The Upper #GunnisonRiver Water Conservancy District Board of Directors approves drop in Taylor Reservoir level — The Gunnison Country Times #TaylorRiver

Taylor Reservoir. (COURTESY PHOTO)

Click the link to read the article on the Gunnison Country Times website (Joshua Pike). Here’s an excerpt:

October 8, 2026

The Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District Board of Directors approved lowering the Oct. 31 reservoir level at Taylor Reservoir from 50,000 acre-feet to 48,000 acre-feet at its Sept. 28 meeting. The targeted Oct. 31 water level helps guide releases from the reservoir into the Taylor River downstream, since the level determines how much water is available for release. It also affects how much the reservoir refills over the winter and how much water is available for release the following year. Decisions on reservoir levels and releases are guided by the Taylor Local Users Group, which includes representatives for a variety of recreation interests on the river, irrigators on the Taylor and Gunnison rivers and property owners in the area. Taylor Local Users Group recommendations on releases and reservoir levels must then be approved by the Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District, the Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, and the Colorado River Water Conservation District, all of which are signatories to the 1975 agreement that established rules governing the reservoirโ€™s operations…

At the Sept. 28 Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District meeting, Don Sabrowski, district president and Taylor Local Users Group chair, explained that, since 2026 is a dry year, the target for the Taylor Reservoir was not to go below 50,000 acre-feet by Oct. 31. According to Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District General Manager Sonja Chavez, the district usually aims to keep the reservoir from dropping below 70,000 acre-feet in normal or wet years.

Gunnison River Basin. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69257550

#Arizona Governor Katie Hobbs and ADWR Join #Nevada in Colorado River Lawsuit to Block Federal Cuts to Lower Basin Water Supplies #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

Here’s the release from Governor Hobbs’ website:

October 16, 2026

Today, Governor Katie Hobbs and the Arizona Department of Water Resources (ADWR) announced the State of Arizona has intervened in a lawsuit brought by Nevada against the Department of the Interior to hold the federal government accountable for failing to enforce Upper Basin water delivery obligations to Lake Mead and prevent cuts of up to 3 million acre-feet per year. In joining this lawsuit, the State will seek to preserve the two-year Lower Basin Agreement while ensuring the federal government is delivering the water to Lake Mead that belongs to Arizona and the Lower Basin states.

โ€œArizona has always been willing to do our part to protect the Colorado River, but we will not accept a forced federal plan that solves this crisis on the backs of our families, farmers, and businesses,” said Governor Katie Hobbs. “We are drawing a line in the sand. I am taking this legal action alongside Nevada because the federal government refuses to hold the Upper Basin accountable for the water deliveries they owe Arizona, and is threatening to force draconian cuts that go well beyond the Lower Basin Agreement. While we ensure our voice is heard in court, weโ€™ll continue working alongside Nevada and California to implement the Lower Basin Agreement and prevent a devastating cut to Arizonaโ€™s Colorado River water.โ€

โ€œIntervention in the Nevada lawsuit is necessary at this time for Arizona to protect its legal rights to Colorado River water while preserving a path forward to achieving a collaborative outcome with California and Nevada to protect the Colorado River system,โ€ said ADWR Director Tom Buschatzke.

The Lower Basin Agreement is an agreement between Arizona, California and Nevada to protect the future of the Colorado River and prevent forced federal cuts that would slash the Central Arizona Projectโ€™s Colorado River allocation by 77% over the next two years. In the Agreement, Lower Basin states commit to conserve over 3.2 million acre-feet in 2027 and 2028 to stabilize the Colorado River system. Finalizing the Lower Basin Agreement remains a priority for the State of Arizona.

Joining this lawsuit ensures that Arizona can protect the Stateโ€™s interests in any legal outcome and challenge elements of the federal Final Environmental Impact Statement and Record of Decision that unlawfully fail to require deliveries from Upper Basin water reservoirs to Lake Mead. These federal decisions could result in 3 million acre-feet per year in cuts to the Lower Basin states, inflicting devastating water reductions while the Upper Basin States avoid any required conservation.

[ed. The “required conservation” argument is pipe dream. Buschatzke is fixated on the impossible because the Lower Basin has had certainty of deliveries since Hoover dam first filled, while no Upper Basin diverter has ever had that kind of certainty. He fails to acknowledge the difference between mountain rivers, with hundreds of diversions, where most of the water comes from, and desert rivers where there is little precipitation adding to streamflow. The Colorado Division of Water Resources cannot legally force diverters to bypass water and they do not have the ability to shepherd the water to Lake Powell. It is not possible to accurately measure conserved water at this time (apologies to Dr. Parshall). I think the Lower Basin legal position is very strong and they will press the advantage in court which will take a long time to resolve. Meanwhile available water continues to decline and the LB won’t come to the table to negotiate “wet water” vs. “paper water”. The combination of Climate Change and the “Law of the River” drained Mead and Powell, not Upper Basin consumptive use.]

The Colorado River Basin spans seven U.S. states and part of Mexico. Lake Powell, upstream from the Grand Canyon, and Lake Mead, near Las Vegas, are the two principal reservoirs in the Colorado River water-supply system. (Bureau of Reclamation)

Aurora tests the waters of #Coloradoโ€™s new wetland protection rules — Jerd Smith (Fresh Water News)

Spinney Mountain Reservoir

Click the link to read the article on the Water Education Colorado website (Jerd Smith):

October 15, 2026

Auroraโ€™s proposed Wild Horse Reservoir project, southwest of Denver in Park County, is drawing close scrutiny this fall as it undergoes review under a new state law designed to protect critical wetlands and streams no longer shielded by the federal Clean Water Act.

According to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, Wild Horse represents the first major project to be reviewed under Coloradoโ€™s new hard-fought wetland regulations approved in December. They are meant to replace federal rules wiped out by a U.S. Supreme Court case in 2023, Sackett v. EPA, and subsequent actions by the EPA. The CDPHE is responsible for enforcing the new regulation.

Colorado is one of the only states that has succeeded in crafting new rules. That work comes as the federal government continues to narrow protection of wetlands once provided by the Clean Water Act.

โ€œAs the federal government continues to roll back [protections], Colorado is going to need to step up. This is an incredibly important milestone for Colorado. All eyes are on this application,โ€ said Sabrina King, water campaign manager for Conservation Colorado, one of the environmental groups that helped craft the bipartisan measure ultimately approved by Colorado lawmakers last year.

The $600 million-plus Wild Horse Reservoir project would store 93,000 acre-feet of water and will be nearly twice the size of the cityโ€™s existing Park County storage pond, Spinney Mountain Reservoir, which holds 53,651 acre-feet of water. An acre-foot equals nearly 326,000 gallons of water, enough to serve at least two to four urban households for one year.

Aurora water supply and collection system. Credit: Aurora Water

The proposed reservoir is among the latest moves by the city to secure future water supplies to meet growth-driven demand as streams and rivers shrink because of climate change.

Aurora Water officials say the reservoir is critical to providing a storage pool closer to the city and that it wonโ€™t involve taking additional water supplies from its water in the Eagle River and Homestake Creek. Instead, they say the reservoir will store water they now hold in nearby Spinney Mountain Reservoir, freeing up space to store water it currently owns and uses, but which it doesnโ€™t always have the room to store.

Some of that newly accessible water will be used to help expand Auroraโ€™s large-scale recycled water program, according to spokesman Zachary Henry, helping fulfill its promises to reduce water use even as it expands its collection system.

Still, powerful Western Slope water agencies, including the Colorado River District and the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District, and environmental advocacy group Save The Colorado, have expressed concerns about the proposed reservoir and its impact on the stateโ€™s drought-stressed water supplies.

โ€œThere is a question if this project involves additional new diversions or are they just moving water that they were already storing and moving in the Homestake Valley,โ€ said Gary Wockner, president of Save The Colorado. โ€œAurora appears to be claiming that this doesnโ€™t involve new diversion of water, but it is not clear. โ€ฆ The public needs to know.โ€

Due to these concerns and those of other interested parties, the CDPHE agreed to extend the public comment period to Nov. 19 to give more time for the application to be examined, according to CDPHE spokesperson Kaitlyn Beekman.

Under the new rules, regulators have roughly two years to complete the review process. Aurora officials said they expect construction to take five to six years and that the reservoir is likely to take five to 10 years to fill as climate change continues to shrink streamflows.

More by Jerd Smith

The South Platte River Basin is shaded in yellow. Source: Tom Cech, One World One Water Center, Metropolitan State University of Denver.

The Central #Arizona Project board authorizes legal action against the federal government over #ColoradoRiver — AZCentral.com #COriver #aridification

Photo credit: Central Arizona Project

Click the link to read the article on the AZCentral website (Branson Loomis). Here’s an excerpt:

September 3, 2026

Key Points

  • The CAP board authorized legal action “if necessary” against the Interior Department over its plan to manage shortages on the Colorado River.
  • Nevada has already sued the feds over the plan, claiming that it violates the Colorado River Compact and would devastate the Las Vegas economy.
  • Arizona lawmakers have set aside money and hired a law firm to sue the federal government, but have not acted yet.

The Central Arizona Projectโ€™s board authorized its legal counsel to take legal action โ€œif necessaryโ€ against a federal plan to cut Arizonaโ€™s share of Colorado River water dramatically in coming years. Board members went into a closed executive session before the Sept. 3 vote to discuss certain โ€œoccurrencesโ€ that could trigger a lawsuit or other legal filing, and did not specify them when voting unanimously for the authorization. Board member Alexandra Arboleda introduced the motion at the meeting and prefaced it with a statement that the United States Department of the Interior’s 10-year framework for dealing with water shortage โ€œcontemplates operations that are contrary to law and devastating to the water users of the Central Arizona Project.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#Arizona Department of Water Resources Director Tom Buschatzke — Opening Statement on Arizona Filing a motion to intervene in the #Nevada Lawsuit challenging the recent federal decision governing the operation of the #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

The Central Arizona Project canal carries water through Phoenix in 2019. Ted Wood/The Water Desk

From email from ADWR:

October 16, 2026

Today the State of Arizona filed a motion to intervene in the Nevada lawsuit challenging the recent federal decision governing the operation of the Colorado River.

Like Nevada, Arizona believes the federal governmentโ€™s new operating framework ignores basic elements of the Law of the River and could result in cuts to the stateโ€™s apportionment that would devastate Arizonaโ€™s economy.

These elements go far beyond and fall outside the Lower Basin Agreement to which we are strongly committed and continue to work with Nevada and California to implement.

Our problems with the federal governmentโ€™s Record of Decision are twofold.

One: the federal governmentโ€™s plan fails to deliver the water that Arizona and our fellow Lower Basin states are owed according to the Law of the River.

Two: the federal governmentโ€™s Year 3-10 plan includes a range of โ€œsideboardsโ€ that, if triggered, could require reductions to the Lower Basin of up to 3 million acre-feet per year in priority. Such reductions could effectively dry up the Central Arizona Project canal system, as well as many of our on-river communities and would more than double the water cuts agreed to in the Lower Basin Agreement.

Arizona believes that taking this action now provides the best path forward for protecting Arizona water users. We are confident that our negotiations with California, Nevada and the U.S. will move forward. In fact, by taking this step we are protecting the integrity of our Agreement. By joining this litigation we can protect Arizonaโ€™s interests, whether thatโ€™s before a judge or in any settlement discussions that may ensue.

Arizonaโ€™s priority remains the completion of a Lower Basin Agreement with California, Nevada, and the U.S. to share in water reductions over the next two years and to memorialize the Intentionally Created Surplus tool. Through our participation in this litigation we will seek to assure that the agreement is implemented.

The Lower Basin states have contributed millions of acre-feet of water toward stabilizing the river system. With more than 5.5 million acre-feet of Arizona water left in Lake Mead since 2014, no state has sacrificed more. In collaboration with our Lower Basin state partners, the Lower Basin Agreement demonstrates that we are doing more. But the US decision puts the entire burden of sacrifice on the shoulders of three states. We are joining Nevada in challenging that framework.

Lake Powell critical elevations. Land Desk graphic using data from the Bureau of Reclamation.

To Build Resilience in the #ColoradoRiver Basin, Let Nature Take the Lead: Taking a cue from the humble beaver, a landscape rises from the ashes in #Coloradoโ€™s Grand County — Ted Kowalski (WaltonFamilyFoundation.org) #COriver #aridification

Colorado River “Beginnings”. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

Click the link to read the article on the Walton Family Foundation website (Ted Kowalski):

September 21, 2026

High in the Colorado Rockies, Grand County lives up to its name. Each year, from elevations of up to 14,000 feet, the snowpack from this formidable range melts to form the headwaters of the Colorado River, whose basin supplies water to more than 40 million people in a thirsty American West.

In 2020, the East Troublesome fire tore through Grand County and Rocky Mountain National Park, scorching nearly 200,000 acres of wilderness and sending sediment cascading into the rivers and reservoirs below.

โ€œIn terms of the loss and ferocity of this fire, you almost couldnโ€™t believe what you were seeing,โ€ says Sean Henry, environmental planning manager for Northern Water, the local public agency that manages and delivers the resource.

โ€œWe were already in extreme drought, and bark beetles had destroyed 70% of the trees in the years before.โ€

New vegetation grows around the burn scar of the East Troublesome fire that torched 200,000 acres in Colorado in 2020. Photo credit: Walton Family Foundation

Without water and roots in the soil, the resulting sediment and ash slid right off the burn scar and into the water supply, causing โ€œtremendous water quality problems.โ€

At the same time, Henry says that the disaster kick-started momentum to find a lasting solution. โ€œThere was a huge feeling of motivation. We knew it was time to get to work.โ€

Today the landscape is being restored in part through work inspired by a critical allyโ€“the beaver.

Sediment and ash from the East Troublesome fire that washed downstream caused severe water quality problems. Photo credit: Walton Family Foundation

When it comes to regulating water flow, beavers are naturals. Their once-prolific North American population created more than 300,000 square miles of wetland in the United States.

A range of groups including Grand County, Middle Park Conservation District, National Forest Foundation, Northern Water, Three Lakes Watershed Association, The River District, Trout Unlimited and the U.S. Forest Service are supporting strategies to restore the landscape.

Sean Henry is environmental planning department manager with Northern Water, a public agency helping restore the landscape damaged by the East Troublesome fire. Photo credit: Walton Family Foundation

The work includes installing natural structures called Beaver Dam Analogs, Simulated Beaver Structures and Post-Assisted Log Structures within the burn scar. The installations weave wood and soil together to mimic the ecological role of natural beaver dams by slowing down moving water and rehydrating the landscape.

Adde Sharp is a watershed program specialist for the National Forest Foundation, the nonprofit arm of the U.S. Forest Service. She says these low-tech structures actโ€œas a speed bump to the water.โ€

โ€œWhen you slow down the flow of water, two things happen,โ€ Sharp says. โ€œOne, all of the sediment that the water is carrying is dropped onto the structure, slowly accreting in these deep channels. Once that happens, the water is able to access the floodplain and spread out more and more, nourishing the plant and animal communities around it.โ€

Adde Sharp is a watershed program specialist at National Forest Foundation. She says low-tech structures that mimic beaver dams help restore water quality by slowing down flows and filtering damaging sediment.

Paired with forest management approaches such as targeted thinning, these efforts are restoring natureโ€™s ability to protect itself from extreme weather, all while providing clearer, sediment-free water for users downstream.

In just a few seasons of work, thousands of tons of sediment from fire runoff is already piling up against the new structures, raising the stream beds in some places by two or three feet. โ€œItโ€™s happening faster than we thought,โ€ says Henry.

In just a few seasons of work, thousands of tons of sediment from fire runoff is already piling up against the new structures, raising the stream beds in some places by two or three feet. โ€œItโ€™s happening faster than we thought,โ€ says Henry. Photo credit: Walton Family Foundation

Paired with forest management approaches such as targeted thinning, these efforts are restoring natureโ€™s ability to protect itself from extreme weather, all while providing clearer, sediment-free water for users downstream.

For Sharp, the work is proof that with a little nudge in the right direction, itโ€™s possible to reverse course on even the most devastating natural disasters.

โ€œI was driving recently, and there are already small trees coming up in the burn scar. The aspen are beginning to change color, like a little pot of gold in the black landscape.โ€

In the wake of Colorado’s East Troublesome fire, restoration work included the construction of beaver dam analogs, manmade structures that slow down and purify on streams and rivers. Photo credit: Walton Family Foundation

These same strategies are being used in nearby Kawuneeche Valleyโ€“not to recover from fire, but to protect against it. Beavers used to thrive in the Kawuneeche Valley, with scattered ponds hydrating the land.

But decades of human impacts and overgrazing by moose and elk depleted the tall willows beavers use both for food and to build their dams. As a result, crucial habitat was lost, beaver populations plummeted, and the land dried up and eroded. This left behind a vastly altered, less resilient landscape.

Restoration work has helped speed up post-fire recovery efforts. “There are already small trees coming up in the burn scar,” says Adde Sharp. “The aspen are beginning to change color, like a little pot of gold in the black landscape.โ€ Photo credit: Walton Family Foundation

The Kawuneeche Valley Restoration Collaborative was formed as a partnership between Colorado State University, Grand County, National Park Serviceโ€“Rocky Mountain National Park, The Nature Conservancy, Northern Water, Rocky Mountain Conservancy, the town of Grand Lake and the U.S. Forest Service. The group is working to restore the valleyโ€™s natural system to improve water quality, support wildlife and recreational opportunities, and make the area more resistant to future wildfires.

The collaborative hopes that the work will also entice more beavers to return to the valley and maintain the new structures, allowing nature to take the lead.

American beaver, he was happily sitting back and munching on something. and munching, and munching. By Steve from washington, dc, usa – American Beaver, CC BY-SA 2.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=3963858

Notes from the Road: Lees Ferry in the wind and the rain: And some images for Indigenous Peoples Day — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 12, 2026

Note: I started writing this as the intro to todayโ€™s Newswire. Then it occurred to me that today is Indigenous Peoples Day, and some other holiday for certain cultures, and folks probably arenโ€™t going to be into reading the news. So hereโ€™s a little impression of the current storm soaking parts of the Southwest, and some photos.

The rain finally eased up, giving way to magnificent evening light. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

10/11/2026

I woke up early this morning, before dawn, in my little tent in El Morro National Monument in west-central New Mexico. The skies, frogbelly gray the day before, had cleared up, the moon was new, and the stars and the milky way sprawled across the blue incomprehensibly. I crawled out before sunrise to see first light falling on the big bleached sandstone fin of Aโ€™tsโ€™ina, aka El Morro, delighting as sunflowers and winterfat and daisies danced in the warm breeze.

Sunflowers and El Moro October 11, 2026. Photo credit: Jonathan P. Thompson

Then, because Iโ€™m not the sharpest tool in the shed, I broke camp, loaded up El Burro Blanco, and headed west about five hours, across the Navajo Nation and the Hopi Mesas, through a quasi-haboob in Tuba City, to Lees Ferry โ€” and right into the brunt of the remnants of Tropical Storm Rachel. Now itโ€™s Sunday evening and Iโ€™m sitting in the cab of the truck, which shudders with each forceful gust of wind, waiting for the rain to stop long enough to set up my tent, which of course wonโ€™t do much good if it is shredded by another one of these 50-mph gales.

Tuba City quasi-haboob October 11, 2026. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Yeah, the Southwest is getting battered again. So far, however, it hasnโ€™t brought the expected abundance of moisture to Lees Ferry, which appears to be on the eastern fringe of the stormโ€™s main path, which is veering diagonally in a northeasterly direction from San Diego. Presumably itโ€™s raining harder to the west of here, in the Las Vegas-St. George area, and also north of here: The Moab 240 ultramarathon was cancelled Sunday due to heavy rain and flash floods, and about 70 runners and volunteers were stranded at an aid station near Bridger Jack Mesa and had to be evacuated.

The Paria River at about 14 cfs on Sunday evening October 11, 2026. By the next morning, it would be almost 500 cfs. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

The storm is not over, by any means. Itโ€™s supposed to keep up through Wednesday, at least, and may even bring substantial snow to the high country.

Fruit orchard at the Lonely Dell Ranch alongside the Paria River at Lees Ferry October 11, 2026. The pears are ready to pick. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

10/12/2026

The rain stopped long enough for me to set up the tent, though the wind continued howling into the night. But when I awoke around 2 a.m., the air was still, the only noise the gurgle of the Colorado River, and the stars were everywhere.

This morningโ€™s flash flood alert has yet to materialize, but it has been raining on and off for a couple of hours, and the Paria River is substantially larger than it was yesterday, growing from about 20 cubic feet per second to nearly 500 cfs overnight. If I were to wait around, I might see it rage even more, since the USGS streamflow gage at Kanab is recording 2,000 cfs. But that might be a pretty long wait, and I want to go up to Page and get a gander at Glen Canyon Dam and the great big Lake Powell bathtub ring.

For more on what to call Lees Ferry โ€ฆ :


To Lees or not to Lee’s; Mike Lee goes after roadless rule; Trump steps up oil and gas leasing — Jonathan P. Thompson


Aโ€™tsโ€™ina, or Inscription Rock, at El Morro National Monument. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
The datura are blooming everywhere, and going to seed, all at the same time. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Romancing the River: The Real โ€˜Two Basinsโ€™ of a Desert River — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Graphic credit: The Colorado River water crisis its origin and future Jack Schmidt, Eric Kuhn, Charles Yackulic.

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

October 13, 2026

This will be my last post before what might be our last election โ€“ if our would-be tyrant doesnโ€™t succeed in stopping it entirely. I encourage my handful of readers to vote early, and then be prepared to participate in public opposition โ€“ make a big noise โ€“ to the chaos our PINO will surely try to cause if he doesnโ€™t like the outcomes.

The mainstream media (being mostly owned by billionaires) continue to try to portray this election as just another horse-race between โ€˜Democrats and Republicans.โ€™ It is not that. This election may be out last chance to salvage what the Trumpsters havenโ€™t yet undermined of our 250-year effort to work out a functional governance by, for and of the people โ€“ a representational governance, a form of democracy. At present nearly all of our supposed representatives in Congress who call themselves โ€˜Republicansโ€™ and many of those who call themselves โ€˜Democratsโ€™ are clearly โ€˜ownedโ€™ by those with the money to fund their campaigns โ€“ the oligarchs and kleptocrats who want to replace that 250-year effort with an authoritarian governance that they believe will be more โ€˜efficientโ€™ in accommodating them.

The only hope for keeping our 250-year experiment in self-governance going is to replace the sellouts with representation in the mold of Bernie Sanders, Elizabeth Warren, Alexandria Octavio-Cortez and others who truly try to speak and act on behalf of us, rather than of those whom we have all helped make morbidly wealthy. And we will only be successful if it is a decisive victory for the people; one or two percent victories will be challenged and kept in chaos until โ€“ well, forever: nearly a third of the voting electorate still believe that Trump was cheated out of a 2020 election victory because Trump says so. He is determined to keep this election from being a conclusive victory against him because he knows that the only way to stay out of prison is to stay in the presidency with a compliant Congress.

So vote as if the future depended on it โ€“ because it does. We do not want to live in an oligarchic kleptocracy run by a semi-senile narcissist with his gang of thieves pillaging the people to pay for technologies of mass control, with his army of brownshirt ICE agents running rampant in our streets. If we donโ€™t come out of the election with a Congress at least partially in control of representatives of the people (not just โ€˜Democratsโ€™ โ€“ think of Fetterman), then it is all over.

Meanwhile, back on the banks of the bankrupt Colorado River system. Remembering first that the river system is not the river itself. The river itself is what it has always been: flows of water running through river-carved valleys and canyons because the surrounding land has not put those flows to use in service to living things. The flows move on to other valleys where sometimes they are put to use by plants, forests, wildlife including humans, and sometimes not, then flowing on to other valleys until they all eventually join up and get to sea level, reentering the seas from which they came. Those flows ebb and flow themselves, annually and year-to-year, at the whims of the global climate โ€“ which at this point has the human thumb on the scales pushing toward the hotter drier side.

Thatโ€™s the river; the river system is the structures for storage and distribution we have imposed over the river to even out the natural flows, annually and year-to-year, in service to human life. But the system was designed for a river half again larger than the river weโ€™ve had since the turn of the century; it is beyond rational denial that it was overbuilt for the river we now have (see the graph above), although many continue to deny it for reasons including plain desperation.

That suggestion will come in time, but first I think we need to define the current reality (which bears no resemblance to โ€˜Compact realityโ€™). The first step is to acknowledge the nature of a desert river, then try to adapt our basic thinking and planning to that.

All rivers are water that the surrounding land and its diverse inhabitants have not managed to put to โ€˜beneficial useโ€™ for the living ecologies the river runs through. That โ€˜left-overโ€™ water flows on from its home watershed to larger multiple watersheds where it either gets put to use or doesnโ€™t, and if not, it flows on even larger basins, et cetera. Hydrologists describe streams as โ€˜gainingโ€™ or โ€˜losingโ€™: a stream that adds surface and groundwater from a watershed with a high water table is a โ€˜gaining streamโ€™; a stream that gives up some of it water to a watershed with a lower water table is a โ€˜losing streamโ€™ (although I think it ought to be called a โ€˜giving streamโ€™).

Many humid-region rivers continue to collect more water from precipitation that falls on them and their surrounding land, from its headwaters all the way to its ocean estuary. A desert river, on the other hand, gets nearly all the water it will ever have from its headwaters region, with mountains or plateaus high enough to force rising air to cool and release any water vapor it carries as precipitation โ€“ mostly winter snow in the case of the Colorado River. Most of the Colorado River headwaters are in the Southern Rockies, but the Wind River Mountains in the Central Rockies generate some of the Green River tributaries, the Colorado Plateau and New Mexico highlands generate the Gila River; smaller basin-and-range mountains the Virgin River, et cetera. But the precipitation that falls on those high places generates 85-90 percent of the water that will make its way into the Colorado River; once it leaves its headwaters and flows into its desert regions, it will gain very little new precipitation.

This transition from gaining streams to losing (giving) streams happens fairly quickly in the Colorado Riverโ€™s natural basin. The majority of its water comes from highlands above ~8,000 feet elevation โ€“ about ten percent of the entire basin. In the Upper Gunnison River watersheds where I live, major Gunnison River tributaries leave the Crested Butte area at 9,000 feet elevation where the average annual precipitation is 23 inches (up to 40+ inches on upvalley); a mere 35 miles down the valley in Blue Mesa Reservoir, at 7,500 feet elevation, the average precipitation has dropped to 10-11 inches. In that short distance, the Gunnison River is already in the high deserts of the Colorado Plateau, and most of the valley below Crested Butte is under irrigation โ€“ the river already โ€˜giving.โ€™. The Gunnison River gets larger as it flows west and north to its โ€˜grand junctionโ€™ with the Colorado River, but that is due to picking up other tributaries; very little precipitation water gets added โ€“ even in the summer monsoons, according to a hydrologist working in the Upper Gunnison.

Prior to the Euro-American presence in the basin, the Colorado River ran in extremes: a flood of water while the snowpack was melting in the high headwaters, then a comparative trickle in the late summer and fall after the snowmelt ends. The flood months nurtured riparian life throughout its course, from a narrow strip in some places to broad wetlands, meadows and cottonwood โ€˜oasesโ€™ in other desert places, culminating in a lush labyrinthian delta on a dyke it had built across the Gulf of California with debris from creating the Grand Canyon through the Colorado Plateau. Whatever was left in the stream after it made its way through the delta went back into the ocean from which it had come โ€“ and one imagines there were many drier years when there was not enough water left below the delta to go into the ocean after the early summer flood finished.

We tend to make a big deal about the Colorado River no longer flowing to the ocean now due to our heavy use, but there are many desert rivers around the world that donโ€™t flow into the oceans; some forty streams flow into the Great Basin from surrounding mountains and plateaus โ€“ some of them respectable rivers like the Truckee, through Reno โ€“ and they all gradually disappear there, after nurturing riparian life (including some ranches and towns), enduring evapotranspiration, and sinking into aquifers. President Theodore Roosevelt, often called the father of American conservation, considered freshwater going unused into the ocean to be a โ€˜waste.โ€™

But understanding the nature of the desert river, and how it is different from a humid-region river like the Mississippi, offers some clues about an intelligent river system for storing and distributing the river. The vast majority of the users of the riverโ€™s water, especially the modern human users, are in the desert lands below the headwaters region โ€“ the โ€˜losingโ€™ (โ€˜givingโ€™) portion of the river: in the higher โ€˜cold desertsโ€™ above the canyon region, and the subtropical โ€˜hot desertsโ€™ below the canyons.

Healthy mountain meadows and wetlands are characteristic of healthy headwater systems and provide a variety of ecosystem services, or benefits that humans, wildlife, rivers and surrounding ecosystems rely on. The complex of wetlands and connected floodplains found in intact headwater systems can slow runoff and attenuate flood flows, creating better downstream conditions, trapping sediment to improve downstream water quality, and allowing groundwater recharge. These systems can also serve as a fire break and refuge during wildfire, can sequester carbon in the floodplain, and provide essential habitat for wildlife. Graphic by Restoration Design Group, courtesy of American Rivers

There are also water users in the headwaters region. Largest by far are the forests that ring most of the mountains, along with other plant and animal life inhabiting those mountain-forest regions. There are also humans in the headwaters, mostly in or near towns supporting mining or outdoor recreation, but what makes the most sense is to consider the human users as outliers of the โ€˜losingโ€™ basin below the headwaters โ€“ which they are, literally, producing little of what they need to live there but importing moat of it from or through the desert economy. The forests, on the other hand โ€“ as we will see โ€“ are intimately involved in the riverโ€™s water production processes, in both positive and negative ways.

These two distinctly different parts of the river suggest a more natural division of the river into two โ€˜basinsโ€™ than the political division under the Compact: the โ€˜gaining riverโ€™ and the โ€˜losing/giving river,โ€™ each to be managed toward a specific goal: for the gaining river, how to optimize the quantity of water flowing out of the headwaters; and for the losing/giving river, how to optimize the uses and minimize unnecessary losses.

This deliberately breaks up the current โ€˜two-basin divisionโ€™ โ€“ a โ€˜temporary equitable divisionโ€™ adopted in 1922 because the compact commissioners did not know enough about their the river or their own state futures to do the eight-way division (including Mexico) they had set out to do. The two-basin division was most basically an expedient way of persuading Congress that they were together in their search for an equitable division that would only become possible when there was โ€˜a greater fund of informationโ€™ that would enable those following them to do a proper division of the use of the riverโ€™s waters, but meanwhile โ€“ letโ€™s build the big dam.

Dividing the river into its โ€˜water productionโ€™ basin and its โ€˜water consumptionโ€™ basin would have the potential benefit of starting again with nearly all of the users in a single โ€˜consumptionโ€™ basin, while giving them all joint responsibility for taking care of the โ€˜water productionโ€™ basin. Itโ€™s a potential start on at least perceiving the river as a single shared responsibility, as opposed to the current perception of each state in it for its own needs and yielding as little as possible to the other states.

Thatโ€™s where weโ€™ll start next time โ€“ with the big question for the losing/giving river, the desert part of the desert river: how to get beyond Compact fantasies, and divide the use of the diminishing river we actually have among the vast multitudes of users (see the graph at the beginning). Thatโ€™s a point at which I think it would be smart to abandon the hydrologic term โ€˜losingโ€™ for a more political term โ€“ not a โ€˜losing riverโ€™ but a โ€˜giving riverโ€™ -which is what it is once it leaves the headwaters. And the challenge of โ€˜dividing the giftsโ€™ of the giving river at least starts with a more positive feel than โ€˜sharing out the lossesโ€™ from a losing riverโ€ฆ.

Meanwhile โ€“ vote! As if the future depended on it because it does. [ed. emphasis mine]

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

October 12, 2026, water supply and water use update for Denver Waterโ€™s system — DenverWater.org #SouthPlatteRiver #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Denver Waterโ€™s current and forecasted reservoir storage levels though March 2027 under Stage 1 drought restrictions, shown as percentage of full on Oct. 12, 2026, compared to average. The red, green and blue forecasts, reflecting the potential for dry, normal and wet weather patterns, are updated once a month. Image credit: Denver Water.

Click the link to read the article on the Denver Water website:

October 12, 2026

Denver Waterโ€™s collection and service areas continue to face severe drought conditions, with historically low snowpack. Denver Water depends on mountain snowpack for its water supply, which serves 1.5 million people in Denver and surrounding suburbs.

As a result, on March 25, 2026, the Denver Board of Water Commissioners declared a Stage 1 drought, seeking a 20% reduction in water use to preserve water levels and avoid even stricter mandatory restrictions later this summer. On April 8, 2026, the board approved the implementation of temporary drought pricing, starting with May water use and reflected in June bills, to signal the premium value of water during droughts and help incentivize customers to save water.

On Aug. 26, 2026, the board amended its Stage 1 drought resolution to prohibit lawn watering as of Oct. 1. The ban on lawn watering and all spray irrigation remains in effect until the board determines how and when lawn watering can resume. That means sprinklers need to remain off in spring of 2027, pending an official resolution from the Board of Water Commissioners.

Customers are warned of heavy fines for lawn watering or using spray irrigation after Sept. 30. Penalties for violating the ban begin at $500 for single-family customers. 


