For the homeward drive, I charged at the newish Ionna chargers in Fruita. I was pulling over 100 KW at the start. Very fast. I bumped up in Glenwood Springs and had enough charge to get home, but owing to my range anxiety, I added 10% in Silverthorne. At the top of Loveland Pass the controls indicated 36% battery charge and an estimated 78 miles of range. But, as fans of regenerative charging know, when I arrived at Gulch Manor the spread was 32% charge and estimated range of 108 miles. It is pretty much downhill from Loveland Pass to my place, 11,990 feet down to 5,400 feet or so, on Berkeley Hill in Denver.
Most of the day Saturday was taken up by the climb from Fruita to the Continental Divide of the Americas.
Coyote Gulch’s Ariya at the summit of Loveland Pass September 19, 2026.
All in all I charged at ChargePoint, Tesla, Tesla/Colorado Energy Office, Rivian, and Ionna chargers. I am so happy with the performance of my Ariya on the first road trip — ~950 miles.
Seminar day did not include an EV element. I ride my bicycle from Fruita to Grand Junction along the Colorado Riverfront Trail. The 14 mile ride has great views of the Colorado National Monument, Grand Mesa, and Mt. Sentinel.
Colorado National Monument from the Colorado Riverfront Trail near Fruita September 18, 2026.
Of course the Colorado River is front and center and it was so gratifying to see the river running with sediment.
Colorado River running muddy September 18, 2026.
It had been rainy all week in western Colorado and you could tell, it was enough to get near average streamflow at the Utah line.
My main takeaway from the seminar was that West Slope water users shared supplies to get through these rough times. Collaboration was mentioned several times as was, “We didn’t call anyone out.”
Check out my live-posts from seminar on my BlueSky feed or the seminar hash tag (click on the “Latest” tab).
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Denver Water can finish its Gross Dam expansion and fill the controversial reservoir in western Boulder County, the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Tuesday, lifting an injunction by a lower court judge and confirming the damโs permits as sound.
The appeals court said the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers had acted responsibly in issuing construction permits for the $600 million expansion, which is largely complete and will be filled using water rights Denver holds in the Colorado River basin on the western side of the Continental Divide.
โWe do not think the Corpsโs choice of cost methodology was arbitrary or capricious,โ the appeals court ruling said. The plaintiffs, including nonprofit Save the Colorado, argued the Corps rejected clear evidence of climate change, but the appeals court ruled the Corps gave the research fair consideration.
โThe Corps considered โ and rejected โ the reliability of that and similar studies, one of which showed that in the Colorado River Basin, โno consistent trends in annual precipitation have been detected over the last 100 years,โโ the appeals court said.
โIn the end, the environmental groups ask us to substitute our judgment for the Corpsโs. They point out scientific studies that, in their view, rebut the Corpsโs reading of the scientific literature and ask us to opine on what the scientific research establishes,โ the appellate ruling said. โBut our job is not to second-guess the Corpsโs assessment as long as it rests on a reasoned basis.โ
โWeโre pleased to see the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals confirm that the Gross Reservoir Expansion Project was lawfully permitted by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and that Denver Water can proceed with the final stages of this critical project to ensure a safe, secure water supply for the 1.5 million people we serve,โ according to a statement from spokesperson Todd Hartman. โWith this decision, Denver Water can move forward with completion of construction, site preparation and eventual filling of the expanded reservoir. An expanded Gross Reservoir is vital to the future of the Denver region.โ
Itโs nonsensical to be putting more straws in, and further draining, the Colorado River at this point in history,โ Wockner said. โThat the law allows it to happen doesnโt make it right, it just makes it legal. I saw something wrong, I stood up, spoke out and took action. It was the right thing to do and I would do it all over again.โ
Wockner said Tuesday the plaintiffs would not be appealing the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Gross Reservoir Dam backs up South Boulder Creek, while also taking in water through the Moffat Tunnel under the divide, from the Fraser and Williams Fork rivers in the Colorado River basin. Denver Water has said the expansion is needed to balance its water storage system currently heavily concentrated on the southern end of the metro area.
The Trump administrationโs Environmental Protection Agency is proposing to further constrain the reach and potency of the Clean Water Act by re-defining what qualifies as โwaters of the United States,โ or WOTUS, which are streams, wetlands, and other water bodies under federal jurisdiction. The proposed definition would disproportionately affect the arid West by lifting protections from thousands of miles of streams, arroyos, and wetlands.
Under the CWA, a firm or individual looking to discharge pollutants or other material into, or dredge or reroute or otherwise alter, a WOTUS waterway must obtain a federal permit from the EPA or Army Corps of Engineers. A battle has raged for more than five decades over what constitutes a WOTUS. The Supreme Courtโs 2023 Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency ruling called for a narrower definition, handing industry and right-wing ideologues a major victory.
Ephemeral streams are streams that do not always flow. They are above the groundwater reservoir and appear after precipitation in the area. Via Socratic.org
The changes in the latest proposed supplemental rule are even more exclusionary than the administrationโs November 2025 proposal, which removed โephemeralโ and โintermittentโ waterways โ i.e. arroyos or washes that run only after rains or snowmelt โ from federal jurisdiction. Included as a WOTUS under that proposal were โrelatively permanent โฆ bodies of surface water that are standing or continuously flowing year-round or at least during the wet season.โ
The new proposal omits the โwet seasonโ verbiage. It then defines โrelatively permanentโ to be synonymous with โperennial,โ which in turn is defined as โโhaving standing or continuously flowing water every day of the year during ordinary conditions.โโ However, โa body of water does not lose its relatively permanent status if it dries up as a result of anomalous events such as drought or dry spell.1 A body of water also does not lose its relatively permanent status if it dries up for no more than a single period of up to 30 consecutive days in any given year as a result of non-anomalous events resulting in a temporary interruption such as low tide or a regularly occurring dry spell.โ Yet, โif flow is interrupted for two periods in any given year, and each period consists of 10 consecutive days of no flow, the water body would not be jurisdictional.โ
A Natural Resources Defense Council analysis found that the new proposal would remove protections from more than 94% of the nationโs wetlands and about 79% of its streams. The changes would hit the West hardest, leaving a state like Arizona with almost no federally protected streams or wetlands.
So hereโs my interpretation of where the updated proposal leaves us:
WOTUS waterways (keeps CWA protections): A year-round river, stream, or lake that never dries up, such as the Animas River, the San Juan River, the Colorado River, the Gunnison River, Cement Creek, Mineral Creek, the Fremont River, and so on, would retain federal protections under the CWA. However, since most of these rivers are fed by intermittent or ephemeral streams, they would also be potentially affected (since is someone altered or polluted a tributary, the effects would eventually reach the mainstem).
Non-WOTUS waterways (would lose CWA protections): All intermittent and ephemeral streams, i.e. arroyos or washes that run only when it rains, such as are ubiquitous in the arid West, would be removed from federal jurisdiction. Other streams and rivers that run seasonally, but regularly dry up for more than 30 consecutive days per year, such as the Paria River, the Dirty Devil, Rio Puerco, Santa Cruz River, or the Mancos River, would also lose federal protections, as would wetlands that are only โwetโ for part of the year.
Vague WOTUS status: Rivers or streams that are perennial as a whole, but on which certain segments dry up for more than 30 days per year (usually because of upstream diversions), e.g.: the Rio Grande through Albuquerque, long sections of the Lower Dolores River between McPhee Dam and its confluence with the San Miguel, the North Fork of the Gunnison around Paonia, lower reaches of the La Plata River, or Junction Creek through Durango, and numerous desert rivers in Arizona and New Mexico.
While the proposed rule would remove federal CWA protections from many waterways, it would not automatically give developers or industry free rein to bulldoze or dump toxic waste into them. State and local laws would still apply, and arroyos and streams on public land would still be protected to some degree by federal environmental laws. Colorado lawmakers passed a bill in 2024 that effectively backfilled the regulatory gap left by the Sackett decision. New Mexico also has moved to implement its own layer of water protections. In more industry-friendly states such as Idaho and Utah, the proposed rule would leave thousands of miles of streams and waterways vulnerable to development and pollution.
The proposed rule is open to public comments until Oct. 9. You may send comments, identified by Docket ID No. EPAโHQโ OWโ2025โ0322, by any of the following methods:
Federal eRulemaking Portal: https://www.regulations.gov/. Follow the online instructions for submitting comments.
Email: OW-Docket@epa.gov. Include Docket ID No. EPAโHQโOWโ 2025โ0322 in the subject line of the message. โข
Mail: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, EPA Docket Center, Water Docket, Mail Code 28221T, 1200 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20460.
Hand Delivery or Courier: EPA Docket Center, WJC West Building, Room 3334, 1301 Constitution Avenue NW, Washington, DC 20004.
For more background on the long and winding struggle to define WOTUS, check out the following:
My February 2022 High Country News piece on the Supreme Court taking up the Sackett Case, including a detailed timeline of the WOTUS definition battle.
And, from the Land Desk archives (youโll need a paid subscription for access):
A new paper is out from the group of Colorado River experts known by some as the โTraveling Wilburys of the Colorado River Basin,โ2 and lo and behold, it actually contains some good news. Namely this: The Lower Basin users have managed to make significant reductions in water use over the last decade and a half without turning the Southwest into a dust-choked wasteland and getting ahead of the latest round of mandated cuts. This indicates that the users can continue to slash water use in the future โ to a degree โ if necessary.
The Lower Basin accounts for about 60% of all consumptive water uses and losses on the Colorado River. Irrigated agriculture, in turn, makes up about 60% of the Lower Basinโs consumptive use. The Imperial Irrigation District, which is primarily agricultural, is the largest single water user on the entire river. This means that the agricultural sector โ and the IID in particular โ โwill play a significant role in future reductions in water use,โ as the authors put it.
So far, the Lower Basinโs farmers and the IID have stepped up. In 2025, the Lower Basin statesโ consumptive use was 5.76 million acre-feet, the lowest since at least 2010. Since 2023, California has used about 13% less water, a reduction attributable mostly to cuts at IID.
Source: The Colorado River Water Supply Crisis in a Few Graphs: Part 2 Agricultural Water Use in the Lower Basin.
Figure 3. Consumptive use in Arizona since 2010. Estimated use in 2026 based on forecast of September 1, 2026.
Notably, IIDโs reductions came mostly during the summer months, the peak season for field crops such as alfalfa, Bermuda grass, and kleingrass, when itโs too hot to grow most garden crops, such as lettuce, onions, and broccoli. During the vegetablesโ growing season, from November through March, water use stayed roughly the same as before. A similar, but less dramatic, dynamic shows up in Arizona.
Figure 6. Box-and-whisker plots of total monthly consumptive use by the IID between 2010 and 2026. Each box is the Inter Quartile Range, defined by the 25th and 75th percentile of the years of data for that month. These boxes represent the typical monthly use pattern since 2010. Red dots are the average use in each month between 2024 and 2026. See text for additional explanation of a box-and-whisker plot.
This suggests a couple of things: 1. The Imperial Irrigation District and other large agricultural users may be able to significantly lower overall water use without harming important garden crops such as broccoli and carrots (easing fears that the Colorado River crisis will deprive us of vegetables); and, 2. The IID is successfully using its vast alfalfa crop as a giant water demand-response tool3. That is, through both fallowing some fields and putting others on a summer water diet, the districtโs farmers have managed to slash water use, while still growing gobs of hay and alfalfa.
And because the IID still has about 150,000 acres of alfalfa, it has huge potential for future water cuts through these same methods, which is the good news. The bad news is that the federal plan for operating the river contemplates Lower Basin cuts of up to 3 million acre-feet per year (resulting in a total annual consumption of 4.5 MAF), which is about twice what the Basin has already achieved.
To consider the viability of such cuts, the authors summed up the smallest monthly use in each Lower Basin state since 2010, even though they didnโt occur simultaneously, and even though in some cases the reductions were due to heavy precipitation, not conservation efforts. The result was 5.03 MAF, still 530,000 acre-feet over the potential target. In other words, getting to 4.5 MAF/year is likely to be much more painful than accomplishing the reductions so far.
Yet some pain is likely to be necessary unless the Westโs warming climate does a rapid about-face, and soon.
๐ธ PARTING SHOT ๐๏ธ
Horse, Torrey, Utah. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
1 * The proposed rule says โonly extreme (D3) and exceptional (D4) droughts would qualify as anomalous drought conditions that can temporarily interrupt perennial flow, and can extend continuously across no more than a five-year timeframe.โ
2 This is an appropriate monicker, coined by longtime Colorado journalist Allen Best, and is great for those of us in Generation X or older. But I worry that it might not mean much to anyone under the age of, say, 40? So if you have any more contemporary suggestions for a group of superstar water wonks, aka, Jack Schmidt, Anne Castle, Eric Kuhn, Kathryn Sorensen, and Katherine Tara, Iโd love to hear them!
3 Demand response is a term typically used in relation to electricity use. Itโs when large power users, or a collection of smaller users, are paid to reduce electricity consumption during times of high demand to ease grid strain. So, for example, during a heat wave, when everyoneโs air conditioners are running full blast, the utility or grid operator would signal a factory, say, or a data center, or even a host of smart thermostats, to scale back their operations or dial down the AC during the hottest time of the day when solar generation might be dropping off. The targeted drop in consumption has the same effect as increasing power generation would, keeping supply and demand in balance.
Since Jonathan wonders if anyone under 40 will get the reference to the Traveling Wilburys, here you go:
Coyote Gulch’s Ariya charging at the Colorado Energy Office partner Tesla charging facility in Cortez.
Thursday was a travel day from Cortez to Fruita. I hadn’t been able to drive that route in an EV before because of the CHAdeMO connector on my Leaf and the distances involved. The Ariya’s CCS1 charging port and the NACS adapter opened up the route for me, not to mention the Ariya’s superb range. I charged in the morning in Cortez at the Tesla/Colorado Energy Office facility. The NACS to CCS1 adapter is standard equipment so I didn’t have to use the one I brought along. This was also the case in Moab where I charged for the leg to Fruita. I stayed with my 80% level at each charger so I had plenty of charge to make the trip.
The route north and west out of Cortez and dryland pinto bean country into the Spanish Valley with the La Sals to the east is breathtaking. There are opportunities to explore the sights aplenty, including the Needles Overlook. From Moab I drove up UT-128 which runs along the Colorado River until it bends east at the base of the Uncompahgre Plateau at the Dewey Bridge site. You then climb a bit to get to the open desert and Interstate 70. There was plenty of streambed showing in the Colorado River and the flat lands near I-70 were as dry as can be. In May 2023 there was a super bloom along that stretch of highway.
The seminar is today at Colorado Mesa University, a 14 mile bicycle ride from Fruita.
Super Bloom along UT-128 during the last road trip with Mrs. Gulch May 2023.
In the struggling Colorado River basin, where water is scarce, the White House has signaled its priorities for how to use the remaining gallons.
Even as scientifically-determined thresholds have been met for releasing water from Glen Canyon Dam for ecological and recreational benefits in Grand Canyon, the Trump administration has decided against those actions in this record-hot year โ deciding not to release cold water from deep in Lake Powell to aid the humpback chub, a threatened fish species, and not to authorize a high-volume release of water to rebuild Grand Canyonโs eroded beaches, which are in terrible condition, according to federal monitoring.
These environmental releases would not change the total volume of water flowing out of Lake Powell over the year, just the timing.
Because the releases bypass the damโs turbines and reduce hydropower generation, which is part of the administrationโs โenergy dominanceโ agenda, the Bureau of Reclamation, the federal agency that manages Glen Canyon Dam, will not be doing them.
โAfter evaluating management alternatives and considering all authorized purposes, the decision was made based on significant hydropower generation concerns under already strained system conditions,โ Reclamation said in a statement in August.
The administrationโs decisions foreshadow more difficult choices ahead. Due to climate change and overuse, the Colorado River is shrinking and warming. Its dams were built and river management goals were laid out during an era that anticipated healthy reservoirs. That is no longer the case. Because Lake Powell and Lake Mead are about a quarter of their capacity or less, the hydrological assumptions that inform current management strategies are outdated, said Jack Schmidt, a scientist who has spent his four-decade career studying the Colorado River.
โEverything needs to be revisited because the driving factors of the Colorado River ecosystem in Grand Canyon are now completely changed and probably forever changed,โ said Schmidt of Utah State Universityโs Center for Colorado River Studies. โEverything was developed in a world of full reservoirs. And now the reservoirs are empty.โ
Tradeoffs Plague Water Managers
Even in the best of times, managing a large dam on a major river is not easy. Dams alter the riverโs natural patterns of flow and temperature. Operators must weigh one set of benefits against another group of costs.
Glen Canyon Dam is one of the thorniest management conundrums. Located near the Arizona-Utah border, the 63-year-old structure has emerged as the most significant water-supply choke point in the Colorado River basin and it is the focus of clamorous debate about water and power infrastructure in a drier climate.
The Colorado River strikes a bright jade color as it flows through Marble Canyon, in northern Arizona, a few miles downstream of the Paria River, a significant source of sand for the Grand Canyon. Photo ยฉ Brett Walton/Circle of Blue
As managers grapple with how much water to release, Glen Canyon Dam is also choking the river of its natural supply of sediment. Without new inputs, sand bars and beaches in Grand Canyon are at risk of disappearing. These features provide habitat, give boaters a place to camp during river trips, and protect archaeological sites.
Most of the riverโs sediment now comes from the Paria River and Little Colorado River, downstream of Glen Canyon. Periodic high-flow water releases from the dam mimic the thunderous floods of the past that carried sediment through Grand Canyon to fortify eroding beaches.
There is enough sediment in the Colorado River below Glen Canyon today to warrant a high-flow release. Yet Reclamation has not done one since 2023. Experts agree that Reclamation is highly unlikely to conduct one this fall either. A final decision will be made in the next few weeks.
The need for a high-flow release is mounting. In August, David Topping, a research hydrologist at the U.S. Geological Surveyโs Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center, presented data showing the ill health of Grand Canyon beaches. A typical sand bar is smaller now than in 2016, when the current management plan that established the high-flow triggers was finalized.
The lack of high-flow releases has deprived researchers of crucial data on how the size and duration of these mini-floods, usually one to four days in length, aid beach-building.
Before and after photos of results of the high flow experiment in 2008 via USGS
โWhat can we do if the administration isnโt willing to allow us to use the bypass tubes for high-flow experiments, if thatโs going to be off the table, at least for a while?โ said Wayne Pullan, Reclamationโs Upper Colorado Region director, at a Glen Canyon management meeting in August, asking attendees to consider management options under political constraints.
โWeโre in a pinch point,โ Pullan added. โA real pinch point.โ
Degraded beaches result in a degraded river experience, said David Brown of the Grand Canyon River Guides, a recreation advocacy group. Rafting groups have to compete for limited real estate in what is generally regarded as one of the worldโs premier river corridors.
โWhen thereโs less campable area, that means everyoneโs kind of getting squished together or your toilet is next to where people are sleeping,โ Brown said.
Non-Native Species Thrive in Warm Water
In addition to sediment, water temperature is the other blinking red environmental indicator.
Raft trip on the Colorado River through Grand Canyon National Park in Arizona, in 2019. Photo ยฉTed Wood/The Water Desk
Smallmouth bass were introduced as a sport fish in the upper Colorado River basin in the late 1960s. Voracious feeders, smallmouth bass view other fish as the sport, happily preying on threatened native species like the humpback chub, an eighteen-inch fish in Grand Canyon with a distinctive smooshed silhouette.
Listed as endangered in 1967, the humpback chub has now bounced back thanks to tens of millions of dollars of conservation investment. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service upgraded the humpback chub to โthreatenedโ status in 2018.
Diagram showing critical reservoir levels at Glen Canyon Dam and Lake Powell. Land Desk diagram with data from the Bureau of Reclamation.
Smallmouth bass live in Lake Powell, preferring the layer of warm water closest to the surface. As the lake shrinks, that warm layer has now reached the level of the penstocks, which pull water into Glen Canyon Damโs turbines for hydropower generation before being released downstream.
In these low-water conditions, the fear is that more smallmouth bass will be delivered into the Colorado River below Glen Canyon.
Once there, they will find a habitable environment. Smallmouth bass spawn when water temperatures exceed 60 degrees Fahrenheit. This year, that mark was breached in June. Today, the river at Lees Ferry, about 16 miles downstream of Glen Canyon Dam, is about 70 F.
These conditions โ when the river temperature is above 60 F for three consecutive days โ are supposed to trigger a release of cold water from deep in Lake Powell. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service says that this โcool mixโ is the โonly conservation measure proven to limit smallmouth bass reproduction.โ Evidence from cool mix releases in 2024 and 2025, which knocked down smallmouth bass numbers, supports that conclusion.
Cool mix, however, will not happen in 2026 due to the Trump administrationโs desire to generate hydropower.
The last cool mix flow, in 2025, cost the Western Area Power Administration, which markets federal hydropower, $6.1 million to replace that electricity for its contractors.
Instead of cool mix, Reclamation says it is focusing on other options to keep smallmouth bass from establishing downstream of Glen Canyon and to preserve the humpback chubโs hard-won conservation gains. In the short term that means stunning the bass with electric-shock tools and physically removing them from the water.
In the longer term, Reclamation is considering installing infrastructure to regulate the temperature of the water that passes through Glen Canyon. The agency calls this one of its โdurable structural solutions.โ
An Uncertain Future
Cool mix and high-flow releases are an attempt to rebalance an ecosystem that the dams destabilized. Congress passed the Grand Canyon Protection Act of 1992, which orders Reclamation to operate Glen Canyon Dam in a manner that protects and reduces harm to the โnatural and cultural resources and visitor use.โ That is, fish, tribal archaeological sites, and rafting.
The act required an environmental impact statement for Glen Canyon Dam that would analyze the actions required to achieve the broad environmental-protection goals set by Congress.
It was a โcompromise to really put all the resources on the same playing field,โ said Jen Pelz of the Grand Canyon Trust. In her view, decisions this year tilt in one direction โ hydropower. โI donโt feel like theyโre being balanced right now.โ
Because the river guides were instrumental in lobbying for Grand Canyon protections, the present-day failures to uphold the actโs goals are all the more galling, Brown said. โItโs very hard to watch it get ignored.โ
Glen Canyon Damโs powerhouse holds the electricity-generating turbines. Photo ยฉ Brett Walton/Circle of Blue
The administration is prioritizing hydropower when hydropower is at a pivot point.
Generation at Glen Canyon is down more than 40% from when Lake Powell was full. Utilities are turning to solar and wind to cover some of the generation losses, while utility-scale batteries are helping to replace the capacity and grid-regulating functions that a large dam provides.
The decision to favor hydropower over ecology reflects bigger problems with the Colorado Riverโs infrastructure. Glen Canyon Dam is not designed for the river as it exists today. Reclamation wants to keep Lake Powell high enough to generate hydropower because the damโs other outlets to deliver water downstream are untested over long periods and were damaged in a previous high-flow release.
Lower basin states and tribes, including Arizona, California, Nevada, and the Gila River Indian Community, have asked the federal government to update Glen Canyonโs infrastructure for water delivery and power generation. Reclamation is assessing three options and expects that study to be released in early 2027. Any additional action will require congressional approval and funding.
Along with the infrastructure problems, man-made climate change is sapping the river and heating up its water. Ecologists consider the Grand Canyon a โnovel ecosystem,โ meaning its native species and natural processes have been disrupted and rearranged by human meddling.
To Schmidt, the former chief of the U.S. Geological Surveyโs Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center, this suggests a wholesale rethinking not just of the riverโs infrastructure but also of our ecological goals for the Colorado River.
โWe as a society get to play God in deciding what attributes of that ecosystem we value, which ones we want to work hard to preserve and which ones we donโt,โ he said. โThe answer is not an obvious one.โ
This story was produced by Circle of Blue, in partnership withThe Water Deskat the University of Colorado Boulderโs Center for Environmental Journalism.
Just days after President Donald Trump angered U.S. ranchers by waiving tariffs on 300,000 metric tons of foreign beef (and whatever other meat-adjacent-material may pass as beef), he threw the livestock industry a bone by ordering a โreviewโ of federal Endangered Species Act protections for gray and Mexican wolves. The order also instructs the Interior Department to push states into removing any state-specific protections and to โrevise their standards for lethal takings of gray wolves and Mexican wolves to assist ranchers in combating predation.โ
In other words, Trump wants to revive the late 19th and early 20th century campaign to exterminate wild predators to benefit ranchers. Will this please a handful of public lands livestock operators who are ideologically inclined to hate wolves, whether they affect their operations or not? Sure. Will it save the American rancher, or even offset the influx of foreign beef? Nope.
Wolves do kill cattle if they are not adequately protected (and the rancher is compensated for the lost livestock), and they can have other impacts on ranching operations in wild areas. But study after study has shown that other factors โ from weather and climate, to sickness and disease โ account for a far greater share of cattle and calf mortalities.
This is the administrationโs latest ploy in its quest to boost the number of cattle on public lands. It is also peddling vacated grazing allotments and easing the already decidedly lax regulations on grazing.
Federal staffing rosters show the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has lost 36% of its staff under the Trump administration, dripping from 9,957 staffers to 6,333 between 2024 and 2026, likely exacerbating a backlog of Endangered Species Act listing decisions.ย (news release)
Milkweed and sweet peas along the Farmers Ditch in the North Fork Valley (and a reminder that irrigation ditches support more than just crops). Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
๐ย COLORADO RIVER CHRONICLESย ๐ง
The irrigation canals, laterals, and ditches are going dry in the Colorado Riverโs Upper Basin weeks before the growing season comes to an end, forcing farmers to rely on September rains or their own storage to get their crops to harvest time. It goes to show that even without mandatory cuts, many Upper Basin water users experience water shortages during dry years.
The biggest and latest user to get cut off by low river flows was the Grand Valley Water Users Association, which began drawing down its Government Highline Canal as โthe river flows drop to undeliverable levels.โ Flows in that canal fell from almost 1,500 cfs at the end of August to about 725 cfs early this week. The more senior Orchard Mesa Irrigation District and Grand Valley Irrigation Company continued to pull water from the river and deliver it to irrigators.
In the North Fork Valley, all but the most senior ditches were shut off weeks ago, after Paonia Reservoir hit dead pool. And on the Dolores River, even the most senior water rights holders โ the Montezuma Valley Irrigation District โ lost their water at the beginning of this month. Usually it holds out for at least another couple of weeks. (Other water users received dramatically curtailed amounts throughout the irrigating season).
In the Grand Valley, the canalโs loss was the riverโs gain: The Colorado River near Palisade, after running as low as 42 cfs this summer, bounced back to around 300 cfs at the end of August. A corresponding increase in flow can be seen at the USGS gage1 near Cisco. This little boost, combined with a few intense, but patchy storms, and a slight increase in releases from Flaming Gorge Reservoir, have brought up inflows into Lake Powell, somewhat slowing the drop in surface levels.
Dolores River watershed
The Dolores River, on the other hand, remains virtually dry downstream of McPhee Dam, and McPhee Reservoirโs surface level is currently about 12 feet lower than it was a year ago.
A tale of water inequality in the West — Jonathan P. Thompson, “I wrote the essay [click the link]โabout my parentsโ farmโs ditch in the North Fork Valley of Western Coloradoโin 2018, which was one of the regionโs driest years on record. The essay is every bit as pertinent today, an equally dry time for most of the Western Slope, even if some details have changed: My sister owns the farm nowโalong with the robust water rightsโโฆ”
The Central Arizona Projectโs board of directorsย authorizes its attorneys to take legal action โif necessaryโ to protect its allotment of Colorado River against the Bureau of Reclamationโs plans for operating the riverโs infrastructure in the coming decade. The CAP stands to lose the most water under a shortage, as Arizona agreed to junior water rights in exchange for federal funding for the vast plumbing project that delivers river water to the central and southern parts of the state. Nevada already sued the federal government over potential cuts to its share of water.ย (Arizona Republic)
Western Colorado anglers and boatersย call on the Bureau of Reclamation to increase water releases from Blue Mesa, Morrow Point, and Crystal Reservoirs to preserve streamflows in the Gunnison River in the Black Canyon, the Gunnison Gorge, and further downstream, saying the decision to reduce releases to protect reservoir levels has โexerted a toll on a vital and cherished natural resource.โย (Aspen Journalism)
๐คย DATA CENTER WATCHย ๐พ
The Big Data Center Buildup drives up electricity demandย in Wyoming and spurs a wave of proposed gas plants, some of which would serve the grid and others dedicated to powering server farm facilities.ย (WyoFile)
โ๏ธย MINING MONITORย โ๏ธ
The Southern Ute Indian Tribe says it will pull out all of the stops to block potential mining projectsย in the La Plata Mountains in southwestern Colorado, adding to the list of entities opposing Metallic Mineralsโย exploratory drilling projectย on the western side of the range.ย (Durango Herald)
New Mexico Land Commissioner Stephanie Garcia Richardย puts state trust lands off-limits to new uranium mining leases, and orders her office to instead focus on cleaning up the more than 1,000 former uranium mining-related sites in the state. The order does not affect private or federal lands.ย (news release)
Anfield Energy looks to raise at least $50 millionย to finance its plan to refurbish and reopen the Shootaring uranium mill โ which has been idle since 1982 โ near Ticaboo, Utah. Anfield is the firm behind the Velvet-Wood uranium mine in the Lisbon Valley and has designs on mining near Slick Rock, Colorado.ย (Northern Miner)
๐ตย PUBLIC LANDSย ๐ฒ
A federal judge temporarily blocks the Trump administrationโs effortย to evict bison from public lands in Montana, finding that the Bureau of Land Managementโs decision to kick the animals off American Prairie-held grazing leases was likely โarbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, and otherwise not in accordance with the law.โย (Public Domain)
The U.S. Department of Agriculture releases its final Forest Service reorganization plan, which includes moving the headquarters to Salt Lake City and shuttering 23 facilities nationwide, including four in California, one in New Mexico, and one in Oregon, with the remainder being in non-Western states. The USDA says โless than 200โ of the agencyโs 30,000 employees are expected to need to relocate, mostly from Washington, D.C. to Fort Collins, Salt Lake City, or a newly established center.ย (news release,ย OPB)
The Center for Western Priorities fact-checks Interior Secretary Doug Burgumโs numerous erroneous statements about the administrationโs dramatic reduction of Grand Staircase-Escalante and Bears Ears National Monuments, finding that on this topic (and others) the cabinet member is a serial liar.ย (Westwise)
๐ ย RANDOM REAL ESTATE ROOMย ๐ค
Anita Verma-Lallian, a real estate investor who made her name buying and selling multi-million-dollar Phoenix-area properties for data centers, unveils a plan for a massive development in Tonopah, Arizona. Tentative plans for the $6 billion to $10 billion development include a movie studio, amusement park, hotels, retail, and a data center complex. The property is adjacent to one where Bill Gatesโ investment firm is planning a โfuturistic smart city.โย (Phoenix Business Journal via KTAR)
๐ปย TRANSPORTATIONย ๐
The Utah Department of Transportation completes the $152 million Energy Corridorย highway improvement project on State Routes 162 and 262 in San Juan County. The routes pass through the Aneth Oil Field and could potentially be used for uranium ore haul trucks traveling from New Mexico mines to the White Mesa Mill near Blanding.ย (ABC4)
๐คฏย ANNALS OF INANITYย ๐คก
When will it stop!?!ย Amid a flurry of inane, bizarre, and cognitively-impaired social media posts, President Donald Trump on Sunday suggested New Mexicoโs name should be changed to โNew America.โย ย (CNN)
๐ย TODAYโs DATAVIZย ๐
Are coal and electricity consumption getting back together? For the latter half of the 20th century, U.S. coal consumption climbed in tandem with electricity demand: As Americans used more power, more coal was burned to generate that power, and vice versa. In 2008, electricity demand plummeted due to the financial crisis, dragging coal consumption down with it.
