

33 1956 CRSPA, supra note 3.

ยณโด Nevada v. Burgum, et al, U.S. District Court, District of Nevada, Case 2:26-cv-02665, filed 08/24/2026. See also, https://mavensnotebook.com/2026/08/25/courthouse-news-nevada-files-suit-over-colorado-river-plan/; https://www.gov.nv.gov/press-releases/nevada-files-lawsuit-against-department-of-the-interior-over-colorado-river-operations-record-of-decision.

ยณโต The term โ€œframeworkโ€ to describe the new DROA was used by the UCRC at its Sept. 15, 2026, Special Meeting. The comments by Tom Buschatzke were made at the August 24, 2026, meeting of the Arizona Reconsultation Committee.

How a century-old pricing system has emptied the #ColoradoRiver: An absurdity of the Colorado River crisis is the role of heavy government subsidization of agricultural water use — Daniel M. Frey (BigPivots.com) #COriver #aridification

Colorado River near Burns. Photo credit: Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Daniel M. Frey):

October 5, 2026

While fighting over water rights and priorities might take decades, the federal government can start aligning what agriculture pays for federal delivery with what municipal users already pay โ€” without waiting for a new compact or a courtroom fight over title.

We are told that nothing can be done about the Colorado River water crisis while officials allow powerful agricultural interests to keep using more of the river for hay and alfalfa than all cities and other industries in the basin combined.

In the Lower Basin, agricultural water districts pay roughly 6% of what municipal utilities pay at wholesale. That pricing perpetuates waste and low-value irrigation, discourages conservation, and undermines any real chance of restoring the riverโ€™s supplies.

Part I of this series (see โ€œAbsurdity of the Colorado River crisis,โ€ Big Pivots, Aug. 30, 2026) showed that nearly half the water put to human use in the Colorado River Basin goes to growing feed for cattle โ€” alfalfa, hay and silage โ€” while 40 million people depend on the same river for drinking water.

That is not a hydrology problem. It is a political one, built on the doctrine that the oldest water right always wins, no matter how the world around it has changed.

This installment goes one layer deeper, into the accounting. The story of the Colorado River is not only about who has the legal right to water. It is about how government pricing, contracts, and cost-shifting have supported overuse on low-value crops.

The volumes restated

Forage crops โ€” mostly alfalfa and hay grown to feed livestock โ€” consume close to half of all water used by people across the Colorado River Basin. In 2023, two separate studies by the Western Agricultural Economics Association and the Arizona Department of Agriculture (see Sources) concluded that in the Lower Basinโ€™s desert valleys, a substantial share is shipped overseas: up to 30% of Imperial Valley alfalfa and more than a fifth of Arizonaโ€™s hay.

In the Upper Basin, including Colorado, forage crops make up roughly 90% of agricultural irrigation, more than three times what Upper Basin households, businesses and industries consume combined. The degree and complexity of irrigation and infrastructure vary across the upper and lower basin. There are small farms and communities that have closely and carefully integrated water with highly efficient and effective irrigation.

It should also be understood that many farms and ranches in the Colorado River Basin, particularly in the Upper Basin, do not depend upon federal-financed infrastructure. This essay is not about them. Rather, it is about both farms and cities who benefit from federal infrastructure. Cities that are home to millions of people are asked to justify every toilet flush and lawn sprinkler while a crop with a modest market value drains the river. That imbalance might be easier to defend if the irrigators paid a market price. Instead, Lower Basin irrigation districts pay about 6% of what cities pay at wholesale.

How the government built โ€” and then discounted โ€” this system

Almost none of the infrastructure that makes Southwestern irrigation possible was built or paid for by farmers alone. The dams, canals, and reservoirs of the Colorado River system were constructed and financed by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, a Department of the Interior agency that has spent more than a century as the largest wholesaler of water in the country.

Under federal reclamation law, the government fronts the capital, and the beneficiaries โ€” irrigation districts, cities, power customers โ€” are supposed to pay it back over time.

Political power derailed equitable pricing during this past century. Reclamation law splits repayment onto two tracks. Municipal and industrial water is repaid over roughly 40 to 50 years โ€” with interest. Irrigation costs are repaid over the same window โ€” interest-free.

Congress wrote the interest-free exemption into the original Reclamation Act of 1902 to spur Western settlement. Homesteaders on arid land had no way to finance dams and canals themselves. Lawmakers reasoned that irrigated farms would eventually generate enough tax base and repayment to justify the up-front public investment.

Cities were not part of that original calculation. Municipal and industrial water became an authorized Reclamation purpose only in 1939, and it was placed on the standard interest-bearing track. The exemption made sense when the goal was populating an unsettled frontier. It has been revisited many times since โ€” always to loosen it โ€” but never ended for a basin now serving forty million urban residents.

That alone would be a meaningful subsidy. It gets larger. Reclamation law also lets irrigation districts apply for โ€œability to payโ€ relief. That economic review can cut a districtโ€™s repayment obligation below its actual share of construction costs if the government decides the district cannot afford the full amount or that the land is not productive enough to justify full-cost pricing. When those obligations go unpaid, the shortfall does not vanish. It is folded into what other customers pay โ€” chiefly hydropower sales and, on some projects, municipal and industrial users. Cities are not just paying full freight for their own water. On many federal projects, they and power customers are backstopping agricultureโ€™s unpaid balance, too.

In the Colorado River Basin alone, the federal government has put more than $8 billion, in unadjusted dollars, into three programs: Hoover Dam and the All-American Canal, the Colorado River Storage Project and the Central Arizona Project. Compounded at 4.6%, roughly what cities have paid to borrow over the past century, $8 billion would be worth more than $75 billion today. The power and municipal shares of those costs carry interest; the irrigation share does not. The financing model was never hidden. The Storage Project โ€” Glen Canyon, Flaming Gorge, Navajo, and the Aspinall Unit โ€” was promoted in the 1950s on the promise that power and municipal features would be repaid with interest and irrigation would not. Hydropower revenue from those dams still covers irrigation costs judged to be beyond farmersโ€™ ability to pay.

At that rate, repaying a construction cost interest-free over 50 years wipes out about 60% of its value compared with what municipalities pay. Add debt forgiveness, stretched repayment periods and โ€œability to payโ€ relief, and the discount grows: economist Richard Wahl found that once interest was counted, irrigators repaid only about fourteen cents of every dollar of irrigation construction costs.

What this looks like in dollars

The gap is not subtle. A December 2025 report from the UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability and the Natural Resources Defense Council analyzed 217 water transactions across the Lower Basin states. The report found that agricultural water districts pay a weighted average of about $30 per acre-foot, while municipal utilities pay about $512.

An acre-foot is 326,000 gallons, enough to supply two to three households for a year. Under this system, a hay farmerโ€™s district pays about $30 and a utility serving a family in Phoenix or San Diego pays roughly $500 โ€” before treatment and local delivery. That is seventeen times as much for the same unit of a scarce public resource.

Federal repayment terms are only one reason for that gap. Under Western water law and most federal contracts, the water itself is essentially free; prices reflect the cost of storing, moving, and treating it, and city systems carry heavier pumping and treatment costs. However, the federal subsidy is part of the gap the public has financed directly โ€” and the part of Washington can most readily change.

Some agricultural districts, including Californiaโ€™s Imperial Irrigation District, the single largest holder of Colorado River water rights, pay the Bureau of Reclamation nothing at all for the water itself. Their contracts do not require payment for the raw supply. When the federal government paid for that same district in 2023 to leave water in Lake Mead, the contract rate was about $776 an acre-foot. The district had asked for as much as $840. Everyone involved already knows what the water is worth.

Who holds the cheap water โ€” 20 large corporate farms

A 2023 ProPublica and Desert Sun investigation found that just twenty large farming entities in Californiaโ€™s Imperial Valley received roughly one-seventh of the entire lower Colorado Riverโ€™s flow in 2022. That is more water than Wyoming, New Mexico, or Nevada each use in a year.

The water right itself is held by the Imperial Irrigation District, a public agency. Those entities are the largest users of that right, not its owners. As a whole โ€” historic farm families, outside investors, institutional landholders and at least one foreign hay company receives 97% of IIDโ€™s water. Every home, school and business in the county combined receives 3%.

Cheap irrigation water is not propping up the rural economy. Imperial County sits on some of the most heavily and cheaply irrigated farmland in the country, yet its per capita income in 2021 was about $19,000 โ€” half the national figure of about $38,000, according to Census Bureau estimates. It posted the highest unemployment rate in California that year.

A 2024 peer-reviewed study of agricultural water productivity across the Colorado River Basin found that the least economically productive counties consume 25% of the Basinโ€™s agricultural water to generate just 3% of its crop revenue. Heavily discounted water is not building broad rural prosperity. Where it produces high value, as in Imperial County, that value is concentrated in a small number of landholders; where it does not, it props up low-value production.

Run the counterfactual. If those same operations paid municipal-scale wholesale rates โ€” $300 to $500 an acre-foot instead of $20 to $30 โ€” the economics of growing export-bound cattle feed in a desert would collapse on their own, without a single acre-foot needing to be fought over in court. Water would move toward higher value uses because it would finally cost what it is worth. That is what a functioning price signal does. Right now, the federal government is underwriting the draining of the river for cheap crops and powerful agricultural interests.

Immediate action does not require new water-rights litigation

The most common argument against fixing this is that it would take years. Because water rights are property, this argument holds, any change must move through negotiation, buyouts, and courts.

That is true if the goal is changing who legally owns the water. It is not true if the goal is changing who pays for the infrastructure that delivers it.

Cost allocation is an administrative and budgetary process, not a property right. The Bureau of Reclamation and the Interior Department already have the statutory tools to reassess โ€œability to payโ€ determinations on a going-forward basis, to stop extending new construction-cost discounts to districts irrigating low-value forage crops, and to fully enforce the Reclamation Reform Actโ€™s full-cost pricing for large landholdings. Congress, which wrote the interest exemption into law, can require interest-bearing repayment in new and renegotiated contracts.

Those are the same terms municipal and industrial users already face. Existing repayment contracts cannot simply be rewritten in midstream; they run until they expire or are mutually amended. None of that touches a single farmerโ€™s decreed water right. It stops asking cities and power customers to keep underwriting the next generation of discounts for overuse on low-value crops.

That change would not resolve the Colorado River crisis itself. But it would start doing what a century of โ€œfirst in time, first in rightโ€ has never done: make the cost of water reflect its scarcity. It would let price โ€” not another emergency federal curtailment โ€” begin moving water toward its most essential uses.