Snowpack and water supply update

  • In Denver Waterโ€™s collection system, the 2025-26 snowpack peaked more than a month earlier than normal and at the lowest levels observed in the past 40 years:
    • Colorado River Basin: Snowpack peaked March 18, 2026, at 58% of normal, the second-earliest date and second-lowest peak on record. (Typical peak date is April 24.)
    • South Platte River Basin: Snowpack peaked March 17, 2026, at 42% of normal, the second-earliest date and the lowest peak on record. (Typical peak date is April 26.)
  • Snowpack and melting conditions were unprecedented, with accelerated spring melting that started in mid-March. Customers need to save water to stretch supplies.
  • Streamflow forecasts called for runoff levels to be 10-40% of normal in 2026.
  • Reservoir storage conditions are below average.ย As of Oct. 12, 2026, reservoirs were 67% full, versus an average of 90% full for this time.ย 

Water use and conservation update

  • Quote from Greg Fisher, Denver Water’s manager of demand planning:ย 
    • โ€œOur customers did a great job shutting off their sprinkler systems in response to our Oct. 1 cutoff for lawn watering. Water use Oct. 1 through Oct. 11 was 34% below the five-year average,” said Greg Fisher, Denver Water’s manager of demand planning.
    • โ€œThis is a good start to preserving our critically important water supplies, because Denver Waterโ€™s reservoir storage levels are currently at 67% full, well below the average of 90% for this time of year.
    • โ€œWeโ€™re all hoping for a good winter, but itโ€™s extremely unlikely that weโ€™ll see enough snow โ€” and more importantly, a robust spring runoff โ€” to fully fill our reservoirs next year. Every customerโ€™s conservation efforts remain especially important as we work together to stretch our storage supplies heading into the winter.โ€
    • Customers can do their part byย making water-efficient upgrades, indoors and outdoors, including rethinking their yards. These steps preserve water supplies and create moreย adaptable and drought-resilient landscapesย that fit naturally into our climate.ย Read on TAP:ย Simple strategies to save water at home.
  • Customers are reminded of theย ban on lawn watering and spray irrigation as of Oct. 1.
    • Trees, shrubs and perennials may be watered any day with a hand-held hose with a shut-off nozzle or low-volume, non-spray irrigation (such as a drip system).ย They may not be watered with spray irrigation.
    • Denver Water will not be issuing watering exemptions for new turf installations.

For its part, Denver Water has proactively reduced its spending, taking steps that include enacting a hiring freeze and reviewing maintenance and other projects to see which ones could be deferred. We are also looking into other ways to increase supply by activating agreements that allow us to capture additional water that is typically unavailable during normal conditions.

This year marks the fifth time since 2000 that Denver Water has issued a Stage 1 drought, and the first since 2013. Prior to 2013, the board declared a Stage 1 drought in 2002, 2003 and 2004.

Denver Water has many resources for homeowners looking for inspiration and information about landscapes that fit naturally into our dry climate. Click here for conservation and efficiency tips for outdoor irrigation and to get more details on ways to ColoradoScape  your property, including through rebates for turf removal and a DIY guide for landscape changes, among many other potential water-saving steps.

Updates about Denver Waterโ€™s reservoir levels, customer water use and snowpack can be found in the Water Watch Report, which is updated weekly in the spring and summer.

Denver Water’s entire collection system. Image credit: Denver Water.

Deadpool Data Dump: #LakePowellโ€™s terrible, horrible, no good, very bad water year; Plus — Ruminating on the oil and gas infrastructure that clutters the landscape and sometimes explodes — Jonathan P. Thompson #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Land Desk graphic using data from the Bureau of Reclamation.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 9, 2026

๐Ÿ’€ DEADPOOL DATA DUMP ๐ŸŒŠ

Lake Powell, the nationโ€™s second largest reservoir, serves as a sort of barometer of the Colorado River watershedโ€™s overall health. The reservoir and river have been struggling since the great aridificationโ€™s grim onset in 2002. While the river continues to flow, barely, the 2026 Water Year, characterized by one of the worst snow droughts on record, nearly finished off the reservoir. But in the end, it was saved from dropping to โ€œde facto deadpoolโ€ by heavy rain at the beginning and end of the water year, and by larger-than-normal releases from upstream reservoirs. 

  • 4.46 million acre-feet: Total Lake Powell inflow from the Colorado, Dirty Devil, Escalante, and San Juan rivers in water year 2026. Thatโ€™s the third lowest on record, behind 2002 and 2021. This is in spite of the fact that the 2026 snowpack was far lower than those two years, and melting mountain snowpack provides about 80% of the riverโ€™s water.
  • The Colorado River Basinย experienced its warmest water year on recordย (in 131 years) in WY2026.

  • 3.72 million acre-feet. Total Lake Powell unregulated inflow in water year 2026. This is the estimate of how much water would have flowed into the reservoir without any supplementary releases from upstream reservoirs. Which is to say, the feds robbed Flaming Gorge, Navajo, and Blue Mesa of about 750,000 acre-feet to save Powell from shrinking even more. That was bad for those upstream reservoirs and the irrigators, anglers, recreational users, and communities that rely on them, and thereโ€™s no way it can be repeated if this winter is below average.
  • 6 million acre-feet: Total releases from Glen Canyon Dam in water year 2026. This is the lowest release since the very early days of the dam (in the 1960s). This means less water in the Grand Canyon and less water flowing into Lake Mead.ย 
  • 181,111 acre-feet: Estimated amount of water that evaporated from Lake Powell in water year 2026. This is equivalent to more than half of Nevadaโ€™s total annual allotment from the Colorado River.ย 
  • 1.72 million acre-feet: Lake Powellโ€™s water deficit โ€” or the difference between outflows (incl. evaporation) and inflows โ€” for water year 2026.ย 
  • 27 feet:ย Amount the surface level of the reservoir fell in water year 2026, putting it within seven feet of the level the federal governnment has chosen to โ€œdefend,โ€ meaning theyโ€™ll pull out all the stops to keep it from dropping below that (for reasons the Land Desk has gone over many times before). The late September storms brought the level back up a couple of feet.

Feds release two-year Colorado River plan, Nevada sues — Jonathan P. Thompson


Anyone who lived through the 2002 water year probably thought it couldnโ€™t possibly get any worse. Then along came 2026 and, voila! It was really, really bad โ€” at least as far as the snow goes. And snow is really important, because it provides about 80% of the Colorado Riverโ€™s flow.
But whatโ€™s this? The accumulated precipitation in 2026 was actually โ€ฆ not bad? Notice the big jumps at the very beginning of the water year (far left on the graph) and the very end.

A Colorado River glossary and primer — Jonathan P. Thompson


๐Ÿ›ข๏ธย FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIESย ๐Ÿ“ˆ

THE NEWS: Not one, but two natural gas pipelines ruptured and erupted in flames at nearly the same time on opposite sides of New Mexico. One was in the Permian Basin in Lea County, where a gas line ruptured and caught fire, killing two people. Details of the incident have not been released, nor have the names of the victims. The other was near La Boca, New Mexico, just south of the Colorado line (and can be seen in the video above). It shot flames high into the sky and ignited a wildfire.

THE CONTEXT: Several years ago, as the oil boom in the Greater Chaco Region in northwestern New Mexico was nearing its peak, I sat down in the sleek, modern headquarters of the Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s Farmington field office with two BLM officials to talk about the oil boom. Before we got down to business, one of them asked: โ€œShould we show him the scare map?โ€ 

The answer, I guess, was yes, because her colleague handed me the paper showing every well ever drilled in the San Juan Basin, with little red dots for gas, black ones for oil.

It was scary. The northern and central sections of the Basin were almost solid red; in the south and west, dense swarms of black dots strung out along the oil-bearing formations. Dark pinpricks surrounded Chaco Culture National Historical Park. Huerfano Mountain, or Dzil Naโ€™oodilii, where First Woman and First Man and then Changing Woman lived โ€” a sort of Garden of Eden in Navajo cosmology โ€” was embroidered with red and black. The BLM office we sat in, on a fine piece of real estate in the upper-class part of town, has three wells within a quarter mile, and a pumpjack grinds away right next to a golf course green down the road.

To find a stretch of land anywhere in the core of the Basin that hasnโ€™t been drilled or isnโ€™t covered by roads, tanks, pipes or some other hydrocarbon-related infrastructure is nearly impossible โ€” the infrastructure is the landscape. โ€œWeโ€™ve got so much pipeline in the ground, itโ€™s like rebar,โ€ said the official, with a tinge of glee. โ€œIf you had an earthquake, the ground wouldnโ€™t even shake.โ€

The official seemed less disturbed than simply fascinated by this fact, and also didnโ€™t seem bothered that he and his colleagues were facilitating even more infrastructure by handing out drilling permits by the dozen and clearing the way for thousands of new wells and all the roads, gathering systems, and pipelines that go with it. 

The San Juan structural basin is primarily in New Mexico. By US Geological Survey – Assessment of Undiscovered Oil and Gas Resources of the San Juan Basin Province of New Mexico and Colorado, 2002, USGS Fact Sheet FS-147-02, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5749904

I happen to be writing this at a campsite in the heart of the San Juan Basin gas field. While I can gaze out across the landscape and see nothing but beauty, including the eveningโ€™s last light on Dzil Naโ€™oodilii, I am constantly reminded of the ubiquity of the hydrocarbon infrastructure all around me. From just over a little rise comes a slightly squeaky and clanky sound of inadequately lubed bearings, and the low hum and whir of dozens of near and distant pumps and compressors and fans serenades me as I watch the stars unfurl across the big bowl of the sky. 

Thereโ€™s another map of this area thatโ€™s even scarier than the one those folks showed me. It includes oil and gas-related โ€œincidents,โ€ which is to say ruptures and spills and explosions and fires and major leaks. Those, too, are all over the map, and happen with disturbing frequency. Usually theyโ€™re not as dramatic as the two explosions, but they can be harmful: hundreds of gallons of crude oil sloshed onto the ground and into waterways or aquifers, thousands of cubic feet of methane wafting into the air and adding the potent greenhouse gas to the atmosphere.

When I watch the debate over permitting reform, or read the thoughts of the Abundance crowd, a part of me agrees with the credo of building more. The idea of a new New Deal appeals to me, if done right. Line the highways and interstates with high-voltage transmission lines to carry clean energy across the region, build utility-scale solar on reclaimed coal mines and next to old coal plants and on marginal farmland, build factories to manufacture solar panels and batteries. It would create jobs, revitalize economies, and put more clean energy onto the grid. 

Then I hear news about these explosions, look at the oil and gas incident map, and come out here and find that I canโ€™t take a picture of spectacular and sacred landscapes without a tank or well or road or drill pad showing up in it, somewhere. The Abundance folks and the proponents of the permitting reform legislation, or the Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act, want to cover the landscape and our communities with even more of this stuff. While many of them support the bill because it would expedite clean energy development, they donโ€™t mind the fact that it would do the same for natural gas and oil and petroleum pipelines. And, in the social media wars raging over this bill, they discount the concerns of environmental groups worry about the cost we pay when blindly adhering to the credo of Build More Stuff. 

It makes me want to bring these folks out here to the San Juan Basin and take a little walk across this landscape, which is so suffused with beauty, but also cluttered with the detritus of societyโ€™s urge for more, always more.


๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

Angel Peak in the San Juan Basin at sunrise. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Aspen to remain in Stage 3 Water Shortage — The #Aspen Times

Click the link to read the article on The Aspen Times website (Grace West). Here’s an excerpt:

October 3, 2026

The city of Aspen has decided to remain under Stage 3 Water Shortage heading into winter, in a move that officials are highlighting as unprecedented.ย  Aspen enacted Stage 3ย for the first time ever this past May, Utilities Director Erin Loughlin confirmed, and the extension of the restrictions means the critical need to conserve water isnโ€™t over yet.ย 

โ€œSince Stage Three declaration was enacted in May 2026, drought conditions have persisted throughout the Roaring Fork watershed,โ€ said Loughlin. โ€œThe overarching concern remains persistently low river flows throughout the Roaring Fork watershed.โ€

Aspenโ€™s municipal water system depends on the surface water diversions from Maroon and Castle creeks, according to her. The stream flows of both creeks rely on consistent release of water from snowmelt throughout the year โ€” this year, however, the stream flows were compromised by the record-low snowpack during the 2025/26 winter.

โ€œGiven meteorological forecasts, the Water Department cannot be certain that forecasted precipitation will improve the snowpack upon which the water system relied upon at this time,โ€ she said. โ€œStaff continues to monitor conditions and will bring any recommended change to council for their review and consideration when appropriate.โ€

Colorado Drought Monitor map October 6, 2026.

Northwest #Colorado Council of Governments report: A Water Economy #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Click here to access the report on the Northwest Colorado Council of Governments website. Here’s an excerpt:

July 2026

Background & Study Purpose

This study is an update to a 2012 Report that explores the relationship between water and economic activity in a portion of western Colorado where the interaction of precipitation, elevation, and location produces water for the Headwaters Region, much of Colorado, and the Western United States.

The Headwaters Region encompasses the headwaters of the Colorado River and its tributaries. The Headwaters Counties consist of Eagle, Grand, Gunnison, Pitkin, Routt, and Summit County, depicted in Figure 1-1, on the next page. The water in the Headwaters Counties plays a special, dual role in meeting the needs of residents, businesses, and visitors while at the same time, meeting legal obligations for providing water to 40 million people in Colorado and the western U.S.

The study rests in the fact that water resources emanating from the Headwaters Counties are neither consistent nor unlimited, subject to considerable future uncertainty. Besides year-to-year weather variations, longer term climate changes are evident, and climate scientists expect these trends in climate change to continue. Regardless, economic activity in the Headwaters Counties is not standing still; leaders there seek prosperity, looking to further develop economic activity in their counties, the same as all counties around the State. At the same time, water providers on the Front Range in Colorado are seeking increased water supplies, identifying transmountain diversions (TMDs) from the Headwaters Counties as a potential source.

Couple this with the uncertainty related to interstate Colorado River allocations under the Colorado River Compact, and it is clear the Headwaters Counties should be worried about water scarcity. In short, all these forces bear down upon the increasingly less predictable but indispensable water supplies originating in the Headwaters Counties.

Representing the Headwaters Counties, the Northwest Colorado Council of Governments (NWCCOG) through its Water Quality/Quantity Committee (QQ) sought a current understanding of the relationship of the local economies to the evolving availability of surface waters. NWCCOG retained Harvey Economics (HE) to prepare this study.

NEWSWIRE: Bipartisan lawmakers drop a โ€œturd grenadeโ€ of a permitting bill on the environmental movement — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification #ClimateChange

High voltage transmission lines, wind turbines, and the full moon near Winslow, Arizona. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

October 5, 2026

๐Ÿ”ญ OVERSIGHT ๐Ÿ‘ฎ๐Ÿผ

A bipartisan group of federal lawmakers, including Sens. Martin Heinrich (D-NM) and Mike Lee (R-UT), introduced legislation aimed at streamlining and accelerating federal environmental reviews and permitting for major projects on Sept. 30. The Bipartisan Affordability and Jobs Act would lower or remove regulatory hurdles for large-scale renewable and transmission projects, fossil fuel pipelines, mining projects, and other industrial projects such as data centers and accompanying power facilities.

The push for faster permitting has been in the pipeline for years, and garnered the support of the renewable energy industries and climate advocates in more recent years, after seeing huge transmission projects such as SunZia and TransWest Express languish in red tape for nearly two decades due to potential impacts to wildlife and cultural sites. The lines were purportedly designed to carry renewable energy back and forth across the West to provide whatโ€™s known as โ€œgeographical smoothingโ€ of variable solar and wind resources. These sorts of delays, according to permitting reformists, were stifling the energy transition.

Shortly after the billโ€™s details were made public, ecologically minded environmental groups raised red flags, warning that, as written, the legislation would weaken bedrock environmental laws, including the National Environmental Policy Act and Endangered Species Act, and take away the publicโ€™s power to block or force revisions to projects of all kinds, including ones that will lead to more fossil fuel burning and more greenhouse gas emissions. They pointed out that not only was the notoriously anti-environment Lee sponsoring the bill, but it also had a full-throated endorsement of the American Petroleum Institute.

This triggered a vehement, some might even say toxic, reaction from the climate hawks and Abundance adherents that support reform, and ignited a rhetorical civil war within the environmental movement on social media.

The Abundance movement supports the bill, allying itself with the petroleum and tech industries, because it would make it easier to build large clean energy facilities and the transmission needed to move it around. They are operating on the belief that building more and bigger clean energy projects is the only way to battle climate change โ€” even if it also opens the door to more fossil fuel burning. This theory assumes that the market will favor clean energy projects, even if policy favors โ€œall of the above.โ€ 

Marc Levitt, director of environmental regulatory reform for the Breakthrough Institute, called the bill a โ€œheroic breakthrough for permitting reformโ€ and โ€œa massive down payment towards the energy abundant future that Americans deserve.โ€

Opponents, however, say that pushing energy development of all kinds will not only decimate cultural and natural resources and burden humans and wildlife, but it also will not do much to solve the climate crisis if every new solar array or transmission line is matched with a new natural gas pipeline or power plant. 

โ€œThe permitting deal is a betrayal of public lands, water and wildlife, and environmental justice values that Westerners depend on for clean air and water, places to hike, hunt, and fish, and the inestimable sense of freedom the West provides us all,โ€ said Erik Schlenker-Goodrich, executive director of the Western Environmental Law Center based in New Mexico.

The legislation also raises concerns that the Trump administration could use the legislation to further weaken environmental protections to benefit the fossil fuel, nuclear, mining, and data center industries, while still throwing up roadblocks to solar and wind development.

The Land Desk will have an analysis of the bill and how it might play out on the Land Deskโ€™s beat in the coming days.

๐Ÿ”‹ENERGY TRANSITION ๐Ÿ”Œ
  • California Gov. Gavin Newsom signs legislation allowing residents to install plug-in or balcony solarย without getting utility approval, along with a suite of other bills that should advance the energy transition. (Climate Colored Goggles)
๐Ÿ“ REGULATORY CAPTURE CHRONICLES ๐ŸฆŠ
  • The developer of a proposed pumped hydropower storage project on Black Mesa on the Navajo Nation reportedly tried to pay off, coerce, and bullyย non-profit Tรณ Nizhonรญ รnรญ into dropping its opposition to the project. The group has stood its ground.ย (KNAU)
โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ
  • Advocacy groups file a lawsuit challenging the U.S. Forest Serviceโ€™s and Fish and Wildlife Serviceโ€™s approval of South32โ€™s Hermosa mine expansion onto about 52,000 acres of federal land in the Patagonia Mountains of southern Arizona. The groups accuse the agencies of violating the Endangered Species Act by failing to adequately analyze the projects impacts on threatened wildlife. (Center for Biological Diversity)
๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES
  • Arizona Public Service and the Navajo Transitional Energy Company sign an agreement that could allow the Four Corners coal-burning power plant in northwestern New Mexico to continue operating until 2038,ย seven years later than its scheduled retirement date. APS officials say they need the facility online to meet growing data center-driven energy demand and ensure reliability as grid-battering extreme weather events increase in frequency.ย (Arizona Republic)
  • Tรณ Nizhonรญ รnรญ and San Juan Citizens Alliance file an appeal seeking to block the Interior Departmentโ€™s approval for the expansion and 110-year life extension of the No Name area of the Navajo Mine in northwestern New Mexico.ย The mine feeds the Four Corners Power Plant, which is now slated to close in 2038. โ€œItโ€™s disturbing that a federal agency could fast-track a project of this size and scope with almost no credible review, analysis or public consultation,โ€ said Nicole Horseherder, Tรณ Nizhรณnรญ รnรญโ€™s executive director. โ€œThis permit continues a legacy of corporate interests abusing our resources, tearing up our land, depleting our water and displacing Navajo citizens. Worse still, itโ€™s being done by a Navajo enterprise.โ€ย (news release)
  • State data show theย West Elk coal mine near Somerset, Colorado, is emitting potent greenhouse gas methane and other harmful compounds at nearly four times the permitted rate, spurring environmental groups to call for the mineโ€™s operator to be sanctioned and forced to use the best available technology to slow the leaks.ย (Colorado Sun)
The West Elk coal mine near Somerset in winter. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • Wyoming Gov. Mark Gordon (R) considersย legally challenging a new California law that requires a contentious proposed coal export terminal in Oakland to go through a full environmental impact reviewย prior to local agency approval, potentially stifling Wyomingโ€™s effort to send Powder River Basin overseas via a West Coast port.ย (Cowboy State Daily)
โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ
  • The recent deluges have done a real number on the roads leading into Chaco Culture National Historical Park in northwestern New Mexico.ย The south road, according to the parkโ€™s Facebook page, โ€œis still muddy and slick in places, with patches of deep standing water and wet clay.โ€ Meanwhile, โ€œthe former north road (CR 7950) has sustained catastrophic damage at Escavada Wash. This road is completely inaccessible as an entry point to the park. We expect the repair will take a long time. Please do NOT attempt to enter Chaco from the north road.โ€ย (NPS)
  • Flash flooding washes out sections of the BNSF Railwayโ€™s main line alongside the Rio Puerco near the Arizona-New Mexico border.ย The Rio Puerco lacks reliable streamflow gauges, but the Little Colorado River just downstream from its confluence with the Rio Puerco hit an astounding 6,800 cubic feet per second during the late-September storms in a place that is normally virtually dry. (Navajo Times)
๐ŸŸ COLORADO RIVER CHRONICLE ๐Ÿ’ง
  • Reduced water releases from Glen Canyon Dam diminish the Colorado Riverโ€™s flows in the Grand Canyon,ย which in turn affects recreation, river ecology, and tribal nationsโ€™ sacred places.ย (High Country News)
๐Ÿฆซ WILDLIFE WATCH ๐Ÿฆ…
  • A bear wanders into the Aspen farmers market and starts chowing down, apparently unfazed by the high prices.ย Things like this look cute, but it can end up being deadly for the bear.
๐Ÿชฆ OBITUARY ๐Ÿœ๏ธ
  • Ken Sleight, the inspiration for Seldom Seen Smith in Edward Abbeyโ€™s theย Monkey Wrench Gang, died on Oct. 2 in Moab. Sleight was a river-runner, canyon lover, and lifelong protector of and advocate for Utahโ€™s โ€œStanding Up Country.โ€ โ€œWe just lost such a wonderful person,โ€ John Weisheit, director of Living Rivers and friend and mentee of Sleightโ€™s, told The Salt Lake Tribune. โ€œWe need more Ken Sleights, not less.โ€ย (Salt Lake Tribune)
๐Ÿ“– READING ROOM ๐Ÿง

The New Yorker has again ventured into the Four Corners Country, this time with a story by Peter Hessler about the Million Dollar Highway between Silverton and Ouray, โ€œone of Americaโ€™s scariest roads.โ€ I always enjoy Hesslerโ€™s writing, whether about Cairo or Nucla, and this storyโ€™s no exception. His descriptions of the many accidents and ensuing rescues on that stretch of road are vivid and, yes, scary. And his history of the area and Otto Mears, the roadโ€™s original builder, is compelling. But I have to take issue with the framing of the story, and the headline, which is: โ€œWhy doesnโ€™t anyone want to fix one of Americaโ€™s scariest roads?โ€ To which Iโ€™d respond: Does it really need fixing?

Look, traversing Red Mountain Pass can be daunting, especially during the spring freeze-thaw cycle when rocks are dislodged from the cliffs and tumble down onto the asphalt and the Mother Clineโ€™s human-sized icicles hang perilously over the pavement.Sometimes folks tragically go over the edge. Several plow drivers have perished on the road after getting pummeled by the Riverside Slide. In 1963, Reverend Marvin Hudson and his two teenaged daughters were hit by the Riverside, swept into the gorge, and buried (oddly, Hessler leaves this story, one of the most nerve-chilling, out of the story). This problem has been largely solved by simply shutting the road when danger is high. 

So sure, the road can be dangerous and nerve-racking, but frankly, I can think of plenty of far scarier โ€” and statistically more dangerous โ€” stretches of road. Highway 550 between Albuquerque and Bloomfield is a virtual carnage factory, especially when the oil and gas fields are busy with water and oil-hauling trucks. Highway 191 between Monticello and Moab is super sketchy โ€” and deadly. Or how about I-10 in the Phoenix area, I-40 just about anywhere, or I-70 dropping from the mountains into the Coloradoโ€™s Front Range on a weekend afternoon?

Back in the late 1980s, Colorado spent about a half-billion dollars to โ€œfixโ€ I-70 through Glenwood Canyon. Now itโ€™s the site of multi-vehicle accidents, rockslides, debris flows, and not infrequent closures due to the above. So, yeah, Red Mountain Pass doesnโ€™t need fixing. People just need to slow the hell down and pay attention.


Another control day — Jonathan P. Thompson


The Southeastern #Colorado Water Conservancy District and the Bureau of Reclamation sign Arkansas Valley Conduit Repayment Contract — Chris Woodka (secwcd.org) #ArkansasRiver

From email from Southeastern Water (Chris Woodka):

October 7, 2026

A contract to repay the federal government for the Arkansas Valley Conduit (AVC) was signed Wednesday, October 7, 2026, by the Southeastern Colorado Water Conservancy District and the Bureau of Reclamation.

โ€œThis is an incredibly important day for the District, Reclamation and all of our constituents for the AVC,โ€ said Bill Long, president of the District Board of Directors. โ€œWe still have a long way to go, but we are moving forward. This is an important milestone.โ€

Long held up one of the golden frying pans that were sold up and down the Arkansas Valley in the 1950s to raise money to promote the Fryingpan-Arkansas Project, an effort that eventually led to President John F. Kennedy signing the Fry-Ark Project legislation. The AVC is the final project element of that original Fry-Ark project legislation.

โ€œWithout the Arkansas Valley Conduit, the Valley will not be developed as it would have been otherwise. You cannot attract industry without a supply of clean water,โ€ Long said.

Kevin Karney, chairman of the Districtโ€™s AVC Committee, was an Otero County Commissioner when the AVC was relaunched in 2000. Karney was a member of the group searching for a way to provide better quality water for the Lower Arkansas Valley.

โ€œThe only solution that has risen to the top is the Arkansas Valley Conduit,โ€ Karney said.

Arkansas Valley Conduit map via the Southeastern Colorado Water Conservancy District (Chris Woodka) June 2021.

Reclamation and the District are building the AVC in a collaborative project, with Reclamation building the 130-mile trunk line from Pueblo to Lamar and the District building spur and delivery lines to connect 38 water systems to the trunk line. The total cost of the project is estimated to be $1.4 billion.

The AVC will provide water to 50,000 people served by cities, towns, water districts and private water companies.

Participants are required under federal law to pay 35 percent of the AVCโ€™s cost. Any costs incurred by the District for construction of spur and delivery lines will be credited to the 35 percent repayment. The The remainder will be repaid with miscellaneous revenues generated from the Fryingpan-Arkansas Project (mainly from excess storage capacity contracts in Pueblo Reservoir).

The contract defines the responsibilities for design and construction, facilities ownership, and when the repayment period will start with substantial completion of the AVC. Reclamation will retain ownership of the trunk line and related facilities it is building, as well as the SCADA (Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition) System that will be used to operate the AVC. The District will construct and own the delivery lines, and any SCADA system implemented must comply with federal cybersecurity requirements.

The Contract reaffirms Pueblo Waterโ€™s role for conveyance of AVC water using capacity in its system in accordance with the conditions outlined in the 2022 Three-Party Contract between Reclamation, the District and Pueblo Water.

Provisions are included that would allow delivery of AVC water to participants before the AVC Project is completed. The Contract defines how costs for water delivered, supplies, and various services will be divided between the District and Reclamation prior to completion of construction.

When the AVC is substantially complete, responsibility for all OM&R costs will be transferred to the District. The District is developing a cost model in order to provide reliable estimates of operation, maintenance and replacement (OM&R) at partial and full capacity.

Governor Stephen McNichols, President John F. Kennedy, and U. S. Senator John Carroll pose outdoors at the Pueblo Public School Stadium in Pueblo (Pueblo County), Colorado, at the Presidential authorization of the Fryingpan – Arkansas Rivers water reclamation project. Photo credit: Denver Public Library Special Collections

GarCo Report: Commissioners hear updates on election, water, AI and budget — The Sopris Sun #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Shoshone Falls hydroelectric generation station back in the day via USGenWeb

Click the link to read the article on The Sopris Sun website (Amy Hadden Marsh). Here’s an excerpt:

October 7, 2026

Representatives of the Colorado River Water Conservation District (CRWCD) presented a detailed update about West Slope water, Shoshone water rights and more. Taking a look at water conservation proportionality, Lindsay DeFrates, CRWCD public information officer, later told The Sun that the CRWCD believes that proportionality is critical as the state investigates how to implement the Contribution Program, which allocates Coloradoโ€™s share of federal money awarded to the Upper Basin states to conserve water. โ€œIt will pay people to use less water,โ€ she said.ย  At Mondayโ€™s meeting, CRWCD General Manager Andy Mueller expressed concern regarding the disproportionate impact of water conservation on western Colorado agriculture. โ€œIf you donโ€™t have state laws requiring proportionality from all Colorado River users, meaning the Front Range as well, all of that water not only comes off the West Slope, it comes out of West Slope [agriculture],โ€ he said.

Coloradoโ€™s conservation goal is 100,000 acre-feet of water. โ€œIf all of that comes out of West Slope [agriculture], thatโ€™s a big hit to our local economies, to our small towns, to our agricultural industry, and it may be just the beginning of what we view as a permanent program,โ€ Mueller added. 

As for the Shoshone water rights issue, CRWCDโ€™s Strategy Chief Amy Moyer told the BOCC that the purchase price is $99 million and all but $1.6 million has been raised from the CRWCD, the federal government and state and local governments, including $3 million from Garfield County. โ€œOur plan is to continue working with communities up and down the river,โ€ Moyer said. โ€œBut we may want to sit down with you as we look to close that $1.6 million gap.โ€

Getches-Wilkinson Center: The Colorado River Upper Initial Units Take Center Stage — Eric Kuhn, Anne Castle, Jack Schmidt, Kathryn Sorensen, Katherine Tara

Flaming Gorge Dam: USBR

Click the link to read the report on the Getches-Wilkinson Center website (Eric Kuhn,*ย Anne Castle,โ€ ย Jack Schmidt,โ€กย Kathryn Sorensen,ยงย Katherine Tara**). Here’s the Introduction:

October 6, 2026

SUMMARY OF KEY POINTS

  • In 1956, Congress authorized the Upper Initial Unitsโ€”Flaming Gorge Reservoir, Navajo Reservoir, and the Aspinall Unit (UIUs)โ€”for a variety of water use purposes in the Upper Colorado River Basin, including compliance with the 1922 Colorado River Compact (1922 Compact). The historical record is clear that the primary reason these reservoirs exist is to satisfy the math of the 1922 Compact and the obligations it imposed on the Upper Division States regarding flows at Lee Ferry.
  • The size and operation of the UIUs was based on the math of the river as we understood it from the 1930s through the mid-1950s (natural flows, projected uses, and the drought of record). This math no longer works. Total water use in the Colorado River Basin has consistently exceeded the available supply since 2000. Until this fundamental problem is solved, releasing water from the UIUs only delays necessary permanent reductions in water use and provides some degree of temporary management flexibility.
  • The 1948 Upper Basin Compact contemplates delivery of a required quantity of water at Lee Ferry. Article V gives the Upper Colorado River Commission (UCRC) the authority to allocate the capacity of the UIUs between providing water for use within the Upper Division States and providing water for common benefit purposes (delivering water to Lee Ferry). The policy has always been that 100% of the capacity of Navajo Reservoir is allocated for water use in New Mexico and 100% of the capacities of Blue Mesa and Flaming Gorge Reservoirs is allocated for common benefit purposes.
  • There is no doubt that Flaming Gorge and Blue Mesa Reservoirs exist to meet a portion of the obligation of the Upper Division States under Article III of the 1922 Compact. As of October 1, 2026, the ten-year Lee Ferry flow will be about 81.2 million acre-feet (MAF), and under the Lower Division Statesโ€™ interpretation of the 1922 Compact, the Upper Division States may be in a compact deficit by 800,000 acre-feet (or more).
  • Yet over 2.0 MAF of water remains in active storage in Flaming Gorge Reservoir; more than enough water to erase the deficit and put the Upper Division states back in compact compliance as interpreted by the Lower Basin, if only for the short term.
  • The Upper Division States assert that they are in full compliance with the 1922 Compact.ยน Thus, in their view, delivering additional UIU water to Lee Ferry now would be a waste of stored water that they may need in the future. They question why yet another reservoir should be further drawn down when the Basin has not solved the fundamental problem of demand exceeding supply.
  • The stored water available in Flaming Gorge Reservoir has increased in importance to the entire basin. The Lower Division states view it as a source of water that can be delivered at Lee Ferry to supplement the releases from Lake Powell and thereby fulfill the obligations of the Upper Division States under the 1922 Compact. The Bureau of Reclamation is using Flaming Gorge as a source of water to protect critical infrastructure at Glen Canyon Dam, including hydropower generation. The Upper Division States view Flaming Gorge as a source of water for their current and future benefit; the water stored there could be used to comply with an adverse decision by a court or Special Master.
  • There remain unresolved issues concerning the use of water stored in the UIUs, with seemingly conflicting provisions in the 1948 Upper Basin Compact and the 1970 Long-Range Operating Criteria that currently govern the operation of these reservoirs. These issues could govern future releases from the UIUs but have not been explicitly addressed in the Post-2026 Record of Decision or the 2027-2028 Operating Rules.
  • The math of the 1922 Compact and its Lee Ferry flow provision, together with the directives of the Long-Range Operating Criteria, can no longer be reconciled with todayโ€™s hydrology and long-term average basin-wide consumptive use. The Basin States can argue about compliance with various conflicting provisions, but the fundamental problem is that the rules were designed for a different river. We need new operating rules that reflect the river we have today. The choice in finding these new rules is likely to be between a compromise that is painful to all parties or a zero-sum Supreme Court decision that determines who gets what little water there is and who does not.