While electricity demand rebounded along with the economy, and then plateaued, coal-burning continued dropping precipitously; the two phenomena had been decoupled from one another. But over the last three years electricity demand has shot back up, in large part due to data centersโ guzzling up a lot of power, but also because of electrification of transportation and buildings, and an increasing need for air-conditioning to fend off rising temperatures. And last year the electric power sectorโs coal consumption shot back up as well. Is the decoupling being undone? Or is this just a minor blip? Only time will tell.
Dataviz by the Land Desk using stats from the Energy Information Administration.
๐ธ PARTING SHOT ๐๏ธ
Continuing with the opening theme โฆ Sign near Bowie, Colorado. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
1 Yes, I use the archaic โgageโ instead of โgaugeโ when referring to USGS streamflow monitors, not just because Iโm archaic, but because thatโsย what the USGS does.
Black Canyon of the Gunnison. Photo credit: NPS/Kris Toy
From email from Reclamation (Andrew Limbach):
On Monday, September 14th at 8:00 AM (MDT), the UVWUA will begin ramping down tunnel diversions to 675-700 cfs. In coordination with that effort, Crystal releases will decrease to 875-900 cfs from 1240 cfs, and flows through the Black Canyon will be between 200-225 cfs. Tunnel diversions are anticipated to be at 700 cfs through October 31.
The Crystal outlet works typically experiences increased levels of cavitation between 900 and 1200 cfs. Therefore, Crystal releases may need to be adjusted as needed to find an optimal operating zone. Recreators and boaters in the Black Canyon should expect fluctuations of river flows until the final releases and diversions are set. Another notification will be sent out once the releases are finalized.
Green Mountain Reservoir August 17, 2026. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots
Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):
September 7, 2026
No place in Colorado that I have visited offers such blunt testimony to the warming, drying climate than Green Mountain Reservoir. It also poses a question to those politicians whose answer to non-winters and ever-hotter summers is more dams and reservoirs.
The reservoir between Silverthorne and Kremmling was 14% full during Labor Day weekend, according to the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, the operator. Put another way, it was 86% empty.
Thatโs worse even than the roughly 78% empty at Lake Powell, the reservoir located roughly 700 river miles downstream from Green Mountain.
Green Mountain was part of Coloradoโs mission begun in the 19th century to put water to โbeneficial use,โ a central axiom of state water law. Pioneer settlers did an admirable job of this, in the beginning using nothing more than horses, oxen and human labor.
In 1902, the federal government became a partner, creating the Bureau of Reclamation. Over the next roughly 90 years, the federal treasury was visited repeatedly to prevent โwasteโ of any portion of the Colorado River flowing into the Pacific Ocean.
Green Mountain Reservoir, back in the day. Photo credit: Denver Water.
Construction of Green Mountain Dam was part of that work. During the hot, dry 1930s, farmers in the Fort Collins-Longmont-Greeley area wanted to import water from the Colorado River headwaters near Grand Lake. Western Slope irrigators objected. Farms in the Grand Junction area would lose late-season water needed to get their crops and orchards across the finish line.
Green Mountain was the compromise. And it has worked out well. A pool of 66,000 acre-feet of water was reserved for down-stream irrigators in the Grand Junction area. Deliveries in this canal usually continue through October, sometimes later.
This year was different. For the first time in 110-plus years, deliveries ended in late August.
DeBeque Canyon has changed somewhat since this photo of the Roller Dam was taken in 1916. Most notably, now the canyon has an interstate highway. Photo/U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. For a more complete history, see the Palisade Historical Society page.
In April, the Glenwood Springs-based Colorado River Water Conservation District issued a warning. Green Mountain was the lowest it had been since filling during World War II. This jeopardized the late-summer flows to irrigators who took delivery of water from the Government Highline Canal. The canal diverts water from the Colorado River at the Roller Dam, a short distance upstream from Palisade. It then distributes water to farms and orchards for 55 miles, nearly to the Utah border.
Wolford Mountain Reservoir back in the day. An aerial view of Wolford Reservoir, formed by Ritschard Dam.
This year, in a testament to cooperation, the Colorado River District and Colorado Water Conservation Board ponied up more than $1 million to buy use of water. Water was tapped from headwaters reservoirs, most notably Wolford and Williams Fork, near Kremmling, and Ruedi, near Basalt. Others, including Front Range diverters, helped.
Williams Fork Reservoir back in the day. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism
Irrigators got only 50% of their normal water. In response, many switched crops to varieties of plants that could survive with less water.
Even so, by late August, the water was running out. The Grand Valley Water Users Association, operator of the canal, stopped deliveries on September 3. Maybe monsoon rains will deliver water to resume operations, but thatโs the story for now.
Once again, the idea that we just need to store more is entirely too simplistic. Yes, saving for a rainy day is always good, but this idea that we can build our way to more water defies ample evidence about the warming, drying climate.
We can have droughts, yes. They come and go. But the science clearly shows that these hot, dry years of the 21st century will not be ephemeral. They have been driven by a warming climate caused by accumulating greenhouse gas emissions.
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
In the 20th century, the Colorado River delivered about 15.2 million acre-feet. In this century, the annual flows have declined to 12.2 million acre-feet. Since 2020, average flows have declined even more, to 10 million acre-feet. And this recent span included a very, very big snow year, in 2022-23, a three-wire winter like those of old. But the spring was like those of the 21st century, early and uncommonly warm.
The pitiful storage in Green Mountain, whose shoreline is seen in the above photograph I took on Aug. 17, testifies to this warming, drying climate. So does the canal near Grand Junction where deliveries were cut off last week for the first time in 110 years. And then we have near doubling of 95 degree-plus days in Denver during last 30 years as compared to the three decades before as reported by KUSA.
Might we figure out better infrastructure? Maybe. The idea of storing water underground, as Greeley began doing several years ago, intrigues. It requires more energy but greatly reduces evaporative loss.
The federal government in its documents has excised climate change. So have many politicians in Colorado speaking on the stump, hewing to the recent version of political correctness.
If there are ideas for storing water that donโt assume a return to the climate of the 20th century, Iโm all for hearing them. But to think this is just another drought defies tons of evidence.
Communities across the West have been anxiously waiting for a plan to manage the Colorado River. The states that share the river have been unable to reach an agreement over how to manage it, forcing the federal government to move forward without one.
The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation recently published a management framework for the next 10 years.
This is not the long-term agreement many had hoped for, but it does leave room for collaborative solutions.
Communities across the West have been anxiously waiting for a plan to manage their water supply from the Colorado River. They watched as the states that share the river talked in circles behind closed doors. They attended conferences where state negotiators repeated the same tired arguments, did not present together, or were entirely absent.
Outside the conference rooms, conditions on the ground were deteriorating. The Colorado River Basin experienced its warmest winter on record. The meager snowpack in the mountains was sucked into parched soils, rivers dwindled, and the Basinโs two major reservoirs hit record lows.
And the situation continues to worsen.
While negotiators were struggling to find consensus, farmers were fallowing fields, raft guides were staring down an uncertain season, neighbors were reporting each other for overwatering, families were discovering that their favorite fishing spots had closed, and municipalities were on the hunt for alternative water supplies.
Three years ago, the U.S Bureau of Reclamation set out to work with the Basin states, Tribes, and stakeholders on a 20-year management plan for the Colorado River. But the states never reached a long-term agreement, forcing the federal government to move forward without one.
On Aug. 21, Reclamation published a framework for managing the river over the next 10 years. While it is not the long-term agreement many had hoped for, it does leave room for collaborative solutions.
What happens next will shape the river for generations.
What Is the Record of Decision?
A Decision-Making Framework
The record of decision lays out a 10-year framework for managing the river.
Under this framework, the Bureau of Reclamation will issue preliminary guidelines every two years for operating the riverโs reservoirs and distributing shortages. Those guidelines will inform Reclamationโs annual plan for the river, which will be released every summer. Reclamation can adjust that plan each April depending on the winterโs snowpack and current reservoir levels. It is a tedious process, but one that allows the agency to modify operations as river conditions change.
State officials have raised concerns that the two-year framework will result in never-ending negotiations while making it difficult to plan ahead and finance solutions. These are valid concerns, but there is an off-ramp. If the states collaborate, they could replace the framework with a long-term deal that provides more certainty to their constituents and removes the need for prolonged negotiations.
Rafting the Colorado River. Photo credit: Western Resource Advocates
A Plan for Managing Water Shortages
In addition to the record of decision, Reclamation issued operating guidelines for 2027 and 2028. These guidelines outline Lake Powell and Lake Mead operations and include shortages the Lower Basin offered earlier this year. Under the guidelines, the Lower Basin will reduce its use of the Colorado River by 1.25 million acre-feet in both 2027 and 2028. It will also pursue 700,000 acre-feet in additional conservation by 2028.
The record of decision allows Reclamation to impose even deeper cuts on the Lower Basin โ up to 3 million acre-feet per year โ if Lake Mead starts to approach the minimum levels needed to produce hydropower and to avoid hitting deadpool.
Reclamation is not mandating cuts in the Upper Basin because its authority to do so is less clear. But that doesnโt mean conservation isnโt urgently needed in the Upper Basin. In the record of decision, Reclamation includes up to 200,000 acre-feet of voluntary conservation each year collectively by Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming.
While this conservation is considered voluntary, it is in the Upper Basinโs best interest to be part of the solution. Flows on the Colorado River have declined by over 30% since 2020. The river will continue to be on a knifeโs edge unless everyone contributes.
By saving water now, the Upper Basin can help keep things from getting worse and reduce the need for emergency releases from upstream reservoirs to prop up Lake Powell. This can help rebuild storage and support the outdoor recreation economy in places like Flaming Gorge in Utah and Blue Mesa in Colorado.
Conservation in the Upper Basin can also help avoid expensive and risky legal battles over the river. The 1922 Colorado River Compact says that the Upper Basin will not cause the flow of the river to be depleted below a certain amount over a 10-year period. The Upper Basin argues that this volume is 75 million acre-feet. The Lower Basin says the amount includes water deliveries for Mexico and is set at 82.5 million acre-feet. We could hit the 82.5 trip wire as soon as this fall, potentially triggering litigation from the Lower Basin. Such a dispute would likely cost taxpayers millions of dollars, take years to resolve, and leave the riverโs future in the hands of the U.S. Supreme Court. If the Lower Basin prevails, water users in the Upper Basin could see drastic cuts to their supply and little time to implement solutions or secure funding to ease the pain.
The four Upper Basin states are at various stages of developing programs to pay water users to decrease their consumption. WRA is advocating for long-term programs that prioritize projects that keep rivers healthy.
Credit: Western Resource Advocates
Is the Latest Plan Enough?
Reclamationโs models show that the reductions planned for the next two years will just barely allow the Basin to scrape by. In the worst-case scenario, the Basin could drain its accessible water savings in Lake Powell. The only water left would be what flows in the river, and that is nowhere near enough to meet current demands.
Whatโs Next?
Implementing Solutions or Handing the Reins to the Supreme Court
The Basin states have an important decision before them โ implement the new guidelines and work toward a long-term deal or take their chances in court.
Nevada was the first to take the plunge. Three days after Reclamation released the record of decision, Nevada filed a lawsuit against the U.S. Department of the Interior and Bureau of Reclamation. The state claims that the plan and the potential cuts to Nevadaโs water supply violate federal law and seeks to halt its implementation.
Nevadaโs lawsuit underscores the need for a deal that all seven states can agree to, rather than a plan imposed by the federal government. There is still an opportunity to reach such an agreement โ the Nevada case does not preclude the seven states from continuing to negotiate or from entering into agreements to stabilize the river.
The states must not let this one case spiral out of control. Litigation between all seven Basin states over the Colorado River Compact would make things much worse.
History shows that multistate water disputes can take at least a decade to be resolved and often have unintended consequences.ย Arizona v. California, a dispute over Colorado River allocations in the Lower Basin, began in 1952 and was not resolved until 1963. The court settled the disagreement over water allocations and ruled that the Secretary of the Interior has broad authority to act as watermaster in the Lower Basin โ giving the federal government greater control over Lower Basin water deliveries.ย Texas v. New Mexico, a dispute over the Rio Grande, went on for 13 years before reaching a resolution last spring. And a dispute between Kansas and Colorado over the Arkansas River was on-again, off-again forย more than a century. The court ruled that Colorado was overusing water and awarded both water and monetary damages to Kansas. And these cases all involved two states โ not seven.
The Colorado River does not have decades. Researchers predict that it will only take one more dry winter to drain the Basinโs accessible water savings.
On top of lost time, state litigation over the 1922 Compact would cost millions of dollars โ money that is better spent implementing conservation programs, restoring watersheds, and increasing water efficiency. And litigation would leave decisions with the Supreme Court, not the communities that depend on the river and know it best.
Nevadaโs lawsuit against the federal government does not change the fact that we have a river to manage. New guidelines are still needed by Oct. 1. The decision-making process must continue and the Basin states must act now to prevent a seven-state legal brawl.
In the coming months WRA will be advocating for:
Protections for the river:ย Protecting river health and our communities are two sides of the same coin. The day-to-day operations of the riverโs reservoirs affect everything from fish habitat to hydropower production to local water supplies and outdoor recreation. Operating guidelines must consider the full range of impacts and incorporate policies that maximize benefits for both our communities and the environment.
Transparent decision making:ย The record of decision includes a plan for issuing new operating guidelines every two years. Those guidelines will affect 35 million people and must not be developed behind closed doors. A clear public process is needed to incorporate input from the Basin states, Tribes, Mexico, water users, communities, scientists, and conservation organizations.
Sustained federal funding:ย Federal funding will be critical to implementing the changes that are needed to secure the Westโs future, including restoring watershed health and incentivizing water use reductions. The river that supplies water to 1 in 10 Americans is worthy of federal investment.
Equitable water access and Tribal inclusion:ย The 30 federally recognized Tribes in the Colorado River Basin have long been excluded from key decisions and denied their fair share of the riverโs water. The new guidelines and programs must uphold Tribal water rights and provide clear pathways for Tribal collaboration.
State collaboration:ย The states have been talking past each other for the last three years and itโs resulted in a federal management plan that few decision makers are happy with, and one state has already filed a lawsuit on. It is time to try a new approach before things get worse. The states must enlist the help of a professional mediator who can facilitate more productive negotiations. And the states must finalize and sign implementation plans โ like the Lower Basinโs proposal to reduce its water use by 1.25 million-acre feet in 2027 and 2028 โ as soon as possible.
Basinwide collaboration:ย Many of the riverโs most successful programs โ including those that restored hundreds of miles of fish habitat and put tens of millions of dollars toward water conservation โ were the result of collaborations between states, federal agencies, Tribal nations, water users, conservation organizations, and others. The challenges the river faces are growing. We must accelerate our efforts, build new partnerships, launch new programs, increase investment, and expand on successful initiatives.
The record of decision has set the stage, now it is time for the riverโs next act.
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Tens of millions of people across the West depend on the Colorado River for drinking water, food, power and their livelihoods. But years of drought, rising temperatures and declining reservoirs have put that lifeline under extraordinary strain. The newly released Record of Decision and federal Operating Guidelines for the river provide a framework for operations, but they cannot resolve the region’s underlying challenges on their own. The work that happens next will determine the future of the river and the communities that rely on it.
2026 marks one of the worst water years on record for the Colorado River Basin and throughout the American West, as river flows dwindle and megafires consume landscape after landscape. Water in Lake Mead, the largest reservoir in the U.S., has dropped to its lowest level since it was filled more than 90 years ago. Long-term planning and investment is critical to stabilize the river while protecting communities from increasingly severe fire, floods and drought.
Reclamation announces 2026 operating conditions for Lake Powell and Lake Mead. Hoover Dam. Photo credit: USBR
The release of the guidelines is a milestone, not the finish line. A document canโt ensure safe water supplies or combat the impacts of severe drought and wildfires. Significant federal, state and local funding needs to be directed towards strategies that make the health of rivers, forests and wetlands a priority. Without it, the Basin will remain at risk of chronic shortages, food supply disruption, energy grid vulnerability and rising economic instability that breed disruption and conflict for the entire region.
It is critical that we take this opportunity to invest in work that focuses on ensuring healthy watersheds, sustainable water use and collaboration between Colorado River Basin states and Tribal Nations.
Nature-based solutionsโincluding river and forest management and wetland restorationโare a crucial part of the Basinโs infrastructure. They enable dependable water supplies, reduce threats from wildfires and flooding, sustain fish and wildlife and support local communities and economies. With so much attention focused on water allocations, reservoir levels and operational decisions, the role of these natural systems cannot get lost in the mix.
Fortunately there are projects throughout the Colorado River Basin that offer a blueprint for how to work with the power of nature to create a more sustainable path forward.
Projects designed to better manage forests and restore wetlands can improve water quality and create natural firebreaks. Regenerative agriculture practices like growing crops that use less water, and limiting the disruption of soil, can help create healthier farmland that better absorbs and retains water so farmers can use less. These approaches are an important part of a broader portfolio of tools that help communities conserve water, reduce risk and strengthen watersheds.
As the Colorado River endures one of its worst water years on record, long-term planning and investment is critical to stabilize water supplies while protecting communities from increasingly severe fire, floods and drought. Grand Canyon and Colorado River by Brian Richter
Transparency and collaboration between the federal government, Basin state leaders, Tribal Nations and Mexico is essential. We know that those closest to the problem are closest to the solution and that we will be more effective when we draw on the collective expertise of everyone who relies on the river. Basin states have not yet been able to negotiate a long-term management plan but that cannot stand in the way of continued work to create a more reliable and resilient Colorado River system.
Philanthropy also has a vital role to play in the future of the Colorado River. We are continuing to collaborate with our grantees to advance innovative, nature-based solutions for the region. Philanthropic investment can help test and scale approaches, fill gaps, build partnerships and demonstrate what is possible in complement to the much-needed federal, state, Tribal and local investments. Together we can help make sure the river can continue to provide for the next generation.
The U.S. Forest Service-owned parcel known as Janeway is adjacent to the Crystal River. A potential nature-based aquifer recharge project could reconnect the historic floodplain to the river and retime spring flows as part of a water supply replacement plan. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
The Trump administration continues its crusade to make Americaโs public lands motorized again. This time itโs the Forest Service launching a revamp of its travel management rule by โsimplifying regulatory requirementsโ to โincrease access, including for motorized vehicles, e-bikes, and other mobility devices.โ The move follows, and is an attempt to implement, President Donald Trumpโs rollback this summer of Nixon-era restrictions on off-highway vehicles on public lands. Comments are being accepted on the proposal until Sept. 23.
This rule would bolster the administrationโs rollback this summer of the 2001 Roadless Rule, which prohibits roadbuilding and commercial timber operations โ with exceptions โ on 45 million acres of National Forest lands.
The current action starts the process of developing an environmental impact statement, which will give more specific details. But the notice of intent gives an overall look at what the administration proposes. Most basically, it aims to open the door for individual forests to relax motorized travel restrictions and open currently closed areas to the vehicles. The โpublic access rule,โ as theyโre calling it, would:
โโฆ establish a presumption that existing roads, trails, airfields, trailheads, and other access routes and points on NFS lands are open to appropriate public use,โ unless the closure is required by law (or other specific reasons). This is a switch from the current โclosed unless designated openโ policy to an โopen unless closedโ framework, with possibly dramatic effects.
โ โฆ establish a requirement to consider new roads, trails, airfields, trailheads, and other access routes and points where appropriate to increase access.โย This appears to be aimed at optimizing, if you will, the Roadless Rule rollback by encouraging new roadbuilding.
โโฆ establish processes and conditions for authorizing limited off-route motor vehicle and other motorized equipment use for, among other things, downed big-game retrieval, firewood collection, dispersed camping, and for designating areas for over-snow and other motorized recreation.โย This oneโs pretty scary, because it would open the door to allowing OHVs or snowmobiles to drive just about anywhere in a forest (except in designated wilderness areas).
You have until Sept. 23 to weigh in on the proposal. To do so electronically (preferred)through the Federal eRulemaking Portal, go toย https://www.regulations.gov, docket number FS-2026-0100, and look for the COMMENT button. Or send snail mail to: Director, Public Benefits, 201 14th Street SW, Public Benefits Office, Washington, DC 20250.
Upper White Canyon and tributaries and Bears Ears in the clouds. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
Several tribal nations, advocacy groups, and Patagonia have filed lawsuits โ and/or revived dormant ones โ seeking to block President Donald Trumpโs proclamations this summer shrinking Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monuments. The legal argument behind the lawsuits is clear and potent: The 1906 Antiquities Act authorizes presidents to establish national monuments, but not to shrink or revoke them. Therefore Trumpโs 2017 and 2026 shrinkages are illegal and should not stand.
History backs the plaintiffs. In 1938, President Franklin D. Roosevelt sought to revoke the Castle Pinckney National Monument, a former military installation in South Carolina. His attorney generalโs analysis, however, determined that the Antiquities Act โdoes not authorize [the President] to abolish [national monuments] after they have been established.โ FDR, respecting the rule of law, let the monument stand. Eventually, Congress, which does have the power to alter national monuments, voted to revoke national monument status for the site.
In 2017, a quartet of legal scholars, including Mark Squillace, of the University of Colorado Law School, published their own analysis in the Virginia Law Review. They, too, found that in 1906 Congress did not delegate to the president the authority to downsize or abolish a national monument or weaken the protections granted by the original national monument proclamation. Furthermore, the Federal Land Policy Management Act of 1976 clarified that only Congress has the power to modify or revoke a national monument.
The cases likely will take years to wend their way through the courts, and may ultimately lead to a U.S. Supreme Court ruling on the power of the Antiquities Act.
Boaters on the Colorado River a few miles downstream from Glen Canyon Dam. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
๐จ๏ธ๐ฆฆ๐ฃ๐ฝย Water Watchย ๐
While climate change-exacerbated drought most notably diminishes the amount of water in rivers, it also raises the temperature of streams, which is especially problematic for fish and other aquatic life. The Colorado River downstream from Glen Canyon Dam, which includes the long stretch through the Grand Canyon, is warming up fast.
When the river stalls out and becomes Lake Powell, the reservoirโs surface just sits in the sun and bakes, while the deeper waters remain chilly. Some fish, like non-native smallmouth bass prefer the warm water, and stay near the surface. When the reservoir is full, the depth of the water at the penstock intakes โ where released water exits the dam โ is too cold for the bass, so they arenโt likely to escape the reservoir into the river below. But as the surface level drops, the depth of the water at the penstock intakes on the dam decreases, meaning that the water released through the damโs turbines and into the river below gets increasingly warmer โ and is more likely to include warm-water fish.
Currently, Lake Powellโs surface is a mere 28 feet above the penstock intakes, meaning the released water is warm and includes a lot of bass. This, in turn, warms up the river below, making it more favorable to the invading bass, which prey on and compete with endangered native fish. Meanwhile, the warmer water stresses the trout, potentially harming the recreational fishery between Lees Ferry and the dam.
So in 2024 as it became clear low reservoir levels were chronic, the Bureau of Reclamation began doing โcool-flow mixes.โ When the river water temperature downstream of the dam hit 59.9ยฐ F, dam operators would begin releasing cooler water from the lower river outlet tubes. This dropped the river temperature enough to help downstream fish, and hurt the bass.
This year, however, the feds halted the cool flow mixes to ensure that all releases go through the turbines and generate hydropower. The Grand Canyon Trust built a niftyย online gadgetย that shows the consequences, which arenโt good: The water temperature at the monitor just below Soap Creek Rapid in the Grand Canyon soared above 70ยฐ F during the waning days of August, and has been above the cool-mix threshold for 78 days this year so far. Click on theย interactive graphย to see how water temperatures have changed over the years โ and how well the cool-mix flows worked in 2024 and 2025.
๐ค Data Center Watch ๐พ
The first data center project on public lands has been halted โ for now.
On Tuesday, the Interior Board of Land Appeals granted a stay on the Townsite Solar 2โs planned data center on federal land near Boulder City, Nevada, blocking further development while legal challenges are considered. The order also expedites consideration of the appeals filed by environmental groups and the city.
In 2023, the Bureau of Land Management authorized Townsite Solar 2 to develop a solar-plus-storage installation on public land in southern Nevada. Then, in November 2025, before beginning construction on the solar facility, the firm requested an amendment to its right of way that instead would allow it to develop a hyperscale data center, a 70-megawatt battery energy storage system, a substation, and biodiesel generators on the same site. The BLM approved the amendment without conducting a new environmental review or public scoping after determining that the new project โis substantially the sameโ as the former one.
Both the Biden and Trump II administrations proposed opening national laboratories and other federal properties to data center development. However, this was the first such project to be approved for BLM land.
Boulder City, the Center for Biological Diversity, and the Sierra Clubย appealedย the approval and requested the stay, arguing that the agency failed to adequately consider the data centerโs potential impacts. The boardโs ruling notes, โAppellants are likely to prevail on that question because the two projects are not โsubstantially the same.โโ The board also determined the appellants โdemonstrated that permanent and irreparable harm is likely to occur to its membersโ aesthetic and recreational interests in the project site.โ
โ๏ธ Mining Monitor โ๏ธ
Federal regulators on Tuesday approved the Navajo Transitional Energy Companyโs proposed Navajo Mine expansion, authorizing the tribal-owned company to extract some 503 million tons of coal over the next 110 years. Yes, you read that right: The coal industry may be in decline, but these folks just got permitted to keep digging up the dirty fuel for over a century more, despite strong opposition from residents and advocacy groups.
The surface mine sits on the Navajo Nation north of Burnham and about 22 miles southwest of Farmington, New Mexico. It was built in the 1960s to serve the nearby Four Corners Power Plant, and remains the facilityโs sole fuel provider.
NTEC says it needs the expansion to continue serving the plant until its closure; its primary owner, Arizona Public Service, plans to shutter the facility by 2041. After that the firm, which also owns coal mines in the Powder River Basin, would apparently try to peddle Navajo Mine coal elsewhere.
This has set off alarm bells for anyone concerned about the landscapes and air quality of the Four Corners region. Not only would the mine tear apart another 9,000 acres of land, displace residents and dwellings, and destroy dozens of historic cultural properties, but that coal would also be burned somewhere, releasing climate-warming and health-harming pollutants in the process. Also concerning is the prospect that the Four Corners plant, which has sullied the regionโs air for more than 60 years, would continue operating indefinitely.
***
The San Carlos Apache Tribe, the Center for Biological Diversity, and the Lower San Pedro Watershed Alliance have filed a lawsuit seeking to stop further exploratory drilling or other development at Faradayโs proposed Copper Creek mining project. The groups accuse the Bureau of Land Management and U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service of failing to consider drillingโs impacts on endangered Mexican spotted owls that are known to inhabit the area.
The mine is proposed for about 78 square kilometers in the Galiuro Mountains east of Mammoth, Arizona, on private, state, and Bureau of Land Management parcels. Last June, the Bureau of Land Management approved Faradayโs plan to construct 67 drill pads, along with associated roads and infrastructure, and the company recently completed the first round of water-intensive drilling.
The complaint also says the BLM failed to consult with the San Carlos Apache Tribe, as required under theย National Historic Preservation Act.
Circle of Blue and True Elements Launch Situation: Colorado River from Stockholm World Water Week
Colorado River faces a โcollective nightmare.โ
New platform delivers a shared view to help inform decisions and collaboration.
Situation: Colorado Riverย is part of Designing Waterโs Future, the initiative to create โa new operating system for the worldโs fresh waterโ โ aligning across finance, policy, media, and innovation.