Why hasnโ€™t it happened?

The authority sits with the Department of the Interior and the Bureau of Reclamation, which set repayment terms and administer ability-to-pay determinations under reclamation law. Legislative jurisdiction belongs to the House Natural Resources Committeeโ€™s Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries and the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committeeโ€™s Subcommittee on Water and Power. Reclamationโ€™s annual budget is funded through the Energy and Water Development appropriations subcommittees in both chambers โ€” not the Interior-Environment subcommittees, whose jurisdiction excludes the Bureau of Reclamation.

The last time Congress meaningfully touched this structure was the Reclamation Reform Act of 1982. Even that act left interest-free repayment and ability-to-pay intact while expanding the size of farms eligible for subsidized water. Since then, as reservoirs have fallen toward dead pool and the federal government has spent billions on emergency conservation payments and drought relief, no bill addressing the underlying interest-free, cost-shifted pricing structure for Colorado River irrigation has reached a committee markup, let alone the floor of either chamber. A review of Congress.gov and GovTrack through August 2026 found none.

The leverage is not confined to a handful of committee chairs in Washington. It runs through the states that depend on the river. Of the 14 U.S. senators representing the Basinโ€™s seven states, seven sit on the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, which has direct jurisdiction over the Bureau of Reclamation and reclamation law:

Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.); Sen. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.), also on the Water and Power Subcommittee; Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), committee chairman; Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), ranking member; Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.), also on Water and Power; Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.), also on Water and Power; and Sen. Alex Padilla (D-Calif.), also on Water and Power.

In the House, 11 basin-state representatives sit on the Natural Resources Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries: Chair Harriet Hageman (R-Wyo.), Tom McClintock (R-Calif.), Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.), Celeste Maloy (R-Utah), Jeff Crank (R-Colo.), Melanie Stansbury (D-N.M.), Dave Min (D-Calif.), Adam Gray (D-Calif.), Luz Rivas (D-Calif.), Julia Brownley (D-Calif.) and Joe Neguse (D-Colo.). Jared Huffman (D-Calif.), ranking member of the full committee, serves ex officio.

Four basin-state members โ€” Ken Calvert (R-Calif.), Celeste Maloy (R-Utah), Mike Levin (D-Calif.), and Susie Lee (D-Nev.) sit on the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Energy and Water Development, which writes Reclamationโ€™s budget every year.

According to the same review, none of these lawmakers, of either party, has introduced legislation addressing the interest-free, ability-to-pay repayment structure at the center of this piece. The people with the most direct stake in the outcome โ€” whose constituents are either the cities paying full price or the districts paying a fraction of it โ€” already hold seats on every committee with the authority to change it.

The hard conclusion

This complicated system of senior rights and subsidies, built and protected for a hundred years, leads to an unavoidable conclusion. Under the banner of property rights and support for agriculture, we have allowed a small number of large, politically connected agricultural users to capture much of the water that forty million people depend on.

Almost half of the water put to human use across seven states, from the high Rockies to California, has been turned to private benefit for irrigation of low-value crops, to the detriment of everyone else in the region. Having secured water rights at no cost and federal infrastructure at a steep discount, those same users are demanding to be paid top dollar โ€” more than $800 an acre-foot โ€” to leave that water in the river.

None of this is a call to end Western agriculture or to strip farmers and ranchers of property they hold in good faith. It is a call to stop asking the public to underwrite, at steadily mounting costs, a pricing structure that a small number of landholders have had a century to defend and a well-organized lobby to protect. The technical authority to change the next round of contracts and ability-to-pay reviews already exists inside agencies Congress funds every year. Using that authority still takes political will the basinโ€™s own delegation has not yet shown.

Taking on powerful agricultural interests requires action from representatives of the forty million people who need a sane and sustainable water policy.

Daniel Frey is a Boulder resident, non-practicing CPA and Certified Energy Manager (CEM). He researches and writes on energy and sustainability issues.

Sourcing for essay

Series

Frey, Daniel M. โ€œAbsurdity of the Colorado River crisis.โ€ Big Pivots, Aug. 30, 2026. bigpivots.com/the-absurdity-of-the-colorado-river-crisis/ [Part I of this series]

Water use and forage crop exports

Richter, Brian D., et al. โ€œNew Water Accounting Reveals Why the Colorado River No Longer Reaches the Sea.โ€ Communications Earth & Environment, vol. 5, 2024, article 134. [source for forage cropsโ€™ share of basin water consumption and the Upper Basin 90% figure]

Sall, Ibrahima, Russell Tronstad, and Chia Yi Chin. โ€œAlfalfa Export and Water Use Estimates for Individual States.โ€ Western Agricultural Economics Association, 2023. waeaonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Alfalfa-Export-and-Water-Use-Estimates-for-Individual-States.pdf [state-level alfalfa export shares and water embedded in exports, 2022]

Frisvold, George, and Dari Duval. โ€œUnderstanding the Economics of Arizona Alfalfa.โ€ University of Arizona Department of Agricultural & Resource Economics, via Arizona Farm Bureau, June 26, 2023. azfb.org/Article/Understanding-the-Economics-of-Arizona-Alfalfa [source for exports equal to 22% of Arizona hay and forage production in 2022]

Yachnin, Jennifer. โ€œCan Alfalfa Survive a Fight Over Colorado River Water?โ€ E&E News by Politico, Sept. 8, 2023. eenews.net/articles/can-alfalfa-survive-a-fight-over-colorado-river-water/ [source for up to 30% of Imperial Valley alfalfa exported, citing Family Farm Alliance data]

Water pricing and cost allocation

Garrison, Noah, Isabel Friedman, and Mark Gold. Free Water While It Lasts: An Analysis of Wholesale Water Pricing in the Lower Colorado River Basin States. UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability & Natural Resources Defense Council, Dec. 11, 2025. ioes.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/Water-Pricing-Report.pdf

Griffiths, Claire. โ€œReport Puts Numbers on Massive Gap in Water Costs in the West.โ€ UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability, Dec. 11, 2025. ioes.ucla.edu/article/report-puts-numbers-on-massive-gap-in-water-costs-in-the-west

โ€œColorado River Water Is Too Cheap, Particularly for Agricultural Users.โ€ Inside Climate News, Dec. 11, 2025. insideclimatenews.org/news/11122025/colorado-river-water-too-cheap/

Mendoza, Katya. โ€œUCLA Report Finds Farmers Pay Far Less Than Cities for Colorado River Water.โ€ AZPM, Dec. 16, 2025. azpm.org/s/102329-ucla-report-finds-farmers-pay-far-less-than-cities-for-colorado-river-water/

โ€œCalifornia Cities Pay a Lot for Water; Some Agricultural Districts Get It for Free.โ€ CalMatters, Dec. 11, 2025 (also republished by U.S. News & World Report). calmatters.org/environment/2025/12/price-of-california-water-cities-growers/

Voice of San Diego. โ€œHow Imperial Valley Spends San Diegoโ€™s Cash for Water.โ€ Nov. 2, 2023. voiceofsandiego.org/2023/11/02/how-imperial-valley-spends-san-diegos-cash-for-water/ [source for San Diegoโ€™s ~$730/acre-foot wholesale price vs. Imperialโ€™s $20]

The 2023 Imperial Irrigation District conservation payments

โ€œThe Colorado Riverโ€™s Biggest User Will Conserve Some Water in Exchange for Federal Dollars.โ€ KPBS Public Media, Dec. 5, 2023. kpbs.org/news/environment/2023/12/05/the-colorado-rivers-biggest-user-will-conserve-some-water-in-exchange-for-federal-dollars [source for the $776/acre-foot payment rate]

Stanford University Water Programs. โ€œColorado River Allocation.โ€ water.stanford.edu/research/projects/colorado-river-allocation [source for the up-to-$840/acre-foot figure from the 2023-2026 System Conservation Implementation Agreement]

Land, water rights and county-level economics

Wilson, Janet, and Nat Lash. โ€œThe Historic Claims That Put a Few California Farming Families First in Line for Colorado River Water.โ€ ProPublica / The Desert Sun, Nov. 9, 2023. propublica.org/article/california-farm-families-gained-control-colorado-river

Lash, Nat, and Janet Wilson. โ€œThe 20 Farming Families Who Use More Water from the Colorado River Than Some Western States.โ€ ProPublica / The Desert Sun, Nov. 9, 2023. projects.propublica.org/california-farmers-colorado-river/ [source for the twenty entities and their 2022 water use]

Frisvold, George B., and Jyothsna Atla. โ€œAgricultural Economic Water Productivity Differences Across Counties in the Colorado River Basin.โ€ Hydrology, vol. 11, no. 8, 2024, article 125. doi.org/10.3390/hydrology11080125

U.S. Census Bureau. American Community Survey (ACS), 1-Year Estimates, Table B19301 (โ€œPer Capita Income in the Past 12 Monthsโ€), 2021. data.census.gov [national and Imperial County per capita income figures]

Reclamation law, repayment structure, and federal cost allocation

Congressional Research Service. โ€œBureau of Reclamation Project Authorization and Financing.โ€ CRS In Focus IF10806, Congress.gov. congress.gov/crs-product/IF10806

Congressional Research Service. โ€œBureau of Reclamation Support for Water Storage Projects.โ€ CRS Report R47987, Congress.gov. congress.gov/crs-product/R47987

U.S. Government Accountability Office. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: Availability of Information on Repayment of Water Project Construction Costs Could Be Better Promoted.โ€ GAO-14-764, 2014. gao.gov/assets/gao-14-764.pdf

U.S. Government Accountability Office. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: Reclamation Law and the Allocation of Construction Costs for Federal Water Projects.โ€ GAOREPORTS-T-RCED-97-150. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-T-RCED-97-150/html/GAOREPORTS-T-RCED-97-150.htm

U.S. Government Accountability Office. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: Information on Allocation and Repayment of Costs of Constructing Water Projects.โ€ GAOREPORTS-RCED-96-109, 1996. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-RCED-96-109/pdf/GAOREPORTS-RCED-96-109.pdf

Wahl, Richard W. Markets for Federal Water: Subsidies, Property Rights, and the Bureau of Reclamation. Resources for the Future, 1989. [source for irrigatorsโ€™ repayment share once interest is counted]

Congressional Research Service. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: History, Authorities, and Issues for Congress.โ€ CRS Report R46303, April 3, 2020. congress.gov/crs-product/R46303 [1939 authorization of municipal and industrial water; history of repayment changes]

U.S. General Accounting Office. โ€œPower Marketing Administrations: Cost Recovery, Financing, and Comparison to Nonfederal Utilities.โ€ GAO/T-AIMD-96-169, Sept. 19, 1996. govinfo.gov/app/details/GAOREPORTS-T-AIMD-96-169 [WAPA required to recover about $1.5 billion in irrigation construction costs through power rates]

Reclamation Reform Act of 1982. Pub. L. No. 97-293, tit. II, 96 Stat. 1263.