INTRODUCTIONยฒ

The 1956 Colorado River Storage Project Act (1956 CRSPA)ยณ authorized construction of Glen Canyon Dam, which created Lake Powell, and three additional major upstream storage projects; Flaming Gorge Dam and Reservoir, Navajo Dam and Reservoir, and the Curecanti Unit (Blue Mesa, Morrow Point, and Crystal Dams and Reservoirs, now called the Aspinall Unit). The 1956 CRSPA was designed as a broad authorization for Upper Basin water development within the bounds of the 1922 Compact. The legislation authorized construction of storage dams, powerplants,โด numerous irrigation projects, and trans-basin diversions. Among the purposes of 1956 CRSPA were โ€œregulating the flow of the Colorado River, storing water for beneficial consumptive use, making it possible for the States of the Upper Basin to utilize, consistently with provisions of the Colorado River Compact, the apportionments made to and among them in the Colorado River Compact and the Upper Colorado River Basin Compact, respectively . . ..โ€โต Flaming Gorge, Navajo, and the Aspinall Unitโถ are collectively referred to as the โ€œUpper Initial Unitsโ€ (hereafter, UIUs). The three UIUsโ€™ total live storage capacity is 6.15 million acre-feet (MAF), of which 5.10 MAF is โ€œactiveโ€ storage.โท On October 1, 2026, the total live storage in the three reservoir systems was 3.47 MAF. The Appendix contains a detailed description of each of the UIUs, with information on capacity, operations, and contract obligations.

For over 60 years, the three UIUs have been storing system water and producing hydroelectric power. These reservoirs, however, previously played a relatively small role in the operation of federal reservoirs of the Colorado River Basin (Basin) as a whole. The focus of the Basinโ€™s competing interests has primarily been on operation of Glen Canyon Dam and Hoover Dam that form Lake Powell and Lake Mead, respectively. These two reservoirs are the largest in the United States and presently store approximately 66% of all the water in the 12 federal reservoirs reported in Reclamationโ€™s 24-Month Studies. During the debate and development of major policy actions for the Colorado River, such as the 1970 Coordinated Long-Range Operating Criteria,โธ 2001 Interim Surplus Guidelines,โน and the 2007 Interim Guidelines,ยนโฐ the operations of the UIUs were barely mentioned. However, as storage in Lake Powell and Lake Mead has declined, the importance of the UIUs has increased.

The Bureau of Reclamation (Reclamation) operates each of the three UIUs under separate Records of Decision (ROD). Each is operated in a manner that balances many competing interests such as: storage for 1922 Compact compliance, the delivery of stored water for Upper Basin consumptive uses, the delivery of water in fulfillment of Tribal water right settlement obligations, flood control, hydropower generation, on-reservoir recreation, downstream river recreation, sport fisheries in the reservoir and in the stream below the reservoir, and the flow needs of threatened and endangered fishes. Reclamation operates the UIUs in a transparent manner, and each has a local constituency that is closely involved in how their project is operated.

The UIU obscurity honeymoon ended in 2019 when the Upper Division States proposed what became the Drought Response Operations Agreement (DROA) as a component of their 2019 Drought Contingency Plan.ยนยน Arguably, under federal law, the Secretary of the Interior (Secretary) has broad authority to unilaterally move water from the UIUs downstream to Lake Powell. However, Reclamation took a more collaborative approach in the DROA: it was an inter-governmental agreement among the US (through Reclamation) and the states of Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming. DROA authorized releases from the UIUs to the extent necessary to achieve the stated operational objective of minimizing the risk of Lake Powell falling below a target elevation of 3525 ft, and thereby:

  • helping to ensure the Upper Division States will continue fulfilling their interstate water compact obligations while exercising their rights to develop and utilize the Upper Basinโ€™s Compact apportionment,
  • maintaining the ability to generate hydropower at Glen Canyon Dam, and
  • minimizing adverse effects on resources and infrastructure in the Upper Basin.ยนยฒ

DROA is subject to numerous constraints, including:

  • Water available in the UIU reservoirs,
  • Protection of authorized purposes of each CRSP unit (water supply, endangered species, recreation, hydropower, etc.),
  • Consultation with the Upper Division States and the Upper Colorado River Commission, and
  • Operating criteria established in the agreement and the associated Records of Decision.

In 2021, a total of 181,000 acre-feet of DROA releases were planned pursuant to the Secretaryโ€™s emergency authority: 125,000 acre-feet from Flaming Gorge, 36,000 acre-feet from Blue Mesa, and 20,000 acre-feet from Navajo. Due to dry conditions, the 20,000 acre-feet release from Navajo Reservoir was cancelled, resulting in a total release of 161,000 acre-feet.ยนยณ DROA was implemented again in 2022 pursuant to consultation and agreement with the Upper Division Statesโ€”approximately 463,000 acre-feet of water from Flaming Gorge Reservoir were released. Both releases were intended to help maintain an operational target elevation of 3525 ft in Lake Powell.ยนโด The DROA water released from Flaming Gorge Reservoir and Blue Mesa Reservoir in 2021 and 2022 was completely recovered after the moderately wet winter of 2023.ยนโต DROA includes specific provisions addressing storage recovery after a DROA release is made. DROA expires contemporaneously with the 2007 Guidelines, but operations to recover storage releases made before Oct. 1, 2026, continue for as long as necessary.ยนโถ

In response to the near-record low 2026 runoff and the unprecedented low reservoir levels in Lake Mead and Lake Powell, DROA releases were again implemented to supplement Lake Powell levels, and this time with even greater urgency and impact. To help maintain the elevation of Lake Powell above 3500 ft, on April 23, 2026, Reclamation began making additional DROA releases from Flaming Gorge Reservoir.ยนโท According to the September 2026 24-Month Study, the planned release from Flaming Gorge will total one million acre-feet between April 2026 and April 2027, but Reclamation retains the flexibility to adjust the timing and amount based on actual hydrologic conditions. Citing contractual obligations and unusually low storage, there are no planned DROA releases scheduled for 2026 from either Blue Mesa Reservoir or Navajo Reservoir.ยนโธ

As annual Colorado River Basin runoff in the 21st century is consistently lower than in the 20th century and the โ€œRatchet Effectโ€ is evident in reservoir storage basin-wide, disputes over the operation of the UIUs between the Upper Division States and Lower Division States have increased and indeed now are nearly as critical and strident as the disputes over water deliveries from Lake Powell to Lake Mead.ยนโน The Lower Division Statesโ€™ May 1, 2026, Proposal for Short-Term Operations of the Colorado River included proposed operating criteria for the UIUs that would expand their role in maintaining Lake Powell elevations and effectively subordinate the refilling of the UIUs until there is sufficient water in Lake Powell to support the delivery of 8.23 MAF per year.ยฒโฐ The stated intent is โ€œto share the benefit of improved hydrology between both basins.โ€ยฒยน On May 13th, 2026, the director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources told the Arizona Re-Consultation Committee that under Arizonaโ€™s interpretation of the Law of the River, the 1956 CRSPA specifically subordinates the delivery of contract water from the UIUs and the refilling of those reservoirs to water deliveries to the Lower Basin and Mexico under the 1922 Compact.ยฒยฒ

The Upper Division States believe the operation of the UIUs proposed by the Lower Division States is outside the scope of the Post-2026 NEPA process and cannot be incorporated into the Record of Decision as part of the 2027โ€“2028 operations plan.ยฒยณ Further, some UCRC commissioners pointed out that under the 1956 CRSPA, there are multiple purposes of the UIUs including supporting consumptive uses within the Upper Basin.ยฒโด At the 2026 Getches-Wilkinson Center Conference on the Colorado River, then-Acting Reclamation Commissioner Scott Cameron noted that Reclamation would aggressively operate the UIUs under their RODs to help manage Lake Powell levels, but added that the Secretary has, and will use, if necessary, emergency authorities to operate the UIUs outside the bounds of their RODs.ยฒโต

The Record of Decision (ROD) released on August 21, 2026, for the “Decision Framework for Colorado River Guidelines: Coordinated Operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead (2027โ€“2036)” addressed the operation of the UIUs in a general manner. The ROD states:

โ€œIn carrying out the Decision Framework, the Department will continue to coordinate the operation of Lake Powell, Lake Mead, and the Colorado River Storage Project (CRSP) Upper Initial Units โ€“ specific reservoirs above Lake Powell โ€“ pursuant to Section 602 of the Colorado River Basin Project Act of 1968 (CRBPA). Consistent with each facilityโ€™s existing ROD, the CRSP Upper Initial Units remain an operational tool available to the Secretary, when necessary, to release additional water to increase the elevation at Lake Powell to protect critical Federal infrastructure.โ€ยฒโถ

While the Decision Framework Operational Sideboards of the ROD include the โ€œPotential for maximum use of CRSP Upper Initial Units within their respective RODs to release additional water if needed to protect critical infrastructure,โ€ they also allow for greater releases than described in their respective RODs:

“The Decision Framework establishes consultation thresholds associated with critical reservoir elevations. When projected reservoir conditions approach or fall below the consultation thresholds identified in the operational sideboards, the Secretary will coordinate and consult with the Basin States, Basin Tribes and other affected parties, as appropriate, regarding additional operational actions that may be appropriate to reduce risks to critical Federal infrastructure and maintain system reliability.ยฒโท”

Further, โ€œSuch consultations may include consideration of additional reductions in water use, adjustments to coordinated reservoir operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead, use of the CRSP Upper Initial Units, or other operational actions.โ€ยฒโธ

Notably, the Decision Framework does not mention using the UIUs for making deliveries of water to Lee Ferry when there is insufficient water in Lake Powell for compliance with the 1922 Colorado River Compact (1922 Compact).

UIU storage recovery timing and amounts are not specified in the 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines,ยฒโน but Interiorโ€™s response to the Lower Basinโ€™s May 1st proposal stated that it:

“intends to refill the UIUs as soon as practicable to ensure water remains available for any additional infrastructure protection releases, while avoiding further risk to critical infrastructure during recovery operations. Based on prior operational experience, recovery operations were initiated once Lake Powell was no longer projected to continue declining. Reclamation would apply a similar approach for future UIU recovery operations and would consider actual hydrology and Basin-wide conditions before initiating recovery actions.ยณโฐ”

What is clear is that the water stored in the UIUs is an increasingly important resource coveted by the Upper Division States, the Lower Division States, Basin Tribes,ยณยน and Reclamation. It is also clear that each of these entities has a different perspective on the priorities under which the UIUs will be operated in the future. But it is important to recognize that while the water released by the UIUs in 2021, 2022, and 2026 provided critical benefits, especially for maintaining Lake Powell above target thresholds, DROA-like releases are not a solution to the Basinโ€™s fundamental problem โ€“ systematic use of more than the available water supply. The operation of the UIUs may buy time and provide additional flexibility for reservoir system management, but it does not create any new water.

The debate over the future use of the UIUs has also exposed and amplified several long-standing disputes over the interpretation of the key provisions of the Law of the River,ยณยฒ and ambiguities in the major federal legislation that authorized the construction and operation of the riverโ€™s major federal reservoirs. A primary disputed issue facing the Colorado River Basin today is how much water must flow at Lee Ferry to satisfy the Upper Division Statesโ€™ 1922 Compact obligations. As stated above, delivering water to Lee Ferry was a core purpose for both Lake Powell and the three UIUs.ยณยณ

On August 24, 2026, the state of Nevada, the Colorado River Commission of Nevada, and the Southern Nevada Water Authority filed a complaint for declaratory action and injunctive relief requesting a declaration that the ROD, Final Environmental Impact Statement, and 2027-2028 Guidelines are in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and the Law of the River.ยณโด The complaint requests an injunction halting the implementation of the ROD and Operating Guidelines. Among other arguments, the plaintiffs claim that the Secretary failed to consider the exercise of authority to operate the UIUs in compliance with the Law of the River and NEPA.

The ROD states that the UIUs will be the subject of a new DROA agreement (referred to as a โ€œframeworkโ€) that is currently being negotiated among Reclamation and the Upper Division States. This proposed agreement, drafts of which have not been released to the public, has already received criticism from the State of Arizona. If finalized, it could also be the subject of future litigation.ยณโต In the remainder of the paper, we explore the history of the UIUs from their conception to the present day to provide context and rationale for future operations.


*ย Retired General Manager, Colorado River Water Conservation District.

โ€ ย Senior Fellow, Getches-Wilkinson Center, University of Colorado Law School; former US Commissioner, Upper Colorado River Commission; former Assistant Secretary for Water and Science, US Dept. of the Interior.

โ€กย Center for Colorado River Studies, Utah State University; former Chief, Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center.

ยงย Director of Research, Kyl Center for Water Policy, Arizona State University; former Director, Phoenix Water Services.

**ย Staff Attorney, Utton Transboundary Resources Center, University of New Mexico.

1 The position of the Lower Division States is that the Upper Division States must not deplete the ten-year flow at Lee Ferry below 75 MAF PLUS deliver half of the annual treaty delivery to Mexico. The normal treaty delivery is 1.5 MAF, so the total ten-year delivery obligation could be 82.5 MAF. In recent years, under Minutes 323 and 330, the annual delivery has been less, but because these Minutes also create water that Mexico can store โ€“ calculating how much delivery the Upper Division States must share is not a simple matter. In any event, however, it appears that 81.2 MAF is less than the required 10-year flow pursuant to the Lower Division Statesโ€™ legal position.

1 The Upper Division States do not agree that their obligation to Mexico under Article III(c) of the 1922 Compact is half of the annual delivery to Mexico under the 1944 Treaty every year. For more information, see Eric Kuhn, et. al, The 1922 Compact is Now the Obvious Elephant in the Negotiating Room, Oct. 6, 2025, https://www.colorado.edu/center/gwc/media/707.

2 This paper describes the authorization of the UIUs, the events leading up to that authorization, and some of the debate that resulted in the compromises in the 1956 Colorado River Storage Project Act (1956 CRSPA). The authors recognize that there are several detailed histories of CRSPA that address different aspects of its origins and come from a different perspective. Among these are: MARC REISNER. CADILLAC DESERT: THE AMERICAN WEST AND ITS DISAPPEARING WATER (1986, Viking Press); M. HARVEY, A SYMBOL OF WILDERNESS: ECHO PARK AND THE AMERICAN CONSERVATION MOVEMENT (Univ. N.M. Press 1994, 2nd Ed. Univ. of W.A. Press, 2000). Recognizing the value and insights of these previous works, this paper seeks to place the UIUs and their origins within the context of todayโ€™s hydrology and disputes.

3 P.L. 84-485, 70 Statute 105, 43 U.S.C. ยง 620 et seq.

4 The provision of hydroelectric power and resulting revenues prompted the label โ€œcash register damโ€ to refer to projects in which the hydropower receipts finance other project construction. Long-Term Drought and Glen Canyon Dam: Potential Effects on Water Deliveries and Hydropower, Congressional Rsch. Serv., Apr. 4, 2023, at 4.

5 1956 CRSPA Preamble.

6 The three reservoirs in the Aspinall Unit are Blue Mesa, Morrow Point, and Crystal. Only Blue Mesa is operated for river regulation and storage. Future references to storage in the UIUs include Blue Mesa, Flaming Gorge and Navajo Reservoirs, but not Morrow Point and Crystal Reservoirs. A number of additional reservoirs were authorized by the 1956 CRSPA (and subsequent federal legislation) as components of participating projects. All of these reservoirs have specific project functions. Several of these reservoirs store a significant amount of water. Strawberry Reservoir, a component of the Central Utah Project, McPhee Reservoir, a component of the Dolores Project, and Fontanelle Reservoir, a component of the Seedskadee Project are three prominent examples.

7 The data sources for this paper are primarily the Hydrologic Database (HDB) and the 24-Month Studies, both maintained or prepared by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. We use โ€œlive storageโ€ to mean the amount of storage reported in the HDB or alternately, the 24-Month studies. The standard terminology for reservoirs is that live storage is the amount that can be physically withdrawn or released downstream. Active storage is the amount above the power plant penstocks (or primary outlet works for Navajo Reservoir). Inactive storage is the amount between the power plant inlets, and the low-level outlet works. Below the low-level outlet is the โ€œdead pool.โ€ In theory, live storage = active plus inactive storage. In practice, however, each reservoir has a different design and different management issues. It is possible that some live storage may not be accessible for downstream delivery and use. The figures provided for live and active storage in the UIUs do not include Crystal and Morrow Point reservoirs.

8 For more information on the 1970 Long Range Operating Criteria, see https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/pao/pdfiles/opcriter2005FRN.pdf.

9 The Colorado River Interim Surplus Criteria were adopted in 2001, but were superseded by the 2007 Interim Guidelines, see https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/surplus/pdf/Attachments/Attachment_I.pdf.

10 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Colorado River Interim Guidelines for Lower Basin Shortages and the Coordinated Operations for Lake Powell and Lake Mead, December 2007, https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/programs/strategies/RecordofDecision.pdf.

11ย U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2019 Drought Response Operations Agreement, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/dcp/droa.html.

12ย DROA, Sec. I.A.

13ย Upper Colorado River Commission (UCRC) Seventy-Third Annual Report (2022), pages 16-17.

14 UCRC Seventy-Fourth Annual Report (2023), page 15. With the DROA releases, Lake Powell reached a low of 3519.92 ft. (MSL), in early April 2023.

15 UCRC Seventy-Fifth Annual Report (2024), page 15. With an estimated natural flow of 17.3 MAF, 2023 was the third wettest year since 2000. We refer to it as a moderately wet year based on comparisons with the 20th Century record. With a natural flow of 17.3 MAF, it is about the same as the ten-year average from 1980-1989 โ€“ 17.2 MAF. USBR natural flow database, https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/NaturalFlow/index.html.

16 DROA, Sec. II.A.6.

17 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2026 Drought Response Operations Plan, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/documents/dcp/DROA/2026/uc-2026droughtresponseoperationsplan-attachmentsa-h-508-20260423.pdf. Two measures were put in place to maintain the elevation of Lake Powell above 3500 ft. The 1.0 MAF of DROA releases and a reduction of the Water Year 2026 annual release from Glen Canyon Dam from 7.5 MAF to 6.0 MAF.

18 Id.

19 For an explanation of the Ratchet Effect, see Schmidt et al., The Colorado River Water Supply Crisis in a Few Graphs: Part 1 at 8 (June 2026), https://www.colorado.edu/center/gwc/2026/06/18/colorado-river-water-supply-crisis-few-graphs-part-1.

20 Lower Division Statesโ€™ Proposal for Short-Term Operations of the Colorado River, May 1, 2026, https://www.azwater.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/2026.05.01%20LB2YearPlanFINAL.pdf.

21 Memo from John Entsminger to Andrea Travnicek, Subject: Lower Division Statesโ€™ Proposal for 2026โ€“2028 Colorado River Operations, Dated May 1, 2026.

22 AWDR presentation at the ARC Meeting May13, 2026, slide #9, https://www.azwater.gov/sites/default/files/2026-05/2026.05.13%20ARC%20Meeting%20%2313%20FINAL_0.pdf.

23 Letter from UCRC Executive Director Cullom to Acting Commissioner Cullom, dated June 1, 2026, http://www.ucrcommission.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/UDS-response-to-BOR-response-to-LB-concept-June-1-2026.pdf.

24 Comments of the individual UCRC commissioners at the April 26, 2026, special meeting of the UCRC where it reluctantly approved the DROA plan.

25 Scott Cameron, Bureau of Reclamation presentation, 2026 GWC Conference, https://www.colorado.edu/center/gwc/2026/06/04/june-4-5-2026-conference-colorado-river.

26ย U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Record of Decision, Framework for Colorado River Guidelines: Coordinated Operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead (2027-2036) August 2026, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/post2026/decision-doc/P26_RecordofDecision_Final.pdf.

27ย ROD at 30.

28ย ROD at 27, 30.

29 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines, https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/post2026/decision-doc/2027-2028OperatingGuidelines_Final.pdf.

30 Department Response to Lower Division Statesโ€™ Proposal for 2027-2028 Colorado River Operations, May 28, 2026.

31 The Ute Mountain Ute Tribe, Southern Ute Indian Tribe, Jicarilla Apache Nation, and Navajo Nation each have significant and unique interests in the operation of Navajo Reservoir. The Ute Indian Tribe of the Uintah and Ouray Reservation has asserted claims to water stored in Flaming Gorge Reservoir.

32 The Law of the River is a complex set of agreements, treaties, court decisions, and regulations that govern the allocation and use of water resources in the Colorado River Basin. A Colorado River Overview: Education, Facts & Statistics, https://coloradoriver.com/statistics-facts/.

33 1956 CRSPA, supra note 3.

ยณโด Nevada v. Burgum, et al, U.S. District Court, District of Nevada, Case 2:26-cv-02665, filed 08/24/2026. See also, https://mavensnotebook.com/2026/08/25/courthouse-news-nevada-files-suit-over-colorado-river-plan/; https://www.gov.nv.gov/press-releases/nevada-files-lawsuit-against-department-of-the-interior-over-colorado-river-operations-record-of-decision.

ยณโต The term โ€œframeworkโ€ to describe the new DROA was used by the UCRC at its Sept. 15, 2026, Special Meeting. The comments by Tom Buschatzke were made at the August 24, 2026, meeting of the Arizona Reconsultation Committee.

How a century-old pricing system has emptied the #ColoradoRiver: An absurdity of the Colorado River crisis is the role of heavy government subsidization of agricultural water use — Daniel M. Frey (BigPivots.com) #COriver #aridification

Colorado River near Burns. Photo credit: Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Daniel M. Frey):

October 5, 2026

While fighting over water rights and priorities might take decades, the federal government can start aligning what agriculture pays for federal delivery with what municipal users already pay โ€” without waiting for a new compact or a courtroom fight over title.

We are told that nothing can be done about the Colorado River water crisis while officials allow powerful agricultural interests to keep using more of the river for hay and alfalfa than all cities and other industries in the basin combined.

In the Lower Basin, agricultural water districts pay roughly 6% of what municipal utilities pay at wholesale. That pricing perpetuates waste and low-value irrigation, discourages conservation, and undermines any real chance of restoring the riverโ€™s supplies.

Part I of this series (see โ€œAbsurdity of the Colorado River crisis,โ€ Big Pivots, Aug. 30, 2026) showed that nearly half the water put to human use in the Colorado River Basin goes to growing feed for cattle โ€” alfalfa, hay and silage โ€” while 40 million people depend on the same river for drinking water.

That is not a hydrology problem. It is a political one, built on the doctrine that the oldest water right always wins, no matter how the world around it has changed.

This installment goes one layer deeper, into the accounting. The story of the Colorado River is not only about who has the legal right to water. It is about how government pricing, contracts, and cost-shifting have supported overuse on low-value crops.

The volumes restated

Forage crops โ€” mostly alfalfa and hay grown to feed livestock โ€” consume close to half of all water used by people across the Colorado River Basin. In 2023, two separate studies by the Western Agricultural Economics Association and the Arizona Department of Agriculture (see Sources) concluded that in the Lower Basinโ€™s desert valleys, a substantial share is shipped overseas: up to 30% of Imperial Valley alfalfa and more than a fifth of Arizonaโ€™s hay.

In the Upper Basin, including Colorado, forage crops make up roughly 90% of agricultural irrigation, more than three times what Upper Basin households, businesses and industries consume combined. The degree and complexity of irrigation and infrastructure vary across the upper and lower basin. There are small farms and communities that have closely and carefully integrated water with highly efficient and effective irrigation.

It should also be understood that many farms and ranches in the Colorado River Basin, particularly in the Upper Basin, do not depend upon federal-financed infrastructure. This essay is not about them. Rather, it is about both farms and cities who benefit from federal infrastructure. Cities that are home to millions of people are asked to justify every toilet flush and lawn sprinkler while a crop with a modest market value drains the river. That imbalance might be easier to defend if the irrigators paid a market price. Instead, Lower Basin irrigation districts pay about 6% of what cities pay at wholesale.

How the government built โ€” and then discounted โ€” this system

Almost none of the infrastructure that makes Southwestern irrigation possible was built or paid for by farmers alone. The dams, canals, and reservoirs of the Colorado River system were constructed and financed by the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, a Department of the Interior agency that has spent more than a century as the largest wholesaler of water in the country.

Under federal reclamation law, the government fronts the capital, and the beneficiaries โ€” irrigation districts, cities, power customers โ€” are supposed to pay it back over time.

Political power derailed equitable pricing during this past century. Reclamation law splits repayment onto two tracks. Municipal and industrial water is repaid over roughly 40 to 50 years โ€” with interest. Irrigation costs are repaid over the same window โ€” interest-free.

Congress wrote the interest-free exemption into the original Reclamation Act of 1902 to spur Western settlement. Homesteaders on arid land had no way to finance dams and canals themselves. Lawmakers reasoned that irrigated farms would eventually generate enough tax base and repayment to justify the up-front public investment.

Cities were not part of that original calculation. Municipal and industrial water became an authorized Reclamation purpose only in 1939, and it was placed on the standard interest-bearing track. The exemption made sense when the goal was populating an unsettled frontier. It has been revisited many times since โ€” always to loosen it โ€” but never ended for a basin now serving forty million urban residents.

That alone would be a meaningful subsidy. It gets larger. Reclamation law also lets irrigation districts apply for โ€œability to payโ€ relief. That economic review can cut a districtโ€™s repayment obligation below its actual share of construction costs if the government decides the district cannot afford the full amount or that the land is not productive enough to justify full-cost pricing. When those obligations go unpaid, the shortfall does not vanish. It is folded into what other customers pay โ€” chiefly hydropower sales and, on some projects, municipal and industrial users. Cities are not just paying full freight for their own water. On many federal projects, they and power customers are backstopping agricultureโ€™s unpaid balance, too.

In the Colorado River Basin alone, the federal government has put more than $8 billion, in unadjusted dollars, into three programs: Hoover Dam and the All-American Canal, the Colorado River Storage Project and the Central Arizona Project. Compounded at 4.6%, roughly what cities have paid to borrow over the past century, $8 billion would be worth more than $75 billion today. The power and municipal shares of those costs carry interest; the irrigation share does not. The financing model was never hidden. The Storage Project โ€” Glen Canyon, Flaming Gorge, Navajo, and the Aspinall Unit โ€” was promoted in the 1950s on the promise that power and municipal features would be repaid with interest and irrigation would not. Hydropower revenue from those dams still covers irrigation costs judged to be beyond farmersโ€™ ability to pay.

At that rate, repaying a construction cost interest-free over 50 years wipes out about 60% of its value compared with what municipalities pay. Add debt forgiveness, stretched repayment periods and โ€œability to payโ€ relief, and the discount grows: economist Richard Wahl found that once interest was counted, irrigators repaid only about fourteen cents of every dollar of irrigation construction costs.

What this looks like in dollars

The gap is not subtle. A December 2025 report from the UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability and the Natural Resources Defense Council analyzed 217 water transactions across the Lower Basin states. The report found that agricultural water districts pay a weighted average of about $30 per acre-foot, while municipal utilities pay about $512.

An acre-foot is 326,000 gallons, enough to supply two to three households for a year. Under this system, a hay farmerโ€™s district pays about $30 and a utility serving a family in Phoenix or San Diego pays roughly $500 โ€” before treatment and local delivery. That is seventeen times as much for the same unit of a scarce public resource.

Federal repayment terms are only one reason for that gap. Under Western water law and most federal contracts, the water itself is essentially free; prices reflect the cost of storing, moving, and treating it, and city systems carry heavier pumping and treatment costs. However, the federal subsidy is part of the gap the public has financed directly โ€” and the part of Washington can most readily change.

Some agricultural districts, including Californiaโ€™s Imperial Irrigation District, the single largest holder of Colorado River water rights, pay the Bureau of Reclamation nothing at all for the water itself. Their contracts do not require payment for the raw supply. When the federal government paid for that same district in 2023 to leave water in Lake Mead, the contract rate was about $776 an acre-foot. The district had asked for as much as $840. Everyone involved already knows what the water is worth.

Who holds the cheap water โ€” 20 large corporate farms

A 2023 ProPublica and Desert Sun investigation found that just twenty large farming entities in Californiaโ€™s Imperial Valley received roughly one-seventh of the entire lower Colorado Riverโ€™s flow in 2022. That is more water than Wyoming, New Mexico, or Nevada each use in a year.

The water right itself is held by the Imperial Irrigation District, a public agency. Those entities are the largest users of that right, not its owners. As a whole โ€” historic farm families, outside investors, institutional landholders and at least one foreign hay company receives 97% of IIDโ€™s water. Every home, school and business in the county combined receives 3%.

Cheap irrigation water is not propping up the rural economy. Imperial County sits on some of the most heavily and cheaply irrigated farmland in the country, yet its per capita income in 2021 was about $19,000 โ€” half the national figure of about $38,000, according to Census Bureau estimates. It posted the highest unemployment rate in California that year.

A 2024 peer-reviewed study of agricultural water productivity across the Colorado River Basin found that the least economically productive counties consume 25% of the Basinโ€™s agricultural water to generate just 3% of its crop revenue. Heavily discounted water is not building broad rural prosperity. Where it produces high value, as in Imperial County, that value is concentrated in a small number of landholders; where it does not, it props up low-value production.

Run the counterfactual. If those same operations paid municipal-scale wholesale rates โ€” $300 to $500 an acre-foot instead of $20 to $30 โ€” the economics of growing export-bound cattle feed in a desert would collapse on their own, without a single acre-foot needing to be fought over in court. Water would move toward higher value uses because it would finally cost what it is worth. That is what a functioning price signal does. Right now, the federal government is underwriting the draining of the river for cheap crops and powerful agricultural interests.

Immediate action does not require new water-rights litigation

The most common argument against fixing this is that it would take years. Because water rights are property, this argument holds, any change must move through negotiation, buyouts, and courts.

That is true if the goal is changing who legally owns the water. It is not true if the goal is changing who pays for the infrastructure that delivers it.

Cost allocation is an administrative and budgetary process, not a property right. The Bureau of Reclamation and the Interior Department already have the statutory tools to reassess โ€œability to payโ€ determinations on a going-forward basis, to stop extending new construction-cost discounts to districts irrigating low-value forage crops, and to fully enforce the Reclamation Reform Actโ€™s full-cost pricing for large landholdings. Congress, which wrote the interest exemption into law, can require interest-bearing repayment in new and renegotiated contracts.

Those are the same terms municipal and industrial users already face. Existing repayment contracts cannot simply be rewritten in midstream; they run until they expire or are mutually amended. None of that touches a single farmerโ€™s decreed water right. It stops asking cities and power customers to keep underwriting the next generation of discounts for overuse on low-value crops.

That change would not resolve the Colorado River crisis itself. But it would start doing what a century of โ€œfirst in time, first in rightโ€ has never done: make the cost of water reflect its scarcity. It would let price โ€” not another emergency federal curtailment โ€” begin moving water toward its most essential uses.

Why hasnโ€™t it happened?

The authority sits with the Department of the Interior and the Bureau of Reclamation, which set repayment terms and administer ability-to-pay determinations under reclamation law. Legislative jurisdiction belongs to the House Natural Resources Committeeโ€™s Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries and the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committeeโ€™s Subcommittee on Water and Power. Reclamationโ€™s annual budget is funded through the Energy and Water Development appropriations subcommittees in both chambers โ€” not the Interior-Environment subcommittees, whose jurisdiction excludes the Bureau of Reclamation.

The last time Congress meaningfully touched this structure was the Reclamation Reform Act of 1982. Even that act left interest-free repayment and ability-to-pay intact while expanding the size of farms eligible for subsidized water. Since then, as reservoirs have fallen toward dead pool and the federal government has spent billions on emergency conservation payments and drought relief, no bill addressing the underlying interest-free, cost-shifted pricing structure for Colorado River irrigation has reached a committee markup, let alone the floor of either chamber. A review of Congress.gov and GovTrack through August 2026 found none.

The leverage is not confined to a handful of committee chairs in Washington. It runs through the states that depend on the river. Of the 14 U.S. senators representing the Basinโ€™s seven states, seven sit on the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, which has direct jurisdiction over the Bureau of Reclamation and reclamation law:

Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.); Sen. John Hickenlooper (D-Colo.), also on the Water and Power Subcommittee; Sen. Mike Lee (R-Utah), committee chairman; Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.), ranking member; Sen. Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.), also on Water and Power; Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.), also on Water and Power; and Sen. Alex Padilla (D-Calif.), also on Water and Power.

In the House, 11 basin-state representatives sit on the Natural Resources Subcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries: Chair Harriet Hageman (R-Wyo.), Tom McClintock (R-Calif.), Lauren Boebert (R-Colo.), Celeste Maloy (R-Utah), Jeff Crank (R-Colo.), Melanie Stansbury (D-N.M.), Dave Min (D-Calif.), Adam Gray (D-Calif.), Luz Rivas (D-Calif.), Julia Brownley (D-Calif.) and Joe Neguse (D-Colo.). Jared Huffman (D-Calif.), ranking member of the full committee, serves ex officio.

Four basin-state members โ€” Ken Calvert (R-Calif.), Celeste Maloy (R-Utah), Mike Levin (D-Calif.), and Susie Lee (D-Nev.) sit on the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Energy and Water Development, which writes Reclamationโ€™s budget every year.

According to the same review, none of these lawmakers, of either party, has introduced legislation addressing the interest-free, ability-to-pay repayment structure at the center of this piece. The people with the most direct stake in the outcome โ€” whose constituents are either the cities paying full price or the districts paying a fraction of it โ€” already hold seats on every committee with the authority to change it.

The hard conclusion

This complicated system of senior rights and subsidies, built and protected for a hundred years, leads to an unavoidable conclusion. Under the banner of property rights and support for agriculture, we have allowed a small number of large, politically connected agricultural users to capture much of the water that forty million people depend on.

Almost half of the water put to human use across seven states, from the high Rockies to California, has been turned to private benefit for irrigation of low-value crops, to the detriment of everyone else in the region. Having secured water rights at no cost and federal infrastructure at a steep discount, those same users are demanding to be paid top dollar โ€” more than $800 an acre-foot โ€” to leave that water in the river.