STOCKHOLM (August 27, 2026) โ As some 2,000 experts gather for World Water Week to address global water challenges and solutions, Circle of Blue and True Elements today launch a new, live data, information and context platform for the Colorado River basin, which faces unprecedented stress as the river and its reservoirs set record lows that are forcing a dramatic reset of water use across the American West. The river supports approximately $1.4 trillion in annual economic activity and 16 million jobs across seven basin states, 30 Tribal Nations, and northwestern Mexico.
Situation: Colorado River begins with real-time and historical data collected into a strategic, user-friendly dashboard. In the face of increasing stress on the basin, the team, which includes reporters from Circle of Blue, will add on-the-ground context to deliver critical insights for policymakers, negotiators, journalists, businesses, and the public.
The core data is assembled from True Elementsโ TrueQi system โ an advanced and comprehensive resources platform that includes satellite observations and river gauges as well as drought indicators, wildfire detections, and reservoir measurements.
The platform arrives at an inflection point for the American West as Lake Mead and Lake Powell reach record low levels amid a warming climate. The combined storage of the two reservoirs is now lower than at any point since 1957 โ before Glen Canyon Dam existed. Ninety-five percent of the basin remains in drought.
โThe basinโs assumptions are being reset in real time, and everyone โ federal, state, Tribal, corporate, business, communities โ needs a trusted, shared view of what is actually happening,โ said J. Carl Ganter, co-founder and managing director of Circle of Blue, the international nonprofit reporting on fresh water and its โnexusโ intersections with food, energy, infrastructure, and health.
The TrueQi platform from True Elements collects real-time and historical federal, state, satellite, and sensor data across the Colorado River basin, the broader American West and globally. As it expands, Situation: Colorado River layers Circle of Blueโs journalism, along with reporting from network partners, on top of key data points, with additional context from academic and research collaborators.
โReal-time and cross-sector data is the foundation while the context makes it real and relevant,โ said Kim Kobza, CEO of True Elements. โTrueQi already delivers the most granular water intelligence in the field. Pairing it with Circle of Blueโs award-winning reporting turns raw numbers into shared guidance.โ
โSituation: Colorado River pulls the data together and makes it accessible to everyone making decisions under the pressure of declining water supplies. We do this with a sense of urgency, humility and collaboration in the face of increasing water crises globally,โ Ganter said. It is part of Designing Waterโs Future, Circle of Blueโs international initiative to better inform and align action across finance, policy, media, innovation, and the public.
The situation is forcing a reckoning for farmers, developers, cities, and industries, including silicon chip manufacturers and data centers. โWe have a colossal failure to act in the face of an inevitable collective nightmare โ and all the predictions are coming true faster than we thought,โ Felicia Marcus, past chair of the California State Water Resources Control Board, told Circle of Blue.
As the basinโs operating assumptions are tested, Situation: Colorado River asks a core question:
What data points and contexts are necessary to inform the most important decisions across the Colorado River basin, and how can new data and intelligence approaches be applied across the U.S. and globally?
The initiative launches with a call for public and expert input at an historic moment. Submit thoughts, questions, suggestions and corrections to coloradoriver@circleofblue.org. This will shape the initiativeโs next iterations of data selection and analysis, editorial focus and priority coverage.
Also available now is Water Savvy 3.0, a free mobile app from True Elements available on the Apple App Store that puts real-time water quality data, alerts and reporting into the hands of the public and students.
The platform is live online today from Stockholm. It is free and designed to be a trusted source for newsrooms, businesses, policymakers, academic researchers, students and the public. A more comprehensive enterprise insights system is available to businesses, agencies, and governments. Circle of Blue original content publishes under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) license.
Durango experienced a drier-than-normal August…The month of August accumulated 0.28 inches of precipitation, 0.12 inches of which occurred Monday. Monday was the highest precipitation day of August, Gillian Felton, a National Weather Service meteorologist in the Grand Junction office, said. August traditionally averages closer to 1.3 inches of rain, according to the weather service, and precipitation this August was down about an inch comparatively. A plethora of reasons contributed to the dry spell, said Brooke Scholtens, a meteorologist with the National Weather Service office in Grand Junction.
โFor the earlier parts of the summer, we were experiencing those drought-like conditions,โ she said. โSo that makes things incredibly difficult, especially since the pushes that we did see of the monsoon, most of the time, we had dry air in the way that was kind of preventing moisture from entering the region.โ
This monsoon has been drier than traditional years, Scholtens said. She added that the weather service measures moisture at Durango-La Plata County Airport, so some areas around Durango may have differing precipitation levels…Monsoons donโt have a specific end date, but it usually wraps up mid- to late-September, Scholtens said…According to theย National Integrated Drought Information System, 91.6% of La Plata County is in a severe drought and 8.4% of the county is in an extreme drought. Durango has been in Stage One water restrictions since early April as part of the city of Durangoโs Drought Management Plan.
Map of the San Juan River, a tributary of the Colorado River, in Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico and Utah, USA. Made using USGS National Map data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=47456307
At recent meetings, the San Juan Water Conservancy District (SJWCD) and the Pagosa Water and Sanitation District (PAWSD) boards of directors approved applications for findings of reasonable diligence for several water rights held by the districts…At an Aug. 13 meeting, the PAWSD Board of Directors unanimously approved applications for findings of reasonable diligence for three sets of water rights, including rights for the San Juan River intake, a group of rights associated with the Dry Gulch Reservoir project that the SJWCD leads development on, and a second enlargement on a water right in Dutton Ditch. The Dry Gulch and Dutton Ditch water rights are held by both PAWSD and the SJWCD, while the San Juan right is exclusive to PAWSD. PAWSD board member Bill Hudson pointed out that these water rights are not rights PAWSD is currently using, but are rights that could be developed in the future if the district needs them…At an Aug. 17 meeting, the SJWCD Board of Directors also unanimously approved diligence filings for the Dry Gulch and Dutton Ditch water rights. SJWCD legal counsel Jeffrey Kane explained to the board that he would file the joint application for the Dry Gulch water rights, while PAWSDโs legal counsel would file the application for the Dutton Ditch water rights.
Reductions in Lower Basin water use during the last four years, including forecast use in 2026, are similar to the initial targets for Lower Basin shortages described in the Final Environmental Impact Statement for Post-2026 Operational Guidelines and Strategies for Lake Powell and Lake Mead (FEIS) and the accompanying Record of Decision (ROD). 6ย Lower Basin consumptive use in 2023, 2024, and 2025, and forecast for 2026 has been the smallest for the entire 2010-2026 period. These four years of smallest use are between 1.4 and 1.7 million acre feet/year (maf/yr) less than the 7.50 maf/yr amount generally recognized as the Lower Basinโs mainstem allocation.
Reductions in Lower Basin use have been achieved by large reductions implemented by Central Arizona Project (CAP) contractors and subcontractors, the Imperial Irrigation District (IID), and non-CAP water users in Arizona. The reductions in use in the IID have been in summer water use and have not a๏ฌected consumptive use in winter when garden crops, such ass lettuce, onions, carrots, and broccoli, are grown.
There is no historical analogy for implementing Lower Basin shortages of 3 maf/yr that would reduce annual consumptive water use to 4.5 maf/yr. We identified the lowest use in each month between 2010 and 2026 in each Lower Basin state and summed those monthly values, even when those months did not occur in the same year. The annual total of the summed lowest monthly uses yielded a minimum total Lower Basin use of 5.03 maf/yr. Thus, implementation of 3 maf/yr shortages would require reductions in monthly use greater than the sum of the smallest monthly uses during the past 17 years.
INTRODUCTION
This paper is part of a series, The Colorado River Water Supply Crisis in a Few Graphs, whose goal is to provide readers with summary information about the natural water supply, reservoir storage, and consumptive uses and losses in the Basin so that readers can better understand and consider the current water crisis. The long-term fate of the water supply provided by the Colorado River depends on many complex and interconnected factors: the natural flow of the river, the amount of water stored in the Basinโs reservoirs, the consumptive uses of that water, the losses caused by reservoir evaporation, and the losses associated with water flowing through natural channels (i.e., transmission losses).
In 2024, approximately 60% of all uses and losses of Colorado River water in the United States occurred in the Lower Basin (Table 1).โท In this paper, we summarize water use in the Lower Basin since 2010, primarily focusing on consumption by the Imperial Irrigation District (IID), the largest user in the entire Colorado River Basin, and on the aggregate consumption by Arizona users not served by the Central Arizona Project (CAP). We focus on these agricultural users, because agriculture makes up approximately 60% of consumptive uses in the Lower Basin,โธ and the agricultural sector will play a significant role in future reductions in water use in the Lower Basin.
Table 1. Consumptive uses and losses in the United States part of the Colorado River Basin in 2024.9
This paper provides historical context in which to consider the magnitude of recent reductions in Lower Basin water use by comparing current water use with typical rates of use since 2010. We also provide historical context for the shortage goals described in the recently released ROD and Operating Guidelines for 2027 and 2028. 10 The ROD lists a potential maximum Lower Basin reduction of 3.0 maf/yr but also includes language that seems to allow for even greater reductions, after consultation, in extraordinary circumstances.
We analyze the Lower Basin water use data summarized by the Bureau of Reclamation in annual decree accounting reports formally titled Colorado River Accounting and Water Use Report: Arizona, California, and Nevada.ยนยน These reports are issued each May and summarize monthly water use by every Lower Basin user. Reclamation also provides monthly provisional data on the current yearโs water use, and the agency provides forecasts of annual use for the current year.ยนยฒ Similarly extensive and precise data describing Upper Basin use are not readily available.
Lake Mead and Lake Powell are the largest reservoirs in the United States and essentially are one gigantic reservoir separated into two parts by the Grand Canyon.ยนยณ Inflow to this gigantic reservoir primarily is snowmelt from the Rocky Mountains, and a significant amount of that runoff is put to beneficial use by Upper Basin users before it reaches Lake Powell. A small amount of additional inflow occurs within the Grand Canyon, and there are occasional inflows to Lake Mead from the Virgin River. Southern Nevada Water Authority directly withdraws water from Lake Mead, and other Lower Basin users divert stream flow after it is released from Lake Mead.
RECENT LOWER BASIN WATER USE
In 2025, total consumptive use in the three Lower Basin states was 5.755 maf, the smallest annual total use since at least 2010 (Fig. 1) and 17% less than the average for 2010-2025.14 This small amount resulted from the lowest annual use in California (3.647 maf) since at least 2010 and the second lowest annual use since 2010 in Arizona (1.911 maf). Lower Basin use in 2026, 5.961 maf, is forecast to be slightly more than in 2025.15
Figure 1. Consumptive use in the Lower Basin since 2010. Estimated use in 2026 based on forecast of September 1, 2026.
Water use in California since 2023, including forecast use in 2026, has been 13% less than between 2010 and 2022.16 Decreased use in California in those years has been primarily due to reductions in use by IID (Fig. 2). IIDโs consumptive use of 2.187 maf in 2025 was the lowest since 2010 and forecast use in 2026 of 2.242 maf is also very low. Average use by IID between 2023 and 2026 will be 12% less than average use between 2010 and 2022.17 Annual consumptive use by the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California (MWD) between 2023 and 2026 will be 13% less than between 2010 and 2022, although the savings are not as great because MWD uses less water than does IID.18
Figure 2. Consumptive use in California since 2010. Estimated use in 2026 based on forecast of September 1, 2026.
The proportionate reductions in water use in Arizona have been much larger than in California. Average statewide water use between 2023 and 2026 will be 25% less than between 2010 and 2022.19 CAP has reduced its uses by 40% between those two time periods, while non-CAP users have reduced consumption by 6%. The smallest use by Arizona was 1.890 maf in 2023 (Fig. 3). Use in 2025 by non-CAP customers, 1.004 maf, was the lowest since at least 2010. Non-CAP use has exceeded CAP use since 2022.
Figure 3. Consumptive use in Arizona since 2010. Estimated use in 2026 based on forecast of September 1, 2026.
LOWER BASIN AGRICULTURAL WATER USE
Imperial Irrigation District
IID is the largest individual user of mainstem Colorado River water in the Colorado River Basin, exceeding use by any state in the Basin except California itself. Much of Californiaโs ongoing reductions in use are due to decreased use by IID resulting from various compensated agreements. Future reductions by IID have the potential to significantly affect the Basinโs effort to balance consumptive use with declining supply.
In comparison to typical annual use since 2010, IIDโs use in 2024 and 2025, as well as forecast use in 2026, has been notably reduced, as represented in a box-and-whisker plot (Fig. 4).20 The box in Figure 4 encloses 50% of the years since 2010, and the length of this box is called the Inter Quartile Range (IQR), bounded by the 25th and 75th percentile of the 17 years of data, including forecast use in 2026. The line through the middle of the box is the median value for this period. Lines extending up and down from the box (i.e., whiskers) extend from the box to values within an acceptable range. Values that are greater than 1.5 times the IQR above the 75th percentile or below the 25th percentile are beyond the acceptable range and are outliers and individually plotted. Thus, 2024, 2025, and forecast use in 2026 are outliers, indicating that use in those years has been significantly less that typical use during the entire period since 2010.
Figure 4. Box-and-whisker plot showing distribution of annual use by IID since 2010. The box is the Inter Quartile Range, defined by the 25th and 75th percentile of the years of annual use data. The line inside the box is the median. Whiskers extend from the box to an acceptable range, and outliers are circles that are labeled. The three most recent years are outliers of low water use. Estimated use in 2026 based on forecast of September 1, 2026. See text for explanation of a box-and-whisker plot.
The largest proportion of irrigated land in IID is devoted to field crop production, the largest proportion of which is devoted to alfalfa (Fig. 5).ยฒยน The area devoted to alfalfa production changes little from year to year and during the year and was approximately 150,000 acres in 2025.ยฒยฒ In 2025, other significant field crops were Bermuda grass and kleingrass, whose average irrigated area was 80,000 and 20,000 acres, respectively. The area devoted to garden crop production changes greatly throughout the year and is largest between November and March. Little land area is devoted to garden crop production in the heat of summer. The most significant garden crops are lettuce, onions, carrots, and broccoli.
Figure 5. Area of IID irrigated for di๏ฌerent categories of crops in 2025. Field crops include alfalfa that is also plotted separately.
Water use by IID is typically lowest between November and February when garden crops are grown (Fig. 6). Water use increases greatly in March and remains high through October when field crops are the primary focus of production (see Appendix).
Figure 6. Box-and-whisker plots of total monthly consumptive use by the IID between 2010 and 2026. Each box is the Inter Quartile Range, defined by the 25th and 75th percentile of the years of data for that month. These boxes represent the typical monthly use pattern since 2010. Red dots are the average use in each month between 2024 and 2026. See text for additional explanation of a box-and-whisker plot.
Reductions in consumption during the past few years have been accomplished primarily by reduced water use between June and September when alfalfa and grass hay are the primary crops. These reductions are reflected in Figure 5 where red dots are the average monthly water use since 2024. Red dots plot below the grey boxes of the IQR in June, July, August, and September, demonstrating that recent water use in these months has been significantly less than typical since 2010. In contrast, recent water use between December and May has been within or slightly less than the IQR.
Agricultural use of mainstem Colorado River water in Arizona
We estimated agricultural use of mainstem Colorado River water in Arizona by subtracting the total diverted by the CAP from the total use in Arizona. This remainder includes all the agricultural uses along the Colorado River as well as a small amount used by the City of Yuma, other towns along the river, and military bases.ยฒยณ
The monthly pattern of water use is similar to the monthly pattern by the IID. The smallest uses are between November and February (Fig. 7). Consumptive use increases in March and is highest between April and August.
Reductions in water use by these Arizona growers have been more modest than by IID. Recent average use has been somewhat less than the typical range between April and July and has been within the typical range in other months, except for November when there was significant precipitation near Yuma in 2025.
Figure 7. Box-and-whisker plots of total monthly consumptive use in Arizona by users of mainstem Colorado River not served by the CAP between 2010 and 2026. Each box is the Inter Quartile Range, defined by the 25th and 75th percentile of the years of data for that month. These boxes represent the typical monthly use pattern since 2010. Red dots are the average use in each month between 2024 and 2026. See text for additional explanation of a box-and-whisker plot.
Management and Policy Implications
Consumptive water use of mainstem water in the Lower Basin has been less than 7.5 maf/yr in every year but one since 2010. Since 2023 including forecast use in 2026, this reduction ranged between 1.4 and 1.7 maf/yr. The Lower Basin states have reduced water use comparable to the initial targets for Lower Basin shortages described in the recently released ROD24 and Operating Guidelines for 2027 and 2028.25 Thus, the good news is that the initial shortage goals of the FEIS have been achieved in recent years.
These savings have been achieved by large reductions in use by the CAP (Fig. 3) and by reduced agricultural water use in summer by IID (Fig. 6) and non-CAP water users in Arizona (Fig. 7). These reductions in agricultural water use have not resulted in changes of the amount of water consumed in winter when garden crops are grown.
The ROD allows for potentially large Lower Basin shortages of up to 3 maf/yr and potentially more in the event that Basin runoff continues to be low and reservoir live storage drops to critical levels. We placed these potential shortages in perspective by summing the smallest monthly use in each Lower Basin state since 2010 even though these months of smallest use did not occur in the same year. In some cases, the smallest water use was not due to significant water conservation but to unusually rainy conditions when demand for supplemental irrigation water was low, such as in November 2025. In other words, there is no historical experience with implementing the annual sum of these smallest monthly uses, because the smallest monthly uses did not occur in the same year.
Nevertheless, summing the lowest monthly use in each state provides perspective to the magnitude of the proposed 3 maf/yr shortages. The summed value of smallest monthly uses yields a potential minimum annual Lower Basin use of 5.03 maf/yr for the three Lower Basin states (Table 2). Although many of the months of smallest use occurred between 2022 and 2026, some were unique months of very low use in the 2010s. There is no historical analogy for imposition of the largest Lower Basin shortages envisioned by the recently released ROD and 2027-28 Operating Guidelines. [ed. emphasis mine]
Table 2. Smallest monthly consumptive use in each Lower Basin state since 2010.
CONCLUSION
The analyses summarized in this paper demonstrate that agricultural water use that supports winter garden crop production has not changed despite recent reductions in annual water use by IID or by non-CAP water users in Arizona. To date, water use by IID and by non-CAP water users in Arizona has been reduced in summer when garden crops are not grown. In times of acute water shortage, it is likely that continued and additional water savings can be achieved by reductions in irrigation of field crops in summer, without causing shortages to garden crop irrigation in the winter.
It is notable, however, that summing the lowest monthly water use in each state since 2010 results in a theoretical reduction from the Lower Basin allocation of 7.5 maf/yr of approximately 2.5 maf/yr, less than the maximum potential Lower Basin shortage envisioned in the recently released ROD. Our calculation of a theoretical shortage is based on summing the smallest use in each month between 2010 and 2026, and these months are not all in the same year. In some cases, the lowest use resulted from unusually large precipitation that reduced irrigation demand, rather than explicit conservation efforts.
The Priority Shortage Allocation Model utilized in the FEIS distributes shortages among the Lower Basin states in a much different manner than the way shortages have been achieved in the past.26 Tabulating the historical minimum monthly uses demonstrates that achieving the 3 maf/yr reductions described in the FEIS and ROD would be very difficult and is without historical precedent. Implementation of such large shortages would likely require new management policies, including compensated fallowing, permanent retirement of irrigated acreage and corresponding water rights, and unprecedented investment in increased irrigation efficiency.
We recognize that our theoretical comparison of minimum monthly uses since 2010 in no way captures the economic dislocation and secondary impacts that might result from implementing such shortages now. A full economic analysis of the impacts of the largest potential Lower Basin reductions described in the FEIS and the ROD is critical for understanding the consequences of significant reductions in water use in the Lower Basin. That type of analysis is beyond our expertise. Nevertheless, we recognize the importance of such an analysis, and we recognize the real-world distress that such large reductions of use might cause.
1ย Center for Colorado River Studies, Utah State University, former Chief, Grand Canyon Monitoring and Research Center.
2ย Getches-Wilkinson Center, Univ. of Colorado Law School, former US Commissioner, Upper Colorado River Commission, former Assistant Secretary for Water and Science, US Dept. of the Interior.
3ย Retired General Manager, Colorado River Water Conservation District.
4ย Kyl Center for Water Policy, Arizona State University, former Director, Phoenix Water Services.
5ย Sta๏ฌ Attorney, Utton Transboundary Resources Center, University of New Mexico.
7ย All annual data in this paper are calendar year. 2024 is the most recent year that consumptive uses and losses data are available for the entire Basin.
8ย Richter et al., 2024, New water accounting reveals why the Colorado River no longer reaches the sea. Communications Earth & Environment 5:134. available at https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-024-01291
โน Upper Basin state uses in Table 1 do not include state reservoir evaporation. Total major and minor state reservoir evaporation is listed separately in Table 1. Colorado River Storage Project (CRSP) reservoir evaporation is evaporation from Blue Mesa, Morrow Point, Flaming Gorge, and Lake Powell reservoirs. Source of Upper Basin data: J. Prairie, Upper Colorado Basin Research and Modeling Group Chief, Bureau of Reclamation. Source of Lower Basin state uses: Reclamation. 2025. Water use report: Arizona, California, Nevada, calendar year 2024. Source of mainstem reservoir evaporation (Mead, Mohave, Havasu) data: S. Tighi, Hydrologist, Reclamation, Lower Colorado Region. Evaporation at Senator Wash and diversion dams estimated at 28,000 af.
10 Department of the Interior, August 2026, Operating Guidelines: Colorado River Guidelines for Coordinated Operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead, Operating Years 2027 and 2028 (2027-28 Operating Guidelines), available atย https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/post2026/decision-doc/2027-2028OperatingGuidelines_Final.pdf. We note that these Operating Guidelines provide for 1.25 maf/yr of shortage, allocated among the Lower Basin states as previously proposed: 760,000 af/yr in Arizona, 440,000 af/yr in California, and 50,000 af/yr in Nevada, The distribution of shortages greater than 1.25 maf/yr is not specified but would presumably be subject to consultation. See 2027-28 Operating Guidelines at 5.3.A. The ROD allows for the development of different methods of shortage allocation. See ROD at 5.
ยนยฒ Lower Colorado River Water Accounting – Actual Water Use and Official Water Use Forecast, both available at https://www.usbr.gov/lc/region/g4000/wtracct.html. Throughout this paper, we refer to the forecast for 2026 that was made on September 1, 2026. The forecast is frequently revised.
ยนยณ There is no significant water use in the Grand Canyon.
14 Average Lower Basin consumptive use between 2010 and 2025 was 6.880 maf/yr.
16 Average use between 2010 and 2022 was 4.326 maf/yr. Average use between 2023 and (forecasted) 2026 will be 3.764 maf/yr.
17 Average use between 2010 and 2022 was 2.600 maf/yr. Average use between 2023 and (forecasted) 2026 will be 2.290 maf/yr.
18 Average use between 2010 and 2022 was 925,000 af/yr. Average use between 2023 and (forecasted) 2026 will be 804,000 af/yr.
19ย Average use between 2010 and 2022 was 2.590 maf/yr. Average use between 2023 and (forecasted) 2026 will be 1.930 maf/yr.
20ย IID used 2.187 maf in 2025, 2.312 maf in 2024, and is forecast to use 2.242 maf in 2026. Median use between 2010 and 2026 was 2.546 and use in 50% of the years of that period was between 2.481 and 2.558 maf/yr.
22ย Total net area of crops in 2025 was approximately 350,000 acres.
23ย Forecast use in 2026 for Bullhead City, Lake Havasu City, Parker, Yuma, U.S. Army Yuma Proving Grounds, and the U.S. Marine Corps Air Station Yuma is 35,000 af.
25ย Department of the Interior, August 2026, Operating Guidelines: Colorado River Guidelines for Coordinated Operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead, Operating Years 2027 and 2028 (2027-28 Operating Guidelines), available atย https://www.usbr.gov/ColoradoRiverBasin/post2026/decision-doc/2027-2028OperatingGuidelines_Final.pdf. We note that these Operating Guidelines provide for 1.25 maf of shortage in each year, allocated among the Lower Basin states as previously proposed: 760,000 af in Arizona, 440,000 af in California, and 50,000 af in Nevada. The distribution of shortage greater than 1.25 maf/yr is not specified but would presumably be the subject of consultation. See 2027-28 Operating Guidelines at 5.3.A. The ROD allows for the development of di๏ฌerent methods of shortage allocation. See ROD at 5.
26ย See FEIS Appendix C, Shortage Allocation Model and Alternative Distribution Model Documentation, at C.4.2. However, the ROD specifies that other methods of shortage allocation may be developed. ROD at 5.
Colorado River “Beginnings”. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism
Click the link to read the article on the Grist website (Austin Corona):
August 28, 2026
Nevada officials have long presented themselves as a voice for compromise and conservation in debates over the Colorado River. The Las Vegas area, home to two-thirds of the stateโs population and most of its economy, has become a model of urban water conservation. As the river has declined from overuse and a decades-long drought exacerbated by climate change, southern Nevada water planners built extensive water reuse facilities and implemented tight restrictions on new turf and fountains, dropping the regionโs per capita water use by 58 percent in roughly 20 years. Meanwhile, in interstate negotiations over the management of the Colorado River, state representatives have positioned themselves as bridge-builders, sometimes referring to themselves as the โmiddle basinโ between the riverโs divided upper and lower basin states.
When the federal governmentโs new management plan for the river was announced earlier this month, most observers thought Arizona, which stands to take the largest immediate cuts, would launch the first lawsuit over the planโs implications for its water supplies. So it came as a surprise to many Colorado River experts when Nevada became the first to sue the federal government over the plan this week.
โI expected that there would be litigation, but it was surprising to me that Nevada fired the first shot,โ said Anne Castle, former chair of the Upper Colorado River Commission.
The natural flow flow at Lees Ferry, which is a calculation of what the Colorado Riverโs flow would be without any upstream dams, diversions, or human consumption. Land Desk graph using Bureau of Reclamation data.
Nevadaโs lawsuit comes after more than two years of negotiations among the seven Colorado River states and the federal government over how to reduce water use on the declining river. The states failed to reach a long-term agreement before the riverโs current management procedures expire in October, leaving the Interior Department to impose its own plan. The federal governmentโs plan largely relies on cuts to water use among the Lower Basin states โ Arizona, Nevada, and California โ to prop up water levels in the riverโs largest reservoirs. Those reservoirs have been draining so quickly that the dwindling water depth could threaten hydropower and dam operations within months without intervention.
Nevada argues that the federal governmentโs plan illegally forces it to take too much of those cuts. In a worst-case scenario, the plan could allow for a 71 percent cut to the Las Vegas areaโs water supply, the state argued, calling it an unacceptable risk to the stateโs largest population center and economic hub. Nevada believes this outcome results from a misreading of the law and also claims the government didnโt consider important alternatives to such drastic cuts.
This worst-case scenario, which experts say is an interpretation of the planโs implications by Nevada, would become possible if reservoir levels continue to drop and if Nevada couldnโt reach an agreement with Arizona and California to help it absorb more of those cuts. Those three states already have such an agreement, which is incorporated into the federal plan and meant to last through 2028, at which point the plan allows the states to update the operations with a new agreement. Without an agreement, the federal government will implement cuts based on preexisting water rights and agreements, cutting the most from Arizona and leaning increasingly on Nevada and California as potential shortages increase. The plan was created through a decision-making process required under the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, which mandates that federal agencies gather public input and consider environmental and socioeconomic impacts of major decisions.
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Blue Mesa Reservoir on the Gunnison River, seen Aug. 30, 2026 at about 21% full. Anglers and boaters say federal water management decisions are negatively impacting fish and recreation below the reservoir. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
As this yearโs historic drought drags on, conflicts over how to share and manage water are bubbling over. Gunnison River anglers and boaters say federal water-management decisions are causing increased water temperatures, prompting fishing closures, and creating serious economic impacts to outfitters and businesses.
An Aug. 26 letter from Drew Peternell, Colorado state director of Trout Unlimited, to U.S. Bureau of Reclamation Area Manager Bart Deming, asks the federal agency to change its approach to drought management. The river conservation nonprofit organization asked Reclamation to increase streamflows in the Black Canyon and Gunnison Gorge to alleviate damage to the fishery; to evaluate water use by downstream irrigators; and to better understand the drivers of storage depletion.
โWe acknowledge that the extraordinary drought conditions of the current water year present significant operational challenges,โ the letter reads. โNevertheless, the decision to reduce flows in the Gunnison River has exerted a toll on a vital and cherished natural resource.โ
At a public Aug. 27 operations meeting in Grand Junction, Reclamation officials said they plan to reduce flows out of Blue Mesa Reservoir to as low as 200 cubic feet per second through February, in an effort to recover some storage in the reservoir, which is depleted after this yearโs record-breaking drought and hot temperatures. Flows so far this month have hovered around 245 cfs.
Peternell said Trout Unlimited would like to see flows of at least 300 cfs in the Gunnison River, the minimum threshold for a healthy environment set by a federal reserve water right. The Black Canyon and Gunnison Gorge are home to a 27-mile-long Gold Medal trout fishery and are downstream of the federally operated Aspinall Unit, which is made up of Blue Mesa, Morrow Point and Crystal reservoirs.
