Roaring Fork Watershed Summit reviews water management and looks ahead — The Sopris Sun #RoaringForkRiver

Mount Sopris, Roaring Fork River in the foreground. Photo credit: Sinjin Eberle

Click the link to read the article on The Sopris Sun website (Annalise Grueter). Here’s an excerpt:

November 18, 2026

The Roaring Fork Watershed Summit was hosted by the Ruedi Water & Power Authority and the Roaring Fork Conservancy. The two organizations work on different facets of water management and advocacy in the region…

The winter of 2025-26 exacerbated the drought that started the previous summer.
A combination of lower-than-average precipitation, warmer-than-average temperatures and unusually mild nighttime temperatures combined to largely set a new minimum record for snowpack water equivalent across Colorado. As of Nov. 12,
precipitation from October and early November is tracking in the median range for the same measurement. While the autumn precipitation has downgraded Pitkin and Garfield counties to lower levels of drought โ€” most of Garfield ranked as โ€œabnormally dryโ€ and Pitkin between โ€œmoderateโ€ and โ€œextremeโ€ by the United States Drought Monitor on Nov. 10. Eagle County remains largely in โ€œexceptional drought,โ€ the highest ranking. Trends of warmer temperatures and lighter monsoon patterns across recent summers have stakeholders considering water management strategies moving forward…

Peak snowpack was approximately half the historical average, while peak runoff was between one-quarter and one-third the watershedโ€™s historical average. Other parts of Colorado experienced those peaks up to two weeks earlier than the Roaring Fork Watershed. Those early low water levels set the stage for challenges across the region…The dry winter meant that many of Coloradoโ€™s reservoirs were not full in March. Those reservoirs, like Green Mountain Reservoir in Kremmling and Ruedi Reservoir up the Fryingpan Valley, help supply water to water rights holders across the Western Slope during the summer. Green Mountain Reservoir in particular is used to ensure water needs across the region, and when full, releases a constant of 1,500 cubic feet per second (cfs) across the warmer months of the year. This year, water levels required the release rate be substantially lower, less than 10% and down to 6.4% of normal by this autumn, Pearson said. Ruedi Reservoir had to be used as a stop-gap for the lower Roaring Fork Watershed and Colorado River downstream, despite not having filled over the winter. Additional water releases from Ruedi started in August…At the Watershed Summit, Bureau of Reclamation Hydrologist Tim Miller shared that Ruedi Reservoir is 36% full as of early November.

Map of the Roaring Fork River drainage basin in western Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69290878

2026 South Platte Forum #SouthPlatteRiver

The South Platte Hotel was a popular stop for people traveling on the #railroad along the #SouthPlatteRiver. #TBT photo from 1925.

I’m heading downstream to Greeley for the 2026 South Platte Forum. Follow along on my BlueSky feed.

The South Platte River Basin is shaded in yellow. Source: Tom Cech, One World One Water Center, Metropolitan State University of Denver.

Historic Southwest Flooding Doesnโ€™t Fix the #ColoradoRiverโ€™s Problems: Recent storms boosted reservoir levels, but not enough to change the river’s long-term outlook — Jennifer Pitt (Audubon.org) #COriver #aridification

Belted Kingfisher. Photo: Jerry amEnde/Audubon Photography Awards

Click the link to read the article on the Audubon website (Jennifer Pitt):

November 12, 2026

In recent weeks, powerful storms battered the Four Corners region. The San Juan River reached some of its highest flows on record, and the Animas and Dolores rivers each logged their fifth-highest levels. Families in Pagosa Springs, Colo., in Bluff, Utah, and Navajo Nation communities now face months of recovery. Though for some observers, there was at least some hope: after years of drought, perhaps all that water would provide a meaningful boost to replenish Colorado River reservoirs, recharge aquifers, and benefit some wildlife habitat.

The gain is small compared to the Colorado River’s deficit. Some of that floodwater reached the Colorado River system. Lake Powell has risen since October 1 by about 19 feet, a gain of roughly one million acre-feet of water. Every drop counts, but Powell holds roughly 24 million acre-feet when full and is still nearly three-quarters empty. Powell and Lake Mead, the systemโ€™s two largest reservoirs, each hold less water today than at this time last year. Meanwhile, water users in Arizona, California, Nevada and Mexico face significant supply reductions in 2027 under new federal guidelines designed to stabilize reservoir storage.

Whiplash is the new normal. Colorado River flows have always varied from year to year. That variability hits hardest when reservoirs are depleted, and it affects water users who depend on unregulated streamflow. Scientists expect a warming climate to bring more intense storms while drying the basin over the long term. And despite strong El Niรฑo conditions this year, history suggests they are not a reliable predictor of above-average Colorado River flows. After last winterโ€™s near-record-low runoff, a second poor snow year would further stress reservoirs that remain well below capacity. It would pose a serious challenge for Lake Powell, which is dangerously close to the elevations where water can no longer pass through Glen Canyon Dam. That impact would cascade downstream to Lake Mead, triggering larger supply reductions and pushing the reservoir closer to its own crisis.

Whatโ€™s needed now. The storms caused devastating damage. They also added modestly to the riverโ€™s supply, but this is a reprieve, not a rescue. The storms are not a reason to stop working on the Colorado River crisisโ€”they are a sign that we urgently need to make progress. Federal and state managers must keep working toward durable, basin-wide demand reductions and a negotiated, consensus agreement on sharing water shortages and managing the river, one that avoids a court-imposed outcome. Congress can also help affected communities by responding to a $2 billion request made by more than 100 Colorado River stakeholdersโ€”including irrigation districts, municipal water providers, Tribes, and conservation NGOs, including Audubonโ€”to fund projects that help people and birds by building resilience to both drought and intense storms. These investments include floodplain restoration, forest health, and water conservation and reuse projects that can replenish reservoirs, strengthen communities’ resilience to drought and flooding, and support bird habitat across the Colorado River Basin.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Aurora Water working to meet state request for Wild Horse Reservoir data amid county resistance: โ€˜Taking more water out of the basin at a time like this adds even more of the burden of shortage onto those who live hereโ€™ — #Aurora Sentinel

A wetland area along Homestake Creek. The creek is listed as a source of water for Aurora’s Wild Horse Reservoir in Park County. Photo credit: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

Click the link to read the article on the Aurora Sentinel website (David O. Williams). Here’s an excerpt:

November 15, 2026

Aurora Water officials on Friday confirmed they are working to provide additional water quality information the state has requested as the city water utility seeks a state Regulation 87 dredge and fill permit for the proposed Wild Horse Reservoir in Park County that would partially be filled by Homestake Creek water from Eagle County.

โ€œWe are continuing to work with CDPHE to provide the additional information they requested for the Regulation 87 review process,โ€ said Aurora Water Senior Communications Strategist Zach Henry in a statement, adding that the deadline for commenting on the project to the state, which has already been extended once, remains in place for Thursday, Nov. 19…

That means there is still urgency for anyone interested to email their comments to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment at cdphe_df_wqcd@state.co.us, with the subject line โ€œWHS PN Commentsโ€ by the end of the day on Thursday, Nov. 19.

Once Aurora Waterโ€™s additional information on water quality and modeling is provided, there will then be another comment period on that subject, according to state officials. Meanwhile, the list of local water officials opposing the proposal only continues to grow.

โ€œHomestake Creek and the Upper Eagle River are already deeply affected by existing transmountain diversions where water moves through pipes from the Western Slope to the Front Range,โ€ wrote Dick Cleveland and George Gregory, board chairs of the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District and Upper Eagle Regional Water Authority, respectively.

Map of the Eagle River drainage basin in Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69310517

West Slope Water Summit: Climate, legal disputes and economics pressure Colorado River and local ag — The #Montrose Press

Screenshot of Blue Mesa Reservoir July 2026 from the West Slope Water Summit presentatiion by the Colorado River District.

Click the link to read the article (and check out the slide show) on The Montrose Press website (Katharhynn Heidelberg). Here’s an excerpt:

November 15, 2026

Andy Mueller stood before an at-capacity room Nov. 13 to deliver the facts: The Westโ€™s population is booming; climate change is reality; there is no magic button to replenish the Colorado River to feed faucets and crops โ€” and a new legal fight over the 100-plus-year-old compact governing its use is looming. Mueller, the general manager of the Colorado River District, updated those attending Montrose Countyโ€™s West Slope Water Summit on the brewing dispute between the Upper Basin states (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming) and Lower Basin states (California, Arizona and Nevada), which have long tussled over whether the Colorado River Compact mandates the apportionments agreed to in 1922 regardless of current hydrology. The states, having failed to resolve their central disputes, could now find themselves in a showdown before the United States Supreme Court…

โ€œWe have a looming legal fight with the Lower Basin. Do we owe a delivery obligation of 75 million or 82.5 million (acre feet) over 10 years, or is that language in the compact just that we shall not cause that river to be depleted below that amount? Itโ€™s not us. Itโ€™s a natural circumstance thatโ€™s being caused by warming temperatures and so itโ€™s not our fault. Itโ€™s the riverโ€™s fault. That is an argument that weโ€™re likely to have, unfortunately, at the Supreme Court,โ€ Mueller said…

Amid the dayโ€™s detailed discussions of lawsuits, compact history and weather patterns, a central question cast its shadow over the entire summit: If we canโ€™t control how much water Mother Nature provides, what can we do to conserve and store more?

Gunnison Tunnel via the National Park Service

โ€œIt seems to me like the biggest bang for the buck in the state of Colorado is to modernize the delivery systems,โ€ State Sen. Marc Catlin, R-Montrose, said, during the summitโ€™s expert panel discussion…โ€œEvery system in the Uncompahgre (Valley) was built in 1912 โ€” itโ€™s still earth and lime canals. Water users have gone about piping a lot of these sites and those kinds of things, but if the state of Colorado is serious about saving water, they need to come to the table with dollars that will help secure savings of water on these irrigation systems. We can continue to talk about it, but until something like that happens, individual agricultural users are not going to be able to generate enough saved water to make a difference.โ€

Catlin said itโ€™s critical to cast an eye on the future, but to act now…A farm is for many like a 401k retirement fund โ€” and the average age of a farmer is about 64, he noted. โ€œHow do we step in when the time comes that you cannot continue to farm, or you canโ€™t afford to farm? What are you supposed to do with those farms rather than sell them?โ€ Catlin asked. The buyer could likely be a speculator instead of another farmer, he said. โ€œWhat will that do to our communities? Thereโ€™s a lot of questions that are going to need to be answered in regards to this. Do communities think farmland is a valuable enough commodity to purchase it the way on the Front Range, (where) they buy open space? โ€ฆ All over the Western Slope, we have to think about it, because things are changing.โ€

The risk is real, Catlin also said. โ€œWe canโ€™t expect the climate to change back to something we knew when we were kids. So weโ€™re going to have to think about how we address these kinds of things.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Conservation Programs in the #ColoradoRiverโ€™s Upper Basin Inch Forward, Despite Thorny Questions — Jake Bolster (InsideClimateNews.org) #COriver #aridification

A group of visitors walks down the boat ramp at Williams Fork Reservoir on July 20, 2026. The ramp was closed this summer due to low water levels caused by drought. Photo credit: Denver Water.

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Jake Bolster):

November 13, 2026

Four upriver states are planning to use $100 million in federal grants to do the work. But itโ€™s unclear whether the federal government will bank the water for them.

New voluntary water conservation programs in the Upper Colorado River Basin appear on track after the 320th meeting of the Upper Colorado River Commission concluded this week. But Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, Wyoming and the federal government have yet to agree on how any conserved water would be credited and stored.

These questions, experts say, may not come with easy answers.

This June, the federal Bureau of Reclamation put $100 million on the table for the four states in the Upper Basin to fund their own voluntary water conservation programs, which usually entails paying ranchers and farmers to use less water. Overuse and drought-diminished flows on the Colorado River threaten the water supply of roughly 40 million people, 30 tribes, seven states and Mexico.

Most Upper Basin states are planning to implement programs in 2027 (Utah already has one running), and their success could be crucial to the statesโ€™ assertion that they should only have to ease the pressure on the Colorado River through voluntary measures. This fall, the federal government implemented new mandatory reductions on the Lower Basin, and Nevada, later joined by Arizona, sued over the potential for even deeper cuts.

โ€œItโ€™s โ€ฆ important to recognize, and I say this in a positive way, a complimentary way, the audacious ambition of attempting to put this together in the time frame that we have,โ€ Wayne Pullan, the Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s Upper Colorado Basin regional director, told negotiators from the Upper Basin states at the virtual meeting.

Colorado made it clear that its program can only move forward with an agreement from Reclamation that conserved water would remain under the stateโ€™s jurisdiction.

From left, Interstate Section Chief at the CWCB Amy Ostdiek, Colorado representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission Becky Mitchell and State Engineer Jason Ullmann, speak on a panel at Colorado Water Congress on Aug. 20 in Steamboat Springs. State officials are rolling out a water conservation program that would pay water users to temporarily cut back. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

โ€œWe really need to get some credit for the upper division states through a program like this,โ€ said Amy Ostdiek of the Colorado Water Conservation Board, who presented the stateโ€™s conservation program. โ€œWhat that means in Colorado is seeing that that water is treated as operationally neutral, and not simply passed downstream.โ€

โ€œOperationally neutralโ€ water is conserved by one state and stored in federal reservoirs for future use by that state. Arizona, California and Nevada, the Lower Basin states, have banked water in Lake Mead, the largest reservoir in the United States, with the option to withdraw it for future use. But the Interior secretary is the legal water master in the Lower Basin and has the ability to allocate surplus water there. The secretary does not play the same role in the Upper Basin.

Green River Basin

Pullan said that Reclamation is โ€œable and willingโ€ to keep working on how the government would credit and handle water conserved by the Upper Basin. Some observers wondered how the Upper Basinโ€™s condition would sit with the federal government, which built and financed the dams that store the water.

โ€œThey donโ€™t like to turn over the keys of the car to the states,โ€ said James Eklund, a partner at Taft Law and Coloradoโ€™s Colorado River negotiator from 2013 to 2019.

The Lower Basin would also need to agree that water conserved in the Upper Basin could be stored for the upstream statesโ€™ use, something Kathryn Sorensen, director of research for Arizona State Universityโ€™s Kyl Center for Water Policy, had a hard time envisioning.

The Lower Basin states โ€œwould expect some sort of quid pro quo for that type of arrangement,โ€ she said.

The Upper and Lower basin negotiators from each of the seven Colorado River states had years to agree on new guidelines for the federal government to implement. After they missed several deadlines, Reclamation implemented its own new operating plan this year, and the states appear no closer to an agreement.

The possibility of one of the seven basin states suing another before the Supreme Court looms over the basin.

Various conservation programs in the Upper Basin are in different phases of development. Utahโ€™s program saved about 5,500 acre feet of water in 2025, Amy Haas, executive director of the Colorado River Authority in Utah, announced at the meeting.

One acre foot of water can supply anywhere from three to six homes for a year, depending on the regionโ€™s climate and urban density.

New Mexico and Wyoming made their programs compatible with other funding sources, like state appropriations or grants from nonprofits, should they become available, state representatives said.

The Upper Basin uses less water than the Lower Basin, which recently reined in its consumption after years of drawing more water than it was allocated, though it has plans to divert yet more water from the river. In its operating guidelines released this summer, Reclamation modeled up to 200,000 acre feet of voluntary conservation annually in the Upper Basinโ€”if hydrology allows.

Eklund, who attended the virtual meeting, said itโ€™s disappointing the seven basin states still canโ€™t agree on a solution to the problems plaguing the Colorado River. โ€œIf this system collapses, it doesnโ€™t really matter what weโ€™re legally entitled to,โ€ he said.

โ€œIf Phoenix sneezes, the Upper Basin catches a cold,โ€ he added. โ€œWeโ€™re very, very connected economically to each other, and if we donโ€™t start governing the system like weโ€™re all part of one country and not seven different sovereign countries, then weโ€™re A: only going to have ourselves to blame, and B: weโ€™re not going to like the results.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Romancing the River โ€“ #ColoradoRiver โ€˜Mathologyโ€™ — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com) #COriver #aridification

An unauthorized 1981 tour of the canal for the Central Arizona Project (CAP) โ€“ no one was around to ask permission, so I had to climb over a fence to get into it. Credit: George Sibley

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

November 10, 2026

The image above is yours truly, in an unauthorized 1981 tour of the canal for the Central Arizona Project (CAP) โ€“ no one was around to ask permission, so I had to climb over a fence to get into it. I was working with film auteur and friend, Len Aitken from Boulder, on a film about the Colorado River based on an article I had written for Harperโ€™s in 1977.

Throughout the film Len used narrative backgrounds, like this one, that showed the massive magnitude of these efforts to, as it were, โ€˜make the Colorado River vision concrete.โ€™ This 3,000 cubic-feet-per-second canal runs 250-some miles, from water backed up behind Parker Dam on the Colorado River (downstream from Hoover Dam) through empty desert to the Phoenix metropolitan area, and then, in smaller size, another hundred miles to Tucson.

With leaves and desert dirt blown in, it looks a little desolate; it was still under construction when we shot the film in 1981, and didnโ€™t start to carry water until 1985; the CAP was declared complete in 1993. But today, Arizonans fear that the desolated look here might be the look of the futureโ€ฆ. And therein lie some stories โ€“ ironic for sure, but also tragic, if your definition of tragedy is โ€˜knowledge gained too late to prevent the unfolding of misfortune that could have been avoided had the knowledge been gained before acting.โ€™ Climate change. American political shifts. And the ever-unfolding tragedy of our overwhelming success as a swarming species.

Last post I said we would begin exploring how the waters of a desert river might be more equitably distributed among users. I will get to that eventually. But right now current events along the Colorado River are unfolding and being reported with no sense of the currents flowing into and through themโ€ฆ. Some backgrounding, the rest of the story, is needed โ€“ if only for a morbid laugh or two.

Underlying these stories is the mythology of the desert conquered, a mythology embraced nationally: that technology, science and rationality would overcome and correct the irregularities and shortfalls of nature. This mythology had begun to show cracks by the time that big ditch was completed;  the Central Arizona Project was the mythologyโ€™s last hurrah in the Colorado River Basin.

When I last wrote here, the Bureau of Reclamation had just rolled out a ten-year management plan to try to save the Colorado River system โ€“ mainly to prevent the two big storage reservoirs, Mead and Powell, from dropping to the dead-pool stage when water cannot be moved past the big dams. In order to be able to continue releasing water from the storage dams,  the Bureau finds it necessary to reduce the amount of water theyโ€™ve been releasing this century.

Accordingly, the Bureau announced in their ten-year plan โ€“ an adaptive plan to be revised as needed every two years โ€“ that 1.2 million acre-feet of cuts must be made in the first two-year segment, the 2027 and 2028 water years, all of it from the three states below Hoover Dam. And given the dour reality that the riverโ€™s flow will continue diminishing as the ambient temperatures rise, the Bureauโ€™s ten-year goal is a total reduction among all users of at least three million acre-feet of consumptive use by 2035, to build up some semblance of carry-over storage in the system.

Nevada then had filed a lawsuit against the Department of Interior/Bureau of Reclamation over the cuts in water delivery proposed. And since then, both the State of Arizona and the Central Arizona Project Board have โ€˜intervenedโ€™ (joined) in the lawsuit.

The lawsuit claims that the Bureau is relying on the three Lower Basin states to carry the entire burden of the consequences of an ongoing quarter-century drought. The plaintiffs want the Bureau to impose cuts on the four Upper Basin states too, or at the very least to adhere to the โ€˜Law of the Riverโ€™ built on the 1922 Colorado River Compact, requiring the Upper Basin states to โ€“ well, to continue doing what they have been doing for a century: making sure enough water gets past the Lee Ferry division point to meet the Lower Basinโ€™s Compact share and the Mexican treaty allotment.

Irony begins with the State of Arizona asking the Bureau to adhere to the letter of the Colorado River Compact; Arizona had refused to ratify the Compact in 1922 โ€“ probably understandably. The original Compact objective had been to insure Californiaโ€™s rapid development would leave enough water in the river for the other six basin states; the Compact they came up with protected half of the riverโ€™s water for the four Upper Basin states, but left Arizona and Nevada, as it were, โ€˜in the cage with the 800-pound Bear State.โ€™

Arizona Navy photo via California State University

In 1934, when the Bureau of Reclamation began construction of Parker Dam, below Hoover Dam (also still in construction), Arizona went on the offensive with California. The purpose of Parker Dam was to back up water for Californiaโ€™s pumping station for its massive 250-mile Colorado River Aqueduct to Los Angeles and San Diego. So Arizonaโ€™s governor sent the National Guard out to stop construction. This quickly devolved into a Keystone Cops comedy. A boat to confront the workers with an order to desist started to sink, and the construction workers rescued the Guardsmen and redeposited them on the Arizona bank, then went back to work and the National Guardsmen slunk back home.

Arizona finally signed the Compact in 1944, to get status to sue California over Compact issues โ€“ a semi-successful suit in which the Supreme Court, after ten years of analysis by โ€˜water masters,โ€™ granted Arizona full use of the Gila River without charging its million-plus acre-feet against Arizonaโ€™s 2.8 million acre-foot โ€˜mainstemโ€™ Compact allotment. But the court also mandated the allotting of water to several of the 22 First People tribes in Arizona and ordered negotiations to commence for providing water for other tribes โ€“ a responsibility bypassed in the original Compact.

But Arizonaโ€™s main problem with Californiaโ€™s Colorado Aqueduct was probably mostly their desire for an aqueduct like that for central Arizona โ€“ envy may be the largest root of irrational antagony.

โ€˜Central Arizonaโ€™ is a region of relatively mellow desert river valleys โ€“ the Verde flowing in from the north off the Colorado Plateau, the Salt flowing out of canyons off the Mogollon Rim, and the Gila flowing up from the south off the Rim. The three desert rivers accumulate around a million acre-feet of upland water in a good year, which originally flowed off across the deserts as the Gila River, to a confluence with the Colorado River at Yuma. But by World War II, all three tributaries were so fully used in Central Arizona that water would only flow to Yuma in a big water year.

When Carl Hayden was elected to the Senate in 1926, after a decade as a central Arizona Representative, he had epitomized the mythology and the vision of a huge water project to bring water from the Colorado River to the upper Gila valleys. In the period of growth after World War II, he made it his opus magnum, with the people of Arizona returning him to office for seven terms until finally in 1968, after numerous defeats, the Colorado River Basin Project Act was passed, with the CAP its main focus. Carl Hayden, 90 years old, could finally resign at the end of his seventh term.

The Central Arizona Project canal carries water through Phoenix in 2019. The project’s former general manager, Ted Cooke, was recently nominated to run the top federal agency for the Colorado River. Those who have worked with Cooke described him as a qualified expert. Ted Wood/The Water Desk

Compromises had been made to the simple purity of his vision, however. In order to get Arizonaโ€™s old nemesis California reluctantly on board for the vote, the bill had to specify that the CAPโ€™s water right would be junior to other existing water rights in the Basin โ€“ thus running roughshod over the original Compact commissionโ€™s desire to allot to each state water to develop on its own schedule, independent of other statesโ€™ appropriative seniority.

By the 1960s, the surface water in the valleys was exhausted, and farmers and developers both had been pumping groundwater to the extent that emptied aquifers were beginning to collapse, causing surface subsidence. So the state was ordered by Interior to come up with a groundwater management plan before construction would start on the CAP. The state created a Department of Water Resources, and in 1980 adopted a Groundwater Management Plan with โ€˜Active Management Areasโ€™ in the parts to be served by the CAP (basically the Phoenix-Tucson corridor); those areas were to be brought into โ€˜safe yieldโ€™ balance where withdrawals from the ground would be matched by CAP water plus existing surface supplies by 2025. Unfortunately, so many existing users were โ€˜grandfatheredโ€™ and exempted from restrictions that it was impossible to meet the 2025 goal of โ€˜safe yieldโ€™ in those AMAs by their target 2025. A quarter century of drought and the onset of climate change have not helped.

They also did something that could be regarded as wasteful, if not just stupid. The CAP base allotment from the Colorado River was just under a million acre-feet, but there was surplus water in the river system that was not yet being used by the Upper Basin states โ€“ and California had already, back in the 1930s, built its aqueduct to carry twice as much as its 500,000 acre-feet allotment, โ€˜borrowingโ€™ some of that surplus until it was needed by others. And if California could do that, why couldnโ€™t Arizona? And the Bureau, avatar of the desert mythology and blessed with a bad head for numbers, went along with it.

So the ditch Iโ€™m standing in was built to carry half again more water than its legal allotment. They advertised the proposed project as carrying a 50-year average of 1.2 maf. But that is what we night call โ€˜mathologyโ€™ โ€“ manipulating numbers to better serve a mythology. That deceptive โ€˜averageโ€™ began with projected deliveries of 1.55 maf in 1985, gradually decreasing to deliveries of 0.984 maf by 2035. So one of the fastest growing areas in the nation would have a declining water supply to grow on, and a canal eventually only 60 percent full โ€“ unless they could find some more water. Maybe from the Columbia River! But Oregon Senator Jackson cut that idea off, inserting in the CR Basin Project Act a ban on even discussing that for 25 years. Nonetheless, ideas of bringing in water from some other mythic river with a โ€˜surplusโ€™ still float around.

A final Arizona short story from the 1970s that foretold the future of the desert mythology. In 1977 โ€“ a complete newbie in Colorado River matters working on an article for Harperโ€™s about the river โ€“ I did a cold call at the office of Wes Steiner, Arizonaโ€™s head water engineer then. I was told that he wasnโ€™t in; he was down at (some auditorium) at an open Water Commission work session about the proposed distribution of municipal CAP water when it was actually built.

I went down to that meeting, and basically watched the death throes of the desert conquest mythology. The Commission had 500,000 uncommitted acre-feet to meet requests for over two million requested for approved or pending developments. The way it resolved the problem was by giving everyone something โ€“ allotments ranging from 3 percent to 100 percent of their requests, with the average around 25 to 30 percent. The engineers were candid in saying that most of the developments would probably outgrow their issue of CAP water, and rather quickly.

As recently as 2021, even though there was no more โ€˜surplusโ€™ water in the Colorado River Basin, the CAP deliveries were still in the 1.3-1.4 maf range; the Bureau, faithful to the mythology, was allowing its diminishing Mead storage to be drawn down to support the mythology.

In 2003 Congress passed a โ€˜Colorado River Quantification Settlement Facilitation Actโ€™ which politely ordered California to stop using borrowed water and bring its Colorado River use down to its Compact allotment of 4.4 maf, which California has been working to do. And nature is now forcing the Bureau to do the same thing to the CAP; from 2022 to the present, CAP deliveries have dropped abruptly to under a million acre-feet. The biggest cuts in the Active Management Areas have been to agriculture โ€“ which just means that the grandfathered farmers will go back to pumping more groundwater, further undermining groundwater management.

And that is basically where Arizona stands today, as it lashes out to sue someone else for its troubles. The CAP will take a large cut in its allotment this year, and probably more cuts within the ten year plan โ€“ not because they lost a lawsuit, but because the river system will just not have enough water to deliver what their โ€˜mathologyโ€™ decreed for them.