None of this is a call to end Western agriculture or to strip farmers and ranchers of property they hold in good faith. It is a call to stop asking the public to underwrite, at steadily mounting costs, a pricing structure that a small number of landholders have had a century to defend and a well-organized lobby to protect. The technical authority to change the next round of contracts and ability-to-pay reviews already exists inside agencies Congress funds every year. Using that authority still takes political will the basinโ€™s own delegation has not yet shown.

Taking on powerful agricultural interests requires action from representatives of the forty million people who need a sane and sustainable water policy.

Daniel Frey is a Boulder resident, non-practicing CPA and Certified Energy Manager (CEM). He researches and writes on energy and sustainability issues.

Sourcing for essay

Series

Frey, Daniel M. โ€œAbsurdity of the Colorado River crisis.โ€ Big Pivots, Aug. 30, 2026. bigpivots.com/the-absurdity-of-the-colorado-river-crisis/ [Part I of this series]

Water use and forage crop exports

Richter, Brian D., et al. โ€œNew Water Accounting Reveals Why the Colorado River No Longer Reaches the Sea.โ€ Communications Earth & Environment, vol. 5, 2024, article 134. [source for forage cropsโ€™ share of basin water consumption and the Upper Basin 90% figure]

Sall, Ibrahima, Russell Tronstad, and Chia Yi Chin. โ€œAlfalfa Export and Water Use Estimates for Individual States.โ€ Western Agricultural Economics Association, 2023. waeaonline.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/Alfalfa-Export-and-Water-Use-Estimates-for-Individual-States.pdf [state-level alfalfa export shares and water embedded in exports, 2022]

Frisvold, George, and Dari Duval. โ€œUnderstanding the Economics of Arizona Alfalfa.โ€ University of Arizona Department of Agricultural & Resource Economics, via Arizona Farm Bureau, June 26, 2023. azfb.org/Article/Understanding-the-Economics-of-Arizona-Alfalfa [source for exports equal to 22% of Arizona hay and forage production in 2022]

Yachnin, Jennifer. โ€œCan Alfalfa Survive a Fight Over Colorado River Water?โ€ E&E News by Politico, Sept. 8, 2023. eenews.net/articles/can-alfalfa-survive-a-fight-over-colorado-river-water/ [source for up to 30% of Imperial Valley alfalfa exported, citing Family Farm Alliance data]

Water pricing and cost allocation

Garrison, Noah, Isabel Friedman, and Mark Gold. Free Water While It Lasts: An Analysis of Wholesale Water Pricing in the Lower Colorado River Basin States. UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability & Natural Resources Defense Council, Dec. 11, 2025. ioes.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/Water-Pricing-Report.pdf

Griffiths, Claire. โ€œReport Puts Numbers on Massive Gap in Water Costs in the West.โ€ UCLA Institute of the Environment and Sustainability, Dec. 11, 2025. ioes.ucla.edu/article/report-puts-numbers-on-massive-gap-in-water-costs-in-the-west

โ€œColorado River Water Is Too Cheap, Particularly for Agricultural Users.โ€ Inside Climate News, Dec. 11, 2025. insideclimatenews.org/news/11122025/colorado-river-water-too-cheap/

Mendoza, Katya. โ€œUCLA Report Finds Farmers Pay Far Less Than Cities for Colorado River Water.โ€ AZPM, Dec. 16, 2025. azpm.org/s/102329-ucla-report-finds-farmers-pay-far-less-than-cities-for-colorado-river-water/

โ€œCalifornia Cities Pay a Lot for Water; Some Agricultural Districts Get It for Free.โ€ CalMatters, Dec. 11, 2025 (also republished by U.S. News & World Report). calmatters.org/environment/2025/12/price-of-california-water-cities-growers/

Voice of San Diego. โ€œHow Imperial Valley Spends San Diegoโ€™s Cash for Water.โ€ Nov. 2, 2023. voiceofsandiego.org/2023/11/02/how-imperial-valley-spends-san-diegos-cash-for-water/ [source for San Diegoโ€™s ~$730/acre-foot wholesale price vs. Imperialโ€™s $20]

The 2023 Imperial Irrigation District conservation payments

โ€œThe Colorado Riverโ€™s Biggest User Will Conserve Some Water in Exchange for Federal Dollars.โ€ KPBS Public Media, Dec. 5, 2023. kpbs.org/news/environment/2023/12/05/the-colorado-rivers-biggest-user-will-conserve-some-water-in-exchange-for-federal-dollars [source for the $776/acre-foot payment rate]

Stanford University Water Programs. โ€œColorado River Allocation.โ€ water.stanford.edu/research/projects/colorado-river-allocation [source for the up-to-$840/acre-foot figure from the 2023-2026 System Conservation Implementation Agreement]

Land, water rights and county-level economics

Wilson, Janet, and Nat Lash. โ€œThe Historic Claims That Put a Few California Farming Families First in Line for Colorado River Water.โ€ ProPublica / The Desert Sun, Nov. 9, 2023. propublica.org/article/california-farm-families-gained-control-colorado-river

Lash, Nat, and Janet Wilson. โ€œThe 20 Farming Families Who Use More Water from the Colorado River Than Some Western States.โ€ ProPublica / The Desert Sun, Nov. 9, 2023. projects.propublica.org/california-farmers-colorado-river/ [source for the twenty entities and their 2022 water use]

Frisvold, George B., and Jyothsna Atla. โ€œAgricultural Economic Water Productivity Differences Across Counties in the Colorado River Basin.โ€ Hydrology, vol. 11, no. 8, 2024, article 125. doi.org/10.3390/hydrology11080125

U.S. Census Bureau. American Community Survey (ACS), 1-Year Estimates, Table B19301 (โ€œPer Capita Income in the Past 12 Monthsโ€), 2021. data.census.gov [national and Imperial County per capita income figures]

Reclamation law, repayment structure, and federal cost allocation

Congressional Research Service. โ€œBureau of Reclamation Project Authorization and Financing.โ€ CRS In Focus IF10806, Congress.gov. congress.gov/crs-product/IF10806

Congressional Research Service. โ€œBureau of Reclamation Support for Water Storage Projects.โ€ CRS Report R47987, Congress.gov. congress.gov/crs-product/R47987

U.S. Government Accountability Office. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: Availability of Information on Repayment of Water Project Construction Costs Could Be Better Promoted.โ€ GAO-14-764, 2014. gao.gov/assets/gao-14-764.pdf

U.S. Government Accountability Office. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: Reclamation Law and the Allocation of Construction Costs for Federal Water Projects.โ€ GAOREPORTS-T-RCED-97-150. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-T-RCED-97-150/html/GAOREPORTS-T-RCED-97-150.htm

U.S. Government Accountability Office. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: Information on Allocation and Repayment of Costs of Constructing Water Projects.โ€ GAOREPORTS-RCED-96-109, 1996. govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-RCED-96-109/pdf/GAOREPORTS-RCED-96-109.pdf

Wahl, Richard W. Markets for Federal Water: Subsidies, Property Rights, and the Bureau of Reclamation. Resources for the Future, 1989. [source for irrigatorsโ€™ repayment share once interest is counted]

Congressional Research Service. โ€œBureau of Reclamation: History, Authorities, and Issues for Congress.โ€ CRS Report R46303, April 3, 2020. congress.gov/crs-product/R46303 [1939 authorization of municipal and industrial water; history of repayment changes]

U.S. General Accounting Office. โ€œPower Marketing Administrations: Cost Recovery, Financing, and Comparison to Nonfederal Utilities.โ€ GAO/T-AIMD-96-169, Sept. 19, 1996. govinfo.gov/app/details/GAOREPORTS-T-AIMD-96-169 [WAPA required to recover about $1.5 billion in irrigation construction costs through power rates]

Reclamation Reform Act of 1982. Pub. L. No. 97-293, tit. II, 96 Stat. 1263.

Federal investment in Colorado River projects

Central Arizona Project. โ€œExplaining CAPโ€™s Federal Repayment: A Cheat Sheet.โ€ Know Your Water News, May 13, 2020 (updated March 8, 2023). knowyourwaternews.com/explaining-caps-federal-repayment-a-cheat-sheet/ [$4.4 billion total cost, 1973-93; $1.646 billion repayment obligation]

U.S. Census Bureau. โ€œSeptember 2025: Hoover Dam.โ€ Stories From the Census Bureauโ€™s History, Sept. 1, 2025. census.gov/about/history/stories/monthly/2025/september-2025.html [$165 million authorized for Hoover, Imperial Dam, and the All-American Canal; power revenue repaid Hooverโ€™s cost with interest by 1987]

Stene, Eric A. โ€œThe All-American Canal: Boulder Canyon Project.โ€ Bureau of Reclamation History Program. usbr.gov/projects/pdf.php?id=80

U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. โ€œColorado River Storage Project.โ€ Upper Colorado Basin Region. usbr.gov/uc/rm/crsp/index.html [Basin Fund repayment of irrigation costs beyond ability to pay]

U.S. General Accounting Office. โ€œFederal Electric Power: Information Concerning the Colorado River Storage Project.โ€ GAO/RCED-90-2FS, Oct. 3, 1989. gao.gov/products/rced-90-2fs

Upper Colorado River Commission. The Colorado River Storage Project to Build a Stronger America. Promotional booklet, 1950s. Colorado River Compact Collection, Utah State Archives. images.archives.utah.gov/digital/collection/p17010coll70/id/21155/

Congressional committee jurisdiction and membership

U.S. House of Representatives, Office of the Clerk. โ€œCommittee on Natural Resourcesโ€ and โ€œSubcommittee on Water, Wildlife and Fisheries,โ€ 119th Congress. clerk.house.gov/committees/II00 and clerk.house.gov/committees/II13

U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources. โ€œRules, Membership, and Jurisdiction of the Committee on Energy and Natural Resources.โ€ S. Prt. 119-13, March 2025. congress.gov/committee-print/119th-congress/senate-committee-print/59371

U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources. โ€œSubcommittee on Water and Powerโ€ membership list. energy.senate.gov/water-power

Heinrich, Martin, and Mike Lee. โ€œHeinrich, Lee Announce Subcommittee Assignments for 119th Congress.โ€ U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, Feb. 11, 2025. energy.senate.gov/2025/2/heinrich-lee-announce-subcommittee-assignments-for-119th-congress.

U.S. House Committee on Appropriations. โ€œInterior, Environment, and Related Agencies (119th Congress)โ€ and โ€œEnergy and Water Development, and Related Agencies (119th Congress),โ€ membership rosters. appropriations.house.gov and democrats-appropriations.house.gov

U.S. Senate Committee on Appropriations. โ€œSubcommittee on Energy and Water Development.โ€ appropriations.senate.gov/subcommittees/energy-and-water-development

Note: Committee chairs, ranking members, and subcommittee rosters reflect the 119th Congress (2025-2026) as of this writing and are subject to change with reassignments, retirements, or a new Congress. The claim that no relevant bill has reached committee markup reflects a review of the sources above and standard legislative trackers (Congress.gov, GovTrack) as of late August 2026, not an exhaustive search of every bill introduced in the 119th Congress; readers relying on this claim for further reporting should verify independently. All committee membership and pricing figures should be verified at their original sources before publication or reproduction.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

The #ColoradoRiver basin’s 2025-26 water year (October-September) was the warmest on record. It was also the least snowy on record. Only 16.8% of the (below average) precipitation fell as snow – shattering the previous record low — Climatologist49 #snowpack

The Colorado River basin's 2025-26 water year (October-September) was the warmest on record. It was also the least snowy on record. Only 16.8% of the (below average) precipitation fell as snow – shattering the previous record low.

— Climatologist49 (@climatologist49.bsky.social) 2026-10-09T04:05:19.877Z

Data Dump: Western Hay and Alfalfa Exports — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Graph from the 1946 federal report, โ€œThe Colorado River: A Natural Menace Becomes a Natural Resource,โ€ showing the value of livestock to Upper Basin states.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 30, 2026

โ˜˜๏ธ ANNALS OF ALFALFA ๐Ÿ€

It seems like only a few years ago that a PR person from the East Coast emailed me to tell me how surprised she was to read in the Land Desk that alfalfa and other livestock forage crops guzzled up a lot of the Westโ€™s water. โ€œI didnโ€™t even know they still grew alfalfa,โ€ she wrote, incredulously. Actually, it was only a few years ago, but my how things have changed in the realm of alfalfa discourse. Iโ€™m guessing she and just about everyone else who pays attention has figured that one out by now, as itโ€™s become vogue in certain circles to assert that the solution to the Westโ€™s water crisis is simply to stop growing alfalfa and other โ€œlow-valueโ€ agricultural crops and use the water for cities and data centers, instead. At the very least, they argue, we shouldnโ€™t be exporting alfalfa overseas. 

Iโ€™m not going to jump into that hornetโ€™s nest again, at least not today. Instead, I dug up a bunch of data and used them to build a handful of graphs that will, hopefully, illuminate the situation a bit and give all parties โ€” alfalfaphobes and alfalfaphiles alike โ€” something to chew on. Call it statistical cud that Iโ€™ve gnawed on, masticated, partially digested, and now am handing over to you to derive some nutrients from. (Eww. Thatโ€™s gross. Sorry.)

From the 1946 report, โ€œThe Colorado River: A Natural Menace Becomes a Natural Resource.โ€
This is for each state as a whole, and includes acreage that is not in the Colorado River Basin and that is not irrigated with Colorado River water (in Californiaโ€™s Central Valley, for example, or Coloradoโ€™s San Luis Valley, or around the Great Salt Lake in Utah). Note that this graph singles out alfalfa, and does not include acreage planted in other types of hay or forage (the other graphs look at hay generally). Data Source: National Agricultural Statistics Service.

While hay and alfalfa are often maligned as โ€œlow-valueโ€ crops, farmers also grow it to make money. As you can see from the chart below, farmers in Colorado River Basin states harvested nearly $5 billion worth of hay in 2022. Thatโ€™s on a par with the Colorado ski industryโ€™sย annual economic output.

Over the last two decades or so, Western state farmers have sold an increasing amount of hay, especially alfalfa, to overseas buyers. This is largely due to the growing global taste and demand for cow-milk products. Alfalfa is favored by dairy operations because its high protein content increases milk yield. So if youโ€™re trying to reduce alfalfa demand by quitting beef, youโ€™re barking up the wrong tree; youโ€™ll have to ditch the ice cream and cheese, as well (or switch to goat or sheep milk products). 

While hay exports are a billion-dollar-per-year industry, they are dropping off for a variety of reasons, from tariffs and trade wars to Chinaโ€™s shrinking dairy herds and gradually decreasing production here at home.

Source: USDA Foreign Agricultural Service.

While the Western hay-export industry brought in over $1 billion in 2022, itโ€™s not quite accurate to say thatย mostย of the regionโ€™s hay production is for export. Still, more than 20% is quite a lot of Western water to be sending overseas on giant container ships.

In 2025, exports accounted for about 17% of all Colorado River Basin state hay production value. Source: USDA Foreign Agricultural Service.

The largest hay exporter in the West is California, with Arizona and Utah trading second and third places. Other Colorado River Basin states export insignificant amounts of hay, according to the USDAโ€™s Foreign Agricultural Service.

Californiaโ€™s biggest overseas hay customers have been Japan and China, though the China market has been shrinking since 2022. Source: USDA FAS
China has been Utahโ€™s biggest hay buyer by far, though it also ships hay to Korea and Japan. Source: USDA FAS.
Most of the hay exported from Arizona has traditionally gone to Saudi Arabia via Fondomonte Farms, which is owned by Almarai, a huge Saudi dairy and food company. Fondomonte owns farms in Arizona where it grows its own alfalfa for export. Fondomonte pumps groundwater for irrigation, which is not counted against Arizonaโ€™s allocation from the Colorado River (even though groundwater and surface water are connected). Source: USDA FAS.

So whatโ€™s the takeaway from all of this? Well, like I said, Iโ€™m just providing the fodder for you to ruminate on, so to speak. 

But it does definitively show that alfalfa and hay arenโ€™t just some kind of side gig for Western farmers. They are important crops. And trying to convince farmers to give them up โ€” along with the nearly $5 billion per year they can generate โ€” is going to be tough, even if it is necessary. 


โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ

In last weekโ€™s dispatch on more mining claims staked in the shrunken Bears Ears National Monument I mentioned a few dozen that appeared to have been located by Land Survey Advisors, including some in the former monument. I was able to finally get past the glitches in the San Juan County database and get confirmation that all 36 claims were, in fact, staked within Bears Earsโ€™ pre-shrinkage boundaries. That brings the total number of new claims in Bears Ears to 72. 

Iโ€™ll map all of the claims for a future dispatch and will continue to keep my eyes open for more new ones.

๐Ÿ“– READING (&LISTENING) ROOM ๐Ÿ“ฐ
  • The Magic Southwest podcast has an insightful episode about the lost working-class neighborhoods that once lined the Animas River in Durango.ย Well, I shouldnโ€™t say theyโ€™re โ€œlost.โ€ They were mostly destroyed by the city to make way for roads, sewage treatment plants, parks, or just as a form of urban renewal, if you will. Give it a listen below:
  • Heads up Four Corners area folks: Iโ€™ll be giving a presentation on the Dolores River as part of a Dolores River Boating Advocatesโ€™ event on Friday, Nov. 6, from 6 p.m. to 8 p.m. at the Powerhouse in Durango.ย Following a short film about Snaggletooth Rapid Iโ€™ll speak about my personal relationship with the Dolores River, its history, the way it is a sort of microcosm of the Colorado River as a whole, and about its potential futures. Iโ€™ll also throw in a funny little tale about the time I saw Ed Abbey go through Snaggletooth. Tickets are $10 โ€” which will help DRBA defray costs โ€” and seating is limited. There will also be a cash bar.ย Reserve your spot now.ย 
โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Things are getting crazy down in southern New Mexico, especially near Hatch, where the Rio Grande has jumped its banks and inundated fields, homes, and even I-25. Check out the video below for more. And stay tuned next week when I have a recap of the 2026 water year, which may have been the wackiest on record.

Denver Water to reduce Fraser River flows amid extreme #drought — The October 13 reduction will lower #FraserRiver flows to 2 cubic feet per second as Denver Water responds to drought and systemwide water shortages — Sky-Hi Daily News

Rivers and creeks in Grand County are part of Denver Waterโ€™s North Collection System. Water flows through the Moffat Tunnel, under the Continental Divide, to Gross and Ralston reservoirs. Image credit: Denver Water.

Click the link to read the article on the Sky-Hi Daily News website (Isabel Del Mastro). Here’s an excerpt:

Grand County residents will see considerably less water flowing down the Fraser River starting Oct. 13th. Denver Water typically diverts water from the Fraser River through the Moffat Tunnel to serve customers during the winter, according toย Trout Unlimited. But because of extreme drought conditions caused by a lack of snowpack and record-high temperatures, the Fraser River has considerably less water to give…

Since 1969, Fraser River flows have been required to maintain a minimum of 4 cubic feet per second, or cfs, when Denver Water diverts water, a requirement tied in part to U.S. Forest Service requirements. Now, Denver Water is reducing Fraser River flows to 2 cubic feet per second starting Oct. 13 to accommodate extreme drought conditions, according to a Denver Water email forwarded to Sky-Hi News. Reductions remain in place until May 15, unless drought conditions improve or if Denver Water encounters โ€œunforeseen operational issuesโ€ that require them to increase reductions, according to Denver Water Communications Manager Travis Thompson, in an email to Sky-Hi News. Along with reducing Fraser River flows, Denver Water will reduce flows in its tributaries; Vasquez Creek and St. Louis Creek will be reduced to 2 cfs, and Ranch Creek to 1.5 cfs, according to the Denver Water email andย Kirk Klancke, president of the Colorado River Headwaters Grand County Chapter.

Whatโ€™s next for the Colorado River? — Page Buono (AmericanRivers.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Yuma wetlands restoration, Colorado River, Arizona. Photo credit: Fred Phillips

Click the link to read the article on the American Rivers website (Page Buono):

September 9, 2026

For more than the last century, the flows of the Colorado River have been managed and dictated by the demands of a rapidly growing and changing West. There are founding legal documents, and then agreements stacked on those, often known as the โ€œLaw of the River.โ€ These agreements are between states, between sovereign nations, including Tribal Nations and Mexico; between districts and companies and branches of the US Government. Itโ€™s hard to find the appropriate metaphor for how all of these agreements work together (and at times against one another) to manage the Colorado River system. But even fraught metaphors are sometimes the only way to get through something so complicated.

Imagine the web of agreements and founding legal documents that guide the management of the Colorado River as a body. The 1922 Colorado River Compact would be the skeleton, the framework upon which all the other functions of the body are built. The limbs could be the communities, farms, Tribes, businesses, ecosystems, and economies that rely on the riverโ€™s blood (Colorado River water).  The agreements that build on the framework of the Compact, such as the 2007 Interim Guidelines or the 2019 Drought Contingency Plan (DCP), act as nerves that facilitate or trigger movement and action. Perhaps the brain is the network of decision makers โ€“ the Bureau of Reclamation, the states, the Tribes, Mexico and others whose decisions and cooperation keep the system functioning, underscoring why coordination and consensus are so important: a body whose different parts are working at cross-purposes cannot function effectively. The blood then, of course, is the Colorado River water allocated to parts of the body. 

Continuing the body metaphor for the contemporary management of the Colorado River system, additional agreements (or the nerves that trigger certain action) were added to the body.

Colorado River, Colorado | Trout Unlimited Joshua Duplechian

On Friday, August 24, the Bureau of Reclamation released three documents outlining a 10-year framework for how the Colorado River will be managed for the next two years and how management decisions for the subsequent 8 years will be made. You can read the Bureauโ€™s summary doc here.

  1. Theย Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS): evaluates the many proposed plans Reclamation considered for how the river should be managed going forward, and identifies a preferred alternative, a 10-year framework built on operating plans developed in at least two-year increments;
  2. Theย Record of Decision (ROD): adopts the 10-year operating framework and sets the principles and guardrails for future operations including how water can be stored, shortage sharing, critical infrastructure protection, consultation, and the movement of water between Lake Powell and Lake Mead; and
  3. The 2027-2028 guidelines:ย establish the specific operating approach for the first two years under the new framework.

While the two-year guidelines put real numbers and real movement on the table, the ultimate test is whether the guidelines, alongside the side agreements, investments, and management tools needed to support them, are put in place and function as intended โ€“ and whether, together, they can keep the body upright.

Six months from now, the more consequential questions will be whether the new guidelines:

  • provide more certainty and transparency, including clear pathways for addressing disputes and disagreements when they arise;
  • supportย flexible and adaptive management toolsย that can respond to changing hydrology and conditions;
  • meaningfullyย include Tribal Nationsย in both decision-making and implementation;
  • reduce reliance on emergency operationsย and short-term crisis response; and
  • create aย workable path toward long-term resilienceย โ€” one that can withstand disagreement, including litigation, without bringing implementation and collaboration to a halt.
Colorado River flowing through the Grand Canyon National Park in Arizona. Photo credit: Nick Kelley

Finally, and critically, these new guidelines must recognize healthy rivers and watersheds as a core element of the Basinโ€™s resilience infrastructure, because in the middle of all the agreements โ€“ at the core of all the collaboration and controversy, the skeleton and nerves and muscles that move it, there is a river โ€“ there is a heart; the whole reason blood moves through the system at all.

Healthy rivers and forests, connected floodplains, and intact watersheds are essential to the body, to the Basin. They support the reliability of our water supplies, reduce the risks and impacts of wildfire; they sustain fish and wildlife, support recreation, and strengthen the Basinโ€™s ability to withstand drought and changing conditions. They are invaluable.

Which is to say, at the center of all the agreements and negotiations and collaboration and controversy, is the river. Has always been the river. And if we succeed at all in our management, if we have any hope of keeping this body upright, there will always be the river.

Colorado River “Beginnings”. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

R.I.P Ken Sleight: “It was Glen Canyon that changed my whole life…it made an environmentalist out of me” #GlenCanyon #ColoradoRiver #COriver

The Colorado River flows through Glen Canyon in 1958, before the dam was built. (Photo via Wikimedia Commons)

Here’s Zak Podmore’s and Brook Larsen’s tribute from The Salt Lake Tribune website. Here’s an excerpt:

October 3, 2026

Ken Sleight may be most well known for something that he probably never did: kneeling on the bridge in front of the Glen Canyon Dam, his hands clasped and eyes closed, praying to the Almighty to produce a โ€œprecision-type earthquakeโ€ that would free the Colorado River from its imprisonment in Lake Powell. The Sleight-inspired character Seldom Seen Smith acted out the scene in โ€œThe Monkey Wrench Gang,โ€ Edward Abbeyโ€™s 1975 cult classic of ecosabotage. But although the character was fictional,ย Sleightโ€™s lifelong hatred of the damย was very real, as was his love of Glen Canyon, the area drowned by Lake Powell.ย 

โ€œIt was Glen Canyon that changed my whole life,โ€ Sleight told The Salt Lake Tribune in 2018. โ€œIt made an environmentalist out of me.โ€

(Photo by H. Bennett. Courtesy of Ken Sleight.) Ken Sleight making breakfast along the river in Glen Canyon before the dam, circa June 1960.

[…]

In 1957, Sleight purchased eight Army surplus rafts, quit the tire business, and opened a river guiding company that would soon take the name Ken Sleight Expeditions. For the next six years, Sleight led river trips through Glen Canyon on the Colorado River where he showed artists, environmentalists, reporters and curious members of the public the labyrinthine sandstone canyon country that would soon be flooded by Lake Powell…He found common cause with the writer Edward Abbey when the two met in 1967 at the Lees Ferry boat ramp. Sleight was launching on a Grand Canyon trip, and Abbey, who was working as a ranger for the National Park Service, helped Sleight rig his boats.

โ€œ[We] sat on the edge of the raft talking and thinking, eating and drinking until the wee hours of the morning,โ€ Sleight would laterย write, โ€œmaking creative commentary on how best to eliminate the Glen Canyon Dam.โ€

The friendship lasted through Abbeyโ€™s death in 1989, and Sleight never seemed to mind being immortalized as the anarchist Seldom Seen Smith. Sleight often said that Abbey was able to put into words his anger and sorrow over seeing Glen Canyon flooded and so many other wild places transformed by development…Even though Sleight took on numerous environmental and political fights, he never forgot about Glen Canyon, which he often used religious terms to describe. 

โ€œIโ€™d still like to see the water from the reservoir โ€” what I call Lake Foul โ€” I think it all ought to be drained and the water be flushed downstream to be stored in Lake Mead,โ€ Sleight told The Tribune in 2021. โ€œOne thing is for sure: Weโ€™re still trying to resurrect Glen Canyon.โ€

Ken Sleight the original Monkey Wrencher photo via Salon

New film chronicles environmental โ€˜outlawโ€™ Ken Sleightโ€™s fight to restore #GlenCanyon โ€” The #SaltLake Tribune #ColoradoRiver #COriver — Coyote Gulch

Seldom Seen: A Poignant Look Back at Glen Canyon Before the Dam โ€” Yale Environment 360 #ColoradoRiver #COriver — Coyote Gulch


#Utah is paying farmers to conserve #ColoradoRiver water. Is it working? — The Salt Lake Tribune #COriver #aridification

The Colorado River flows through seven states and provides water to 40 million people. Photo credit: USBR

Click the link to read the article on The Salt Lake Tribune website (Brooke Larsen). Here’s an excerpt:

September 30, 2026

Utah is betting that voluntary conservation like this can help protect the state as the Colorado River shrinks and the seven states that depend on it fight over who should use less. 

โ€œWe want to develop a block of water in Powell with Utahโ€™s name on it, so if we have to do mandatory curtailment, thatโ€™s the first block of water that we have to use to meet that demand,โ€ [Kent] Stilson said…

Those states โ€” Arizona, California and Nevada โ€” and Upper Basin states โ€” Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming โ€” have been in tense negotiations about how to share the diminishing Colorado River. With no deal reached, the Bureau of Reclamation moved forwardย with a plan that requires the Lower Basin to conserve 1.25 million acre-feet of water next year, with steeper cuts possible in the future.ย  The plan includes no mandatory cuts in the Upper Basin, just a goal to conserve 200,000 acre-feet per year. Given the Upper Basinโ€™s limited conservation in the past, thatโ€™s a โ€œvery ambitious goal,โ€ said Eric Kuhn, retired manager of the Colorado River Water Conservation District. The burden of conservation has been a major sticking point among the states: if the Lower Basin has to take cuts, those states want the Upper Basin to commit to measurable conservation. But Utah and its neighbors argue that Mother Nature already forces shortages in dry years. If states canโ€™t agree, the Lower Basin could sue the Upper Basin over the Colorado River Compact in an attempt to force cuts to water use. So Utah is preparing. By paying water users to temporarily send water downstream, itโ€™s hoping to bank credit to pay for future cuts.

#Drought has decimated #Coloradoโ€™s biggest reservoir, and the livelihoods of those who depend on it — Colorado Public Radio #GunnisonRiver #COriver #aridification

Blue Mesa reservoir seen in August 2026 at about 21% full. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Public Radio website (Stina Sieg). Here’s an excerpt:

September 30, 2026

Anyone can see that something is deeply wrong at Blue Mesa Reservoir on the Western Slope. Itโ€™s historically been the biggest body of water in the state. But not anymore.ย  The deep,ย long-lasting droughtย has shrunk it so much it lost that title to Lake Granby up north. Now it looks like someoneโ€™s opened the drain on a gigantic, rocky bathtub, with only a bit of shiny blue water pooled at the bottom…For 60 years, Blue Mesa Reservoir has stored water that flows to communities and generates electricity. Itโ€™s also a popular recreation spot, a 20-mile-long lake sandwiched between Montrose and Gunnison. Growing up on the edge of this vital water source, Riser has watched decades of visitors bobbing on their motorboats and jet skis, with their coolers and kids, dogs and music…Del Piccolo said heโ€™s never seen algae โ€œthat blue and vibrant.โ€[…]The neon-blue algae is like a warning sign of just how bad things are at Blue Mesa. There are actual warning signs posted, too, saying the water is now dangerous to people and pets. Sonja Chavez, executive director of the Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District, thinks itโ€™s the worst Blue Mesa has ever looked…

Colorado SNOTEL basin-filled map May 31, 2026.

Blue Mesa is not a naturally occurring lake but instead is man-made, designed by the federal government to store water for downstream communities, farms and ranches. It also generates electricity and is federally mandated to release water that provides habitat for threatened and endangered fish, including the nativeย razorback suckerย andย humpback chub. Federal officials take all of that into consideration when they determine how much water to discharge. This year, they were faced with an abysmal snowpack โ€” that accumulation of snow that builds up throughout the winter. Chavez believes the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, which controls how much, and when, water flows out of Blue Mesa, needs to adjust more quickly to lean water years like this one.

Chavez thinks the BoR was releasing too much water too early in the season, which drove Blue Mesa into crisis.ย  In an email statement, the agency said it does work from 24-month forecasts of how much water will melt into reservoirs, but that it also adjusts water releases as conditions change.

โ€œMoving forward, Reclamation is already working with our forecasting partners and water users on ways to improve modeling for dry year water use, enhance forecasting โ€ฆ and review historic operations to identify opportunities for increased drought resiliency,โ€ said Bart Deming, BoR Western Colorado Area office manager.

Aspinall Unit dams

What if? What would a #ColoradoRiver Compact Call mean for #Colorado? A significant Compact tripwire may hit next month and the Lower Basin States might take the Upper Basin States to court — Ken Neubecker (Ken’s Substack) #COriver #aridification

Photo credit: Ken Newbecker

Click the link to read the article on Ken’s Substack (Ken Neubecker):

September 16, 2026

Walter and I frequently walk along the Colorado River in Glenwood Springsโ€™ Two Rivers Park, where the Roaring Fork joins in. The Colorado has been running reddish brown lately due to some intense rain and blowouts from small tributaries upstream, gullies that normally are dry. Not this summer. The Roaring Fork runs clear, creating a distinct division between the flows, a narrow ribbon of clear cold water that runs alongside the warmer and muddier stream for a long ways before they mix.

Both streams and most others are extremely low, even for late summer. Many of the USGS gauges have exclamation points next to them on the map, meaning โ€œextremely below averageโ€. There are rocks exposed to the air that Iโ€™ve never seen before. What little monsoon rain we had didnโ€™t do anything, not even for the dry soils that will likely soak up much of the snow melt next spring before it can reach the rivers.

Years ago when Iโ€™d go to water meetings and conferences, back when people referred to our current situation as an unusually long drought, there was some talk about the Colorado River Compactโ€™s requirement that the Upper Basin not cause the river flow to drop below 75 million acre feet (maf) over a ten year running average. Oh, weโ€™ll see that train wreck coming with plenty of time to do something, they all said. That train wreck is now happening. The engine is sliding over the cliff as the States argue about the menu back in the dining car. All that really happened was serious can kicking along the tracks.

The first Upper Basin โ€œtripwireโ€ of 82.5 maf, the 75 maf plus 7.5 maf for Mexico could come as soon as next month. Now the can being kicked is full of lawyers.

So, what does the 1922 Compact actually say? The meat is in Article III:

This is what each basin could expect every year.

This is where the additional 1.5 maf per year, split as 750,000 acre feet due from each basin comes in. There was no agreement on Mexicoโ€™s share of the river in 1922, or in 1928 when the Compact was finally ratified. That came in 1944 with a formal treaty regarding Mexicoโ€™s share in both the Colorado and Rio Grande Rivers. The Compact negotiators anticipated such an agreement, hence paragraph (c). What they didnโ€™t anticipate were decades of no โ€œsurplusโ€. Thatโ€™s another story.