โItโs been a tough year for everyone and thereโs not enough water to go around, unfortunately, so we appreciate that Reclamation is in a tough spot,โ Peternell said in an interview with Aspen Journalism. โBut 300 cfs is a minimum flow target for the Black Canyon and itโs the minimum amount of water the fishery really needs to survive down there, and weโre below that. Weโre down to 250 or 240, and thatโs hard on the fish, itโs hard on the people who make a living off that fishery.โ
Federal water managers control how much water flows out of the Aspinall Unit in the highly engineered Gunnison River system, which is the largest tributary of the Colorado River in the state. Reclamation officials project storage in Coloradoโs largest reservoir could fall to just 128,000 acre-feet, or 15% full, by the end of the year under the most probable scenario.
At the Aug. 27 meeting, officials presented modeling that showed releasing water at a rate of 300 cfs could cause Blue Mesa to fall below the level needed to make hydropower, but 200 cfs will allow storage to build back up slightly over the winter. Reclamation officials presented modeling projections that showed if they donโt reduce releases now, the amount of water coming out of Blue Mesa may need to be dialed back to just 150 cfs this winter to preserve the ability to make hydropower.
โIf we didnโt act, this slide right here is a plane going down and we pull up at the last second,โ said Reece Carpenter, a Reclamation staffer with the Resources Management Division at the Western Area Office in Grand Junction. โSo itโs very important for Reclamation and all of our partners to have that coordination to make some decisions.โ
This management decision rests on a sentence in theย Record of Decisionย for the Aspinall Unitโs environmental impact statement, designed to protect endangered fish, that says โthe minimum downstream flow through the Black Canyon of the Gunnison National Park and Gunnison Gorge National Conservation Area is 300 cfs, except in severe drought when the flow may decrease.โ And the Colorado River Basin is experiencing the most severe drought in recorded history.
Tim Patterson, owner of RIGS Fly Shop & Guide Service in Ridgway and who has been guiding for more than 30 years, said Gunnison Gorge trips represent more than half of his companyโs guiding and outfitting business, and that flows of 200 cfs are a deal breaker. Low flows contribute to higher water temperatures, which can lead to fishing closures, and make navigating some rapids difficult, if not impossible.
Patterson would like more advance notice from federal water managers when flows will be dropping, and real-time temperature and flow monitoring. Patterson said he has already canceled a handful of trips this year and may have to cancel more if flows stay below about 250 cfs.
โThe Gunnison Gorge National Conservation Area, as far as a guided fly-fishing trip, is a bucket-list trip known around the world and a must-do,โ Patterson said. โSo people have planned for over a year in advance for this experience, and it just puts us in a real tough spot.โ
Boaters in the Gunnison Gorge National Conservation Area. A Ridgway outfitter said he has had to cancel trips this year because of low flows in the river. CREDIT: RIGS FLY SHOP & GUIDE SERVICE
Farmers facing โimmeasurable hardshipโ
While flows in the river decline, downstream irrigators are still taking nearly their entire allocation of water. The Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association is still diverting just more than 1,000 cfs through the Gunnison Tunnel. The association is a vast expanse of farmland that extends from just south of Montrose to Delta, and is the largest water user in the Upper Colorado River Basin. Water from the Gunnison River transforms the arid high desert into lush green fields of corn, pinto beans, onions and alfalfa.
The association normally gets half of its water supply from the Uncompahgre River. But this basin saw some of the worst snowpack in the state at just 14% of median. That means farmers in this area are experiencing deep water cuts this year. And some growers made the tough decision to leave fields dry and unplanted this year.
โIโve got a senior water right, and I got 50% of my system thatโs fallowed right now,โ Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association General Manager Steve Pope said at the Aug. 27 meeting.
This field in the Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association district has been fallowed this season due to a lack of water. The state of Colorado announced Wednesday that it will set up a conservation program using federal dollars, which means more fields on the Western Slope could soon look like this.ย CREDIT:ย HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
This yearโs conditions on the Gunnison River highlight how tensions are exacerbated among water-user groups โ especially in times of extreme drought. Coloradoโs prior appropriation system of water law says the oldest water rights have first use of the river, which almost always means agricultural water users get their water first.
The state didnโt begin to grant water rights for the environment until the 1970s and for recreation until around the early 2000s. Although a large part of the Western Slopeโs economy, culture and identity is now centered around outdoor recreation, keeping enough water in rivers for boating and fish is often the last priority.
The letter from Trout Unlimited asks Reclamation to evaluate power contracts with the Uncompahgre Water Users Association, which has several hydropower generating stations on its system of canals, and implement clear efficiency standards for water use. The letter lists reasons that suggest more water is being diverted from the Gunnison River than is necessary for irrigation.
Pope called their concerns โabsolutely ridiculous.โ
โThese farmers have suffered immeasurable hardships this year, and for someone to say, โWe think you should further reduce to maintain water temperatures and fish flows in the Black Canyon,โโ Pope said. โThey donโt bring a water right to the table; they donโt bring anything but a demand, and I donโt agree with it. Irrigation and agriculture is the senior priority, and itโs going to be used.โ
Pope said he plans to dial back Gunnison River diversions to about 700 cfs by mid-September, but the river wonโt see a bump in flows because of Reclamationโs plan to keep dam releases low to build back storage.
This rock formation known as the Dillon Pinnacles on the shores of Blue Mesa Reservoir on Aug. 30, 2026. Federal water managers say they will hold reservoir releases to between 200 and 300 cfs until February in an effort to recover storage in the reservoir. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
Patterson is hoping his business can get through September โ which is the busiest month for multiday trips through the gorge โ relatively unscathed. He would like to see more collaboration and communication between water managers and water users, and he wants anglers to have a seat at the table.
Patterson framed the issue not as a fight among water users, but as an unevenly built safety net in times of shortage. For now, river recreation remains largely at the mercy of upstream decision-makers.
โWeโre seeing it all over the Colorado drainage,โ Patterson said. โYou canโt demand water that isnโt there. But passing it through a special place like this and working with us on times of years to minimize water temperature issues and things like that is a great step. I think it starts with acknowledging that this place is special and important and deserves to be protected.โ
The Government Highline Canal, courtesy ofย Wikipedia.
Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):
September 3, 2026
Farmers served by the Government Highline Canal as of today will get no water, a result of last winterโs dismal snowpack and low levels in Green Mountain Reservoir
The Government Highline Canal has delivered water to farms in Coloradoโs Grand Valley during irrigation season for more than 110 years.
Thursday will be a first in that long history. No water will be available in that canal to farmers, even though the growing season has not ended.
โThis will be the first time since around 1914 the Government Highline Canal has been at undeliverable levels during the irrigation season, which usually runs until Nov. 1 (and sometimes later),โ said Tina Bergonzini, general manager of the Grand Valley Water Users Association.
Water supplied by reservoirs upstream in the Colorado River headwaters has essentially run out.
The predicament on the Colorado River had become apparent by April. Record-breaking heat of March made it extremely likely that runoff would be anemic. It got a bit better in May, but not much.
This was clearly evident at Green Mountain Reservoir, between Silverthorne and Kremmling. The dam had been built between 1938 and 1943, as part of a quid pro quo. Farmers in northeastern Colorado, particularly in the Fort Collins-Longmont-Greeley triangle, wanted to divert water from the Colorado River headwaters.
Western Slope representatives objected. They worried that they would lose irrigation water they needed after spring runoff subsided in June and July. The federally financed dam was the answer. It can hold nearly 154,745 acre-feet of water. Of that, 66,000 is marked for delivery to downstream irrigators, most in the Grand Junction area.
Green Mountain was the quid for the quo of the Colorado Big-Thompson Project annual diversion of between 200,000 and 230,000 acre-feet through the Continental Divide.
It worked โ until this year.
In April, the low levels in the reservoir made it clear that the farmers would not get the full amount of water they had come to expect. The Glenwood Springs-based Colorado River District created a plan to ease the shortage.
The district โ which had been created to look out after Western Slope interests in the 1930s โ looked into how it could tap various pools of water, getting a thimbleful here, a cupful there. Irrigators wouldnโt become whole, but they would get help, said Andy Mueller, the general manager of the River District at the boardโs April meeting.
DeBeque Canyon has changed somewhat since this photo of the Roller Dam was taken in 1916. Most notably, now the canyon has an interstate highway. Photo/U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. For a more complete history, see the Palisade Historical Society page.
Water for the Grand Valley Canal is diverted from the Colorado River at what is called the Roller Dam on the Colorado River just east of Palisade. It continues 55 miles down the valley, mostly north of I-70, ending near Mack, 10 miles from the Utah border.
The canal is called the โgovernmentโ for a good reason. It was built with federal money via the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, an agency created in 1902 to help turn arid places like the Grand Valley into gardens and orchards. Accounts vary about when the water began flowing in the canal. Some say 1913, others 1914 or 1915. Regardless, the water has always flowed since before the United States entered World War I.
Until this year.
Early in the irrigation season, irrigators benefitting from the canal agreed to curtail their water use in exchange for getting water from reservoirs near the Colorado River headwaters later in the season.
That sounds simple enough. The mechanics are complicated. Crucial to understand is the seniority of the โCameo callโ at the Roller Dam, where water is diverted. Upstream users have to honor that very senior call.
The call is for 1,950 cubic feet per second. Grand Valleyโs Bergonzini said her district lowered the target by 300 cfs and then another 200 cfs, or 1,450 cfs. That left a little more water in Green Mountain. Altogether, the reduced water diverted from the Colorado โ combined with the two storms during May โ brought the amount of water available in Green Mountain up to 50% of the allotment for the Grand Valley farmers.
This story has endless details. The essential story is that those with rights to water on the Colorado River within Colorado โ including a transmountain diverter, Northern Water โ have worked with the irrigation district to ensure the farmers in the Grand Valley had some water during the growing days of summer. Water officials stress what Bergonzini calls โteamwork and collaboration between entities.โ
Upstream reservoirs tapped included Wolford and Wiliams Fork, both near Kremmling, and Ruedi, near Basalt. An additional 5,000 came from Granby Reservoir late in the season.
Helping out were appropriations of $450,000 from the River District in April and then, in May, $585,000 from the Colorado Water Conservation Board.
Still, farmers dependent upon the ditch only got 50% of the water they normally would from Green Mountain.
Some of the teamwork involves Orchard Mesa Irrigation District. The Grand Valley and Orchard Mesa districts have an agreement to share shortages.
A short distance east of Palisade, water from the Colorado River is pumped up to Orchard Mesa. Photo/Allen Best
Orchard Mesa pumps water uphill from near Palisade to the mesa, site of many of the peaches for which Palisade is famous. Farther down on the Government Highline Canal, other farms grow alfalfa, wheat, and usually corn. This year, however, little corn was grown, yielding to Sudan grass, triticale, and barley, as they are shorter season and can be grown with less water, said Grand Valleyโs Bergonzini.
Both peach and grape orchards on Orchard Mesa have done quite well, said Rob Talbott, president of the irrigation districtโs board of directors.
The fundamental story, he said, is that โeverybody is doing whatever they can to share their water.โ
The sharing continues. The peach orchards need water now if they will be productive next year.
โThe peach trees (primarily on Orchard Mesa) need water right now to get ready for hibernation whereas my growers (served by Government Highline Canal) can wait for a bit to water in winter wheat and hay. They crop switched earlier this year to shorter season crops, so we have different needs,โ explained Bergonzini.
The canal is designed for flows of 730 cfs, not for the 100 cfs now available. As such, she said, itโs better to let the peach trees have the water now.
โThen, IF THE RIVER HAS RISEN SOME,โ said Bergonzini, using all-caps for emphasis in her e-mail, Grand Valley will take Orchard Mesaโs irrigation water and augment it with what is available in the river to get some crops watered along the 55-mile canal.
That could happen at the end of September.
โWe are planning on running late โ perhaps the middle of November if the weather allows without freezing, to assure our growers get good moisture on their fall crops,โ she said.
Lauren Boebert at the Colorado Water Congress Annual Summer Conference. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots
Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):
August 31, 2026
Many political office-seekers spoke at the annual summer conference in Steamboat. Some โyโalled to the attendees. Others not so much. Most called forย ย more water storage and โforest resilience.โ
โGod bless, yโall,โ said Victor Marx, the Republican candidate for governor in Colorado in wrapping up his allotted 15 minutes at the podium at the Colorado Water Congress summer conference in Steamboat Springs.
Lauren Boebert, who represents the Fourth Congressional District in Colorado, followed him on the agenda. โIt is wonderful to be back with yโall at Water Congress,โ said Boebert, a Republican seeking her fourth term in Congress.
Yโalls were common during her quarter-hour on stage. It being a water conference, one of them had to do with water. โSo yโall better get real good at that xero-scaping for your lawns and everything youโre building out there because your cactus, your cacti might do just fine, but weโre taking it back,โ she said of Arizona.
Dwayne Romero, the Democratic candidate in Boebertโs former Third Congressional District, who preceded them, used none.
What this says exactly, Iโm not sure. Yโall is a Southern locution that has become somewhat more common across the United States. I do note that Romero grew up in southeast Texas while Marx was reared in Louisiana, both of those places thick with yโalls and drawls. As for Boebert, she came to Colorado from Florida at the age of four.
Water Congressโs twice-annual conferences always have elected officials as well as water leaders from across Colorado. This being election season in 2026, the time devoted to the pols was greater than normal.
Victor Marx, the Republican nominee for Colorado governor, says Colorado must be prepared adequately for when the rain and snow returns. Photo/Allen Best
Like Marx, some are seeking statewide offices, while others, including Boebert and Romero, are running for Congress in districts with more rural areas.
That makes sense, as the Water Congress has a strong rural constituency. Denver Water is well represented, but so is Logan County. I also noted that Rod Lenz, the chair of the Republican River Water Conservation Districtโs board of directors, managed to get to the conference by Wednesday morning after a meeting in Holyoke that lasted long into the previous afternoon. Thatโs a good five-hour trip by car.
As for the yโalls, I have no idea whether Jeff Hurd, the Third Congressional District incumbent, Phil Weiser, the Democratic nominee for governor, drawled yโalls. I suspect not. I have heard both speak several times. Neither is a yโall guy. Both are also attorneys.
Perhaps not surprisingly, Romero and Boebert started out on much the same note in their remarks about the Colorado River. Romero mentioned โdecades of lower-basin useโ and urged solidarity with Coloradoโs negotiating team on โprotecting Coloradoโs compact entitlements.โ Boebert struck the same tone but with more pugilistic language. โWeโre fighting for what belongs to us and for our future generations.โ
Beyond those obligatory remarks, the two candidates differed greatly. Boebert talked about what she has done for her constituents regarding water and mentioned her work on the Arkansas Valley Conduit Project. โEven though my dear great president may have vetoed that, we are still working to get that over the line for Southeast Colorado.โ
Boebert was typical Boebert, saucy and sort of interesting in how she played to her base. She wore blue jeans, as that seems to be her style when making the rounds in Colorado. In what may be more revealing, she also tried to talk about her bi-partisan work. I also noticed she did so when running in a tight race in her former congressional district, the third, in 2022. She won that race by a mere 546 votes, precipitating her move across the Continental Divide.
Maybe itโs because she is in what appears to be a tougher contest with the Democratic candidate, Eileen Laubacher, a retired Navy rear admiral, in a district that in the past has been unflinchingly Republican. Laubacherโs resume, money and growing institutional support could, noted Axios in a story last week, โmake Boebert sweat.โ Laubacher also spoke at the conference. But again, I was elsewhere.
Themes
Two themes were evident in remarks made by the office-seekers and others at the conference. One was the need for more storage, the other for more โwatershed restorationโ via Proposition 137, the proposal on the November ballot to divert sales tax revenues from sporting goods to do work in the forests and expand funding for parks.
The discussions in a general way crossed party lines but the storage case was cited more prominently by Republican speakers. Absent, though, was the sort of specifics I thirsted for.
Politicians rarely get into the details when on the stump, of course. And 15 minutes isnโt much time. Boebertโs comments will likely be echoed in the next two months.
โForest management is not optional anymore. It never was, and for anyone to come up and present policy that is more reactive then proactive is failing you and each and every one of us โ is failing future generations,โ said Boebert. โHealthy forests hold snow longer, release water cleaner, and protect our watersheds from catastrophic fires that turn drinking water into ash.โ
Boebert then took aim at clean energy.
โWe hear all the environmental claims about carbon emissions, but these wildfires that are too quickly growing out of control, burning down our beautiful state, neighboring states in the West, with more than 6 billion standing dead trees that no one will allow us to harvest or not harvest enough of, unfortunately even taking lives of first respondersโฆโ
Boebert attributed to NASA a statistic: A wildfire produces more greenhouse gas emissions than all of the cars fueled by fossil fuels in a year.
โSo EVs arenโt the answer. Sending your money to DC for wind and solar isnโt the answer. Itโs being good stewards of our land, managing our forests.โ
The storage theme also got lots of attention. It was bipartisan. Little of the conversation went very deep. Some of it was almost insultingly oversimplified.
Consider what Marx had to say: โWe canโt make it snow. We canโt make it rain. But we can decide whether weโre prepared for when the water comes. So I believe we should store water in good years. Lord, please send it.โ
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
It sounds good, being โprepared adequately.โ But that statement assumes good years will come. Examining the science, Colorado State Universityโs Brad Udall has suggested there may not be any good years, let alone enough to fill all the [reservoirs] already built.
Consider that we have two giant reservoirs on the Colorado River sitting 75% empty. And in the headwaters, Green Mountain Reservoir is 15.1% full, as of Sunday, according to the Bureau of Reclamation. Blue Mesa Reservoir was only marginally better. Navajo, on the Colorado-New Mexico border, is doing better at 40% to 45%.
Romeroโs call for partnership
Of the three office-seekers I heard, Romero was most interesting. It was obvious to me he had taken the time to study the Colorado River issues. As for Marx, he rambled.
Romeroโs comments were calculated, of course. He was making a case for stability after the chaos of the Trump presidency.
โWe have to restore Congress and our federal agencies as institutions that work. Congress has to legislate. It has to authorize projects. It has to appropriate money. It has to conduct oversight. Those are all the rules that were stipulated in the Constitution for our Congress,โ he said.
I suspect Jeff Hurd would agree with at least parts of that statement.
Green Mountain Reservoir, seen here on Aug.17, sits about 85% empty. Most other reservoirs have more water stored, but not that much. Photo/Allen Best
He later talked about what this meant on the ground. โA rancher canโt make long-term conservation investments around a pilot program that could disappear with the next administration,โ he said.
What must be restored, he continued, is a federal partnership with the state, โwhere federal dollars turn local grit into lasting resilience. So hereโs the heart of it: We have the right people, we have the expertise, we have the will. Now we need to bring real, sustained funding and solutions and resources to bear, enough to help us build resilience for the next 50 years of demand. And we need genuine, reliable partners.โ
As for resilience, said Romero, it comes from many projects. โItโs a modernized diversion that lets a farmer grow more with less. Itโs a storage that gives a community room to breathe in a drought. Itโs a treated watershed that doesnโt burn catastrophically. And itโs securing an historic right like Shoshone, so it benefits Colorado permanently.โ
Shoshone, of course, is the hydroelectric plant in Glenwood Canyon, and the Colorado River District is nearing success in its multi-year effort to make sure that the very senior water rights continue to ensure water flows downstream. Itโs complicated, of course.
โThese things take money. The federal government has helped build the water structure that made this modern American West possible. It is their responsibility to be a reliable partner with us, adapting that infrastructure and those institutions to the 21st century. They need to stay with us for capital and capital improvements.โ
Romero wrapped up his speech with this observation: โOur hardest moments are often when we find our common ground.โ That means, he said, โcreating solutions that last beyond the next drought, the next negotiations, or the next administration, but for generations to come.โ
Sounds good โ but where does additional storage make sense that allows communities to breathe?
As for forest resilience, it sounds good โ but what exactly is being proposed? Most environmental organizations seem to support Proposition 137, as do Denver Water and Northern Water. Western Resource Advocates and other environmental organizations are pushing it.
I still have major questions about the mechanics even after sitting through an hour-long press conference on Monday morning. Sometimes I can be fuzzy in my thinking, but in this case I think thereโs some fuzziness about what is being proposed.
It was among the first to see its lower-priority water eliminated in the 2019 Drought Contingency Plan.
The Eloy irrigation district secured state and federal aid to resume pumping groundwater, but those wells only produce a fraction of the water that the Central Arizona Project once delivered.
In a gravity-fed system like CAIDDโs, less water in canals means less momentum to push water to every customer.
โSome laterals are better than others,โ said district president Dan Shedd, who irrigated 2,200 acres when Colorado River water was still flowing.
Thatโs down to about 600 acres now.
โMy neighbor canโt farm as much as I can because of where the wells are situated. Most of us are less than 50%.โ
Farms need extra in summer
Farmers across the district have adapted to this new reality.
Most have fallowed land. Some have sold or leased parcels to solar projects to help make ends meet.
Many remaining fields have been reconfigured into smaller plots, so lower-pressure water can move uniformly across them.
And farmers are diversifying what they grow.
โNormally, Iโd have 1,600 acres in cotton,โ Shedd, an Arizona Farm Bureau member, said.
โBut now Iโm growing wheat and garbanzo beans in the winter when thereโs more water. Itโs just a break-even deal.โ
Summer is a different story.
Though more profitable alfalfa, cotton, corn and Bermuda grass can be grown then, it can be a struggle to pump enough water when the heatโs on and everyone needs irrigation at once.
In past years, the irrigation district has secured extra supplies from nearby providers to supplement when needs are highest.
But that water is growing scarce as others across Arizona now face cuts.
CAIDD knows it needs to do more.
Cadiz has groundwater to sell
Meanwhile, a California company called Cadiz is looking for interested parties to sell its groundwater, which it says would otherwise be lost to evaporation in a dry lakebed.
The water and land management company has secured rights to pump up to 75,000 acre-feet of water a year from an aquifer roughly the size of Lake Mead.
Its Mojave Groundwater Bank, located about two hours west of Lake Havasu City in Arizona, is neither new nor universally welcomed in California.
Opponents have tried to stop the project multiple times over 30 years.
But Cadiz recently secured the last federal permit it needs to begin converting a natural gas line to transport its water north and west.
The idea, at least initially, is to exchange that water with users who receive supplies from the State Water Project.
That water would flow to Los Angeles, in an agreement that has yet to be cemented, where users there would agree to conserve a commensurate amount of Colorado River water.
Central Arizona Project map via Mountain Town News
And then, in other agreements that still must be negotiated, 10,000 acre-feet of that water would flow to CAIDD through the Central Arizona Project canal.
Effort now is to lower the price
If this sounds complicated, it is.
Finalizing complex agreements to move water every year for at least five decades is one thing.
Lowering the price for CAIDD to officially bite on this deal is another.
โWe canโt pass the cost onto food,โ Cadiz CEO Susan Kennedy said, particularly when farmers already operate on slim margins.
Kennedy โ a long-time California political operative โ is rustling the bushes for private investment and an 80% federal funding match.
She is also working with the Bureau of Reclamation to develop a model exchange agreement that could be used to expedite other interstate water transfers.
This could change the narrative
Ten thousand acre-feet is a drop in the bucket for CAIDD, which even at diminished capacity delivered about 160,000 acre-feet last year.
Itโs not enough water to restore fields that have been taken out of production.
But it is enough to provide more long-term certainty for those that remain.
If the deal comes together, it could prove to other irrigation districts that new supplies arenโt necessarily out of reach, and that agriculture has a more secure future in Arizona, despite its current water challenges.
And even if it doesnโt, district leaders contend, the conversation could open doors to other ideas and opportunities.
โThis could bring water to Arizona, whether or not we can utilize it,โ said Ron McEachern, CAIDDโs former general manager.
Eagle County is currently within the region of Colorado facing D4 conditions, which is the most extreme level of drought. Colorado Drought Monitor map August 25, 2026
Click the link to read the article on the Vail Daily website (John LaConte). Here’s an excerpt:
August 28, 2026
Upper Eagle Regional Water Authority now required to replace diversions with more water
On Aug. 14, the Colorado Division of Water Resources placed whatโs known as a โcallโ on the Eagle River, meaning that any water user with junior water rights is now required to stop diverting, or replace their diversions with augmentation water. The call came as no surprise to water managers, and is not uncommon in drought years when the Eagle River between Gore Creek and Lake Creek reaches an average flow that is less than 85 cubic feet per second between May 1 and Sept. 30. That minimum average threshold was set in a court decree issued Oct. 7, 1981, which said that minimum streamflow is โrequired to preserve the natural environment to a reasonable degree on the Eagle River.โ What is uncommon, said Tim Friday, director of water & utility resources for the Eagle River Water & Sanitation District, is the fact that the Colorado Division of Water Resources consulted with the district before placing the call on the Eagle River. The call could have been placed a month earlier, as the average minimum flow had dropped below 85 cfs back in July, but the Division of Water Resources stalled it a month in case flows came back up…The Eagle River Water & Sanitation District isnโt as affected by the call, as many of the water rights in the district are senior to the 1981 court decree, but the Upper Eagle Regional Water Authority, which also supplies water to many properties in Eagle County, has water rights that are junior to the 1981 decree…For more information about the instream flow rights on the Eagle River, visitย Coloradoโs Decision Support Systems website.
This ditch in the Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association flows past an unplanted field. The River District is concerned that legal tools the state plans to use for its new conservation program could favor certain regions, like the Uncompahgre Valley. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
Colorado could most easily wring water from Grand, Uncompahgre, Upper Gunnison valleys
Western Slope water managers are raising concerns that the legal tools used under Coloradoโs new conservation program could cause negative impacts to local communities and the stateโs agricultural industry.
In a letter to the state water board, the Glenwood Springs-based Colorado River Water Conservation District said it is concerned that the legal mechanisms state officials plan to use to move conserved water into downstream reservoirs may mean certain geographic areas are more likely to give up water. The River District also says the programโs framework should be set by lawmakers โ with a significant stakeholder process โ during the 2027 session, instead of by the Colorado Water Conservation Board and state Division of Water Resources officials.
At its July meeting, River District staff presented a map of the river basins in its 15-county region, showing which areas were most likely to participate in a conservation program. The Uncompahgre River basin; Dolores River basin; Colorado River in the Grand Valley; White River near Rangely; and Green River, Little Snake; and the Yampa in the Maybell/ Lily Park area were the most likely regions to see participation in a new state conservation program.
โWhat it shows is the potential for the disparate impacts,โ River District General Manager Andy Mueller said at the July board meeting. โAnd because itโs so easy to pay someone in the Grand Valley for a full [growing] season, thatโs going to be the inclination. Thatโs the easy thing.โ
In July, officials from the CWCB and Division of Water Resources unveiled what they are calling a โnear-term contribution program,โ designed to pay water users in the Upper Colorado River Basin (Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming) to voluntarily cut back for the next two years. The state of Colorado will run its own program, alongside similar programs in Utah and Wyoming, using $100 million in promised funding from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.
โWe have this federal funding available to us and to bring those funds into Colorado, we need to hit the ground running and start the application window,โ Amy Ostdiek, interstate section chief at the CWCB, said in an interview with Aspen Journalism. โSo we are looking at doing this with the tools we have available under the law as it exists today. And thatโs just kind of the reality of the timing of it.โ
Shepherding vs. existing authorities
One of the complications of setting up a contribution program are the legal tools used to move water saved upstream to either Lake Powell or Blue Mesa Reservoir, where the state can then get credit from Reclamation for the stored water. One of the criticisms of past pilot conservation programs was that the water was not tracked to Lake Powell nor measured to see how much ended up there.
State lawmakers would need to pass a law to ensure that conserved water is protected as it moves through the river system so that it reaches a specified downstream reservoir without being taken by other water users along the way, a process known as โshepherding.โ State officials believe they have the legal authority to shepherd water across the state line only in the case of a call from the Lower Basin states (California, Arizona and Nevada). And so far, the Lower Basin has never placed a compact call.
That means the most straightforward places to wring water from the state are the Grand Valley, the Uncompahgre Valley and the Upper Gunnison Valley. The irrigation districts of the Grand and Uncompahgre valleys are close to the state line and the Upper Gunnison Valley is just above Blue Mesa, so the majority of water conserved in these locations will get to where it needs to go without the state Division of Water Resources having to actively shepherd it.
The River District has long warned that these types of programs, if not done carefully, could cause negative economic impacts by removing water from the Western Slopeโs rural agricultural communities.
โWithout shepherding, you end up with the potential that there are certain areas that are targeted and can produce water in this program and other areas that cannot,โ Mueller said. โTherefore, you end up with these disproportionate impacts that weโve been concerned about.โ
Sonia Chavez is the general manager of the Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District, one of the areas that could be singled out. The 59,000 irrigated acres of agricultural land in the district produces mostly hay and is above the stateโs largest reservoir, Blue Mesa, where state officials plan to store water conserved under the program.
โThat has not been lost on us that we are the only community sitting above a federal reservoir in the state of Colorado,โ Chavez said.
State officials say they intend to use their โexisting authoritiesโ for this new program, without the change in state law needed to allow shepherding. But the precise definition of existing authorities is still unclear. Officials said it could include loans of conserved water to the stateโs instream flow program or releasing water from Blue Mesa Reservoir at times of year when downstream users wonโt pick it up, so the water is nearly guaranteed to get to the state line.
The River Districtโs letter asks the CWCB for more clarity on the definition of existing authorities and how they would be used as part of a contribution program.
From left, Interstate Section Chief at the CWCB Amy Ostdiek, Colorado representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission Becky Mitchell and State Engineer Jason Ullmann, speak on a panel at Colorado Water Congress on August 20, 2026 in Steamboat Springs. State officials are rolling out a water conservation program that would pay water users to temporarily cut back. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
Lawmaker involvement
The creation of a conservation program for Colorado comes at a critical time for the basin, which remains locked in the grip of a historic drought, combined with a management crisis. With the seven states that share the river still unable to find agreement on a new framework after more than two years of failed negotiations, the federal government has stepped in with its own two-year operating plan. That plan, which was released last week and includes cuts to water use in the Lower Basin, immediately triggered a lawsuit from the state of Nevada.