The structural deficit refers to the consumption by Lower Basin states of more water than enters Lake Mead each year. The deficit, which includes losses from evaporation, is estimated at 1.2 million acre-feet a year. (Image: Central Arizona Project circa 2019)

But it should be noted that these initial Bureau cuts only take care of the โ€˜structural deficit,โ€™ which was the Bureau allowing the Lower Basin States to continue considering their system losses (evaporation and bank losses) and their half of the Mexican obligation as covered by โ€˜surplus,โ€™ even though the mythic surplus disappeared when the CAP went online in the late 1980s and Upper Basin kept increasing. Conservatively, the Bureau released more than a million acre-feet per year for three decades that should have been deducted from the allotments to the Lower Basin states since the beginning of the whole river project (as they are for the Upper Basin states). Those 30-plus million acre-foot releases are where the storage base disappeared; climate-change and drought are only contributing factors.

One hopes that all of this will come out when the Supremesโ€™ water master digs in. But Arizona and all the states would probably do better if instead they all just held a cremation for the old river mythology (and the mathology of its misbegotten Compact), and set about enacting a new mythology in which they all transcend state boundaries and work together on sharing out the use and maintenance of a one still beautiful, diminishing, desert river and its mountain waters that run through them all.


NOTE: Anyone interested can see Len Aitkenโ€™s 1981 film โ€˜โ€™The River in the Desertโ€™ by clicking here. Itโ€™s a little fuzzy because it was transposed from film (remember film?), and there are a few things I wish Iโ€™d said better. But much of it has stood the test of time pretty well.

Iโ€™ve also included the 1977 Harperโ€™s essay, โ€˜The Desert Empireโ€™ โ€“ ditto on standing the test of time.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Will the ‘super’ El Niรฑo save the day? #ElNiรฑo has arrived. What does that mean for Denver Water? — Aidan Lyde (DenverWater.org) #ENSO #SouthPlatteRiver #ColoradoRiver

Click the link to read the article on the Denver Water website (Aidan Lyde):

November 6, 2026

Editorโ€™s note: This story was written by Aidan Lyde, a water planner who focuses on climate at Denver Water.


Weather headlines over the last few months have featured a parade of promises about a โ€œsuperโ€ El Niรฑo, with suggestions that this yearโ€™s version of the climate pattern tied to sea surface temperatures in the Pacific Ocean will translate into a snowy winter for Colorado.

But can we be so sure El Niรฑo will save Denver Water or Colorado from the ongoing drought?

The short answer is: We shouldnโ€™t count on it.

El Niรฑoโ€™s influence on Colorado weather patterns is less certain than its impacts elsewhere, and we need to be prepared for a range of potential future outcomes.

An analysis conducted by Denver Waterโ€™s Climate Adaptation Program illustrates this uncertainty.

The team looked at the historical record to find years when there was either a strong or very strong El Niรฑo from September through February. Then, they analyzed whether precipitation amounts during those years were wetter or drier than average for Park, Summit, Grand and Denver counties.

The team’s findings?

  • None of the three major mountain counties in Denver Waterโ€™s collection system (Park, Summit and Grand counties) demonstrated a pattern of being consistently wetter than average.
  • In fact, two mountain counties, Summit and Grand, appeared to be consistently drier than average during strong/very strong El Niรฑo years.
  • However, Denver County tended to be consistently wetter than average during those periods, with all but one year wetter than average.
Looking at records dating to the 1950s, Denver County has been wetter than average during El Niรฑo years, while Grand County appears to have been drier than average during those years. Image credit: Denver Water.

How does El Niรฑo impact Colorado?

Colorado has a complicated relationship with El Niรฑo.

El Niรฑo typically leads to warmer conditions in the Northern U.S., drier conditions in parts of the Midwest and South, and wetter conditions across the southern tier of states.

Colorado sits between many of these expected weather conditions, so we don’t have a clear idea of what to expect.

El Niรฑo tends to bring warmer conditions to regions north of Colorado and wetter conditions to regions south of Colorado. ENSOโ€™s influence on Colorado weather patterns is less certain. Image credit: oceanservice.noaa.gov.

That said, previous El Niรฑo events have generally resulted in greater precipitation in certain regions of Colorado.

The graphics below show the correlation between seasonal precipitation (winter, spring, summer and fall) and El Niรฑo events in Colorado over the last 75 years, from 1950 to 2025.

The areas in green experienced wetter-than-average conditions during El Niรฑo during the different seasons.

These graphics show the correlation between the Relative Oceanic Niรฑo Index and Colorado precipitation, using data from 1950-2025. Areas in green have been wetter during El Niรฑo, while areas in blue (in the winter chart) have been wetter during La Niรฑa in the seasons shown. Only areas with 95% statistical significance in the relationship are shown. Image credit: Peter Goble, Colorado Climate Center.

However, as this El Niรฑo event is shaping up to be among the strongest on record, there are no guarantees that this year will continue to follow the seasonal precipitation patterns we have seen in the past throughout Colorado.

The bottom line for Denver Water

We donโ€™t actually know whether Denver Water will receive a boost in water supply or if the dry conditions will continue into next year.

Thereโ€™s a decent chance that some parts of our collection system will experience wetter conditions, while the signal is mixed for other areas where it could be wetter, drier or average.

We also expect El Niรฑo to raise global temperatures, which could result in less of the precipitation we do receive translating into an available water supply stored in our reservoirs.

The bottom line: Keep hoping for rain and snow, but donโ€™t be surprised if the drought continues.

Image 1: Sample sea surface temperaure anomalies (Celsius) during El Niรฑo (left) and La Niรฑa (right). Source: climate.gov

What is El Niรฑo?

The El Niรฑo-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is a recurring climate pattern that involves natural changes in sea surface temperatures in the tropical Pacific Ocean.

El Niรฑo is the โ€œwarmโ€ phase of ENSO and is characterized by warmer-than-normal ocean temperatures in the tropical Pacific Ocean due to a weakening of the trade winds that blow from east to west along the equator.

La Niรฑa is ENSOโ€™s โ€œcoolโ€ phase and is characterized by cooler-than-normal ocean temperatures in this region due to a strengthening of the trade winds.

While it varies, El Niรฑo and La Niรฑa events typically last nine to twelve months and occur every two to seven years.

El Niรฑo and La Niรฑa patterns influence weather patterns around the U.S. and the world due to the influence of sea surface temperatures on atmospheric currents. However, El Niรฑoโ€™s impact on weather varies by region, and those impacts arenโ€™t always as clear as weโ€™d like them to be.

What’s the deal with “super” El Niรฑo?

As it turns out, โ€œsuperโ€ El Niรฑo is not an official scientific designation despite its common use.

Officially, the term describes what the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, known as NOAA, classifies as a โ€œvery strongโ€ El Niรฑo. The strength of an El Niรฑo event is categorized as โ€œweak,โ€ โ€œmoderate,โ€ โ€œstrong,โ€ or โ€œvery strongโ€ based on how much ocean temperatures rise above normal.

The NOAA Climate Prediction Center estimates a greater than 83% chance of a โ€œstrongโ€ to โ€œvery strongโ€ El Niรฑo through January-March 2027, which could rank among the largest El Niรฑo events in the historical record dating back to 1950.

The NOAA Climate Prediction Center estimates a greater than 83% chance of a โ€œstrongโ€ to โ€œvery strongโ€ El Niรฑo through January-March 2027. Image credit: NOAA Climate Prediction Center.

Itโ€™s important to note that stronger El Niรฑo events do not always mean bigger weather and climate impacts; instead, they make it more likely that certain impacts could occur (such as heat waves, drought or extreme rainfall).

NOAA forecasts El Niรฑo to strengthen over the fall and winter before weakening through the spring.

Why Shoshone water rights matter to Mesa County

Shoshone hydroelectric plant penstocks. Photo credit: Mesa County

Click the link to read the release on the Mesa County website

November 10, 2026

The Colorado River supports farms, businesses, recreation, wildlife and communities across Mesa County. Some of the river’s flow is influenced by water rights held by the Shoshone Hydroelectric Plant in Glenwood Canyon, nearly 90 miles upstream from the Grand Valley.

Mesa County has committed $1 million toward a proposed purchase of those rights and is participating in a water court case that could shape how they are used in the future.

The Shoshone plant holds two water rights that together allow it to use up to 1,408 cubic feet of water per second when the rights are available.

In Colorado, older water rights have priority over newer ones. When a senior right is in priority and calls for the water, some upstream users with junior rights may have to reduce their diversions so water can reach the senior right.

The plant uses the water to generate electricity and then returns it to the river. The water is not consumed, but goes back into the river after making power. Its historic rights have helped support downstream river uses, including in the Grand Valley.

The Shoshone rights are tied primarily to generating electricity. If the plant permanently stops operating, the river’s historic benefits from the rights could be at risk.

The Colorado River District has agreed to buy the water rights from Public Service Company of Colorado, an Xcel Energy subsidiary. The purchase agreement is referred to as the $99 million transaction. If the sale goes through, Xcel would continue operating the plant and lease the rights from the River District while the plant remains in operation.

The River District, the Colorado Water Conservation Board and Public Service Company are asking the Water Court to add instream flow as an authorized use when the rights are not being used to generate power. Instream flow is water that stays in a river to support the natural environment.

The proposed instream flow use applies to a roughly two-mile stretch between the Shoshone diversion dam and the plant’s discharge outlets. The application does not ask for a new water right or for instream flow use downstream of that stretch.

The case is pending in the Colorado Water Court. The court must determine how the rights have historically been used, including how often they called for water and how much water was involved. It must also determine what limits and safeguards are needed to prevent harm to other water rights.

In January 2026, the County filed a statement of opposition in support of the application. That filing makes the County a party to the case so it can support the proposed change while advocating for safeguards that protect local water users.

No final court decision has been made. A trial is scheduled for July 2028. The purchase has not closed and current hydropower operations continue. The purchase also depends on other steps, including securing the required funding and receiving Colorado Public Utilities Commission approval.

The County’s interest is tied to the river’s importance to Mesa County’s economy and quality of life.

Mesa County will continue to participate in the case and share updates as the process moves forward.

Bicycling the Colorado National Monument, Grand Valley in the distance via Colorado.com

The Central #Arizona Project steps back from project to boost #ColoradoRiver snow with cloud seeding — KJZZ #COriver #aridification

Cloud-seeding graphic via Science Matters

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

November 10, 2026

The Central Arizona Project, or CAP, operates a 336-mile-long canal system that carries water from the Colorado River, across the desert, and into the Phoenix and Tucson areas. Since 2007, it has been part of a collaborative effort to run cloud seeding equipment in Colorado, Utah and Wyoming. In a close vote at its latest board meeting, the agency chose not to renew funding for the programโ€™s next chapter. Cloud seeding is a technology that can help boost snow totals in the mountains where the Colorado River begins. It is done by releasing particles into the air that cannot make new snow, but can essentially tell clouds where to drop their moisture. The program has brought together water users that benefit from faraway snowmelt โ€” like CAP, water agencies in Las Vegas and Los Angeles and major farming districts in Southern California โ€” and agencies that manage water near the snowy mountains themselves…

In recent years, water agencies in Arizona, California and Nevada have sent about $1.5 million per year to upstream cloud seeding work. Going forward, each agencyโ€™s funding for cloud seeding work would be capped at $525,000 per year in 2027 and gradually climb to $750,000 per year in 2036. CAP board members questioned whether Colorado River users in Arizona would be getting their moneyโ€™s worth.

โ€œIt’s hard to see how this is really going to help our customers, especially in the environment that we’re working in right now, and our taxpayers,โ€ said Alexandra Arboleda, a CAP board member who voted against renewing funding for the program.

Some board members expressed concern over the efficacy of cloud seeding. Scientific studies of the technology have proven that it can add snow in mountain areas, but research is limited on exactly how much.

โ€œThe science says it works, but the outcome is difficult to really measure at the end of the dayโ€ said Stephen Miller, a CAP board member who voted against renewing funding for the program. “That’s where the skepticism comes in.โ€

Scientists and technicians who implement cloud seeding in the Rocky Mountains are confident that it can meaningfully bring snow to places it is needed, and CAP experts made that case to board members. Nolie Templeton, CAPโ€™s Colorado River policy and analysis manager, pointed to studies that suggest up to 20% boosts to snowpack.

A panoramic view of Salt Lake City, June 2009. By Jonnyapple – Own work, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=6967127

Colorado River District Releases New Financial Planning Toolkit for West Slope Irrigation Companies — Matt Aboussie (ColoradoRiverDistrict.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Photo credit: Jonathan Thompson

Click the link to read the release on the Colorado River District website (Matt Aboussie)

November 9, 2026

Free toolkit helps irrigation water providers plan for infrastructure investments, evaluate financial needs, and improve long-term stability.

The Colorado River Districtโ€™s Community Funding Partnership program has released a new Irrigation Company Financial Assessment Toolkit. This free, downloadable resource is designed to help irrigation and ditch companies across the Western Slope evaluate their financial health, plan for aging infrastructure, and make informed decisions about long-term operations and maintenance.

Approved by the River District Board in April 2026 and developed through the River Districtโ€™s Community Funding Partnership (CFP) in partnership with SGM, Inc., the toolkit provides irrigation company boards, managers, and operators a practical way to assess budgetary needs and explore financial strategies to maintain and modernize critical water infrastructure.

Many Western Slope irrigation systems face mounting challenges as infrastructure ages, maintenance costs rise, and outside funding becomes increasingly competitive and uncertain. The new toolkit helps irrigation water providers take a proactive approach by strengthening local financial planning and increasing financial independence to better navigate fluctuating grants and external funding sources.

โ€œWest Slope agriculture depends on irrigation infrastructure that, in many cases, has been serving communities for nearly a century,โ€ said Melissa Wills, Community Funding Partnership Program Manager for the Colorado River District. โ€œOur goal is to give irrigation companies practical tools to understand their financial position, anticipate future expenses, and make informed decisions that will keep their systems operating for generations to come.โ€

The user-friendly, spreadsheet-based toolkit allows irrigation providers to privately enter information about their existing rate structures, revenues, expenses, debt obligations, and anticipated capital improvement costs. Using this information, the toolkit helps companies evaluate potential rate structures and financial scenarios aligned with their operational needs and long-term goals.

The toolkit also includes instructions and financial management guidance to support decision-making by irrigation company boards and managers. Companies can download and use the toolkit independently, without sharing their financial information with the River District.

Learn more about the Community Funding Partnership and explore the new toolkit on our website here: coloradoriverdistrict.org/grantee-resources.

A map showing the boundaries of the Colorado River District, and its 15 member counties

Eagle River Coalition Announces Opposition to Aurora Waterโ€™s Wild Horse Reservoir Application as Submitted: A 19th-century solution to a 21st-century problem — Matt Moseley

Credit: WildHorseReservoir.org

From email from Matt Moseley:

November 12, 2026 โ€” The Eagle River Coalition announced its opposition to Aurora Waterโ€™s application to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) for its proposed 95,000-acre-foot Wild Horse Reservoir in Park County, arguing that too many questions remain about the projectโ€™s water sources and potential impacts on Homestake Creek, the Eagle River, and the Colorado River Basin.

Of particular concern is the amount of water the project may require from the Homestake system and the potential consequences for an already heavily diverted watershed. In a recent interview with the Vail Daily, Aurora Water acknowledged that it was โ€œdifficult to provide specificsโ€ about how much Homestake water would be needed for Wild Horse.

โ€œThat is precisely the problem,โ€ said Vicki Flynn, executive director of the Eagle River Coalition. โ€œIf Aurora Water cannot provide specifics about how much water it needs from Homestake Creek, how can CDPHE adequately evaluate the project’s impacts? Our rivers and communities deserve clear answers before a project of this scale moves forward. The application, as currently submitted, should be rejected.โ€

A growing coalition, such as the Vail Valley Partnership, is calling on CDPHE to reject the application and require a complete accounting of the project’s water sources, the volume and timing of proposed diversions, potential changes to existing transmountain diversion operations, and cumulative impacts on streamflows and downstream communities.

The Eagle River Coalition recognizes the importance of long-term water planning but believes new storage proposals must be evaluated transparently and with full consideration of impacts to the rivers and communities that sustain the Western Slope.

โ€œThis is a 19th-century solution to a 21st-century problem,โ€ said Flynn.

The public comment period closes November 19, 2026. The Coalition encourages residents, businesses and river users to submit comments to CDPHE at cdphe_df_wqcd@state.co.us with the subject line WHS PN Comments.

Map of the Eagle River drainage basin in Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69310517

Interview with Amy Haas: Even with heavy rainfall, #LakePowell is still about 6 feet lower than a year ago — KJZZ.org #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Tracked Colorado River system reservoirs in flow order, each drawn filled to its percent-full reading as of November 11, 2026. Blue Mesa (Gunnison), Flaming Gorge (Green) and Navajo (San Juan) are upper-basin tributary storage; their water reaches the mainstem through Lake Powell. Credit: ReservoirBench.com

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Lauren Gilger). Here’s an excerpt:

November 11, 2026

LAUREN GILGER: We just heard before the break how devastating the impacts of all of the rain weโ€™ve seen this fall can be. But now, letโ€™s turn to a conversation about the other side of that story, and itโ€™s at least partially good.

We know weโ€™re facing a dire water future and an ongoing fight over water from one of our main sources, the Colorado River. Well, that water is stored in two big reservoirs up in northern Arizona, Lake Powell and Lake Mead, and they are both historically low. In fact, just a few months ago, in mid-September, Lake Powell sat just 146 feet above dead pool, the level at which thereโ€™s not enough water to flow downstream through Glen Canyon Dam.

So how much has this historic rainfall helped those drying-up reservoirs? I took that question to Amy Haas, executive director of the Colorado River Authority of Utah, and she told me itโ€™s a dramatically different situation than what we were looking at just a few months ago.

AMY HAAS: In mid-September, we saw the record low at Lake Powell. Lake Powell hit elevation 3,516 feet and change in mid-September. And today, fast forward, less than two months, we are seeing an elevation at Powell of 3,538 feet. So this is basically a net gain in elevation of about 22 feet from the all-time low at Powell in mid-September…

AMY HAAS: So while itโ€™s been a blessing, we are not out of the woods in terms of these critically low reservoir elevations. And again, weโ€™re still significantly lower than we were just exactly a year ago.

LAUREN GILGER: So we have taken a little bit of a step back from the edge, but we are nowhere near where we need to be, it sounds like.

AMY HAAS: Absolutely. And weโ€™re still very early in the water year. Lake Powell inflows, Lake Powell is most affected based on snowmelt. And we wonโ€™t know what our water year really sets up to be until we see what our winter looks like and any sort of snowmelt runoff into the reservoir. So itโ€™s still early days, and I think while this is a very auspicious sign, weโ€™ve still got to be mindful that weโ€™ve got a lot of months to go.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#Nevada Judge Could Dictate Wyoming’s Future Share Of #ColoradoRiver Water — Cowboy State Daily #COriver #aridification

Wyoming State Engineer Brandon Gebhart, left, and state water attorney Chris Brown updated lawmakers on Friday about escalating tensions over Colorado River water rights. (Courtesy Wyoming Legislative Service Office)

Click the link to read the article on the Cowboy State Daily website (Mark Heinz). Here’s an excerpt:

November 6, 2026

As Nevada and Arizona prepare for a federal court battle with the U.S. Department of the Interior over dwindling water supplies from the Colorado River, state officials are warning legislators that Wyoming could be impacted by the fight. State Engineerย Brandon Gebhardt represents Wyoming on the Upper Colorado River Commission. On Friday in Casper, he told the Legislatureโ€™s Select Water Committee that the commission hadnโ€™t yet decided whether the four Upper Basin states will intervene in the court battle.

Water committee co-chair Rep. Martha Lawley, R-Worland, said the potential effects of the federal court battle involving Nevada on Wyoming canโ€™t be taken lightly.

โ€œWe could end up in a situation where a federal court in the state of Nevada could be taking over the (water) management. Really, the job of the Bureau of Reclamation,โ€ she said.

Gebhardt was joined in updating the committee by Chris Brown, supervising attorney general for the water section in the Wyoming Attorney Generalโ€™s Office. At one point, Lawley asked Brown if her assessment of the situation was accurate.

โ€œMadame Chair, from my personal perspective, you are on target,โ€ Brown responded.

Brown at one point suggested that tensions over the Colorado River could end up before the Supreme Court.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Coloradoโ€™s anemic water flows could have been worse if not for a vote 6 years ago — #Colorado Public Radio

The Colorado River in McInnis Canyons National Conservation Area, near Grand Junction, Colorado, on April 26, 2019. Photo by Mitch Tobin/The Water Desk

Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Public Radio website (Tom Hesse). Here’s an excerpt:

November 9, 2026

Western Colorado saw paltry water flows this summer, but in some parts of Western Colorado, that depressed runoff highlighted infrastructure improvements that are slowly making the region more resilient to drought.

โ€œWhen you really see the difference is in summers like this โ€” when we just have a little bit of water, and we have to be extremely intentional and efficient with it,โ€ Melissa Wills, a program manager with the Colorado River District, said. โ€œIf you are relying on 100-year-old infrastructure, it’s going to be a difficult summer.โ€

Wills manages the Community Funding Partnership, a program funded through a 2020 ballot question. That measure increased property taxes by almost $2 for every $100,000 in value to support water projects and passed with more than 70% support during the 2020 general election. In the five years the program has been funded, itโ€™s dolled out around $34 million in grant funds across Western Colorado, funding everything from canal improvements to studies researching alternative forage plants better suited to drier climates…Wills said most of the grants are meant to give local entities a leg up on applying for bigger-dollar prizes. An irrigation district may not stand out in the Bureau of Reclamation grant field, but an irrigation district with a $50,000 head start on their proposal is a different story…

In the Roaring Fork Valley, funds generated by the 2020 ballot measure contributed to a multi-agency effort to restore a part of the Crystal River that runs through Carbondaleโ€™s Riverfront Park. The restoration included removing invasive plants, stabilizing the riverbank and creating a low-flow channel for the river that served to improve fish habitat and flow to one of the townโ€™s major ditch diversions. Heather Lewin with the Roaring Fork Conservancy said the restored river saw better streamflows this year, despite the poor snowpack, compared to past low-water years. Notably, Lewin said, the improvements allow the city to avoid having to create temporary โ€œpush-upโ€ dams in low-water years when heavy equipment was needed to divert meager flows to keep water going where it needed to.

โ€œIn those low flow years, that cobble push-up dam spanned the whole reach of the river along with the damage that it did moving about a quarter mile upstream, instream, pushing cobbles in a stretch where you only had maybe an inch or two of water to begin with,โ€ Lewin said. โ€œThe instream benefits of not creating that additional stressor in a year when we’re dealing with low flows and high temperature already has a huge benefit to that reach as well.โ€

Water savings from the project are difficult to measure, but Lewin said the improvements in fish habitat and flows to the diversion ditch have been notable. Sheโ€™s hopeful the restoration effort can be replicated in other places.

Map of the Roaring Fork River drainage basin in western Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69290878

Why did Andy Mueller drive to Rocky Ford?: Manager of Colorado River District agreed to talk to farmers and ranchers in lower #ArkansasRiver Valley. He had a reason — Allen Best (BigPivots.com) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Crowley County 40 years after water transfers dried up farmland. Photo credit: LexNichols

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

November 7, 2026

Rocky Ford has long been known for its cantaloupes, of course. Best in Colorado, and many places beyond.

Cantaloupe season is long past. So why was Andy Mueller willing to drive all the way from Glenwood Springs this week to speak at a water meeting in Rocky Ford?

The simple answer is that because Mueller, the general manager of the Colorado River Water Conservation District, was asked. The ask occurred last winter in the hallway of a conference center in Loveland where the Colorado Cattlemenโ€™s Association was meeting. Muellerโ€™s district includes much of Western Colorado which, other than the ski valleys, remains heavily agricultural.

Making the request was Jack Goble, who has an office in Rocky Ford, headquarters for the Lower Arkansas River Water Conservancy District. He was planning to stage the districtโ€™s first water summit, and he thought Mueller would be a valuable speaker, to lend perspective.

After all, they share a water source: the Colorado River.

Colorado has four water conservation districts, all of them created by state legislators. The Colorado River District was created in 1939 and encompasses 15 of the 20 Western Slope counties.

Southwestern Colorado also has a conservation district, as do the San Luis Valley and the Republic River Basin. They are charged with protecting and developing their water resources. In all cases, with diminishing river flows or, in the case of the Republican River Basin, declining groundwater levels, protecting is the operative word.

Conservancy districts, in contrast, can be formed by local communities, subject to approval of district courts. They are typically formed to build, finance, and operate local dams, reservoirs, and other water infrastructure. Colorado has more than 50 water conservancy districts, and sometimes there are several within the confines of a conservation district.

Cantaloupes gett harvested in lower Arkansas River Valley. Photo/LexNichols

The Lower Arkansas River Water Conservancy District was formed in 2002, a notorious drought year, but in response to what even then was a growing concern.

Since the 1970s, Front Range communities have looked covetously at the water flowing down the Arkansas River to be used for agriculture. Crowley County, located northeast of Pueblo, has become the poster child for buy-and-dry. See above photo.

The cities โ€” including Colorado Springs but also Aurora โ€” have found willing sellers from among the farmers. But taken together, the communities in the district worry about being left with only enough water to flow into Kansas as necessary to meet the compact obligations governing the Arkansas River. That would gut their already thin and struggling economies.

The inaugural Ark Valley meeting drew maybe 150 people, reported Goble, including farmers and ranchers up and down the valley but many from outside the district. State Sen. Cleave Simpson, the manager of the Rio Grande Water Conservation District (and Senate minority leader), was there from Alamosa, as were Jim Yahn and Joe Frank from Sterling.

In creating this water summit, said Goble, the intent was to โ€œhelp those in Lower Arkansas River Valley get engaged and informed on water issues, because it will determine our future, what happens with water.โ€

The Colorado River District holds similar meetings. The first was held in 2004 and attracted just a few dozen people. It now attracts about 300 to Grand Junction each September with dozens more watching remotely.

In Rocky Ford, Russ Schumacher, the state climatologist, spoke about the warming and mostly drying climate. Sean Cronin, manager of Boulder Countyโ€™s St. Vrain and Left Hand Water Conservancy District, also spoke.

A highlight was the unveiling of a new interactive website called โ€œWhen Water Leaves: The Story of a Buy-and-Dry in Coloradoโ€™s Lower Arkansas River.โ€ The website is part history lesson, part polemic. It tells the story of how communities took root in the 19th century, how canals were built, how farms were created.

It also tells about how more than 100,000 acres of historically irrigated farmland have dried up in the five-county area from Pueblo downstream to the Kansas border. Of those, 40,000 acres dried up due to water that now goes to Front Range cities.

The StoryMap identifies 40,000 additional irrigated acres at high risk of permanent dry-up. Models provided by The Freshwater Trust estimate $184 million in lost economic output.

โ€œOne community should not be sacrificed for the growth of another,โ€ said Goble in the press release that was issued concurrent with the meeting in Rocky Ford. โ€œColorado should not grow its cities by drying up the agricultural communities that feed them.โ€

The website is nifty. If you are at all curious about the Lower Arkansas River Valley, you will want to check it out.

The Arkansas River originates near Leadville. There, the flows of the river are augmented by several transmountain diversions, most of them small in quantity but two notably bigger. Largest is the Fryingpan-Arkansas Project, a federal diversion launched in 1963 to divert 55,000 acre-feet annually (on average) from the Fryingpan River above Basalt. The somewhat older Twin Lakes project diverts 38,000 acre-feet from the Roaring Fork River headwaters above Aspen.