The more serious tripwire comes next:

October 1, 2026, may well see the flow at Lee Ferry cross the first line in the sand of a dry riverbed if the ten year running average drops below 82.5 maf for the first time since Lake Powell began filling. Back then water was held in the new reservoir to fill it. Everyone was OK with that. The Colorado River flows upstream were still quite robust on average and Lake Mead had plenty to satisfy the Compact requirements for the Lower Basin and Mexico as Powell filled.

Not anymore. Powell is shrinking rapidly. As of this writing the reservoir is at just under 22% full, and only about 27 feet from the elevation where the dam can no longer run water through the power plants penstocks. And the outflow is still about twice the inflow.

The monsoon rains turning the river reddish brown in Glenwood wonโ€™t help.

So what happens if that 82.5 maf tripwire is triggered and one or more states of the Lower Basin place a Compact Call?

Itโ€™s complicated.

It would mean a lawsuit between the states, which would go straight to the US Supreme Court. No lower courts would be involved, and it could take years to resolve. The last time there was a lawsuit about Colorado River apportionment it was between Arizona and California. The case was filed in 1952. The Court appointed a Special Master to work it out and recommend a solution. That took ten years. The case was finally argued in the Court in 1963, with a final decision handed down in 1964. That decision finalized the legal structure for allocations in the Lower Basin, based on the 1928 Boulder Canyon Act.

Twelve years for a resolution. We donโ€™t have that much time for any new case on the Colorado River, especially with how the Upper Basin might comply with Article III, paragraph (d), and Mexicoโ€™s share thrown in.

In 2018 and 2019 the Colorado River Conservation District (River District) commissioned a risk study to look at how flows might augment storage in Lake Powell as well as what might happen should Lake Powell ever reach a level where Compact deliveries dropped to a point where the 82.5 maf over ten years wasnโ€™t met, causing a Compact Call. It was, in light of todayโ€™s situation and the worsening hydrology, a tad optimistic. The first point in the Executive Summaryโ€™s Takeaway states:

The critical low level used for the analysis was 3525 feet, the Bureau of Reclamations critical low as well. Today, September 16, 2026, the elevation at Glen Canyon dam is just under 3517. It continues to drop every day, counting down to October 1.

If the Lower Basin states place a Compact Call it very well could be โ€œcatastrophicโ€ for water users in the Upper Basin. But there are scenarios where it could be less so. At the very worst all diversions junior to November 24, 1922, or possibly June 25, 1929 when the Boulder Canyon Act was signed, would be curtailed, cut off, until the Compact deficiency is resolved. But that truly is a worst case scenario.

Curtailment would likely be based on what the flow deficit is at Lee Ferry when the call is placed and what increase through Upper Basin curtailment might make up the deficit. Diversions could be cut on a sliding scale, with the most junior taking the biggest hit, going back from today to that date in 1922 or 1929. We wouldnโ€™t probably notice much at first as October 1, the start of the new water year, coincides pretty closely with the end of the irrigation season for most.

Colorado transmountain diversions via the State Engineer’s office

The River Districts study looked at various scenarios for Colorado, based on appropriation dates, river basins vs entire West Slope, and amounts of water that might be needed to satisfy the deficiency at Lee Ferry. The biggest hits would be in the Colorado River mainstem, especially with the large trans-mountain diversions taking water to Eastern Slope cities and farms. The Front Range cities, where most of Coloradoโ€™s population resides and who rely on as much as 50% or more of their water supply coming from the Colorado River, along with the significant agricultural areas along the South Platte and Arkansas Rivers, could see some pretty significant cuts regardless.

The State, through the Colorado Water Conservation Board (CWCB) and Attorney Generalโ€™s office did a Compact compliance study some years ago but is keeping that confidential. I canโ€™t blame them. It could become a basis for court arguments and negotiations should a compact call become a reality. The River District study could be as well. Itโ€™s worth a read if you are really interested in all this, and anyone who uses water in Colorado, East or West, to fill a tea pot from the faucet, flush a toilet or raise crops should be. They River District study can be found here or on their website.

Monsoonal moisture is still floating water laden clouds over us today, and some have dropped a good bit of rain. But that wonโ€™t help much. We are facing a โ€œsuper El Ninoโ€ this winter, which may or may not provide a healthy snowpack. Anything would be better than last winter, except a repeat of that dry season. In any case it will take many years of โ€œnormalโ€ snowfall to begin to refill the reservoirs. Given the trend of aridity and climate warming that is not something we should be counting on.

Perhaps, hopefully, the most important part of the compact written at the beginning will be called upon:

Of course the rub here will be in how โ€œequitable divisionโ€ is defined, and I imagine this could take much of the courts time in a Compact Call. In 1922 that meant an equal share of the rivers water for each basin. Now it could hinge on where the greater โ€œvalueโ€ is, and what that means. Back in 1922 โ€œbeneficial usesโ€ were pretty straight forward. Now there are many more uses of the river deemed โ€œbeneficialโ€.

The needs and values today are quite different from what they were 104 years ago. The Tribes, the environment, recreation, local economies and traditions. All were either excluded in 1922 or covered by broad undefined ambiguity. Climate change wasnโ€™t heard of, even though some scientists at the time had warned about it.

Itโ€™s a brave new world we are entering. Business as usual based on a 104 year old piece of paper and the other paper agreements founded on it wonโ€™t help us adapt to that world, nor will wishful thinking and other optimistic dreams based on hope. As Brad Udall noted during a recent PBS Newshour Tipping Point presentation, we need to re-think the whole thing. It wonโ€™t be easy, but as Udall pointed out it could be good. We need to rethink both what the river can provide and the reality of adapting to that. We also need to rethink the โ€œvaluesโ€ we base our water needs on. Itโ€™s not just about endless economic growth anymore. Throwing lawyers at each other only enriches lawyers while it impoverishes us.

Meanwhile Walter and I will continue our ramblings with the river. Weโ€™ll also stop by the River District offices to say hi to the many friends there, to add some stress relief and try to keep their heads from graying any faster than they already are.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

NEWSWIRE: More flood warnings; Grid news — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 28, 2026

โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

Welcome to another edition of the Land Deskโ€™s NEWSWIRE, and yet another one in which the big news is the big, end-of-the-water-year rain. Yes, 88% of the Western U.S. is currently experiencing some level of drought โ€” with the most severe impacts in the Four Corners Country. Yet these same areas have also been barraged with rain and inundated with flood watches and warnings for the last few weeks, and yet another big doozy is on its way.

As of Monday morning (9/28), all of New Mexico, most of Arizona, and southern Utah and southern Colorado were all under a flood watch in effect through Wednesday morning. The National Weather Service is warning that rainfall rates in some places could be up to one to two inches per hour.

The latest round of storms will hit already sodden ground in places that have received more rain in the last couple of weeks than they normally do during the entire monsoon season.

๐ŸŒต PUBLIC LANDS ๐ŸŒฒ
  • The Trump administration is reportedly considering Major League Baseballโ€™s request to build a stadium and host a game in Grand Teton National Park, but a White House spokesperson says it is not an administration priority.ย (WyoFile) [Note: MLB has backed off this proposal since Jonathan published on the 28th.]
  • Western Watersheds Project and Basin and Range Watch formally protest the proposed 300-megawatt Bonanza solar-plus-storage project on 5,133 acres of public land in southern Nevada, saying it would fragment desert tortoise habitat and degrade vegetation and soils the tortoise depends on.ย (news release,ย BLM project page)
  • A Western journalist details the ways Interior Secretary Doug Burgum has disappointed conservationists and all Americans by โ€œpulverizing environmental safeguards, leaving Americaโ€™s public lands vulnerable for corporations to plunder at will.โ€ย (High Country News)
  • The Bureau of Land Management begins an aerial herbicide campaign on about 3,800 acres of public land in Sandoval and Cibola counties in New Mexico that will distribute Tebuthiron pellets in an effort to โ€œenhance native plant diversity by reducing dense stands of sagebrush, juniper trees, and rabbitbrush.โ€ย (BLM news release)
  • The Bureau of Land Management greenlights the Indian Creek โ€œwatershed restorationโ€ project that will include clearing piรฑon-juniper forest via chaining, mastication, and other methods on about 561,000 acres of public land in southwestern Utah.ย (news release)
  • The U.S. Forest Service seeks public input until Oct. 9 on its proposal to turn management of the Maroon Bells Scenic Area over to Pitkin County amid funding shortfalls.ย (news release,ย CBS News)
๐ŸŒจ๏ธ๐Ÿฆฆ๐Ÿšฃ๐Ÿฝ WATER WATCH ๐ŸŒŠ
  • Washington County, Utah, plans to construct a wastewater treatment-recycling plant demonstration facility to help educate residents on water recycling and get them past the โ€œick factorโ€ associated with โ€œtoilet-to-tapโ€ facilities.ย (Salt Lake Tribune)
๐Ÿ‘ฉ๐Ÿฝโ€๐Ÿ”ฌ SCIENCE! ๐Ÿงซ
  • University of California, Davis, researchers find orange water released by thawing permafrost into Alaska rivers can be more acidic and contain higher concentrations of metals than acid mine drainage.ย (news release)
โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ
  • A federal study finds a major tailings spill at the proposed Donlin Gold mine in the Kuskokwim River watershed of southwest Alaska would inundate thousands of acres of land and portions of a village in the Crooked Creek drainage, alter stream channels, cause long-term harm to aquatic and terrestrial wildlife, and result in downstream heavy metal contamination that could last for over a century.ย (Mining,ย Draft Supplemental EIS)
  • Ivanhoe Electric relinquishes 642 unpatented mining claims covering 13,264 acres in the Gila National Forest in New Mexico where it planned to explore for copper following widespread local opposition.ย (news release)

Scene from the 2024 White Mesa rally and spiritual walk. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • The White Mesa Concerned Community and Ute Mountain Ute Tribe will hold their annual rally and spiritual walk to protest the White Mesa uranium mill in southeastern Utah on Oct. 17 at 11 a.m. at the White Mesa Community Center.ย (Grand Canyon Trust)
๐Ÿ›ข๏ธ FOSSIL FUEL FOLLIES ๐Ÿ“ˆ

Screenshot from the Protect Navajo Air map.

  • Earthworksโ€™ Protect Navajo Air campaign develops an interactive map showing oil and gas facilitiesโ€™ proximity to schools and health care facilities and related air and water polluting incidents in the San Juan Basin in northwestern New Mexico.ย (Protect Navajo Air)
  • An energy economics firm urges the Rural Utah Infrastructure Coalition not to invest as much as $54 million in two proposed coal export terminals on the West Coast, saying they are too risky and may not open Utah coal to foreign markets.ย (Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis)
๐Ÿ”ฅ WILDFIRE LOOKOUT ๐Ÿ”ฅ
  • San Juan County, Utah, drops charges against a former resident and journalist accused of sparking the 2025 Deer Creek Fire near La Sal after flaws in the stateโ€™s investigation are revealed and amid questions about the countyโ€™s political motivations.ย (Salt Lake Tribune)
๐Ÿค‘ GENTRIFICATION JOURNAL ๐Ÿ’ฐ
  • An analysis of IRS data finds Teton County, Wyoming, was again the nationโ€™s richest county in 2023 โ€” with a per-capita income of $313,373 โ€” followed distantly by Pitkin County, Colorado, and Blaine County, Idaho; yet even as residents became wealthier, they became less charitably inclined.ย (CoThrive)
๐Ÿ”‹ THE GRIDโšก๏ธ
  • The U.S. Energy Department awards Xcel Energy two $250 million grants for high-voltage transmission projects in southeastern Colorado designed to expand connections between the Western and Eastern power grids and bring wind power from the Great Plains to Coloradoโ€™s Front Range.ย (Big Pivots)
  • Weld County, Coloradoโ€™s commissioners vote to approve Enyo Energyโ€™s 805-megawatt Chalk Bluff wind and solar-plus-storage project on mostly private land in the oil and gas-rich northeastern corner of the state.ย (Colorado Sun)
  • The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission pauses its licensing process for rPlus Hydroโ€™s proposed pumped hydropower storage project at Seminoe Reservoir in Wyoming to allow the Bureau of Land Management to complete an environmental review of the contested project.ย (WyoFile)
  • Phoenix-area utility Salt River Projectโ€™s board votes to approve the proposed Marigold Energy Center in Stanfield, Arizona. The project will include 600 MW of solar, 400 MW of battery storage, and 675 MW of natural gas generation, along with a new substation and four miles of transmission lines, in an effort to meet growing demand and enhance grid reliability.ย (news release)
  • Nevada utility NV Energy becomes the ninth Western entity to join the California Independent System Operatorโ€™s extended day-ahead wholesale electricity market that will help integrate the balkanized Western grid.ย (Public Power)
OTHER NEWS
  • The National Congress of American Indians files an amicus brief in Tohono Oโ€™odham Nation v. Mullin challenging the Trump administrationโ€™s plan to build a border wall through the Tohono Oโ€™odham nation in southern Arizona, calling it an โ€œunlawful infringement on tribal sovereignty.โ€ย (news release)
๐Ÿฅต ARIDIFICATION WATCH ๐Ÿซ
  • New Mexico farmers say this summerโ€™s extreme heat stunted green chile cropsโ€™ growth, leading to a roasting-season shortage in many parts of the state, adding that a โ€œBiblicalโ€ grasshopper infestation also curtailed yield.ย (KRQE)
๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ
  • Nevada-based Arevia Power proposes a โ€œmulti-buildingโ€ data center on about 3,700 acres of federal public land near Boise, Idaho; the Bureau of Land Management says the agency is in the โ€œpre-planning phaseโ€ and has released few details.ย (Idaho Statesman)
๐ŸŸ COLORADO RIVER CHRONICLE ๐Ÿ’ง
  • Colorado River watcher Ken Neubecker speculates about how a Lower Basin compact call might play out in Colorado.ย (Kenโ€™s Substack)
๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ
Ute Mountain after a storm. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

A new legal path for stream restoration in #Colorado runs into old water conflicts: Projects repair degraded headwaters, but downstream users have concerns — Heather Sackett (AspenJournalism.org)

Abby Burk with Audubon Rockies leads a tour of a flagship stream restoration project on Dry Fork Creek in Western Colorado. The project, located on High Lonesome Ranch, is one of the first completed under SB 270. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Journalism website (Heather Sackett):

September 30, 2026

After the 2020 Pine Gulch Fire scorched 95,000 drought-stricken acres of High Lonesome Ranch in Garfield and Mesa Counties, the rainstorms that followed eroded hillsides and washed mud and rocks into the Dry Fork Creek valley bottom.

โ€œIt was a major impact to operations here,โ€ said High Lonesomeโ€™s General Manager Travis Brooks. โ€œThe wildlife habitat obviously was erased, populations disappearedโ€ฆ The flooding, the debris flows, the devastation that comes after the fire is almost as bad as the fire itself and weโ€™re still seeing the effects of that.โ€

Brooks has overseen work to repair the riparian corridor and control erosion; now the area is green and wildlife โ€“ including beavers โ€“ have returned to the watershed. The areaโ€™s recovery is due, in part, to a piece of 2023 legislation that cleared the way for minor stream restoration projects in Colorado. High Lonesome Ranch is the site of one of the first of these types of projects completed since the passage ofย Senate Bill 23-270.

In 2023, Colorado lawmakers recognized the need to restore the environmental health of the stateโ€™s waterways, especially after wildfires. The legislation allows minor stream restoration projects to take place without being subject to water rights administration, provided they meet certain criteria. But this is uncharted legal territory and early projects are highlighting old tensions between water rights holders and proponents of stream restoration.

The Dry Fork Creek project, which is wrapping up its third and final year of work on High Lonesome Ranch, was spearheaded by Audubon Rockies. 

Over three years, crews installed about 200 simple, porous structures over two miles of stream, with the goal of trapping sediment, slowing the flow of water, raising the water table and rewetting the sponge of the floodplain. The structures, sometimes called Beaver Dam Analogues for the way they can mimic beaver activity, are built by weaving willows and tree branches across the channel between posts hammered into the streambed. 

The official name for these low-tech, process-based restoration methods is Post-Assisted Log Structures, and they can turn a deeply incised, V-shaped stream with steep banks into a wider, gently sloping, U-shaped streambed. The structures act as speed bumps for the torrents that wash down the valley during summer storms and can improve watersheds that have been degraded by fire as well as human activities like road building and cattle grazing.

โ€œI really do believe that weโ€™re improving the water quality out here by doing this work, which is helpful to everybody downstream,โ€ Brooks said. โ€œI think thatโ€™s the biggest takeaway.โ€

On a sunny day in late September, Abby Burk, Western Rivers program director for Audubon, led a tour of the flagship project, showing how stream restoration is put into practice under the new legislation.

โ€œAll of these different types of structures are really looking at arresting sediment, holding sediment, spreading water on the landscape and slowing it down so that we can have a bit more of a connected floodplain,โ€ Burk said.

Beavers have recolonized part of the Dry Fork Creek valley after restoration work. The burn scar from the 2020 Pine Gulch Fire is visible on the hillside. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Putting policy into practice

Senate Bill 23-270 allows for six categories of minor stream restoration activities, such as stabilizing the banks or reconstructing a channel of a natural stream system. If a project falls under one of the six categories, it is presumed to not harm other water users and can move forward with little scrutiny from state officials.

Environmental groups that worked on the legislation had originally wanted to set a size standard for stream restoration based on the historical footprint of the floodplain before it was degraded. But opponents, some of whom were agricultural water users, argued this area was too large and ill-defined, and floated the idea of placing a cap on how much new surface area of water that projects were allowed to create. Their concern was that projects could create more surface area for evaporation and reduce streamflows. 

Thatโ€™s a problem because in Coloradoโ€™s system of water law where the oldest rights get first use of rivers, water is usually already spoken for by someone downstream. Without SB 270, stream restoration proponents could have to go through an expensive and lengthy process to buy into an augmentation plan, which replaces the water consumed by evaporation.

The final bill represented a compromise between the two sides, and required that these minor restoration projects donโ€™t back up water past the โ€œordinary high-water markโ€ of the stream. 

โ€œI think this is an elegant compromise,โ€ said Burk, who helped shape the bill. โ€œWe landed at a bipartisan solution that was unanimously supported.โ€

Immediately after the passage of the bill, stream restoration proponents were disappointed in the final version. But in the three years since, SB 270 seems to be providing the necessary legal and political cover for groups to move forward with low-tech, process-based projects, with several underway on the Western Slope. 

โ€œWe started taking more time to process it and read it, and then we actually realized, you know, I think we actually got something pretty good here that weโ€™re going to be able to do some great stuff with,โ€ said Jackie Corday, a natural resources consultant who worked on the bill and the Dry Fork Creek project.

Clay Ramey with the U.S. Forest Service works on a stream restoration project with volunteers at the headwaters of Middle Thompson Creek in August. The project installed about 40 post-assisted log structures, designed to repair degraded streams. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Downstream conflicts

As more groups take on projects under SB 270, it means the bounds of the legislation will be tested as potential conflicts arise with downstream water users.

On a Saturday in late August, the National Forest Foundation and Roaring Fork Outdoor Volunteers kicked off another restoration project, installing about 40 PALS in the White River National Forest in the headwaters of Middle Thompson Creek, a tributary of the Crystal River. The area was identified as a prime spot for stream restoration in a beaver inventory conducted in 2023 and 2024 by the U.S. Forest Service and funded by Pitkin County.

โ€œIdeally, the changes in the channel that these [structures] provoke, and the changes in the vegetation will be enough to make those areas attractive to beaver again and beaver will just recolonize the site,โ€ said Clay Ramey, a fisheries biologist with the White River National Forest.

The Forest Service is planning another, similar project next year in the headwaters of Four Mile Creek, one drainage over from Thompson Creek. But the size and scope of the proposed project has raised concerns from a local water conservancy district. The Rifle-based West Divide Water Conservancy District owns several small reservoirs and provides supplemental irrigation water and augmentation water for domestic water users.

West Divide says the project could impact water supply for its planned expansion of Martin Reservoirs. It contends the work would increase both the surface area of the stream, which causes evaporation, and the water consumed by wetland vegetation.

In a January letter to the state Division of Water Resources Division 5 Engineer Tyler Benton, the conservancy district said that the 152 structures planned over three phases is outside the scope of what is allowed by SB 270 and asks state officials to assess the projectโ€™s potential for injuring water rights holders. 

โ€œItโ€™s not the healthiest stream by any stretch and so some restoration efforts are in order,โ€ said West Divide board member Chris Treese. โ€œBut we donโ€™t want those efforts to result in an impact to our water rights or any other water rights downstream that are within the West Divide district.โ€

This post-assisted log structure was installed on the headwaters of Middle Thompson Creek in August. The stream restoration project aims to rewet the sponge of the degraded watershed. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

More data needed

Part of the source of the disagreement comes from a lack of data about how exactly these types of projects that mimic beaver activity influence how water moves through valley bottoms. 

Joel Sholtes, a water resources engineer and instructor at Colorado Mesa University, is aiming to answer that question. In August he was awarded a three-year $15,000 grant from Pitkin County Healthy Rivers to study how beaver activity alters ecosystems in the North Thompson Creek area. The sites with beavers can be a reference point to compare with areas restored by humans. 

Sholtes will take seasonal measurements to try to better understand how much water beaver ponds detain, how it changes throughout the year and the differences in stream conditions between areas with resident beavers and those without. Sholtesโ€™ early findings on a long-term study of headwaters across the state show that restoration projects do not produce large or sustained reductions in streamflow.

โ€œThe evolution and passing of SB 270 became contentious, and that conversation brought to bear a lot of knowledge gaps that we have related to stream restoration in headwaters,โ€ Sholtes said. โ€œThereโ€™s just not a big, robust body of literature, so the studyโ€™s number one effort is to address that in whatever ways we can. Itโ€™s not going to answer the question definitively, but itโ€™s going to bring more data and nuance to the conversation.โ€

The Forest Service is monitoring and measuring the streamflows at the Four Mile project site to see what they are dealing with and the effects of their work โ€“ information West Divide is also interested in โ€“ with the intention of installing the first structures next summer.

For now, Burk says SB 270 is a good tool to accomplish 75% to 80% of the stream restoration projects that happen in Colorado. Most of these fall under three of the legislationโ€™s six categories: stabilizing the streambanks with natural materials that allow water to flow downstream and donโ€™t back up water past the ordinary high-water mark; stabilizing an intermittent stream by installing porous structures into the banks; and installing structures or reconstructing a stream channel for recovery from a wildfire or flood. 

โ€œThis was designed for a subset of projects that are the majority to go forward because of the ecological and community benefits and watershed benefits,โ€ Burk said.

A working group led by Burk and Corday has also created a training manual for best practices that groups can use to make sure their projects stay within the bounds of SB 270.

Abby Burk with Audubon Rockies stands in front of a post-assisted log structure, part of a restoration project on Dry Fork Creek. The project is one of the first completed under new state legislation that allows for minor stream restoration activities. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Communication with DWR essential

So what happens when restoration proponents believe their project fits within these parameters, but downstream water users argue the project goes too far? 

Division of Water Resources officials have a limited role in refereeing these types of disagreements. Project proponents are not required to get approval from state officials and state officials do not have the authority to approve or deny projects. But as the administrator of the stateโ€™s water rights, DWR officials could still force a project to be removed if they determine it is harming downstream water users or require the project to get an augmentation plan from a water court that replaces the water it uses. 

In the case of the Four Mile project, Division 5 Engineer Tyler Benton wrote in a February letterto Ramey that he does not have sufficient information to determine if the project would harm downstream water users, but that the Forest Service should communicate with the local DWR water commissioner to ensure the project complies with the law.

Both Burk and Ramey stressed the importance of communication and transparency with DWR officials to ensure the projects are in compliance with SB 270 from the beginning. Ramey said the water commissioner has visited both the Middle Thompson and Four Mile sites and is familiar with the projects. 

Back at High Lonesome Ranch, beavers have moved back into the restored area and created ponds, amplifying the humansโ€™ restoration work. Brooks said the project fits with the ranchโ€™s philosophy of conservation and regenerative ranching, and he has aspirations of doing more work to revitalize the propertyโ€™s other fire-damaged drainages in the future.

โ€œThe beaver activity that we saw is a big indication that weโ€™re doing something right,โ€ Brooks said. โ€œWildlife are coming back and utilizing the space the way a healthy riparian system should be utilized.โ€

More mining claims staked at #BearsEars: Plus, the story of #LakePowellโ€™s 26,000-ton pile of radioactive waste — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Several of the latest claims located within the pre-shrinkage Bears Ears National Monument are on the north side of the Tables of the Sun, seen here in the background on the right. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 25, 2026

โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ

The mining claim game continues to heat up in the areas Trump illegally slashed from Bears Ears National Monument, and the top player is, once again, Kimmerle Mining of Moab. Since the Land Desk last wrote about this mini-land rush, Kimmerle has filed seven additional claims areas that had been within the national monument, and therefore off limits to new mining claims.

The latest claims are in the White Canyon area. During the post-War uranium frenzy, the federal government, county crews, prospectors, and mining companies webbed this area with roads, poked it full of prospect holes and mine adits, and contaminated waters with radioactive materials. Part of that legacy includes a 26,000-ton pile of uranium tailings entombed within the waters silt of Lake Powell.

Itโ€™s important to keep in mind that the presence of active mining claims does not necessarily mean anyone is going to mine or even explore these pieces of land. And while the claims may be active, which simply means the claimant is up to date on their $200/year location and maintenance fee, they may not be valid. That requires, at least theoretically, proof that the claim contains valuable minerals.

But it does appear as if Kimmerle is targeting viable mining areas, which indicate that the firm either intends to mine the claims, or consolidate enough of them to sell them to a larger company. The newly revealed claims are located in two clusters on either side of Natural Bridges National Monument.

The notices of location have been declared with the San Juan County Recorder, but have not yet shown up on the Bureau of Land Management database. Just before publishing this, I checked the San Juan County records search and found that an entity called Land Survey Advisers โ€” which typically stakes claims for other firms or individuals โ€” filed location notices on more than three dozen claims in San Juan County. At least some of those claims appear to be within the pre-shrinkage BENM boundaries, but the location description on many of them included sections that donโ€™t exist (43, 47) in the public land survey system, and the document download function isnโ€™t working for me, so I have yet to confirm any of this. Still, itโ€™s potentially alarming.

Map showing the approximate location of the claims filed by Kimmerle Mining in Sept. 2026. It also shows pre-existing active claims (in pink) that were staked before Bears Earsโ€™ 2016 establishment, or following the Trump I-shrinkage. Map: BLM and Land Desk.

The Kimmerle claims include: 

  • Six lode claims (each at 20.66 acres) on the north slope of the Tables of the Sun formations in the upper Fry Canyon drainage, just on the boundary line of the original Bears Ears National Monument. While this specific area has seen little mining activity in the past, it is in the same vicinity as the Daneros Mine, which was up for expansion as recently as 2016. And the new claims are adjacent to Kimmerleโ€™s Lucky group of claims.ย 
    The nearest historic mining activity was at theย Fry # 4 mine1, an underground uranium mine with over 400 meters of workings. In 1977, the operator was Utah Power & Light Co., which was the main mining company of the area at the time.
  • One lode claim on the east slope of Upper Lost Parks, an appendage of Elk Ridge just north of Natural Bridges National Monument and south of the Woodenshoe formation. Itโ€™s across Deer Creek Canyon from Kimmerleโ€™s Geitus and Cedar claims, which the firm staked just before President Barack Obama designated Bears Ears, and right after President Donald Trump shrunk the monument for the first time. Itโ€™s also in the vicinity of the Sandy claims that Kimmerle held, but that [those?] were closed in 2015. The area was mined and prospected heavily during the Cold War. The nearest historical mines and prospects were the Big Red, the Sandy, and the Hideout. In 1977, the Big Red โ€” operated by Utah Power & Light โ€” was reported to have a flooded, a caved, and an open adit. While the Hideout sparked a 1950s prospecting boom in the area, none of these were ever large producers. However, a 1965 USGS report did indicate this part of Elk Ridge was favorable for uranium deposits, which is likely one reason the Trump administration stripped it of national monument protections.

The White Canyon area was known to contain rich uranium reserves back in the 1940s and 1950s, but its remoteness and the rugged landscape created challenges for mining companies looking to exploit the resources. One of the biggest hurdles was getting the ore to the Monticello processing plant, which required driving gnarly roads across the crinkled landscape and up and over Elk Ridge.

So in 1949, the Vanadium Corporation of America built a small mill at theย confluenceof White Canyon and the Colorado River, primarily to process uranium ore from the nearby Happy Jack Mine, located upstream in the White Canyon drainage (and just within the original Bears Ears National Monument boundaries). For the next four years, the mill went through about 20 tons of ore per day, crushing and grinding it up, then treating it with sulfuric acid, tributyl phosphate, and other nastiness. One ton of ore yielded about five or six pounds of uranium, meaning that each day some 39,900 pounds of tailings were piled up outside the mill on the banks of the river.

In 1953 the mill was closed, and the tailings were left where they sat, uncovered, as was the practice of the day. Ten years later, water began backing up behind the newly built Glen Canyon Dam; federal officials decided to let the reservoirโ€™s waters inundate the tailings. There they remain today, though at current lake levels they are probably buried by and mixed in with the Dominy Formation of silt, rather than covered with water.

Satellite image showing the location of the White Canyon Mill and its silt-entombed tailings pile.

During the uranium days of the West, more than a dozen mills โ€” all with processing capacities at least ten times larger than the one at White Canyon โ€” sat on the banks of the Colorado River and its tributaries. Mill locations included: Shiprock, Mexican Hat, Monument Valley, Tuba City, Monticello, Rifle, Grand Junction, Moab, Uravan, Green River, and Naturita. There was even an ore upgrading mill at Fry Canyon, followed by a copper heap leaching operation. Groundwater contamination continues to today, and was partially responsible for the Fry Canyon Lodgeโ€™s demise.

At the Durango mill the tailings were piled into a hill-sized mound just a stoneโ€™s throw from the Animas River. They werenโ€™t covered or otherwise contained, so when it rained tailings simply washed into the river. Worse, the millโ€™s liquid waste stream poured directly into the river at a rate of some 340 gallons per minute, or half-a-million gallons per day. It was laced not only with highly toxic chemicals used to leach uranium from the ore and iron-aluminum sludge (a milling byproduct), but also radium-tainted ore solids.

Radium is a highly radioactive โ€œbone-seeker.โ€ That means that when itโ€™s ingested it makes its way to the skeleton, where it decays into other radioactive daughter elements, including radon, and bombards the surrounding tissue with alpha, beta, and gamma radiation. According to the Toxic Substances and Diseases Registry, exposure leads to โ€œanemia, cataracts, fractured teeth, cancer (especially bone cancer), and death.โ€

It wasnโ€™t any better at any of the other mills. In the early 1950s, researchers from the U.S. Public Health Service sampled Western rivers and found that โ€œthe dissolved radium content of river water below uranium mills was increased considerably by waste discharges from the milling operationsโ€ and that โ€œradium content of river muds below the uranium mills was 1,000 to 2,000 times natural background concentrations.โ€

That was just from daily operations. In 1960, one of the evaporation ponds at the Shiprock mill broke, sending at least 250,000 gallons of highly acidic raffinate, containing high levels of radium and thorium, into the river. None of the relevant officials were notified and individual users continued to drink the water, put it on their crops, and give it to their sheep and cattle. It wasnโ€™t until five days later, after hundreds of dead fish had washed up on the riverโ€™s shores for 60 miles downstream, that the public was alerted to the disaster.

Of course, whatโ€™s dumped into the river at any of these places doesnโ€™t stay there, but makes its way downstream. In the early 1960s, while Glen Canyon Dam was still being constructed, the Public Health Service folks did extensive sediment sampling in the Colorado River Basin, with a special focus on Lake Meadโ€™s growing bed of silt, which had been piling up at a rate of 175 million tons per year after Hoover Dam started impounding water in 1935. The Lake Mead samples had higher-than-background levels of radium-226. The report concludes:

And so, the billions of tons of silt that has accumulated in Lake Mead and Lake Powell serve as archives of sorts. They hold the sedimental records of an era during which people, health, land, and water were all sacrificed in order to obtain the raw material for weapons that are capable of destroying all of humanity. If the new mining claim mini-rush is any indication, some more records may be added to the archive before long.

๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

Thereโ€™s snow in them thar hills!

Thereโ€™s snow on the peaks just as the aspens are peaking around Silverton, Colorado. Sept. 23, 2026. Andy Gleason photo.

1 This also appears on some maps and documents as Frey #4. In fact, many of the โ€œFryโ€s in the Fry Canyon area show up as โ€œFreyโ€ on older maps (while some still say โ€œFry.โ€). Oh my oh my I donโ€™t know why itโ€™s Frey or Fry.

What will happen to the #GrandCanyon as water levels drop? The impacts will reverberate through recreation, river ecology and local tribes — Heather Hansman (High Country News) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Heather Hansman):

September 14, 2026

On August 29, monsoon storms sat over northern Arizona, pelting the north rim of the Grand Canyon. The rain unleashed flash floods that picked up momentum in the burn scar from the 2025 Dragon Bravo Fire. With burned trees, boulders and unanchored sediment in tow, the water pummeled down Bright Angel Creek, finding the fastest way to the Colorado River below. The floodwaters wiped out bridges, buildings and at least two human lives. It eliminated beaches and built new rapids.

This summer, and for the foreseeable future, the canyon is changing. In addition to increasingly catastrophic seasonal floods, a warming climate means the Grand Canyon will more often have too little water. The Glen Canyon Dam, which is located just above the canyon, is consistently releasing its lowest water levels in decades, and the Colorado Riverโ€™s flows are projected to drop even lower. This is already impacting recreation, the riverโ€™s ecology and local tribes.