While the Lower Basin states are subject to mandatory cuts under the federal plan, the Upper Basin is not. But the four Upper Basin states have offered to voluntarily contribute 100,000 acre-feet of water over the next two years, when conditions allow, which would be set forth in a parallel agreement with Reclamation separate from the federal management plan. Coloradoโs conservation program is an effort to make good on that promise.
โWeโre in the post-2026 world, and I think that acting now and doing what we can with the authorities that we have shows Coloradoโs commitment and demonstrates that we are at the table in a meaningful way,โ Ostdiek said. โWe think itโs important, for various reasons, to move forward with this now.โ
In its letter, the River District also asks for the state to limit the criteria it uses to approve participation to a one-year, temporary program so lawmakers can use the 2027 session to use a stakeholder process to come up with a framework for a future program beginning in 2028.
โThe Colorado River District has long advocated that any government action that facilitates a Colorado River conserved consumptive use program inside the State of Colorado โ or directs the Colorado State Engineer to shepherd conserved water to the state line, whether done under existing authorities or otherwise โ must only be done through legislation enacted by the Colorado General Assembly,โ the River Districtโs letter reads.
At a June hearing of the stateโs Water Resources and Agriculture Review Committee, lawmakers told state officials that the legislature should be involved in the creation of a conservation program.
But putting the conservation issue โ which remains controversial โ before stakeholders and lawmakers hasnโt yielded results in the past. In 2023, a 17-member, state-wide drought task force, was supposed to make recommendations to lawmakers about what a conservation program should look like. The group could not agree and did not advance any recommendations on that topic, with some members saying a state conservation program was premature.
And at an August 2025 meeting of the Water Resources and Agricultural Review Committee, some Delta County ranchers asked lawmakers to consider a bill to allow shepherding during the 2026 session. They did not.
State officials held a workshop to get feedback about a water conservation program at Colorado Water Congress Aug. 19 in Steamboat Springs. Water users have for years expressed concerns about equity and protecting water rights in programs like this. CREDIT: HEATHER SACKETT/ASPEN JOURNALISM
CWCB taking feedback
CWCB officials are currently taking comments and feedback on the contribution program. They held a well-attended workshop for water users on August 19, 2026 at Colorado Water Congress in Steamboat Springs. Attendees had many of the same lingering concerns that haveย been voiced for years, including how to protect water rights and how to encourage participation across the state.ย
State officials plan to offer different amounts of compensation to participating water users to account for the difference in the value of relatively cheap water on the Western Slope versus more expensive water on the Front Range. So far, in previous pilot conservation programs, every participant has been a Western Slope water user.
Western Slope agricultural water users have long said that if they donโt see comparable cuts being taken by Front Range municipalities, which collectively draw about 500,000 acre-feet from the headwaters of the Colorado River each year, that they wonโt want to participate. They donโt want Front Range urban growth to be fueled by water cuts west of the Continental Divide.
At the workshop, Northern Waterโs Director of Engineering Kyle Whitaker tried to put that fear to rest, saying the water provider, which supplies water to farms and communities on the Front Range like Fort Collins, Boulder and Longmont through its Colorado-Big Thompson project, would participate in future conservation programs.
โAs transmountain diverters to the east, I only speak for Northern Water, and we will participate from here going forward,โ Whitaker said. โWeโve been working on things to be a part of this for a number of years now, and those are finally in place.โ
The CWCB is set to consider the criteria for program participation at its September meeting.
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
It seems like every time the Colorado River and other Western water woes make national headlines, some pundit โ usually from the East Coast โ weighs in with their โsimpleโ or โobviousโ solution. And I get mad and start throwing things around the room, then type out some blistering rant riddled with epithets and insults.
Well, the Colorado River is in the news again, and with it have come the usual swarm of oversimplified hot-takes. The one that really got my goat this time is from Matthew Yglesias, who wrote a piece headlined: The Western water crisis has a simple solution: Stop giving the majority of the water away to farmers for almost nothing!
These things piss me off so much not because theyโre wrong, but because there is no โsimpleโ solution to the Western water crisis. Thatโs because the crisis itself isnโt simple, and saying that it has simple fixes implies that the folks who have spent a lot of time trying to solve the problem are a bunch of idiots, since they hadnโt come up with this solution already. It seems as if Yglesias and his ilk assume that the West is not only monolithic, but that we Westerners are a bunch of backwoods bumpkins who donโt understand the regionโs own problems.
Who cares what these bozos believe, right? Right. But judging by the comments on Yglesiasโ social media posts, a lot of other people are similarly deluded. So I figured his piece provides a nice opportunity to clear some things up.
West Drought Monitor map August 25, 2026
In fact, there is no single โWestern water crisis.โ The West is huge and is geographically, hydrographically, and ecologically diverse. While most, but not all, of the Western U.S. is in some stage of drought currently, not all of those places are experiencing a water crisis, per se. There is a Colorado River water crisis and a Rio Grande water crisis and a San Joaquin Valley water crisis, but those crises are not all the same.
The Colorado River crisis is multifaceted and manifests in different ways in different places and on different levels. The river itself is in crisis, in that stretches of the mainstem and its tributaries virtually dry up during summers like this one. Its users are facing a potential crisis, i.e. looming shortages, as in some of them are getting less water from the river than they did in the past. And the vast and complex plumbing system and legal framework that has been built up to harness and govern the river is perhaps facing the most immediate crisis: It is collapsing under its own weight and in many ways has become obsolete. Each of these is a distinct calamity, with its own twists, turns, causes, and bevy of potential solutions.
From his perch in the Northeast, however, Yglesias sees just one dimension, writing in the โnut grafโ of his piece:
Uh, not quite.
Yes, irrigated agriculture is by far the dominant consumer of Colorado River water, accounting for 52% of overall consumption and 74% of direct human consumption. And yes, agricultural users typically and notoriously pay less for the water than municipal users. No, this is not dictated by federal law.
Agricultural users were among the first entities in the colonial-settler era to put large quantities of water to beneficial use, giving them the most senior rights to the largest quantities of water. The Imperial Irrigation District, for example, has senior rights to about 3 million acre-feet of Colorado River water, most of which is used for agriculture.
These water rights holders have a legal right to use a set amount of water each year. They are not leasing or purchasing the water from the federal government or anyone else. Itโs essentially theirs, for free, as long as they are able to divert it from the river and put it to beneficial use.
San Luis People’s Ditch March 17, 2018. Photo credit: Greg Hobbs
Usually the water rights are held by irrigation districts, ditch companies, municipalities, corporations, or, in some cases, very large individual landholders. In the late 1800s, these entities built their own diversions, canals, and delivery systems. Construction was often financed by private investors and the individual irrigators, who held stocks, or shares, in the ditch company. Each share would entitle its holder to a set amount of water from the canal. The shareholder would pay an annual fee for each share to cover construction, maintenance, and operating costs.
The Bureau of Reclamation was established in 1902 to build larger scale dams, diversions, and canals to deliver water to users and to spur agricultural development in the arid West. Call it the nationalized version of an irrigation district, but on steroids. The federal government paid for the projects, but the irrigation districts and municipal water utilities they served were expected to pay back the costs over time. The taxpayers supposedly wouldnโt have to pay a dime. Yet as the years went by, and as the budgets of the projects skyrocketed, the terms of the paybacks were relaxed, especially for agricultural users. This effectively subsidized water delivery, which in turn lowered farmersโ costs.
The All American Canal, the largest diversion on the Colorado River, passes through Winterhaven, CA on its way to the Imperial Valley. The Colorado River is seen flowing next to it.
One of the Bureauโs big projects was the 80-mile-long All-American Canal, built in the 1930s to ferry Colorado River water to the Imperial Irrigation District and other users. The IID entered into a 50-year payback contract, which ended in 1994. The Bureau still owns the canal, but the IID operates and maintains it and other infrastructure that delivers Colorado River water to nine cities and some 500,000 acres of farmland.
The IID pays nothing for the Colorado River water itself. It does pay to operate and maintain its vast water delivery system, and offsets those costs by charging agricultural and municipal users just $20 per acre-foot for water it delivers, a bargain basement rate. In other words, Imperial Valley farmers do get cheap water, but so do Imperial Valley cities and even industry (which pays $85/af, also relatively affordable). IID also brings in about $160 million annually by selling water to the San Diego County Water Authority. The operating costs for the All-American Canal system are lower than, say, the Central Arizona Projectโs, because the All-American Canal is gravity fed, whereas the CAP uses huge amounts of electricity to pump water uphill.
Similar setups exist across the Colorado River Basin. But each system is distinct, and each has its own mix of federal and private funding and operational scenarios and rates.
And hereโs one of the main flaws of Yglesiasโs argument: He assumes that thereโs some all powerful actor out there that sets rates and standards for water from the Colorado River, although he himself clearly doesnโt know who or what that actor is (he always uses the passive voice, or the all-encompassing โyouโ in these cases). Thatโs because that entity doesnโt exist. While the feds could stop subsidizing agriculture, and should not build any more water projects, they donโt have the authority to step in and adjust water rates. States probably could set rates for groundwater, but they canโt charge the IID for exercising their water rights on the Colorado River.
Next, Yglesias pivots to pillorying alfalfa, because thatโs in vogue these days. Iโm not going to get into that too much, because Iโve written about it so many times here before, but this little bit is pretty funny:
Now, Iโmย no alfalfa apologistย (nor am I anย alfalfaphobe), but I feel like I should point out that most of the alfalfa grown with Colorado River water is used to feed dairy cows, which in turn produce milk and cheese and ice cream. Unless Yglesias is a vegan, he might want to consider that. He then argues that since alfalfa is relatively low-value (money wise) compared to Las Vegas casinos, Phoenix microchip factories, or housing, the water should be going to casinos, factories, and housing, not farms, which would presumably happen if farmers had to pay more for water (i.e. theyโd go broke and be forced to sell).
First off, there is nothing novel or groundbreaking about this idea. Sprawl has been gobbling up farmland, and water rights, for decades in the West. Phoenix didnโt just grow into the desert, it also grew into citrus orchards and alfalfa fields, and will probably continue to build housing and data centers on what ag land remains. A different version of this concept, where a city or developer purchases a farmerโs water rights, but uses them somewhere else โ a practice known as buy and dry โ is also not uncommon.
This does not solve the water crisis. Instead of cutting consumption, which is whatโs needed, it merely shifts the consumption from one use โ agriculture โ to other ones, such as housing and golf courses and chip manufacturing and data centers. This may wring more cash out of each acre-foot of water, but it doesnโt lower consumption. An acre-foot is an acre-foot, whether itโs going to alfalfa, a golf course, a neighborhoodโs lawns, a data center or a swimming pool.
Besides, transitioning land out of agriculture comes with its own problems. We can argue forever about whether farming alfalfa or any other crop in the desert is appropriate, or of adequately high value, or whatever. We can argue that the Bureau of Reclamation should never have existed, and that irrigating the arid West should have been left to private entities operating in a free market. But the fact is, there is farming in the desert, those projects did end up subsidizing the agriculture industry, and communities, economies, cultures, and even new landscapes have emerged from and formed around those farms.
Photo of Crowley County by Jennifer Goodland
Taking vast swaths of land out of farming, whether to build houses or solar panels or to buy the water rights and use them somewhere else, has myriad consequences, many of them negative. Fields can become noxious-weed-clogged dust pits, the wildlife and ecosystems that have come to rely on irrigation runoff dry up, farm workers and families and the businesses that rely on them are displaced, communitiesโ economies are upended. As Madeline Wilson, an agricultural systems specialist for Colorado State Universityโs extension office pointed out at a 2024 panel on dust-on-snow, every field fallowed in the San Luis Valley for conservation purposes also represents a family. โWeโre not just talking about drying up lands,โ she said, โbut the drying up of our economy.โ
In no way does this mean that farms should be immune from curtailment. Indeed, because agriculture is the biggest user of Colorado River water, it will have to take the largest cuts in consumption. There is simply nowhere else from which the 4 million acre-feet or more of reductions per year needed to bring demand into line with dwindling supplies can come. But forcing farmers into bankruptcy by jacking up water rates (if there was a mechanism to do so), or prescribing โincredibly simpleโ policy solutions that donโt consider the complexities of the situation and its myriad moving parts or the on-the-ground impacts, isnโt the way to do it.
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
The โroot causeโ of the Colorado River crises is not alfalfa or pecans or cotton or cattle, itโs not the prior appropriation doctrine or the low price of water, itโs not overpopulation, itโs not data centers or golf courses or lawns or bad forest management or lack of or too many reservoirs. The root cause is twofold. First, thereโs scarcity. The Southwest is an arid place, and climate change-exacerbated warming is drying it out more: there is less precipitation; the precipitation we do get is falling as rain, not snow; the snow we get is melting faster; and evapotranspiration is happening at a higher rate. This all leads to less water in the streams, reservoirs, rivers, and even aquifers. Secondly, thereโs the chronic and long-term failure to acknowledge the scarcity, and the stubborn refusal to adapt to it and adjust consumption accordingly.
Consumptive use of Colorado River water for the Lower Basinโs largest users over time. Source: Bureau of Reclamation.
There has been progress. Over the last two decades some of the biggest water users on the river have slashed their water use considerably, sometimes because they had no choice, in some cases because they were incentivized to do so, and in other cases they did it to get ahead of future cuts. Last year, for example, the Imperial Irrigation District used 900,000 acre-feet less than it did in 1999. By its count, it has conserved over 9 million acre-feet since 2003 by fallowing fields and deploying various efficiency measures. And yet theyโve done so while continuing to grow nearly $240 million worth of alfalfa annually. It will need to do more; everyone will. But itโs a pretty big start.
Thereย isย one simple solution to the Colorado River crises: Everyone on the river has to use less water. Period. This wonโt come from pithy policy prescriptions or one-dimensional solutions. It will require the tribal nations, the states, and all of the water users in the basin to come together and find a new way to approach and think about and revere the lifeline of the Southwest.
Coming in September: The Land Desk News Feed! This will be a once-a-week roundup of the Westโs most important headlines, journalism, and commentary, curated and summarized by yours truly. Iโm thinking it will probably drop on Wednesdays, but havenโt settled on anything, yet. Most weeks it will come in addition to the regular two Land Desk dispatches, but some weeks it may take one of the othersโ place (meaning youโd only get two newsletters that week so as to not clog up your inbox all the time!).
All paid and free subscribers should expect the first edition on Sept. 9.
๐ธ Parting Shot ๐๏ธ
Church and Cerro Pedernal, Youngsville, NM. Jonathan P. Thompson photo
Click the link to read the article on the InkStain website (Karl Flessa):
August 20, 2026
In the classic Monty Python sketch, a customer returns to the pet shop where, just 30 minutes ago, he purchased a parrot. He complains that the parrot is dead. The shopkeeper tries to convince the customer the parrot is only resting or is stunned.
In the ensuing argument, the customer uses no fewer than eighteen euphemisms: โThis parrot is definitely deceasedโฆdemisedโฆpassed onโฆno moreโฆceased to beโฆexpiredโฆgone to meet his makerโฆa stiffโฆbereft of lifeโฆrests in peaceโฆpushing up the daisiesโฆmetabolic processes are now historyโฆoff the twigโฆkicked the bucketโฆshuffled off his mortal coilโฆrun down the curtainโฆjoined the bleedinโ choir invisible.โ
Indeed, the parrot was nailed to its perch, already dead when the customer bought it.
The Compact and its subsequent agreements are as dead as that parrot.
The Compact is dead because it is founded on a false premise: a river that can produce the prescribed amount of water.
The Compact is dead because it is unjust: neither the Tribes nor nature participate in negotiations.
The Compact is dead because it doesnโt work.ย The Basin States are locked in battle; the Federal government tinkers and dithers.
In the longer version of the sketch, the shopkeeper goes to the back in search of a live replacement, returning to report โโฆweโre right out of parrots.โ
So are we.
We need a new Compact.
Proposals are not lacking: proportional allocations, Tribal standing, a whole-basin approach, adjustments based on actual flows, a basin authority, natureโs fair share, interstate tradingโฆ .
Whatโs lacking is the courage to change. [ed. emphasis mine]
The Compact is a dead parrot.
Delph Carpenter’s original map showing a reservoir at Glen Canyon and one at Black Canyon via Greg Hobbs
At its Aug. 17 meeting, the San Juan Water Conservancy District (SJWCD) Board of Directors moved forward with contracting engineering firm RJH Consultants to perform a water demand study for the districtโs reservoir project. SJWCD board president Randy Cooper opened discussion of the study by summarizing the history of the study, which the board delayed approving at its last meeting since board treasurer Joe Tedder was not at the meeting and had not had an opportunity to review the contract. He explained that the $147,400 cost of the study would be split between 2026 and 2027, which RJH had agreed to. In response to a question from Tedder, Cooper stated that RJH would be ready to start work on the study immediately upon board approval…The board agreed that RJH should provide monthly updates on the project to ensure that the project adapts to any changing circumstances or barriers the district encounters, which Jones raised concerns about.
I drove to the bluff overlooking the โGunnyโ to process the sad news โ news that hasnโt yet been made official โ that by October a big portion of the lower Gunnison River in western Colorado will be dry. The official term is โfully dewatered.โ
Monsoons were supposed to be heavy this year. As I looked down at the river in late August, clouds in the distance appeared almost monsoonal. Wisps of rain streamed out, but they evaporated before reaching the parched ground. It just about made me cry.
Below me, the North Fork of the Gunnison unceremoniously trickled into the Gunnison River at a place known as Pleasure Park, a weather-beaten outpost of civilization thatโs one of the last best-kept secrets in Colorado.
The Gunnison River starts high in the Elk Mountains and flows into Coloradoโs largest body of water, Blue Mesa reservoir, though currently it is only the second largest because of drought. Then it flows free through Black Canyon National Park, but only after most of its water gets diverted to irrigate farmland surrounding the towns of Delta and Montrose. The park is a gem, albeit one of the least visited in the nation. From above thereโs not much to do except walk to outlooks to stare at sheer, colorful rock walls on the other side and the thin ribbon of river 2,000 feet below.
The โGunnyโ then flows through the remote yet accessible Gunnison Gorge Wilderness. In this thin crack of the earth, Iโve spent the past 12 summers working as a wilderness fly-fishing river guide.
Accessible is a relative term. The hearty few that run this remote wild river get to the water by hiking a rough 1.2-mile-long mule trail that drops steeply for almost 600 vertical feet. Even getting to the trailhead takes an hour and a half from the nearest town, and itโs on a four-wheel-drive road thatโs been the death knell of many a low-clearance vehicle. Rocky on a good day, it can become impassable when wet.
For those with the dough, a mule packer can be hired to transport boat and gear to the river. Those with the youth, knees, and determination can backpack down rafts, frames, oars, fishing and camping gear. Even elite guests, including former presidents who book fly-fishing trips with commercial guide services, carry their personal gear down to the river.
World-class fishing is why anybody makes the effort, 14 miles of wilderness Gold Medal water, the action peaking in June when large hungry trout key in on an epic salmon-fly hatch.
This stretch of river may be navigable, but it features 18 named technical rapids, and any one of them can humble experienced river runners. Rapids called โImprovise,โ โBoulder Garden,โ and โSqueezeโ can feel more like rock than water, and almost every rapid has ruined a trip at some point. The river is littered with rocks that also earned names because they have strong personalities: โQueen of Hearts,โ โThe Table and Tombstone,โ and โDicky Do.โ Others carry the monikers of unlucky guides.
All these barriers have kept crowds at bay though now thereโs a new constraint โ 90-to-100-degree temperatures for days on end. The Gorge can remain runnable in 14-foot rafts down to about 300 cubic feet per second, but even then itโs tight. Today itโs running well below that, and the water is too warm for the fish. Most commercial trips have been canceled.
Jacob Richards. Photo credit: Writers on the Range
Looking upriver into the Gorge, I donโt see any boats fishing their way out of the wilderness, and it doesnโt take much to imagine the riverbed โ a sad meander of dry cobbles bleached white, punctuated by stagnant pools full of belly-up trout.
This place, with its rugged remoteness, wild rapids and world-class trout fishing, has carved its way into my soul. I mourn for future generations who will probably know a much different river.
I feel bad for the salty guides out both trips and tips. I mourn too for the bugs that fattened the fish that paid my bills, for the mergansers, ring-tail cats and desert bighorn sheep. All need a river thatโs wet.
Jacob Richards is a contributor to Writers on the Range, an independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about the West. He is a writer about Western environmental issues and sometime outdoor guide. He lives in Fruita in western Colorado.
Nixon Rock, in the Gunnison Gorge. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism
Denver Waterโs collection and service areas continue to face severe drought conditions, with historically high temperatures, low streamflows and reservoir storage far below normal. As a result, at its meeting today, the Denver Board of Water Commissioners amended its Stage 1 drought resolution to prohibit lawn watering as of Oct. 1.
Until that time, Denver Water customers are still required to followย mandatory watering restrictionsย of two assigned days per week through Sept. 30, per the current Stage 1 drought restrictions that remain in place.
A group of visitors walks down the boat ramp at Williams Fork Reservoir on July 20. The ramp was closed this summer due to low water levels caused by drought. Photo credit: Denver Water.
โThe drought afflicting the Denver region and its water supply system has only worsened over the course of the summer, making it clear that we need to take additional steps in response,โ said Tyrone Gant, president of the Denver Board of Water Commissioners. โFormally ending lawn watering Oct. 1 will help stretch our supplies, as we will be entering next spring with storage levels far below normal.โ
While the boardโs Stage 1 drought declaration set a target for system-wide reduction of 20% below the five-year average in water consumption, prolonged hot and dry conditions have led to many customers using more water during their permitted irrigation days to keep trees, shrubs and landscapes alive, making the conservation target difficult to achieve. With drought conditions ongoing, Denver Water staff project storage supplies could drop to 60% before the 2027 runoff season.
โDespite the blistering conditions, customers overall have reduced their water use this summer. But with a lack of precipitation and the hottest first seven months in the Denver region weโve recorded, we must take this additional step,โ said Denver Water CEO/Manager Alan Salazar. โItโs critical that our customers turn sprinklers off Oct. 1, so that we can extend our water supply.โ
Lawn watering and all spray irrigation must stop after Sept. 30, 2026, as part of an amendment to the Stage 1 drought declaration originally approved March 25. Trees, plants and gardens may be watered any day by hand if needed. Photo credit: Denver Water.
The resolution includes additional details outlining the kind of watering still permitted after the shutdown date.
High-traffic, active-use grass areas, such as parks and school fields, may only be watered after Sept. 30, under a Denver Water-approved water budget or variance. Additionally, recycled water users can continue to irrigate any day of the week, following the standard watering rules, as they are relying on reused water supply.
Trees, shrubs and perennials may be watered any day with a hand-held hose with a shutoff nozzle or low-volume, non-spray irrigation (such as a drip system). They may not be watered by spray irrigation.
Annuals and vegetables may be watered any day with a hand-held hose with a shutoff nozzle or low-volume, non-spray irrigation, until the first frost. They may not be watered by spray irrigation.
Grass establishment is not allowed after Sept. 30, except under special circumstances outlined under an approved variance.
An irrigation system may be operated for installation, repair or reasonable maintenance, so long as the system is attended throughout the period of operation and water waste does not occur.ย
Placing a soaker hose around the tree along the drip line is an effective way to water trees without wasting water. Reminder: Don’t water established trees too close to the trunk. Photo credit: Denver Water.
Conditions in Denver Waterโs service and collection areas continue to worsen. The amended resolution outlines specific factors driving the additional board action.
Denver Waterโs water collection system watersheds remain in various levels of drought as defined by the U.S. Drought Monitor.
Natural streamflow in the areas that flow into Denver Waterโs storage reservoirs for the period of April to July was 95,000 acre-feet, which is 22% of normal and marks the lowest level observed since recordkeeping began 110 years ago.
The Denver metro area is experiencing the hottest year on record (through July) with average daily high temperatures five degrees above normal and four inches below normal precipitation.
As of Aug. 24, 2026, storage in Denver Waterโs supply reservoirs is at 72% full, which is significantly lower than the historic median of 94% full for this time of year.
โIf you are the only one on your block with a lush green lawn, you might want to revisit your watering practices, as your overuse is compounding the impacts of this historic drought on our water storage supplies,โ said Greg Fisher, Denver Waterโs manager of demand planning.
โWeโre asking everyone to care more and water less, so we donโt have to take more drastic steps in the future, which could create more damaging impacts to our landscapes.โ
With reservoir levels continuing to drop, Denver Water is asking customers to Use Only What You Need. Every drop saved, both indoors and outdoors, makes a difference. Photo credit: Denver Water.
Watering season typically runs from May 1 to Oct.1, during which Denver Waterโs annual watering rules are in place. In a non-drought year, the start and end dates are general guidance for customers to turn on and off their irrigation systems. With this amendment to its March 25 drought resolution, the board has made the Oct. 1 date mandatory this year, prohibiting lawn watering as of that date.
In addition, the lawn watering ban remains in effect until the board determines how and when lawn watering can resume. That means sprinklers need to remain off in spring of 2027, pending an official resolution from the Board of Water Commissioners. [ed. emphasis mine]
The Colorado River flows through Palisade CO, Friday, June 9, 2023. (William Woody)
Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Newsline website (by Chase Woodruff):
August 26, 2026
Elected officials from across Coloradoโs political spectrum continued a 68-year-old tradition last week when they took to the stage at the annual summer conference of the Colorado Water Congress in Steamboat Springs.
Connecting the news in Colorado to the big picture. First convened by Gov. Steve McNichols in 1958, the Water Congress brings together experts, policymakers, agricultural producers and other interest groups to negotiate and strategize in a state where water has always been a scarce and carefully managed resource.
Thatโs never been more true than it is today, at a time of extreme drought and escalating political conflict over the future of the Colorado River. The riverโs cumulative flow at Cameo, just upstream of Palisade and Grand Junction, is at a record low this year, and Colorado and six other states that depend on its water are likely headed for an extended, high-stakes court battle over how to apportion the cuts forced on them by more than two decades of persistently dry conditions.
Addressing the Water Congress, Colorado leaders said the way forward for water users is through, as Attorney General Phil Weiser, the Democratic nominee for governor, put it, โcollaboration and innovation.โ They talked about storage and diversion projects, conservation measures and drought-resistant crops. They promised to defend farmers and ranchers from so-called โbuy and dryโ purchases of their water rights by municipal utilities, and to fight off efforts by the Lower Basin states of Arizona, California and Nevada to force mandatory cuts on upstream users in Colorado.
Notably absent, however, from the eventโs three days of speeches on water policy โ from politicians on both sides of the aisle โ was the predominant reason why the situation on the Colorado River is bad and getting worse: human-caused climate change. Neither Weiser nor Victor Marx, the Republican candidate for governor, made any mention of the threat posed to Western water supplies by rising global temperatures. It was missing, too, from speeches by both GOP U.S. Rep. Lauren Boebert, a longtime fossil-fuel industry booster, and Democratic U.S. Rep. Joe Neguse, a former member of the House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis. [ed. emphasis mine]
Dwayne Romero, the Democratic nominee in Coloradoโs drought-ravaged 3rd Congressional District, went so far as to say that โthe climate is putting new pressure onโ water management issues, but no further.
The lack of acknowledgment of the causes of the Colorado River Basinโs post-2000 megadrought comes as Colorado Republicans largely continue to ignore or deny the science of climate change โ and as Democrats have been pressured by some party consultants to deemphasize the issue in the wake of their defeat in the 2024 election.
Clockwise from top left: U.S. Rep. Lauren Boebert, a Windsor Republican; Democratic congressional nominee Dwayne Romero; U.S. Rep. Joe Neguse, a Lafayette Democrat; and GOP governor nominee Victor Marx spoke at the summer conference of the Colorado Water Congress in Steamboat Springs from Aug. 18 to 19, 2026. (Photos by Chase Woodruff/Colorado Newsline)
But even as this โclimate hushing,โ as Rhode Island Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse dubbed it earlier this year, appears to have taken hold in the Democratic Party, hydrologists and climatologists have grown increasingly confident in identifying human emissions, rather than natural variability, as the overwhelming factor driving the Westโs water woes.
Whether or not itโs politically expedient for either party to say so, the scientific consensus is that rising levels of greenhouse gases in the Earthโs atmosphere โ mostly the result of burning oil, gas and coal โ have pushed the Colorado River system to the brink, and that drought conditions are likely to continue to worsen as long as those emissions continue to push global temperatures higher.
โHot droughtโ and beyond
As of 2024, average global temperatures had risen by more than 2.3 degrees Fahrenheit over pre-industrial levels, according to NOAAย data, and climate scientists haveย concludedย that virtually all of that observed warming is due to greenhouse gas emissions from human activity. Parts of Colorado, including much of the Western Slope, are among the areas in the U.S. where average temperature increases have beenย most severe.
Even in the absence of any other changes to global climate patterns, this higher heat alone can lead to drier conditions on the ground, by increasing the rate at which moisture evaporates โ sometimes calledย evaporative demand, a measure of the atmosphereโs โthirst.โ In a 2024ย reportย for the Colorado Water Conservation Board, state climatologists found that evaporative demand had risen by 5% statewide between 1980 and 2022, and was projected to increase by 8% to 17% by 2050.
Within about a decade of the onset of the Colorado River megadrought in the 2000s, researchers began to conclude that rising temperatures were a major factor, making the drought more severe than it otherwise wouldโve been. In an influential paper published in 2017, hydrologists Brad Udall and Jonathan Overpeck used the term โhot droughtโ to describe the basinโs current conditions, distinguishing it it from previous 20th-century โdry droughts,โ caused largely by lower precipitation.