Water imported into the Arkansas River Basin is prized because it can be used without having to deliver return flows into the river. In other words, it can in turn be diverted out of the basin to Aurora, for example, which can then recycle the water. Colorado Springs, too, can recycle the water.

These diversions use Colorado River water, which is where Andy Mueller comes in. At his districtโ€™s annual meeting in Grand Junction, speaker after speaker has laid out the science of the warming climate.

Andy Mueller, general manager of the Colorado River Water Conservation District, has used the districtโ€™s annual forum in Grand Junction as a way to convey the need for planning for a time of less water. Photo credit: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

Mueller himself said two years ago that those who depend upon the Colorado River need to start planning for the day that it delivers only 9 million acre-feet. During the 20th century, it delivered an average 15.2 million acre-feet. In this century, the annual average has been 12.5. In recent years, it has fallen further to 10 million acre-feet.

The question then becomes: where will cities get their water? The simple answer is from agriculture, which uses 75% of the water in the Colorado River.

After returning from Rocky Ford, Mueller told me that his Western Slope district has policies focused on protecting agriculture, especially within its 15-county district. โ€œBut identifying the threat to agriculture in our state is really important,โ€ he said.

The seven basin states have infamously come up short in agreeing how to address the reality of a river that is dramatically underdelivering what was assumed by the 1922 compact and the infrastructure subsequently built to deliver the water to farms, especially, but also cities.

Consider, for example, that two tunnels from the Colorado River headwaters (Roberts, from Dillon Reservoir, and Moffat, from Winter Park) deliver roughly half of Denver Waterโ€™s supply for its 1.5 million customers in Denver and suburbs). These diversions are junior to the 1922 compact.

If the disagreement between the seven basin states ends up before the Supreme Court, how will that court rule?

โ€œThere is a risk that the Supreme Court will disagree with us,โ€ explained Mueller. โ€œAnd because of that risk, I am concerned that water mangers throughout the state will need to go look for replacement water for their Colorado River Water.โ€

That gives the Glenwood Springs-based conservation district commonality with the farmers in the Lower Arkansas River as well as those in the Rio Grande Basin and the South Platte.

โ€œI donโ€™t want the lower Ark to be dried up, and I donโ€™t want the lower South Platte to be dried up, and I certainly donโ€™t want the Colorado Basin to be dried up,โ€ said Mueller.

โ€œI will also say this: The River District does its best work when it builds coalitions of like-minded partners, and I think the areas I just mentioned all have values very similar to the River District policies in terms of preserving agriculture. We are only impactful when we operate in coalitions.โ€

Mueller worries that the negotiations among the states will erupt into overt bitterness. โ€œIt will make the battle over the wolf reintroduction look like childโ€™s play,โ€ he said, referring to Coloradoโ€™s intra-state dispute.

Colorado Rivers. Credit: Geology.com

Mancos issues boil/bottle water advisory after flooding disrupts treatment plant: Water from the Mancos municipal system is not safe to drink following flooding — The #Cortez Journal

Mancos middle and high school students volunteered to help fill sandbags for community members in need of them following recent flooding. The town of Mancos was also required to issue a boil/bottle water advisory on Friday due to unsafe water in the municipal water system. (Courtesy of Town Hall of Mancos Facebook)

Click the link to read the article on The Cortez Journal website (Bailey Duran). Here’s an excerpt:

The town of Mancos issued a boil/bottle water advisory Friday for customers of its municipal water system after flooding forced the release of โ€œinadequately treatedโ€ water. The Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment required the advisory.

โ€œDue to ongoing impacts from the recent flooding, the town was required to allow inadequately treated water into the distribution system to maintain system pressure,โ€ the town said on its Facebook page.

The advisory will remain in effect until the health department determines the water is safe again and issues written authorization. All water in homes and businesses served by the town system is not considered safe and should only be used for flushing toilets until further notice. Residents on Mancos Rural Water or private wells are not affected.

Travel is not advised to the San Juan National Forest: Severe flooding has damaged Forest roads and infrastructure, extent unknown — Lorena Williams (USFS) #SanJuanRiver

Credit: San Juan National Forest

Click the link to read the release on the USFS website:

November 2, 2026

Travel on San Juan National Forest System Roads is strongly discouraged and not advised due to life-threatening hazards. Record flooding across Southwest Colorado has left San Juan National Forest roads, trails, and other infrastructure inaccessible, severely damaged and, in many cases, unpassable. Highways across multiple counties are closed, and evacuation and shelter-in-place orders have been issued for multiple communities. Donโ€™t become a statisticโ€”rescue will not be readily available due to the current demand for search and rescue services.

โ€œPublic safety is our top priority, which is why we do not recommend travel on the San Juan National Forest at this time,โ€ said Forest Supervisor Steve Hattenback on Monday morning. โ€œWe will not begin to assess the extent of the damage until flood waters recede and our staff can begin to assess forest conditions. What we do know is that flood waters are extremely high, many roads and bridges are completely destroyed, and unsafe conditions persist on all three San Juan National Forest districts. We encourage the public to monitor the situation closely, and to postpone or cancel plans to visit the woods until conditions improve.โ€

Offices Closed: All offices are closed at this time:

  • Pagosa District Office (phones and internet also down)
  • Durango Forest Headquarters
  • Dolores District Office
  • Columbine District Office is closed Mon โ€“ Thurs, and is expected to be open for its regular office hours on Friday.

Additional Resources:

If you know of a forest visitor trapped down an unpassable road who needs evacuation help in:

  • Archuleta County, call 9-1-1 or the non-emergency dispatch line at 970-731-2160 when they are ready to be evacuated.
  • La Plata County, call 9-1-1 if an emergency, or non-emergency dispatch at 970-385-2900.

Please report abandoned property information if you are forced to leave vehicles behind by emailing the San Juan National Forest at: sm.fs.sanjuannf@usda.gov with the subject line of Personal Property. Please provide your name, phone number, license plates, description of property, and a detailed location, in addition to any other pertinent information.

For information on the San Juan National Forest, call (970) 247-4874, visit the forest website, or follow us on Facebook.

The 2026 Deluge: Aftermath; Day of the Dead Flood moves into third biggest on record on the #AnimasRiver in #Durango — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #SanJuanRiver

The Animas River at Oxbow Park in north Durango on Nov. 2. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

November 4, 2026

Oh, Water, you give and take away. Following one of the driest years on record, the water once again came pouring out of the sky and raging through the streams and rivers, setting new high-water records, bringing new life to the parched earth, and wreaking havoc and destruction wherever waterways and humanity intersected.

The rains stopped two days ago, but streams in southwestern Colorado continue to run at levels that would have been considered abnormally high a month ago. North of Durango, a tree careening down Hermosa Creek got wedged underneath the railroad bridge, creating a dam of sorts and forcing the muddy waters to jump the bank and run through a trailer park and neighborhoods, forcing more evacuations and closing Highway 550. Several other Durango area roads remain closed due to washouts or debris.

Junction Creek in Durango on the morning of Nov. 2, 2026. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Other roads remain closed throughout the region. Highway 160 between Bayfield and Pagosa is shut down because the Piedra River โ€” which exceeded 17,000 cfs yet again โ€” washed out the highway bridge. Hwy 151 from Chimney Rock to Arboles remains closed after being wrecked by the previous flood. Hwy 160 over Wolf Creek Pass is shut, as is Hwy 17 over Cumbres Pass between Chama and Antonito. These closures have basically marooned Pagosa, which suffered serious damage during this round of flooding.

In Utah, State Road 162 north of Montezuma Creek remains closed โ€” this is one of the stretches of road that was totally overhauled over the last couple of years. And Hwy 163 between Mexican Hat and Bluff is shut down after Comb Wash took a big bite out of the highway bridge.

Meanwhile, hundreds of affected residents are just beginning the long ordeal of cleaning up and attempting to cope with this disaster.

Having lived through a flood that filled my home with nine feet of water, I can imagine what these people have gone through, and the difficult journey they face ahead of them. Itโ€™s heartbreaking to consider, and pains me even to write it down, yet it seems necessary. (Itโ€™s equally heartening to see the communities come together to rescue and support those most affected).

After the sheer panic that hits when you realize the water is rising in your front yard; the adrenalin that sets in as you try to gather up loved ones, pets, important documents, and the phone and the laptop and wade through thigh-deep water in the yard; the elation that follows your escape and survival, comes the devastation of returning to your home, walking inside, and seeing furniture and appliances and books and possessions strewn about as if a mischievous god had picked up the house and shook it. If your home is still there, that is.

Every surface that was under water will be blanketed with fine, dense, tenacious mud. It will coat clothing. In many cases the mud itself will be tainted with sewage or other waste, and as the waters subside, a fecund odor infuses everything. Particle wood rots, drywall deteriorates, hardwoods warp, mold grows. When the mud dries it becomes quasi-sandstone that can be near impossible to remove; break it up and it turns to fine dust that is hazardous to inhale. For months or even years after the cleanup and renovations are done, people who were flooded will find the mud embedded in items or clothing.

Floods donโ€™t discriminate, and are as likely to damage multi-million dollar homes as they are to inundate trailer parks. But the financial burden of recovery and cleanup weighs far heavier on low- and even middle-income folks. Many standard homeowners insurance policies do not include flood insurance, and your average homeowner or renter is likely to forego supplemental flood coverage because itโ€™s very expensive, especially for homes in historic floodplains or near waterways.

Iโ€™d like to believe this was an anomaly, something we can look back on as a sort of freak occurrence that, eventually, will be so unusual that it will feel as if it were unreal, something that became exaggerated by the passing of time. The 1911 Flood feels that way to me sometimes. How is it possible that the Animas River carried nearly twice the flows we saw on Nov. 2? Surely that could never happen again. Right?

And yet, we know this was not an anomaly because the early November deluge was the fifth abnormally high precipitation event of the previous six weeks, which was capped off by two record-breaking, catastrophic flooding events. On the one hand this is historic, unprecedented, a once-in-a-century event; on the other hand it could become nearly routine in our rapidly changing climate.

Either way, if my experience is any indication, one thing is almost certain: The people affected by these floods will feel a tinge of anxiety every time the weather forecast calls for heavy rain.

The Animas River at Santa Rita Park on Nov. 2, 2026, when it was running at about 12,100 cfs. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

The second flood of 2026 (and water year 2027) was the third largest on record at the USGS streamflow gage on the Animas River in Durango, with a peak flow of 13,000 cubic feet per second. That puts it ahead of both 1949 and 1970, but still well behind both 1911 (water year 1912) and 1927.

โ€ Peak flow on Nov. 2, 2026. โ€ โ€ Peak flow on Oct. 23, 2026. This is listed as 2027 because it occurred during the 2027 Water Year, which goes from Oct. 1, 2026, to Sept. 30, 2027.

Itโ€™s interesting to see how the Animas Riverโ€™s streamflows change over the course of the 45 miles or so between the Durango gage and the Farmington one. On Nov. 2, the Animas appears to have gained about 6,900 cfs over that stretch of river, while on Oct. 23 it only gained 800 cfs. A lot of this came from the two major tributaries โ€” Lightner Creek and the Florida River โ€” joining the Animas downstream from the Durango gage, along with numerous washes and arroyos adding their load.

Meanwhile, back in 1970 the peak streamflow in Farmington was 700 cfs lower than it was in Durango. Iโ€™m not sure how to explain that one.

Hereโ€™s some video and commentary I made at Santa Rita Park in Durango when the river was around 12,100 cfs. It would still gain another 900 cfs before peaking later that day: https://www.landdesk.org/p/live-with-jonathan-p-thompson

Election update: Clean water wins big in key ballot measures, recent clean water ballot measure victories show how communities are investing in healthier rivers, safer drinking water, and stronger protections — Sinjin Eberle (AmericanRivers.org)

Vinica Brook watershed, Massachusetts | ยฉ 2022 Jerry and Marcy Monkman/EcoPhotographyVinica

Click the link to read the article on the American Rivers website (Sinjin Eberle):

November 4, 2026

The midterm election showed that voters are clamoring for practical solutions to their communitiesโ€™ problems. So, while some of the results were a surprise, it is no surprise that voters approved nearly a billion dollars for clean water and healthy rivers on election day, demonstrating once again that water is a powerful unifying value with strong bipartisan support.

Action for water has taken on new urgency in recent years, as pollution threatens drinking water sources, infrastructure is crumbling nationwide, and communities are at risk of weather extremes from flooding to water scarcity.

Where water policy won on the ballot

This November, the American Rivers Action Fund supported five ballot measures to advance solutions at the local and state level:

Buffalo River, Arkansas | Angela Peace

In Arkansas, voters across the state approved Issue 4, authorizing a $500 million bond to provide critical funding to upgrade or build new clean water infrastructure for communities and agriculture. Other supporters of the measure include the Arkansas Farm Bureau, Arkansas Water and Wastewater Managers Association, Agricultural Council of Arkansas, and The Nature Conservancy, among many others.

In Massachusetts, the Action Fund supported the statewide Yes on 6 campaign to redirect an existing tax on sporting goods into conservation programs and projects, including those working for clean, safe, reliable drinking water, floodplain and river restoration, and open space. We partnered with Massachusetts Audubon, The Nature Conservancy, and Trust for Public Lands among a wide array of local conservation and land trust organizations to support this measure.

The American Rivers Action Fund also supported two county measures where water was on the ballot. In Dubuque County, Iowa, voters strongly approved a measure to provide $18 million for floodplain restoration, agricultural clean water projects, and riverside open space along the Mississippi River. We worked with the Iowa Natural Heritage Foundation, numerous land trusts, and Dubuque County to promote this important initiative in a rural county. And in Delaware County, Pennsylvaniathe Action Fund supported partners including Natural Lands, Trust for Public Lands, and others in passing an initiative to provide a $120 million dollar bonding authority to protect the water, natural areas, and wildlife across a county with increasingly urgent development pressure.

Upper Colorado River, Colorado | Russ Schnitzer

Similarly in Colorado, the Action Fund supported Proposition 137, which also will redirect a previously established tax on sporting goods into conservation purposes, including healthy rivers, wildfire prevention, and wildfire-ready watersheds. This measure will provide around $175 million per year for substantial investments across the state. Other supporters included The Nature Conservancy, Western Resource Advocates, Trust for Public Lands, and many others.

What recent clean water ballot wins tell us about the future

This latest round of successes builds on recent momentum. In July, Texas voters approved Proposition 4, with a record $20B for water over the next 20 years โ€“ the largest statewide ballot initiative to be passed in the country โ€“ was led by the National Wildlife Federation, Environmental Defense Fund, and others. And this past August, voters in Missouri overwhelmingly approved a measure to renew the stateโ€™s constitutional fund for state parks, agricultural water conservation programs, and healthy rivers and floodplains. The measure was backed by financial and communications support by the American Rivers Action Fund and won with over 82% approval statewide. Partners included the Missouri Farm Bureau, Trust for Public Lands, hunting and sporting groups, and land trusts and State Parks organizations across the state.

โ€œFamilies feel the consequences when their water isnโ€™t safe and their rivers arenโ€™t healthy,โ€ said Heather Taylor-Miesle, Executive Director of the American Rivers Action Fund. โ€œThey feel it in their pocketbooks, they worry about the safety of the water their kids are drinking, and theyโ€™re tired of mucking out their basements when it floods. These latest ballot wins prove that voters want real action. Nationwide, weโ€™re seeing a growing wave of momentum across the political spectrum demanding clean water and healthy rivers. When water is on the ballot, water wins.โ€

Created by Imgur user Fejetlenfej , a geographer and GIS analyst with a โ€˜lifelong passion for beautiful maps.โ€™ It highlights the massive expanse of river basins across the country โ€“ in particular, those which feed the Mississippi River, in pink.

Relentless rain, stubborn saturation: Historic flooding hits the Four Corners region once again — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #SanJuanRiver #AnimasRiver

A slough in the west Animas Valley north of Durango. The wetlands pictured here have been mostly drylands in recent years, but filled up and saturated surrounding ground during the previous high water in late October. Now itโ€™s rising again as torrential rains pound the region. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

November 1, 2026

โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Itโ€™s Sunday afternoon, the first day of November, and if tomorrow is the Day of the Dead, today is the Day of the Deluge here where I sit, a couple miles north of Durango. A hard rain has fallen relentlessly for the past 15 hours or so, only occasionally easing up for a few minutes at a time. An hour ago, the La Plata County Sheriff sent out an alert closing all county roads due to flooding conditions. While the segment of county road Iโ€™m on remains passable, numerous other roads have shut down themselves as debris flows bring mud, silt, and high water onto the roadways.

In need of provisions, and with a journalistic desire to see what the hell was happening out there, a friend and I ventured out to find waterfalls spilling off of Animas Mountain onto the highway into town, bringing rocks and silt with them. The liquor store, abiding by the shelter-in-place order, was just closing up for the day as we arrived.

Reports poured in about flooding around town: Highway 160 just east of town had turned to a river after Lightner Creek apparently jumped its banks; Junction Creek also was flooding, affecting some homes and forcing evacuations. To the south, San Juan County, New Mexicoโ€™s Office of Emergency Management urged all residents within a half mile of the San Juan, Animas, and La Plata rivers to head to higher ground. As the text alerts reached phones, and the serious of the situation became apparent, the roads emptied out.

So far, the flooding is mostly limited to arroyos and smaller waterways, but the major rivers continue to rise. Parts of Pagosa Springs and surrounding areas along the San Juan River are under a mandatory evacuation order as I write this, and the river is forecast to crest around 19.71 feet, or about four feet higher than the Oct. 23 peak (9,100 cubic feet per second). If it reaches that point, it will not only cause catastrophic damage, but would also be larger than the 1911 flood, making it the largest on record, by far.

Even if the river levels donโ€™t meet or exceed those of October 1911, this autumnโ€™s deluges are still historic. Autumn storms and floods are not uncommon in this area. But to have a succession of storms this big, dumping this much moisture, and bringing multiple rivers and streams to record or near-record levels over just a few weeks, is very unusual and possibly unprecedented, at least over the last 130 years or so. Itโ€™s also extraordinarily challenging for those who live in the path of these rivers, arroyos, and streams โ€” people who are only beginning to muck out the sewage-tainted silt from the last flood a week ago.

Also somewhat freakish is the timing: Flooding on Nov. 1 is odd because typically the moisture would be falling as snow by this time of year, which would keep the moisture on the ground rather than in the streams. Yet as of Sunday afternoon, it was still coming down as rain and Schneeregen up to about 11,000 feet in elevation, melting existing snow and leading to big streamflows in high country creeks and rivers. The snow-line is expected to drop considerably later tonight, snarling travel while also creating a nice base for the snowpack. If it comes soon enough, it may even keep some of that moisture out of the streams โ€” at least until next spring, when itโ€™s needed.

In the meantime, we sit and wait and watch nervously to see what the rivers will do.

Some notable streamflow data from around the region, as of Nov. 1 at about 5 p.m. (keeping in mind this is all provisional, real-time data):

  • McElmo Creek near the Colorado-Utah state line hit 1,610 cfs at 2:45 pm on Nov. 1, which is about 30 cfs higher than the Oct. 22 high mark.
  • The Piedra River near Arboles was at 16,800 cfs at 8 p.m. on Nov. 1, just 200 cfs short of its peak during last weekโ€™s floods (when the gage was knocked out of commission).

  • The San Juan River at Pagosa Springs was at 11,000 cfs at 7 p.m. โ€” 2,000 cfs higher than last weekโ€™s flood โ€” and still rising. The gage height is on track to exceed 1911โ€™s, though itโ€™s not yet clear that the streamflow will beat 1911โ€™s 25,000 cfs. Either way, it will be devastating.
  • The Animas River at the gage in Durango was at 4,790 cfs and still rising at 4:30 p.m. At the same time, the gage just downstream (below the confluence with Lightner Creek) 7,010 cfs, indicating that Lightner Creek was somewhere around 1,200 cfs (thereโ€™s no gage on that stream).

Thatโ€™s nothing compared to what was going on further south and west โ€ฆ

  • Oak Creek near Cornville, Arizona, jumped from 165 cfs to over 27,000 cfs in a matter of hours on Nov. 1.
  • The Salt River just upstream from Roosevelt Reservoir was at 107,000 cfs and rising at 5 p.m. on Nov. 1. Thatโ€™s an insanely huge amount of water. Itโ€™s also the third highest flow on record in over a century.

  • The Agua Fria River near Rock Springs, Arizona, was virtually dry a few weeks ago. Today, it reached 22,900 cfs.
  • The Verde River below Tangle Creek in central Arizona was at 89,000 cfs at 6:14 p.m. on Nov. 1.

Thatโ€™s it for now. Iโ€™ll be trying to put this all into context if and when the waters subside โ€ฆ

How this #ColoradoRiver disaster can be averted: Brad Udall remains hopeful a settlement will be negotiated but warns that huge changes will be needed in response to #ClimateChange — Allen Best (BigPivots.com) #COriver #aridification

Brad Udall. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

November 3, 2026

Brad Udall remains hopeful a settlement will be negotiated but warns that huge changes will be needed in response to climate change. Might prior appropriation be one of them?

Colorado State Universityโ€™s Brad Udall makes the case that the Colorado River Basin is the worldโ€™s first place where climate change is โ€œforcing a complete redo of water management.โ€

The climate change component of that statement seems unassailable. Flows in the Colorado River have declined 21% this century. A river that averaged 15.2 million acre-feet in flows during the 20thcentury has fallen to 12.2 million acre-feet in the 21st. It has further tapered off to 10 million acre-feet in the last few years.

Temperature increases of 3.3 degrees Fahrenheit since 1970 explain much of that decline. A one- degree Fahrenheit rise in temperature results in 5% loss due to increased evaporation. โ€œHot drought,โ€ the phrase Udall favors, will only worsen, he says, as the process he and others call aridification will continue to worsen. Temperatures, said Udall at a recent forum, can continue to rise.

โ€œThe latest science tells us that the rate of warming has almost doubled. And the fossil fuel industry is showing no signs of exit or no signs of transformation to some other business model that doesnโ€™t involve polluting the Earth,โ€ he said.

Existing greenhouse gas emissions will, he added, continue to incrementally heat the Earth into the 22nd century even if humanity can reduce greenhouse gas emissions to zero.

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

As for the water management redo, itโ€™s still early. Colorado River runoff has been in decline for the last quarter-century. California and Arizona, the two lower-basin states with great thirst, were able to live off water banked in the two giant reservoirs, Mead and Powell, for many of those years. Only as the storage has ratcheted down to dangerously low levels have meaningful reductions in use begun, some only temporary in nature but others permanent.

The two states plus Nevada last year used about 6.8 million acre-feet from the river, less than the 7.5 million apportioned them the Colorado River Compact of 1922 and far less than the 8.5 million acre-feet they had averaged for several decades.

Upper-basin states had also been allotted 7.5 million acre-feet by the 1922 compact, but they have never come close to using that much water. Lacking the certainty of large upstream reservoirs, they have used about 4.5 million acre-feet.

Big cuts ahead

But big changes necessarily lie ahead, certainly for the lower-basin states but also Colorado and the other upper-basin states, Udall said in in a recent 90-minute plus presentation called โ€œDancing with Deadpool: a 27-Year-Long Colorado River Crisis.โ€ The forum in Jefferson County was sponsored by the Colorado Renewable Energy Society and New Energy Colorado.

โ€œWe gotta get rid of those old agreements,โ€ said Udall, the senior water and climate research scientist/scholar at Colorado Water Center.

โ€œWe in the Upper Basin must share this risk and not increase our use. The Lower Basin needs to plan on bigger cuts, more than 3 million acre-feet,โ€ he said, citing a paper he co-authored called โ€œWhat will it take to stabilize the Colorado River?โ€ that was published in 2022 in Science. In addition, he wrote a related paper along with New Mexicoโ€™s John Fleck that iin 2021 was published in Science.

โ€œAg has to bear the brunt of the cuts, because theyโ€™re 75% of the use, but M and I have to help,โ€ he said, referring to agriculture, municipal and industrial.

Strong disagreements exist between the two basins, upper and lower, beyond a general agreement to cut 1.2 million acre-feet in use. โ€œThe lower Basin really wants the Upper Basin to share, maybe on the order of 200,000 acre-feet a year, maybe 5%. And the Upper Basin says no way, and until recently has said weโ€™re going to even increase our use. โ€œ

Native America in the Colorado River Basin. Credit: USBR

Amidst all this, the claims of the 30 or so tribes in the basin need to be resolved. A 1907 Supreme Court ruling found that when the U.S. government ordered Native Americans onto reservations that it guaranteed them the water necessary to be farmers. They control about 25% of the water with some claims, importantly those of the Navajo Nation, still in question. โ€œTribal water is a really big deal,โ€ said Udall.

And Arizona, he said, with two-thirds of tribes, has a disproportionate burden of figuring out how to satisfy rights of the tribes while making everything else work reasonably well, too.

Arizona, he emphasized, is โ€œcentral to the problem and central to the solution.โ€ The Central Arizona Project will necessarily get less water, but it will not be zero, he added.

As for the unprecedented low river flows โ€” and unprecedented high temperatures โ€” of the 2025-26 water year, he predicted โ€œit wonโ€™t be the last time we see this. When it comes back, itโ€™ll be worse.โ€

As Udall spoke those words, it was raining hard in Coloradoโ€™s San Juan Mountains, water that helped raise the water levels of Lake Powell by about 15 feet going into November compared to a mid-September low. Still, Powell was little more than 25% full. The Colorado River problems go far deeper than can be solved by even an extraordinary storm cycle.

โ€œTrue,โ€ said Kathryn Sorensen, director of research at Arizona State Universityโ€™s Kyle Center for Water Research, responding to a New York Times story posted today,  โ€œbut theyโ€™ve helped pull us from the brink at Lake Powell, doubling or perhaps tripling the amount of realistically accessible storage there.โ€

Prior appropriation

Many analyists have concluded that the doctrine of prior appropriation, the legal structure for determining who gets how much water and when, must be modified. It is commonly called first in time, first in right.

The lower basin has roughly 100 diversions, nearly all very large and many of them administered through use of federal infrastructure. There, this principle is less important than in the upper basin, which has thousands and thousands of diversions, many small. Even so, it is the basic principle that allows California a bigger ladle for the Colorado River than Arizona. Arizona got in line as a result of federal legislation in 1968, the Colorado River Basin Project Act.

That law stipulated that water for the Central Arizona Project would be subordinate to Californiaโ€™s 4.4 million acre-foot annual allocation in case of  shortage.

Prior appropriation โ€œdoesnโ€™t really fit with the 21st century,โ€ said Udall. He described it as a โ€œwinner take allโ€ legal system developed in the 18th century by the farmers and miners who were the first colonists of Colorado and other parts of the West.

โ€œYou know, first in time makes first in right,โ€ he explained. โ€œAnd I argue all the time that 4-year-olds around the globe discover this rule every day. โ€˜Itโ€™s mine. I was here first.โ€™ And most parents step in and say, โ€˜No, no, you need to share that.โ€™ Thatโ€™s the system we have. And some people now own vastly expensive water rights because of this, and weโ€™re not going to overturn it.โ€

The doctrine did, he conceded, make sense in the 20th century. โ€œIf you were a junior water right holder, you could actually develop resilience and firm that water right by building storage, so that in really big years youโ€™d capture some water. And then, in the low years, when you werenโ€™t entitled to any water, youโ€™d use your storage to make up that deficient. Well, in a climate change world, that strategy now becomes next to impossible to deal with. Because we donโ€™t have these big years to fill up your reservoirs.โ€

The doctrine is โ€œembedded in how the Colorado River works, including the Central Arizona Project and its junior status to California,โ€ he continued. โ€œAgricultural rights are generally senior to cities, and โ€ฆ this creates problems because you end up potentially with a situation where Denver could get called out by agricultural water rights on the West Slopeโ€ of Colorado, especially those ag rights with appropriation dates prior to the Colorado River Compact.