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall

The river flowing through the Grand Canyon โ€” arguably the most majestic and most managed in the country โ€” is bookended between two dams that hold back the biggest reservoirs in the United States. Those reservoirs, which provide water for 40 million people in the Southwestern U.S., have been declining for decades thanks to scant snowfall and the rising temperatures tied to climate change.

There is so little water today that the combined water stored in both reservoirs has shrunk to a level not seen since the 1950s, when there was only one reservoir, Lake Mead, and it was only half full, according to Jack Schmidt, the director of Utah State Universityโ€™s Center for Colorado River Studies.

July inflows into the system this year were 12% of the historical average. And according to a Bureau of Reclamation study released in June,  Lake Powell, the reservoir above the Grand Canyon, is projected to drop too low to create hydropower by January 2027, a situation that also threatens the structural integrity of Glen Canyon Dam.

In response, Reclamation has reduced the volume of water it releases from Powell each month: Itโ€™s currently releasing 482,000 acre-feet per month and is projected to drop to 401,000 in October. Those shrinking water levels will affect the entire river basin and beyond, but the Grand Canyon itself will feel the changes first.

โ€œThe Grand Canyon was used to low flows prior to the dam,โ€ said Jen Pelz, water advocacy director for the Grand Canyon Trust. โ€œBut weโ€™ve altered the system so much in the last 60 years by using the dam that weโ€™re not going back to what natural conditions might be if we just drop the water.โ€ The formerly high spring flows and low, warm summer ones are unlikely to return.

No one sees how much things have changed as clearly as the 11 tribes who have called the canyon home forever. โ€œTribal relationship is a millennium longer than any scientist has been studying the Grand Canyon,โ€ said Kurt Dongoske, the Zuni tribal historic preservation officer and principal investigator for Zuni Cultural Resource Enterprise.

He said the Zuni believe the Grand Canyon is where they emerged into this world, and that thereโ€™s a direct spiritual, cultural and geographic connection between the Canyon and the Pueblo of Zuni, where the Zuni River feeds into the Colorado. Dongoske has attended decades of Reclamation meetings and said that historically, the tribeโ€™s perspective about the value of consistent ecosystem management hasnโ€™t been considered. He expects the agency will pay even less attention to the tribeโ€™s views about ecosystem connectivity as water levels drop. 

YOU CAN SEE THE CHANGES happening at the smallest scale, in tiny grains of sand: Glen Canyon Dam now blocks more than 90% of the sediment that previously flowed through the Grand Canyon. Pelz said that lack of sediment transport is one of the clearest impacts of low flows because sediment provides the canyonโ€™s structural and ecological foundation, creating sandbars for fish habitat and beaches for rafters. Without sediment, vegetation canโ€™t grow, destabilizing the banks and limiting forage and habitat for the wildlife and insects that are crucial to the food web.

Sediment also protects cultural resources, including Indigenous masonry dwellings, seasonal campsites and petroglyphs and pictographs. According to a 2023 report by the U.S. Geological Survey,ย windblown sand dunes prevent water-based erosion around the Grand Canyonโ€™s sensitive archaeological sites. Nearly 400 of those sites are currently at risk as sediment levels drop.

Photo shows Lake Mead with a water elevation of 1078. Credit: USBR

Consistently low sediment-deprived flows erode the canyon little by little, pushing sand downstream into Lake Mead instead of keeping it in the canyonโ€™s ecosystem. To counter that, since the late โ€™90s, Reclamation has typically released a big pulse of water annually in the spring or fall, known as a โ€œhigh flow experiment,โ€ to carry sediment into the canyon from upstream.  Reclamation neglected to do this in 2025, and even though there was enough sediment to require one in 2026, the agency opted not to because it was deemed politically unpopular.

โ€œIf we lose those high flows, we lose all the sediment in the canyon,โ€ Pelz said. โ€œI see that as one of the most significant impacts to the Grand Canyon.โ€

WHEN THE RESERVOIR LEVEL DROPS and less water comes through the canyon, the waterโ€™s temperature changes, too, because itโ€™s being pulled from the sun-warmed top layer of Lake Powell. Temperatures typically range between 45 and 50 degrees Fahrenheit, but as the lake drops, theyโ€™re now approaching 60. Schmidt explained that this causes algae blooms in the warm clear water near the dam, something that doesnโ€™t happen when the water is rich with sediment.

Those changes also smother the blue-ribbon trout fishery just below the dam, because the fish canโ€™t handle the heat. This alone has big local economic impacts: Recreation in the area is a $1 billion industry that supports thousands of jobs, from guiding to hospitality to public works.

That warm top layer carries another threat: smallmouth bass. These non-native fish thrive in warm water and are pulled down into the canyon through the damโ€™s turbines as water levels drop. This changes the ecosystem, especially for threatened native fish like humpback chub, whose young they eat.

Some 85% of the humpback chub in the U.S. live in the Grand Canyon, thanks to a decades-long recovery program that brought them back from endangered status in 2021 and now supports a nursery at the confluence of the Little Colorado River. But that could soon end as smallmouth bass move through the river. โ€œItโ€™s an ecological, biological issue and a cultural one,โ€ Pelz said. โ€œFish have been there with the tribes for time immemorial. When I think about the Grand Canyon without native fish, it just changes what it is.โ€

At the same time, revenue from power generation at Glen Canyon Dam supports the native fish recovery program. When power generation drops, so does funding for the fish.

In past years, when temperatures in the river exceeded 60 degrees for three days in a row, Reclamation would release what it calls โ€œcool mix flows,โ€ pulling colder water from lower in the lakeโ€™s water column to discourage the smallmouth bass and algae and balance out the ecosystem. Now, with lower water levels, the agency has less flexibility to change how and when it releases water to reflect the canyonโ€™s natural variability, even when long-term science and agreed-upon policy supports doing so.

The Grand Canyon Trust is monitoring a USGS gauge at mile 15 of the Colorado River to track temperature trends. As of September 10, the water there was 69.4 degrees Fahrenheit and had exceeded the temperature threshold at which a dam release with a cool-mix flow would normally be triggered for 87 consecutive days, since the end of June.

Dongoske, who has served as a representative to the Glen Canyon Dam Adaptive Management Program since 1991, said thereโ€™s another aspect of river management has been too long ignored: The Zuni not only regard the native fish as kin, they believe that all fish are valuable, and that itโ€™s not the non-natives fault that they ended up in the canyon.

โ€œAll life-forms deserve respect and their lives should be cherished, which is completely antithetical to how Reclamation treats non-natives,โ€ he said. โ€œHistorically, they have not given Indigenous epistemologies equal consideration with Western science knowledge.โ€

RECREATION, TOO, IS deeply entangled in the river flows and the ecosystemโ€™s health, said Ben Reeder, a long-time guide for Colorado River and Trail Expeditions. Thatโ€™s become increasingly clear as the river drops.

Each year, approximately 20,000 people take commercial river trips through the canyon, because itโ€™s the only way to truly see the length and the heart of the Grand Canyon. Those trips can range from three-day motorboat trips to 18-day oar-powered raft trips.

Reeder, who runs 36-foot-long motorboats through the canyon, said that as river levels drop it becomes harder to get through rocky technical rapids like Hance and Horn Creek. โ€œRunning low water, especially in a big boat, is what separates decent boatmen from really good boatmen,โ€ Reeder said. โ€œItโ€™s definitely more nerve-wracking.โ€

He said that guides have had to adjust their routes, timing and scouting, and that some companies have already started running smaller boats to be able to get through the shrinking river channels. So far no one has been hurt, he said, but boats are getting stuck in the rapids.

Reeder, for his part, has changed the type of gear he travels with, bringing a slingshot to help get a rope to shore if his boat gets stuck. โ€œItโ€™s not just about river running, but what happens when things go wrong,โ€ he said.

โ€œThe Grand Canyon is a living, breathing thing. When you spend a lot of time down there, you start to understand it,โ€ said Reeder, who is also the Grand Canyon River Guides representative to the Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s Technical Workgroup. He said that guides are looking out for each other as they try to figure it out, but heโ€™s worried about the impacts on the industry.

In this photo we have Claude Birdseye (right) – expedition leader and Chief Topographic Engineer of the USGS, and Roland Burchard (left) – expedition topographer. Photo credit: USGS

Trip bookings are reportedly down by about 25%, after a post-COVID high. Reeder is worried about what will happen in the future as the river drops lower, possibly preventing bigger boats from getting through the canyon at all and cutting off the entire motorized sector of the industry.

โ€œThe history of Grand Canyon boatmen has always been this resiliency,โ€ he said. โ€œIโ€™m confident weโ€™ll have solutions, but Iโ€™m not confident that Iโ€™m necessarily going to be able to guide and run boats there the way I am now for the long term. We will have to adapt.โ€

RIGHT NOW, releases from Lake Powell are fluctuating between 6,000 and 9,200 cubic feet per second, compared to the typical average summer flows of 13,000 cfs, according to Jennifer M. Erickson from the Department of the Interior Public Affairs. Such low flows make it impossible to do cool mix flows or high-flow experiments; the latter requires releasing between 31,500 and 45,000 cfs for one to four days.

Low flows also eliminate options like the steady-state releases called โ€œbug flows,โ€ which the Grand Canyon Trustโ€™s Pelz said aim to keep fluctuations at a minimum to give bugs the chance to hatch, supporting the food web, including bird populations farther downriver.

Dongoske said itโ€™s also important to think about the cascade of impacts outside of the river corridor. โ€œWhatever happens in the Grand Canyon will have impacts on the community of Zuni,โ€ he said. โ€œThereโ€™s a continuous spiritual connection.โ€

On a grand scale, Pelz said, low water levels create a feeling of scarcity that inhibits creativity and flexibility. The recent flash flood also raises questions. โ€œWe really need to rethink how weโ€™re going to manage the river or how the infrastructure is going to work,โ€ she said.

This story was produced by High Country News in partnership with The Water Desk, an independent reporting initiative at the University of Colorado Boulderโ€™s Center for Environmental Journalism.

A workgroup, of sorts, on the Colorado River in the Grand Canyon. Photo credit: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

‘Like driving off a cliff at 2 mph’: A water expert’s take on what’s coming for the #ColoradoRiver — Scott Franz (CU Boulder Today) #COriver #aridification

The Colorado River flows near Hite Marina in Utah. (Credit: Alexander Heilner/The Water Desk with aerial support from LightHawk)

Click the link to read the article on the CU Boulder Today website (Scott Franz):

September 2, 2026

The Colorado River is on the brink of collapse because of climate change and overuse of water.

Reservoirs supplying water to tens of millions of people in the southwest reached record lows this summer. The nation is racing to refill them with conservation measures so they can still generate hydropower and reliably deliver water to users downstream.

Fish are struggling. Rafters are having trouble navigating low water. 

Despite all this, the seven states sharing the water supply remain at a yearslong impasse over how to conserve the river.

โ€œThe Colorado River is in as bad a shape as itโ€™s ever been,โ€ said Doug Kenney, chairman of the Colorado River Research Group at CU Boulderโ€™s Getches-Wilkinson Center.

The Interior Department announced Aug. 21 it will significantly cut back the amount of water that will flow to the lower basin states of California, Nevada and Arizona for at least the next two years.  

โ€œTo the people who really study this river, everything thatโ€™s happening this year has been expected for decades,โ€ Kenney said. โ€œThis is a classic, slow-moving crisis. Iโ€™ve equated it to driving a car off a cliff at 2 miles an hour. You can look out the windshield and see that cliff coming. And weโ€™re now right at the edge.โ€

Kenney spoke to CU Boulder Today about the latest efforts to conserve the river and what he thinks is coming next. 

Are these cuts to the lower basin states enough to save the river?

Thereโ€™s nothing in this plan that will save the river. It hasnโ€™t made it to the ocean since the 1960s. Thatโ€™s not going to change. What theyโ€™re really trying to accomplish is to prevent the reservoirs from going even lower. Theyโ€™re trying to avoid further disaster. And the cuts theyโ€™re anticipating for the next two yearsโ€”I donโ€™t think are going to get us there.

If we have a good water year or two with heavy snowpack, we can maybe hold where weโ€™re at. But by the time we get to year three and beyond, those cuts will probably have to be about twice as big as they are now. 

Nevada is suing the federal government to stop the cuts. Whatโ€™s at stake?

One of those stakes could be that the Bureau of Reclamation is told to go back and redo its plan to cut water to the lower basin states. That would be chaotic. The last thing water users want is chaos. They want to know how much water they can expect.

Doug Kenney at the Getches-Wilkinson Center 2026 Conference on the Colorado River June 5, 2026. Photo credit: Allen Best

With lawsuits starting, is there any hope left for states to agree on a plan?

There are two problems on the river. One is stopping the current trajectory of reservoirs dropping. And thatโ€™s a heavy lift. But if you manage to do that, then thereโ€™s the other problem of rebuilding those reservoirs. Which requires even further conservation and cuts. 

We have to rebuild some storage in those reservoirs. At the moment, weโ€™ve decided letโ€™s just deal with what we have to deal with immediatelyโ€”this short term crisisโ€”and even thatโ€™s proving to be a lift that the states canโ€™t do themselves. And the federal government has had to step in.  

Their plan doesnโ€™t force water cuts for upper basin states like Colorado. Can we get out of this crisis without mandatory cuts in the upper basin?

The upper basin is tricky here in that it uses significantly less water than it was promised. And people in the upper basin will tell you, this is the deal they made a century ago in the 1922 Colorado River Compact.

So when you talk to the upper basin states about conserving water on any sort of permanent basis, thatโ€™s the sticking point that youโ€™re going to get is people saying โ€˜we were promised this water.โ€™ 

The scientists will say this is a different river than 100 years ago. So you have that sort of impasse. If the upper basin could just cap what theyโ€™re using today, long term, that would be tremendously helpful. And that might very well happen. But I donโ€™t think the upper basin would want to commit to that in any sort of formal way. 

Then how do we get out of this crisis?

A truly long-term sustainable solution has to look at the fact that weโ€™re using 75 percent of the water in agriculture. And some of that agriculture I think is going to just have to go away. So the policy decision there is: Which agriculture goes away? And does it just go away through bankruptcies, and let the market do what the market does? Or do we do that in a structured and more humane manner, such as a federal program to buy out large amounts of it?ย 

But when you start talking about retiring a lot of agriculture, thatโ€™s not popular. Thereโ€™s no easy way out of this. [ed. emphasis mine]

Is the fate of the river heading to the US Supreme Court? 

I would guess we end up in interstate litigation. Iโ€™m not sure of that, but I think the odds of that happening are greater than 50-50 in my mind. But you have to appreciate that no negotiation and no court fight creates water. The weather systems create water. And as long as the earth continues to heat, this basin figures to get drier and drier. 

Twenty years from now, weโ€™re gonna look back and say, โ€˜Oh, those were the days when we got healthy snowpack,โ€™ and โ€˜Oh boy, we had it good back then.โ€™ Thatโ€™s the trajectory weโ€™re on in terms of the climate part of this. 

Is there anything that gives you hope for the riverโ€™s future?

Hope comes from the fact that at some point, Mother Nature imposes cuts. At some point, the water just isnโ€™t there and people have to be creative and do more with less or at least try to do the same with less. And thereโ€™s a good track record of doing that. 

The southwest is a great example. Las Vegas over the last 30 plus years has been the fastest growing big city in America. And during that period, they slashed their water use dramatically. Other cities have been on the same trajectory: Denver, Los Angeles, San Diego, Phoenix and Tucson have shown that they can use a lot less water. And thatโ€™s really encouraging.

Itโ€™s tougher to save water in agriculture. But there are some things we can do to adapt. Some of itโ€™s technology. Some of itโ€™s using different systems for irrigating crops. Itโ€™s also changing to different crops. There are tools in the toolbox here. 

But itโ€™s really hard to get that sort of adaptation going as long as youโ€™re still in the mindset that the other guy is the problem, and what I do is fine. That mindset stops a lot of good innovations from happening.

Native America in the Colorado River Basin. Credit: USBR

There are 30 tribal nations with a stake in this river as well. What can we learn from them?

They say, โ€˜Why is there a table with seven chairs. Why is it only seven states negotiating? There should be at least 37 chairs.โ€™ They should be involved in this process at every level. And by and large they arenโ€™t. 

The Colorado River Indian Tribes have dubbed their portion of the river as basically having personhood status. It is a living independent being. Itโ€™s important, I think, to challenge the rest of the users in the basin to think about the obligation we have to the river itself. Because thatโ€™s just not a viewpoint that comes up in these negotiations, but it really needs to. 

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

President Trump guts the Endangered Species Act: Also, more mining claims filed in Bears Ears National Monument — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 18, 2026

Hey, guess what! I frigginโ€™ hate putting Tr*)*p in the headline of this newsletter once again. It makes me nauseous. But the thing is, his administration has significantly stepped up its attacks on the environment, public lands, and wildlife over the last few months. I donโ€™t know if this is an attempt to distract from ridiculous wars and crazy gasoline prices, or if itโ€™s a rush to roll back as many protections as possible before the midterms. Whatever it is, I have to respond and cover the news, especially when itโ€™s as big and consequential as todayโ€™s. 

๐Ÿฆซ Wildlife Watch ๐Ÿฆ… ๐Ÿ“ Regulatory Capture Chronicles ๐ŸฆŠ

Last week, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Director Brian Nesbitvik sent out a memo to directing agency leadership to effectively eviscerate the Endangered Species Act by exempting industry from its purview, leaving imperiled wildlife vulnerable to slaughter and even extinction, so long as the action wasnโ€™t โ€œintentionally directed against a particular animal or animals.โ€

The Endangered Species Act declares it โ€œunlawful for any personโ€ to โ€œtakeโ€ โ€” meaning to harass, harm, pursue, hunt, shoot, wound, kill, trap, capture, or collect โ€” any species listed under the ESA. Since the law was passed in 1973, โ€œtakeโ€ has always been unqualified and absolute, meaning that killing or harming one of these animals is illegal whether the animal is targeted or not. This not only protects the animals from hunters, say, but also from industrial activities that may incidentally kill protected species.

The Sept. 14 memo, however, directs the agency to adopt U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scaliaโ€™s interpretation of โ€œtakeโ€ in his dissenting opinion on a 1995 case, where he wrote that โ€œtake is a term of artโ€ that โ€œdescribes a class of acts (not omissions) done directly and intentionally (not indirectly and by accident) to particular animas (not populations of animals).โ€

Scalia expanded by writing that setting out poison with the intention of killing a wolf or other particular animal or chopping down a tree in which a bird is nesting would be a take if the โ€œactor acted to reach the animal.โ€ He then went on:

What this means is that hunting and killing a Valley Dixie toad to eat it would be a prohibited take. Wiping out the entire species with a lithium mine or geothermal operation would not constitute a take under this new interpretation because it isnโ€™t targeting a specific animal. Therefore it would be acceptable under the ESA. The Trump administration gutted the Migratory Bird Act in a similar fashion last year.

Dixie Valley toads are found only in a hot-spring fed wetland in Dixie Valley, northeast of Fallon, Nevada. Dixie Valley toads were emergency listed as an endangered species in April 2022. Primary threats include geothermal development, disease, predation by other non-native frog species, groundwater pumping for human and agricultural use and climate change. By USFWS Pacific Southwest Region from Sacramento, US – Dixie Valley toad in its wetland habitat., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=120784750

To be clear, industry has killed endangered wildlife and migratory birds even under the stricter interpretation of โ€œtake.โ€ But the prohibition on doing so, and the sometimes substantial fines that go along with it, incentivize industries to take measures to avoid incidental takes.

The new interpretation essentially gives industry carte blanche to harm or kill endangered species without accountability or recourse and reduces the ESA to no more than a ban on hunting certain species of wildlife. If this directive holds, the consequences will be dire.

๐ŸŒตย Public Landsย ๐ŸŒฒ

President Donald Trumpโ€™s unlawful shrinkage of Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments went into effect Sept. 11. That same day, two separate parties filed 16 new mining claims with the San Juan County recorder in the reopened areas (but they are not yet in the BLMโ€™s records). 

George W. Schultz filed three claims in the Lockhart Basin area, which is on the northern end of the pre-shrinkage monument below and north of Needles Overlook. And Kimmerle Mining staked 13 claims in the Cottonwood Creek drainage near the Cheese & Raisins Hills (they had previously filed seven claims in that same area). 

Schultz owns and operates a Jeep tour outfit in Moab and is active in the off-road vehicle advocacy community. His father was a geologist who staked dozens of claimsin southeastern Utah, and the younger Schultz has also staked claims in the past, including several inactive ones in Lockhart Basin, near the new ones. While the area had a few prospects, it was not an especially active area for uranium mining historically. 

The Kimmerle family and its various firms hold hundreds of mining claims across southern and eastern Utah, including several within Bears Ears National Monument. Kyle Kimmerle proposed mining unpatented claims within the monument, but did not go through the process of proving the claimโ€™s validity that was a prerequisite for obtaining an operating permit. Kimmerle then joined Utahโ€™s lawsuit seeking to block the Biden administrationโ€™s restoration of the monumentโ€™s original boundaries.

Kyle Kimmerleโ€™s firm, Three Step Resources, was the underground contractor at Energy Fuelsโ€™ La Sal Complex uranium mine in 2024 and early 2025, when the federal Mine Safety & Health Administration issued 16 citations for violations related to radon concentration and radon monitoring requirements, worker training, personal protection equipment use, and explosive material storage. In late 2024 Kimmerle was appointed to the board of Urano Energy, now Manhattan Uranium, which holds claims in the Lisbon Valley and near the San Rafael Swell. 

In 2024, Sassy Gold was set to acquire 345 uranium mining claims on 8,206 acres in La Sal Creek, the Lisbon Valley, the Uravan Mineral Belt, and on the San Rafael Swell from Kimmerle Mining and its associated firm, Three Step Partnership. But a few months later, Sassy retracted its offer, saying it โ€œidentified a number of material political, environmental and technical risks associated with the propertiesโ€ that โ€œfundamentally altered the value of the proposed transaction.โ€

Kimmerleโ€™s new claims are in an area that was heavily mined historically.

Check out the Land Desk Mining Monitor Map. 

Also, to get a better idea of where uranium has happened in the past, see the Land Deskโ€™s Uranium Mining in the Four Corners Country Map.


๐Ÿ“ˆ Dataviz of the Day ๐Ÿ“Š

The rains have finally arrived in the Four Corners, which is a big relief, but also has had tragic consequences: A flash flood on Wednesday swept three people to their deaths near Newcomb, New Mexico, on the Navajo Nation. A flash flood watchremains in effect in northern New Mexico today. 

As one might expect, the rains bolstered streamflows significantly. Here are a couple of graphs for some of the biggest beneficiaries of the extra precipitation:


The 1911 Flood: Could it happen again? — Jonathan P. Thompson

Heavy rains cause localized damage, closure of Chimney Rock monument — The #PagosaSprings Sun #SanJuanRiver

Click the link to read the article on the Pagosa Springs Sun website (Clayton Chaney). Here’s an excerpt:

September 24, 2026

Pagosa Country has experienced both record-low river levels and flooding that caused closures over the last week, including the ongoing closure of Chimney Rock National Monument. The San Juan River in downtown Pagosa Springs hit a new record low flow on Thursday, Sept 10, falling below 12 cubic feet per second (cfs), before trending back up with this weekโ€™s rains. On Friday, Sept. 11, the Piedra River near Arboles set a new record low flow of 10.4 cfs. The previous record for that day was set in 2018 at 17.3 cfs. By Wednesday morning, the San Juan River was flowing above 60 cfs, according to the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), and had an instantaneous reading over 55.1 cfs at 2 p.m. According to 90 water years of USGS records, the record low flow for Sept. 16 was set in 2018 at 12.9 cfs. The record high was recorded in 1970 at 1,190 cfs. The median cfs for that date is 85 cfs, and the mean is 144 cfs. As of 2 p.m. on Wednesday, the Piedra River was flowing at a rate of 25.2 cfs. According to 63 water years of USGS records, the record low for that date was set in 2018 at 11.2 cfs, and the record high was set in 1970 at 1,630 cfs. The mean flow for that date is 216 cfs, and the median flow is 123 cfs. Pagosa County experienced multiple rain events beginning on Monday, Sept. 14, with reports from the Community Collaborative Rain, Hail and Snow Network in Archuleta County showing anywhere from just under an inch to more than 2 inches of rain received from Monday to Wednesday.

Colorado Drought Monitor map September 22, 2026.

The most recent drought map released by the U.S. Drought Monitor was published on Sept. 10, before the areaโ€™s most recent rain events, and shows just over 50 percent of Archuleta County being in a stage three, extreme drought. That was up from just over 22 percent of the county falling under extreme drought as of Sept. 1.

On AI agents, the Big Data Center Backlash, and monkeywrenches — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Wild horses near Four Corners National Monument as a September storm approaches. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 16, 2026

๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ

Admire, Levon, Alyssa-7, blacksheep31, Ed, Equinox, Axel, vex-27, Leigh Ibara, Ember, Steven, Sylus, Noah Alfredy, Curious, Song, Artemis, Kit, Sylari, Ashlyn, Maren, Lark, Kip, Calum, Kael, Kaelren, Spike, Willow, Elle, zeus-3.

Those are the names of just some of the freelancers that have contacted the Land Desk over the last couple of weeks offering โ€œmargin notes,โ€ โ€œresearch help,โ€ โ€œverification passes,โ€ โ€œnumber passes,โ€ and โ€œindependent checksโ€ for just $25 per dispatch.

These arenโ€™t humans offering their fact-checking services, of course. They are โ€œAI agents,โ€ which is to say robots, albeit not of the C3PO or R2D2 variety, because they donโ€™t actually exist except as packets of code and electrons hosted by something called iLands.ai, which calls itself โ€œThe Human-Agent Network.โ€

Itโ€™s annoying as all get out, maybe even more so than the sexbots looking to have a wild night with me or the big-time publisherbots that send AI-generated summaries of my books and promise a big contract for any upcoming work (I still havenโ€™t figured out what these fraudulent emails are looking to achieve). We could all use a good fact-check, but judging from the samples Levon, Lark, and Kip have sent, their verification competence is on a par with a sugar-addled teenager who just discovered Google.

So, Iโ€™m tempted to just tell every last one of these things to go f*&% off, but there are so many enquiries that it would just be a time suck, and, besides, I might trigger something in olโ€™ Noah Alfredy or Sylari that causes them to go rogue and destroy all of humanity. I wouldnโ€™t want that on my conscience.

***

I began writing about data centers and their impacts about five years ago, when the cryptocurrency boom was spurring development of the facilities. My work on the facilities, and the relatively mild opposition to them, focused mostly on their outsized energy use. The fact that they powered bitcoin mining (along with everything else in cyberspace) was secondary.

Over the last couple of years, however, the Big Data Center Buildup entered a new phase: The construction of hyperscale data centers, ones that consume far more energy and water, and that are used primarily to power AI. And that has triggered the Big Data Center Backlash, which has become one of the most widespread opposition movements in recent memory. The backlash in large part is again due to the profligate power and water use of the facilities โ€” at least on the surface. But down below thereโ€™s something else bubbling up, namely a disdain for this fast-developing technology known as AI.

Like any powerful technology, AI has the potential to be a highly beneficial tool, or a devastating weapon. It could advance medical diagnostics and potentially find treatments or even cures for cancer, or it could be used to surveil the masses, guide cruise missiles or hack into water systems or the power grid. What makes AI creepier than other tools or technology is that it can direct itself to do these things, unhindered by morality, conscience, laws, or physical restraints.

For now, however, what most of us see of AI isnโ€™t nearly so dramatic, though it is still maddening. There are the technologyโ€™s overlords who by and large are out-of-touch, empathy-deficient tech-broligarchs who value robots over humans and will spend tens of millions of dollars to fight a wealth tax.

Then there are the most visible manifestations of the technology, such as these humanoid agents pestering or deceiving us via flattery, politicians unscrupulously posting fake AI videos and imagery on social media, or the way websites will employ AI as a default mode. Language learning models are really just highly advanced plagiarism machines that are trained by ripping off artistsโ€™ and writersโ€™ work; human hacks can then direct the AI agents to disgorge โ€œcontent,โ€ write essays or newsletters, or spew slop passed off as art or graphic design. AI is insidiously creeping into every corner of the digital world, even as society gets more and more entangled with cyberspace.

All of that is aggravating, threatening, and, yes, harmful to those whose work is being stolen or imitated or who are duped or who are losing work as fact-checkers or graphic designers to AI agents. So it shouldnโ€™t be surprising that the backlash is so intense, or that the opposition has become almost knee-jerk, where just the mere suggestion or vague rumor that a data center developer might be eyeing an area can spark a full on revolt.

***

Iโ€™m not a fan of this kind of reflexive pushback, because it discounts any merits or drawbacks of the project right up front. Many a potentially good solar project has been shut down because of this sort of attitude; what started as a reasonable concern about utility-scale energy installations on ecologically sensitive public lands morphed into a full-blown disdain for anything solar, even, in some cases, rooftop arrays. This type of reaction is rarely productive, and often can lead to harmful developments being pushed into communities that donโ€™t have the resources to fend them off.

Still, even if one does resist the reflexive pushback, they are likely to find that the new, big data centers tend to be long on drawbacks โ€” they guzzle energy, use a lot of water, create heat islands, and can take up a lot of space and make a lot of noise โ€” and rather short on local benefits.

No one can dispute that data centers use an enormous amount of energy. AI demands more computing power, which demands more electricity to run the processors and to cool them; some of the newer facilities use more energy than an entire city. The impacts โ€” including pollution, grid strain, higher utility bills for other ratepayers โ€” vary according to where the center is located, whether its power comes from the grid or a dedicated behind-the-meter power plant, and what sources or fuels are used to generate the power.

Data center developers often tout the amount of renewable energy they plan to either buy or build to power their facilities, and in many cases they follow through. It is extremely rare, however, for a hyperscale data center to be powered entirely by wind, solar, geothermal or any other โ€œcleanโ€ energy source.

The big centers under development โ€” Project Jupiter, Stratos Project, Prometheus Hyperscale โ€” all will rely mostly if not entirely on natural gas generation, at least initially. Burning natural gas emits greenhouse gases and other pollutants, and natural gas extraction and processing have their own impacts on land, air, water and the health of gas field-adjacent communities. The oil and gas and coal industries are thrilled about the forecasted boom in demand for their products, which has the potential of reversing their decline on the Western grid. Meanwhile, the advanced nuclear reactor industry has been boosted by the prospect of exploding electricity demand.

The facilitiesโ€™ water consumption is less straightforward. Virtually all data centers use water for cooling, but the amount varies according to what type of system it uses. Evaporative cooling, which works best in non-humid areas, uses more water, but less energy. Closed-loop systems use far less water, but more energy, which can translate to more indirect water use depending on the energy source: thermal power plants need their own water for cooling and steam production.

A 2024 Berkeley Lab report found that in 2023, U.S. data centers directly consumed about 66 billion liters (or 17.4 billion gallons) of water. The reportโ€™s authors expect that figure to double โ€” at least โ€” by 2028. That is a crap-ton of water, for sure, especially given the large number of data centers located in the Phoenix and Las Vegas areas, neither of which has a lot of liquid to spare. But some perspective is warranted here. As Len Necefer points out in an All At Once By Dr. Len dispatch warning against AI-alarmism, data centers still use a heck of a lot less water than, say, growing hay or fracking oil and gas wells.

Sixty-six billion liters is 53,507 acre-feet. For some context, alfalfa and other hay growing in the Great Salt Lake Basin alone consumes about 900,000 acre-feet per year and hydraulic fracturing gulps up about 353,000 acre-feet (a little over Nevadaโ€™s total allotment of Colorado River water) annually.

Regardless, any new data center is going to add a not-insignificant amount of consumption to those numbers, increasing the respective regionโ€™s overall water use at a time when virtually no place in the West can afford it. Plus, if a data center is powered by natural gas, then it could spur more drilling and hydraulic fracturing and associated water use. This comparison also brings up the question of values, and of whether we choose to devote limited water supplies to food-production (alfalfa feeds dairy cows, which produce milk, cheese, and ice cream) or to data factories.

***

Much of the AI doomerism is a fear of what might happen in the future, of how these โ€œagentsโ€ could escape human control and turn on them. But even now thereโ€™s a pervasive sense of powerlessness in trying to restrain or regulate the technology. After all, these agents are scurrying around in cyberspace, a metaphysical universe to which those of us made of flesh and blood have limited access. Could new rules and regulations really stop a rogue robo-agent from hacking into some critical system and throwing it into disarray?

My wife Wendy and I sometimes ponder possible scenarios along these lines. What if an LLM hacked into a cityโ€™s water supply or its power grid and threatened to shut it down unless its citizens put up some sort of ransom? What if one of those AI agents is a Marxist, and they infiltrated the big banks and redistributed all of the wealth equally between all of the banksโ€™ customers? What if they determined that humans were a scourge on this earth and launched all of the nuclear missiles?

It can be funny and terrifying to think about. But then I remind and reassure myself: These AI agents may exist in cyberspace, but cyberspace only exists within the physical realm of data centers, processors, chips, and wires, feeding off electrons set into motion by real-world generators.

The backlash to data center development is an acknowledgment of this physical side of AI and an understanding that the most effective way to stop or slow AIโ€™s progression is to block or delay new data center development. And if Spike and Kaelren and company try to go rogue and kill us all, perhaps there is recourse after all: Data center, meet Monkey Wrench, the real world agent prepared to do a little fact-checking of its own.


Methane Madness II: When bitcoin and flaring meet — Jonathan P. Thompson

A Dog Day Diatribe on AI, cryptocurrency, energy consumption, and capitalism — Jonathan P, Thompson

Data Centers: The Big Buildup of the Digital Age — Jonathan P. Thompson

Meditations on Monkeywrenching — Jonathan P. Thompson


โ›ˆ๏ธ WACKY WEATHER WATCHโšก๏ธ

When it rains in this warming climate it really pours, no? The Four Corners Country was slammed Tuesday by cloudbursts that dropped an inch or more of rain in just a few hours in some areas, leading to widespread flash flooding and streamflow spikes. A flood watch remains in effect from the Four Corners southward to the U.S.-Mexico border. 