Further research has only solidified those conclusions. Using historical soil-moisture data and tree-ring records, one 2022 study found that the current megadrought is the worst dry spell the Southwest has experienced in at least 1,200 years. Studies generally agree that about 40% to 50% of the Colorado Riverโs declining flows can be attributed to higher temperatures alone.
Colorado statewide annual temperature anomaly (ยฐF) with respect to the 1901-2000 average. Graphic credit: Colorado Climate Center
Still, scientists were cautious about the other half of the hydrological equation โ whether, and to what extent, climate change was influencing rainfall and snowfall, too. Modeling global warmingโs precise impacts on precipitation patterns proved more complicated than identifying what state climatologists called the โbasic physical relationshipโ between heat and evaporation.
โCompared to the 20th century, the 21st century has indeed been drier, but only by about 2.5%,โ hydrologists with the Colorado River Research Group wrote in 2016. โWhether or not this is the leading edge of a trend, or merely a part of normal variability, is unknown.โ
In just the last two years, however, new research has begun to dispel that uncertainty โ and the findings, wrote Udall and Overpeck last year, โtranslate to mostly bad news.โ
Itโs precipitation, too
Overall precipitation in the Upper Colorado River Basin has continued to decline since 2000, with multi-year averages about 7% lower than previous levels as of 2025. Colorado was one of nine states in the West to have experienced their warmest winter on record in 2025-26, and statewide snowpack fell to its lowest level in more than 40 years, setting the stage for this summerโs extreme conditions.
Researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder found last year that global warming is reducing precipitation in the West by stalling a key oceanic climate cycle known as the Pacific decadal oscillation, indicating that the regionโs persistently dry conditions are being driven by human emissions โmore intensely โ and more directly โ than previously understood.โ Another 2025 paper by a different group of researchers echoed their findings.
โWhatโs important here is that weโre showing that rainfall has also been influenced by humans, in addition to just evaporation,โ Pedro DiNezio, one of the CU Boulder studyโs co-authors, told Newsline last year. โBoth contribute to drought.โ
A final key takeaway from climatological research on the Colorado River is that the higher global temperatures get, the worse things will be for river flows, which are not likely to ever return to their previous โnormal.โ Udall and others have encouraged the use of the term โaridification,โ rather than drought or megadrought, to more accurately describe whatโs happening to the river basin. But itโs also why he and Overpeck wrote last year that thereโs a โsilver liningโ to the better understanding of riverโs hydrology that researchers have gained over the last decade.
โWe can say with confidence that human-caused emissions of greenhouse gases are having an increasingly negative impact on the flows of the Colorado River,โ they wrote. โThis climate change impact will continue to worsen, but because humans cause it, humans can halt it.โ
The Trendline offers analysis on public policy in Colorado. Articles explore ways to think about the news based on research, history and other important context, helping Coloradans connect the headlines to the big picture.
Colorado Newsline is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Colorado Newsline maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Quentin Young for questions: info@coloradonewsline.com.
Created by Imgur user Fejetlenfej , a geographer and GIS analyst with a โlifelong passion for beautiful maps.โ It highlights the massive expanse of river basins across the country โ in particular, those which feed the Mississippi River, in pink.
Why don’t we just build a pipeline from the Mississippi River, Great Lakes, or another major water source and pump that water to Lake Mead? Simple, right?
It’s one of the most common suggestions we hear to solve drought in the West. In this episode of Tap the Truth, we explore what it would actually take to move water across the country and why these projects are more complicated than they might seem.
Importing water is not as simple as laying pipe across a map. Interstate agreements, water rights, environmental impacts, water quality concerns, permitting challenges, and costs all need to be considered.
We also discuss why communities throughout the country are facing their own water challenges and why conservation remains one of the most reliable and cost effective tools available today.
Want to make a personal impact on Southern Nevada’s water future? Visit SNWA.com to learn about water saving programs, rebates, and conservation tips.
Watch more Tap the Truth episodes for straightforward answers to common questions about water, Lake Mead, the Colorado River, and Southern Nevada’s water supply.
The Yampa River at Deerlodge Park July 24, 2021 downstream from the confluence with the Little Snake River. There was a ditch running in Maybell above this location. Irrigated hay looked good. Dryland hay not so much.
A rare call has been placed on the main stem of the Yampa River as historic drought conditions continue to strain water supplies across Northwest Colorado, potentially curtailing more than 300 upstream diversions and prompting water managers to urge residents to conserve wherever possible. The call was placed Aug. 19 at the Lily Park Ditch No. 1, Pump Station No. 1, near the confluence of the Little Snake and Yampa rivers.ย The agricultural water right carries a priority date of May 28, 1923…Holly Kirkpatrick, public affairs manager for the Upper Yampa Water Conservancy District, said the call is only the fifth to occur on the main stem of the Yampa River below Stagecoach Reservoir…Kirkpatrick said well over 300 diversions upstream of the calling point could be subject to curtailment if they have priority dates junior to May 28, 1923. The call also applies to tributaries upstream of the Little Snake and Yampa river confluence. Some of those tributaries, however, may already have little or no natural streamflow available because of the severity of this yearโs drought, she said. The Upper Yampa Water Conservancy District reported Aug. 20 that baseflows in tributaries across the basin remained below the 10th percentile, an indication of unusually low water levels. The districtโs report showed the Yampa River below Craig flowing at 94 cubic feet per second, compared with a historical mean of 156 cfs for the date. In Steamboat Springs, the river was flowing at 58 cfs compared with a historical mean of 96 cfs. Reservoir releases are now supplying much of the water moving through the Yampa River, Kirkpatrick said.
Central Arizona Project map via Mountain Town News
Click the link to read the article on the KTAR website (Heidi Hommel). Here’s an excerpt:
August 26, 2026
The Upper Basin is on the verge of violating the Colorado River Compact for the first time in the agreementโs 104-year history, failing to send enough water downstream to the Lower Basin, Central Arizona Project President Terry Goddard toldย KTAR News 92.3 FMย on Monday…Goddard said the new framework from the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation that will guide operations through 2036 could make it worse…
โWe have a violation of the compact either today or within the next month,โ Goddard said.
The compact requires the Upper Basin to deliver 75 million acre-feet to the Lower Basin over any rolling 10-year period, averaging 7.5 million acre-feet a year. Goddard said the Upper Basin is falling short of that obligation for the first time in the compactโs history, releasing only 6 million acre-feet this year and running right at the 10-year threshold. [ed. As Ed Millard says, the action is not from the Upper Basin but from Reclamation]
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
A moisture index satellite image of Las Vegas, Nevada. Southern Nevada stands to lose as much as 71% of its Colorado River allotment under the Department of Interiorโs operating guidelines for the river and its two largest reservoirs. Source: Copernicus Browser.
THE NEWS:The U.S. Interior Department on Friday handed down the operating guidelines for the Colorado River for the next two years, while also finalizing the 10-year decision framework that will guide these plans. And on Monday, Nevada filed a lawsuit challenging both the framework and operating plan, saying that potential shortages required by the plan could cause โcause devastating environmental, socioeconomic, and health and human safety impacts to southern Nevada and its citizens.โ
THE CONTEXT: Interior, i.e. the Bureau of Reclamation, did two things. The first was to hand down a record of decision on the framework that will guide operating plans for the next decade, which I wrote about here, so Iโll skip the details this time.
They also released a more specific plan for the 2027 and 2028 operating years. In the new plan, the feds affirm their commitment to โdefendingโ minimum power pool in Lake Powell, or a reservoir surface elevation of 3,490 feet. When the water falls below this level, water can no longer be released via the penstocks and hydropower turbines, so it must all go through the lower river outlet works, which werenโt designed for sustained use.
Notably, Reclamation plans to do this by โinitially seeking to maintain a minimum elevation of 3,510 feet. This provides an operational buffer and provides additional flexibility in recognition of the operational risks associated with sustained operations below elevation 3,490 feet โฆ .โ
The current elevation is 3,518 feet, meaning it could reach that upper buffer zone of 3,510 feet in October if current levels of decline continue.
To prevent it from falling any further, Reclamation would cut back releases from Glen Canyon Dam, which in turn would cut flows through the Grand Canyon and into Lake Mead, which would pull down Meadโs levels and trigger mandatory cuts for the Lower Basin users. Under the new operating plan so far, these cuts arenโt as onerous as many feared, and actually match up with what the Lower Basin had proposed to do voluntarily. The deets:
The Lower Basin would receive 6.25 million acre-feet from the Colorado River, or 1.25 MAF below the Colorado River Compactโs allotment of 7.5 MAF.
Arizona would receive 2.04 MAF; California 3.96 MAF; and Nevada 250,000 AF.
This means Arizona would take a 760,000 AF cut; Nevada a 50,000 AF cut; and California a 440,000 AF cut.
Arizona takes the largest cut by percentage and volume because the Central Arizona Project, which delivers most of the stateโs Colorado River water, has junior water rights to other big users on the river.
But if reservoir levels continue to drop, then Reclamation could impose further cuts on the Lower Basin, potentially slashing Nevadaโs water deliveries by as much as 213,556 acre-feet, or about 71% of its total entitlement of 300,000 acre-feet. This would be truly disastrous for the Las Vegas metro area, which relies on the Colorado River for about 90% of its water. And itโs not like there are a bunch of alfalfa fields the city could โbuy and dryโ for the water rights.
The Southern Nevada Water Authority has managed to cut overall water consumptionover the last three decades, even as the population has soared, through system-wide efficiencies, incentives, tearing up ornamental grass, water recycling, and extra fees for water gluttons. Las Vegas still has room to conserve, but as Western water scholar John Fleck put it, there โis an absurdity to a plan that would require Las Vegas to cut 71%. Thatโs existential.โ
Even more astonishing than the fact that the federal government is considering virtually drying up one of the Southwestโs major metropolises is their justification for doing so: To protect Glen Canyon Dam and keep it producing hydropower, even at greatly diminished levels, and โ though itโs not stated โ to keep lake-based recreation somewhat viable.
You have to remember that when the feds vow to defend the 3,500-foot level at Lake Powell, and when they refuse to even consider re-engineering Glen Canyon Dam to allow for releases at lower levels, either by rebuilding the outlet tubes or tunneling a bypass around the dam, they are also saying they are going to trap more than 4 million acre-feet of water behind the dam that could otherwise flow downstream into the Grand Canyon and Lake Mead. Thatโs enough water to fill Nevadaโs entire allotment for more than 13 years that, instead, will be sitting in the reservoir and slowly evaporating.
Nevadaโs lawsuit โ which is against the federal government, not the Upper Basin states โ alleges that the fedsโ plan violates the Law of the River. It slams the plan for not explicitly calling for releasing more water from Upper Basin reservoirs to prop up Powell, does not require Upper Basin states to make any cuts, and fails to consider a long-term alternative or engineered solution alternative to address Glen Canyonโs infrastructure limitations. The plan also does not account for its potential impacts on hydropower production at Hoover Dam, which drops off steeply as reservoir levels decline (meaning that preserving power output at Glen Canyon could lead to a net reduction in combined output from the two dams).
Save the Colorado, a river advocacy group, came out in support of Nevadaโs lawsuit in a written statement. “Las Vegas has one of the best water conservation programs in the entire U.S.,โ said Gary Wockner, the groupโs executive director. โPenalizing Las Vegas for water use is like penalizing an obese person who lost a lot of weight taking GLP1s.โ
Rough Times at the national parks these days. In Bryce Canyon, a sudden thunderstorm left visitors stranded on trails and requiring rescue, with two of them transported to a hospital for hypothermia. It also unleashed some serious flash flooding. In Zion National Park, a rockslide narrowly missed a shuttle bus and forced the closure of a portion of the Zion Canyon Scenic Drive. And in Canyonlands, officials were searching for a missing individual in Horseshoe Canyon, a remote area north of the parkโs Maze district. Temperatures in the area were in the 90s. In Death Valley, a French tourist died after his car got stuck in the mud on a remote road in 116ยฐ F heat.
The video below shows flooding near Tropic, Utah, downstream from Bryce Canyon National Park. Source: Garfield County Sheriff.
In May, I wrote about how climate change and aridification and a shrinking Lake Powell were coming for the Bullfrog Marina, on the northwest side of the reservoir. The water was simply getting too low for the marina to remain viable, so they were planning on moving it across the reservoir to Halls Crossing Marina.
At the time, it was not yet clear how lower water levels and the marinaโs removal might affect visitation to the remote area. Now preliminary numbers are in:
67,277:ย Total recreation visitors to the Bullfrog District of Glen Canyon National Recreation Area, January through July 2025
44,206: Total recreation visitors to the Bullfrog District, January through July 2026.
Thatโs a decrease of over 23,000 visits, or a 34% drop. Even more dramatic is the drop in overnight stays in July, from over 47,000 in 2025 to just 17,000 in 2026. Then did folks make the long drive over to Halls Crossing, instead? It appears that some of them may have once the marina was moved, but overall this year visitation is also down on the northeast side of the reservoir.
18,023:ย Total recreation visitors to the Halls Crossing District of Glen Canyon National Recreation Area, January through July 2025.ย
15,099: Total recreation visitors to the Halls Crossing District, January through July 2026.
Thatโs a decrease of 2,944 visits, or a 19% drop. This may not all be related directly to the dropping lake levels. Horseshoe Bend, which is in Glen Canyon National Recreation Area but downstream from the reservoir, has also seen a significant drop off in visitors this spring and summer. In a future dispatch Iโll take a closer look at tourism numbers in general to get a better sense of how widespread the declines are.
And now for the images showing Bullfrog with the marina, and without. The first image is from August 2024, when the reservoirโs surface elevation was at about 3,580 feet. The marina was still there, and the boat ramps still made it all the way to the water. The second image is from August 2026, with a surface level of just over 3,518 feet. Look closely and youโll see the marina is gone, and the ramps are high and dry.
Bullfrog Bay and Marina, August 2024. Source: Copernicus.
Bullfrog Bay and no marina, August 2026. Source: Copernicus.
Colorado River “Beginnings”. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism
Click the link to read the article on the KUNC website (Stephanie Daniel):
August 24, 2026
This story was produced by the Mountain West News Bureau, a collaboration between Boise State Public Radio, Wyoming Public Media, Nevada Public Radio, KUNR in Nevada, KUNC in Northern Colorado, KANW in New Mexico, Colorado Public Radio and KJZZ in Arizona as well as NPR, with support from affiliate newsrooms across the region. Funding for the Mountain West News Bureau is provided in part by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting and Eric and Wendy Schmidt.
Three states are being required to cut their water use under a final plan for managing the Colorado River over the next two years, while the four upstream states are being asked to voluntarily conserve water.
The U.S. Department of the Interior released the Record of Decision for managing the river over the next decade and laying out more specific rules for the next two years. The plan is intended to protect Lake Powell and Lake Mead, which have fallen to historically low levels after years of drought.
Arizona, California and Nevada will have to collectively reduce their water use by 1.25 million acre-feet per year over the next two years, with additional restrictions possible if conditions worsen, according to the plan.
Colorado, Utah, New Mexico and Wyoming are not subject to mandatory reductions; instead, those states are setting up programs to voluntarily conserve water.
โUnder the proposed plan issued by the Department of the Interior, southern Nevada could lose more than 70 percent of its already meager Colorado River allocation while the Upper Basin states of Colorado, Utah, New Mexico, and Wyoming are not required to contribute a drop,โ Nevada Governor Joe Lombardo said in a news release on Monday.
Upper Basin officials say their water users already face reductions when drought leaves less water available and that the federal government doesnโt have authority to impose mandatory cuts in their states. But they say the Upper Basin is willing to contribute voluntarily.
โNot because we have to, or that we feel like we legally have to,โ Coloradoโs river negotiator Becky Mitchell said at a conference last week in Steamboat Springs, โbut because the importance of this system and the survival of this system is a responsibility for everyone.โ
The federal framework envisions up to 200,000 acre-feet of water per year in Upper Basin contributions when conditions allow. The federal government is dedicating $100 million to the Upper Basin to compensate farmers, cities or other water users to use less. Colorado, Wyoming and Utah are also setting up their own state programs to facilitate participation.
Colorado officials expect applications could open this fall and projects could start next year.
โOur position has been and continues to be that we’re going to be part of the solution,โ said Amy Ostdiek, section chief for the Colorado Water Conservation Board at the Steamboat conference. โWe’re going to do it in the ways that we can, at the times that we can, but we can’t provide water certainty for our neighbors downstream that we don’t have ourselves.โ
Criteria for selecting projects, how water users will be compensated and how the Upper Basin gains credit for conserved water are still being worked out.
The Green River flows beneath the Flaming Gorge Dam in Utah. The federal government is sending water from the reservoir to prop up Lake Powell, something it could do in future dry years under a plan to manage the Colorado River. Ted Wood/The Water Desk
The federal plan also creates a potential โconservation poolโ in Lake Powell, allowing the Upper Basin states to store a certain amount of conserved water.
John Berggren, a water policy analyst with the nonprofit Western Resource Advocates, has advocated for a conservation pool and said its inclusion in the federal framework is promising. However, exactly how it would work is not clear.
โHow that pool operates, how the water is used, when it’s moved, if it’s moved, who decides that โ all that is going to depend on future agreements,โ he said.
Some key questions, he said, have to do with what the conserved water is credited towards, such as whether itโs used to offset shortages in the Lower Basin or help the Upper Basin fulfill their legal obligations to deliver water downstream.
The new framework also allows the Upper Basin to come to an agreement with the Interior Department to draw down a few reservoirs when Lake Powell nears getting too low for hydropower. That started happening this year, with water released from Flaming Gorge Reservoir in Wyoming.
Adult Zebra mussel. Photo credit: Colorado Parks and Wildlife
Click the link to read the article on The Aspen Times website (Ali Longwell). Here’s an excerpt:
August 25, 2026
After 2025 saw aย flurry of zebra mussel detectionsย in the Colorado River system, Colorado Parks and Wildlifeโs weekly sampling this summer has led to zero new discoveries of the invasive species. This does not mean, however, that zebra mussels โย notorious for their prolific reproduction and destruction of ecosystems and infrastructureย โ are gone from the basin or that the battle to curb their spread is over.ย When zebra mussels establish a presence in a body of water, they multiply quickly. A single zebra mussel can produce up to 30,000 veligers โ their microscopic, free-floating larvae โ in one spawning event and up to one million in a year. As they root and attach to hard surfaces โ like docks, rocks and pipes โ and their density increases, they can cause significant damage and clogging to water infrastructure…
This summer, Parks and Wildlife has continued weekly sampling in the Colorado River from its headwaters near Granby to the Colorado-Utah state line, according to Robert Walters, Colorado Parks and Wildlifeโs invasive species program manager…Walters said the agency has taken over 500 plankton tow samplesย since May, not only in the Colorado River, but in its major tributaries including the Gunnison, Roaring Fork and Eagle rivers…Despite the lack of discoveries, the Colorado River, from its confluence with the Eagle River to the state border with Utah, remains one of six bodies of water that are consideredย infestedย with the highly invasive zebra mussels. A body of water is considered โinfestedโ when adult and veliger zebra mussels have been found in it. In Colorado, for a body to no longer be considered infested, it must have five consecutive years without detections of that species, according to Walters. The five-year clock resets at each detection.ย
A simple illustration of water income and water expenses in a humanโwater system. Water bankruptcy is the outcome of both insolvency and irreversibility conditions, i.e., when water use (expenditure) exceeds water supply (renewable and non-renewable assets) for an extended period resulting in irreparable damages to the underlying natural capital that contributes to water production and stability of the hydrological cycle.
Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):
โAmid chronic groundwater depletion, water overallocation, land and soil degradation, deforestation, and pollution, all compounded by global heating, a UN report today declared the dawn of an era of global water bankruptcy, inviting world leaders to facilitate honest, science-based adaptation to a new reality.โ
Our Colorado River made their list of exemplary global โhot spotsโ for bankruptcy, with the observation that โthe Colorado River and its reservoirs have become symbols of over-promised water.โ
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
Youโve seen the word โcrisisโ used frequently this year in the countless morbid articles about the Colorado River. But the UNU Institute director Kaveh Madani argued that we are now โpost-crisisโ: the term โcrisisโ implies a deviation from the normal, a disruption to be dealt with in order to get back to normal, but there is now, Madani says, no going back to what passed for โnormalโ in the last century. [ed. emphasis mine]
The study indicates that we have drained too many aquifers, resulting in subsidence that destroys the aquifers for the rest of the geological age; we have lost high-storage wetlands to gullying and lowered water tables; we have spread too much surface water out to dry under an atmosphere heating up incrementally with every additional gallon of fossil fuel we burn; desertification spreads in our wake; et cetera, et cetera. As a result:
The report makes the case for a fundamental shift in the global water agendaโfrom repeatedly reacting to emergencies to โbankruptcy management.โ That means confronting overshoot with transparent water accounting, enforceable limits, and protection of the water-related natural capital that produces and stores waterโaquifers, wetlands, soils, rivers, and glaciersโwhile ensuring transitions are explicitly equity-oriented and protect vulnerable communities and livelihoods.
There is in this research paper the kind of lovely naivete that one finds in most of the analyses of Big Issues today (climate change, systemic racism, corporate personhood versus people, etc.); there is an underlying conviction that when the facts are all laid out, we will rationally accept that, yes, we are indeed in a bankrupt situation. And so we will all sit down together, like rational beings would, and work out ways to resolve the โreality deficitโ between what has been promised and what can be delivered.
This ignores the fact that, when we are first confronted with evidence of something so big in its threat to our way of life, that its correction might require creating a whole new way of life, our first response is to say, โthis canโt be so.โ There has to be a mistake. And a long winding road leads on, into and through a morass of denial, anger, blames cast, responsibilities denied, hopeful negotiations and underlying despair โ the whole medieval pilgrimโs Slough of Despond that must be negotiated before we might actually sit down together and work out some way of resolving the โreality deficit.โ
There is, however, a kind of honesty in coming around to realizing โ and acknowledging โ that a system might be bankrupt. Bankruptcy is not necessarily the end song of what has become bankrupt, although it can be (Chapter 7 bankruptcy). It can instead be a time of operational or financial reorganization, aa time for acknowledging circumstances, conditions and misconceptions not originally taken into account that, accounted for, might enable a measure of eventual recovery and even success.
The seven Colorado River Basin states, still stuck in the zomboid Colorado River Compact, are not there yet, but the Bureau of Reclamation might be getting there. On the viable assumption that the seven states will not come up with a last-minute plan before the end of September and expiration of the Interim and Interim Interim Guidelines, they are preparing to institute a temporary plan that will maintain functionality in the river storage and delivery system, with (they hope) no embarrassing โdead poolโ episodes โ which basically means getting and keeping as much water as possible in the two big reservoirs, Mead and Powell, and that can only happen at considerable cost to users below the big reservoirs.
The Bureau plan will not be carved in stone for forever like the Colorado River Compact; the Bureau will basically be planning operations for two-year periods, through the coming decade; every two years, the parties of interest will reconvene to review and revise the operating plan as circumstances require. This โadaptiveโ approach makes sense in a bankruptcy situation in which the future is mostly unknown. [ed. emphasis mine]
The plan really has no surprises for anyone who remembers the 2022 bolt of reality that caused Bureau Commissioner Camille Touton to tell the water leaders in the seven states to immediately plan to voluntarily cut 2-4 million acre-feet (maf) of water use โ basically a quarter of river use at that time โ or the Interior Department would do it for them. That โ in the centennial year of the Compact โ is probably a good marker for the Bureauโs acknowledgement that we were beyond crisis, and slipping into bankruptcy.
The structural deficit refers to the consumption by Lower Basin states of more water than enters Lake Mead each year. The deficit, which includes losses from evaporation, is estimated at 1.2 million acre-feet a year. (Image: Central Arizona Project circa 2019)
That 2022 siren call was met by the Lower Basin states agreeing to finally take the Lower Basin system losses (evaporation, etc.) and their half of the Mexican obligation out of their river-use shares rather than out of Mead storage until the 2027 water year โ provided they would be paid to do so. The absence of โsurplus flowsโ to take care of those losses โ ~1.25 maf โ from the coming online of the Central Arizona Project was a principal source of the draining of the big reservoirs, the so-called โstructural deficit,โ 30 maf of storage gifted to the Lower Basin.
(A side note on this: The Upper Basin states, since a 1970 Law-of-the-River agreement, have been regularly sending downstream their 750,000 acre-feet for the Mexican obligation and absorbing as part of their whateverโs-left-over share of the river the ~400,000 acre-feet of Upper Basin system losses. The four states have never asked for or been paid for doing that.)
But that 1.25 maf of voluntary shortages was only a large fraction of the 2-4 maf of cuts the Bureau said needed to happen. So the Bureauโs original 2027-28 plan announcement in late July included cuts of up to 40 percent for the states below Mead Reservoir (Arizona, California and Nevada) โ roughly equivalent to the 2022 request for 2-4 maf in cuts. The three downriver states countered that with an offer to permanently do the same 1.25 maf cut (with payment) for 2027-28 they were doing for 2025-26, with intimations of lawsuits if the Bureau pushed too far beyond that.
Arizona has led the countercharge from the states below Mead Reservoir โ being the state with the most to lose, since the junior status of the Central Arizona Project means it would be practically shut down by 40 percent cuts in usage.
A letter to the Interior Department from Tom Buschatzky, Arizonaโs Director of Water Resources, castigated the Bureau plan for making no mention of the Colorado River Compact and the Law of the River (LOTR). The letter insisted that Article III(c) and (d) of the Compact be executed to the letter as stated in the LOTR 1970 agreement: that a minimum of 8.23 maf be released from Powell Reservoir every year โ the Compact commitment of 7.5 maf per year on average passing Lee Ferry, plus the Upper Basinโs share of the Mexican obligation (750,000 af/year).
In their August 21 announcement of the more detailed plan for 2027-28, the Bureau backed down from the 40 percent number, and now wants a 20 percent reduction in use for the two years โ more in line with the Lower Basinโs willingness to continue taking care of its own system losses and Mexican share, but requiring some additional cuts โ and avoided discussion of the Compact issue raised. It will, however, probably be pushing for more cuts in the 2028 discussions for the 2029-30 plan renewal; the Bureau still feels that it needs at least 3 maf in permanent cuts to begin any hope of turning the current near-bankruptcy around, and bringing demand in line with at least current supply.
The Bureau would also like the seven states to be reviewing, revising and executing the two-year plans consensually by 2036, rather than imposing it on them. But Arizona, according to the Buschatzky letter, wants a โlonger, more comprehensiveโ plan from the states, consistent with the LOTR, and โdoes not accept a framework that gives the federal government the discretion to select from a wide range of alternativesโincluding catastrophic cuts to the Lower Basinโevery two years for the next decade.โ
โBankruptcy managementโ would seem to argue that the Colorado River Compact should be on the table along with everything else โ including the nonexistence of the 18 maf river for which the Compact was written. Aย detailed analysis of the current situationย by the โRiver Eldersโ โ the Kuhn-Schmidt-Castle group โ suggested that โBasin water users must focus on solutions to the fundamental, wet-water math problem, rather than legal arguments over paper water.โ [ed. emphasis mine]
Nonetheless, Buschatzkeโs letter states that โArizona reserves the right to seek the resolution of its Compact rights in an appropriate judicial forum.โ The states are not yet willing to acknowledge the bankruptcy of the Compact โ a Humpty-Dumpty that not all the patches and bandaids of the Law of the River can put back together for an ever-shrinking 21st century Colorado River.
That, more or less, is where the river systemโs future sits as of August 21. There will โ thanks to the Bureau โ be a plan for moving carefully into the future, a two-year step at time. A big question is how hard the Bureau will begin to push for the 3-4 maf in permanent cuts by users necessary to stop the march into real dead-pool bankruptcy of the system โ leading to another big question: whether the Compact nostalgitarians will push the system into dead-pool bankruptcy by suing the Bureau/Interior Department over paper water, tying things up in court for another several years.
Ah, the lovely Slough of Despond. There with Henry: โAll day the sun has shone on the surface of some savage swamp, where the single spruce stands hung with usnea lichens, and small hawks circulate above, and the chickadee lisps among the evergreens, and the partridge and rabbit skulk beneath; but now a more dismal and fitting day dawns, and a different race of creatures awakes to express the meaning of Nature thereโฆ.โ Bankruptcy, the Apocalypse โ only the end for those who fail to see that something else is always struggling for a chance to be born; donโt put a period where God (or Nature) would put a comma (Gracie Allen). As Henry also observed, โThe light which puts out our eyes is darkness to us. Only that day dawns to which we are awakeโฆ.โ
Next post, I want to go back to the โdesert riverโ concept to think a little outside the (Compact) box.
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Click the link to read the release on the ADWR website:
August 21, 2026
After more than three years of difficult negotiations over post-2026 Colorado River Operations guidelines, Arizona and the Lower Basin states have created a level of stability for the Colorado River system with the adoption of the 2027-2028 operating guidelines in the Record of Decision. While the framework for years 3-10 continues to be of concern, we applaud the Department of the Interior for clarifying the decision-making process for operations beyond 2028. That outcome allows for continued negotiations for years 3-10 while preserving our ability to protect Arizonaโs legal rights to Colorado River water.