โ€œIโ€™ve been arguing that we canโ€™t have 1,500 farmers depriving 20 million people in California and 7 million in Arizona and 2 million in Nevada and 2 million in Colorado with these senior rights,โ€ he said.

In 2010, working with Jonathan Overpeck, a researcher then affiliated with the University of Arizona (and now Michigan), Udall had begun to warn of dry times ahead. In a paper published in 2017 by Water Resources Research called โ€œThe twenty-first century Colorado River hot drought and implications for the future,โ€ they predicted 20% losses in river flows by mid-century and 35% by end of century. Those, they said, were conservative estimates.

The backstory is that for nearly a century the Colorado River Basin states โ€” importantly abetted by the federal treasury โ€” had created the infrastructure that assumed far more water even than what optimistically was assumed by the Colorado River Compact of 1922.

Deep family history

Udall brings to the Colorado River discussion perspectives informed by his unusual circumstances.

โ€œIโ€™m a great -great grandson of John D. Lee, the founder of Leeโ€™s Ferry,โ€ Brad at his presentation on Oct. 22. โ€œYou might think thatโ€™s kind of special. Turns out Lee had 21 wives, and thereโ€™s a chance he had 800,000 descendants, which might in fact be part of the problem right now.โ€

A long-time resident of Colorado, Brad grew up in Arizona, the son of Morris Udall, who represented Arizona in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1961 to 1991. His uncle Stewart Udall had represented the same district before becoming the secretary of Interior in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations from 1961 to 1969.

In other words, Udallโ€™s relatives were involved in creating at least some of the agreement infrastructure that now looks ill-advised. That includes the Central Arizona Project, which delivers Colorado River water via a system of canals and pipes that pumps water up 3,000 feet in elevation and across 336 miles to Phoenix, Tucson and farms between. Even then, during the debate in the 1960s, Mo Udall and other supporters realized the Colorado River would not have sufficient water. They were betting that water could be imported, such as from the Snake River in Wyomingโ€™s Jackson Hole. That never flew.

Alex Hager, formerly a reporter in Colorado for Greeley-based KUNC, probed the history in a story for KZJJ in Arizona title โ€œArizonaโ€™s lifeline to the Colorado River is drying up. Were warnings from history ignored?โ€

โ€œI think Stewart and Mo sort of blew it on some of this,โ€ Brad told Hager. But he also counseled some compassion. They had grown up on a farm in Arizona during the Great Depression. By the time they came to power after World War II, an era of booming national optimism may have colored their political thinking.

โ€œThe 1968 idea was we could build our way out of anything,โ€ Brad said. โ€œWe could engineer our way out of every crisis. Weโ€™re smart. Weโ€™re rich. The worldโ€™s our oyster.โ€

Udall gives many slide shows, each building on the last one. The best of them need at least an hour to deliver, because the story is that complicated. This was the third presentation by Udall heard this year by this writer. Unlike some others, though, this audience consisted of people most attentive to the energy transition. To his credit, Udall was able to craft his presentation in a way that did not require vast knowledge of the arcane world of water. He did this without sacrificing details.

Udall sees himself as a truth-teller with an unpleasant message. โ€œAs a scientist, I kind of feel like itโ€™s my job to tell people how it is. And if I can tell it with a little humor and a smile on my face, even if itโ€™s a tough message, maybe theyโ€™ll hear that message,โ€ he said.

The truth he sought to share was the need for great changes in how this declining source of water is shared by 40 million people โ€” changes necessary very, very soon. Those changes will likely include Colorado and other headwaters states, probably an agreement to conservation measures that reduce use by 2% to 5%.

Important, he said, will be better accounting of volumes of use in the upper-basin states. Lacking hard numbers, itโ€™s hard to judge equities. The counter argument has been that Colorado, in particular, has so many small users that this accounting poses an extremely difficult challenge.

What also must be noted is that Udallโ€™s critique inevitably is easier to deliver than setting out a precise outline of what this new future must entail. That, of course, likely would have required another hour or more.

โ€œI still think weโ€™ll get a negotiated solution,โ€ he said as he wrapped up his presentation. But then he added an asterisk, referencing the lawsuit filed by first Nevada in August, then joined by Arizona in October, challenging the federal governmentโ€™s order for cuts in water use. โ€œAlthough every day these lawsuits continue I get more depressed,โ€ he added.

After Udallโ€™s presentation, in the cafeteria where munchies were delivered, I heard one listener who suggested that Phil Weiser, when governor, might consider making Udall the representative of Colorado on the Upper Colorado River Commission. That is not a rap against Becky Mitchell, the current representative, who by all accounts has represented Colorado well in the difficult discussions. It is, though, an interesting idea.

You can watch/listen to Udallโ€™s presentation (and see his slides).
In late October, 100 people turned out at the Unitarian Church between Wheat Ridge and Golden to hear Brad Udall share his thought and knowledge about the Colorado River.

Following are a few more highlights:

Fuzziness of 1922 compact

The 1922 compact has several fuzzy components, most troubling being what was meant in Article 3D, the non-depletion clause, which says the upper basin states โ€œwill not causeโ€ the flows at Lee Ferry to drop below 75 million acre-feet across every rolling 10-year average.

โ€œIn the 20th century, there was only one way for that number to fall below 75 million. acre-feet, and that was if the basin used the water. But in the 21st century, we have a second way for those flows to fall below 75 million acre-feet, which is climate change, of course, and no one knows what this (delivery obligation) means,โ€ said Udall.

Too, the compact โ€œtotally excluded tribal water rights, despite a critically important Supreme Court decree in 1908 (Winters Doctrine), saying that tribes were entitled to water.โ€

As for the abundance of annual flows in the river, โ€œThey actually thought in 1922 that they were going to come back in 1962 and allocate a whole bunch of water because they hadnโ€™t allocated all of it.โ€

On deadpan

โ€œThere would be real harm if we hit deadpool. I mean, there would be a lot of people hurt. You hit Deadpool, you turn control of these reservoirs over to Mother Nature, away from us, and thatโ€™s a fundamental mistake.โ€

Getting into the mess

โ€œWeโ€™ve made a whole bunch of mistakes through time,โ€ he said. โ€œWe allocated water permanently. We assumed too much water. And there are a whole bunch of unrealistic policies. We now have a solution in sight for the next two years, but it will not be enough. And litigation (Nevada and now Arizona suing the federal government) just announced clouds what might really happen.โ€

Musical chairs

While the compact apportioned 7.5 million acre-feet to the upper basins states, they have never used more than 5.5 million acre-feet and mostly have stuck to around 4.5 million ace-feet.

โ€œThey feel like theyโ€™re still entitled to it, but itโ€™s also a little bit of a game of musical chairs, right? I mean, the music stopped here, and because you never grew into that, itโ€™s really hard to figure out how you possibly can use more given the facts on the ground., Weโ€™re sitting on a 2 million acre-feet per year imbalance.โ€

An acre-foot

An acre-foot is 325,000 gallons of water, enough for 10 people for a year. In the upper basin, a farmer might put one or two acre-feet of water on top of a field to get a crop of hay in the summer. In Arizona and California, where itโ€™s hot, they might put 10 feet on top of their field to get 10 different cuttings of alfalfa.

A high desert thunderstorm lights up the sky behind Glen Canyon Dam — Photo USBR

The big reservoirs

In January 2000, Powell and Mead were about 95% full, with 47 million acre-feet. In August 2026, they were 24% full.

No analog

Our high-flow years on Colorado River are now half as frequent, and our low-flow years are about two and a half times as common. โ€œThe take-home here is that thereโ€™s no analog in the 20th century to what weโ€™re seeing now,โ€ he said.

Colorado, the headwaters

Of the water that originates in Colorado, 90% flows out of the state.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Arizona water agencies are in court over the #ColoradoRiver. What comes next? — KJZZ #COriver #aridification

The Colorado River’s Horseshoe Bend. Photo credit: Gert Boers/Unsplash

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

November 2, 2026

The Arizona Department of Water Resources filed a motion to intervene in Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit against the federal government. The Central Arizona Project โ€” which operates a 336-mile canal system that carries Colorado River Water to the Phoenix and Tucson areas โ€” did the same less than two weeks later. The legal moves represent an escalation in a contentious, yearslong saga over how to respond to increasingly dry conditions along a river that supplies nearly 40 million people across seven Western states…Nevadaโ€™s original lawsuit chiefly argues one thing. It says the Interior Department needs to go back and redo its plans for cutting back water use in three Colorado River states โ€” Arizona, California and Nevada, collectively known as the Lower Basin…With states at an impasse, the federal government reluctantly came up with its own plan. The Interior Department decided that the Lower Basin would have to cut back, but did not force any new cutbacks on the Upper Basin. The plan gives Interior the option to cut Colorado River supplies for Arizona, California and Nevada by up to 40% per year, with Arizona being the hardest hit. Those states were quick to call that plan unfair. Now, theyโ€™re going further and arguing that it was illegal…

Photo credit: Central Arizona Project

The lawsuit argues that federal authorities are legally obligated to consider the impact of new water management plans while drawing up required environmental paperwork. A plan that slashes so much water for millions of people and major industries, it explains, has not done enough to consider the harm of those cutbacks. Arizonaโ€™s top water official, Tom Buschatzke, said the new river plan would โ€œdevastateโ€ Arizonaโ€™s economy, and โ€œignores basic elements of the law of the riverโ€ to do so…Those agencies, alongside Nevada, are asking Interior to come up with a new cutback plan that considers that harm and spreads water cuts more evenly across the region…That ask for a redo is only part of the reason Arizona joined Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit. Between the lines of the filing, the state is making a bigger point. The Lower Basin is in this mess, the state explains, because its upstream neighbors are violating the foundational laws that have governed the river since 1922. If that doesnโ€™t change, Arizona has the ammunition it needs to take an Upper Basin state, or states, to the Supreme Court sometime soon. It is using this lawsuit to put those ideas in writing…Now, some water officials say the conditions are right to bring that bigger lawsuit. Arizona could sue a state or states in the Upper Basin for failing to deliver a legally-mandated amount of water downstream. CAP officials say the upstream states have already fallen below that amount…

Itโ€™s impossible to predict exactly how long a case over the 1922 Colorado River Compact would take to work its way through the legal process, but other water disputes can provide some hints. In Texas v. New Mexico and Colorado, a dispute over water from the Rio Grande spent 13 years in court before it was finally settled in early 2026. In 1985, Kansas sued Colorado for taking too much water from the Arkansas River. That case wasnโ€™t resolved until 2009, more than two decades after it began. A Colorado River case would be highly complex, considering the riverโ€™s connection to seven states, 30 federally recognized Native American tribes and the country of Mexico. Because of that, Eklund said, it could take even longer than two decades, a perilously long time given the record-setting low levels at the nationโ€™s largest reservoirs.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Map of the Arkansas River drainage basin. Created using USGS National Map and NASA SRTM data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=79039596
The Rio Grande Basin spans Colorado, New Mexico and Texas. Credit: Chas Chamberlin

Archuleta County faces lasting challenges after severe flooding: Road closures, damaged infrastructure and communication outages affect residents across region — The #Durango Herald #SanJuanRiver

Pagosa Springs recorded 1 to 1.5 inches of rainfall from Sunday afternoon through Monday morning, according to National Weather Service data. (Courtesy of Matthew Martin and @thisispagosa)

Click the link to read the article on The Durango Herald website (Tyler Brown). Here’s an excerpt:

November 2, 2026

[Vicki] Shaffer said cellular service was down, leaving residents to rely on landline phones or internet connections to communicate. T-Mobile service was restored at about 4:45 p.m. Monday. She could not provide updated figures on the number of people rescued or evacuated, or the number of structures destroyed. Videos circulating on social media showed floodwaters carrying a home down the San Juan River and into a pedestrian bridge, destroying the structure. Another post showed part of the foundation of the Pagosa Springs History Museum building torn away by floodwaters. According to Shaffer, National Guard helicopters returned to Pagosa Springs on Monday to aid in rescue and recovery efforts. U.S. Highway 160 remained closed from both directions entering Pagosa Springs on Tuesday, as CDOT crews tended to a portion of the Piedra River Bridge which had been completely washed away from the floods…

An aerial view of Colorado Highway 151 flood damage from the previous week, between Ignacio and Pagosa Springs. (Courtesy of Colorado Department of Transportation)

State Highway 151 near Chimney Rock also remained closed because of flood damage.

#Mancos residents asked to conserve water after flooding: Significant damages to wastewater facility and Cottonwood Park — The #Cortez Journal #MancosRiver

Flooding in Mancos. Credit: Facebook via Google (I could not locate the poster.)

Click the link to read the article on The Cortez Journal website (Anna Watson). Here’s an excerpt:

November 2, 2026

Residents are being asked to conserve water because the flood levels have caused an increase in sediment levels. A town news release said residents are required to limit nonessential use to help maintain an adequate supply while treatment conditions improve. Goodall said there is no indication the townโ€™s main drinking water supply has been contaminated, but he said officials must manage the high sediment levels, ensuring they build up a reserve of potable water. Goodall estimates residents will need to conserve water for one to two weeks or until the sediment dissipates…

He said officials were still assessing the damage of the wastewater treatment facility. In a post on Facebook, the town said floodwaters topped the wastewater treatment lagoons, causing water to overflow into and out of the ponds. The incident impacts the wastewater system, not the townโ€™s infrastructure upstream that treats drinking water…โ€œOur crews remain on the scene to manage the situation. Out of an abundance of caution and in compliance with safety protocols, we have already notified downstream partners, including the CDPHE, the Ute Tribe, and federal oversight agencies, to ensure a coordinated response,โ€ the post read. Out of safety, the town asked that people avoid contact with the Mancos River downstream of Cottonwood Park.

Map of the San Juan River, a tributary of the Colorado River, in Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico and Utah, USA. Made using USGS National Map data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=47456307

Evacuations, road closures continue as flooding peaks in southwest #Colorado: #SanJuanRiver peaked at 16.81 feet Sunday night in #PagosaSprings, river gauges show — The #Denver Post

Click the link to read the article on The Denver Post website (Lauren Penington and Katie Langford). Here’s an excerpt:

November 2, 2026

Dangerous floodwaters threatened homes and communities across southwestern Colorado on Monday, causing widespread damage to towns and counties already incapacitated by flooding from rain-swollen rivers one week earlier. The San Juan River in Pagosa Springs rose to nearly 17 feet on Sunday as an estimated 3 to 4 inches of rain fell over land already saturated by heavy precipitation. The river did not hit the record-breaking 22-foot crest that forecasters expected, but the 16.81-foot crest recorded Sunday night is the second-highest on record and two feet higher than one week ago, according to preliminary data from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administrationโ€™s river gauges. Southern Colorado officials ordered mandatory evacuations for people living in parts of La Plata, Archuleta, Rio Grande, Mineral, Conejos and Montezuma counties, including parts of Pagosa Springs, Durango, Del Norte, Ignacio and Mancos…Sundayโ€™s storm brought similar or slightly less rain than the storm that caused widespread flooding in the area more than a week earlier, but the water had nowhere to go, National Weather Service meteorologist Eric Petersen said. The ground was still saturated from the previous floods, unable to absorb much more, and reservoirs were already filled to the brink, pushing water downstream, said Petersen, who works in the weather serviceโ€™s Pueblo office…

Mandatory evacuation orders are also in effect for residents along the South Fork of the Rio Grande River, including in Del Norte, Monte Vista and South Fork. Part of southern Del Norte remained on pre-evacuation status. An updated evacuation map is available online. Roughly 2,773 people were evacuated, according to South Fork Fire Rescue. As of Monday morning, no injuries or missing people had been reported…The South Fork of the Rio Grande hit โ€œmajorโ€ flooding of 8.88 feet late Sunday night near South Fork and held relatively steady overnight. As of Monday morning, the river was still expected to rise near Del Norte and Monte Vista, according to NOAA flood gauges.

Animas River Flooding

#PagosaSprings water and wastewater service providers report at least $13 million in flooding damage — The Pagosa Springs Sun

A view of San Juan River flooding in downtown Pagosa Springs on Friday, October 23, 2026. (Photo courtesy of Jacque Aragon)

Click the link to read the article on The Pagosa Springs Sun website (Josh Pike). Here’s an excerpt:

October 29, 2026

Pagosa Springsโ€™ water and wastewater service providers โ€” the Pagosa Area Water and Sanitation District (PAWSD) and the Pagosa Springs Sanitation General Improvement District (PSSGID) โ€” suffered more than $13 million in damage to their systems in last weekโ€™s flooding event, according to Wednesday estimates. The PSSGID suffered about $9 million in damage, stated Pagosa Springs Town Manager David Harris, while PAWSD Programs Manager Renee Lewis indicated that, on Wednesday morning, PAWSD estimated damages at $4,005,000. Lewis emphasized that this is a โ€œVERY preliminaryโ€ estimate since some PAWSD infrastructure is still inaccessible. According to Harris, the PSSGID, which provides sewer service for downtown Pagosa Springs and is operated by the Town of Pagosa Springs, primarily suffered damage to all three of its lift stations, its two pumping stations on the line that moves wastewater from downtown to PAWSDโ€™s Vista wastewater treatment plant, and to the sewer line that runs under the 1st Street bridge on U.S. 160. He explained that the pumps and electrical equipment at these stations all suffered damage due to being inundated with water and that at least some of the equipment in all these stations will likely need to be replaced. Harris stated that the pump stations on the line to Vista are currently operating with one set of dry and submersible pumps each, when they normally use two sets of pumps that alternate operations to give each set downtime. He indicated that the inundation during the flooding also led to the system overflowing raw sewage into the San Juan River once its pumping capacity was exceeded at the Vista pipeline. The forced main for the Vista pipeline handled 1.7 million gallons of water on Thursday, Oct. 22; 1.58 million gallons on Friday, Oct. 23; and 1.32 million gallons on Saturday, Oct. 24, Harris stated. He added that the pipeline usually handles about 350,000 gallons of wastewater per day…

The damage to the 1st Street bridge pipeline was due to the water rising high enough to destroy the pipe that runs under the bridge, Harris stated. Prior to the flooding, the PSSGID implemented a bypass using a flexible pipe running along the sidewalk on top of the bridge and a temporary pump on the east end of the bridge, Harris explained, which is still in operation since the normal pipe has been destroyed. He added that this incident accounts for a significant portion of the cost of the damages that the PSSGID suffered. Harris also stated that the PSSGID suffered other miscellaneous damage, including to work that was in progress to replace sections of the McCabe Creek sewer line, which is a large source of inflow and infiltration of outside water into the PSSGID system…Connor states in his update that the district will likely have to replace the exposed lines at Mockingbird Lane and North Pagosa Boulevard in the future, but that this will occur in conjunction with the county repairing the road washouts that cause the exposures. His update states that the Snowball and Hatcher Lake water treatment plants are fully operational and that the diversion on the San Juan River that provides water to the Snowball plant and its associated reservoir has been cleared sufficiently to allow water to flow into the reservoir. The San Juan water treatment plant, located at PAWSDโ€™s offices at 100 Lyn Ave., which also contains the Vista wastewater treatment plant, was shut off before the flooding began, according to Lewis. In an Oct. 23 update to the PAWSD board, Connor also states that the Vista wastewater treatment plant โ€œheldโ€ during the flooding and remains operational. He adds that the plant treated 5.7 million gallons of wastewater during the Oct. 22 and Oct. 23 flooding events. In her update, Lewis states that damage to the river and creek diversions that feed PAWSDโ€™s water treatment plants is yet to be fully determined.

Arizona’s lifeline to the Colorado River is drying up. Its designers warned us decades ago — KJZZ.org

Photo credit: Central Arizona Project

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

October 28, 2026

…this tense moment and this 21st century crisis are not showing up as a complete surprise. In fact, the architects of that canal system gave explicit warnings that its position near the front of the line for cutbacks would mean lower flows in the future. The warnings they issued in the 1960s appear to have been largely ignored in the decades since, and the fingerprints of their ambition are still shaping the headlines of today…Phoenix and Tucson as we know them today wouldn’t exist without a gravity-defying, 336-mile system of canals, pipelines and pumping plants that cut through the desert, collectively known as the Central Arizona Project, or CAP. Today, water shortages threaten the expensive, improbable system, and a series of warnings about the canal’s future from the 1960s, seem prescient.

Most Wells Around the Grand Canyon With High Arsenic Levels Are at #Uranium Mine, New Analysis Shows — Wyatt Myskow (InsideClimateNews.org)

The evaporation pond at the Pinyon Plain Mine in Arizona. Credit: Blake McCord

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Wyatt Myskow):

October 28, 2026

Pinyon Plain Mine representatives argue that the toxic metal is naturally occurring, not contamination from the mining operation.

Three of four wells across the Grand Canyon region that have average arsenic levels above the Environmental Protection Agencyโ€™s standard for safe drinking water are at the site of a controversial uranium mine, a new analysis of groundwater sampling shows.

The analysis from the Grand Canyon Trust, a nonprofit advocating for protection of the canyon and the Colorado Plateau, relied on 32 years of groundwater sampling across 40 sites from the U.S. Geological Survey and the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality. The Pinyon Plain Mine, where the contaminated wells are located, lies within a national monument just nine miles away from the South Rim of the Grand Canyon.

The heightened arsenic levels at the mine site are not a coincidence, Misael Cabrera, senior vice president of environment, safety and sustainability for the mining company, Energy Fuels Resources Inc., said, as arsenic is found in highly mineralized areas, like at the Pinyon Plain Mine site.

โ€œWe donโ€™t get to choose where we put a mine,โ€ he said. โ€œNature puts the minerals in certain locations, and then if we want to harvest those minerals, we have to go to those locations.โ€

Cabrera was the director of the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality when the mine was being permitted.

It is the latest dispute in a months-long debate over the rising arsenic levels, what is increasing them and whether the contaminant is at risk of spreading throughout the region. Pinyon Plain mineโ€”located within the Baaj Nwaavjo Iโ€™tah Kukveniโ€”Ancestral Footprints of the Grand Canyon National Monument, is one of the countryโ€™s first new uranium minesdriven by a resurgence of interest in nuclear energy.

The analysis comes after ADEQ permitted Energy Fuels to raise the levels of arsenic at one of the mineโ€™s monitoring wells that require the company to issue an alert about the contamination. That decision prompted outcry from local communities and researchers.

โ€œOur opposition is not based on fear or politics,โ€ said Havasupai Tribal Chairwoman Melinda Yaiva at a press conference announcing the findings. โ€œIt is based on our responsibility as a sovereign tribal nation to protect our people, our homeland and the water that makes life in Supai (the tribeโ€™s village in the Grand Canyon) possible. Today, the immediate issue is arsenic.โ€

For years, the mineโ€™s opponents have expressed concern it would contaminate the regionโ€™s groundwater. Research from hydrologists found the shallow groundwater aquifer the mine drills into is connected to the deeper, regional aquifer. Reviews by the U.S. Geological Survey and the Environmental Protection Agency followed and found more research is needed to understand if the mine site poses a threat to the regionโ€™s water quality.

Cabrera said no data shows there is a risk for the mineโ€™s water to spread.

โ€œDespite all of the evidence that we have on record, despite all of the regulatory approvals, despite the multiple court cases, we are still being assumed to be guilty before proven innocent,โ€ he said. โ€œWe really need to reflect on that as a country if we want to be able to produce our own energy without relying so heavily on foreign sources.โ€

He likened the current situation to looking at a traffic map of Arizona, where major cities like Phoenix would have the most congestion. โ€œIn the same vein, you are going to have higher levels of mineralsโ€ like arsenic at mine sites.

Laura Crossey, an emeritus professor of earth science at the University of New Mexico, who for decades has researched the hydrogeology of the Grand Canyon, has a traffic analogy as well. Dismissing data showing the aquifers are connected and that contamination can spread is โ€œlike studying the traffic pattern of Phoenix by only looking at the side streets and ignoring the interstates that move through, that are carrying much higher volumes, much higher speeds.โ€

One monitoring well at Energy Fuelsโ€™ Pinyon Plain Mine exceeded permitted alert levels for arsenic four times since 2025, before the company applied to amend its permit to allow for higher levels of arsenic. The groundwater in the mineโ€™s sump is over 3,000 times the limit for arsenic in drinking water. At the mineโ€™s monitoring wells, the water is nearly two, three and six times the safe drinking water levels of arsenic, respectively.

โ€œThis is a kind of a failure in the monitoring program and the regulatory process, because at the present time, we donโ€™t really know why the arsenic is rising, because it hasnโ€™t been thoroughly investigated,โ€ said Brad Esser, a retired environmental radiochemistry researcher at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory.

If the mineโ€™s evaporation pond is leaking, it can be patched. If the groundwater pumping is changing the hydrologic flow, then limits can be placed on the pumping. But without a definitive study and answer to whatโ€™s causing the increasing levels of arsenic, a mitigation plan canโ€™t be put in place, he said.

Image Source: Michigan State University Extension, Water Quality Bulletin # 35, August 1991

ADEQ and the company have claimed the arsenic issue is natural, and not due to mining. They attribute the rising arsenic levels to its groundwater pumping causing a โ€œcone of depressionโ€ around the well that is drawing in water with more naturally occurring arsenic from further reaches of the aquifer.

Protesters voice their opposition to uranium hauling from the Pinyon Plain Mine in Arizona. Credit: Blake McCord

Critics have questioned that claim and said more data was needed to prove it before permitting higher arsenic alert levels. The analysis of regional arsenic levels in groundwater, they say, shows the company and ADEQโ€™s hypothesis is wrong.

โ€œIf arsenic concentrations in groundwater outside the mine are lower than inside, how can drawing low concentration outside increase the already high and increasing arsenic concentrations inside the property,โ€ asked Dave Kreamer, emeritus professor of hydrology at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. โ€œYou would think that adding cleaner water, groundwater from outside, shouldnโ€™t it dilute the high concentrations inside? Iโ€™ve been asking this question of ADEQ monthly since June 1, and have not got an answer yet.โ€

Most at risk is the Havasupai Tribe, whose reservation is in the Grand Canyon. Its only source of water is Havasu Creek, which is directly fed by the regional Redwall-Mauv aquiferโ€”the deeper regional groundwater supply.

The tribe has objected to ADEQ raising the allowable arsenic levels at the mine site, and appealed the decision. That appeal was dismissed by the agencyโ€™s appeals board, which concluded the tribe lacked standing. Yaiva said the tribe is considering what other options it has, including legal ones.