Federal investment in Colorado River projects

Central Arizona Project. โ€œExplaining CAPโ€™s Federal Repayment: A Cheat Sheet.โ€ Know Your Water News, May 13, 2020 (updated March 8, 2023). knowyourwaternews.com/explaining-caps-federal-repayment-a-cheat-sheet/ [$4.4 billion total cost, 1973-93; $1.646 billion repayment obligation]

U.S. Census Bureau. โ€œSeptember 2025: Hoover Dam.โ€ Stories From the Census Bureauโ€™s History, Sept. 1, 2025. census.gov/about/history/stories/monthly/2025/september-2025.html [$165 million authorized for Hoover, Imperial Dam, and the All-American Canal; power revenue repaid Hooverโ€™s cost with interest by 1987]

Stene, Eric A. โ€œThe All-American Canal: Boulder Canyon Project.โ€ Bureau of Reclamation History Program. usbr.gov/projects/pdf.php?id=80

U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. โ€œColorado River Storage Project.โ€ Upper Colorado Basin Region. usbr.gov/uc/rm/crsp/index.html [Basin Fund repayment of irrigation costs beyond ability to pay]

U.S. General Accounting Office. โ€œFederal Electric Power: Information Concerning the Colorado River Storage Project.โ€ GAO/RCED-90-2FS, Oct. 3, 1989. gao.gov/products/rced-90-2fs

Upper Colorado River Commission. The Colorado River Storage Project to Build a Stronger America. Promotional booklet, 1950s. Colorado River Compact Collection, Utah State Archives. images.archives.utah.gov/digital/collection/p17010coll70/id/21155/

Congressional committee jurisdiction and membership

U.S. House of Representatives, Office of the Clerk. โ€œCommittee on Natural Resourcesโ€ and โ€œSubcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries,โ€ 119th Congress. clerk.house.gov/committees/II00 and clerk.house.gov/committees/II13

U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources. โ€œRules, Membership, and Jurisdiction of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources.โ€ S. Prt. 119-13, March 2025. congress.gov/committee-print/119th-congress/senate-committee-print/59371

U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources. โ€œSubcommittee on Water and Powerโ€ membership list. energy.senate.gov/water-power

Heinrich, Martin, and Mike Lee. โ€œHeinrich, Lee Announce Subcommittee Assignments for 119th Congress.โ€ U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Feb. 11, 2025. energy.senate.gov/2025/2/heinrich-lee-announce-subcommittee-assignments-for-119th-congress.

U.S. House Committee on Appropriations. โ€œInterior, Environment, and Related Agencies (119th Congress)โ€ and โ€œEnergy and Water Development, and Related Agencies (119th Congress),โ€ membership rosters. appropriations.house.gov and democrats-appropriations.house.gov

U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations. โ€œSubcommittee on Energy and Water Development.โ€ appropriations.senate.gov/subcommittees/energy-and-water-development

Note: Committee chairs, ranking members, and subcommittee rosters reflect the 119th Congress (2025-2026) as of this writing and are subject to change with reassignments, retirements, or a new Congress. The claim that no relevant bill has reached committee markup reflects a review of the sources above and standard legislative trackers (Congress.gov, GovTrack) as of late August 2026, not an exhaustive search of every bill introduced in the 119th Congress; readers relying on this claim for further reporting should verify independently. All committee membership and pricing figures should be verified at their original sources before publication or reproduction.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Unexpected voices in the national #climate debate: A few paragraphs in a #Meeker newspaper triggered a legal brief supporting #Boulder in Supreme Court case heard on Monday — Allen Best (BigPivots.com)

Suncor refinery Commerce City. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

October 6, 2026

Four paragraphs buried in a story published by the Meeker Herald-Times during mid-June triggered the entry of several Colorado ranchers into the Boulder-Suncor case argued on Monday morning before the U.S. Supreme Court.

The Herald Times is the newspaper of record (and the only one) in Rio Blanco County, which is in the stateโ€™s northwestern corner. Itโ€™s distinctly rural. Cattle numbers vary by season, somewhere between 16,000 and 25,000. In all seasons they outnumber humans: 6,529 as of the 2020 census.

The newspaper story recounted a June 9 meeting of county commissioners. They heard about agrivoltaics from Longmontโ€™s Byron Kominek (Jackโ€™s Solar Garden) and their county attorney advised them on best legal procedures for setting meeting agendas. The new Colorado State University County extension agent had stopped by to say hello, and the state transportation director for the region delivered an update on highway plans.

In the storyโ€™s 32nd paragraph, news was delivered that the county commissioners had agreed to participate in an amicus brief in the Supreme Court case siding with Suncor and Exxon Mobil at a cost to the county up to $17,500.

โ€œThe outcome of this decision by the Supreme Court will affect 100 other cases across the United States, so we felt that it was well worth our time and money to try and do the right thing,โ€ explained Commissioner Doug Overton of why Rio Blanco County should add its name to the filing by the Associated Governments of Northwest Colorado.

Deirdre Macnab later read that story at her nearby ranch along the White River. She had a different and visceral reaction as to what constituted the โ€œright thingโ€ in this case.

Unlike many of her neighbors in Rio Blanco County, who have family trees several generations deep, she had arrived in 2020 from Florida and, before that, Manhattan. She has her own Wikipedia entry, which describes her as an โ€œAmerican womenโ€™s rights and voting rights activist and sustainable agriculture rancher.โ€

Macnab decided other voices were needed from Rio Blanco County in this case.

โ€œI called Boulder County and spoke to some of the attorneys there,โ€ she related in a noon-hour session with students at the University of Colorado Law School on Oct. 1. โ€œWould you be interested in hearing from some of the people who are involved in agriculture in the state?โ€ she asked. Yes, they said.

โ€œAnd it wasnโ€™t very difficult to find a number of ranchers.โ€

One rancher, a veterinarian, lives near Grand Junction, Macnab told the audience in Boulder, speaking from a remote source.

โ€œShe is currently selling her herd of cattle because it does not make financial sense to try to feed her cattle hay through the winter because the heat and the drought this year was so extreme that she was not able to grow the forage that she usually grows. Weโ€™re seeing hay prices that have increased by more than 50%. This is just one example of many ranchers that Iโ€™ve spoken to.โ€

Another among her agricultural acquaintances, she said, has pigs near Hayden. โ€œHe said his pigs were dying of sunstroke, and he was facing the decision of having to go out of business because for the first time he was having to haul water at a cost of $2,000 to $3,000 a month.โ€

Meeker and other parts of the Western Slope have been warming at a faster rate than Colorado altogether. And Colorado, of course, has warmed rapidly in the last 125 years, particularly during the last 25. A map posted on the Colorado State Universityโ€™s Colorado Climate Center website tells the story of temperature increases from 1895 to 2025 in shades of pink, orange and red. Far western Colorado from the San Juans north to Wyoming โ€” including both Grand Junction and Rio Blanco County โ€” is deep red.

Macnab began her comments to the law students with a description of the two wildfires in 2025 that afflicted Rio Blanco County. The Lee, the fifth largest in Coloradoโ€™s recorded history, and the Elk together covered more than 137,000 acres.

โ€œI have a neighbor rancher,โ€ said Macnab. โ€œHe had 60 cows that burned to death. I had another neighbor and close friend whose entire ranch burned, and she nearly lost her house. There were flame marks on her house. A number of ranchers lost miles and miles of fence.โ€

Kathleen Kelley in June explained to visitors the devastation of the Lee Fire of the previous summer. Photo/Allen Best

That good friend who nearly lost her house and a great deal of fence, too, was Kathleen Kelley. Kelley had grown up in Meeker and had been ranching since the 1980s, as her father had before.

Like Macnab, Kelley differs from many other ranchers in the White River Valley, where Meeker is located. She drives an electric car. As for the house that didnโ€™t burn, it had triple-pane windows, a rarity everywhere, more costly but more energy efficient. In this case, the triple panes prevented heat from exploding the windows and allowing the flames to leap into the house.

Kelley was unusual in other ways, too. When still in her 20s, she had been elected a Colorado state legislator, the youngest ever female to do so. Now in her 70s, she retired earlier this year after a 20-year stint as a teacher in Meeker. She contributed an essay to Big Pivots in September after the death of Windell Berry. It can be found here.

Being retired, she told Big Pivots, she feels more freedom โ€” and responsibility to speak out. She has had many opportunities in recent months. It began in an account in the The Denver Post last year about the fire. Then, earlier this year, the Trump administration refused funds to aid the ranchers of Rio Blanco County, an apparent case of spite against Colorado. An enterprising New York Times reporter, who had grown up in Colorado Springs, contacted her, resulting in a story in that newspaper this summer.

In recent weeks, she has in turn been contacted first by a reporter from Colorado Newsline and then by other reporters from Los Angeles to Washington D.C. They want to know about her involvement in the lawsuit. Recent days brought more mentions in publications such as Mother Jones and Grist.

Kelley was interviewed by a radio station in Boston in a report that was broadcast on Monday. The radio station also interviewed a county commissioner in Mesa County, which is on the other side of this fence.

These inquiries were not the result of a PR machine. Rather, it appears to have been a case of journalists reading each othersโ€™ stories. And it happened very, very quickly..

โ€œI have been involved in a lot of grassroots efforts, but this one was was the least orchestrated one I have ever seen,โ€ she said. It was, she added, not a message massaged by an advocacy group, but rather a group of ranchers saying what they had to say.

โ€œFor Colorado ranchers, climate change is not an abstract possibility, but a lived reality that is threatening the economic viability of a way of life that has been central to communities for generations,โ€ says the amicus brief that was filed on behalf of the ranchers.

The PIceance Basin in Rio Blanco County was full of drilling rigs in 2007 when gas prices reached $14/million Btu before tumbling rapidly as the recession arrived. Photo/Allen Best

The brief filed on behalf of Rio Blanco County โ€” the government, not the handful of ranchers โ€” also includes seven other Western Slope counties: Archuleta, Delta, Grand, Garfield, Mesa, Montezuma, and Montrose. That brief argues that the economic interests of the counties would be harmed because they depend upon oil and gas extraction. In Montezuma County (Cortez), between 40% and 50% of county tax revenue has historically come from oil-and-gas production,โ€ the brief says. โ€œThe potential impacts of this litigation on those counties are staggering.โ€

A clear exception is Grand County, which has virtually no oil and gas extraction. (This writer used to live there). Apparently, Grand County is just along for the ride.