We will continue to work with our partners in Arizona, the Lower Basin and Interior, to finalize the agreements necessary to implement the Lower Basin Plan. With the Record of Decision, the 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines and the supporting agreements in place, we can focus on a longer-term, equitable, basin-wide outcome that includes shared sacrifices along with our Upper Basin partners in an effort to avoid protracted litigation. The actions in the Lower Basin in recent decades to protect the system have demonstrated how much we can accomplish when we all join together as part of the solution. โย Tom Buschatzke, Director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources
Tom Buschatzke. Photo credit: Arizona Department of Water Resources
Colorado River negotiators are seen at the 2025 Colorado River Water Users Association Annual Conference. From left to right: Becky Mitchell (Colorado), Tom Buschatzke (Arizona), Brandon Gebhart (Wyoming), and John Entsminger (Nevada). (Photo by Jeniffer Solis/Nevada Current)
Nevada officials filed a federal lawsuit challenging the Trump administrationโs order for cuts in water use Monday, marking a major escalation of tensions between the seven states that share the Colorado River. The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court of Nevada, asserts that the U.S. Bureau of Reclamationโs operating plan unlawfully authorizes the federal government to reduce the stateโs allocation of the river by up to 71 percent annually sometime over the next 10 years. Such a cut would slash the stateโs share of 300,000 acre-feet down to 86,444 acre-feet. Nevadaโs use, after cashing in water recycling credits with its state-of-the-art system, came in at 198,000 acre-feet last year.
โThere are four states upstream of us that are facing zero mandatory reductions,โ said John Entsminger, general manager of the Southern Nevada Water Authority, in a Monday interview. โThat is not going to balance the system. This is a system-wide problem. It requires system-wide solutions.โ
Lawyers for the Colorado River Commission of Nevada, the water authority and the state as a whole requested an injunction to halt implementation until federal documents can reflect the toll water cuts would have on Southern Nevadaโs $180 billion economy.
โThis shortfall will cause devastating environmental, socioeconomic, and health and human safety impacts to southern Nevada and its citizens,โ attorneys wrote. โFederal Defendants failed to consider such impacts in any meaningful way.โ
While 2027 and 2028 will see allocation cuts that the Lower Basin states of Nevada, California and Arizona have already agreed to, the years 2029 to 2036 could bring much harsher reductions. Entsminger said he felt it was important for Nevada to have its own representation on the issue, but he added he would be surprised if California and Arizona donโt sign on to the lawsuit, considering officials remain aligned in their positions. No mandatory cuts will be imposed on the Upper Basin states of Colorado, Utah, New Mexico and Wyoming. Entsminger submitted a letter to all six Colorado River basin states Monday, saying the stateโs decision to sue wasnโt made lightly but that โhiding from reasonable legal interpretations in order to defer hard political decisions helps no one over the long term and further endangers our shared resource.โ
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
Earlier that same day, the Department of Interior had issued its record of decision about how it would manage the key dams and hence the river during the two water years beginning in October. This came after Colorado and the six other basin states had failed during two years of negotiations to agree about how to share diminished river flows.
As even schoolboys in Kentucky likely know, the Colorado River has encountered severe problems since 2000. Flows in the river are down 20% and continuing to decline in direct proportion to rising temperatures. The two big reservoirs, Mead and Powell, have declined 75% in stored water.
The lower-basin states, which get their water from these two big reservoirs, had already cut their use significantly. The Department of Interior has ordered the three states to expect 1.25 million acre-feet less water from Mead during the next two years. It also expects the three states to figure out how to store 700,000 acre-feet over the next two years. Colorado and other upper basin states cannot expand water use.
Agriculture users, said Udall, will bear the brunt of these cutbacks. Municipal users โ all the cities from Coloradoโs Front Range to southern California get water from the river and its tributaries โ will have to chip in with water savings. Infrastructure limitations of the two big dams, Hoover and Glen Canyon, when holding little water need to be resolved. For example, penstocks [river outlet tubes] on the two big dams were never designed for day-in, day-out use, as may be necessary with reduced amounts of water. And as for the hydroelectric production? Yes, itโs a small amount but important. It provides backup power.
The process created by the Interior Department โ the Bureau of Reclamation is the key agency within Interior โ requires new plans every two years for the next decade. Udall sees merit in this approach.
โWhen the negotiations started, the idea was that weโre going to get a 20-year plan. We got five two-year plans, which you might see as a setback, but I think we might have blundered into something actually useful, because it potentially is true adaptive management, where people get to pay attention repeatedly as this evolves.โ [ed. emphasis mine]
Udall also sees strong dynamics producing solutions.
โI think weโre going to see a solution because the people who are involved in the negotiations are hard-working. Theyโre knowledgeable. Theyโre intelligent. They have super good relationships with each other. And they know that the chips are down. If they donโt solve it, the solution Mother Nature provides will be downright ugly. I think we will solve this. I actually do.โ
When the breakthroughs will occur, Udall said he didnโt know. And he hedged his confidence with caution. โI wonโt put bets on this.โ
What is clear, though, is that Arizona will be key to solving the conundrum of 21st century flows being far less than 20th century expectations. The river in the last century average 15.2 million acre-feet. Even when it carried healthy volumes of water, though, the river had ceased to reach an embayment of the Pacific Ocean. Flows this century have declined and, since 2020, remarkably so: to an average of just 10 million acre-feet.
Flows will almost certainly decline further. Accumulating greenhouse gas emissions guarantee continued warming, producing reduced flows.
โWestern water law is enormously complicated and really inhibits solutions,โ he said. โWeโve made a whole bunch of policy mistakes through time, including permanent allocations, assuming way too much water, and enforcing or legalizing really unrealistic policies.โ
Whether the framework created by the federal government for finding solutions will work, he said, will depend upon hydrology. In some circles optimism remains that the strong El Niรฑo this year will produce improved precipitation and hence greater flows. And maybe it will, said Udall, but the record on flows during El Nino years has been all over the scattergram. A few very big years โ 1983 and 1998 stand out โ yes. But some real duds, too. In other words, this coming winter could conceivably be as bad as the past winter. Or, if not as bad, then will continue the downhill slide.
Now rewriting the rules
Udall also made the point that prior agreements were incremental in nature, unlike what the new federal rules represent.
โThe rules in 2007 and 2019 were really hard fought, but they were incremental. They were truly incremental. What weโre looking at right now, itโs not incremental. Itโs a complete rethink,โ he said.
โI think people mistakenly thought that, given the successes in 2007, 2019, we would just kind of waltz our way to new rules. And I think thatโs the wrong way to think about whatโs going on. This is a really a different deal in 2026.โ
This new paradigm imposed by the federal government, Udall went on to say, is the โfirst global instance where climate change is forcing a complete redo of water management. I think I can make a pretty good case for that.โ
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
Udall has become well known at water meetings in Colorado and beyond, particularly during the last decade, in warning that communities and economic sectors dependent upon the Colorado River were headed for trouble. Climate change is water change, he began saying more than 20 years ago. And in 2014, he conducted research along with another scholar, Jonathan Overpeck, that showed the strong correlation between rising temperatures and reduced flows in the river. That science, he said, has strengthened.
Although living in Boulder, Udall in recent years has been affiliated with Colorado State Universityโs Colorado Water Center. There, he wears the title of senior water and climate research scientist/scholar.
However, Udall is also understood in terms of his family tree. He is a descendant of John D. Lee, the Mormon settler for whom Lee Ferry (also called Lees Ferry) is named. Located in Arizona, near the Utah border, it divides the Colorado Riverโs upper and lower basins.
Donโt make too much of being a John D. Lee descendant, he said. โHe had 21 wives that we know of, and some have suggested he has 800,000 descendants. That might actually be part of the problem with the Colorado River.โ
Ken Sleight the original Monkey Wrencher photo via Salon
As for his personal familiarity with the river, Udall divulged that he has rafted the Grand Canyon 45 times, at least some of those in the employ of Ken Sleight, best understood by readers of Edward Abbeyโs โMonkey Wrench Gangโ as the model for Seldom Seen Smith.
Arizonaโs role
In Udallโs view, Arizona is central to solving this 21stย century problem. The Central Arizona Project will โsee a whole lot less water, but itโs not going to zero. I donโt know quite how that gets revolved, but thatโs just so clear,โ he said.
The Central Arizona Project delivers water from the Colorado River through 336 miles of canal to metropolitan Phoenix and ultimately Tucson, with farms along the way. It was authorized by Congress in 1968 and completed in 1993. Both his father, Morris, and his uncle, Stewart, were key figures in this. It can deliver 1.6 million acre-feet, the majority of the 2.8 million acre-feet that Arizona was scheduled to receive from the Colorado River under a 1964 court ruling.
As Udall pointed out, farms that got water from the project have received far less since cutbacks began in 2020. And now, more cuts for the farms โ and cities โ will be coming.
Given an hour for his presentation, far longer than his usual 20- or 30-minute slots, Udall had time to sketch some history, even taking time to define the universal way of measuring water quantities in the basin, the acre-foot.
โThe reason that an acre-foot is used is farmers farm in terms of an acre,โ he explained. โIn the upper basin, you might put a foot or two feet of water on top of an acre to get a hay crop out. In the lower basin, near the Mexico border, you might put 10 feet of water on top of an irrigated field to get 10 different cuttings of alfalfa.โ
Credit: The Land Desk
Thoughts about hay
Alfalfa came up in the Q&A. The question, in not so many words, was how to cut back water used to feed livestock. After all, agriculture uses about 75% of the water (after evaporation) in the Colorado River, and alfalfa and other feedstocks comprise a large portion of that. A full hour could have been devoted to that question โ and likely left topics on the table. The tension inherent in this topic is revealed in how the Family Farm Alliance describes this push replace animal forage to crop switching: โcrop shaming.โ
โItโs easy to hate on alfalfa because people donโt eat it, but we kind of do, right? Dairy, ice cream, beef cattle. And the idea that youโre going to tell farmers not to grow alfalfa, which turns out to be a pretty good crop for them in their rotation, probably isnโt going to work very well. Youโre probably far better off to say, โHey, hereโs your reduced allocation. You use it as you want,โโ responded Udall
โI think most people in this room donโt care about corn. We very much care about alfalfa, and its water use, but Iโm not sure trying to prohibit farmers from using a crop thatโs key in their rotation and actually has some kind of interesting benefits is a suitable way to get there. โ
Udall also mentioned the difficulties of crop switching.
โItโs been suggested that ag shift to higher value products that use less water. One way to do that is only grow stuff in the winter because growing in Yuma (Arizona) and Imperial (Valley) in midsummer is not a great idea. But when you ask a farmer to shift produce or products, you ask them to change marketing, you ask them to (change) labor, transportation, storage, equipment, knowledge. You ask them to change a lot of things, and arguably thereโs a need to help this transition happen.โ
This discussion, he concluded, is one that needs to be had but is very complicated. โIt really is going to take a deep dive to figure out how to deal with this.โ
You will be able to soon hear what Udall had to say (and see the slides he shared) at the Getches-Wilkinson Centerโs site. The history lessons alone make it worth an hour.
A few other snippets:
โข โThe lower basin wants some contribution from the upper basin (in reducing use) maybe 5% or maybe 2%, but some kind of skin (in the game). And the upper Basin says no way. Until recently, the upper basin wanted to reserve the right to increase its use.โ
โข Our (Colorado delegate to the Upper Colorado River Commission) Becky Mitchell has recently been saying, you know, none of this gets us any extra water. And we need to move beyond this, and I applaud Becky for saying that.โ
โข Udall told a fascinating story about the Central Arizona Project. At the time the proposal for federal funding was before Congress, the Upper Colorado River Commission paid a Denver-based engineer to examine the numbers. That engineerโs conclusion: Thereโs not enough water for the Arizona project once the upper basin uses its full allocation (as defined in the Colorado River Compact of 1922). The number was 1.2 million acre-feet a year. And the two big reservoirs, Mead and Powell, have been losing 1.25 million acre-feet a year.
โข The idea in 1968, said Udall, was that the federal government was going to figure out how to augment flows of the Colorado River. One of the ideas was to export water from the Snake River in Wyomingโs Jackson Hole to the Green River and hence the Colorado. Washington Sen. Henry โScoopโ Jackson and other members of Congress from the Pacific Northwest objected. And the augmentation that was part of the thinking never has happened.
Green River Basin
โข On the first-in-time, first-in-right premise of Western water law. โYou know, first-in-time, first-in-rank gets reinvented by 4-year-olds every day of the year throughout the world. I was here first; itโs mine. And most parents step in and say youโre going to share, right: But not Western water law. It was completely understandable in the 1800s, where you had a few users. But itโs really not so great in modern society. โฆ
โYou canโt have a case where 1,500 famers deprive 5 million people in Phoenix or 2 million people in the Front Range of water, of what Iโll call critical human water needs. It just isnโt going to work politically. Shared sacrifice would be a whole lot better way to deal with this.โ
Itโs pretty hard to cut back water use under Western water law, because if one user decides not to take water, the next user downstream can grab it. โIf weโre trying to get water to Lake Powell, you have to rethink how this gets done.โ
Colorado statewide annual temperature anomaly (ยฐF) with respect to the 1901-2000 average. Graphic credit: Colorado Climate Center
โข Temperatures have increased 3 degrees Fahrenheit since 1979. โNot a single year after 2000 is below the 20th century average,โ he said of the Colorado River Basin. โIncreased temps lead to increased evaporation. We think you can lose up to 5% flow (of water) per degree rise.โ
Temperature increases have produced up to 15% increase in losses due to evaporation.
โข As for precipitation, the last 27 years have been the worst 27 years since record-keeping began in 1895. The declines worsened beginning in around 2015.
A 1% decline in precipitation leads to a 2% decline in flows.
โข As for Udall writing a book, as one audience member suggested, he said other authors have covered much of the same ground, even if he has a somewhat different angle. โI donโt know. I need an assistant!โ
Brad Udall is pictured at Boulder Reservoir, which helps deliver water from the Upper Colorado River to the Front Range. Photo: Vance Jacobs/Colorado State University
The Bureau of Reclamation’s 10-year plan for managing Colorado River flows seeks to preserve enough water behind the Hoover Dam to sustain electricity generation. (Angus M. Thuermer Jr./WyoFile)
A federal drought plan for the Colorado River and its tributaries in Wyoming shouldnโt stop Wyoming from building a new dam and reservoir in Carbon County, two Western water experts say.
The Bureau of Reclamation plan for the sweeping basin focuses on maintaining enough water in Lake Powell and Lake Mead to generate electricity and prevent degradation of critical infrastructure, professors from Utah and Arizona said last week.
The 10-year framework to manage water storage and releases in the complex seven-state, two-nation system seeks to balance predictability and flexibility in two-year increments. It also acknowledges that the government has little to no authority over water use in headwater states Wyoming, Utah, Colorado and New Mexico, said Sarah Porter, the director of the Kyl Center for Water Policy at Arizona State Universityโs Morrison Institute.
โOne way of reading the final environmental impact statement,โ Porter said, โis the Bureauโs determination that it doesnโt really have any authority to limit water use in the headwaters.โ [ed. emphasis mine]
A controversial dam proposed on the West Fork of Battle Creek, which flows into the Little Snake River, above, and the Colorado River could still be built despite a drought that prevents Lake Powell and Lake Mead from filling. (EcoFlight)
Drought will likely cause agricultural stress in Arizona, Nevada and California, threatening the supply of winter vegetables and possibly other crops, she said.
โWe probably wonโt be eating as many salads,โ she said, because Arizona is where winter lettuce is harvested. โItโs all grown in Yuma.โ
More important for Wyoming might be that the Bureau of Reclamationโs final environmental impact statement recognizes the independence of headwater, or upper-division, states to essentially use water as they see fit. Efforts to conserve water in the Upper Basin โare not within the scope of this EIS,โ the federal document states.
So while farmers downstream may see their traditional supplies cut, Wyoming forges ahead with plans for the 10,000-acre-foot West Fork dam and reservoir in Carbon County where 6,000 acre-feet a year would be poured onto fields for late-season irrigation on ranches.
Energy equation
The Bureau is imposing the plan after the seven states failed to agree on how to share Colorado River flows as drought crimps traditional allotments that were based on too-rosy estimates.
โWe have the lowest reservoir storage weโve ever seen,โ said David Rosenberg, a Utah State University professor and water researcher. โWe have very low inflows.โ
He and Porter spoke in a Zoom webinar hosted by SciLine, a nonprofit that connects reporters with scientists.
The two called the Bureau of Reclamation plan a decision-making framework for distributing water in the three Lower Basin states โ initially for two years.
โIt doesnโt place the basin on a path to stabilizing the system at all,โ Porter said. โIt doesnโt resolve conflict at all. It doesnโt achieve the [long-term] things that the basin really needs at this point.โ [ed. emphasis mine]
The Colorado River Basin spans seven U.S. states and part of Mexico. Lake Powell, upstream from the Grand Canyon, and Lake Mead, near Las Vegas, are the two principal reservoirs in the Colorado River water-supply system. (Bureau of Reclamation)
But the plan is โa very clear statement,โ Rosenberg said, โof how theyโre going to protect infrastructure.โ
That infrastructure includes the two major dams, associated power plants and canals that would become useless, even degraded, if the water levels in Powell and Mead drop below critical levels. With the plan, Rosenberg said, the Bureau states: โWeโre still going to be generating hydropower.โ
View below Flaming Gorge Dam from the Green River, eastern Utah. Photo credit: USGSBlue Mesa Dam. Photo credit: ReclamationThe outflow at the bottom of Navajo Dam in New Mexico. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism
Powellโsย Glen Canyonย and Meadโsย Hoover dams can generate some $443 million of market-price electricity a year when operating fully, according to calculations from the Bureau of Reclamation and theU.S. Energy Information Administration. To keep those two reservoirs flush, the Bureau will release water from Wyomingโs Flaming Gorge Reservoir and from Coloradoโs Blue Mesa Reservoir and New Mexicoโs and Coloradoโs Navajo Reservoir.
Beyond that, the Bureauโs plan targets the three Lower Basin states for reductions, depending on water in the river system and reservoirs.
Headwater states largely rely on stream and river flows determined by spring runoff. The at-risk region in Wyoming includes the Green River and its tributaries and the Little Snake River in Carbon County.
In contrast, the Lower Basin โgets all of its water, Colorado River water, from the reservoirs,โ Porter said. Itโs a lot more complicated to curtail Upper Basin use โthan simply to not deliver water out of a reservoir,โ she said. โAnd thatโs a sore point with the Lower Basin.โ
The two professors predicted a fight. โWe expect theyโll be challenging this administrative process,โ Porter said of the lower division statesโ reaction to the Bureauโs EIS.
Compact call coming
Thereโs more on the horizon too.
โI also expect that within the next year and a half, or maybe two years, there will be what we call a compact call,โ Porter said, โa demand from the Lower Basin for water that the Lower Basin contends the Upper Basin is obligated to deliver.
โThat challenge will occur in the United States Supreme Court and that could take 10, 20, 30 years.โ
Under the 1922 Colorado River Compact and associated agreements, the upper division states canโt diminish the flow from Lake Powell below 7.5 million acre-feet annually, calculated on a 10-year rolling average. Thatโs half what engineers originally calculated the watershed would produce; half belonging to the headwater states, half to the Lower Basin. That estimate is now considered to have been exuberantly optimistic. [ed. emphasis mine]
โWe really need to figure out a way collectively to be reducing demand in the Colorado River by at least 3 million acre-feet out of the 15 million,โ Porter said, โand that probably canโt all fall on the Lower Basin.
โThe Lower Basin,โ she said, โdidnโt agree to be junior to the Upper Basin.โ
If Upper Basin states donโt deliver the 7.5 million acre-feet past the Lee Ferry gauging station just below Lake Powell, headwaters curtailment will begin, starting with the most recent, or junior, water-right holders.
Until then, conservation in Wyoming will be voluntary, generally meaning that if an irrigator or other user forgoes their water right, they will need to be paid. In previous trial conservation programs, that has cost $500 an acre foot.
But a compact call by Lower Basin states would lead to curtailment โ a mandatory cutting off of Upper Basin water use starting with the most recent, or junior, rightsโ holders. Long-established ranches and irrigators hold senior rights while Wyoming municipalities and industries in the Green River Basin are likely among the first to be curtailed.
The proposed dam would be 264 feet high, 700 feet long and made out of concrete. (Major King for WyoFile)
Under the โLaw of the River,โ Wyoming has rights โ on paper โ to 14% of the Upper Basinโs 7.5 million acre-feet annually. Thatโs about 1 million acre-feet. But the state engineer estimated in 2010 that Wyomingโs rights amount to 847,000 acre-feet a year, according to the stateโs 2010 plan for the basin. Wyoming uses 680,076 acre-feet and has rights to another 166,924, the latest plan states.
That makes the 100,000 or so Wyomingites who rely on or use Green River water relatively water rich compared to the 40 million down-streamers who rely on the river for some or all of their agricultural and municipal needs. In essence, 100,000 Wyomingites have rights to almost 1 million acre-feet while 39.9 million down-streamers divvy up 7.5 million acre-feet.
The implications go beyond the scarcity of your garden-variety salad.
โIf there are big reductions in water supplies to those [Lower Basin] areas, there really will be impacts on our food supply nationally, not to mention other impacts,โ Porter said.
Phoenix reclaims wastewater through a multi-step filtration process – settling, aeration, disinfection – turning it into clean water for parks, cooling, and natural restoration.
Recycling water
While the prospect of southwestern metropolises crashing headlong into ugly sewerage problems caused by the crisis would seem to loom, donโt put all your money into wag-bags and porta potties yet. The municipalities are figuring out how to cope.
โThose cities are making massive investments in advanced water purification to treat reclaimed water to potable to reduce reliance on annual deliveries of Colorado River water,โ Porter said. โThat access to other water supplies or other water management strategies isnโt really available to agricultural water users or, to a great extent, the tribes who are significant rights holders to Colorado River water.
โWe may see impacts to cities really smoothed out and not be very disruptive,โ she said. โIf we do have disruptive impacts, they will probably fall on rural areas and tribal communities in the Lower Basin.โ
And the existing plans and commitments, including a federal outline announced in late July 2026, donโt get close to achieving whatโs needed to keep the river flowing. Hereโs a look at the key issues making an agreement so hard to reach.
The Lower Basin states โ Arizona, California and Nevada โ have been using less water, even as their populations have grown.
They have proposed to further reduce water use in 2027 and 2028, and Mexico has, too. Those decreases, coming only from the Lower Basin states, would be the biggest-ever reductions of Colorado River water use, but they would amount to only about 3.7 million acre-feet over two years, about half what is likely needed.
If the winter of 2026-27 is like the winter the West had in 2025-26, the river and reservoirs will likely be at that point by mid-2027. A really good winter with lots of snow might push the timing out a year or two, but it wonโt solve the problem: People are using a lot more water from the reservoirs than nature is replenishing each year with rainfall and snowfall.
The other key problem is evaporation. These massive reservoirs are in a hot, dry region. The U.S. Geological Survey estimates that annual evaporation is about 1.5 million acre-feet. Thatโs about 10% of what the seven states expect to be able to use each year โ and about half of the overall cuts in water use that would be needed to keep the river flowing.
Even if sufficient water were released from Lake Powell to Lake Mead to cover the Lower Basinโs and Mexicoโs apportionments, Lake Mead would continue to decline because of evaporation.
What would deep cuts mean for people?
Farmers and ranchers in the Upper Basin have had less water available in 2026 because the winter was extraordinarily dry.
But if water levels at Lake Powell and Lake Mead fall too low to allow dam managers to release stored water, the effects would be on the Lower Basin.
Entities that receive water from the Central Arizona Project have junior priority in the Lower Basin. Central Arizona cities have yearsโ worth of groundwater they could access โ not a forever supply, but enough to use for some years while they work on developing new water supplies.
If cuts go deeper, tribal and nontribal agriculture along the main stem would arguably take the hardest hit. They may have higher-priority rights, but if thereโs no water theyโre still in trouble. And there isnโt an alternative water supply for agriculture along the riverโs main route.
Across the nation, people would notice higher costs and limited availability of some produce, especially in the winter. At times of year when those crops canโt grow in colder parts of the country, Yuma County, Arizona, and Imperial County, California, are key suppliers of vegetables. Other products would be affected too, including Desert durum wheat, a high-gluten wheat that is preferred for pasta.
What would those cuts mean for electricity?
The federal Bureau of Reclamation has made clear its commitment to continuing hydropower production by keeping reservoir elevations above the minimum level needed to generate electricity.
As a result, the reservoirs will likely not reach the point called โdeadpool,โ at which no water can move through the dam. But they may reach levels at which no water beyond whatโs required to generate power โ or what arrives as rain or snow โ would flow downstream.
What are the statesโ positions?
The Lower Basin states have said they would reduce water use by 1.6 million acre-feet a year, effectively handling the reduction due to evaporation. But the Lower Basin has remained insistent on the Upper Basin statesโ sharing in additional conservation measures.
Without a negotiated way forward, there are two potential legal fights on the horizon, which could happen at the same time.
One is a Supreme Court fight over how to interpret the Colorado River Compact. It tends to take about a decade to resolve interstate water-sharing fights in the Supreme Court. If that happens, the region will face years of uncertainty regarding the amount of water available to different users.
At the same time, negotiators, tribes and others in the Lower Basin have made clear that they donโt agree with the approach to the crisis the Bureau of Reclamation announced in late July 2026. The specifics of how that plan will be carried out have not yet been released, but Arizona and Nevada have already threatened to sue.
I think itโs going to require federal leadership. In the 1930s a national effort set out to improve farming efficiency all around the nation, but especially in the South and West. Under the Bankhead-Jones Act of 1937, the federal government bought millions of acres of marginal farmland to take it out of production.
Farming is important, but not every acre of farmland should stay in production. If itโs a choice between making sure some water goes to cities or keeping every possible acre of farmland irrigated, we have to be able to discuss both options.
Becky Mitchell, Colorado member of the Upper Colorado River Commission, speaks to PBS News about the fight for Colorado River water near the banks of the river in Grand Junction on Aug. 19, 2026. (Screenshot via YouTube/PBS News)
The future of the Colorado River is looking bleak, and officials in the seven states that depend on its water say theyโre happy to negotiate โ but with current use rules expiring at the end of the year, compromise seems unlikely.
During a more than two-hour PBS special on Wednesday, officials from the Upper and Lower basins, as well as farmers and water experts, painted an alarming picture of a shrinking river without enough water to meet legal allocation obligations set more than 100 years ago.
The Colorado River is a vital source of drinking water for 40 million people in the seven states, Mexico and 30 Native American tribes, and it provides water for farming operations and hydroelectricity.
The Lower Basin states โ Arizona, Nevada and California โ and the Upper Basin states โ Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming โ have been attempting to negotiate an updated water usage agreement for more than two years. So far, theyโve been unsuccessful.
Because of the negotiating impasse, the federal government has devised a plan to replace the agreement that expires at the end of the year. It will impose drastic cuts on the Lower Basin states, and Arizona will feel the brunt of those cuts with a cut to its river water of up to 77%.
Arizona faces an outsized burden when it comes to reductions because the Central Arizona Project, a series of canals that supplies Colorado River water to the metropolitan Phoenix and Tucson areas, is one of the newest users of the river water, making it legally one of the first to be cut.
The major sticking point in the negotiations is the Upper Basin statesโ refusal to commit to any mandatory cuts, while the Lower Basin states already take cuts in dry years.
Becky Mitchell, Coloradoโs water commissioner, said that her state already deals with mandatory cuts, theyโre just from Mother Nature, not the U.S. government. The Colorado River is fed by melting snowpack in the Rocky Mountains, which is at a record low this year.
โWhat I canโt promise is to deliver water when itโs not there,โ Mitchell said. โNobody can.โ
She characterized the Lower Basin statesโ argument that the Upper Basin wasnโt taking mandatory cuts as a โmajor flaw,โ since the Upper Basin uses anywhere between three to five millions acre-feet per year, based on whatโs available.
An acre-foot of water is enough to cover an acre of land to a depth of one foot, or about 325,851 gallons. Thatโs enough to provide three homes in Arizona a year of water, on average.
Mitchell said the cuts from Mother Nature are โfar more fierce than the federal government will ever be,โ putting farmers on the western slope of the Rockies at risk of going out of business.
And while those in the Upper Basin balk at the swimming pools and golf courses in the middle of the desert that are prevalent in urban centers of Arizona and Nevada, municipalities account for only about 25% of the Lower Basinโs water use.
Agriculture accounts for the other 75%. Andrea Travnik, assistant secretary for water and science at the U.S. Department of Interior, dodged a question from PBS about whether the federal government would contemplate putting restrictions on water use for farming, which would be incredibly politically unpopular.
Travnik said that the federal government has already worked with the states to raise water levels in Lake Mead through conservation efforts, and will continue to push for conservation, in addition to other solutions like desalination โ which is extremely expensive โ and water reuse.
But Brad Udall, a water and climate scientist at Colorado State University, said that if the 1,500 farmers that depend on Colorado River water for their crops are pitted against the 5 million people in metropolitan Phoenix and the 18 million people in the greater Los Angeles area, the winner will be obvious.
Udall thinks the states need to ditch the outdated 1922 Colorado River Compact, which allocated 7.5 million acre-feet for each basin, and was based on a faulty model that assumed the river system could supply 15 million acre-feet annually. While use agreements have been updated numerous times since then, the allocations to each basin remain the same.
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
The region is in the midst of a 20-year mega drought that is wreaking havoc on the river. Since 2000, flows in the Colorado River have decreased by 20%. And since, 2020 flows are down 35%.
After negotiations with the Upper Basin were unfruitful earlier this year, the Lower Basin states in May offered their own proposal to reduce their shared usage by 1.25 million acre-feet annually in 2027 and 2028, with about a 30% cut for Arizona.
This proposal was aimed at helping to stabilize water levels in Lake Powell and Lake Mead, the systemโs two key reservoirs, whose water levels fell this month to their lowest point since 1957.