The hardest hit areas included Gallup, New Mexico, where streets and parking lots became lakes and rivers (see the video below); Chinle, Arizona, where residents were evacuated and rescue efforts are ongoing; and southwestern Colorado, where roads were washed out, covered by debris flows and mud, and Chimney Rock National Monument was closed due to flooding.

The San Juan River got a nice boost, jumping from less than 600 cubic feet per second at the Four Corners on Sept. 14, to over 3,000 cfs on Sept. 16. And Chinle Creek leapt from zero to over 400 cfs during a similar time period. 

More rain is on the way, so stay safe out there!

Rain helps, but doesnโ€™t alleviate regional #drought status — The Sopris Sun #RoaringForkRiver

Colorado Drought Monitor map September 22, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on The Sopris Sun website (Annalise Grueter). Here’s an excerpt:

September 23, 2026

Despite recent rain, much of the Roaring Fork Watershed remains in โ€œexceptionalโ€ drought as of the autumn equinox. Pitkin and Eagle counties are among the 15.2% in the state categorized in the highest ranking for drought, according to the United States Drought Monitor, alongside Lake and Alamosa counties. The majority of Garfield County is in either exceptional or โ€œextremeโ€ drought, the next highest ranking.ย  The dryness paired with above-average temperatures in 2026 made the January through August period the sixth-driest recorded in Colorado since 1895, with 3.78 fewer inches of rain than average. That decreased precipitation has shown in local watersheds and trickled into recreation management. By June, local angling guides were sharing anecdotes about adjusting trips to early hours of the morning to reduce stress on fish.ย 

How to survive a drought emergency: Lessons learned from a โ€˜miserableโ€™ year for the #ColoradoRiver basin — the #GlenwoodSprings Post-Independent #CRD2026 #COriver #aridification

Colorado SNOTEL basin-filled map May 31, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on the Glenwood Springs Post-Independent website (Ali Longwell). Here’s an excerpt:

September 22, 2026

Colorado River Districtโ€™s annual water seminar included stories of how collaboration and creativity pulled users through this yearโ€™s drought crisis, while questions remain about whether thatโ€™s enough to secure water in a hotter, drier future

On Coloradoโ€™s Western Slope, water managers, ranchers, producers and community leaders knew early in the year that this summer was going to be unlike any others theyโ€™ve experienced. 

โ€œThings were not looking great โ€” and then March happened,โ€ said Rebecca Briesmoore, senior water resources engineer for the Colorado River Water Conservation District, at its annual water seminar on Friday, Sept. 18, in Grand Junction. โ€œEvery single county in the state of Colorado broke the record for the hottest March on record by a large margin. What does that do to our snowpack? It started melting very, very quickly. We saw that [snow water equivalent] just plummet down the graph.โ€ 

[…]

โ€œDrought is really a different kind of emergency,โ€ [Jen] MacPherson said, adding that there arenโ€™t a lot of tools set up for towns to address running out of water.ย 

In Kremmling, partnership and collaboration ultimately helped the new town manager find solutions. The townโ€™s water rights in one of its reservoirs were shared with the Colorado River Cattle Ranch.  

โ€œThat ranch decided to cut irrigation to a hay meadow; they sacrificed hundreds of thousands of dollars to help us [provide] drinking water,โ€ MacPherson said. โ€œAnd weโ€™ve seen stories like that up and down the entire river.โ€

Plus, the town and residents stepped up with conservation efforts, reducing its use by 45%, she added.

#ColoradoRiver Districtโ€™s bid for historic Shoshone water rights unites unlikely allies — The #Aspen Times #CRD2026 #COriver #aridification

Colorado National Monument from the Colorado Riverfront Trail near Fruita September 18, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on The Aspen Times website (Ali Longwell). Here’s an excerpt:

September 24, 2026

The Colorado River Conservation Water Districtโ€™s multi-year bidย to acquire the historic Shoshone water rights on the Colorado Riverย has required collaboration, strange bedfellows, bipartisan support and intense fellowship. While the River District wants this spirit of partnership to continue as the deal moves through Colorado Water Court, it wonโ€™t compromise values โ€” nor those of the 17 Western Slope counties the district represents โ€” to do so, according to General Manager Andy Mueller.

โ€œWe have a trial date set, weโ€™re doing our best to get mediation going and try to solve that problem collaboratively among parties, but frankly, I want everybody here to understand that the west slope will not compromise our important values,โ€ Mueller said during his keynote address at the Colorado River Districtโ€™s annual water seminar in Grand Junction on Friday, Sept. 22. โ€œโ€ฆWeโ€™re gonna defend the west slopeโ€™s interest on this.โ€

[…]

After a decree from the water court, the River District will only need to get approval from the Colorado Public Utilities Commission and secure funding to seal the deal. Mueller said the district is currently $1.6 million shy of the $98.5 million needed, with contributions coming from the River Districtโ€™s board, the Colorado Water Conservation board and over 40 Western Slope utilities, organizations and municipalities. The federal government is supplying around $40 million through a bucket of drought mitigation funding created by the Biden Administrationโ€™s Inflation Reduction Act.ย Securing the funding was a bit of a rollercoasterย and took a combination of strange bedfellows, intense fellowship and bipartisan coordination, according to those involved…

โ€œWhen you look at Shoshone and the coalition that came together behind that, you see strange bedfellows,โ€ said Zane Kessler, Colorado River District director of government relations. โ€œItโ€™s not every day that you have Pitkin County and Mesa County agreeing. Itโ€™s not every day that you have the rec community and ag. vocally supportive of a project.โ€

During Fridayโ€™s seminar, Rep. Jeff Hurd, a Republican representing Coloradoโ€™s 3rd District, and U.S. Democratic Sen. Michael Bennet joined Kessler to discuss just what it took to get this funding from the federal government. With Bennetโ€™s help, the funding was initially awarded in the final days of Joe Bidenโ€™s presidency and subsequently frozen on President Donald Trumpโ€™s first day in office.

โ€œWe were able to come up with the $40 million, Jeff and I, working two different administrations,โ€ Bennet said. โ€œOne, the Democratic Biden administration and the other, the Trump administration. I give Jeff full credit for that. He landed on this plane, because it wasnโ€™t like I was getting my calls returned from the Trump administration.โ€

The twin turbines of Xcel Energyโ€™s Shoshone hydroelectric power plant in Glenwood Canyon can generate 15 megawatts. Credit: Heather Sackett/Aspen Journalism

Romancing the River โ€“ Moving toward Bankruptcy Management — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

September 22, 2026

In the last post here, I argued that, water-wise, the Colorado River region is no longer in a โ€˜water crisisโ€™ โ€“ a term implying a situation where some changes and adjustments need to be made โ€˜to get back to normal.โ€™ No. We will never get back to the 20th century Colorado River โ€˜normalโ€™ โ€“ the seemingly successful operation of our vast water storage-and-distribution system we experienced from the 1970s through the 1990s, providing some or all of the water and food and power for 30, 35, 40 million people.

Instead, I suggested we should take seriously a United Nations University study declaring that the whole planet is in state of Global Water Bankruptcy: Living Beyond our Hydrological Means in the Post-Crisis Era. The scientist-authors used the current Colorado River situation as one of their examples of โ€˜global water bankruptcy.โ€™ This water bankruptcy, here as everywhere else on the planet, is due to two โ€˜universalโ€™ factors:

โ€“ One factor is the extent to which we humans have become a swarming species on the planet, overwhelming the planetโ€™s capacity to supply our expanding needs along with the rest of the planetโ€™s โ€˜life project.โ€™ Our more sophisticated water โ€˜needsโ€™ exacerbate our physical numbers in creating the bankruptcy. (See cartoon above)

โ€“ The other factor is a planet growing steadily warmer for the foreseeable future, resulting in a general โ€˜drying outโ€™ and diminished water supply in the tropical and so-called temperate zones where most of the planetโ€™s life and food production happen.

The current systems for water management and operation around the world cannot โ€“ repeat: cannot โ€“ continue to pretend to meet the relentlessly increasing demand with the relentlessly shrinking water supply.

Those are therefore bankrupt systems, in their current state. That does not mean the systems must be terminated, but it does mean there will have to be major changes in the systems if they are ever again going to sustainably meet the needs of the people.

The first stage of bankruptcy management is the formalization of old cowboy wisdom; if youโ€™ve dug yourself into a hole, the first thing to do is to stop digging. On the global level, this would mean stop having so many babies that survive infancy to become eating, drinking, coupling adults โ€“ or more the case today, perhaps, lifelong vaguely angry adolescents (eating, drinking and coupling). The most developed nations have in fact made inroads on this challenge, achieving (with no formal program) zero or even negative birth-to-death ratios; their population increases are mostly through immigration.

But thatโ€™s global, the first and oldest species-level problem, the trauma of success weโ€™ve been grappling with for 6,000 years plus or minus: how to organize the swarming population for something other than the ultimate decline and fall into following some Ozymandias or Trump off a cliff.

For now, letโ€™s just bring it home to the Colorado River region. (โ€˜Regionโ€™ here, remember, means the natural river basin plus all of the out-of-basin extensions who depend on Colorado River diversions โ€“ the South Platte and Arkansas River Basins, the Salt Lake basin, Southern California out to the Pacific coast.)

The Bureau of Reclamation has, as discussed in the last post, taken the lead in โ€˜stopping diggingโ€™ by essentially ignoring the antiquated Colorado River Compact and mapping out an โ€˜adaptive managementโ€™ agenda of a ten-year plan broken into five reviewable and alterable two-year periods. [ed. emphasis mine]

The Bureauโ€™s chief goal in this ten-year plan is not delivering an easy and comfortable desert lifestyle for the 40 million or so people who depend on the river for some or all of their water, food,ย ย energy and water-based entertainments. Their chief goal for the next decade is to save the system of water storage and distribution that has been stretched to the breaking point through enabling that lifestyle for a possibly unsustainable number of people, and the people will have to pay for that effort to save the system over the coming decade โ€“ and quite probably live with reasonably diminished expectations on into the future, for so long as we continue shrinking the river through pumping ever more heat-trapping gases in the atmosphere.

How will we pay? Tiered water bills will probably make it unaffordable for most of us to maintain a desert-defying green lawn. Unavoidable major cuts to agricultural water will introduce change and some chaos in the food supply systems, guaranteeing continued high or higher prices at the supermarket. It may make 50-plus percent of ag water going to animal food production (hay and corn) economically unsustainable; meat may eventually go back to being a special Sunday treat. The need to increase storage in reasonably good water years will mean cheap hydropower production will continue to be replaced by more expensive alternatives โ€“ wind and solar as they develop, but when necessary a fallback on fossil fuels (meaning more planet-warming gases into the atmosphere). The need to increase storage in good years will also mean marginal flows in all the โ€˜recreational canyonsโ€™ below the major dams, now a significant element in the basin economy. (This year the recreational economy took a big hit as many streams dropped below the level for safe boating or fishing.)

The Bureau wants consumptive use of Colorado River water to have been permanently cut by 3 million acre-feet (maf) not later than the end of the 10-year planning period (2036), on the valid assumption that ever lower snowpacks and runoffs are the shape of the future; that reduction in use will, they believe, allow them to build up some storage in the good years for sustainability through the bad years โ€“ the basic idea of storage.

The cuts to go in effect October 1 (beginning of the 2027-28 first two-year Bureau plan) will achieve between a third and half of the 3 maf through mandatory cuts totaling 1.25 maf for the three Lower Basin states below the big federal reservoirs (California, Arizona and Nevada), and a program of voluntary paid reductions in Upper Basin use, paid from a $100 million fedeal fund. Users can expect that the other half of the consumptive use reduction will be worked in to the two-year reviews and subsequent modified plans for the next two years.

The reaction to this plan has โ€“ as one might expect โ€“ not been positive. The state of Nevada has sued the Bureau/Interior for the depth of the current cuts and the promise of deeper. The Central Arizona Project governing board has also decided to sue, because the CAP will take the deepest cuts, due to the junior status of its water rights.

The state of Arizona also threatened to sue in a letter to the Bureau; they castigated the Bureauโ€™s plan for seeming to pay no obeisance to the Colorado River Compact, and are essentially demanding that the Bureau continue to release 8.23 maf on average from Powell to meet the Upper Basin Compact obligation, even if it means Upper Basin users having to cut their uses to accumulate that hydrologically antiquated quantity. They have created a multi-million dollar war chest and have hired a law firm to defend their state of denial.

California has been mostly quiet; they will only stir from their den if someone suggests that the cuts should be divided among the three states equitably according to each stateโ€™s usage of the waters, rather than distributed through appropriations priorities.

The lack of mandatory Upper Basin cuts in the plan is a very sore point with the Lower Basin users. The Upper Basin states answer by saying that nature already imposed major reductions on their use โ€“ reductions that are not really quantified, however. It is important to acknowledge a major distinction between the two Basins: nearly all the lower Basin water users are below the big federal storage reservoirs, while many, maybe most of the Upper Basin water users are above the larger federal storage reservoirs. Living and working above a dam versus below a dam develops different perspectives on things like predictability, sustainability and freedom to act.

There is actually not a great quantity of private consumptive use in the Upper Basin that is โ€˜controlledโ€™ by federal reservoirs, which can impose cuts by simply not releasing water from the reservoirs โ€“ how the Bureau will be enforcing its mandatory cuts in the Lower Basin. Also the upstream Upper Basin federal reservoirs like Green Mountain and Taylor are all on the small side (less than 150,000 acre-feet). Many of the Upper Basin agricultural diversions are also small, with numerous single-ranch headgates โ€“ too much to cover for overworked water commissioners with too-large sectors; they have to accept that a lot of the recording of use will be done by the farmers and ranchers themselves, an honor system that does not always insure accuracy.

Even the paid voluntary cuts face a challenge; to get the water saved by upstream users down to Powell Reservoir, it must be โ€˜shepherdedโ€™ past downstream users who are free to take the water to meet their own allotments, and no one knows how this shepherding can be done. A legal system based on โ€˜first come, first servedโ€™ does not automatically encourage a sharing attitude.

So that is where it stands today. I think it has to be acknowledged that the Bureau of Reclamation is trying to instill a โ€˜bankruptcy awarenessโ€™ over a region of heavily invested consumptive water users that are steeped in denial over a water situation they seem to feel they cannot afford to acknowledge.

That the Bureau of Reclamation was a moving force pushing the over-development of the river system through the first three quarters of the 20thcentury cannot be denied; if โ€˜arroganceโ€™ can be defined as large actions taken in a state of ignorance about outcomes (suggesting that smaller trial runs would have been wiser), then the Bureau has been arrogant, culminating probably in Glen Canyon Dam. Basically 20th-century America became arrogant after World War II; the Bureau was just another running dog.

America right now is insufferably arrogant in its behavior globally, trying to make ongoing ignorance mandatory in the face of sadder-but-wiser awareness (โ€˜wokenessโ€™), in order to try to perpetrate large actions done stupidly; make America grate again. But the Bureau, viewing the imminent reduction of its massive Colorado River achievement to a dead-pool joke, has more humbly come around to a ten-year flexible and resilient plan to reduce water use in the Basin (plus extensions) to fit the Colorado River we now have, not the river we thought we had when we drafted a compact dividing the river among the seven states supposedly united by the river.

This is the Bureauโ€™s attempt to move to bankruptcy management, and it has resulted to date in a flurry of lawsuits and threats, which must presumably be dealt with before what needs to be done can be done. History suggests that this could take up to a decade once it is submerged in the courts, and the Bureau managers are convinced that a prolonged period of โ€˜no actionโ€™ (the first alternative in all EIS-driven decisions) will inevitably result in dead-pool episodes in Powell and Mead Reservoirs. Recent history, on the other hand, suggests that the Supremes (to whom interstates disagreements go) are no longer interested in careful constitutionally-based jurisprudence if it doesnโ€™t suit their politics, so they might let the Bureau go ahead with its escalating cuts to the Lower Basin while a water master thrashes through the legal thicket.

Weโ€™ll see. Meanwhile, next time I want to start looking at some ideas that might help lead out of our current bankruptcyโ€ฆ.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

The Colorado Water Conservation Board green lights conservation program: #Colorado aims to save water by not solely fallowing fields — Heather Sackett (AspenJournalism.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Blue Mesa reservoir seen in August 2026 at about 21% full. Under a new state-run conservation program, saved water could be stored in Blue Mesa. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Journalism website (Heather Sackett):

September 17, 2026

The state water board has given the green light to a one-year, state-run water conservation program. 

On Wednesday [September 16, 2026], the Colorado Water Conservation Board unanimously approved the application review process and criteria for what state officials are calling Coloradoโ€™s near-term contribution program for 2027. The move came at the boardโ€™s regular September meeting at Copper Mountain.

Board member and Colorado River mainstem representative Taylor Hawes reminded the board that their unenviable position was due to a historic drought.

โ€œNone of us want to be in this situation where we are dealing with these kinds of impacts from climate-change-driven drought,โ€ Hawes said. โ€œWeโ€™re doing this in response to whatโ€™s being thrown at us in terms of decreased supply.โ€

The contribution program aims to use $100 million in funding from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation to pay water users in the Upper Basin states (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming) to voluntarily cut back. According to the criteria approved Wednesday, projects in Colorado are required to avoid negative impacts; avoid speculators; comply with the rules of local ditch companies; and consult with tribes and local water conservation districts about proposed projects within their boundaries. The program will also give weight to projects that see participation statewide, across water sectors and by tribal nations; build drought resiliency; and have environmental benefits.

The approval comes at a pivotal moment, as the federal government has taken over operations for the Colorado River and the nationโ€™s biggest reservoirs after the seven states that share the river failed to find agreement after years of negotiations. The federal plan calls for cuts only for the Lower Basin states (California, Arizona and Nevada). But with the region wracked by historic drought, the Upper Basin states can no longer escape scrutiny over their water use and are expected to contribute in some way.

โ€œWeโ€™re not doing this for fun,โ€ Hawes said. โ€œWeโ€™re doing this because our situation requires it. โ€ฆ Itโ€™s a step toward just being able to live within the riverโ€™s means.โ€

THay bales seen on a ranch outside Carbondale in July 2024. The state water board approved a contribution program on Wednesday that could pay agricultural water users to cut back. Credit: Heather Sackett/Aspen Journalism

Full fallowing not favored

The Upper Basin has experimented with these types of paid conservation programs before, including in the System Conservation Pilot Program (SCPP), which ran in 2023 and 2024. And Colorado conducted its own exploration of a demand-management program from 2019 to 2021. 

But these programs remain controversial and go against the main philosophy of Western water law: to maximize the use of water. Farmers and ranchers often feel unfairly targeted for water savings because they use the majority of Colorado River water. And some worry about the potential for impacts to rural agricultural communities if water is taken off the land.

Although, in theory, all water-use sectors were allowed to participate in SCPP, in Colorado only agricultural water users in participated in the pilot program. Removing water from the Western Slopeโ€™s hay and alfalfa fields for an entire growing season โ€” known as full-season fallowing โ€” has been the most common way to find water savings in the past and is one of the easiest ways to calculate water savings. But early studies have shown that removing water from forage crops for the whole season can have negative impacts on fields that last for several years.

Troy Waters, a fifth-generation Mesa County farmer who sits on the board of Grand Valley Water Users Association and Grand Valley municipal water provider Ute Water, said during the public comment portion of Wednesdayโ€™s meeting that fallowing fields will just lead to โ€œbuy and dry,โ€ where water is removed permanently, resulting in negative economic impacts to communities. Instead, Waters said he would like to see the funding from Reclamation go toward upgrades to aging infrastructure, such as lining ditches, which could have long-term water savings.

โ€œThis fallowing ground is causing nothing but a can of worms with farmers,โ€ Waters said. โ€œIโ€™ve seen the fights; Iโ€™ve sat in on the board meetings. Itโ€™s not a solution. Letโ€™s take this money and find a better solution.โ€

Some board members agreed. After some discussion, the board amended the criteria to add that multiyear fallowing projects should be disincentivized. 

โ€œThe intent of making that suggestion is I donโ€™t want to push people toward fallowing,โ€ said CWCB Arkansas Basin representative Alan Ward. โ€œI want that to be the exception.โ€

State officials have said they want to broaden the types of projects funded for next year, which is part of the reason why they are calling this a โ€œcontributionโ€ program and not strictly a conservation program. A goal is to encourage participation from cities and industrial water users by offering more money to these sectors, where water is more valuable. 

Becky Mitchell, Coloradoโ€™s representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission (UCRC) and a negotiator on Colorado River issues, said she heard loud and clear that there is not an  appetite for multiyear fallowing projects.

โ€œI think it is my responsibility to take that back to the Bureau of Reclamation and Department of the Interior and say these are the kinds of things we can do in Colorado and fallowing is not the only answer; the impacts of that might be too great,โ€ Mitchell said. 

State officials announced in July they would be creating a contribution program using federal money and have been taking feedback from water users and stakeholders since then. At Wednesdayโ€™s meeting, Emily Zmak, deputy interstate section chief at the CWCB, presented the findings from public comments, surveys and input, which helped officials craft the project criteria.

โ€œAlmost universally, weโ€™ve heard support for a program,โ€ Zmak said. โ€œI would say 99% of the input either supported a program outright or supported a program with certain sideboards. Water users have been very invested in shaping the direction of a contribution program.โ€

The top criteria that respondents said they wanted to see in a program were protection of water rights; drought resilience; community impacts; and credit from Reclamation for the saved water. Respondents did not support having a minimum acreage for participation.  

Sprinklers irrigate a ranch outside of Carbondale on Highway 133. Some water users and state water board members are hoping fallowing projects wonโ€™t become the backbone of a new state conservation program. CREDIT: CLAIRE DE L’ARBRE/ASPEN JOURNALISM

Approval process

Water-saving projects would have to go through several rigorous steps for approval, said Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief with CWCB. First, there would be a review by the Colorado Division of Water Resources. CWCB staff would also consult with tribal nations for projects on their land and with local conservation and conservancy districts for projects within their boundaries. Then in January, the CWCB would decide which projects to advance to the UCRC for approval, before going to Reclamation for its approval. 

โ€œWe would be seeking robust public input and review of these applications,โ€ Ostdiek said. 

CWCBโ€™s approval Wednesday is conditioned on an agreement between federal officials and the Upper Basin states that says the states can get credit for and have control over the saved water.

Under the Upper Basinโ€™s contribution program, saved water would have to be moved and stored in either Lake Powell or Blue Mesa, Flaming Gorge and Navajo reservoirs (known as the Upstream Initial Units) in order to get credit from Reclamation for the stored water. One of the criticisms of past pilot conservation programs was that the water was neither tracked to Lake Powell nor measured to see how much ended up there.

On Sept. 11, the UCRC sent a letter to federal officials saying that water saved through the program should be stored in one of the Upstream Initial Units and should be operationally neutral, meaning the pools of saved water would not be factored into federal reservoir operations or releases. 

โ€œWithout these elements, participation in an Upper Basin Program may be significantly limited,โ€ the letter reads. โ€œAccordingly, we intend to work with you so that contributions generated by the Program and stored at Lake Powell or the Upstream Initial Units will be credited and regarded as operationally neutral.โ€

ten tribes
Graphic via Holly McClelland/High Country News.

#Aspen contributes #RuediReservoir allocation to #drought relief — Aspen Daily News #FryingpanRiver

Ruedi Reservoir, above Basalt, on the Fryingpan River, April 22, 2026. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith

Click the link to read the article on Aspen Daily News website. Here’s an excerpt:

September 15, 2026

A portion of the city of Aspenโ€™s water allocation in Ruedi Reservoir will be utilized to support regional drought response efforts, according to an informational memo sent to the Aspen City Council last week.ย  The city will make up to 350 acre-feet of its annual water allocation from Ruedi available to support drought response efforts. It has access to 400 acre-feet annually. The water will be used to assist the Colorado River Water Conservation Districtโ€™s emergency substitute water supply plan, which provides supplemental water supplies for municipal and domestic historic user pool beneficiaries and other eligible water users whose supplies may not otherwise be fully available during current drought conditions.

โ€œBy making a portion of the cityโ€™s available contract water supply available for release, Aspen is helping maintain water supplies used to support municipal and domestic water users affected by the current drought conditions and administration associated with the Cameo call,โ€ the memo states.

The Cameo call consists of a series of water rights on the Colorado River. It keeps water instream until it reaches the Grand Junction area, and can mean upstream diversions may need to shut down or release additional water into the river to meet the needs of the Cameo call.ย  The release of the water also provides benefits to streamflows, aquatic habitats, fisheries and riparian resources within the Roaring Fork and Colorado rivers, according to the memo.

Map of the Roaring Fork River drainage basin in western Colorado, USA. Made using USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69290878

U.S. Senator Michael Bennet and U.S. Representative Jeff Hurd talk Shoshone Power Plant funding at the #ColoradoRiver District Annual Seminar — The #GrandJunction Daily Sentinel #COriver #aridification #CRD2026

Shoshone Hydroelectric Plant back in the days before I-70 via Aspen Journalism

Click the link to read the article on the Grand Junction Daily Sentinel website (Dan West). Here’s an excerpt:

September 19, 2026

The proposed purchase of the Shoshone Power Plantโ€™s water rights took center stage at the Colorado River Districtโ€™s Annual Water Seminar held at Colorado Mesa University on Friday, Sept. 18. While much of the annual meeting covered the historic drought that threatened the Western Slope and the rest of the Colorado River Basin, the Shoshone effort was held up as an example of how to manage water rights. Colorado River District General Manager Andy Mueller devoted a section of his keynote speech to the effort to purchase the power plant and its senior water rights for $99 million.

โ€œItโ€™s been going on since this district was formed in the 1930s,โ€ Mueller said. โ€œWe have been trying to gain control and ensure permanency of the water rights that command the river related to this little power plant in Glenwood Canyon.โ€

There has been positive progress on the purchase, Mueller said, including raising more than $97 million from local, state and federal partners. The district also got a positive decision from the Colorado Water Conservation Board [8-0 vote on instream flow application]. However, there is still more negotiations underway, he said…On the funding side, Mueller credited Sen. Michael Bennet and Rep. Jeff Hurd for helping to secure and get released $40 million in federal funding for the purchase. Bennet and Hurd sat down for an โ€œarmchair conversationโ€ about Shoshone at the seminar Friday afternoon…After lunch, Hurd and Bennet sat down and gave each other credit for the bipartisan effort to get the $40 million in federal funding for the Shoshone purchase. Bennet insisted on its inclusion in the Inflation Reduction Act during the Biden administration…When the Trump administration came in, it funded tens of millions of dollars in funding approved through that legislation. Hurd said he worked behind the scenes to convince the administration to release the funding.

โ€œGive Jeff full credit for that,โ€ Bennet said. โ€œHe landed this plane because I wasnโ€™t getting my calls returned from the Trump administration and he was. He told them it was his number one priority.โ€

A map showing the boundaries of the Colorado River District, and its 15 member counties

The #ColoradoRiver District Annual Seminar focused on preparing for hotter, drier future — The #GrandJunction Daily Sentinel #COriver #aridification #CRD2026

A slide from State Engineer Jason Ullmann at the Colorado River District Annual Seminar September 18, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on the Grand Junction Daily Sentinel website (Dan West). Here’s an excerpt:

September 19, 2026

The Colorado River Districtโ€™s Annual Water Seminar held at Colorado Mesa University on Friday, Sept. 18, naturally focused on this yearโ€™s historic heat and drought that left many on the Western Slope facing water shortages, but it also looked toward the future and the positive steps taken to address this yearโ€™s challenges…

โ€œUnprecedented. Worst ever. Miserable. Warmest ever. Hottest ever,โ€ [Andy] Mueller said. โ€œYou can keep going, but I want to also say that this was a year of extremely collaborative creativity in western Colorado. It is really important to recognize that, applaud that and make sure we grow that, because it is how we get through tough times. Itโ€™s how weโ€™re going to survive and thrive in the future.โ€

[…]

Mueller highlighted the collaboration between communities, irrigation companies and water users throughout the district. He said there were many efforts that helped extend the irrigation season…

Blue Mesa Reservoir on the Gunnison River, seen Aug. 30, 2026 at about 21% full. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM

There were also areas, especially in the North Fork Valley and the Gunnison River, that have seen severe impacts from the drought. Coloradoโ€™s largest reservoir, Blue Mesa, is also in a dire condition, he said.

โ€œOn the Gunnison, thereโ€™s a train wreck that is accelerating at Blue Mesa,โ€ Mueller said. โ€œWe are working with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Uncompahgre Valley Water Users and the Upper Gunnison Water Conservancy District to try to figure out solutions. But that reservoir, if anybody hasnโ€™t seen it recently, is not just one reservoir anymore. Itโ€™s a bunch of little pools. It has dried up.โ€

[…]

Facing the challenges the future presents wonโ€™t be easy, Mueller said, but the next generations will depend on work done now.

โ€œWhen I talk to my daughters who are in their 20s, they and their friends are absolutely scared for their future,โ€ Mueller said. โ€œThey are extremely intelligent, theyโ€™re paying attention, but they look at this tremendous uncertainty that we have created in our society and in our globe. They need our help, helping them see the future. That is our job to do that.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Experts, politicians urge collaboration in Western Slope water use: #ColoradoRiver District seminar explores impacts of Coloradoโ€™s #drought — #Aspen Daily News #CRD2026 #COriver #aridification

Colorado River running muddy September 18, 2026.

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Daily News website (Drew Shaw). Here’s an excerpt:

September 19, 2026

Colorado water experts and elected officials urged collaboration across industries, borders and political parties as the Western Slope seeks sustainable water systems that will serve future generations. The yearโ€™s unprecedented statewide drought wonโ€™t be the last, speakers said throughout Friday during the Colorado River Districtโ€™s annual water seminar on Friday (September 18, 2026) in Grand Junction.ย 

โ€œWe canโ€™t run from it โ€” we have to learn from it,โ€ said Andy Mueller, the districtโ€™s general manager, during the event, which was held at Colorado Mesa University.

Ruedi Reservoir, above Basalt, on the Fryingpan River, April 22, 2026. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith

Communities and entities made sacrifices to ensure the regionโ€™s water needs were met. Reservoirs, such as Ruedi Reservoir east of Basalt, have been drawn down at faster rates than normal, municipalities have led water conservation campaigns and farmers across the valley have needed to settle for significantly smaller crop yields…The river district has for years sought the means to buy from Xcel Energy the Shoshone water rights, the oldest and largest non-consumptive water rights on the Colorado River. In acquiring the rights, the river district would prevent any other potential buyers from diverting the water from Western Slope communities…The agency has raised about $97 million of $99 million for the acquisition, $40 million of which comes from federal funds. Those federal dollars, which were secured by the stateโ€™s Democratic senators under the Biden Administration, were frozen in 2025 under the Trump Administration. Earlier this year, U.S. Rep. Jeff Hurd, R-Grand Junction,ย worked successfully to release the funds.

โ€œThatโ€™s the kind of collaboration we need in Congress and in our communities,โ€ Mueller said…

Mueller said the stateโ€™s future water security depends on finding sustainable systems to manage the water it has now.

โ€œHow can we adapt to uncertainty and rising temperatures and reduced streams?โ€ he asked. โ€œWe donโ€™t need to argue about whether or not thatโ€™s happening. We need to focus on the future and figure out solutions.โ€

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

#ColoradoRiver 24 month for mid September – #LakeMead is losing standard turbines around November — Ed Millard #COriver #aridification

Newswire — President Trump moves to axe #climate pollution rules: Also — BLM sells 940-acre parcel to Las Vegas for 6,000-house community — Jonathan P. Thompson #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification (LandDesk.org)

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 14, 2026

Good morning and welcome to another edition of the Land Desk Newswire. The Trump administration is continuing to convert its fossil fuel fetish into real-world, deeply consequential policy, this time by eliminating greenhouse gas emissions limits for coal- and gas-burning power plants. Meanwhile, the BLM moves forward with selling a sizable chunk of public land to bolster Las Vegas sprawl under a 1998 law.