The Suncor-Boulder case fundamentally involves climate change, although the specific question before the Supreme Court is over jurisdiction. Boulder and Boulder County (and on the coattails, San Miguel County) sued Suncor and ExxonMobil in 2018, claiming monetary damages resulting from warming and other climate changes caused by greenhouse gas emissions. It cites floods, heat and drought.

This filing was in Colorado courts. The fossil fuel companies tried to get the case moved to federal court, but the Colorado Supreme Court ruled in 2025 that the state courts do have jurisdiction. Suncor, ExxonMobil and their supporters want the Boulder case โ€” and dozens of others like it from elsewhere in the country โ€” decided in federal courts.

Lawyers from the law school in Boulder at the noon session last Thursday sorted through the legal twists and turns of this case in the noon-hour session. Itโ€™s complicated.

โ€œYou may be experiencing what Iโ€™m experiencing, which is kind of a Kafka-esque disorientation of confusion,โ€ said Chris Winter, executive director of the Getches-Wilkinson Center at the University of Colorado Law School. The federal government, he said, wants to have it both ways. It is arguing that this is a federal case while it also says it has no statutory authority to regulate greenhouse gas emissions under the Clean Air Act.

โ€œSo thatโ€™s awfully confusing. Iโ€™m confused. I know a lot of you are confused as well.โ€

The New York Times, in a report published Sunday, said critics had called the federal governmentโ€™s position a paradox. โ€œThe federal government is trying to get out of the business of regulating greenhouse gases, while also saying it has sole authority to regulate greenhouse gases.โ€

Confusion continued into Monday morningโ€™s two-hour hearing before the Supreme Court. The Times reported that at least two justices admitted to being confused at various junctures in what the newspaper described as a โ€œcomplex dispute.โ€

The question arose whether the federal government could have it both ways. โ€œAs I understand it, the EPA has disclaimed the power to regulate greenhouse gases,โ€ said Justice Neil Gorsuch. The Wall Street Journal also reported that questions from Chief Justice John Roberts suggested an openness to Boulderโ€™s argument.

That leaves open some potential for a 4-4 vote next year, which would leave the case in the Colorado Supreme Court. Justice Samuel Alito announced on Sept. 28 that he would not participate because of his ownership of stock in oil and gas companies. In the case of a tie, Boulder would win the question of jurisdiction, leaving the case in Colorado.

The decision will likely not be delivered until next June, possibly July, according to the national reporters who camp out at the Supreme Court.

โ€œThe argument was harder to read than most,โ€ said the Timesโ€™ Adam Liptak. โ€œThe three Democratic appointees were likely votes for Boulder, and Justice Kavanaugh was adamant in his support for the energy companies. But the remaining Republican appointeesโ€™ questions were more mixed, and Boulder needs only one of their votes to prevail in light of Justice Alitoโ€™s recusal.โ€

But, once again, itโ€™s a complex case deep into the legal weeds.

In question, at least in part, is whether this case has parallels with the litigation against a handful of tobacco companies in the 1990s that ultimately yielded a $206 billion settlement. In this case, though, the sources of emissions are much more diffuse โ€“ and importantly, global. Too, as Gale Norton, a former attorney general in Colorado (and interior secretary in the Bush administration) told the New York Times, fossil fuels have benefited people broadly. The same claim for tobacco is a much more difficult case to make.

Bloomberg, in an Oct. 1 story, said that climate suits, unlike the tobacco suits, have had trouble getting off the ground. The Supreme Court closed one avenue, ruling unanimously in 2011 that states cannot invoke federal law to force utilities to cut greenhouse gas emissions.

Boulder has tried a different approach, filing in state law and using traditional tort doctrines in arguing the oil companies misled the public about the risks of climate change while simultaneously contributing to the problem by producing and promoting fossil fuels.

The Wall Street Journal, in an editorial, took a dim view of Boulderโ€™s case. Boulder, it said, โ€œcannot supplant Congressโ€™s power to regulate commerce among the states. Tolerating Boulderโ€™s raid would blow the Constitutionโ€™s doors open to laws like those in New York and Vermont that seek to raid U.S. oil and gas producers for alleged damages caused by global CO2 emissions.โ€

William Barr, the former attorney general, had something similar to say in a guest commentary in the same publication under the headline: โ€œBoulder Has No Business Making Foreign Policy.โ€

Boulderโ€™s suit, wrote Barr, โ€œasks a state court to impose potentially enormous liability on selected American energy companies for their alleged contribution to a worldwide phenomenon. Yet the overwhelming share of the conduct at issue lies beyond not only Coloradoโ€™s borders but Americaโ€™s.โ€

The U.S. Constitution, he said, does not allow state and local governments to make that kind of judgement.

These legal abstractions were largely absent in the remarks of Boulder and Boulder Count officials after the oral arguments before the Supreme Court. Instead, Mayor Aaron Brockett issued a statement that talked about โ€œhotter summers and extreme heat, to drought, declining snowpack, worsening wildfire risk and devastating fires. And every time those impacts intensify, our community pays,โ€ he said.

At her 2,000-acre ranch near Meeker, Kelley on Sunday pondered what connected her and the other ranchers who had filed the brief in August. Jay Fetcher, who has been profiled in Big Pivots, has a ranch northwest of Steamboat Springs, where he has continued the observations of his father, who since the late 1940s began noting the date of the last snow on the ranch. Snow has disappeared earlier over the decades โ€” especially so this year. See: โ€œAlong the Elk River, earlier springs and more uncertainty.โ€

Cattle far outnumber people in Rio Blanco County, and when water is available โ€” as it obviously was on this pasture near Meeker in August โ€” the meadows can turn vibrant green. Photo/Allen Best

Another rancher, Mike Callicrate, lives in Evergreen but was a bull rider in his younger days and married a Kansas farm girl and has feedlots there. He has an opinionated website called nobull.mikecallicarte.com, where he inveighs against the โ€œoligarchs and multinational corporationsโ€ of our food system.

The common theme among these and others who signed onto the brief, said Kelley, was a belief in regenerative agriculture.

Last week, reviewing the filings with the Supreme Court in this Boulder-Suncor case, Kelley noticed the date the oil companies had asked the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case โ€” arguing that Colorado had no jurisdiction: Aug. 8, 2025.

That same day, she said, she and her family were evacuated a second time because of the Lee Fire, leaving her to wonder whether they would have a house to which they could return.

โ€œOn one hand these guys are evading responsibility and on the other hand is my family not knowing whether we will be able to afford the impacts of the Lee Fire on our property.

Kelley confides that she rarely cries, but she did when she saw that date.

โ€œThat was like a two-by-four with nails.โ€

Supreme Court wrestles with who should pay for #ClimateChange: The Supreme Court’s decision on a #Colorado lawsuit could shape dozens of efforts to make fossil fuel companies pay for #climate damages — Austin Corona (Grist.org)

Click the link to read the article on the Grist website (Austin Corona):

October 6, 2026

The Supreme Court opened its 2026-2027 term Monday with a climate case: a lawsuit brought by Boulder, Colorado, against ExxonMobil and Suncor, a Canadian oil company, over the costs of a warming planet. The case is one of dozens across the country in which local governments have sued fossil fuel companies for their role in driving climate change and are seeking compensation as they now deal with its effects. The Supreme Courtโ€™s decision could decide the fate of all those other cases and the idea that oil companies must pay for the damages their products caused.

The justices gave no clear signs of how the court will rule, but over the course of two hours of questioning, they did demonstrate unison on one point: It is a hard and consequential task to identify who is legally liable for the impacts of climate change. 

Although Boulderโ€™s case was first filed in Colorado courts, oil and gas companies asked the Supreme Court to step in, arguing that important climate change matters shouldnโ€™t play out at the state level. Instead, they say, the issue belongs to Congress and the White House. Boulder wants the court to send the case back to Colorado, where it can proceed. 

Eight justices โ€” Justice Samuel Alito removed himself from the case โ€” attempted repeatedly to cast the case into something legible and simple. Multiple times, justices from both sides of the ideological spectrum asked attorneys, โ€œWhy make this argument so complex?โ€ Yet they seldom openly agreed on what the simpler argument would be. The consequences for oil companies weighed heavily on some parts of the discussion, while the consequences for communities dealing with a warming planet went largely unexplored.

Some judges attempted to describe it as a case about reducing emissions โ€” a framing that aligns closely with what ExxonMobil and Suncor argue. If Boulderโ€™s case is an attempt to reduce greenhouse gas emissions through state court, it opens the possibility that a state court could police activity all over the country, and even the world. No state law could be appropriate to apply to the cumulative impact of global pollution, the companies argue.

โ€œThis case involves an unprecedented effort to use state law to regulate global conduct,โ€ said Kannon Shanmugam, the attorney representing oil companies.

Several justices seemed to agree with that general picture. Kavanaugh said he could see no difference between allowing a state court to order oil and gas companies to pay damages for climate-related harms and allowing a state to effectively regulate greenhouse gas emissions all over the world. He told Boulderโ€™s attorney, Kevin Russell, that he was downplaying the effect this case could have on oil companies, arguing it could โ€œbankruptโ€ some of them. In his closing arguments, Shanmugam reinforced the idea that the chaotic consequences of the case could reach the scale of climate change itself. 

โ€œBoulder could tag me โ€ฆ when I am in Colorado in two weeks and sue me on a nuisance claim for refilling my car and thereby contributing to global climate change,โ€ he said. 

Marshall Fire December 30, 2021. Photo credit: Boulder County

Ironically, these questions were far from what Boulder claimed it wanted to do with its case. The city hasnโ€™t asked to stop companies from producing oil and gas, or to stop those who burn them from sending greenhouse gases into the atmosphere. Rather, it wants oil companies to pay for deceiving the public into thinking those products werenโ€™t producing large-scale harms through climate change. 

Justice Elena Kagan argued Boulderโ€™s case was similar to suits that states brought against cigarette companies in the 1990s, seeking compensation for health care costs linked to tobacco consumption. The companies werenโ€™t required to stop selling cigarettes, but to roll back their pro-cigarette marketing and fund awareness campaigns around the effects of smoking.