Something Havasupai children are taught at birth, Yaiva said, is that water is sacred. Havasu Creek, located on the tribeโ€™s reservation and famed for its vibrant blue-green waters, is not just a beautiful place, she said. โ€œIt is the lifeblood of our homeland.โ€

โ€œOur people drink this water,โ€ she said. โ€œWe cook with it. We grow food with it. We care for our animals with it, and depend on it every day. It is also part of our ceremonies, our traditions, and our culture, and our identity as Havasupai people. Our relationship with this water goes back generations, long before the state of Arizona existed, long before the federal government approved the uranium mining near our homeland.โ€

In addition to supporting the Havasupai people, the waters in Havasu Canyon give life to an array of animals and plants. Photo credit: Amy S. Martin via The Grand Canyon Trust

One of the most extreme rainstorms in state records — Russ Schumacher (#Colorado #Climate Center)

Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Climate Center website (Russ Schumacher):

October 30, 2026

Last week, from Wednesday, October 21 into Sunday, October 25, southern Coloradoโ€”along with neighboring areas of New Mexico, Utah, and Arizonaโ€”received widespread heavy rainfall. Thankfully, as of this writing no fatalities or significant injuries have been reported from the resulting flooding, but the destruction has been immense. Roads have been washed out throughout the region, homes have been damaged, water rescues were needed, and recreation areas have been affected. [The Colorado Sun has been doing great reporting on the flood impacts, as has the Navajo Times for areas downstream on the San Juan River. Jonathan Thompson at the Land Desk summarized where the streamflow ranked on various rivers.] Here, weโ€™ll look at the rainfall that led to the flooding, and make the case that this rainstorm wasnโ€™t just unusual for this part of Colorado, but should be considered among the most extreme storms in state history.

Colorado Highway 151 washed out, between Pagosa Springs and Ignacio. Photo courtesy of the Colorado Department of Transportation.

Extreme rainfall and floods in southern Colorado

There is a history of heavy rainstorms in the fall in southern Colorado, typically with a connection to the remnants of tropical systems in the eastern Pacific Ocean. The โ€œSonora hurricaneโ€ of October 1911 was one such storm, which led to the flood of record on the San Juan River and other rivers in the region. Just last year (2025), a similar weather system produced major flooding in southwestern Colorado. That event, which we covered in a couple of blogposts last October, was a one-two punch of moisture from a pair tropical cyclones. Even earlier this fall, the remnants of Tropical Storm Polo moved through the southwestern US and brought heavy rainfall and flooding. But by at least some metrics, the recent late-October storm appears to have topped all of these, especially in the lower-and middle elevation areas of southern Colorado.

The meteorological setup for this event was slightly different from those past cases, which had a more direct influence from the remnant tropical cyclones. The late-October event did have some influence from Tropical Storm Trudy, which formed and moved northward toward the west coast of Mexico in mid-October. Trudy then dissipated and never continued on into the US. However, some of the moisture associated with Trudy, along with generally increased atmospheric moisture in the Pacific related to El Niรฑo (more on that later), was transported northward by a very strong trough of low pressure that approached the US West Coast. So even without a direct influence from a tropical cyclone, a sustained โ€œfirehoseโ€ of water vapor was aimed at southern Colorado.

How much rain fell, and where?

In terms of the total rainfall accumulation, the highest amounts were observed around the San Juan Mountains in Colorado and New Mexico, and the Abajo Mountains in southeastern Utah. Up to 8 inches of rain fell in four days at high elevations, with widespread observations of 4-6โ€ณ at lower elevations (first map below). Where the rain amounts were most unusual, however, was in the San Luis Valley. Remember that the San Luis Valley is a very dry place: the average annualprecipitation is only 7-9โ€ณ, and getting more than an inch of rain in a single storm is extremely rare. The San Juan Mountains to the west intercept any moisture that heads toward the valley, making a very effective rain shadow. The second map below shows that the entire San Luis Valley received more than 4 times their usual October precipitation in four days. The amounts may not look big (2-4 inches), but this type of rainstorm just doesnโ€™t tend to happen!

Total precipitation (inches) from 22-25 October 2026 with gridded data from the PRISM Climate Group and observations from SNOTEL stations and the Community Collaborative Rain, Hail, and Snow (CoCoRaHS) network.

Percent of the average October precipitation that fell in this four-day period. The San Juan River and Rio Grande are also shown in blue.

Several stations in the San Luis Valley with climate records extending back 100 years or more had their wettest two-day period on record, including Alamosa, Monte Vista, and Del Norte. (Alamosa and Monte Vista also had their wettest 3-day period.) One way to illustrate how rare a rain event is for a given area is through precipitation frequency analysis, which estimates the probability of a given amount of rain falling in any year. These are often converted to average recurrence intervals (ARIs), so that a storm with a 1% chance of happening in any year is referred to as a โ€œ100-yearโ€ storm. That terminology can be misleading, because it doesnโ€™t mean that such a storm canโ€™t happen again for another 100 years: itโ€™s just an average. Weโ€™ll use that terminology here because itโ€™s simpler, but keep this caveat in mind1.

We see below that for the two-day period from Wednesday morning (21st) to Friday morning (23rd), 2-6 inches of rain fell across southern Colorado. For much of the region (light red shading on the right map below), these two-day totals represented at least a 10-year rainstorm; in parts of Archuleta County and much of the San Luis Valley it was a 100-year rainstorm, and in several parts of the SLV it was more than a 1000-year storm.

Left) Precipitation estimate from NOAAโ€™s Stage IV analysis for the 48-hour period ending the morning of October 23, 2026. (Right) Locations with 48-hour precipitation with less than a 1 in 10 chance (light red shading), less than a 1 in 100 chance (red shading), and less than a 1 in 1000 year (brown shading) of being exceeded in any given year. (Or in other terms, rainfall exceeding a 1 in 10 year average return period in light red, 1 in 100 year in red, and 1 in 1000 year in brown. Average recurrence interval estimates from NOAA Atlas 14.

I want to highlight one observation in particular, from South Fork, Colorado, where the South Fork of the Rio Grande merges with the main stem of that river. A CoCoRaHS volunteer observer reported 4.46โ€ณ of rain in two days, which is an astonishing amount of rain for that location, with less than a 1 in 1000 chance of happening in any given year, based on available statistics. Unfortunately, the flood damage in South Fork was significant, including at the Fun Valley Family Resort. That observer recorded another 1.15โ€ณ of rain on the 25th, for a 4-day rainfall total of 5.64โ€ณ

CoCoRaHS rainfall observations for October 22-23, 2026, in southwestern Colorado.

[I want to take a moment to give a word of huge appreciation to the CoCoRaHS volunteer observers throughout the region, and to particularly point out the observers around Pagosa Springs. That community has now seen two major floods in two years, and the incredible volunteer network, many of them recruited by the Pagosa Weather team, has collected a remarkable dataset documenting the details of both of those storms.]

How did the rainfall compare to last Octoberโ€™s storms?

The map below compares the 4-day total rainfall from the recent event to the totals from the wettest 4-day period in the storms last October. In the San Juan and Rio Grande watersheds, this yearโ€™s event had considerably more precipitation. In the San Luis Valley and extending into Archuleta County and northern New Mexico, 2-4โ€ณ more rain fell in this yearโ€™s storm. The exception was at the highest elevations of the San Juans and in La Plata County, where the October 2025 storm had more precipitation. At least part of this was because last yearโ€™s event was effectively all rain, whereas the high peaks were getting snow in this yearโ€™s storm. The flood peak on the San Juan River at Pagosa Springs was more than 2 feet higher in October 2026 than in the 2025 flood.

Total precipitation from 22-25 October 2026 minus 11-14 October 2025. With the exception of the high elevations of the San Juan Mountains, the October 2026 storm brought more precipitation across southern Colorado.

If we compare the โ€œ1000-year rainfallโ€ in the October 2026 storm to past events like the September 2013 Front Range floods, this yearโ€™s storm remarkably had even greater coverage of very rare rainfall amounts. Although the total amount of rainfall may not have been as great, considering the records broken and the spatial coverage of rainfall that was extremely rare for the locations where it fell, the October 2026 storm in southern Colorado should clearly be added to the list of the most extreme rainstorms in Colorado history. Trying to rank those storms would be very difficult, but such a list would surely include the October 1911 โ€œSonora hurricaneโ€ rainfall, the June 1921 storm that flooded Penrose and Pueblo, the June 1965 storms in both northern and southeastern Colorado, the 1976 Big Thompson storm, the September 2013 โ€œGreat Colorado floodโ€œ, and now the October 2026 event in southern Colorado and neighboring states.

What did the storm mean for the drought?

The flip side to all of the flood damage is the benefit to the drought and water supply situation. Going back to the beginning of September, much of southern Colorado has had record-high precipitation, after a brutal snow season and a hot, dry summer. The persistent heavy rain has led to major improvements in drought. Much of southwestern Colorado is now drought-free on the US Drought Monitor, with 3 to 5 category improvements over the last two months.

Eight-week change in the US Drought Monitor, showing 2-5 class improvements across southern Colorado. From https://droughtmonitor.unl.edu/Maps/ChangeMaps.aspx

Rivers in southern Colorado that were near record-low flows in the summer are now near record high flows for the fall. Some reservoirs have seen significant increases in storage as well, particularly Navajo Reservoir on the San Juan River, just across the border in New Mexico. That reservoir saw essentially no increase from snowmelt in the spring and summer, and was nearing record low levels as of early September; the recent storms gave it a huge and much-needed boost. My colleague here at the CCC Peter Goble calculated that from October 22 to 25, approximately 884,000 acre-feet of water fell just in Mineral, Hinsdale, and Archuleta Counties. And going back to the start of the rains in early September, that number would be even bigger.

Time series of storage in Navajo Reservoir, as of October 27, 2026. From https://climate.colostate.edu/drought/#reservoirs

Farther downstream on the Colorado River, Lake Powell has also seen a noticeable boost in storage, such that it is no longer at a record low. But this is important perspective to keep in mind: even with all the rain, it just gets Powell storage to โ€œnot quite record lowโ€. Other important Colorado reservoirs farther north, like Granby and Blue Mesa saw much less precipitation and very little increase in storage from recent storms. Going straight from flood to drought to flood might look something like โ€œaverageโ€ precipitation, but it isnโ€™t the preferred pathway to get that water. And having a lot of rain in the fall doesnโ€™t undo the damage that was done from the drought earlier in the year (impacts to recreation, agriculture, wildfires, and on and on). So, the drought relief is substantial and welcome now, but we still need a good mountain snow season to improve the situation across Colorado and the southwestern US as a whole.

Where does El Niรฑo fit in to this story, and whatโ€™s coming next?

As Peter outlined in this post, the fall season is when we see some of the most robust connections between El Niรฑo and precipitation in Colorado, with falls tending to be wetter than average in southern Colorado during El Niรฑo. It is quite remarkable how closely this fallโ€™s precipitation patterns thus far match the historical correlations: on the figure below, look at how similar the green shading in the map on the left is to the areas that have seen above-average precipitation this fall!

(left) Map showing the historical correlation between El Niรฑo-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) and fall precipitation in Colorado, with areas shaded in green showing where fall tends to be wetter during El Niรฑo. (right) Percent of average precipitation from September 1 through October 27.

El Niรฑo years, with warm ocean temperatures in the eastern Pacific, tend to allow for more moisture to be transported into southern Colorado in the fall. El Niรฑo years also tend to have more hurricanes in the eastern Pacific (this has very much been the case this year), which increase the chances for extreme rainstorms like the ones weโ€™ve seen this fall. So thereโ€™s a pretty clear fingerprint of El Niรฑo on this fall season. And, for both better and worse, itโ€™s not going to slow down: another storm will affect southern Colorado this weekend, bringing more water for drought relief, but also more flood risk to the areas that have already been hard-hit. (Sunday, November 1 will see the greatest risk of more heavy rain and flooding, as well as snow at the high elevations.)

Unfortunately, the picture gets murkier as we look beyond that into the main mountain snow season. Although the fall (and spring) seasons tend to be wetter during El Niรฑo years, the signal in the core of winter is not as strong. A big snow year is certainly one possible outcome, but is by no means guaranteed.


1 Another caveat is that the rarer the precipitation amount, the less certain the recurrence interval estimates are. NOAAโ€™s Atlas 14 and the Colorado-New Mexico Regional Extreme Precipitation Study provide uncertainty estimates around the calculations. Here weโ€™re using the โ€˜most likelyโ€™ value from those calculations. โ†ฉ๏ธŽ

The #SanJuanRiver swells up, spreads destruction: The latest round of storms have moved on, but flooding continues — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 26, 2026

Watching the streamflow gages for Four Corners area rivers has been astounding; seeing the images of the destruction wrought by the high waters is heart-rending. As of mid-day Monday, the rains had mostly moved on, and streamflows were continuing to drop in most areas, but the San Juan River was still running strong at 39,000 cubic feet per second (which appears to be the peak for this storm system). Meanwhile, hundreds of people were only beginning to recover from the flooding, which not only soaked homes and businesses, but also damaged infrastructure โ€” including sewage treatment facilities โ€” sending contaminated water downstream.

The rains had no more mercy on the other side of the Great Divide, where the Rio Grande and its tributaries have also flooded communities and infrastructure. The South Fork of the Rio Grande rumbled through the Fun Valley RV resort before making its way into streets and homes of San Luis Valley communities such as Del Norte. On Monday, flows were still rising at the USGS gage near Cerro, New Mexico, upstream from the Taos Gorge, indicating that the brunt of the stream surge has not yet reached riverside communities such as Embudo, Ohkay Owingeh Pueblo, or Espaรฑola.

National and regional news outlets โ€” along with social media weather chasers โ€” are all over the flooding and the damage it brought with it, although the bigger outlets havenโ€™t deeply covered the widespread impacts on the Navajo Nation, where even heavy rains, without any actual flooding, can muck up roads and transportation for days, stranding people in remote areas. For that coverage, Iโ€™d urge you to check out the extensive reporting at the Navajo Times.

An unexpected consequence of flooding: More natural gas flaring in the Aneth Oil Field in SE Utah.

As for the Land Desk, Iโ€™m just trying to get a handle on how these high streamflows fit into the historical context. Itโ€™s not easy, in part because thereโ€™s a lot of erroneous information floating around, but also because a lot of the streamflow gages were knocked offline before their respective streams hit their peaks. And then thereโ€™s the lack of consistent measurements and record-keeping over time.

Even so, some of the numbers are just mind-blowing. Take the Piedra River, which runs into the San Juan on the north end of Navajo Reservoir. It reached 17,000 cfs at the USGS gage near its mouth at Arboles then went offline, though it appears that it didnโ€™t rise much higher. Peak streamflow records on this gage only go back to 1964, but still, this yearโ€™s flow was more than twice that of the second highest, which came during the flood of September 1970.

This is the peak flow for the respective water year. Keep in mind that we have been in the 2027 water year since Oct. 1. Land Desk graph using USGS data.

The San Juan River in Pagosa flooded just over a year ago after a huge storm pounded the San Juan Mountains, setting the third highest streamflow on record (eclipsed by the 1911 flood). This yearโ€™s flows were even higher, and slipped into the third place spot.

Land Desk graph using USGS data.

Downstream from there, the San Juan River at Carracas (just upstream from Navajo Reservoir) was raging at 13,000 cfs when it went offline on Oct. 22 (compared to 9,750 cfs in 1970). Combine that with the Piedra flows, and you have at least 30,000 cfs pouring into the reservoir, causing its surface level to shoot up more than 20 feet. Luckily, the reservoir had plenty of room for the new water following the dry summer, meaning it could hold most of it back. Had the dam not been there, the downstream flows would have been far larger, and far more destructive.

Iโ€™ve heard a few news reports say that the San Juan River at Farmington reached the highest levels on record since 1909. I canโ€™t find any evidence that thatโ€™s true. Although this gage went offline, a field measurement was taken on Oct. 23 at or near the peak when it was 33,100 cfs. This is still lower than was measured in 1927 and 1929. Estimates for the 1911 Flood are far higher than that (in 1916, USGS hydrologists roughly estimated a 150,000 cfs flow around Shiprock).

Had Navajo Dam not held back that 30,000+ cfs from the San Juan and the Piedra, the flow here very well could have been close to a record high.

Land Desk graph using USGS data.

Contributing to the Farmington gageโ€™s flow is the Animas River, a San Juan Tributary. It got huge, but didnโ€™t quite exceed the September 1970 floodโ€™s streamflow. Measured flows in Oct. 1911 (water year 1912), 1927, and 1949 also exceeded this yearโ€™s flow.

Iโ€™ve been told on good authority that the USGS gage just below the Animas-La Plata pumping plant is more accurate than this one (near the Swinging Bridge in the middle of town). However, I stick with this gage because it has the longest historical record of almost any gage in the region. Land Desk graph using USGS data.

After Farmington, the San Juan River continues to receive waters from multiple tributaries, including: La Plata River, Shumway Arroyo, Deadmanโ€™s Wash, Shiprock Wash, and the Mancos River โ€” all swollen by rains. So by the time it reached the gage at Four Corners, it was running a whopping 54,100 cfs on the night of Oct. 24. Records on this gage only go back to 1988, so thereโ€™s not adequate historical context for a good comparison. But itโ€™s indisputably a huge amount of water, and set off alarm bells downstream in Aneth, Montezuma Creek, Bluff, and Mexican Hat, Utah.

Past the Four Corners gage, this veritable wall of water was supplemented by McElmo Creek (which peaked during the storm at a very large 1,590 cfs), Montezuma Creek, and Recapture Creek before reaching Bluff. After breaching a wastewater storage pond for the town of Montezuma Creek, the waters continued onward, spreading out in the floodplain near St. Christopherโ€™s Mission east of Bluff, inundating fields and homes, and then moving into Bluffโ€™s fringe, where it also affected structures. In a Facebook post, Bluff Mayor Josh Ewing estimated that โ€œ17 homes and 3 businesses have extensive damage.โ€

Downstream from Bluff, more tributaries add even more to the San Juan monster: Cottonwood, Comb, and Chinle washes and Lime Creek. However, by the time that pulse of upstream flows had reached this area, the rains had subsided along with those arroyosโ€™ flows. So the USGS gage โ€œnear Bluff,โ€ which is actually located at Mexican Hat, ended up peaking at 38,000 cfs 41,600 cfs on Monday at about 10:30 a.m. That actually puts this yearโ€™s peak (WY 2027 in the graph below) at 5th place since 1915. There was no gauge here during the 1911 Flood, but a USGS paleo-flood investigation concluded that the river that year reached about 150,000 cfs.

Land Desk graph using USGS data.

All of this is good for Lake Powell, of course. After reaching a record low of about 3,516 feet in mid-September, the reservoirโ€™s surface elevation has jumped up to 3,527 feet, and will surely rise more as this San Juan River pulse reaches it in a few days. Whether this is just a temporary respite, or a more long-term salve for the Colorado River crisis depends on whether this El Niรฑo-influenced moisture burst will continue into winter and transform from rain into the mountain snowpack on which the rivers rely.

For an in-depth look at the regionโ€™s floods from ancient times to today, check out this (newly updated) longform Land Desk piece from the archives, available exclusively to paid subscribers. But donโ€™t get mad at the paywall, break it down for less than a cup of coffee a month and โ€ฆ


Four Corners floods: past, present, and … future? Is this the year for a 1911 repeat? — Jonathan P. Thompson


#Colorado wonโ€™t launch water-conservation program in 2027 without guarantee from feds: Officials say saved water should not be released for Lower Basin use — Heather Sackett (AspenJournalism.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Lake Powell behind Glen Canyon Dam. The Upper Basin states signed a grant implementation agreement with Reclamation to fund a voluntary contribution program, but Colorado wants assurances the saved water wonโ€™t be for Lower Basin use. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Journalism website (Heather Sackett):

October 27, 2026

Colorado water managers say a state-run conservation program planned for 2027 is in jeopardy as they wait on an agreement with federal officials.

Before they open the application period for a new conservation program, state officials want assurance from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation that conserved water they store in Lake Powell wonโ€™t just be released downstream for Lower Basin use.

In September, the state water board approved the application review process and criteria for what state officials are calling Coloradoโ€™s near-term contribution program for 2027. The program aims to use nearly $100 million in funding from Reclamation to pay water users in the Upper Basin states (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming) to voluntarily cut back.

But that approval depends upon whether Colorado can get credit for and have control over the stored water. State officials said repeatedly at an Oct. 21 meeting with the Colorado River Water Conservation District that they need assurance in writing from Reclamation that the pool of stored water must be โ€œoperationally neutralโ€ โ€” meaning it would not be factored into reservoir releases or used by the Lower Basin โ€” before they move forward with a state-run program.

Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief with the Colorado Water Conservation Board, state engineer Jason Ullmann and Becky Mitchell, the Upper Colorado River Commissionโ€™s Colorado representative, fielded questions from River District board members.

โ€œEssentially, we donโ€™t want to move forward with any of this process with opening the application window, going through all of this, unless and until we have that assurance from Reclamation that this water is not simply going to be released downstream,โ€ Ostdiek told River District board members.

From left, Interstate Section Chief at the CWCB Amy Ostdiek, Colorado representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission Becky Mitchell and State Engineer Jason Ullmann, speak on a panel at Colorado Water Congress on Aug. 20 in Steamboat Springs. State officials plan to roll out a water conservation program that would pay water users to temporarily cut back in 2027, but need federal assurances first. CREDIT:ย HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Federal officials say operational neutrality for a conservation pool in Lake Powell will require approval from the Lower Basin states (California, Arizona and Nevada). At a UCRC meeting Oct. 19, the Upper Basin states approved a grant implementation agreement, which allows Reclamation to administer the contribution program grant money to the states.

But according to a prepared statement by Wayne Pullan, Reclamationโ€™s Upper Colorado Basin regional director, the grant agreement โ€œdoes not establish any new terms for how conserved or contributed water will be credited to the system or subsequently released โ€” that will require a separate process and agreement, as well as consensus among the seven basin states.โ€

The new two-year federal operating plan for the Colorado River, which was adopted in August, calls for 1.25 million acre-feet of mandatory cuts among the Lower Basin states and annual Lake Powell releases between 6 million and 7 million acre-feet. It also includes the possibility of up to 200,000 acre-feet of Upper Basin voluntary conservation. But beyond this basic framework, many details of operations and programs are left to be hashed out in separate agreements between the states and Reclamation.

Time is running out to get a conservation agreement in place before the 2027 irrigation season. According to the timeline given by state officials, the application window was supposed to be October and November, followed by an evaluation and approval process that would have contracts with participants in place by spring. The Upper Colorado River Commission sent a letter to Reclamation officials in September saying that operational neutrality was essential to the success of a program. Officials say they have not yet received a formal response.

โ€œIโ€™m optimistic that the Upper Division states and Reclamation will develop an appropriate agreement that meets everybodyโ€™s needs,โ€ said Chuck Cullom, executive director of the UCRC. โ€œWhat I am concerned about is how timely that agreement can be developed to support 2027 programs.โ€

River District General Manager Andy Mueller said the district backs state officials and supports the decision not to open the application process without a written agreement from Reclamation. The River District protects water interests across 15 Western Slope counties. Although the conservation program would be open to anyone in the state who uses water from the Colorado River Basin, itโ€™s understood that most of the conserved water would come from Western Slope agriculture, as it has in previous pilot programs.

โ€œDonโ€™t run the program next year if you canโ€™t run it well, if you canโ€™t operate it in a way that protects the values and interests of our communities and agricultural industries,โ€ Mueller told state officials. โ€œPlease donโ€™t do it halfway. Donโ€™t do it too late. Donโ€™t let the federal governmentโ€™s refusal to act in a timely way damage the communities that these folks represent.โ€

Lake Powell as seen from the air in 2019. Colorado officials have said they need assurance from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation that water stored in Powell as part of a conservation program wonโ€™t just be sent downstream for the Lower Basin to use. CREDIT: ECOFLIGHT

Delay could mean low participation rates

Last weekโ€™s discussion came as the federal government has taken over Colorado River operations and management of the nationโ€™s biggest reservoirs after the seven states that share the river could not find agreement after years of failed negotiations.

Upper Basin water managers have long pointed fingers at their Lower Basin neighbors, saying their overuse was responsible for driving the system into crisis. They want to make sure that any water saved through conservation in the Upper Basin wonโ€™t simply be released downstream to be used by the Lower Basin. Precisely what the conserved water will be used for is still unclear and is one of the issues that remain to be figured out in an agreement between the Upper Colorado River Commission and Reclamation.

From 2019 to 2021, Colorado explored what officials called a demand management program, which would have allowed the Upper Basin states to conserve up to 500,000 acre-feet in a pool in Lake Powell. In that case, the water could have been used to help the Upper Basin states meet their water-delivery obligations to the Lower Basin under the terms of the 1922 Colorado River Compact.

But in recent years, officials have been talking about a conserved pool of water being used to boost Lake Powell levels to protect critical infrastructure and maintain the ability to produce hydropower at Glen Canyon Dam. Some experts say flexible, operationally neutral pools could protect Glen Canyon Dam infrastructure, minimize the need for large releases from upstream reservoirs and reduce the risk of litigation among the seven basin states that share the Colorado River.

โ€œReclamationโ€™s priority remains balancing water-delivery obligations and protecting critical infrastructure at Lake Powell,โ€ Pullan said at last weekโ€™s UCRC meeting. โ€œAnd protecting critical infrastructure at Lake Powell means staying above elevation 3,510.โ€

Anne Castle, a Colorado River expert and former federal representative to the UCRC, explained why the Upper and Lower basin states might have different views on operational neutrality. Under the federal guidelines for reservoir operations the amount of water released from Lake Powell each year is based on how much water is in the reservoir. When levels dip below certain thresholds, it triggers a reduction in how much is released.

โ€œThe Lower Basin doesnโ€™t want that to happen,โ€ Castle said.

If a pool of water conserved by the Upper Basin is not operationally neutral, it could bump up Lake Powell above the trigger elevations and cause more water to be released to the Lower Basin.

โ€œThe Upper Basin states are saying we want that pool to be operationally neutral so that that increase in elevation doesnโ€™t affect the releases from Powell,โ€ Castle said. โ€œReclamation has always taken the position that they canโ€™t do that on their own; the Lower Basin states would have to agree that some portion of the water in Powell doesnโ€™t count against the release requirements.โ€

Because the amount of water released from Lake Powell each year is based on how much water is in the reservoir โ€” not on the yearโ€™s snowpack or how much water flows into the reservoir โ€” more water has been released over the past 25 years than has come in, drawing it down to critically low levels.

In 2023 and 2024, the Upper Basin states participated in a federally funded conservation program, known as the System Conservation Pilot Program. Officials received criticism from water users for its hasty rollout in the fall of 2023, and the first year didnโ€™t see much participation because of the short timeline to apply and plan for the following irrigation season. This yearโ€™s delay could run the risk of a similar scenario.

โ€œOne of the painful lessons that we learned from 2023 projects is that the later you go into the fall and winter, the more difficult it is for water users to participate,โ€ Cullom said. โ€œThe longer we go in time, I would anticipate the fewer participants we will get. โ€ฆ At what point have we run out of time? Weโ€™re already later in the year than I think anybody is happy with.โ€

Even if Coloradoโ€™s program canโ€™t come together in time for the 2027 season, the Reclamation funding is good through 2031, Mitchell said, so a program could take place in a future year. She warned River District board members that if Colorado canโ€™t run the program this year, she expects criticism from water users and managers.