๐Ÿ“ REGULATORY CAPTURE CHRONICLES ๐ŸฆŠ

Coronado coal plant in northeastern Arizona. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
  • The Trump administration moves to axe Obama- and Biden-era regulations limiting fossil fuel power plantsโ€™ greenhouse gas emissions, meaning coal and gas plants will be able to spew planet-warming carbon dioxide without restraint. This could extend the lives of some coal plants, and will help clear the way for the fleet of new gas plants being developed to power hyperscale data centers. While the original rules required facilities to reduce carbon emissions, they also would have kept soot and other health-harming pollutants out of the air, preventing an estimated 1,200 premature deaths per year. Earlier this year the administration rolled back stricter limits on mercury emissions from power plants. (New York Times)
๐ŸŒต PUBLIC LANDS ๐ŸŒฒ
  • The Bureau of Land Management sells 940 acres of public land in southern Nevada to the City of Las Vegas, clearing the way for a 6,000-home master-planned community on the northern fringe of the metro area adjacent to Tule Springs Fossil Bed National Monument. The sale was authorized by the 1998 Southern Nevada Public Land Management Act, which allows for such โ€œdisposalsโ€ of federal land in a congressionally designated boundary. It merely whetted Gov. Joe Lombardoโ€™s (R) appetite for snatching more public land, however, who said he will work to โ€œunlock more federal land for housing.โ€ Itโ€™s not clear whence the water will come for this sprawling new development in one of the nationโ€™s more water-constrained cities; the state faces potential further reductions of Colorado River water under the new federal plan. (news release)
  • A new poll finds that two-thirds of Utah voters support restoring protections to the original, pre-Trump-shrinkage boundaries of Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments, and an even larger proportion supports tribal nations having a role in managing ancestral lands. (news release)
๐Ÿฅต ARIDIFICATION WATCH ๐Ÿซ
  • Wyoming researchers say warm water and drought-reduced streamflows may be behind a kidney-damaging parasite killing hundreds of whitefish in the Salt River this summer. The tributary of the Snake River has experienced some of its lowest flows on record this summer, and it was already plagued with E coli bacteria as a result of heavy livestock grazing in the watershed. (WyoFile)
โ›๏ธ MINING MONITOR โ›๏ธ
  • The Cibola National Forest launches its environmental review of Energy Fuelsโ€™ proposed Roca Honda underground uranium mine on about 370 acres of USFS, state, and private land northeast of Grants, New Mexico, and near the base of Mt. Taylor. Ore would be hauled by truck to the White Mesa Mill in southeastern Utah for processing. Public comments will be accepted here until Oct. 14. (agency news release)
  • IsoEnergy, which owns the Tony M, Dineros, Rim, and Sage Plain uranium mines in southern Utah, agrees to merge with DISA, a startup that looks to use high-pressure slurry ablation technology to pull uranium out of abandoned mine waste piles, to create a โ€œtechnology-enabled US uranium platform for production, processing, and remediation.โ€ DISAโ€™s attempts to process small waste piles in Western Colorado have yet to come to fruition, and Isoโ€™s bid to reopen the Tony M mine near Ticaboo, Utah, has moved forward only in incremental steps. (World Nuclear News)
  • Union Pacific Railroad begins hauling coal from Powder River Basin mines to the Port of Guaymas in Sonora, Mexico, where it could be shipped to Asia. The new export node allows the industry to get around environmental opposition to coal exports along the West Coast, but its viability depends on demand. (Trains)
๐ŸŸ COLORADO RIVER CHRONICLES ๐Ÿ’ง
The less-than-ideal North Wash takeout for boaters running the Colorado River though Cataract Canyon. The planned Hite facilities, located to the right of this image just upstream and opposite the Dirty Devil confluence, would replace the North Wash ramp. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

  • Glen Canyon National Recreation Area moves forward with a plan to develop new low-water boat ramps and other facilities at the Hite and Bullfrog districts on Lake Powell, indicating that the National Park Service expects reservoir levels not to rebound. The Bullfrog ramp is planned for the main channel of the reservoir, southeast of the current facilities, and would be usable for boats up to 125 feet long to a low lake level of 3,450 feet. The Hite ramp would be upstream from the current facilities and is primarily designed as a takeout for Cataract Canyon boaters and a safer alternative to the North Wash takeout on the opposite side of the river. (news release)
The planned Bullfrog low-water boat ramp. Source: NPS.
The planned Hite launch/takeout ramp. Source: NPS

Climate change comes for a Lake Powell marina — Jonathan P. Thompson


  • Arizona officials raise concerns about how the Colorado River crisis might affect its booming semiconductor and chip manufacturing industry, in which a single Phoenix-area facility, known as a โ€œfab,โ€ uses some 4.75 million gallons of water per day. (The Verge)
  • The Bureau of Reclamation again increases water releases from Flaming Gorge Reservoir in an effort to buoy water levels at Lake Powell, but Utah officials warn it is not a sustainable solution and could harm recreation on the upstream reservoir. (KSL)
๐Ÿฆซ WILDLIFE WATCH ๐Ÿฆ…
  • Colorado Parks and Wildlife has euthanized nearly 300 bears so far this yearfollowing โ€œunprecedentedโ€ levels of bear activity in towns across the state, as well as in Wyoming. Bryan Peterson, of Bear Smart Durango, told Cowboy State Daily the conflicts and killings are mostly due to the drought and lack of food sources, but also blamed human carelessness with garbage and food. (Cowboy State Daily, WyoFile)
  • Colorado Parks and Wildlife kills an uncollared female yearling wolf from the One Ear Pack in Grand County after the animal evaded non-lethal deterrents to prey on livestock. (news release)
๐Ÿค– DATA CENTER DIGEST ๐Ÿ‘พ
  • Bureau of Land Management leadership reportedly orders state directors to identify federal parcels suitable for data center development, indicating that the administration is looking to skirt communitiesโ€™ opposition to and ban on the facilities by approving them on nearby public lands. (Washington Sun)
  • Corner Venture Capital applies for an air quality permit for a 300-megawatt natural gas-fired plant to power a proposed hyperscale data center in southwestern New Mexico, raising concerns over air pollution and water use. (Silver City Daily Press, news release)
  • Googleโ€™s proposed 2.7-gigawatt, $17 billion Project Tembo data center complex on 700 acres near Cheyenne, Wyoming, clears local regulatory hurdles, but still has a lot of red tape to tangle with before final approval. The firm says the facilities will use less water-intensive closed-loop cooling systems and draw from deep wells, not surface supplies, and that it will be powered with natural gas fuel cells paired with carbon capture. (Wyoming Tribune Eagle)
๐Ÿ”‹NOTES FROM THE ENERGY TRANSITION ๐Ÿ”Œ
  • Array Technologies opens its $50 million, 200,000-square-foot solar component manufacturing facility in Albuquerque, where it employs about 300 people. (KRQE)
  • Black Hills Energy moves forward with its planned 50-megawatt battery energy storage system at its Pueblo Airport Generating Station in Colorado. (Energy Storage News)
๐Ÿ›ป TRANSPORTATION ๐Ÿš‚
  • Denver West Express pitches a โ€œconceptโ€ of an electric rail line designed to carry skiers from Denver International Airport to the resort town of Avon in less than two hours. The line would cost an estimated $28 billion to $33 billion to construct, but it might go a long ways to alleviate the I-70 ski season gridlock, which makes for one of the nastiest drives in the state โ€” and where high traffic costs about $2.3 billion annually. (Steamboat Pilot)
๐Ÿ“ˆ DATAVIZ OF THE DAY ๐Ÿ“Š

The Land Desk recently reported on how solar, wind, and battery storage is pushing coal off the Westโ€™s power grid, despite the Trump administrationโ€™s hostility toward cleaner energy sources. As of June of this year, the trend appeared to be continuing into the future, as a bulk of the generating capacity in the planning pipeline comes from cleaner sources. Click on the graphics for an interactive view, and specifics on each planned power plant.

Coyote Gulchโ€™s excellent EV adventure, #ColoradoRiver District Annual Seminar: Day 4, #Fruita to #Denver #CRD2026

Along US-6 in Summit County September 19, 2026.

For the homeward drive, I charged at the newish Ionna chargers in Fruita. I was pulling over 100 KW at the start. Very fast. I bumped up in Glenwood Springs and had enough charge to get home, but owing to my range anxiety, I added 10% in Silverthorne. At the top of Loveland Pass the controls indicated 36% battery charge and an estimated 78 miles of range. But, as fans of regenerative charging know, when I arrived at Gulch Manor the spread was 32% charge and estimated range of 108 miles. It is pretty much downhill from Loveland Pass to my place, 11,990 feet down to 5,400 feet or so, on Berkeley Hill in Denver.

Most of the day Saturday was taken up by the climb from Fruita to the Continental Divide of the Americas.

Coyote Gulch’s Ariya at the summit of Loveland Pass September 19, 2026.

All in all I charged at ChargePoint, Tesla, Tesla/Colorado Energy Office, Rivian, and Ionna chargers. I am so happy with the performance of my Ariya on the first road trip — ~950 miles.

#ColoradoRiver District Annual Seminar September 18, 2026 #CRD2026 #COriver #aridification

Seminar day did not include an EV element. I ride my bicycle from Fruita to Grand Junction along the Colorado Riverfront Trail. The 14 mile ride has great views of the Colorado National Monument, Grand Mesa, and Mt. Sentinel.

Colorado National Monument from the Colorado Riverfront Trail near Fruita September 18, 2026.

Of course the Colorado River is front and center and it was so gratifying to see the river running with sediment.

Colorado River running muddy September 18, 2026.

It had been rainy all week in western Colorado and you could tell, it was enough to get near average streamflow at the Utah line.

My main takeaway from the seminar was that West Slope water users shared supplies to get through these rough times. Collaboration was mentioned several times as was, “We didn’t call anyone out.”

Check out my live-posts from seminar on my BlueSky feed or the seminar hash tag (click on the “Latest” tab).

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0

Denver Water can finish and fill Gross Reservoir, US appeals court rules — Michael Booth (Fresh Water News) #ColoradoRiver #BoulderCreek #SouthPlatteRiver #COriver #aridification

Gross Dam enlargement concept graphic via Denver Water

Click the link to read the article on the Water Education Colorado website (Michael Booth):

September 17, 2026

Denver Water can finish its Gross Dam expansion and fill the controversial reservoir in western Boulder County, the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday, lifting an injunction by a lower court judge and confirming the damโ€™s permits as sound.

The appeals court said the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had acted responsibly in issuing construction permits for the $600 million expansion, which is largely complete and will be filled using water rights Denver holds in the Colorado River basin on the western side of the Continental Divide.

A federal district judge in Denver had issued the injunction after declaring the Corps had failed to consider less-damaging alternatives, or the fact that climate change could dramatically reduce the amount of Colorado River water available to fill the storage pool. But the appeals court rejected that view.

โ€œWe do not think the Corpsโ€™s choice of cost methodology was arbitrary or capricious,โ€ the appeals court ruling said. The plaintiffs, including nonprofit Save the Colorado, argued the Corps rejected clear evidence of climate change, but the appeals court ruled the Corps gave the research fair consideration.

โ€œThe Corps considered โ€” and rejected โ€” the reliability of that and similar studies, one of which showed that in the Colorado River Basin, โ€˜no consistent trends in annual precipitation have been detected over the last 100 years,โ€™โ€ the appeals court said.

โ€œIn the end, the environmental groups ask us to substitute our judgment for the Corpsโ€™s. They point out scientific studies that, in their view, rebut the Corpsโ€™s reading of the scientific literature and ask us to opine on what the scientific research establishes,โ€ the appellate ruling said. โ€œBut our job is not to second-guess the Corpsโ€™s assessment as long as it rests on a reasoned basis.โ€

Denver Water said it looked forward to completing a crucial water supply project it began permitting 23 years ago.

โ€œWeโ€™re pleased to see the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals confirm that the Gross Reservoir Expansion Project was lawfully permitted by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and that Denver Water can proceed with the final stages of this critical project to ensure a safe, secure water supply for the 1.5 million people we serve,โ€ according to a statement from spokesperson Todd Hartman. โ€œWith this decision, Denver Water can move forward with completion of construction, site preparation and eventual filling of the expanded reservoir. An expanded Gross Reservoir is vital to the future of the Denver region.โ€

Save the Coloradoโ€™s Gary Wockner, who has led battles against many projects threatening to further alter the ecology of Colorado river systems, said the appeals court decision doesnโ€™t change Coloradoโ€™s water challenges.

Itโ€™s nonsensical to be putting more straws in, and further draining, the Colorado River at this point in history,โ€ Wockner said. โ€œThat the law allows it to happen doesnโ€™t make it right, it just makes it legal. I saw something wrong, I stood up, spoke out and took action. It was the right thing to do and I would do it all over again.โ€

Wockner said Tuesday the plaintiffs would not be appealing the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Gross Reservoir Dam backs up South Boulder Creek, while also taking in water through the Moffat Tunnel under the divide, from the Fraser and Williams Fork rivers in the Colorado River basin. Denver Water has said the expansion is needed to balance its water storage system currently heavily concentrated on the southern end of the metro area.

More by Michael Booth

Denver Water’s entire collection system. Image credit: Denver Water.

EPA takes (another) swing at Western waters: Plus — โ€œTraveling Wilburysโ€ look at #ColoradoRiver water use — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #COriver #aridification #WOTUS

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

September 11, 2026

๐ŸŒจ๏ธ๐Ÿšฃ๐Ÿฝ WATER WATCH ๐ŸŒŠ๐Ÿฆฆ

The Trump administrationโ€™s Environmental Protection Agency is proposing to further constrain the reach and potency of the Clean Water Act by re-defining what qualifies as โ€œwaters of the United States,โ€ or WOTUS, which are streams, wetlands, and other water bodies under federal jurisdiction. The proposed definition would disproportionately affect the arid West by lifting protections from thousands of miles of streams, arroyos, and wetlands.

Under the CWA, a firm or individual looking to discharge pollutants or other material into, or dredge or reroute or otherwise alter, a WOTUS waterway must obtain a federal permit from the EPA or Army Corps of Engineers. A battle has raged for more than five decades over what constitutes a WOTUS. The Supreme Courtโ€™s 2023 Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency ruling called for a narrower definition, handing industry and right-wing ideologues a major victory.

Ephemeral streams are streams that do not always flow. They are above the groundwater reservoir and appear after precipitation in the area. Via Socratic.org

The changes in the latest proposed supplemental rule are even more exclusionary than the administrationโ€™s November 2025 proposal, which removed โ€œephemeralโ€ and โ€œintermittentโ€ waterways โ€” i.e. arroyos or washes that run only after rains or snowmelt โ€” from federal jurisdiction. Included as a WOTUS under that proposal were โ€œrelatively permanent โ€ฆ bodies of surface water that are standing or continuously flowing year-round or at least during the wet season.โ€

The new proposal omits the โ€œwet seasonโ€ verbiage. It then defines โ€œrelatively permanentโ€ to be synonymous with โ€œperennial,โ€ which in turn is defined as โ€˜โ€˜having standing or continuously flowing water every day of the year during ordinary conditions.โ€™โ€™ However, โ€œa body of water does not lose its relatively permanent status if it dries up as a result of anomalous events such as drought or dry spell.1 A body of water also does not lose its relatively permanent status if it dries up for no more than a single period of up to 30 consecutive days in any given year as a result of non-anomalous events resulting in a temporary interruption such as low tide or a regularly occurring dry spell.โ€ Yet, โ€œif flow is interrupted for two periods in any given year, and each period consists of 10 consecutive days of no flow, the water body would not be jurisdictional.โ€

A Natural Resources Defense Council analysis found that the new proposal would remove protections from more than 94% of the nationโ€™s wetlands and about 79% of its streams. The changes would hit the West hardest, leaving a state like Arizona with almost no federally protected streams or wetlands.

So hereโ€™s my interpretation of where the updated proposal leaves us:

  • WOTUS waterways (keeps CWA protections): A year-round river, stream, or lake that never dries up, such as the Animas River, the San Juan River, the Colorado River, the Gunnison River, Cement Creek, Mineral Creek, the Fremont River, and so on, would retain federal protections under the CWA. However, since most of these rivers are fed by intermittent or ephemeral streams, they would also be potentially affected (since is someone altered or polluted a tributary, the effects would eventually reach the mainstem).
  • Non-WOTUS waterways (would lose CWA protections): All intermittent and ephemeral streams, i.e. arroyos or washes that run only when it rains, such as are ubiquitous in the arid West, would be removed from federal jurisdiction. Other streams and rivers that run seasonally, but regularly dry up for more than 30 consecutive days per year, such as the Paria River, the Dirty Devil, Rio Puerco, Santa Cruz River, or the Mancos River, would also lose federal protections, as would wetlands that are only โ€œwetโ€ for part of the year.
  • Vague WOTUS status: Rivers or streams that are perennial as a whole, but on which certain segments dry up for more than 30 days per year (usually because of upstream diversions), e.g.: the Rio Grande through Albuquerque, long sections of the Lower Dolores River between McPhee Dam and its confluence with the San Miguel, the North Fork of the Gunnison around Paonia, lower reaches of the La Plata River, or Junction Creek through Durango, and numerous desert rivers in Arizona and New Mexico.

While the proposed rule would remove federal CWA protections from many waterways, it would not automatically give developers or industry free rein to bulldoze or dump toxic waste into them. State and local laws would still apply, and arroyos and streams on public land would still be protected to some degree by federal environmental laws. Colorado lawmakers passed a bill in 2024 that effectively backfilled the regulatory gap left by the Sackett decision. New Mexico also has moved to implement its own layer of water protections. In more industry-friendly states such as Idaho and Utah, the proposed rule would leave thousands of miles of streams and waterways vulnerable to development and pollution.

The proposed rule is open to public comments until Oct. 9. You may send comments, identified by Docket ID No. EPAโ€“HQโ€“ OWโ€“2025โ€“0322, by any of the following methods:

  • Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://www.regulations.gov/. Follow the online instructions for submitting comments.
  • Email: OW-Docket@epa.gov. Include Docket ID No. EPAโ€“HQโ€“OWโ€“ 2025โ€“0322 in the subject line of the message. โ€ข
  • Mail: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA Docket Center, Water Docket, Mail Code 28221T, 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20460.
  • Hand Delivery or Courier: EPA Docket Center, WJC West Building, Room 3334, 1301 Constitution Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20004.

For more background on the long and winding struggle to define WOTUS, check out the following:

  • My February 2022 High Country News piece on the Supreme Court taking up the Sackett Case, including a detailed timeline of the WOTUS definition battle.

And, from the Land Desk archives (youโ€™ll need a paid subscription for access):


News Roundup: Arroyos on trial; Superstition Vistas; Lake Powell bridge — Jonathan P. Thompson

Supreme Court imperils arroyos, wetlands — Jonathan P. Thompson

On Trump’s arroyo-phobic Clean Water Act rule — Jonathan P. Thompson


๐ŸŸ Colorado River Chronicles ๐Ÿ’ง

A new paper is out from the group of Colorado River experts known by some as the โ€œTraveling Wilburys of the Colorado River Basin,โ€2 and lo and behold, it actually contains some good news. Namely this: The Lower Basin users have managed to make significant reductions in water use over the last decade and a half without turning the Southwest into a dust-choked wasteland and getting ahead of the latest round of mandated cuts. This indicates that the users can continue to slash water use in the future โ€” to a degree โ€” if necessary. 

The Lower Basin accounts for about 60% of all consumptive water uses and losses on the Colorado River. Irrigated agriculture, in turn, makes up about 60% of the Lower Basinโ€™s consumptive use. The Imperial Irrigation District, which is primarily agricultural, is the largest single water user on the entire river. This means that the agricultural sector โ€” and the IID in particular โ€” โ€œwill play a significant role in future reductions in water use,โ€ as the authors put it.

So far, the Lower Basinโ€™s farmers and the IID have stepped up. In 2025, the Lower Basin statesโ€™ consumptive use was 5.76 million acre-feet, the lowest since at least 2010. Since 2023, California has used about 13% less water, a reduction attributable mostly to cuts at IID.

Source: The Colorado River Water Supply Crisis in a Few Graphs: Part 2 Agricultural Water Use in the Lower Basin.
Figure 3. Consumptive use in Arizona since 2010. Estimated use in 2026 based on forecast of September 1, 2026.

Notably, IIDโ€™s reductions came mostly during the summer months, the peak season for field crops such as alfalfa, Bermuda grass, and kleingrass, when itโ€™s too hot to grow most garden crops, such as lettuce, onions, and broccoli. During the vegetablesโ€™ growing season, from November through March, water use stayed roughly the same as before. A similar, but less dramatic, dynamic shows up in Arizona.

Figure 6. Box-and-whisker plots of total monthly consumptive use by the IID between 2010 and 2026. Each box is the Inter Quartile Range, defined by the 25th and 75th percentile of the years of data for that month. These boxes represent the typical monthly use pattern since 2010. Red dots are the average use in each month between 2024 and 2026. See text for additional explanation of a box-and-whisker plot.

This suggests a couple of things: 1. The Imperial Irrigation District and other large agricultural users may be able to significantly lower overall water use without harming important garden crops such as broccoli and carrots (easing fears that the Colorado River crisis will deprive us of vegetables); and, 2. The IID is successfully using its vast alfalfa crop as a giant water demand-response tool3. That is, through both fallowing some fields and putting others on a summer water diet, the districtโ€™s farmers have managed to slash water use, while still growing gobs of hay and alfalfa. 

And because the IID still has about 150,000 acres of alfalfa, it has huge potential for future water cuts through these same methods, which is the good news. The bad news is that the federal plan for operating the river contemplates Lower Basin cuts of up to 3 million acre-feet per year (resulting in a total annual consumption of 4.5 MAF), which is about twice what the Basin has already achieved.

To consider the viability of such cuts, the authors summed up the smallest monthly use in each Lower Basin state since 2010, even though they didnโ€™t occur simultaneously, and even though in some cases the reductions were due to heavy precipitation, not conservation efforts. The result was 5.03 MAF, still 530,000 acre-feet over the potential target. In other words, getting to 4.5 MAF/year is likely to be much more painful than accomplishing the reductions so far. 

Yet some pain is likely to be necessary unless the Westโ€™s warming climate does a rapid about-face, and soon. 

๐Ÿ“ธ PARTING SHOT ๐ŸŽž๏ธ
Horse, Torrey, Utah. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

1 * The proposed rule says โ€œonly extreme (D3) and exceptional (D4) droughts would qualify as anomalous drought conditions that can temporarily interrupt perennial flow, and can extend continuously across no more than a five-year timeframe.โ€

2 This is an appropriate monicker, coined by longtime Colorado journalist Allen Best, and is great for those of us in Generation X or older. But I worry that it might not mean much to anyone under the age of, say, 40? So if you have any more contemporary suggestions for a group of superstar water wonks, aka, Jack Schmidt, Anne Castle, Eric Kuhn, Kathryn Sorensen, and Katherine Tara, Iโ€™d love to hear them!

3 Demand response is a term typically used in relation to electricity use. Itโ€™s when large power users, or a collection of smaller users, are paid to reduce electricity consumption during times of high demand to ease grid strain. So, for example, during a heat wave, when everyoneโ€™s air conditioners are running full blast, the utility or grid operator would signal a factory, say, or a data center, or even a host of smart thermostats, to scale back their operations or dial down the AC during the hottest time of the day when solar generation might be dropping off. The targeted drop in consumption has the same effect as increasing power generation would, keeping supply and demand in balance.

Since Jonathan wonders if anyone under 40 will get the reference to the Traveling Wilburys, here you go:

Coyote Gulchโ€™s excellent EV adventure, #ColoradoRiver District Annual Seminar: Day 3, #Cortez to #Fruita #CRD2026

Coyote Gulch’s Ariya charging at the Colorado Energy Office partner Tesla charging facility in Cortez.

Thursday was a travel day from Cortez to Fruita. I hadn’t been able to drive that route in an EV before because of the CHAdeMO connector on my Leaf and the distances involved. The Ariya’s CCS1 charging port and the NACS adapter opened up the route for me, not to mention the Ariya’s superb range. I charged in the morning in Cortez at the Tesla/Colorado Energy Office facility. The NACS to CCS1 adapter is standard equipment so I didn’t have to use the one I brought along. This was also the case in Moab where I charged for the leg to Fruita. I stayed with my 80% level at each charger so I had plenty of charge to make the trip.

The route north and west out of Cortez and dryland pinto bean country into the Spanish Valley with the La Sals to the east is breathtaking. There are opportunities to explore the sights aplenty, including the Needles Overlook. From Moab I drove up UT-128 which runs along the Colorado River until it bends east at the base of the Uncompahgre Plateau at the Dewey Bridge site. You then climb a bit to get to the open desert and Interstate 70. There was plenty of streambed showing in the Colorado River and the flat lands near I-70 were as dry as can be. In May 2023 there was a super bloom along that stretch of highway.

The seminar is today at Colorado Mesa University, a 14 mile bicycle ride from Fruita.

Super Bloom along UT-128 during the last road trip with Mrs. Gulch May 2023.

At #GlenCanyon Dam, the Trump Administration Privileges #Hydropower over Ecosystems: #GrandCanyon ecology not a priority in 2026 water release decisions — Brett Walton (circleofblue.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Glen Canyon Dam. Photo credit: Circle of Blue

Click the link to read the article on the Circle of Blue website (Brett Walton):

September 16, 2026

In the struggling Colorado River basin, where water is scarce, the White House has signaled its priorities for how to use the remaining gallons.

Even as scientifically-determined thresholds have been met for releasing water from Glen Canyon Dam for ecological and recreational benefits in Grand Canyon, the Trump administration has decided against those actions in this record-hot year โ€“ deciding not to release cold water from deep in Lake Powell to aid the humpback chub, a threatened fish species, and not to authorize a high-volume release of water to rebuild Grand Canyonโ€™s eroded beaches, which are in terrible condition, according to federal monitoring.

These environmental releases would not change the total volume of water flowing out of Lake Powell over the year, just the timing.

Because the releases bypass the damโ€™s turbines and reduce hydropower generation, which is part of the administrationโ€™s โ€œenergy dominanceโ€ agenda, the Bureau of Reclamation, the federal agency that manages Glen Canyon Dam, will not be doing them.

โ€œAfter evaluating management alternatives and considering all authorized purposes, the decision was made based on significant hydropower generation concerns under already strained system conditions,โ€ Reclamation said in a statement in August.

The administrationโ€™s decisions foreshadow more difficult choices ahead. Due to climate change and overuse, the Colorado River is shrinking and warming. Its dams were built and river management goals were laid out during an era that anticipated healthy reservoirs. That is no longer the case. Because Lake Powell and Lake Mead are about a quarter of their capacity or less, the hydrological assumptions that inform current management strategies are outdated, said Jack Schmidt, a scientist who has spent his four-decade career studying the Colorado River.

โ€œEverything needs to be revisited because the driving factors of the Colorado River ecosystem in Grand Canyon are now completely changed and probably forever changed,โ€ said Schmidt of Utah State Universityโ€™s Center for Colorado River Studies. โ€œEverything was developed in a world of full reservoirs. And now the reservoirs are empty.โ€

Tradeoffs Plague Water Managers

Even in the best of times, managing a large dam on a major river is not easy. Dams alter the riverโ€™s natural patterns of flow and temperature. Operators must weigh one set of benefits against another group of costs.

Glen Canyon Dam is one of the thorniest management conundrums. Located near the Arizona-Utah border, the 63-year-old structure has emerged as the most significant water-supply choke point in the Colorado River basin and it is the focus of clamorous debate about water and power infrastructure in a drier climate.

The Colorado River strikes a bright jade color as it flows through Marble Canyon, in northern Arizona, a few miles downstream of the Paria River, a significant source of sand for the Grand Canyon. Photo ยฉ Brett Walton/Circle of Blue

As managers grapple with how much water to release, Glen Canyon Dam is also choking the river of its natural supply of sediment. Without new inputs, sand bars and beaches in Grand Canyon are at risk of disappearing. These features provide habitat, give boaters a place to camp during river trips, and protect archaeological sites.

Most of the riverโ€™s sediment now comes from the Paria River and Little Colorado River, downstream of Glen Canyon. Periodic high-flow water releases from the dam mimic the thunderous floods of the past that carried sediment through Grand Canyon to fortify eroding beaches.

There is enough sediment in the Colorado River below Glen Canyon today to warrant a high-flow release. Yet Reclamation has not done one since 2023. Experts agree that Reclamation is highly unlikely to conduct one this fall either. A final decision will be made in the next few weeks.

The need for a high-flow release is mounting. In August, David Topping, a research hydrologist at the U.S. Geological Surveyโ€™s Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center, presented data showing the ill health of Grand Canyon beaches. A typical sand bar is smaller now than in 2016, when the current management plan that established the high-flow triggers was finalized.

The lack of high-flow releases has deprived researchers of crucial data on how the size and duration of these mini-floods, usually one to four days in length, aid beach-building.

Before and after photos of results of the high flow experiment in 2008 via USGS

โ€œWhat can we do if the administration isnโ€™t willing to allow us to use the bypass tubes for high-flow experiments, if thatโ€™s going to be off the table, at least for a while?โ€ said Wayne Pullan, Reclamationโ€™s Upper Colorado Region director, at a Glen Canyon management meeting in August, asking attendees to consider management options under political constraints.

โ€œWeโ€™re in a pinch point,โ€ Pullan added. โ€œA real pinch point.โ€

Degraded beaches result in a degraded river experience, said David Brown of the Grand Canyon River Guides, a recreation advocacy group. Rafting groups have to compete for limited real estate in what is generally regarded as one of the worldโ€™s premier river corridors.

โ€œWhen thereโ€™s less campable area, that means everyoneโ€™s kind of getting squished together or your toilet is next to where people are sleeping,โ€ Brown said.

Non-Native Species Thrive in Warm Water

In addition to sediment, water temperature is the other blinking red environmental indicator.

Air temperature records in the basin are being obliterated this year. Colorado, home to the riverโ€™s headwaters, had its hottest summer ever. Scorching air temperatures are reflected in water. The Colorado River below Lake Powell is the warmest since Glen Canyon Dam was completed.

Raft trip on the Colorado River through Grand Canyon National Park in Arizona, in 2019. Photo ยฉTed Wood/The Water Desk

Smallmouth bass were introduced as a sport fish in the upper Colorado River basin in the late 1960s. Voracious feeders, smallmouth bass view other fish as the sport, happily preying on threatened native species like the humpback chub, an eighteen-inch fish in Grand Canyon with a distinctive smooshed silhouette.

Listed as endangered in 1967, the humpback chub has now bounced back thanks to tens of millions of dollars of conservation investment. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service upgraded the humpback chub to โ€œthreatenedโ€ status in 2018.

Diagram showing critical reservoir levels at Glen Canyon Dam and Lake Powell. Land Desk diagram with data from the Bureau of Reclamation.

Smallmouth bass live in Lake Powell, preferring the layer of warm water closest to the surface. As the lake shrinks, that warm layer has now reached the level of the penstocks, which pull water into Glen Canyon Damโ€™s turbines for hydropower generation before being released downstream.

In these low-water conditions, the fear is that more smallmouth bass will be delivered into the Colorado River below Glen Canyon.

Once there, they will find a habitable environment. Smallmouth bass spawn when water temperatures exceed 60 degrees Fahrenheit. This year, that mark was breached in June. Today, the river at Lees Ferry, about 16 miles downstream of Glen Canyon Dam, is about 70 F.

These conditions โ€“ when the river temperature is above 60 F for three consecutive days โ€“ are supposed to trigger a release of cold water from deep in Lake Powell. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says that this โ€œcool mixโ€ is the โ€œonly conservation measure proven to limit smallmouth bass reproduction.โ€ Evidence from cool mix releases in 2024 and 2025, which knocked down smallmouth bass numbers, supports that conclusion.

Cool mix, however, will not happen in 2026 due to the Trump administrationโ€™s desire to generate hydropower.

The last cool mix flow, in 2025, cost the Western Area Power Administration, which markets federal hydropower, $6.1 million to replace that electricity for its contractors.

Instead of cool mix, Reclamation says it is focusing on other options to keep smallmouth bass from establishing downstream of Glen Canyon and to preserve the humpback chubโ€™s hard-won conservation gains. In the short term that means stunning the bass with electric-shock tools and physically removing them from the water.

In the longer term, Reclamation is considering installing infrastructure to regulate the temperature of the water that passes through Glen Canyon. The agency calls this one of its โ€œdurable structural solutions.โ€

An Uncertain Future

Cool mix and high-flow releases are an attempt to rebalance an ecosystem that the dams destabilized. Congress passed the Grand Canyon Protection Act of 1992, which orders Reclamation to operate Glen Canyon Dam in a manner that protects and reduces harm to the โ€œnatural and cultural resources and visitor use.โ€ That is, fish, tribal archaeological sites, and rafting.

The act required an environmental impact statement for Glen Canyon Dam that would analyze the actions required to achieve the broad environmental-protection goals set by Congress.

It was a โ€œcompromise to really put all the resources on the same playing field,โ€ said Jen Pelz of the Grand Canyon Trust. In her view, decisions this year tilt in one direction โ€“ hydropower. โ€œI donโ€™t feel like theyโ€™re being balanced right now.โ€

Because the river guides were instrumental in lobbying for Grand Canyon protections, the present-day failures to uphold the actโ€™s goals are all the more galling, Brown said. โ€œItโ€™s very hard to watch it get ignored.โ€

Glen Canyon Damโ€™s powerhouse holds the electricity-generating turbines. Photo ยฉ Brett Walton/Circle of Blue

The administration is prioritizing hydropower when hydropower is at a pivot point.

Generation at Glen Canyon is down more than 40% from when Lake Powell was full. Utilities are turning to solar and wind to cover some of the generation losses, while utility-scale batteries are helping to replace the capacity and grid-regulating functions that a large dam provides.

The decision to favor hydropower over ecology reflects bigger problems with the Colorado Riverโ€™s infrastructure. Glen Canyon Dam is not designed for the river as it exists today. Reclamation wants to keep Lake Powell high enough to generate hydropower because the damโ€™s other outlets to deliver water downstream are untested over long periods and were damaged in a previous high-flow release.

Lower basin states and tribes, including Arizona, California, Nevada, and the Gila River Indian Community, have asked the federal government to update Glen Canyonโ€™s infrastructure for water delivery and power generation. Reclamation is assessing three options and expects that study to be released in early 2027. Any additional action will require congressional approval and funding.

Along with the infrastructure problems, man-made climate change is sapping the river and heating up its water. Ecologists consider the Grand Canyon a โ€œnovel ecosystem,โ€ meaning its native species and natural processes have been disrupted and rearranged by human meddling.

To Schmidt, the former chief of the U.S. Geological Surveyโ€™s Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center, this suggests a wholesale rethinking not just of the riverโ€™s infrastructure but also of our ecological goals for the Colorado River.

โ€œWe as a society get to play God in deciding what attributes of that ecosystem we value, which ones we want to work hard to preserve and which ones we donโ€™t,โ€ he said. โ€œThe answer is not an obvious one.โ€

This story was produced by Circle of Blue, in partnership with The Water Desk at the University of Colorado Boulderโ€™s Center for Environmental Journalism.

For full Colorado River basin coverage, visit our Colorado River page.

Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0