โ€œThis is not an effort to reduce emissions,โ€ said Russell. โ€œUnder our deception theory, they can continue to produce as much fossil fuels as they like and contribute to as much air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions as the market will bear when consumers are properly informed about the consequences of that decision.โ€

โ€œIt doesnโ€™t prohibit them from engaging in the conduct. It requires them to internalize a portion of the cost of their activities by paying for some of the damage,โ€ Russell said later.

Kavanaugh called Russellโ€™s phrasing โ€œcavalier,โ€ saying that those costs could be significant to oil and gas companies. Some firms, including Suncor, have told their shareholders the accumulating climate cases against them could affect their bottom lines. 

An Exxon gas station lies only blocks from the Supreme Court building on Massachusetts Avenue in Washington, D.C. Exxon Mobil is one of the defendants in Boulderโ€™s climate case. The Heritage Foundation, a conservative think tank, looms behind the station. Austin Corona / Grist

If the case is allowed to proceed in Colorado courts and Boulder wins, it could open the floodgates for other cases, Shanmugam argued: โ€œMore [suits] are being filed by the week โ€ฆ so given the extraordinary magnitude of these cases, where, in each of these cases, plaintiffs are seeking billions of dollars of damages, we need an answer to this question sooner rather than later.โ€

Justices typically hear opening arguments and ask questions at the beginning of the courtโ€™s term and then take months before publishing a decision. This thread was only one of several they teased apart during the arguments, including arguments over statesโ€™ regulatory authorities under the Constitution and the intent of the Clean Air Act. Judges could use a range of rationales for their ultimate ruling, each of which would affect other climate suits against oil companies differently because those suits depend on different legal bases.

โ€œStates and local governments are trying to recoup costs related to harms from climate change in a lot of different types of lawsuits,โ€ said Erika Kranz, an attorney with Harvard Law Schoolโ€™s environmental and energy law program. Whether these other cases โ€œrun into trouble will depend on how justices write their decision.โ€

Itโ€™s also possible justices send the case back to Colorado, either by deciding the Supreme Court isnโ€™t the right place for it or by voting 4-4, which would leave Boulder able to carry on with its state-level lawsuit. (Alito has not explained why he removed himself from the case, though he has faced accusations that his investments in oil and gas companies not related to the case made his participation inappropriate.)

Kranz and Chris Winter, executive director of the Getches-Wilkinson Center at the University of Colorado Law School, said itโ€™s hard to know whether that emphasis showed the court was leaning toward the oil companies, but it suggested that at least some justices were deeply concerned about the caseโ€™s potential financial consequences for the industry.

Boulderโ€™s lawyers must now convince them that this risk to oil and gas companies was beside the point, Winter said. To do that, Boulder will have to overcome justicesโ€™ claims that itโ€™s trying to reduce emissions through the court.

โ€œThereโ€™s a lot of concern from the oil industry, from corporate actors, and from the conservative justices about the significant consequences of these cases,โ€ Winter said. โ€œOne way to get at that is to equate this case with previous cases, which were much more directly about regulation of pollution.โ€

Colorado statewide annual temperature anomaly (ยฐF) with respect to the 1901-2000 average. Graphic credit: Colorado Climate Center

U.S. Supreme Court justices appear skeptical of allowing Boulder climate lawsuit to proceed: Case could be turning point in efforts to hold fossil fuel industry accountable — Chase Woodruff (ColoradoNewsline.com) #ClimateChange

An aerial view of a Boulder County neighborhood that burned in the Marshall Fire, on Dec. 31, 2021. (Hart Van Denburg/CPR, pool)

Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Newsline websilte (Chase Woodruff):

October 5, 2026

The U.S. Supreme Courtโ€™s conservative majority Monday appeared broadly sympathetic to fossil fuel companiesโ€™ argument that allowing two Colorado local governments to sue them over climate change in state court would be a โ€œrecipe for chaos.โ€

Attorneys for both sides in Suncor v. Boulder, along with the Trump administration, presented oral arguments in a two-hour hearing, the first of the Supreme Courtโ€™s 2026-27 term. The case originated in Colorado in 2018, when Boulderโ€™s city and county governments sued Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy, seeking monetary damages under state tort law for their role in contributing to climate change.

Despite being filed eight years ago, the case has yet to proceed to trial, as the fossil fuel companies have repeatedly tried to have it dismissed or moved to federal court by arguing that the Constitution and federal clean-air laws preempt such state-level proceedings.

As justices waded into a thicket of jurisdictional issues raised by Suncor and Exxon when they petitioned the nationโ€™s highest court to weigh in last year, Chief Justice John Roberts noted the โ€œpractical matterโ€ of what could happen nationwide if Boulderโ€™s case is allowed to proceed.

โ€œPresumably if you prevail, the next day, a municipality in every single state will file a lawsuit, probably copy your pleadings, and then thereโ€™ll be at least 50 โ€ฆ causes of action filed,โ€ he told the attorney representing Boulder. โ€œHow would you think that will work out on the ground?โ€

With more than 30 similar lawsuits already filed by state and local governments across the country, environmental advocates say the outcome in Suncor v. Boulder could be a turning point in efforts to hold the fossil fuel industry accountable for climate change.

Justice Elena Kagan, the most senior of the courtโ€™s three liberal justices, compared the wave of climate litigation to state-level efforts against tobacco companies in the 1990s and against opioid manufacturers in the 2010s. She asked the attorney for Suncor and Exxon if those lawsuits should have been preempted, too.

Kannon Shanmugam, representing the companies, said the tobacco litigation involved โ€œa more traditional misrepresentation claimโ€ and consumers โ€œsuffering injury quite directly.โ€

โ€œIโ€™m waiting to see the distinction,โ€ Kagan replied. โ€œBecause this complaint talks a lot about misrepresentations that are made by the defendants.โ€

Climate change in Colorado

In a statement Monday, Boulder County said that its case seeks to hold the companies โ€œresponsible for knowingly contributing to climate alteration while concealing the dangers of their products.โ€

The Suncor v. Boulder proceedings come after another unprecedented summer of record heat, extreme drought conditions and destructive wildfire activity impacting Boulder and other Colorado communities, as human-caused climate change, mostly the result of fossil fuel combustion, pushes average global temperatures to dangerous new highs. In December 2021, Boulder County was the location of the Marshall Fire โ€” the most destructive fire in Colorado history, and one in which scientists say climate change was a factor.

โ€œFaced with these rising costs, we ask, is it fair for communities to shoulder these costs alone? We believe it is not,โ€ Boulder Countyโ€™s statement said. โ€œFor decades, the companies producing and selling fossil fuels knew that their products contribute to a changing climate. These companies are asking the Court to help them evade responsibility.โ€

Alito absent

Absent from Mondayโ€™s oral arguments was Justice Samuel Alito, one of the Supreme Courtโ€™s most conservative members. Alito recused himself from further proceedings in the case last week, after environmental advocates had called for him to step aside because he owns stock in at least two oil companies.

Alongside the two parties to the case, Sarah Harris, U.S. deputy solicitor general, appeared before the court on the Trump administrationโ€™s behalf, asking the justices to side with the fossil fuel companies. In an unusual move, the administration filed an unsolicited brief in support of Suncor and Exxonโ€™s initial petition to the court shortly after it was filed in August 2025.

โ€œWe agree with petitioners: interstate air pollution is an inherently federal area, and Congress hasnโ€™t authorized this suit in the Clean Air Act,โ€ Harris told the justices.

Though he posed multiple questions to Shanmugam about the companiesโ€™ legal arguments, conservative Justice Brett Kavanaugh appeared to agree, saying that the court had multiple precedents making it โ€œcrystal clearโ€ that issues involving interstate air and water pollution are subject to federal preemption.

โ€œWe donโ€™t have to reinvent the wheel,โ€ Kavanaugh said. โ€œBecause weโ€™ve said this multiple times โ€” and Congress, presumably, when doing the Clean Air Act and doing the Clean Air Act amendments, has relied on this courtโ€™s precedents, establishing that this kind of pollution is a federal law matter.โ€

Attorney Kevin Russell, representing Boulder, reiterated that the plaintiffsโ€™ case against Suncor and Exxon goes beyond an attempt to merely regulate greenhouse gas emissions.

โ€œThe deception claims, I think, are far outside anything the Clean Air Act is designed to deal with,โ€ Russell said. โ€œThe Clean Air Act doesnโ€™t give the EPA authority to figure out what is the ideal amount of emissions โ€ฆ or the right mix of fuels, or the right level of economic activity. It is a much more precise mandate that is limited to putting a cap on the amount of emissions from particular point sources.โ€

But both Kagan and Roberts sounded skeptical of Boulderโ€™s position that its litigation isnโ€™t seeking to regulate emissions.

โ€œEverything depends on this idea that the defendants are responsible for excessive emissions,โ€ Kagan said.

โ€œIsnโ€™t your suit an attempt to evade those (Clean Air Act precedents)?โ€ asked Roberts. โ€œItโ€™s an effort to reduce emissions. The fuel production itself doesnโ€™t have the sort of universal harm that weโ€™re talking about.โ€

As Mondayโ€™s hearing began in Washington, climate activists gathered at a rally in Boulder, where Mayor Aaron Brockett, survivors of the Marshall Fire and other speakers urged the Supreme Court not to issue a ruling that lets the fossil fuel industry off the hook.

โ€œOur community and many others have suffered terribly from worsening wildfires, floods and drought because of the deception of big oil companies, who knew that burning fossil fuels would overheat our planet, but chose to obfuscate the truth to prioritize their profits,โ€ Micah Parkin, an advocate with climate group 350 Colorado, said in a statement. โ€œBoulder deserves to have our day in court to hold these corporations accountable for the costs our community is having to bear.โ€

Looking towards Boulder at the Marshall Fire December 30, 2021 From 53rd and Stuart in Adams County. Note the atmospheric mountain wave, where winds accelerate down the slope of mountains, extend only a short distance downwind from the mountains, then subside further downwind and blow in the opposite direction, much like the backward flowing current behind a rock in a swift river.

Whatโ€™s next for the Colorado River? — Page Buono (AmericanRivers.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Yuma wetlands restoration, Colorado River, Arizona. Photo credit: Fred Phillips

Click the link to read the article on the American Rivers website (Page Buono):

September 9, 2026

For more than the last century, the flows of the Colorado River have been managed and dictated by the demands of a rapidly growing and changing West. There are founding legal documents, and then agreements stacked on those, often known as the โ€œLaw of the River.โ€ These agreements are between states, between sovereign nations, including Tribal Nations and Mexico; between districts and companies and branches of the US Government. Itโ€™s hard to find the appropriate metaphor for how all of these agreements work together (and at times against one another) to manage the Colorado River system. But even fraught metaphors are sometimes the only way to get through something so complicated.