โ€œI want to be perfectly honest: If we canโ€™t move forward with this program, there will be pressure from within our own state,โ€ Mitchell said. โ€œBut as of right now, I donโ€™t have the assurances that I need that this water will be protected, and I think thatโ€™s an important component.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

September, October far surpass average monthly rainfall in #Durango: Two months account for bulk of this yearโ€™s precipitation — The Durango Herald #AnimasRiver

Click the link to read the article on The Durango Herald website (Gabrielle Wallace). Here’s an excerpt:

October 26, 2026

After last weekโ€™s heavy rain, October has more than tripled its average monthly precipitation in Durango, according to the National Weather Service in Grand Junction. As of Monday [October 26, 2026], Durango had received 4.28 inches of rain in October alone, said Lucas Boyer, a meteorologist with the NWS. On average, October usually brings in about 1.31 inches, he said. Last October saw 4.26 inches for the entire month, which was an all-time high, he said…The average precipitation for Durango in an entire year is about 12 inches, Boyer said, but Durango has already seen just over 15 inches year-to-date. The all-time high recorded in a year for Durango is about 20 inches, he added. Even with the heavy rains from September and October, Boyer doesnโ€™t expect Durango to hit a new maximum this year…Not only has Durango already seen 15 inches of precipitation so far this year, but more than 10 of those inches were from September and October alone, Boyer reported. September saw 6.2 inches of rain this year, about 4.4 inches more than last year, which saw only 1.8 inches of rain. The September average precipitation in Durango is 1.9 inches. This Septemberโ€™s precipitation was more than triple the monthly average, just as October also tripled its monthly average.

#Cortez sets record for October rainfall; recent storms lift McPhee Reservoir: Montezuma County avoids widespread damage during Four Corners flooding — The Cortez Journal #DoloresRiver #McElmoCreek

Click the link to read the article on The Cortez Journal website (Anna Watson). Here’s an excerpt:

October 26, 2026

Heavy rain triggered historic flooding last week across much of the Four Corners, submerging fields, homes and buildings; washing away several roads; and causing rivers including the San Juan, Rio Blanco and Animas to exceed flood stages…Areas in Archuleta, La Plata and San Juan (New Mexico) counties experienced the most severe damage, while Montezuma County avoided major destruction, according to local officials…Montezuma County Sheriff Steve Nowlin said his office received relatively few weather calls, noting the county appears to have fared better than surrounding counties. However, he noted deputies have remained busy responding to other incidents and calls. County spokeswoman Vicki Shaffer said countywide damage had been fairly minor…

Dolores Water Conservancy District General Manager Ken Curtis said precipitation has been five to six times higher than expected, while runoff has been nearly 10 times the October average. McPhee Reservoir has risen about 12 feet following a gain of 8,000 acre-feet of water in September and another 34,000 acre-feet in October. Curtis said the accumulation is unusual for this later season.

โ€œWe are still very low. We were almost at dead or an inactive pool, so 12 feet is great, but we have a long way to go,โ€ he said, explaining the reservoir is still 51 feet from being full.

Rain Enhancement Technologies’ Upper Yampa Weather Enhancement Pilot Advances Toward Final Permit Approval After Colorado Public Hearing: Installation in Coloradoโ€™s Flat Tops targeted for November to enhance snowpack this

Our WETA (Weather Enhancement Technology Array) systems create negative ions using naturally occurring wind patterns. WETA uses a high voltage DC charge to create corona inception points releasing electrons that ionize passing air particles. These ionized particles are carried up to cloud layers at around 2,000 feet altitude. In the clouds, the charged particles help accelerate the collision and combination of water droplets, causing them to become heavy enough to fall as rain. Credit: Rain Enhancement Technologies

Click the link to read the release on the Rain Enhancement Technologies website (Neal Stein and Linda Maynard):

October 21, 2026 — Rain Enhancement Technologies Holdco, Inc. (NASDAQ: RAIN) (“RET” or the “Company”), a leading provider of ionization rain and snowfall generation technology, today announced that its weather enhancement pilot in Colorado’s Upper Yampa River Basin has completed the state’s required public hearing with no objections raised. The hearing, held October 14, 2026, by the Colorado Water Conservation Board (CWCB), is a key step in Colorado’s weather modification permitting process and moves the permit for the one-year pilot to final approval, with operations targeted to begin in November 2026.

The pilot, first announced in July, will deploy the WETA (Weather Enhancement Technology Array), RET’s ground-based, solar-powered ionization system, in the Flat Tops area of Northwest Colorado. The WETA can operate year-round, enhancing snowpack in winter and rainfall from spring through fall. Under a statement of work between RET and the Upper Yampa Water Conservancy District, the CWCB is planning to fund the pilot, with the District serving as fiscal agent. The pilot targets the drainage basin of the Yamcolo Reservoir, one of the District’s primary water supply facilities, with an area of expected impact of up to 192,000 acres. The expanded target area reflects detailed modeling of the final installation site, which showed wider distribution than initially expected after the pilot was first announced.

At the hearing, the RET team, including CEO Randy Seidl, VP of Engineering Scott Morris and members of the Company’s meteorology and data science staff, walked state officials and local stakeholders through how the pilot meets the twelve criteria Colorado requires of weather modification permit applicants, from target area and operating methods to economic benefit, scientific feasibility, risks and safeguards, and environmental impact. The team also outlined the pilot’s operating safeguards, including automatic shutdown when wind speed or direction falls outside set parameters, suspension of operations during National Weather Service watches and warnings, and coordination with local land managers.

“A public hearing with no objections tells us that the people closest to this watershed, from water managers to land managers to local officials, understand what the WETA does and how carefully we operate it,” said Randy Seidl, CEO of Rain Enhancement Technologies. “We appreciate the support of the CWCB, the Upper Yampa Water Conservancy District, Colorado Parks and Wildlife and the Colorado River District in getting us here. With the permit moving forward, we’re preparing to install in November and look forward to giving Colorado independently validated results to evaluate.”

“Beyond the reservoirs downstream, this site gives us a chance to benefit the land right around it,” said Scott Morris, VP of Engineering at Rain Enhancement Technologies. “We’ll be operating to provide some enhancement to Lake Avery, which is right near the site, and we expect more rainfall and snowpack over the surrounding wilderness areas, which should benefit the forests and the wildlife there.”

“Public hearings are an important part of how Colorado permits weather modification programs, giving local communities and agencies a chance to review a proposed operation and raise any concerns before a permit is issued,” said Andrew Rickert, Program Manager for the CWCB’s Weather Modification Program. “The RET team laid out its responses to the state’s permit criteria clearly, and our next step is to finalize the permit so the pilot can begin, and the results can be evaluated.”

Performance will be measured with a network of instruments installed in and around the target area, including snow-melting tipping-bucket rain gauges and Doppler precipitation sensors, alongside existing SNOTEL (Snow Telemetry) and NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) data. RET’s meteorology and data science team will compare precipitation in the target area against control areas using three independent statistical methods, the same peer-reviewed approach applied to the Company’s winter operations in Utah’s La Sal Mountains, where the WETA delivered a greater than 20% increase in snow water equivalent over the 2025-26 season. The District will receive regular operating reports, and the final seasonal report will be submitted for independent peer review.

Once permitted, the Upper Yampa pilot would become the ninth permitted weather modification program in Colorado and RET’s second in the state, joining its program in Weld County.

About Rain Enhancement Technologies, Inc.

Rain Enhancement Technologies was founded to provide the world with reliable access to water, one of life’s most important resources. To achieve this mission, RET develops, manufactures, and commercializes ionization precipitation generation technology that enhances rainfall and snowpack to address water scarcity challenges. The Company is also developing applications for fog mitigation to expand its weather modification capabilities. RET’s chemical-free, solar-powered technology seeks to transform water resource management for businesses, society, and the planet. To learn more, go to www.rainenhancement.com.

The Colorado Water Conservation Boardโ€™s Weather Modification Program issues permits and monitors weather modification activities across the state. This map shows the permitted projects in Colorado as of October 2025. Credit: Colorado Water Conservation Board

More coverage on The Aspen Times website (Ali Longwell). Here’s an excerpt:

Octobe 26, 2026

The one-year pilot, which is funded by a $100,000 grant from the Colorado Water Conservation Board to the Upper Yampa Water Conservancy District, plans to test a ground-based, solar-powered technology from Rain Enhancement Technologies…Standing at Yamcolo Reservoir just below the Yampa Riverโ€™s headwaters in August, Andy Rossi, the Upper Yampa districtโ€™s general manager, described the technology as โ€œbrand new and experimental.โ€

[…]

Compared to โ€œtypicalโ€ cloud-seeding technology, which involves injecting tiny particles โ€” most commonly silver iodide crystals โ€” into clouds to enhance their precipitation potential, this ground-based technology uses ionization to target a similar effect. Rain Enhancement Technologies calls it the Weather Enhancement Technology Array. In an October interview, Rossi said the installation will be about 30 feet wide and 20 feet long and resembles a ranch gate, with a large frame and electrified coil. It relies entirely on solar power. According to the statement of work for the pilot, โ€œeach station releases electrically charged negative ions into naturally occurring wind flow feeding the cloud with the โ€˜fuelโ€™ needed to cultivate precipitation.โ€ These charges enter the cloud mass and enhance condensation, causing cloud droplets to โ€œprogressively growโ€ until they are large and heavy enough to fall as precipitation, it adds. Meteorologists and technicians with Rain Enhancement Technology will then track storms remotely, firing up the apparatus โ€œwhen they see a storm track that is: one, headed in the right direction โ€ฆ and two, it has the right predicted moisture content there,โ€ Rossi said. A test of the technology outside of Moab, Utah, reportedly led the snow-water equivalent to increase by over 20%. Andrew Rickert, Coloradoโ€™s weather modification program manager, said in April that more traditional cloud-seeding systems can increase a stormโ€™s snowfall by roughly 8-12% when generators are turned on. The Upper Yampa installation will be located at Colorado Parks and Wildlifeโ€™s State Wildlife Area near Lake Avery, with the intent of increasing precipitation in a 200,000-acre area of the Flat Tops and into the basin.

Yampa River Basin via Wikimedia.

Farmington flood — John Fleck (InkStain.net) #SanJuanRiver

A flood for the ages. Credit: InkStain.net

Click the link to read the article on the Ink Stain website (John Fleck):

October 24, 2026

The group chat among my Colorado River posse blew up again this morning as the nerds compared reservoir and stream gage readings resulting from a storm for the ages in the Four Corners.

Staring at gages, you can see the wave of water coming down the San Juan. The gage at Bloomfield blew out late Thursday night, reading 13,100 cubic feet per second (cfs) before it failed. Downstream, the wave blew out the gage at the Bolack Ranch Bridge 7 hours later, running at 17,100 cfs. By the time the USGS gage on the San Juan at Farmington blew out Friday afternoon, the river had risen to ~32,600 cfs, the most water recorded there since the 1930s and more than double the biggest peak since Navajo Dam was completed in the early 1960s.

Flooding stretched from Pagosa Springs on the San Juan River in Colorado to Dennehotso on the Navajo Nation, with what appears to be the greatest impact on human communities in the Northwest New Mexico community of Farmington, at the confluence of the Animas and San Juan rivers. (The Tri-City Record seems to be the go-to source for news out of Farmington, also Patrick Lohmann at SourceNM, local and regional journalism FTW.) The reporteveryone keeps citing in news stories, via the National Weather Service, from late morning yesterday (Friday, Oct. 23), cites Farmington-area law enforcement saying โ€œAs many as 1500 homes and buildings are estimated to be impacted by flooding.โ€ Thatโ€™s 24 hours old.

At 11 a.m. this morning (Saturday, Oct. 24), they closed the Highway 64 bridge over the San Juan in Shiprock after the San Juan overtopped the bridge.

Iโ€™m only loosely familiar with the area, and Iโ€™m not on the ground up there, but based on the gage readings and reports from emergency managers it looks like most of the water came out of two normally dry tributaries โ€“ Gobernador Canyon (a 111-square-mile watershed) and the much larger Caรฑon Largo (1,714 square miles). This is mostly a process of elimination โ€“ the gage below the Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s Navajo Dam peaked at 2,190 cfs Thursday night, which puts an upper bound on the release. Gobernador and Largo are the most plausible ungaged watersheds between the dam and Bloomfield. Also, there was a report of flooding and evacuations in Largo Wash and Gobernador Canyon Thursday evening at 5:39 p.m., less than 6 hours before the Bloomfield gage went dark. The Animas at Farmington was only adding ~8,000 cfs Friday when the gage on the San Juan hit ~32,600 cfs and stopped reporting.

One of the lessons I learned as a young journalist covering earthquakes in California is that the places identified as having the most damage from a natural disaster are not necessarily the worst-hit places. Theyโ€™re often the places that are the worst hit and still have the ability to communicate. This is sparsely populated Navajo and Jicarilla Apache Country, and Iโ€™d assume that the danger and the damage weโ€™re hearing about from the population centers does not tell the full story of the suffering underway in the region.

Climate and flooding

We have three different primary kinds of flooding in the interior arid Southwestern United States: from spring and summer snowmelt; localized flooding from the summer monsoons; and autumn tropical storm remnants. Weโ€™re now experiencing a wave of classic tropical storm remnants.

The moisture that hit the Four Corners came from the remnants of Hurricane Trudy, which skirted the west coast of Mexico Oct. 16-19. This is not a visit from the hurricane itself, but rather its remnant moisture being pulled into the storm track, providing massive moisture fuel for what follows.

A group led by Elizabeth Ritchie at the University of Arizona some years back quantified the impact these storms can have:[1]

Although the tropical cycloneโ€“strength winds rapidly diminish upon making landfall, these systems still carry a large quantity of tropical moisture and, upon interaction with mountainous topography, are found to drop up to 30% of the local annual precipitation.

Much like the summer monsoon, the impact of climate change on this kind of storm in the future is challenging to understand because these storms happen at spatial scales that are difficult for General Circulation Models, the big climate models used to understand the effects of rising greenhouse gases, to resolve. The coarse resolution of the GCMs tends to underestimate how much precipitation comes from the biggest storms โ€“ this is an issue I wrote about back in my science journalism days in the โ€™00s. We have new higher resolution GCMs now, but they still seem to struggle with this.[2]


1Ritchie, Elizabeth A., Kimberly M. Wood, David S. Gutzler, and Sarah R. White. โ€œThe influence of eastern Pacific tropical cyclone remnants on the southwestern United States.โ€ Monthly Weather Review 139, no. 1 (2011): 192-210.

2Bjarke, Nels R., Ben Livneh, Joseph J. Barsugli, Angeline G. Pendergrass, and Eric E. Small. โ€œEvaluating Large-Storm Dominance in High-Resolution GCMs and Observations Across the Western Contiguous United States.โ€ Earthโ€™s Future 12, no. 6 (2024): e2023EF004289. https://doi.org/10.1029/2023EF004289.

Map of the San Juan River, a tributary of the Colorado River, in Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico and Utah, USA. Made using USGS National Map data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=47456307

#LakePowell rose five feet in a week. #LakeMead is still at the bottom. What the Four Corners flood did, and did not do, for the #ColoradoRiver — The Kiowa County Press #COriver #aridification

Click the link to read the article on the Kiowa County Press website. Here’s an excerpt:

October 25, 2026

Three Pacific storms in five weeks have soaked the Southwest, and the third one, the remnants of Hurricane Trudy, turned into the flood that tore through southwest Colorado and northwest New Mexico on October 22 and 23. The water is now arriving in the Colorado River’s two great reservoirs, or rather in one of them. Lake Powell stood at 3,525 feet on October 23, up five feet in a week and eight and a half feet above the record low it set September 15. Lake Mead set a new record low of its own on October 22…For the river, the difference between the three storms is where the rain fell. Polo and Rachel mostly rained below Glen Canyon Dam, or on country that drains to Lake Mead through the tributaries between the two lakes. Trudy rained on the San Juan, the Animas, the Piedra and the Dolores, which feed Lake Powell. The Piedra ran at twice its previous record, the San Juan at Four Corners at nearly four times its record, and Navajo Reservoir, which catches the upper San Juan, gained about 215,000 acre-feet between October 12 and October 24, going from 50 percent full to 62. Vallecito Reservoir above Durango went from 55 percent full on October 12 to 86 percent, and Lemon Reservoir from 59 to 83. Lake Powell took in about 56,000 acre-feet on October 21, 104,000 on October 22 and 81,000 on October 23, against a Glen Canyon Dam release of about 13,000 acre-feet a day. Since October 12 the lake has gained about 340,000 acre-feet. It holds 5.5 million acre-feet, 24 percent of capacity. Reclamation’s weekly update of October 18, written before the flood, already had the Upper Basin at 214 percent of normal precipitation for the water year that began October 1. Lake Mead’s level has little to do with any of it. It depends on how much Glen Canyon Dam lets through and how much Hoover Dam sends on to Arizona, California, Nevada and Mexico. Glen Canyon has released a steady 6,600 cubic feet per second all month. Hoover was releasing 8,000 to 10,000 until October 23, when it dropped to about 5,600, according to Reclamation’s daily river report. The lake reached 1,037.16 feet on October 22, its lowest since it first filled, according to the agency’s Lake Mead elevation records, and rose half a foot by October 24 only because less water was leaving. It holds 6.8 million acre-feet, 26 percent of capacity.

How did last weekโ€™s #AnimasRiver flows compare with historical records? River peaked at 11,200 cubic feet per second Friday, less than half its all-time recorded high — The #Durango Herald

Durango flood of 1911 river scene. Photo credit Center of Southwest Studies, Fort Lewis College.

Click the link to read the article on The Durango Herald website (Shane Benjamin). Here’s an excerpt:

October 25, 2026

Heavy rain from the remnants of Hurricane Trudy that dumped 3 to 5 inches of rain across Southwest Colorado in about 24 hours Thursday caused the Animas River to overflow its banks and reminded residents of the risk of living in a 100-year flood plain. The swollen river reached a flow of 11,200 cubic feet per second at 2 p.m. Friday in Durango. That was nearly eight times the previous 2026 peak of 1,450 cfs, recorded May 15…Still, Fridayโ€™s surge was less than half the riverโ€™s highest recorded flow. On Oct. 5, 1911, the Animas River reached an estimated 25,000 cfs. And not far behind: On June 29, 1927, it reached an estimated 20,000 cfs.

The Animas River in Durango reached 8,700 feet and rising as of 7:30 a.m. on Friday. Thatโ€™s the highest it has been since the flood of 1970 (11,600 cfs) and the 11th highest since consistent measurements began in 1911 (though itโ€™s likely to move into 10th place later today). Further downstream, the Cedar Hill gage near the New Mexico-Colorado line was reading 10,800 cfs on Friday morning, and will likely continue to rise, with the potential for downstream flooding (it will also add to the San Juan Riverโ€™s considerable flows).

Floods strand families, force rescues as #SanJuanRiver nears major flood stage — The Navajo Times

Further downstream, the San Juan River near Bluff, Utah (actually, the gage is located closer to Mexican Hat, and is just below the confluences with Chinle and Comb washes) reached 16,200 cfs on Thursday afternoon. Navajo Dam sits between the high flows in Pagosa and this streamflow gage, so that will keep the upstream high water from increasing levels downstream even more.

Click the link to read the article on The Navajo Times website (Donovan Quintero). Here’s an excerpt:

A surge on the San Juan River moved toward Shiprock on Friday after two days of storms flooded homes, stranded families and forced rescues throughout the Navajo Nation. The San Juan River at Shiprock reached 17.3 feet Friday night, above the 15.5-foot flood stage, according to the National Weather Service. Forecasters expected the river to reach 20.7 feet late Saturday morning, just above major flood stage of 20.5 feet. Upstream in Farmington, the river reached 14.1 feet Friday, surpassing the previous record of 12.3 feet set in 1909. By late afternoon, the river had spread over its floodplain beside the U.S. Highway 64 bridges in Shiprock…At an earlier San Juan County briefing Friday, Navajo Police Deputy Chief Donnie Kee said the highest water was expected to reach Shiprock late Friday night or early Saturday…Police warned families along the river from Farmington west through Upper Fruitland, Nenahnezad, San Juan Chapter, Hogback and Shiprock to Montezuma Creek, Utah. Navajo Nation President Buu Nygren and Shiprock Chapter Vice President Debra Yazzie issued an evacuation alert for families near the river…The floodwater also carried raw sewage after rising water inundated the Bloomfield wastewater treatment plant upstream of Navajo communities, sending untreated wastewater into the river.

Map of the San Juan River, a tributary of the Colorado River, in Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico and Utah, USA. Made using USGS National Map data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=47456307

Rain and floods and tornadoes, oh my! Another burst of tropical moisture slams the Southwest, and this oneโ€™s a real doozy — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

A couple of bald eagles watch the storm move in from a cottonwood tree near Norwood, Colorado. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

From Jonathan’s BlueSky feed this morning:

This is an insane amount of water heading toward Montezuma Creek, Bluff, and Mexican Hat.

— Jonathan Thompson at the Land Desk (@landdesk.bsky.social) 2026-10-25T15:33:39.840Z

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 23, 2026

Yet another round of storms slammed the Southwest this week, wreaking havoc across the region and hitting the Four Corners Country hard. By Friday morning, the rain had let up in most places, but some rivers are continuing to rise toward flood levels. Hereโ€™s a quick rundown of some notable impacts, then on to the hydrographs:

  • The Navajo Nation once again suffered major flash flooding that washed out roads or otherwise rendered them impassible. Perhaps the worst of it unfolded in Dennehetso, a low-lying community between Kayenta and Mexican Water, where the Navajo Department of Emergency Management and other agencies had to use a specialized vehicle to rescue 30 people from flooded homes.
  • An emergency was declared in Hurricane, Utah, after a couple of inches of rain fell in the headwaters of Gould Wash, which then partially inundated the southwest Utah community.
  • An evacuation order was issued for low lying areas along the San Juan River, as stream levels met and then exceeded last Octoberโ€™s high-water levels.
  • The Colorado Department of Transportation closed a segment of Hwy 550 over Red Mountain Pass, CO 17 over Cumbres Pass, Hwy 160 over Wolf Creek Pass, CO 151 near Chimney Rock, and a section of Hwy 160 west of Pagosa Springs due to flooding, debris flows, and/or safety concerns. Those segments remained closed as of Friday morning at 8 a.m.


RERUN: Four Corners floods: past, present, and … future? Is this the year for a 1911 repeat? — Jonathan P. Thompson


Now for a look at some streamflows.

The Animas River in Durango reached 8,700 feet and rising as of 7:30 a.m. on Friday. Thatโ€™s the highest it has been since the flood of 1970 (11,600 cfs) and the 11th highest since consistent measurements began in 1911 (though itโ€™s likely to move into 10th place later today). Further downstream, the Cedar Hill gage near the New Mexico-Colorado line was reading 10,800 cfs on Friday morning, and will likely continue to rise, with the potential for downstream flooding (it will also add to the San Juan Riverโ€™s considerable flows).
The San Juan River in Pagosa Springs hit โ€œaction stageโ€ late Thursday. On Friday morning it reached 9,100 cfs and appeared to still be on the rise. That is the third highest recorded streamflow at that gage, following the flood of October 1911 (25,000 cfs) and the June 1927 flood (16,000 cfs).
Further downstream, the San Juan River near Bluff, Utah (actually, the gage is located closer to Mexican Hat, and is just below the confluences with Chinle and Comb washes) reached 16,200 cfs on Thursday afternoon. Navajo Dam sits between the high flows in Pagosa and this streamflow gage, so that will keep the upstream high water from increasing levels downstream even more.
The Little Colorado River, which gives a good indicator of conditions on the Navajo Nation, topped out at 17,100 cfs on Thursday evening. This gage has only been keeping peak streamflow records since 2003, but this level is by far the highest the river has been in 23 years (second place was 7,550 in 2012).
The Dolores River at Bedrock, Colorado, reached 4,560 cfs on Friday morning, which is the highest it has been since 2005, and the third highest since McPhee Dam started impounding water upstream in 1983.

While itโ€™s been a bit too warm for this wet stuff to take the form of snow in the lowlands and midlands, it has left a good coating of wet, white stuff on the peaks. The Center for Snow and Avalanche Studies monitor at its Senator Beck Study Plot near Red Mountain Pass is recording 12.8 inches of snow, with about five inches of snow water equivalent. Thatโ€™s significantly higher than what the nearby SNOTEL station is currently recording (2.8 inches of SWE).

The #ColoradoRiver is shrinking. Hereโ€™s why that matters for Utahโ€™s biggest cities — The Salt Lake Tribune #COriver #aridification

Looking North East towards Upper Stillwater dam. By Jmanidb – Own work, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=11202632

Click the link to read the article on The Salt Lake Tribune website (Brooke Larsen and David Condos). Here’s an excerpt:

October 20, 2026

Transbasin diversions, such as the Central Utah Project, bring water from the Colorado River Basin to the Great Basin, where most Utahns live.

A massive concrete wall rises 200-feet above a trickling creek where Duchesne Countyโ€™s tan plateaus transform into green forested slopes. Behind it, snowmelt from the Uinta Mountains pools into a dark blue reservoir, water lapping on red rock shores. At just over 8,000 feet in elevation, the Upper Stillwater Dam marks the start of the Central Utah Project, which conveys water from the Colorado River Basin to the Great Basin where around 90% of Utahns live…From Upper Stillwater, a drop of water, which otherwise would flow to the Duchesne River, then the Green River before meeting the Colorado, begins a journey west. It does that thanks to decades of engineering and over 100 miles of tunnels, pipelines and diversions that carry the water to the stateโ€™s biggest cities. After a pit stop at Strawberry Reservoir, it cuts through the mountains and flows into pipelines that deliver water to farms, lawns and taps across the Wasatch Front. Some of that water even makes it as far as the Salt Lake City International Airport…

Graphic credit: Central Utah Project

In all, just over a quarter of the water used in Salt Lake, Utah and Wasatch counties comes from the Colorado River Basin, according to Utah State University…In addition to the Central Utah Project, two other major transbasin diversions and a handful of small projects bring Colorado River water to the Great Basin. The Provo River Water Users Association diverts water from the Duchesne River to the Provo River for farms in the Heber and Kamas areas and cities such as Sandy and Orem. The Strawberry Valley Project, one of the oldest transbasin diversions in the West, brings water from the Strawberry Reservoir to farms and cities in Utah County. This project [predates] the Central Utah Project and distributes water to users separately, but aspects of the two projectsโ€™ operations have become integrated at Strawberry Reservoir…All the transbasin diversions combined diverted around 165,000 acre-feet of water in 2024 to the Great Basin, according to the Upper Colorado River Commission, making up around 15% of Utahโ€™s total Colorado River consumptionthat year.

Map showing the Great Basin drainage basin as defined hydrologically. By Kmusser – Own work, Elevation data from SRTM, all other features from the National Atlas. Rand McNally, The New International Atlas, 1993 used as reference., CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=12079426

#Drought conditions for Gunnison county improved going into winter — The #CrestedButte News

Colorado Drought Monitor map October 20, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on The Crested Butte News website (Katherine Nettles). Here’s an excerpt:

October 21, 2026

For the second year in a row, fall precipitation has come in heavy following an extremely dry summer season. In a county work session update on October 13, Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District (UGRWCD) senior water program manager Beverly Richards described how the wet month of September helped close out the water year with a boost of moisture to streams and soils ahead of winter. However, warm temperatures have worked against the moisture boost, and reservoir storage and overall drought conditions remain a long-term concern for water experts along the Colorado and Gunnison River Basins. Richards said September precipitation in most of Gunnison County was about 110-190% of average, and other areas of the state saw similar conditions. It was the 9th wettest in 30 years and tied with 1940 for fifth wettest in a longer historical record.