Udall described both reservoirs as just above deadpool, the point at which water drops too low to flow past a dam by gravity.
โDeadpool is a point where you lose control of the reservoir,โ he said. โMother Nature controls what happens. It controls what comes in. It controls what you send out the bottom.โ
Reaching deadpool would turn those reservoirs into nothing more than concrete basins where water evaporates, Udall said.
โItโs kind of hard to overstate the consequences of losing those water bank accounts for the states that rely on it in the Lower Basin,โ he said.
While Mitchell said that the Upper Basin couldnโt guarantee its 7.5 million acre-feet delivery of water to the Lower Basin, it would attempt to prevent the reservoirs from reaching deadpool.
Tom Buschatzke, director of the Arizona Department of Water Resources, said that the basins could come to an agreement today, if the Upper Basin would agree to take a 2% mandatory cut of its annual available water supply, or about 100,000 acre-feet in a year with 5 million acre feet available.
Mitchell did not say she would agree to those cuts, saying that the Upper Basin states are already managing their water responsibly.
But Arizona and the other Lower Basin states have undertaken significant conservation efforts for Colorado River water since 2014 and have reduced their consumption from 7.4 million acre-feet in 2015 to just over 6 million in 2024, adding 165 feet of water to Lake Mead.
All of the water officials who participated in the PBS special said they would prefer to hammer out a compromise instead of going to court, but that they were committed to protecting their water rights.
In March, Arizona retained the high-powered law firm Sullivan & Cromwell to represent the state in possible litigation among the Colorado River Basin states and the federal government.
Kathryn Sorensen, director of research at the Kyl Center for Water Policy at Arizona State University, said that while the fight for Colorado River water has become โexistentialโ because of overallocation, Arizonans shouldnโt panic yet.
Even if the Central Arizona Project goes dry, she said, Phoenix still has banked groundwater and the Salt and Verde rivers to fall back on. Sorensen said she doesnโt expect municipal water shortages, but she does predict higher water bills.
The Trump administrationโs draft โpreferred alternativeโ plan for the river, released last month, could reduce the Lower Basinโs allocation by 3 million acre-feet per year, slashing Arizonaโs water supply from the river by more than 75%. But thereโs still a possibility that the federal government could implement the Lower Basinโs proposal for smaller cuts instead.
The federal governmentโs new river usage rules, which are still being negotiated, will be released later this year.
Udall said that the U.S. is totally failing to address the overall cause of the riverโs decline.
โThereโs a whole bunch of scientific studies that suggest that this is very much human-caused,โ Udall said. โItโs due to our greenhouse gas emissions and the warming of the earth right now.โ
This story was originally produced by Arizona Mirror, which is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network which includes Colorado Newsline, and is supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity.
Colorado Newsline is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Colorado Newsline maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Quentin Young for questions: info@coloradonewsline.com.
For Mead and Powell, fresh record lows. Data: USBR; Graph: Jack Schmidt
Click the link to read the article on the InkStain website (Jack Schmidt and John Fleck):
August 7, 2026
When Lake Meadโs elevation crossed the threshold of 1,040 feet above sea level in the spring of 1937, stretching upstream 100 miles behind Hoover Dam in the deserts of the Arizona Nevada border, it was national news.
So much water!
Kerrville Times, Kerrville Texas, May 13, 1937
As Mead drops past that threshold in the opposite direction in the summer of 2026, itโs telling a different story. So little water.
Two milestones in the last few days are worthy of note. The first is Lake Mead itself, which in the last two days dropped past the previous lowest levels in history set in 2022, meaning it is now the lowest it has been since the reservoir was first filled in the 1930s.
Lake Mead was at 7.012 maf yesterday (Aug. 6, 2026) (1040.5 ft). The previous record low was 7.018 maf (1040.58 ft) that was set on July 28, 2022. Thus, yesterdayโs reservoir contents in Lake Mead are the lowest since at least May 1937.
Meanwhile, Lake Powell is now 85,000 af (1.51 ft) above its lowest historical amount since it was first filled in the 1960s.
But that does not fully capture the extent of the crisis. Total reservoir contents of all 46 reservoirs in the Reclamation data base (extending from Fontenelle and Grand Lakes to Lake Havasu) was at 21.27 maf on July 1, the lowest since at least May 29, 1965 (probably earlier, since the Reclamation data base doesnโt report many reservoir contents at that early date).
The vultures didnโt wait long to feed on the carrion of shrunken national monuments. Within days of President Donald Trumpโs order slashing nearly 3 million acres from Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monuments, mining claims were filed within the former boundaries of both monuments with San Juan County and Kane County, respectively.
While Trumpโs shrinkage did reopen that land to new mining claims and mineral leasing, it does not go into effect until Sept. 11, 60 days after the proclamations were issued. The claims have not officially been recorded with the Bureau of Land Management.
On July 14, Kimmerle Mining LLC out of Moab filed seven claims just within the eastern border of what had been Bears Ears National Monument just two days earlier. A few weeks later, Charles Rosequist filed two claims in the southwest corner of the GSENM, near Kaibab Gulch and the Vermilion Cliffs.
Kimmerle Mining, its principal Kyle Kimmerle, and other family members hold dozens of mining claims across southern Utah and western Colorado uranium country. The family firm became known for staking claims in what would become Bears Ears National Monument leading up to its designation, and for locating more after Trumpโs first national monument shrinkage in 2017.
Just before Biden restored the boundaries in 2021, Kimmerle Mining staked five new claims within the national monument and acquired additional claims from another firm in the historic White Canyon mining district. Kimmerle Mining promptly filed for a permit to do exploration work there, but the BLM said they had to demonstrate the claimsโ โvalidity,โ or show that they contained โvaluable minerals.โ The process for doing so would cost up to $100,000. Shortly thereafter, Kimmerle joined the state of Utahโs lawsuit seeking to eviscerate the national monument, claiming that its establishment had caused him to lose out on mining profits.
And, in 2018, the Kimmerle family staked the Easy Peasy claims in the Cottonwood Wash drainage in what had been Bears Ears National Monument. The new claims are adjacent to those, in the Cheese & Raisins Hills area, which was mined historically for vanadium and uranium. The Shumway brothers staked claims there back in the 1930s, including the Big Hole Mine, and the ruins of an old vanadium mill are still visible nearby.
Remnants of a historic vanadium processing plant in the Cottonwood Wash drainage near where Kimmerle Mining filed seven mining claims in an area removed from Bears Ears National Monument. Jonathan P. Thompson photo
Whether the firm plans to mine the claims, or is just looking for more grounds for a future lawsuit in the event that the next administration restores the boundaries isnโt clear. They have been known to use mining claims to make political points: Late last year, Kimmerle Mining staked four 20.66-acre lode claims on the east slope of the Henry Mountains,ย naming them Trump I, Trump 2, Trump 3, and Trump 4.
Also in the shady mining moves around national monument shrinkage: Less than a week before Trump issued the proclamations, Energy Fuels CEO Ross Bhappu purchased 74,000 shares of the uranium mining and milling firmโs stock, and the companyโs chairman Bruce Hansen bought 4,000 shares. Democratic lawmakers on the House Natural Resources committee are now investigating the trade and the possibility that the executives received privileged, non-public information from the Trump administration in advance of the shrinkage.
Energy Fuels owns and operates the White Mesa uranium mill in San Juan County, Utah, east of Bears Ears National Monument. The company lobbied the Obama administration prior to its original 2016 designation. Though the administration ultimately excluded Energy Fuelsโ Daneros mine from the monument, the firm lamented the fact that seven miles of the mineโs one access road still fell within the boundaries.
In 2017 Energy Fuels lobbyists, including former U.S. Rep. Mary Bono, R-Calif., met with Trump administration officials, and requested that it โreduce the size of the (Bears Ears National Monument) to only those specific resource areas or sites, if any, deemed to need additional protection beyond what is already available to Federal land management agencies.โ
In 2021, IsoEnergy acquired the Daneros Mine and other mining properties from Energy Fuels. But any ore mined in the former Bears Ears is likely to be processed at Energy Fuelsโ White Mesa mill, so they stand to benefit from the shrinkage.ย
โ๏ธ Wacky Weather Watchโก๏ธ
It wasnโt exactly a hurricane that hit Hurricane, but it was pretty darned destructive. This past weekend a huge storm pounded southwestern Utah, leading to arroyo-busting flash floods that turned the cityโs streets into rivers of mud. The water gave a big boost to the Virgin River, which shot up from about 165 cubic feet per second to over 4,000 cfs in a matter of hours.
๐ Colorado River Chronicles ๐ง
Lake Powell reached a grim benchmark this past weekend, when its surface elevation dropped to its lowest level since 1968, when the nationโs second largest reservoir was still filling up. In April of 2023, the level fell to 3,519.92 feet. On August 15 of this year, it reached 3,519.91 feet and is still falling at a rate of about two inches per day.
While not exactly surprising, the event launched many a news story in the mainstream media. And as is often the case with complicated issues like these โ and the Glen Canyon Dam problem is not exactly simple or straightforward โ some of the facts in these stories can be a little less than factual, and could use a bit of clarification.
The graphic showing reservoir levels at Lake Powell says that at 3,370 feet, known as dead pool, โWater no longer flows past the dam.โ As Zak Podmore โ who wrote the book on Lake Powell and deadpool โย pointed out on X-Twitter, that is not quite right. What actually would happen is that the dam would become a run-of-the-river facility, meaning water released from the dam would be equal to water flowing into the reservoir (minus losses from seepage and evaporation). So the Grand Canyon would not go completely dry, though there would be times when flows are pretty darned low.
The piece notes: โAbout 6 million people across the Southwest rely on electricity from the dams [both Glen Canyon and Hoover].โ This isnโt wrong, itโs just worded in a way that overstates the importance of these generatorsโ energy output to the Western power grid. Combined, the dams produce enough electricity annually to power some 550,000 households for a year. That power is sold at cost to municipalities, cooperatives, tribal nations, irrigation districts, and utilities across the West, which include it as part of their larger portfolios. The 6 million figure probably refers to all of the customers all of those entities serve; if the dams go down, these folks most likely wouldnโt notice except for a small jump in their power bills.
Humpback chub. National Park Service illustration by Joe Tomelleri.
Protect the Grand Canyonโs Humpback Chub A guest dispatch by Ron Rudolph
This month Lake Powell will shrink to a level last seen in 1968, a few months before the first astronauts orbited the Moon.ย The receding reservoir has forced the Bureau of Reclamation to abandon the practice of releasing cool water from the reservoir, a strategy used successfully to prevent smallmouth bass from becoming entrenched in Grand Canyon National Park below Glen Canyon Dam.1ย The bass are an invasive species that can escape from Lake Powell and could imperil the Grand Canyonโs native humpback chub population, the most important remnant of a federally protected species that was once widespread throughout the Colorado River system.2ย Scientists attribute steep declines in the humpback chub population in the upper Colorado River Basin largely to smallmouth bass predation.3
Sustaining the humpback chub population in the Grand Canyon is essential to prevent the speciesโ extinction. With cool water releases no longer feasible, protecting the humpback chub now requires a different approach. Increasing the delivery of sediment into the Grand Canyon may be the most effective remaining tool. Additional sediment transported from Lake Powell, either around or through Glen Canyon Dam, would increase turbidity, making it more difficult for smallmouth bass to establish a stable population.
The Bureauโs decision to halt cool water releases reflects the severity of the ongoing drought, which has reduced this yearโs unregulated flow of the Colorado River to the second lowest since Glen Canyon Dam was completed 63 years ago.4ย In April, the agency instituted unprecedented efforts to bolster Lake Powell, which were intended to preserve Glen Canyon Damโs ability to generate hydropower.5ย Despite those efforts, the Bureauโs July 24-month forecast of the minimum probable flow of water into Lake Powell anticipates Glen Canyon Dam will be unable to generate electricity from February 2027 through at least June 2028.6ย In fiscal year 2025, Glen Canyon Dam generated enough electricity to supply the annual average needs of 269,000 U.S. households.7
Humpback chub evolved exclusively in the Colorado River system, the water often referred to as โtoo thick to drink and too thin to plow.โ It developed exquisite adaptations to thrive in a volatile environment, driven by flash floods that can rapidly turn relatively clear water to an opaque reddish-brown, making it impossible to see oneโs finger one inch below the surface. Its gills and mouth have protective flaps that prevent sediment from clogging them, its eyes are tailored to see in muddy water, and special sensory organs detect prey and plants, allowing the fish to breathe and eat in highly turbid conditions. In contrast, smallmouth bass evolved in clear lakes and streams, relying on their vision to obtain food.
Fortunately, the adult humpback chub population is flourishing in the western Grand Canyon where sediment from the annual monsoon season turns the river into a torrent of mud. From 2010 to 2024, the population grew about 160-fold, with the median population estimated at about 70,000.8ย This resurgence caused the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to reclassify the species from being endangered โ i.e., in imminent threat of extinction, under the Endangeredย Species Act โย to a less serious status of threatened.9
Smallmouth bass were not present in the Grand Canyon prior to the construction of Glen Canyon Dam, but now occur occasionally in its western section. The largest smallmouth bass captured in the park – 15.2 inches – was found in the far western section of the Grand Canyon in 2006.10ย The fact that humpback chub flourish in the western Grand Canyon while smallmouth bass do not underscores the importance of intense and sustained pulses of turbidity created by suspended particulates. These conditions appear to be a key factor in preventing smallmouth bass from becoming established.ย
Because Glen Canyon Dam traps most sediment before it can reach the Grand Canyon, the Bureau should commission a study to evaluate options for increasing sediment delivery from Lake Powell. A sediment bypass system, such as a pipeline around or through the dam, could provide the turbidity needed to suppress smallmouth bass in the absence of cool water releases. Given current hydrologic realities, such an approach may be the most effective longโterm strategy for protecting the humpback chub and preserving the ecological integrity of the Grand Canyon.
1 โFeds Nix Grand Canyon fish protection flows below Lake Powell,โ Arizona Republic, August 7, 2026
2 Glen Canyon Adaptive Management Program โย https://gcdamp.com/index.php/ Smallmouth_Bass_Page
3 U.S. Geological Survey, โDropping the Bass: USGS science helps partners stop spread of invasive smallmouth bass in the Colorado River,โ March 21, 2025
4 The Bureau of Reclamationโs July 2026 โMost Probableโ 24-Month Study projects unregulated inflow for this water year at 3.501 million acre-feet. 2002 is the driest on record at 2.64 MAFย
6 Bureau of Reclamation, July 2026 Probable Minimum 24-Month Study;ย https://www.usbr.gov/ lc/region/g4000/24mo_MIN.pdf. When Lake Powell drops below elevation 3,490, it can no longer generate hydropower. See Bureau of Reclamation, Final Environmental Impact Statement, Post-2026 Operational Guidelines and Strategies for Lake Powell and Lake Mead, Technical Appendix 15, Dams and Electrical Power Resources, page 15-11
7 In Fiscal Year 2025 Glen Canyon Dam generated 2,792,000,000 kilowatt-hours of electricity, according to the Western Area Power Administrationโs Statistical Index โย https:// http://www.wapa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/FY-2025-Statistical-Appendix.pdf, page 9. According to the U.S., Energy Information Administration, U.S. households use an average of 10,365 kWh annually.ย https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=97&t=3; avg monthly consumption 863; annual 10,365 kWh EIAย https://www.eia.gov/electricity/ sales_revenue_price/pdf/table_5a.pdf
8 Dzul et al., โIntegrating mark-recapture, catch, and expert habitat assessments to quantify recent increases in humpback chub abundance over a 200 km long river segment of the Colorado River in western Grand Canyon,โ Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, July 2026. Dzul estimated with 95% confidence that the population was between 40,000โ200,000
Department of the Interior releases Operating Guidelines and Record of Decision for the Colorado River. Photo credit: USBR
Click the link to read the release on the USBR website:
August 21, 2026
The Department of the Interior issued the 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines and the Record of Decision for the Post-2026 Colorado River Operations Final EIS, establishing a 10-year Decision Framework with a broad operational range that will be used to develop future operational guidelines for Lake Powell and Lake Mead. Together these decisions provide for reliable operations of the Colorado River system, delivery of vital water supplies, and protect critical federal infrastructure while preserving the flexibility necessary to respond to Basin statesโ voluntary actions, consensus recommendations and the continued prolonged drought. The combined contents of Lake Powell and Lake Mead have not been this low since before Lake Powell began filling following the closure of the gates at Glen Canyon Dam in 1963, with both Lake Powell and Lake Mead hitting record lows the last few weeks.
Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2025. Note the tiny points on the annual data so that you can flyspeck the individual years. Credit: Brad Udall
“We are grateful for the Seven Basin States, the thirty Basin Tribes, Mexico, and many other basin stakeholders who have provided the feedback and voluntary arrangements necessary for the development of the 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines.โ said Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum. โForty million people, millions of acres of farmland and ranchland, industries that power the American West, and some of our nationโs fastest growing metropolitan areas depend on the Colorado River.”
ย The 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines respond to hydrologic conditions and provide flexible tools to protect critical infrastructure at Glen Canyon Dam and Hoover Dam. They were developed after extensive engagement with the seven Basin States and incorporate concepts from proposals from both the Upper and Lower Basins and Basin tribes.
These 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines:
Provide objective criteria to determine releases from Lake Powell based on actual hydrology and maintaining a minimum elevation of 3,510 feet to support continued operational reliability at Glen Canyon Dam.
Provides for reductions in deliveries of Colorado River water among the Lower Basin States of 1.25 million acre-feet in each year of the next two years. If the Lower Basin States implement their proposed sharing agreement, the reduction per State would be:
Arizona: 760,000 acre-feetย
California: 440,000 acre-feetย
Nevada: 50,000 acre-feetย
Provide for Lower Basin States to voluntarily conserve and store at least 700,000 acre-feet of water over the two-year period to protect the system, in addition to the 1.25 million acre-feet per year of reductions.ย
Provide for the Upper Basin States to enter into an agreement, in consultation with Lower Basin States and Basin tribes, using the Secretary’s authorities to operate the Colorado River Storage Project Upper Initial Units (i.e. Aspinall (CO), Flaming Gorge (UT/WY) and Navajo (CO/NM) Reservoirs) to help protect Glen Canyon Dam infrastructure.
Provide tools and flexibility in the Lower Basin to respond to drought conditions by allowing water users to store water.
Provides for a Federally managed pool to help meet tribal firming obligations and provide limited offsetting to reduce tribal impacts.
Provide elevation triggers for coordination and consultations to determine additional actions, if necessary, to minimize operational risks to infrastructure, and manage risks to the urban, agricultural, and natural systems that rely on the Colorado River.ย
Reclamation also released today the August 2026 24-Month Study, determining the 2027 operations based on the new guidelines. Lake Powell will begin the October 1 water year between elevations 3,540 and 3,510 feet, placing operations in the Lower Elevation Infrastructure Protection Range with an expected water year release between 6.0 and 7.0 million acre-feet. Reclamation will begin the water year with lower releases between 6.0 and 7.0 million acre-feet in order to attempt to maintain an elevation of 3,510 feet or higher and will adjust releases through April to continue to maintain elevation 3,510 feet. The water year 2027 release volume will be determined in April. For Lake Mead, water deliveries to the Lower Basin States will be reduced by 1.25 million-acre feet for calendar year 2027.
The Decision Framework establishes an operational range that provides the flexibility to develop specific operating guidelines within the 10-year period while preserving the opportunity for Colorado River Basin negotiations to continue and, if successful, be incorporated into years three or four or longer for future operational guidelines. Operational elements include enhanced coordinated reservoir operations and expanded opportunities for the storage and delivery of conserved water in system reservoirs and other flexible water management tools. The Decision Framework prioritizes consensus agreements, voluntary actions, and a commitment to coordination and consultation throughout the period of adoption.
The Decision Framework anticipates operating guidelines in two-year periods and can be scaled longer depending on evolving Basin circumstances. This mechanism leaves room for the Basin States, tribes and stakeholders to adjust these parameters with their own voluntary actions and consensus whenever such agreements are reached.
โThese decisions provide a water management strategy for Basin stakeholders to respond to the prolonged drought by incorporating flexible tools and voluntary actions while leaving room for consensus agreements,โ said Assistant Secretary โ Water and Science Andrea Travnicek. โThe Department and Reclamation will continue to work with all Basin stakeholders to identify areas to maximize efforts throughout the Basin to modernize infrastructure, develop conservation programs, and identify innovative approaches to deliver water under changing conditionsโ.
Since the beginning of the Trump administration, President Trump has made delivering water to people a high priority. The administration has demonstrated a commitment to improving and enhancing water supply within the Colorado River Basin through investments in water storage, distribution, treatment, and improving water efficiency. Specifically in the Lower Basin investments over $3 billion have been made since January 2025.
In April 2026, the Secretary asked for feedback from the seven Basin States on potential water supply and conservation projects throughout the Colorado River Basin during a time of shortage. The administration continues to review the submittals and will work with the Basin States and Basin Tribes to identify opportunities to use available Working Families Tax Cuts funds, and other federal cost-share programs related to water storage and expansion and optimization; desalination and advanced water treatment; and water movement, exchanges and infrastructure.
Background
The NEPA process was initiated in June 2023. Over this three-year period the Department of the Interior and Bureau of Reclamation engaged extensively with Basin stakeholders and that input is reflected in the alternatives analyzed in the Final EIS and the Preferred Alternative of a Decision Framework that would guide future operational guidelines, released on July 31, 2026. The 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines and ROD released today further incorporate extensive feedback from Basin stakeholders. The Final EIS, ROD and 2027-2028 Operating Guidelines are available on Reclamationโs website.
For the past 26 years, the Colorado River Basin has been experiencing an unprecedented multidecadal drought, resulting in historically low runoff and reservoir levels. Conditions worsened during 2026, driven in part by the lowest observed snowpack on record during the winter of 2025-2026. Last week, Lake Mead reached a record-low elevation, highlighting the need for flexible operations that can respond to rapidly changing conditions across the Colorado River Basin.
A separate binational process addressing water deliveries to Mexico is nearing completion and the Department is committed to continued collaboration with Mexico. The Department will conduct all necessary and appropriate discussions regarding post-2026 operations and implementation of the 1944 Water Treaty with Mexico through the International Boundary and Water Commission in consultation with the Department of State.
The Colorado River provides water for more than 40 million people and generates hydropower for seven states. It serves as a vital resource for 30 tribes and two Mexican states, sustaining 5.5 million acres of farmland and agricultural communities throughout the West, while also supporting critical ecosystems and protecting endangered species.
Map of the Colorado River drainage basin, created using USGS data. By Shannon1 Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.0
At a Breckenridge Town Council work session Tuesday, Aug. 11, council member Dick Carleton requested public works staff lead a longer discussion examining whether the section of river starting at Skelly Pond could be lined to keep more water above ground. Carleton said a group of โinformed citizensโ approached him with concerns over the lack of water flowing through town…Phelps plans to return to council Tuesday, Aug. 25, with information about what it would take to install a continuous liner through that stretch of river and to gauge the councilโs interest in pursuing a design.ย
The riverโs current state, like nearly all other bodies of water across the West, is closely tied toย unprecedented drought conditions. Phelps said flows between the dredge pond all the way to Ski Hill Road have approached the lowest levels recorded during 42 years of recorded monitoring. The median flow for this time of year typically remains around 32 cubic feet per second, according to Phelps. In the last two weeks, flows have ranged from as low as 12 cfs to 22 cfs. Rain on Wednesday, Aug. 12, temporarily pushed the flow to about 22 cfs, but by the next day it had already fallen below 16 cfs.
Army Corps approves a permit for the Line 5 oil pipeline tunnel just as a state permit is invalidated.
NOAA finds that July was the warmest month in the countryโs 132-year historical record.
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service takes comments on draining farmland near protected prairie wetlands.
Two Senate Democrats introduce water system cybersecurity bill.
USGS reports on long-term changes in U.S. groundwater and surface water.
And lastly, the two big Colorado River reservoirs drop to all-time lows as the federal government prepares a new two-year operating plan.
โWhat can we do if the administration isnโt willing to allow us to use the [Glen Canyon Dam] bypass tubes for high-flow experiments, if thatโs going to be off the table, at least for a while?โ โ Wayne Pullan, Upper Colorado regional director at the Bureau of Reclamation, discussing Trump administration constraints on using Glen Canyon Dam to assist threatened fish in the Grand Canyon and rebuild eroded beaches along that stretch of the Colorado River. Earlier this month, Reclamation decided against a short-term release of cold water from deeper in Lake Powell to disrupt non-native fish spawning because the release would have reduced hydropower generation. โWeโre in a pinch point,โ Pullan added. โA real pinch point.โ
News Briefs
Line 5 Decision The Army Corps of Engineers approved a permit for Enbridge to build a tunnel beneath the Straits of Mackinac, a waterway that connects Lake Michigan to Lake Huron. The tunnel would house a new Line 5 oil pipeline.
The federal agencyโs decision is not the final word. State permits for the tunnel are being litigated and reversed. On July 31, the Michigan Supreme Court invalidated a state Public Service Commission approval because the commission did not properly assess project impacts or need.
Cybersecurity Bill Some two weeks after Iranian hackers allegedly targeted U.S. water utilities, two Senate Democrats introduced a bill to bolster water system cybersecurity.
The Water Cyber Shield Act focuses on risk reduction. It requires water systems to assess their cybersecurity risks, develop a response plan, and submit them for state approval. The submitted information is exempt from FOIA.
The bill also requires the EPA to establish baseline cybersecurity standards that impose more burdens on higher risk water systems. It authorizes $300 million annually over five years to help drinking water systems identify and fix vulnerabilities, as well as $300 million annually for wastewater systems.
According to NOAA data, it was the hottest single month since record-keeping began at the end of the Gilded Age, in 1895.
The average temperature for those 31 days was 76.9 F, which was 3.3 F above the 20th century average. It was especially warm in the Intermountain West, where states are also observing record-low river flows. [ed.emphasis mine]
Water Trends The West and the High Plains are drying while the Upper Midwest and Northeast are getting wetter.
That is the broad pattern identified in a U.S. Geological Survey evaluation of large-scale groundwater and surface water changes between 1980 and 2020.
On the Radar
Colorado Riverโs Shrinking Reservoirs Both Lake Mead and Lake Powell now sit at their lowest levels since the manmade reservoirs were first filled.
The record-breaking plunge underscores the precarity of water supplies in the Colorado River basin. Because this yearโs mountain snowpack has already melted, the reservoirs will likely set new lows through at least next April.
Lake Mead key elevations. Credit: USBR
Lake Mead is at 1,039 feet, four feet above the level at which hydropower generating capacity at Hoover Dam will drop by 70 percent.
Lake Powell rests at 3,519 feet. The Bureau of Reclamation is attempting to keep the reservoir above 3,500 feet to protect Glen Canyon Damโs water supply and power-generating infrastructure.
Draining, or Not Draining, Prairie Wetlands The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service took comments on the process for draining waterlogged lands for farming in an important duck habitat in the northern plains where the government holds wetlands easements.
Formed by retreating glaciers, prairie potholes are shallow ponds in Iowa, Minnesota, Montana, North Dakota, and South Dakota that sustain most of North Americaโs waterfowl. To protect the habitat, the FWS began buying easements from farmers in 1959. Those easements prohibit draining the wetlands.
To grow crops on sodden land, farmers install drain tile โ perforated pipes placed underground. Farmers whose land contains an easement can request the FWS calculate a distance beyond the wetlands where drain tile can be installed.
The agency wants to know how it should make those calculations.
Prairie-Pothole Region of North Dakota. Photo Credit: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service
This past week, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation posted an attention-grabbing statistic. By dropping to less than 25% of its capacity, Blue Mesa Reservoir has lost its status as the stateโs largest body of water. Lake Granby, itself just 62% full, now holds the title.
Recent best seller set in Iola and the West Fork of the Gunnison River. Click the image to read about it.
The ruins of Iola, a community flooded in the creation of Blue Mesa, are now visible. Parts of the Gunnison River snake through the lakebed in imitation of its historic path before the reservoir was dammed in the 1960s.
In a different year, the water storage unit that includes Blue Mesa might have helped replenish Lake Powell, the second-largest reservoir in the U.S., which nowย sits worryingly closeย to power pool. Power pool is the threshold when water levels drop too low to produce hydroelectric power…Thereโs no chance of Blue Mesa contributing much to Lake Powell this year, said Steve Pope, manager of the Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association…The Uncompahgre Valley Water Users Association relies on water stored in the Blue Mesa, which is diverted downstream through the Gunnison Tunnel to irrigate tens of thousands of acres of farmland. The communities of Montrose, Delta and Olathe also rely on raw water from the tunnel for municipal use.ย The association typically has a secondary water supply from the Uncompahgre River, but Pope said that source is โnonexistentโ this year. In anticipation of shortages, the association already limited users to 50% of their allocations this spring. Pope said he hoped no further restrictions would be necessary before Labor Day. Large row crop producers have already fallowed 30%-60% of their land in the valley, he said…
The Bureau of Reclamation has taken steps to avoid that scenario, said Caleb Foy, senior water resources engineer at the Colorado River Water Conservation District. Water managers were already anticipating a historically dry year this spring, when the window for the mountains to accumulate snowpack passed leaving the lowest amount ever recorded. Snowpack melts in spring to produce runoff, which feeds the Colorado River Basin. If the Bureau of Reclamation and water rights holders along the Gunnison River had not put restrictions in place, Blue Mesa might have been on a trajectory to drain past power pool, Foy said. The reservoirโs generators have an 86.4-megawatt capacity, enough to generate power for about 3,400 homes.