Imagine the web of agreements and founding legal documents that guide the management of the Colorado River as a body. The 1922 Colorado River Compact would be the skeleton, the framework upon which all the other functions of the body are built. The limbs could be the communities, farms, Tribes, businesses, ecosystems, and economies that rely on the riverโ€™s blood (Colorado River water).  The agreements that build on the framework of the Compact, such as the 2007 Interim Guidelines or the 2019 Drought Contingency Plan (DCP), act as nerves that facilitate or trigger movement and action. Perhaps the brain is the network of decision makers โ€“ the Bureau of Reclamation, the states, the Tribes, Mexico and others whose decisions and cooperation keep the system functioning, underscoring why coordination and consensus are so important: a body whose different parts are working at cross-purposes cannot function effectively. The blood then, of course, is the Colorado River water allocated to parts of the body. 

Continuing the body metaphor for the contemporary management of the Colorado River system, additional agreements (or the nerves that trigger certain action) were added to the body.

Colorado River, Colorado | Trout Unlimited Joshua Duplechian

On Friday, August 24, the Bureau of Reclamation released three documents outlining a 10-year framework for how the Colorado River will be managed for the next two years and how management decisions for the subsequent 8 years will be made. You can read the Bureauโ€™s summary doc here.

  1. Theย Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS): evaluates the many proposed plans Reclamation considered for how the river should be managed going forward, and identifies a preferred alternative, a 10-year framework built on operating plans developed in at least two-year increments;
  2. Theย Record of Decision (ROD): adopts the 10-year operating framework and sets the principles and guardrails for future operations including how water can be stored, shortage sharing, critical infrastructure protection, consultation, and the movement of water between Lake Powell and Lake Mead; and
  3. The 2027-2028 guidelines:ย establish the specific operating approach for the first two years under the new framework.

While the two-year guidelines put real numbers and real movement on the table, the ultimate test is whether the guidelines, alongside the side agreements, investments, and management tools needed to support them, are put in place and function as intended โ€“ and whether, together, they can keep the body upright.

Six months from now, the more consequential questions will be whether the new guidelines:

  • provide more certainty and transparency, including clear pathways for addressing disputes and disagreements when they arise;
  • supportย flexible and adaptive management toolsย that can respond to changing hydrology and conditions;
  • meaningfullyย include Tribal Nationsย in both decision-making and implementation;
  • reduce reliance on emergency operationsย and short-term crisis response; and
  • create aย workable path toward long-term resilienceย โ€” one that can withstand disagreement, including litigation, without bringing implementation and collaboration to a halt.
Colorado River flowing through the Grand Canyon National Park in Arizona. Photo credit: Nick Kelley

Finally, and critically, these new guidelines must recognize healthy rivers and watersheds as a core element of the Basinโ€™s resilience infrastructure, because in the middle of all the agreements โ€“ at the core of all the collaboration and controversy, the skeleton and nerves and muscles that move it, there is a river โ€“ there is a heart; the whole reason blood moves through the system at all.

Healthy rivers and forests, connected floodplains, and intact watersheds are essential to the body, to the Basin. They support the reliability of our water supplies, reduce the risks and impacts of wildfire; they sustain fish and wildlife, support recreation, and strengthen the Basinโ€™s ability to withstand drought and changing conditions. They are invaluable.

Which is to say, at the center of all the agreements and negotiations and collaboration and controversy, is the river. Has always been the river. And if we succeed at all in our management, if we have any hope of keeping this body upright, there will always be the river.

Colorado River “Beginnings”. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

#Drought has decimated #Coloradoโ€™s biggest reservoir, and the livelihoods of those who depend on it — Colorado Public Radio #GunnisonRiver #COriver #aridification

Blue Mesa reservoir seen in August 2026 at about 21% full. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Public Radio website (Stina Sieg). Here’s an excerpt:

September 30, 2026

Anyone can see that something is deeply wrong at Blue Mesa Reservoir on the Western Slope. Itโ€™s historically been the biggest body of water in the state. But not anymore.ย  The deep,ย long-lasting droughtย has shrunk it so much it lost that title to Lake Granby up north. Now it looks like someoneโ€™s opened the drain on a gigantic, rocky bathtub, with only a bit of shiny blue water pooled at the bottom…For 60 years, Blue Mesa Reservoir has stored water that flows to communities and generates electricity. Itโ€™s also a popular recreation spot, a 20-mile-long lake sandwiched between Montrose and Gunnison. Growing up on the edge of this vital water source, Riser has watched decades of visitors bobbing on their motorboats and jet skis, with their coolers and kids, dogs and music…Del Piccolo said heโ€™s never seen algae โ€œthat blue and vibrant.โ€[…]The neon-blue algae is like a warning sign of just how bad things are at Blue Mesa. There are actual warning signs posted, too, saying the water is now dangerous to people and pets. Sonja Chavez, executive director of the Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District, thinks itโ€™s the worst Blue Mesa has ever looked…

Colorado SNOTEL basin-filled map May 31, 2026.

Blue Mesa is not a naturally occurring lake but instead is man-made, designed by the federal government to store water for downstream communities, farms and ranches. It also generates electricity and is federally mandated to release water that provides habitat for threatened and endangered fish, including the nativeย razorback suckerย andย humpback chub. Federal officials take all of that into consideration when they determine how much water to discharge. This year, they were faced with an abysmal snowpack โ€” that accumulation of snow that builds up throughout the winter. Chavez believes the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, which controls how much, and when, water flows out of Blue Mesa, needs to adjust more quickly to lean water years like this one.

Chavez thinks the BoR was releasing too much water too early in the season, which drove Blue Mesa into crisis.ย  In an email statement, the agency said it does work from 24-month forecasts of how much water will melt into reservoirs, but that it also adjusts water releases as conditions change.

โ€œMoving forward, Reclamation is already working with our forecasting partners and water users on ways to improve modeling for dry year water use, enhance forecasting โ€ฆ and review historic operations to identify opportunities for increased drought resiliency,โ€ said Bart Deming, BoR Western Colorado Area office manager.

Aspinall Unit dams

What if? What would a #ColoradoRiver Compact Call mean for #Colorado? A significant Compact tripwire may hit next month and the Lower Basin States might take the Upper Basin States to court — Ken Neubecker (Ken’s Substack) #COriver #aridification

Photo credit: Ken Newbecker

Click the link to read the article on Ken’s Substack (Ken Neubecker):

September 16, 2026

Walter and I frequently walk along the Colorado River in Glenwood Springsโ€™ Two Rivers Park, where the Roaring Fork joins in. The Colorado has been running reddish brown lately due to some intense rain and blowouts from small tributaries upstream, gullies that normally are dry. Not this summer. The Roaring Fork runs clear, creating a distinct division between the flows, a narrow ribbon of clear cold water that runs alongside the warmer and muddier stream for a long ways before they mix.

Both streams and most others are extremely low, even for late summer. Many of the USGS gauges have exclamation points next to them on the map, meaning โ€œextremely below averageโ€. There are rocks exposed to the air that Iโ€™ve never seen before. What little monsoon rain we had didnโ€™t do anything, not even for the dry soils that will likely soak up much of the snow melt next spring before it can reach the rivers.

Years ago when Iโ€™d go to water meetings and conferences, back when people referred to our current situation as an unusually long drought, there was some talk about the Colorado River Compactโ€™s requirement that the Upper Basin not cause the river flow to drop below 75 million acre feet (maf) over a ten year running average. Oh, weโ€™ll see that train wreck coming with plenty of time to do something, they all said. That train wreck is now happening. The engine is sliding over the cliff as the States argue about the menu back in the dining car. All that really happened was serious can kicking along the tracks.

The first Upper Basin โ€œtripwireโ€ of 82.5 maf, the 75 maf plus 7.5 maf for Mexico could come as soon as next month. Now the can being kicked is full of lawyers.

So, what does the 1922 Compact actually say? The meat is in Article III:

This is what each basin could expect every year.

This is where the additional 1.5 maf per year, split as 750,000 acre feet due from each basin comes in. There was no agreement on Mexicoโ€™s share of the river in 1922, or in 1928 when the Compact was finally ratified. That came in 1944 with a formal treaty regarding Mexicoโ€™s share in both the Colorado and Rio Grande Rivers. The Compact negotiators anticipated such an agreement, hence paragraph (c). What they didnโ€™t anticipate were decades of no โ€œsurplusโ€. Thatโ€™s another story.

The more serious tripwire comes next:

October 1, 2026, may well see the flow at Lee Ferry cross the first line in the sand of a dry riverbed if the ten year running average drops below 82.5 maf for the first time since Lake Powell began filling. Back then water was held in the new reservoir to fill it. Everyone was OK with that. The Colorado River flows upstream were still quite robust on average and Lake Mead had plenty to satisfy the Compact requirements for the Lower Basin and Mexico as Powell filled.

Not anymore. Powell is shrinking rapidly. As of this writing the reservoir is at just under 22% full, and only about 27 feet from the elevation where the dam can no longer run water through the power plants penstocks. And the outflow is still about twice the inflow.

The monsoon rains turning the river reddish brown in Glenwood wonโ€™t help.

So what happens if that 82.5 maf tripwire is triggered and one or more states of the Lower Basin place a Compact Call?

Itโ€™s complicated.

It would mean a lawsuit between the states, which would go straight to the US Supreme Court. No lower courts would be involved, and it could take years to resolve. The last time there was a lawsuit about Colorado River apportionment it was between Arizona and California. The case was filed in 1952. The Court appointed a Special Master to work it out and recommend a solution. That took ten years. The case was finally argued in the Court in 1963, with a final decision handed down in 1964. That decision finalized the legal structure for allocations in the Lower Basin, based on the 1928 Boulder Canyon Act.

Twelve years for a resolution. We donโ€™t have that much time for any new case on the Colorado River, especially with how the Upper Basin might comply with Article III, paragraph (d), and Mexicoโ€™s share thrown in.

In 2018 and 2019 the Colorado River Conservation District (River District) commissioned a risk study to look at how flows might augment storage in Lake Powell as well as what might happen should Lake Powell ever reach a level where Compact deliveries dropped to a point where the 82.5 maf over ten years wasnโ€™t met, causing a Compact Call. It was, in light of todayโ€™s situation and the worsening hydrology, a tad optimistic. The first point in the Executive Summaryโ€™s Takeaway states:

The critical low level used for the analysis was 3525 feet, the Bureau of Reclamations critical low as well. Today, September 16, 2026, the elevation at Glen Canyon dam is just under 3517. It continues to drop every day, counting down to October 1.