Unfortunately, despite that recent rainfall and even some snow, 100% of Gunnison County remains in severe to exceptional drought. โ€œAreas to the south like Hinsdale and Sawatch County have seen some improvement in drought conditions due to the precipitation that occurred in September,โ€ said Richards. While those southern areas saw one class of drought condition/soil moisture improvement, Gunnison County overall had one class of drought condition degradation. Richards reported that some southern areas received between three and six inches of rain during the early October precipitation events. The Upper Gunnison Basin was at 17% of the median amount of precipitation for the end of water year 2026 (which ended September 30) and temperature conditions for September were very warmโ€”the second warmest in 132 years of record for the state. Richards said that was also 5.5 degrees warmer than the 20th century average…Temperatures in early October ranged from four to six degrees above normal based on the period of record…

Stream flows have been variable across the basin, including huge increases in flow at the Lake Fork, Slate and Taylor rivers around September 29. Richards said this helped make up for the low flows in August. The Slate River flow increased 129% in seven hours, and the Taylor increased by 153% in 16 hours. โ€œSo that precipitation event really helped stream flows quite a bit,โ€ said Richards. Reservoir storage is at 47% of average for the entire basin and 33% of average for the upper basin (which includes Taylor and Blue Mesa reservoirs). Blue Mesa ended the water year at 143, 497-acre feet, which was 52% of the end of year levels in 2002, the next lowest year. Richards said Blue Mesa elevation has since declined another 1,030-acre feet and is 17% full. The current elevation of 7,413 feet is about 20 feet above the minimum power pool and 106 feet below the full pool. โ€œWe received communication on September 28 from the Bureau of Reclamation (BOR) that they were anticipating it may fall below power pool in April 2027 if conditions continue to decline,โ€ reported Richards. โ€œItโ€™s in really dire condition.โ€

Map of the Gunnison River drainage basin in Colorado, USA. Made using public domain USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69257550

Vail Valley residents triple #Denverโ€™s water savings during historic #drought — 9News.com

Map of the Eagle River drainage basin in Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69310517

Click the link to read the article on the 9News website (Matt Renoux, Alexander Kirk). Here’s an excerpt:

October 20, 2026

Customers of the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District in western Colorado cut their water usage by 30% this summer. The savings is more than triple the 9% reduction achieved by Denver Water customers, thanks to a strong messaging campaign, strict fines, and a sharp drop in outdoor watering. Denver Water had asked customers to reduce use by 20%. Many Colorado water districts statewide saw drops of 10% to 20%…Vail Valley customers saved more than 1,000 acre-feet of water…Officials say the district faced an uphill battle because many residents are part-time, especially in summer, and may not know about restrictions. Staff took their message on the road, speaking with people face-to-face at events and festivals. Despite the savings, the district remains at high risk for low water storage and is keeping restrictions in place. Reservoirs and rivers will need help filling in the spring.

#Colorado’s Forgotten Diversion Dilemma: The Colorado-Big Thompson project was at the center of a fierce debate that shaped Americansโ€™ relationships to their national parks — Michael Weeks (HistoryColorado.org) #SouthPlatteRiver #ColoradoRiver #COriver

Members of the Colorado Mountain Club looking west towards Grand Lake from on top of the Continental Divide. Many outdoor-oriented activities opposed the C-BT project, fearing environmental damage and the intrusion of commerce into wild Western landscapes. History Colorado Collection, 83.495.3.17

Click the link to read the article on the History Colorado website (Michael Weeks):

February 14, 2023

This article originally appeared in The Colorado Magazine from History Colorado.

Few visitors to Rocky Mountain National Park will ever visit the East Portal. And why would they? Located just a few miles south of Estes Park, the East Portal contains no views of snow-capped peaks or broad valleys teeming with wildlife. Instead, it is framed by low-lying hills and power lines that draw energy from water flowing out of an odd-looking tunnel and pooling into a nondescript reservoir. It is, compared to some of the areaโ€™s more breathtaking vistas, an unremarkable landscape with seemingly little connection with the one drawing hordes of sightseers and adventurers into nearby Rocky Mountain National Park.

Yet appearances can be deceiving. Even while unsuspecting visitors explore one of the nationโ€™s iconic landscapes, the tunnel is redirecting the natural flow of the Colorado River underneath the Rocky Mountains and out the East Portal, en route to users across Northern Colorado. Completed in 1944, the Alva B. Adams Tunnel forms the critical undermountain link in the Colorado-Big Thompson Project (C-BT), a piece of hidden infrastructure that, as you read this, is supplying water to farms and municipalities across the Northern Front Range.

Despite the C-BTโ€™s importance, few Coloradans consider it when they turn on their showers or dig into a plate of seasonal Front Range veggies. But from 1933, when it was proposed, until 1937, when Congress approved the project, the C-BT inspired passionate support and vitriolic opposition from a range of interest groups that Coloradans today would recognize immediately.

The supportersโ€™ side included farmers, industrialists, local boosters and scientists. In the midst of a decade characterized by drought and depression, they argued that C-BT water would rescue the regionโ€™s agricultural economy from collapse by the simple act of moving water from a region that possessed it in comparative abundance to one desperately needing it.

First water through the Adams Tunnel. Photo credit Northern Water.

On the other side were conservationists and nature-lovers who complained bitterly that the Adams tunnel would desecrate Rocky Mountain National Park. They wrote protest letters, pamphlets, and editorials, and appeared before hearings in Congress and the Department of the Interior. Some complained that the tunnel was a commercial intrusion into a national park. They excoriated the business interests and town developers for wanting to scar a landscape set aside for preservation and the enjoyment of the American people. They worried that it would set a precedent for the exploitation of other national parks. Other conservation-minded opponents argued that the tunnel violated the need to preserve wild places for the sake of wilderness. To remove water from the woods and pump it onto the plains, they said, would be to fundamentally alter fragile western ecosystems. The war of words reached such a fever pitch that historian Donald Swain says that the C-BT offered one of the most consequential examples of water project opposition in American history.

Itโ€™s not news that water is central to life, and thatโ€™s especially true here in arid Colorado. Access to water and the sanctity of public landsโ€”issues that defined the fight over the Colorado-Big Thompson Projectโ€”resonate perhaps more than ever as climate change challenges our ability to engineer around aridity. Vitriolic discussions over water use for agriculture, for growing cities, for energy development, and for recreation are happening with just as much ferocity today as they did nine decades ago. Coloradoโ€™s central urban strip continues attracting residents at a breakneck pace, in part due to the outdoor lifestyle afforded by such close access to public lands. Cities on the Front Range are still buying C-BT water rights from farmers…even as the oil and gas industry injects some of that same water thousands of feet into the earth to be lost to underground hydraulic fracturing.

No matter what the use, hardly anybody gets to use water in Colorado without a fight. Itโ€™s as true today as it was in 1933, when the Colorado-Big Thompson project threatened to forever change one of the nationโ€™s most prominent protected landscapes: the snowy peaks and verdant valleys of Rocky Mountain National Park.

Tyndall Glacier in Rocky Mountain National Park. Meltwater from the parkโ€™s many glaciers feed water needs across Colorado. History Colorado Collection, 83.495.1.57

Origins of Conflict

Ever since goldโ€™s discovery near Denver in 1858, Front Range residents have far outnumbered those living in the western half of the state. But eighty percent of the stateโ€™s precipitation falls west of the Continental Divide, creating a problem for the many urban Front Range residents who live in a much drier climate. So, as Coloradoโ€™s population grew throughout the late 1800s, it did not take long for the water-starved majority to devise methods for circumventing geographic barriers.

Grand River Ditch July 2016. Photo credit Greg Hobbs.

Moving water underneath or around a mountain from one watershed to anotherโ€”a process called transmountain diversionโ€”was nothing new when the C-BT controversy emerged during the 1930s. The largest of these early projects, called the Grand River Ditch, transported water in an unlined ditch and wooden flumes to Fort Collins through an area that would eventually become part of Rocky Mountain National Park. In 1904 the Bureau of Reclamation, with sights set on a much larger diversion, suggested damming Grand Lake and then constructing a twelve-mile tunnel that could fill the ditches of Northern Colorado farmers. However, high construction costs and complex engineering tabled the project.

As water users created precedents for gravity-defying projects, conservationists developed a reputation for opposing them. The most notable example involved San Franciscoโ€™s 1907 proposal to dam Yosemiteโ€™s Hetch Hetchy Valley for water and power generation. Though Congress eventually approved San Franciscoโ€™s application, the project galvanized opposition from conservation organizations such as the Sierra Club. Protesters argued that national parks existed for the beauty and enjoyment of the nation and its people and that commercial development violated those core principles.

Politicians and federal officials took note of this growing tension between water developers and conservationists, spurring them to craft laws and principles for human activities in national parks. When Congress established Rocky Mountain National Park in 1915, Franklin Lane, Secretary of the Interior, sought to ensure the legality of water projects within park boundaries. As a former attorney for the city of San Francisco, Lane played a critical role in the bruising battle over damming Yosemiteโ€™s Hetch Hetchy Valley. Head of the vast Interior Department, which oversaw both national parks and the water project builders at the Bureau of Reclamation, Lane worried that national park designation might present too many obstacles to water development. So, the wily attorney inserted the following language into Rocky Mountainโ€™s founding document: โ€œThe United States Reclamation Service may enter upon and utilize for flowage or other purposes any area within said park which may be necessary for the development and maintenance of a Government reclamation project.โ€

That language offered a legal justification for diverting water through the park. However, the following year Congress muddied the waters a bit. In 1916, legislators approved the Organic Act, a lengthy bureaucratic document which, among other things, established the National Park Service. According to the Act, that new agencyโ€™s mission was to โ€œconserve the scenery and the natural and historic objects and the wildlife therein and to provide for the enjoyment of the same in such manner and by such means as will leave them unimpaired for the enjoyment of future generations.โ€ For conservationists and park service employees, the Organic Act was a manifesto for resistance to all kinds of commercial development. Certainly, they reasoned, dynamiting a tunnel through the length of Rocky Mountain National Park would impair the publicโ€™s enjoyment and break the illusion of standing in an untouched wilderness.

Colorado-Big Thompson Project elevation profile map. Courtesy of Northern Water.

Circumstances brought the potential of a massive hole through the national park into public consciousness during the 1930s as Colorado suffered through drought and economic collapse. As crops dried up, an array of Northern Colorado groups came together to request that the federal government investigate the feasibility of blasting a tunnel that could divert Colorado River water through Rocky Mountain. These included five counties, all but one member of Coloradoโ€™s Congressional delegation, editors of each of the regionโ€™s major newspapers, a majority of local elected officials, and Front Range farmers. In 1934 the Bureau of Reclamation agreed to conduct engineering studies in advance of a project proposal. Reclamation Commissioner John C. Page followed up with a letter to Acting Park Service Director Arthur Demaray requesting entry. Demaray refused.

In a formal letter of denial addressed to Secretary of the Interior Harold Ickes, Demaray penned the opening arguments in the fight over the tunnel. He complained that engineering studies taken in the park would require test drillings, resulting in โ€œscarsโ€ and โ€œunsightly debris.โ€ According to Demaray, such surveys and any tunnel which might be built required constructing access roads and trails to โ€œplaces where roads and trails should not rightfully go.โ€ Demarayโ€™s letter rhetorically transformed a local irrigation project into a national issue, pointing out that conservationists had fought to keep national parks โ€œinviolate from such projects,โ€ and that the proposed survey could be โ€œan opening wedge in a hard-won wall of protection which surrounds our park system.โ€ In response, Ickes, a noted supporter of national parks, nonetheless authorized the engineering surveys, believing that he was obligated by the fact that water diversion projects were embedded in Rocky Mountainโ€™s founding legislation.

Conservationists Make Their Case

Following Ickesโ€™ approval, conservation forces quickly mobilized in opposition. Organizations such as the Sierra Club and the Wilderness Society mailed flyers to their supporters and placed ads in newspapers throughout the country. Individuals then sent dozens of protest letters to federal agencies. While some letters appear entirely original, others were variations on templates developed by conservation organizations. Many of these letters are housed at the Broomfield branch of the National Archives. In addition, nationally recognized figures in the National Park Service, directors of conservation organizations, and scientists wrote op-ed pieces in magazines and newspapers.

Their strident opposition came during a period when national parks were drawing patrons in record numbers as many sought escape from the crushing economic collapse of the Great Depression. As the federal government considered the Colorado-Big Thompson Project between 1934 and 1937, annual visitation to Rocky Mountain National Park nearly doubled to 650,000. This was motivated in part by the recently built Trail Ridge Road, which offered stunning views to motorists as they traveled across the Continental Divide between Estes Park and Grand Lake.

The arguments made by conservationists in opposition to the tunnel probably resonate with todayโ€™s Coloradans who enjoy recreating in the stateโ€™s public lands. Letter writers universally expressed concerns that a massive engineering project inside park borders would mar the scenery and set the stage for similar projects in national parks elsewhere. Most protesters extolled the uniqueness of the landscape inside Rocky Mountain National Park, arguing that it was the highest expression of nature and the people of the nation had afforded it the most stringent degree of protection available at the time. Consequently, only development that enhanced the scenery and natural beauty of the parks should be allowed. Many made this distinction clear when they offered support for farmersโ€™ need for water, as long as the conduits that delivered the resource were outside of the park boundaries. Other writers expressed concerns about the declining number of wild places in America, arguing that national parks offered the best opportunity for humans to have unimpaired encounters with wild nature. Finally, many protesters viewed Rocky Mountain through patriotic lenses. They claimed that national parks existed for every American and that a tunnel would prioritize local interests over national ones.

Among the varied written protests, none received more attention than a 1936 pamphlet titled, โ€œA Protest of Conservation Organizations Against the Exploitation of Rocky Mountain National Park.โ€ Its signatories included the most notable conservation organizations of the 1930s, including the Wilderness Society, the American Forestry Association, The Izaak Walton League, the Sierra Club, and the National Parks Association. They argued that the tunnel โ€œviolates the most sacred principle of National Parks, namely, freedom from commercial or economic exploitation,โ€ and that if approved by Congress it would โ€œestablish a precedent for the commercial invasion of other parks.โ€

The most likely author of that pamphlet, Robert Sterling Yard, took the protest a step further, by arguing that the proposed tunnel was an assault on one among a dwindling number of wild places in America. By the 1930s, Yard was in a strong position to make this claim. As the head of the National Park Serviceโ€™s Educational Division from 1916-1919, he promoted national parks as Americaโ€™s โ€œscenic masterpiecesโ€ which, like great art, had the potential to build a more enlightened public. For Yard, irrigation projects in national parks were akin to defacing a Rembrandt painting. So, during the 1920s, he directed much of his energy toward fighting water projects in parks such as Yellowstone, Glacier, and Grand Teton.

During the same period, Yard became increasingly concerned that parks such as Rocky Mountain were being overrun with tourists who seemed more interested in driving through than in enlightening their minds. Though not the same as boring a hole through the mountain or clearcutting a forest, Yard regarded the assault of asphalt and autos as commercial invasions just the same, since they encouraged visitors to rapidly consume landscapes while disregarding their geologic or biologic value. For Yard, blasting holes through the park and the proliferation of roads were two sides of the same coin. Both compromised the core mission of national parks.

By 1930, Yard concluded that the best way to preserve the scientific and scenic qualities of the nationโ€™s iconic parks was to promote vast roadless tracts called wilderness areas. So, in 1935, even as the first tunnel engineering surveys were getting underway, he helped to form the Wilderness Society. According to the Societyโ€™s first publication, wilderness areas are โ€œvirgin tracts in which human activities have never modified the normal processes of nature. They thus preserve the native vegetation and physiographic conditions which have existed for an inestimable period. They present the culmination of an unbroken series of natural events stretching infinitely into the past, and a richness and beauty beyond description or compare.โ€ In short, Yard and his allies argued that the proposed tunnel would do more than deface park scenery; it would violate the fundamental laws of nature. To restore natureโ€™s balance, Rocky Mountain needed less construction and more wilderness.

The most common protest expressed by Robert Sterling Yard and his conservationist allies was that the C-BT prioritized local needs over national ones. Yardโ€™s Wilderness Society colleague Bernard Frank expressed that sentiment when he wrote that the national parks were areas โ€œdedicated to the service and enjoyment of the people of the United States as a whole and not to any narrow interests of any particular locality.โ€ Frank later emphasized that it would be the โ€œprimeval qualitiesโ€ of the park which would be compromised should local โ€œnarrow interestsโ€ prevail. Letter writers Laurel and Lincoln Ellison of Montana cited national interests as well, claiming that the countryโ€™s need for outdoor recreation in โ€œunspoiled natureโ€ฆshould take precedence over such local demands for irrigation and water power.โ€ In an editorial in the New York Times, former National Park Service Director Horace Albright chimed in with similar reasoning. He cited the five million tourists who had visited Rocky Mountain National Park since 1915, the 550,000 travelers who entered the park in 1936, and the seven-and-half million dollars spent by park visitors, arguing that the C-BT would destroy โ€œthe natural charm of the landscape.โ€ He concluded that โ€œprivate interests should give way to the general good.โ€

The arguments against the tunnel put forth by conservationists resonate in Colorado today. Presently, there are forty-two wilderness areas in the state, most of which have been designated since Congress passed the Wilderness Act in 1964. Each wilderness is intended to minimize human impacts by restricting all forms of mechanized travel. In fact, four of these wilderness areas border Rocky Mountain National Park. Moreover, much of the park has been managed as wilderness since 1974. At the same time, the visitorโ€™s desire to motor through has only increased. It took twenty years for total park visitation to hit the five million mark. Today, nearly that many people tour the park by car annually. These numbers are especially evident when spontaneous traffic jams occur at sites where elk or moose grace the roadside. Whether those scenes support or violate the conservation mission of Rocky Mountain remains the subject of sometimes heated debate.

Making the Case for the C-BT

Letโ€™s return now for a moment to the East Portal, where Colorado River water flows out of the Alva B. Adams Tunnel and exits Rocky Mountain National Park. From there the water plunges 2,900 feet through twelve reservoirs and over one hundred miles of canals before it is available to farmers, municipalities, and businesses in Northern Colorado. In 1937, the intended beneficiaries of that water needed to address some of the arguments made by conservationists, even as they directed the debate away from the sanctity of national parks and toward economic benefit. Would the C-BT bring enough benefit to justify its price tag, estimated to be $44 million in 1937? To gain Congressional support and to counter conservationistsโ€™ arguments that the Adams Tunnel would desecrate a national treasure, they had to make the case that the C-BT would bring substantial economic benefit to the nation.

Ralph Parshall squats next to the flume he designed at the Bellevue Hydrology Lab using water from the Cache la Poudre River. 1946. Photo Credit: Water Resource Archive, Colorado State University

Among the many people clamoring for the C-BT, Ralph Parshall stands out. While Parshall was not the loudest voice in the debate, his arguments and evidence were perhaps the most convincing. A resident of Northern Colorado himself, Parshall graduated at the top of his engineering class at Colorado Agricultural College (CACโ€”the forerunner of Colorado State University) in 1904. After completing a masterโ€™s degree at the University of Chicago, he was hired by his alma mater in 1907. As a professor at CAC, Parshall engineered reservoirs, dams, and irrigation canals in Northern Colorado. Then, in 1913, Parshall took a position as an irrigation engineer with the USDAโ€™s Bureau of Agricultural Engineering where he worked for the next forty years. While at the USDA, Parshallโ€™s office and lab remained on the campus of CAC where he collaborated with students and faculty throughout his career.

By the time the C-BT came into public consciousness in the 1930s, Parshall was a well-known figure due to his namesake invention, the Parshall Flume. That innovation made water distribution to agricultural users more equitable wherever it was installed as it increased measurement accuracy in canals and ditches by up to thirty percent. This helped farmers to know how much water they were receiving and prevented water users from taking more than their allotted shares. By 1935, Parshall had also distinguished himself as a pioneer of snow surveys and for developing devices to remove debris from irrigation canals. Combined, Parshallโ€™s work enabled farmers to plan their operations effectively since they could predict the quantity of water available to them. He also earned the respect of individual farmers since he frequently supervised the design and installation of his inventions on their land. Consequently, when the USDA needed a knowledgeable and well-respected figure to prepare an economic analysis of the C-BT, Parshall was a clear choice. He possessed an unshakeable reputation as a skilled irrigation engineer with intimate knowledge of the Northern Colorado landscape.

Parshallโ€™s Agricultural Economic Summary Relating to the Colorado-Big Thompson Project came out in January 1937. It contained a dizzying array of economic data collected by Parshall and his team of researchers. They compiled statistics on value, acreage, water rights, and loan status for every irrigated farm in the region. They also collected precipitation records, breaking down the quantity of water available for every irrigation district and mutual irrigation company in the C-BTโ€™s service area. Parshall went to pains to show how C-BT water would be an affordable and effective solution to the regionโ€™s water woes.

Even as the data spoke loudly, Parshallโ€™s applied understanding of Northern Coloradoโ€™s irrigation-dependent farmers amplified statistics. Aware that a massive Reclamation project might be viewed as a government handout in the midst of the Depression, Parshall characterized the regionโ€™s farmers as โ€œhardy, self-reliant American farmers and townspeopleโ€ who needed additional water to โ€œstabilize the present economic achievement and make secure the possibilities of future progress.โ€ In a nod to popular Depression-era programs, Parshall stated that the guarantee of sufficient water would be like โ€œsocial securityโ€ for existing farmers, enabling them to gain the same security in their later years that working class Americans received. Seeking to demonstrate that the C-BT was a difference maker, Parshall argued that its greatest value would be that its flows would be available late in the growing season, when some water users ran out of water and when an additional application of water to high value crops might make the difference between breaking even and crushing debt. In stark financial terms, Parshall stated that irrigation provided $64 million worth of property value to Northern Colorado, a region valued at $200 million. This additional property value resulted in local, state, and federal taxes that could be invested in schools, infrastructure and economic development.

In Parshallโ€™s analysis of the seventy years of irrigation in the region prior to 1935, he concluded that land values were high because of โ€œgreater assurance that crops will be produced and the possibility of growing crops of higher value than could be grown without irrigation.โ€ According to Parshall, the economic gains made possible by irrigation were far higher than the C-BTโ€™s estimated $44 million price tag. But Parshall extended his analysis far beyond the farm, arguing that prosperous Northern Colorado farmers supported the growth of local businesses, increased railroad traffic, enabled more construction, strengthened financial institutions, and made possible the sort of increased highway traffic that carries with it travelers and tourists eager to spend their money in local businesses.

Sugar beets back in the day. Credit: UC Berkeley

Knowing that C-BT opponents might argue that the nation was suffering from too much agricultural production, Parshall turned that caution on its head by claiming that more water would shift agricultural production away from crops grown in surplus and toward crops not grown in sufficient quantities. For example, he argued that wheat, whose national supply had far outstripped its demand, was a crop of choice in Northern Colorado only when water was in short supply. By contrast, sugar beets, the most lucrative crop in the region, demanded more water than wheat. Yet, the majority of the nationโ€™s sugar was imported. Consequently, according to Parshall, increasing Northern Coloradoโ€™s water supplies would push farmers to grow more beets and less wheat, thus aligning the nationโ€™s agriculture more closely with consumer demand and reducing dependency on foreign sugar. Parshall concluded that the C-BT would support self-reliant, productive Americans who created real economic value that extended to the nation. In short, the C-BT was an overwhelmingly good investment.

No entity agreed more with Parshall’s assessment than Great Western Sugar, the nationโ€™s largest supplier of domestic sugar and Northern Coloradoโ€™s most important economic driver. Great Westernโ€™s factories depended on the same water as the farmers who sold the company its beets. Moreover, as a late arrival to the region, its junior rights werenโ€™t secure. In fact, during the 1934 refining campaign, the companyโ€™s ditches ran dry, and it had to beg local irrigation companies for water to complete its operations. So, the company always craved more water, either by cultivating relationships with its growers or through projects such as the C-BT. To energize local C-BT support, Great Western made liberal use of its grower magazine, Through the Leaves. In it the company published reader-friendly versions of scientific articles showing how their beet harvests would increase with just a little more water. In 1936, the company said it more explicitly: C-BT water would result in an average annual income increase of $400 per grower.

To make the national case for the C-BT, Great Western employed lobbyists in Congress. This was nothing new since the company had always pressured legislators to enact high tariffs against foreign sugar. In 1937, those lobbyists shifted from taxes to water. Great Western also took to the airwaves to make its case. In cooperation with other western beet sugar companies, it paid the National Broadcasting Company (NBC) to do a series of short radio programs titled, โ€œSugar Beets Tell the World.โ€ The broadcasts emphasized how sugar beets grown in the irrigated regions of the West contributed to the American economy, providing figures on grower income, railroad shipments, resources used in refining beets into sugar, and the varied ways beet sugar was consumed. To hear Great Western tell it, beet sugar was essential to the American economy, and the C-BT was essential to the beet sugar industry.

Ultimately, the arguments made by Ralph Parshall, Great Western Sugar, and supporters of the C-BT proved successful. After spirited debate in June and July of 1937, Congress passed bills approving the project and authorizing an initial $900,000 in funding. The following year, prospective water users signed a contract to pay a maximum of $25 million over the course of forty years for the project, with the remainder of the costs being paid for by hydroelectric power generation. That $25 million cap turned out to be quite a bargain. When Reclamation finally completed the C-BT in 1957, total costs had soared to over $160 million.

Conservation, Cattle, and Water

The completion of the C-BT in 1957 heralded shifts in Northern Coloradoโ€™s agricultural landscape that would make the region look familiar to the present-day observer. Former Colorado Agricultural Commissioner Don Ament recently reflected on some of these changes while talking about his familyโ€™s long history in the region. During the 1930s, Amentโ€™s family emphasized sugar beets on their irrigated lands near Sterling. As Ament transitioned into farming for himself in the 1950s and 1960s, he shifted from sugar beets to corn. As he explains, the C-BT played a critical role in the move to corn, a crop that required more water. More importantly, Amentโ€™s well-watered corn found a ready market in the growing commercial cattle feeding industry. By 1970, Northern Colorado possessed the worldโ€™s largest collection of commercially fed cattle, and the regionโ€™s farmers cultivated most of their feed. Today, this is still true. As Ament points out: โ€œtwo-thirds of Coloradoโ€™s agricultural output is livestock, primarily cattle.โ€ Most of those animals are fed with corn from farms irrigated by C-BT water.

Don Ament (right) at a Colorado Foundation for Water Education (now Water Education Colorado) event May 2016.

If the C-BTโ€™s story in the 1960s and 1970s revolved around agricultural possibilities through increased water, the projectโ€™s story today is about growing municipal demands for water. During the 1950s, Northern Colorado possessed a population of fewer than 200,000 mostly rural residents. The 2020 census shows that the regionโ€™s population today is well over one million, with the majority concentrated in cities within thirty miles of the Front Range. Each of the cities receives an allocation of C-BT water for residential use. In support of this shift, the Bureau of Reclamation built new storage reservoirs and increased the capacity of existing ones, while extending water supply lines to previously underserved areas. This has led to increased tensions between municipalities and farmers over selling water rights. During the last thirty years, Northern Waterโ€”the agency that administers the C-BTโ€”agreed to supply water to cities outside of original C-BT boundaries such as Broomfield, Superior, Lafayette, and Louisville. Other cities, such as Thornton, have been more aggressive. In 1986, to accommodate aggressive growth, it paid $55 million to buy up more than 20,000 acres of farmland and the associated water rights in Weld and Larimer Counties. All of this adds greater pressure to conserve remaining supplies.