If the Lower Basin states place a Compact Call it very well could be โ€œcatastrophicโ€ for water users in the Upper Basin. But there are scenarios where it could be less so. At the very worst all diversions junior to November 24, 1922, or possibly June 25, 1929 when the Boulder Canyon Act was signed, would be curtailed, cut off, until the Compact deficiency is resolved. But that truly is a worst case scenario.

Curtailment would likely be based on what the flow deficit is at Lee Ferry when the call is placed and what increase through Upper Basin curtailment might make up the deficit. Diversions could be cut on a sliding scale, with the most junior taking the biggest hit, going back from today to that date in 1922 or 1929. We wouldnโ€™t probably notice much at first as October 1, the start of the new water year, coincides pretty closely with the end of the irrigation season for most.

Colorado transmountain diversions via the State Engineer’s office

The River Districts study looked at various scenarios for Colorado, based on appropriation dates, river basins vs entire West Slope, and amounts of water that might be needed to satisfy the deficiency at Lee Ferry. The biggest hits would be in the Colorado River mainstem, especially with the large trans-mountain diversions taking water to Eastern Slope cities and farms. The Front Range cities, where most of Coloradoโ€™s population resides and who rely on as much as 50% or more of their water supply coming from the Colorado River, along with the significant agricultural areas along the South Platte and Arkansas Rivers, could see some pretty significant cuts regardless.

The State, through the Colorado Water Conservation Board (CWCB) and Attorney Generalโ€™s office did a Compact compliance study some years ago but is keeping that confidential. I canโ€™t blame them. It could become a basis for court arguments and negotiations should a compact call become a reality. The River District study could be as well. Itโ€™s worth a read if you are really interested in all this, and anyone who uses water in Colorado, East or West, to fill a tea pot from the faucet, flush a toilet or raise crops should be. They River District study can be found here or on their website.

Monsoonal moisture is still floating water laden clouds over us today, and some have dropped a good bit of rain. But that wonโ€™t help much. We are facing a โ€œsuper El Ninoโ€ this winter, which may or may not provide a healthy snowpack. Anything would be better than last winter, except a repeat of that dry season. In any case it will take many years of โ€œnormalโ€ snowfall to begin to refill the reservoirs. Given the trend of aridity and climate warming that is not something we should be counting on.

Perhaps, hopefully, the most important part of the compact written at the beginning will be called upon:

Of course the rub here will be in how โ€œequitable divisionโ€ is defined, and I imagine this could take much of the courts time in a Compact Call. In 1922 that meant an equal share of the rivers water for each basin. Now it could hinge on where the greater โ€œvalueโ€ is, and what that means. Back in 1922 โ€œbeneficial usesโ€ were pretty straight forward. Now there are many more uses of the river deemed โ€œbeneficialโ€.

The needs and values today are quite different from what they were 104 years ago. The Tribes, the environment, recreation, local economies and traditions. All were either excluded in 1922 or covered by broad undefined ambiguity. Climate change wasnโ€™t heard of, even though some scientists at the time had warned about it.

Itโ€™s a brave new world we are entering. Business as usual based on a 104 year old piece of paper and the other paper agreements founded on it wonโ€™t help us adapt to that world, nor will wishful thinking and other optimistic dreams based on hope. As Brad Udall noted during a recent PBS Newshour Tipping Point presentation, we need to re-think the whole thing. It wonโ€™t be easy, but as Udall pointed out it could be good. We need to rethink both what the river can provide and the reality of adapting to that. We also need to rethink the โ€œvaluesโ€ we base our water needs on. Itโ€™s not just about endless economic growth anymore. Throwing lawyers at each other only enriches lawyers while it impoverishes us.

Meanwhile Walter and I will continue our ramblings with the river. Weโ€™ll also stop by the River District offices to say hi to the many friends there, to add some stress relief and try to keep their heads from graying any faster than they already are.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

NEWSWIRE: More flood warnings; Grid news — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 28, 2026

โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Welcome to another edition of the Land Deskโ€™s NEWSWIRE, and yet another one in which the big news is the big, end-of-the-water-year rain. Yes, 88% of the Western U.S. is currently experiencing some level of drought โ€” with the most severe impacts in the Four Corners Country. Yet these same areas have also been barraged with rain and inundated with flood watches and warnings for the last few weeks, and yet another big doozy is on its way.

As of Monday morning (9/28), all of New Mexico, most of Arizona, and southern Utah and southern Colorado were all under a flood watch in effect through Wednesday morning. The National Weather Service is warning that rainfall rates in some places could be up to one to two inches per hour.

The latest round of storms will hit already sodden ground in places that have received more rain in the last couple of weeks than they normally do during the entire monsoon season.

๐ŸŒต PUBLIC LANDS ๐ŸŒฒ
  • The Trump administration is reportedly considering Major League Baseballโ€™s request to build a stadium and host a game in Grand Teton National Park, but a White House spokesperson says it is not an administration priority.ย (WyoFile) [Note: MLB has backed off this proposal since Jonathan published on the 28th.]
  • Western Watersheds Project and Basin and Range Watch formally protest the proposed 300-megawatt Bonanza solar-plus-storage project on 5,133 acres of public land in southern Nevada, saying it would fragment desert tortoise habitat and degrade vegetation and soils the tortoise depends on.ย (news release,ย BLM project page)
  • A Western journalist details the ways Interior Secretary Doug Burgum has disappointed conservationists and all Americans by โ€œpulverizing environmental safeguards, leaving Americaโ€™s public lands vulnerable for corporations to plunder at will.โ€ย (High Country News)
  • The Bureau of Land Management begins an aerial herbicide campaign on about 3,800 acres of public land in Sandoval and Cibola counties in New Mexico that will distribute Tebuthiron pellets in an effort to โ€œenhance native plant diversity by reducing dense stands of sagebrush, juniper trees, and rabbitbrush.โ€ย (BLM news release)
  • The Bureau of Land Management greenlights the Indian Creek โ€œwatershed restorationโ€ project that will include clearing piรฑon-juniper forest via chaining, mastication, and other methods on about 561,000 acres of public land in southwestern Utah.ย (news release)
  • The U.S. Forest Service seeks public input until Oct. 9 on its proposal to turn management of the Maroon Bells Scenic Area over to Pitkin County amid funding shortfalls.ย (news release,ย CBS News)
๐ŸŒจ๏ธ๐Ÿฆฆ๐Ÿšฃ๐Ÿฝ WATER WATCH ๐ŸŒŠ
  • Washington County, Utah, plans to construct a wastewater treatment-recycling plant demonstration facility to help educate residents on water recycling and get them past the โ€œick factorโ€ associated with โ€œtoilet-to-tapโ€ facilities.ย (Salt Lake Tribune)
๐Ÿ‘ฉ๐Ÿฝโ€๐Ÿ”ฌ SCIENCE! ๐Ÿงซ
  • University of California, Davis, researchers find orange water released by thawing permafrost into Alaska rivers can be more acidic and contain higher concentrations of metals than acid mine drainage.ย (news release)
โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ
  • A federal study finds a major tailings spill at the proposed Donlin Gold mine in the Kuskokwim River watershed of southwest Alaska would inundate thousands of acres of land and portions of a village in the Crooked Creek drainage, alter stream channels, cause long-term harm to aquatic and terrestrial wildlife, and result in downstream heavy metal contamination that could last for over a century.ย (Mining,ย Draft Supplemental EIS)
  • Ivanhoe Electric relinquishes 642 unpatented mining claims covering 13,264 acres in the Gila National Forest in New Mexico where it planned to explore for copper following widespread local opposition.ย (news release)

Scene from the 2024 White Mesa rally and spiritual walk. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • The White Mesa Concerned Community and Ute Mountain Ute Tribe will hold their annual rally and spiritual walk to protest the White Mesa uranium mill in southeastern Utah on Oct. 17 at 11 a.m. at the White Mesa Community Center.ย (Grand Canyon Trust)
๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES ๐Ÿ“ˆ

Screenshot from the Protect Navajo Air map.

  • Earthworksโ€™ Protect Navajo Air campaign develops an interactive map showing oil and gas facilitiesโ€™ proximity to schools and health care facilities and related air and water polluting incidents in the San Juan Basin in northwestern New Mexico.ย (Protect Navajo Air)
  • An energy economics firm urges the Rural Utah Infrastructure Coalition not to invest as much as $54 million in two proposed coal export terminals on the West Coast, saying they are too risky and may not open Utah coal to foreign markets.ย (Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis)
๐Ÿ”ฅ WILDFIRE LOOKOUT ๐Ÿ”ฅ
  • San Juan County, Utah, drops charges against a former resident and journalist accused of sparking the 2025 Deer Creek Fire near La Sal after flaws in the stateโ€™s investigation are revealed and amid questions about the countyโ€™s political motivations.ย (Salt Lake Tribune)
๐Ÿค‘ GENTRIFICATION JOURNAL ๐Ÿ’ฐ
  • An analysis of IRS data finds Teton County, Wyoming, was again the nationโ€™s richest county in 2023 โ€” with a per-capita income of $313,373 โ€” followed distantly by Pitkin County, Colorado, and Blaine County, Idaho; yet even as residents became wealthier, they became less charitably inclined.ย (CoThrive)
๐Ÿ”‹ THE GRIDโšก๏ธ
  • The U.S. Energy Department awards Xcel Energy two $250 million grants for high-voltage transmission projects in southeastern Colorado designed to expand connections between the Western and Eastern power grids and bring wind power from the Great Plains to Coloradoโ€™s Front Range.ย (Big Pivots)
  • Weld County, Coloradoโ€™s commissioners vote to approve Enyo Energyโ€™s 805-megawatt Chalk Bluff wind and solar-plus-storage project on mostly private land in the oil and gas-rich northeastern corner of the state.ย (Colorado Sun)
  • The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission pauses its licensing process for rPlus Hydroโ€™s proposed pumped hydropower storage project at Seminoe Reservoir in Wyoming to allow the Bureau of Land Management to complete an environmental review of the contested project.ย (WyoFile)
  • Phoenix-area utility Salt River Projectโ€™s board votes to approve the proposed Marigold Energy Center in Stanfield, Arizona. The project will include 600 MW of solar, 400 MW of battery storage, and 675 MW of natural gas generation, along with a new substation and four miles of transmission lines, in an effort to meet growing demand and enhance grid reliability.ย (news release)
  • Nevada utility NV Energy becomes the ninth Western entity to join the California Independent System Operatorโ€™s extended day-ahead wholesale electricity market that will help integrate the balkanized Western grid.ย (Public Power)
OTHER NEWS
  • The National Congress of American Indians files an amicus brief in Tohono Oโ€™odham Nation v. Mullin challenging the Trump administrationโ€™s plan to build a border wall through the Tohono Oโ€™odham nation in southern Arizona, calling it an โ€œunlawful infringement on tribal sovereignty.โ€ย (news release)
๐Ÿฅต ARIDIFICATION WATCH ๐Ÿซ
  • New Mexico farmers say this summerโ€™s extreme heat stunted green chile cropsโ€™ growth, leading to a roasting-season shortage in many parts of the state, adding that a โ€œBiblicalโ€ grasshopper infestation also curtailed yield.ย (KRQE)
๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ
  • Nevada-based Arevia Power proposes a โ€œmulti-buildingโ€ data center on about 3,700 acres of federal public land near Boise, Idaho; the Bureau of Land Management says the agency is in the โ€œpre-planning phaseโ€ and has released few details.ย (Idaho Statesman)
๐ŸŸ COLORADO RIVER CHRONICLE ๐Ÿ’ง
  • Colorado River watcher Ken Neubecker speculates about how a Lower Basin compact call might play out in Colorado.ย (Kenโ€™s Substack)
๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ
Ute Mountain after a storm. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Gaps narrowing between high-speed EV chargers on #Coloradoโ€™s highways: Ironically, sale of EVs has faltered in 2026 even as drivers now are within 30 miles of fast-charger on 83% of federal and state highways — Allen Best (BigPivots.com)

DC Fast Chargers at Walmart. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

September 7, 2026

Colorado has nearly 500 fast-charging EV stations compared to 2,350 gas and diesel stations.

EV drivers will not find an EV fast charger on every street. However, state officials say Colorado is fast approaching the time where EV drivers can travel between the stateโ€™s four corners โ€” not just along the Front Range and major interstates โ€” and be confident of being relatively close to a fast-charging station. This, say state officials, represents a milestone.

โ€œPublic investment has helped make it possible to establish charging in locations that are essential to a truly statewide network but can be more difficult for the private market to serve on its own,โ€ said Shoshana Lew, the executive director of the Colorado Department of Transportation, in a press release.

Gaps have been fast receding since 2020. Today, 83% of Coloradoโ€™s state highway network is within 30 miles of a DC fast-charging station, more than double the 40% six years ago.

Now, a new round of state funding is focused on providing drivers confidence they will be no more than 30 miles from a fast-charging station on federal highways.

Animation of DC Fast Charger build-out in Colorado. Credit: CDOT Note: Tesla and Rivian DC Fast charging facilities are not on this map and they are available to other EV brands. One exception that I know of — the Cortez location is a joint Tesla/Colorado Energy Office operation.

Decline in sales

Ironically, the boom in sale of new EVs has slackened. New battery-electric vehicle registrations declined 55% this year through June compared to the same period in 2025, according to the Colorado Automobile Dealers Associationโ€™s 2026 second quarter report.

Colorado in the final months of 2024 led the nation in the percentage of sales adoption rate for EVs and plug-in hybrids. At one point, about a third of new car sales in Colorado were battery-electric, plug-in hybrids or hybrids. In 2025, sale of electric-only vehicles began slowing in favor of plug-in hybrids.

This most recent decline can be explained in part by the end of generous state and federal tax-based discounts to buyers. Tax credits of up to $6,000 offered by Colorado in 2025 dropped to $750 in January. The federal tax credit of $6,000 ended in September 2025.

Also relevant is that car sales altogether have slowed 15% in Colorado. This decline in EV sales is part of that broader decline.

Travis Madsen expects EV sales to recover.

โ€œThe investment Colorado is making recognizes that the future of road transportation will be electric,โ€ said Madsen, the director of transportation programs for the Southwest Energy Efficiency Project, an environmental advocacy organization. โ€œThese investments are smart. Coloradans will save a ton of money, because itโ€™s cheaper to drive an EV than an internal combustion engine vehicle.โ€

Madsen also expects improving incentives will be part of the discussion when Colorado legislators gather again in January for the 2027 session. Too, he suspects that a shift in the political makeup of Congress and perhaps the presidency in 2028 may result in restored federal tax incentives.

In addition, Madsen suspects the introduction of new models of bare-bones pickup trucks will spur sales. One new pickup, called Slate, comes in at $25,000 and will have a range of 205 miles. Fordโ€™s Fathom will sell for a bit less than $30,000. Ford says the Fathom will have a range of 300 miles, but some auto writers seem skeptical. EV Charging Stations, for example, said an optional higher-capacity battery may be necessary to get this range.

Colorado currently has 217,000 registered EVS and plug-in hybrids among its 5.54 million cars, pickups and vans, according to the Alliance for Automotive Innovation. The state has a 2030 goal of 940,000 and a 2035 goal of 2.1 million.

A lot of federal help

Federal funding of $56.5 million administered through the National Electric Vehicle Infrastructure, or NEVI, program, has bolstered Coloradoโ€™s efforts to create its EV fast-charging network. So far, 17 of the fast-charging locations supported by the federal program have opened, but another 33 are under development.

Several of the EV fast-charging gaps on the lesser traveled highways of Coloradoโ€™s lightly populated eastern plains have been narrowed in the last year with the help of this federal program. For example, somebody driving southeast from Limon on Highway 287 toward Lamar or east on Highway 24 to Kansas would have had no way to charge an electric vehicle until fast-charging stations were added in 2025 at both Eads and Kit Carson. Wray also gained a station.

Walden, seen here during Christmas 2020, is in line to get an EV fast-charger. Photo/Allen Best

Another gap was filled in southwestern Colorado for drivers traveling the 80 miles from Durango to the Four Corners Monument. That station is at Cortez.

Other stations installed with help of the federal program are operating in Frisco, Longmont, Monument, Seibert, Grand Junction, Limon, Montrose, Maybell, Sterling, Durango, Lyons, Pagosa Springs and Walsenburg.

Now CDOT and the Colorado Energy Office are evaluating applications from the ninth round of the DCFC Plazas Grant Program. The state expects to have $14 million available. In this funding round, the state introduced a โ€œgap incentiveโ€ of $174,000 per charging port aimed at attracting projects to high-priority communities and segments with persistent charging gaps:

  1. Bennett/Strasburg,
  2. Cheyenne Wells,
  3. Fraser/Winter Park,
  4. Gunnison,
  5. Holly,
  6. Ignacio / Southern Ute Reservation,
  7. Julesburg,
  8. Saguache,
  9. Walden,
  10. Wellington.

See details here.

State officials did not provide information about how much state money has been used to expand this fast-charging network. Also unclear is how the fast-charging stations installed by Tesla figure into this statewide matrix of fast-chargers. Nearly every major EV brand now has access to Teslaโ€™s supercharging network.

Achieving scale

The goal all along in this effort to electrify transportation has been to achieve scale.

A website at the Colorado Department of Transportation shows the slow and then accelerating spread. First the stations were entirely along the Front Range. The first fast-charger in a rural area was installed in 2017, at a location in the San Luis Valley, followed by more along the interstate highways and then secondary highways. The expansion has been particularly rapid since 2020.

โ€œColorado has reached the point where we are no longer simply building the foundation of an EV fast-charging network โ€” we are filling in the remaining gaps and making that network increasingly useful for travel throughout the state,โ€ said CDOTโ€™s Lew.

โ€œWidespread EV adoption in Colorado would not be possible without convenient access to charging all across the state, from the Eastern Plains to the Western Slope and everything in between,โ€ said Will Toor, executive director of the Colorado Energy Office.

Sifting through the numbers, though, the International Council on Clean Transportation in April released a report that paints a slightly less rosy picture of Coloradoโ€™s fast-charging infrastructure. โ€œMeeting Coloradoโ€™s EV goals will require significant continued investment in charging infrastructure,โ€ the council said.

The council said existing state and federal grants and utility investments, if made, could cover about 84% of non-home DC fast-charger needs through 2035.

And there is also this. Charging stations still take more time and are somewhat less assured, especially when traveling beyond Coloradoโ€™s borders. Consider the story of Florence resident Steve Andrews, an EV driver (Bolt) for many years.

In driving to Wisconsin this year, he will use an internal-combustion engine. Driving his Bolt, with its range of 250 to 300 miles, he says, would take close to a day longer. [Note: He could have rented a Tesla from Turo. This was the option I chose because my Leaf, like the Bolt, was not a road EV.]

Just how the charging infrastructure will evolve is anybodyโ€™s guess. It currently takes maybe 30 minutes to juice up a depleted battery, compared to 5 minutes to gas up a car or 10 or more minutes to fill the 36-gallon tank of a hulking pickup like a Ford 250 or 350.

In both cases the fast-chargers and the gas dispensers are located adjacent to shopping convenience stores. Operators make their money selling potato chips and soft drinks while also offering rest rooms.

Madsen said high-speed charging technology may evolve in uncertain ways. China already has very-fast-charging that can fill a depleted battery in 9 minutes, but that technology is not yet available in the United States.

โ€œThe way it works right now is you need to stop for 15 to 20 minutes, 30 minutes if you get a really big charge. It therefore makes sense to put these (charging stations) at places where drivers can spend time taking care of their other needs.โ€

U.S. 160 between Trinidad and Springfield in southeastern Colorado carries little traffic, even on a Fourth of July weekend. Photo/AllenBest

Highways with few travelers

Colorado โ€” luckily โ€” still has places where you need to think ahead no matter what kind of car you are driving. Consider U.S. 160, which connects Trinidad and Springfield, in the stateโ€™s southeastern quadrant. The landscape is delightfully sparse. You can drive 20 minutes or more, even on a holiday weekend, without encountering another vehicle. Itโ€™s you and the cows and likely pronghorn, too.

That 122-mile stretch of highway currently has one place to buy gasoline or diesel. It has no place to charge your EV, whether slowly or fast. Itโ€™s not among the โ€œgapsโ€ identified in state transportation planning. Probably, it will stay that way for a while.


Coyote Gulch’s Ariya at the summit of Loveland Pass September 19, 2026.

Here’s the link to my last post from my first road trip in my excellent road EV. I charged at ChargePoint, Tesla, Tesla/Colorado Energy Office, Rivian, and Ionna chargers.