One of Monfort of Colorado’s feedlots, ca. 1970. Its pens could hold up to 100,000 steers.
Courtesy of Greeley Museum.

For conservationists, the unsuccessful fight to block the construction of the Alva B. Adams Tunnel through Rocky Mountain National Park turned out to be just the first in many battles over water projects within the Colorado River watershed. During the early 1950s, Congressional legislators proposed a series of large-scale projects called the Colorado River Storage Plan, to be constructed for irrigation, power, and flood control at various locales along the river. The most controversial piece of the plan involved constructing two dams along the Green River, within the boundaries of Dinosaur National Monument. In opposition, conservationists, led by the Sierra Club, undertook a massive publicity campaign that successfully removed the dams from the bill. However, it came at a cost as conservationists made a deal to withdraw their opposition to another project dam in a little-known area of sandstone cliffs rich in Native American artifacts known as Glen Canyon. In 1963, that dam was completed creating Lake Powell, which dams the Colorado, San Juan, Escalante, and Green Rivers. Presently, drought, climate change, and water demands have reduced Lake Powell to one-quarter of its capacity, prompting some conservationists, scientists, and others to call for tearing down the dam holding it back.

If there is a single thread that ties together the water and conservation issues of the 1930s with those of the present, it is that the process of moving and storing water is value-laden. For 1930s farmers in Northern Colorado C-BT water was money, since accessing sufficient water at a reasonable price during the Depression would support increased crop production. For conservationists, the cost of the water was too dear, since it would defile one of the most iconic landscapes in America, setting a precedent for the commercial exploitation of other national parks. Both sides tried to answer questions about the relative value of our natural and scenic resources. Those questions are as pertinent today as they were back then.


Michael Weeks

Michael Weeks

Guest Author

Michael Weeks is a lecturer in the Department of History and Political Science at Utah Valley University. He is the author of Cattle Beet Capital: Making Industrial Agriculture in Northern Colorado, which tells the story of how Greeley evolved from a planned agricultural colony to become the worldโ€™s epicenter for commercial cattle feeding.

Colorado transmountain diversions via the State Engineer’s office

NEWSWIRE: The soaking of the Southwest continues, plus a lot more — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

The La Plata Mountains in full autumnal splendor. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Jonathan posted this on BlueSky after the publication of the article below:

San Juan River downstream from Bluff hit 14,800 cfs last night, it's highest level since 2013. More rain coming today. This will boost Lake Powell's levels and give rafters a pretty fast ride! nwis.waterdata.usgs.gov/ut/nwis/peak…

— Jonathan Thompson at the Land Desk (@landdesk.bsky.social) 2026-10-22T13:51:00.840Z

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website:

October 14, 2026

โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Welcome to another totally human-curated (and a bit late) edition of the Land Deskโ€™s Newswire, a weekly compendium of important news happening around the Four Corners Country and beyond. Once again, the big news is the weird weather, which includes soaking rain, snow, big rivers, and even a tornado.

The Paria River where it meets the Colorado swelled up to about 2,000 cubic feet per second two days ago, and had I stuck around Lees Ferry for an hour or so longer I might have witnessed it. Instead, I headed south and east under a constant gray sky and passing through squalls on the way.

โ€œForrest Gump Hillโ€ in Monument Valley, the place to where people travel from far far away to take a photo of themselves in the middle of the road, was as crowded โ€” and hazardous โ€” as ever. The buttes and bluffs near Montezuma and Aneth were carpeted with such green that I was disoriented, and in McElmo Canyon, where it looks like farmers will easily get another cutting of hay, the vibe was much more August monsoon than October storm.

The landscape around Aneth, Utah, is unusually verdant this October. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • Tropical Storm Rachel has brought significant moisture to a big swath of the Southwest and beyond over the last few days. Observers with the CoCoRaHSnetwork reported 24-hour rainfall totals of as much as two inches (in the Hermosa area north of Durango), bringing the Animas River through Durango up to 2,380 cubic feet per second and rising, as of noon on Oct. 14. A bit to the east of there, the Piedra River near Arboles shot up to 2,190 cfs, and Vallecito Creek has topped 1,000 cfs as I write this around noon on Oct. 14.
  • As of the morning of Oct. 14, very wet, slushy snow โ€” or, as the Germans call it, Schneeregen โ€” was falling on Dove Creek, Colorado, elevation 6,800 feet. It wasnโ€™t sticking there, yet, but folks in Silverton (9,318 feet) woke up to a dusting on the ground, marking the first SNOTEL station-detected snowpack in the Animas River watershed (a .6โ€ snow water equivalent).
  • Southwest Colorado residents reported a tornado between Tiffany and Allison, near the New Mexico border on the afternoon of Oct. 13. One Facebook poster said it hit her dadโ€™s property and damaged outbuildings, while others reported that it took out barns, ripped up fencing, and uprooted trees.
  • Social media posts show that thereโ€™s enough snow on Grand Mesa in western Colorado for some ski touring.
  • SNOTEL stations on the Upper Colorado River Basin are showing well above normal precipitation accumulation for the first two weeks of Water Year 2027.

And in other weather and climate related news โ€ฆ

The heat has once again taken its toll in the Phoenix area. The cityโ€™s fire department recorded 1,744 heat-related calls โ€” significantly more than last year โ€” between May 1 and Aug. 31, including 98 rescues from mountain trails and 14 patients that had to be hoisted by helicopter. Maricopa County has recorded 389 confirmed heat-related fatalities this summer, with another 383 under investigation. (ABC15, Maricopa County)

๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES ๐Ÿ“ˆ

  • The Bureau of Land Management moves ahead with plans to lease 113 parcels covering 126,440 acres of public land in Colorado for oil and gas drilling, despite widespread opposition. Among the land to be on the auction block in December are 5,000 acres on the Roan Plateau and several parcels in the HD Mountains and near Chimney Rock National Monument just north of the Southern Ute Indian Reservation in southwestern Colorado. The protest period ends on Nov. 8. (Aspen Daily News, BLM)
  • A New Mexico advocate laments Permian Basin oil and gas drillingโ€™s effects on residents, the landscape, and the Pecos River, calling it a โ€œbeautiful river in the middle of a hellscape.โ€ (Capital & Main)
  • An analysis finds Arizona utility Salt River Project customers could pay up to eight times more to operate the Craig coal plant under the Trump administrationโ€™s emergency orders than for solar-plus-storage resources. The plant was scheduled to shut down at the end of last year. (Energy & Policy Institute)
  • A coalition of environmental groups files a lawsuit seeking to block the Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s approval of a road construction project, aka hydrocarbon highway, in Gate Canyon in eastern Utah designed to expedite oil-hauling in the Uinta Basin. Gate Canyon feeds into the culturally significant Nine Mile Canyon. (SUWA, BLM)
๐ŸŒต PUBLIC LANDS ๐ŸŒฒ
  • A federal court temporarily blocks the Trump administrationโ€™s plans to reorganize โ€” some would say dismantle โ€” the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which included moving the Forest Service headquarters to Salt Lake City and shuttering multiple research facilities. โ€œThese forced moves were never about efficiency. They were about pushing experienced people out the door,โ€ said American Federation of Government Employees President Everett Kelley in a statement. (Politico)
  • U.S. Rep. Paul Gosar (R-Ariz.) introduces legislation that would require congressional approval for federal land withdrawals of more than 5,000 acres, including for presidential designations of national monuments under the Antiquities Act. (Navajo-Hopi Observer)
๐Ÿฆซ WILDLIFE WATCH ๐Ÿฆ…
  • The Preregrine Fund releases four more California condors into the wild at Marble Canyon in northern Arizona, bringing the areaโ€™s flock of the endangered birds up to 96. (Arizona Republic)
Condor X8, a female hatched in 2018, sits on a Navajo Bridge beam which spans Marble Canyon in northern Arizona. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • Wyoming wildlife officials say 14% of the Sublette Pronghorn Herd died over six weeks this summer, and attribute the unusually high mortality rate to malnutrition resulting from drought-parched forage. (WyoFile)

๐Ÿ›ป TRANSPORTATION ๐Ÿš‚

  • Len Necefer goes deep on the electric vehicle charging network โ€” or lack thereof โ€” on tribal nationsโ€™ land in Arizona. (All At Once by Dr. Len)

๐Ÿค‘ GENTRIFICATION JOURNAL๐Ÿ’ฐ

  • Sublette County, Wyomingโ€™s commissioners vote to eliminate a 2021 zoning change that cleared the way for billionaire Joe Rickettโ€™s proposed upscale resort in the Upper Hoback River area. (WyoFile)

๐ŸŒจ๏ธ๐Ÿฆฆ๐Ÿšฃ๐Ÿฝ WATER WATCH ๐ŸŒŠ

  • Rural Arizonans in the Prescott area are forced to haul water as regional population growth and aridification draw down groundwater levels and dry out wells. (Cronkite News)

โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ

  • The Navajo Nationโ€™s Coppermine Chapter passes a resolution โ€œunequivocallyโ€ opposing Chakana Copperโ€™s proposed Copper Mesa Project in a historically mined area near Page, Arizona; mining company executives say they wonโ€™t go forward unless the project is โ€œwholeheartedly endorsed by the community.โ€ (KJZZ, Essential Minerals)
  • Hillsboro, New Mexico, residents push back on New Mexico Copperโ€™s proposed Copper Flat mining project near the small community, with water consumption topping their list of concerns. (Searchlight New Mexico, New Mexico Copper)

๐Ÿ”ญ OVERSIGHT (or lack thereof) ๐Ÿ‘ฎ๐Ÿผ

  • Journalist and clean energy advocate Bill McKibben delves into the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or permitting reform legislation, thoroughly exploring arguments for and agains. Though he is conflicted, and agrees on many points with proponents of the bill, he ultimately comes down in opposition to the legislation because it weakens bedrock environmental laws and would benefit fossil fuels. (The Crucial Years)
  • An 18-year Interior Department veteran resigns to protest the Trump administrationโ€™s โ€œdeeply troubling assault on the rule of lawโ€ and its efforts to weaken or eviscerate environmental protections to benefit the fossil fuel industries. (Public Domain)
An outtake from John Murdockโ€™s resignation letter from the Department of the Interior. Source: Public Domain.
  • Leaked data show the Interior Department has lost nearly 10,000 permanent staffers since the Trump administration took office, with the Bureau of Land Management staff down by 45% since 2024. (Wes Silerโ€™s Newsletter)
๐Ÿ“Š ECONOMIC INDICATORS ๐Ÿ’ธ
  • Page, Arizonaโ€™s economy shows signs of a shift as the lodging, retail, restaurant, and grocery sectors fade while the construction, remote seller, amusements, and commercial leasing areas surge. (Choose Page)
๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ
  • An analysis finds about 100 data centers have driven nearly all of the increased demand on Arizona Public Serviceโ€™s power grid, and the utility is charging its entire customer base to purchase outside power to meet the growing load, prompting state Attorney General Kris Mayes to call for an investigation. (KJZZ, Abhay Padgaonkar)
  • Arizona data show that the stateโ€™s sales and use tax exemption for data centersโ€™ computer equipment cost the state $38.5 million in fiscal year 2025, up from $19.4 million in 2024. (Good Jobs First)
  • Federal data show proposals for grid-connected gas-fired power plants have nearly tripled over the last three years, largely due to data center-driven electricity demand growth. At least 12 of the facilities in the planning pipeline are in the Western U.S. (Environment America)
  • Oracle considers trucking natural gas to its Project Jupiter data center complexunder construction in southern New Mexico after the state denied its proposed gas pipeline, prompting Energy Transfer LP to reroute it. Oracle also trucks gas to one of its data centers in Salt Lake City, adding to the facilityโ€™s environmental impacts. (Searchlight New Mexico)
๐ŸŒž GOOD NEWS! ๐Ÿ˜Ž
  • The MacArthur Foundation awards Chip Thomas, aka Jetsonorama, a genius grant for his large-scale murals with social justice themes that can be found across the Southwest and on the Navajo Nation. (NPR)
  • The High Desert Museum is accepting nominations for the Jordan Schnitzer Prize of the West, a $50,000 philanthropic award for leaders tackling the American Westโ€™s most pressing environmental challenges, from water scarcity to wildfire, that is awarded annually to an individual or small group who has contributed in practice, scholarship, or policy to the regionโ€™s future, with emphasis on innovation, social impact, uncommon collaborations, and scalability. Nominations are open through Dec. 31. (High Desert Museum)
Dolores River watershed
๐Ÿ“– READING LIST ๐Ÿ“ฐ
  • Heads up Four Corners area folks: Iโ€™ll be giving a presentation on the Dolores River as part of a Dolores River Boating Advocatesโ€™ event on Friday, Nov. 6, from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. at the Powerhouse in Durango. Following a short film about Snaggletooth Rapid Iโ€™ll speak about my personal relationship with the Dolores River, its history, the way it is a sort of microcosm of the Colorado River as a whole, and about its potential futures. Iโ€™ll also throw in a funny little tale about the time I saw Ed Abbey go through Snaggletooth. Tickets are $10 โ€” which will help DRBA defray costs โ€” and seating is limited. There will also be a cash bar. Reserve your spot now: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/a-changing-dolores-river-a-conversation-with-drba-and-jonathan-thompson-tickets-2001390992334
POSTSCRIPT

Iโ€™m going to be out and about and on the road and often off grid for the next week, meaning these dispatches may come even more sporadically than this one! My apologies for any confusion or Land Desk withdrawal symptoms that may lead to.

Herd of pronghorns. Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=216046

Arizona joins Nevada to fight federal Colorado River plan: The Grand Canyon State is suing over Trump administration rules that would sharply reduce the amount of water Arizona receives from the river — Stephanie Casanova (High Country News)

The Hoover Dam impounds the Colorado River and forms Lake Mead, pictured in 2022. Arizona has joined Nevada’s lawsuit against the Trump administration’s 10-year plan for managing the drying Colorado River. Christopher Clark / U.S. Bureau of Reclamation

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Stephanie Casanova):

October 20, 2026

The Arizona Department of Water Resources filed a motion Friday to intervene in Nevadaโ€™s earlier lawsuit, claiming the federal governmentโ€™s plan for the shrinking river would โ€œdevastate Arizonaโ€™s economy,โ€ the agencyโ€™s director said in a news release.

โ€œThe Stateโ€™s towns, cities, tribes, farmers, factories, and businesses cannot survive without sufficient water from the Colorado River,โ€ attorneys for the state claim in the motion.

Nevada filed a lawsuit in late August against several federal agencies, arguing that their plan places a heavier burden on the Lower Basin states. The amount of water in the  Colorado River is dwindling because of climate change, which is reducing the amount of snow and runoff that fills reservoirs like Lake Mead and Lake Powell, and mid-20th century agreements that promised water users more water than actually exists. Because the seven states that rely on the Colorado River couldnโ€™t reach an agreement on how to manage the water, the federal issued a plan intended to better balance the amount of water in the river with the amount withdrawn.

Arizona and Nevada argue they have already taken steps to conserve water and are being unfairly targeted.

โ€œThe Lower Basin states have contributed millions of acre-feet of water toward stabilizing the river system. With more than 5.5 million acre-feet of Arizona water left in Lake Mead since 2014, no state has sacrificed more,โ€ Arizona Department of Water Resources Director Tom Buschatzke said in an Oct. 16 statement. โ€œThe US decision puts the entire burden of sacrifice on the shoulders of three states. We are joining Nevada in challenging that framework.โ€

The Colorado River is divided between Upper Basin states โ€” Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming โ€” and Lower Basin states: Arizona, Nevada and California. The 1922 Colorado River Compact allocates 7.5 million acre-feet of water annually to each of the two basins, as well as a smaller portion for parts of Mรฉxico. The U.S. states in each basin divide their shares.

An acre-foot is the equivalent of almost 326,000 gallons of water, enough water to cover a football field in roughly a foot of water. In Arizona, one acre-foot typically is enough to serve three single-family homes for a year, according to the Arizona Department of Water Resources.

California gets the largest share of Colorado River water: 4.4 million acre-feet per year, or about 27%. The stateโ€™s Lower Basin peers get smaller allocations. Arizona receives 2.8 million acre-feet, or about 17% annually. Nevada receives 300,000 acre-feet, or about 2% annually, according to Congressional reports and a California public policy analysis.

“We will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses.”

The U.S. Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s plan requires the Lower Basin states to shoulder potential cuts. For Arizona, the proposal means a reduction of 760,000 acre-feet per year โ€” about a quarter of the stateโ€™s water allocation and the largest cut among the three Lower Basin states. California would be required to cut 440,000 acre-feet per year and Nevada 50,000 acre-feet. The cuts could amount to up to 3 million acre-feet.

The federal government is not requiring cuts for Upper Basin states. Instead, the government is asking the upstream states to voluntarily contribute 200,000 acre-feet each of the two years.

โ€œArizona has always been willing to do our part to protect the Colorado River, but we will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses,” Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs said in a statement Friday.

The Department of the Interior criticized Arizonaโ€™s legal action and said the Trump Administration is working with the Basin states, tribes and water users on an agreement.

โ€œGovernor Hobbs is wrong, and itโ€™s unfortunate to see Arizona playing politics instead of working toward meaningful solutions,โ€ a spokesperson for the Department of the Interior told Arizona Luminaria in an email statement. โ€œLitigation wonโ€™t create a single additional drop of water or change the hydrologic realities facing the Colorado River Basin.โ€ [ed. emphasis mine]

In a complaint Arizona filed with its motion to join Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit, the state claims there was a flaw in the federal governmentโ€™s environmental review underpinning the decision. Every federal option considered โ€œassumed that the Upper Basin States would make no meaningful reduction in their own use, no matter how little water the River produced.

โ€œThe alternatives placed the full burden of any resulting shortfall on the Lower Basin,โ€ the complaint says.

Western water rights are prioritized according to a โ€œfirst in time, first in rightโ€ doctrine, meaning those who claimed or purchased river water first are prioritized over water users who did so later. That means Arizona’s Colorado River rights are lower priority than California’s, which were acquired earlier.

โ€œSuch reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project canal system, as well as many of our on-river communities and would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement,โ€ Buschatzke said.

Nevadaโ€™s August lawsuit came just three days after the U.S. Department of the Interior formally announced its Colorado River plan in August. In it, Nevada claims the cuts โ€œwill cause devastating environmental, socioeconomic, and health and human safety impacts to southern Nevada and its citizens.โ€

The lawsuit also claims that the federal governmentโ€™s plan violates several requirements within the Law of the River, based on a series of records that include compacts, treaties, laws and court decisions that manage the Colorado River.

Nevada Gov. Joe Lombardo welcomed Arizonaโ€™s decision to join the lawsuit, saying in a Friday statement that itโ€™s โ€œan important step in challenging a federal plan that unfairly burdens the Lower Basin and fails to require the Upper Basin to make meaningful reductions.โ€

Arizona says joining Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit would allow it to avoid filing a separate but similar lawsuit, and allow the borderlands state to represent its own interests.

โ€œArizona believes that taking this action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users,โ€ Buschatzke said.

This story was produced as part of the Western Environmental Reporting Collaborative, a partnership between Arizona Luminaria, High Country News, Report for America and local news organizations across the West.

We welcome reader letters. Email High Country News at editor@hcn.org or submit a letter to the editor. See our letters to the editor policy.

This story has been updated with comments from the U.S. Department of the Interior.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

How climate change is messing with the Westโ€™s weather: Record fires, floods and weather whiplash makes for a region of extremes — Jonathan P. Thompson (High Country News) #RioGrande #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

New Mexicoโ€™s Elephant Butte Reservoir was nearly full on June 2, 1994 (left), in contrast with very low levels on July 27, 2026 (right). NASA Earth Observatory/Michala Garrison

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 19, 2026

On July 11, the Rio Grande dried up at the streamflow gauge about 18 miles upstream from Truth or Consequences, New Mexico. It was notable, because this stretch of riverbed was once actually underneath Elephant Butte Reservoir, the stateโ€™s largest reservoir and an important storage facility for downstream irrigators. But by this summer, two decades of drought had reduced Elephant Butte to just 1.7% of its 652 billion-gallon capacity, leaving behind a mudflat that soon became a dry, dusty riverbed. By September, however, the previously barren riverbed was flowing at more than 3,000 cubic feet per second. Elephant Butteโ€™s surface level rose by several feet, and the green chile-growing communities of the Lower Rio Grande Valley experienced severe flooding caused by record-breaking rainfall boosted by a hurricane in the Pacific.

In many ways, this contrast of extreme dryness with surprising amounts of drenching moisture provides a snapshot of the 2026 water year, which ended on Sept. 30. In the Colorado River and Rio Grande watersheds, it was marked by both intense drought and record-breaking rains that inspired devastating wildfires later followed by catastrophic floods. One of the driest 10 months on record was bookmarked by record-breaking rainfall.

In short, the 2026 water year was one of the weirdest ever experienced by much of the West. And climate changeโ€™s fingerprints are all over it.

The water year started off on a rainy note, especially in the San Juan River Basin in southwestern Colorado, the source of one of the Colorado Riverโ€™s largest tributaries. Remnants of a tropical storm dumped over 6 inches of rain in about 48 hours at Wolf Creek Pass, near the headwaters of the San Juan and Rio Grande. This caused the San Juan River to swell to more than 8,000 cubic feet per second, jump its banks, and wreak havoc and destruction on the town of Pagosa Springs. It also boosted the surface elevation of Navajo Reservoir on the Colorado-New Mexico border by some 50 feet.

Dashboard 1

It all seemed to bode well for the winter to come. If that amount of moisture were to fall as snow, it would provide a deep base for skiers and for the following springโ€™s runoff, which is what keeps the nationโ€™s second-biggest reservoir, Lake Powell, from going dry. But this year, the snow failed to fall like it normally would, even in the depths of winter. When it did fall, it tended to melt, sometimes even before it reached the ground.

Part of the problem was timing: The abundant precipitation came too early to fall as snow. But the biggest factor was temperature. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration data reveals that most of the West experienced its warmest autumn and winter on record. The only exception was the Pacific Northwest, which had its second-warmest autumn and winter in 130 years. The result was that even places that received near-normal precipitation accumulation and werenโ€™t technically in a drought suffered through one of the most severe snow droughts in recorded history.

The Westโ€™s streams and rivers โ€” and therefore its reservoirs and irrigation ditches and municipal water systems โ€” depend on snowmelt for at least 80% of their flows. A bad snow year leads to scant runoff, which in turn drains reservoirs. In September, Lake Powell reached its lowest level since the 1960s, setting off alarms across the region for the tens of millions of people that rely on it.

Droughts โ€” even snow droughts โ€” arenโ€™t unusual in the West. Nor are extreme weather fluctuations. But this yearโ€™s drought was one of the most severe in over a century. A peer-reviewed paper published this summer out of the Colorado School of Mines determined that it was almost certainly the result of human-caused climate change.

The authors found that across the West as a whole, the 2026 snow drought was about four times more likely to occur in the current climate than during the 1850-1900 comparison period. In the Upper Colorado River Basin, where the drought was most severe, these dire conditions were about 14 times more likely to occur in our current climate than in pre-industrial times.

That doesnโ€™t mean we should expect severe snow droughts every year from here on out. But as global temperatures continue to increase, Westerners should gird themselves for more extreme, increasingly weird, and very often destructive weather.

Note: This story was updated to include charts for the snow water equivalent in the upper Colorado River region from 2026.

We welcome reader letters. Email High Country News at editor@hcn.org or submit a letter to the editor. See our letters to the editor policy.

#Arizona joins #ColoradoRiver fight in federal court — The Deseret News #COriver #aridification

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

Click the link to read the article on The Deseret News website (Leah Bowers). Here’s an excerpt:

October 16, 2026

Arizona Department of Water Resources Director Tom Buschatzke said the litigation pathway was never the preferred alternative. โ€œWe were not successful in coming to an equitable outcome among all seven states,โ€ he added…

The core of the departmentโ€™s decision โ€” and the source of contention between the states โ€” is how the water conservation efforts are split. The four Upper Basin states (Utah, Colorado, New Mexico and Wyoming) face no mandatory water reductions โ€” they are subject to voluntary conservation goals. The three Lower Basin states (Arizona, California and Nevada), however, could be required to cut their water usage by up to 3 million acre-feet…Even between the three Lower Basin states, the cuts are not spread evenly. Arizona is expected to accept 61% of the cuts, California 35% and Nevada 4%…

โ€œSuch reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project as well as many of our on-river communities,โ€ said Buschatzke. โ€œIt would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement. Arizona believes that taking its action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users.โ€

Arizona claims the new guidelines โ€œfailed to deliverโ€ the water that Lower Basin states are owed: โ€œLike Nevada, Arizona believes the federal governmentโ€™s new operating framework ignores basic elements of the law of the river,โ€ said Buschatzke. โ€œIt could result in cuts to the state apportionment that would devastate Arizonaโ€™s economy.โ€

[…]

A multistate compact adopted in 1922 designates 1.5 million acre-feet to Mexico, 7.5 million acre-feet to the Upper Basin states, 7.5 million acre-feet to the Lower Basin states and 1.5 million acre-feet to evapotranspiration. That totals 18 million acre-feet in the Colorado River each year. However, some experts say much of the conflict the Southwestern states live with now is due to bad math from the beginning of the law โ€” claiming there was never 18 million acre-feet of water to divide in the first place.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#Arizona moves to join #ColoradoRiver lawsuit alongside #Nevada — KJZZ #COriver #aridification

Marble Canyon. Photo credit: Western Resource Advocates

Click the link to read the article on the KJZZ website (Alex Hager). Here’s an excerpt:

October 16, 2026

Arizona has filed to join a lawsuit against the federal government over its new plan for managing the Colorado River. The federal plan would cut Colorado River supplies for Arizona, California and Nevada by about 20% through 2028, and could cut them by about 40% after that. The lawsuit, originally filed by Nevada in August, argues that the plan is too harmful to water users in those states. Arizona would take the largest cuts under the new federal plan, and state officials have openly criticized it. By filing a motion to intervene in Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit, they are arguing that the federal water plan is not only unfair, but illegal.

โ€œArizona believes the federal government’s new operating framework ignores basic elements of the law of the river and could result in cuts to the state apportionment that would devastate Arizona’s economy,โ€ said Tom Buschatzke, director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources.

Tom Buschatzke. Photo credit: Arizona Department of Water Resources

The lawsuit is not the so-called โ€œnuclear optionโ€ that could bring Colorado River matters before the Supreme Court. That would likely require one state to sue another. Arizona has laid out its case to sue if it determines that upstream states are not sending a legally-required amount of water downstream, but has not yet done so…The lawsuit Arizona filed to join on Friday does something different. Nevadaโ€™s original suit claims that the federal government violated procedural laws while creating its new plans for managing water. The Bureau of Reclamation, the federal agency which operates reservoirs and dams across the West, is required to fill out a lot of paperwork alongside big decisions about water management. Within that paperwork, Reclamation has to explain how its new strategy might impact the environment, people and businesses that are connected to the river system. Nevadaโ€™s lawsuit โ€” and Arizonaโ€™s motion to join it โ€” argues that Reclamation did not do enough to consider the extent of that impact.