Data Dump: Abandoned oil and gas wells in #NewMexico: Also: Public lands continue to take a beating, despite one small victory — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

A serious mess, also known as the NE Hogback #53 well and associated infrastructure. Chuza, the most recent owner of the site in the Horseshoe Gallup oil field in northwestern New Mexico, went bankrupt. That left New Mexico and federal taxpayers holding the cleanup bill. The site has been partially reclaimed, but only partially. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

July 2, 2025

๐Ÿ›ข๏ธย Hydrocarbon Hoedownย ๐Ÿ“ˆย Data Dumpย ๐Ÿ“Š

A new report on New Mexicoโ€™s abandoned and orphaned oil and gas wells presents an alarming and expensive scenario for the state. It reveals that while the industry generates a lot of revenue for the state, cleaning up its mess is also poised to cost state and federal taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars. No, this report was not put out by an environmental or progressive advocates, but by the stateโ€™s legislative finance committee.

New Mexico has been an oil and gas hotspot for more than a century, during which drillers have sunk at least 121,000 wells, mostly in the San Juan and Permian basins in the northwest and southeast portions of the state. Newly drilled wells typically kick out a large volume of oil and/or gas during the first months after drilling, generating a lot of cash for their operators and for state coffers, and helping to push production numbers for the state through the roof.

Decline curve generated by decline curve analysis software, utilized in petroleum economics to indicate the depletion of oil & gas in a petroleum reservoir. By Richard Banks – Sent to me personally, GFDL, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=33914059

But the wells are soon afflicted with whatโ€™s known as the decline curve, meaning that the longer they pump, the less they pump. You know, itโ€™s kind of like aging in people. Eventually, aging will render all oil and gas wells into low-producing stripper wells (Iโ€™m not sure how this analogy extends to the human realm, but hey โ€ฆ) that kick out less than 10 barrels of oil per day. Thousands of New Mexico wells are extreme strippers, producing one barrel or less daily. Yet they continue to spew methane, hydrogen sulfide, and volatile organic compounds at the same as or an even higher rate than their younger, more vital counterparts.


A trip through a sacrifice zone: The Horseshoe Gallup oilfield — Jonathan P. Thompson


This is problematic for a number of reasons. For one, the operators of stripper wells are likely to be smaller, less financially secure companies, and itโ€™s easier and cheaper for them to keep the wells in a nearly inactive state โ€” during which the wells continue to ooze pollutants into the air and groundwater โ€” than to decommission, plug, and reclaim them. It may make economic sense to abandon these wells, or for the companies to cease to exist and โ€œorphanโ€ the wells, leaving them to the state or federal taxpayers to clean up, since reclamation bonds are woefully inadequate. And, finally, these wells generate almost nothing in production taxes, meaning that they arenโ€™t contributing much to the stateโ€™s conservation fund, a portion of which is used to clean up abandoned and orphaned wells.


Saga of an Oil Well (The Horseshoe Gallup Field Sacrifice Zone Part II) — Jonathan P. Thompson


The near constant drone of drilling for over a century has resulted in a near-constant addition of low- to non-producing wells to New Mexicoโ€™s rosters. While responsible and financially solvent companies plug and reclaim their own wells, many smaller operators simply walk away.

New Mexicoโ€™s Oil Conservation Division is currently responsible for plugging close to 1,000 abandoned and orphaned wells, including 700 on state or private land, and for remediation and reclamation of an additional 500 well sites and 18 infrastructure sites (such as leaky tank batteries).

Detail of interactive map showing orphaned, inactive, and low-producing wells on state and private land in the San Juan Basin (this leaves out hundreds of additional such wells on federal lands).

At recent rates, plugging them will take close to a decade, not including remediation/reclamation. OCD is also responsible for remediation and reclamation of an additional 500 well sites and 18 infrastructure sties. In total, plugging, remediation, and reclamation of all currently orphaned wells and infrastructure on state and private land is estimated to cost a minimum of $208 million, and likely more. And thatโ€™s just for now.

The report goes on to say: โ€œโ€ฆ in addition to wells the state already has legal authority to plug, thousands of inactive and low-producing wells are at risk of being orphaned, potentially increasing the stateโ€™s liability by many orders of magnitude.โ€ There are about 1,400 inactive at high risk of being orphaned on state and private land, according to the OCD. And there are thousands more that are extremely low-producing wells โ€” putting out less than one barrel of oil equivalent per day โ€” for which the โ€œexpected cost of cleanup far exceeds predicted future revenues, increasing their risk of being orphaned.โ€

And the kicker: โ€œAltogether, the stateโ€™s current and near-future liability for well plugging and site remediation is estimated to be between $700 million and $1.6 billion.โ€

More data from the report:

  • 38,817 Number of stripper wells, meaning they produce less than 10 barrels of oil-equivalent daily, in New Mexico, making up about 64% of the stateโ€™s active wells. This number will continue to increase.
  • $100,000 Average cost to plug single oil and gas well.
  • 450% Percent the average state-contracted cost to plug an oil and gas well in New Mexico has increased since 2019.
  • $250,000 Maximum amount of financial assurance an operator in New Mexico must post to cover the costs of plugging and reclaiming its wells. This cap applies whether the operator has five wells or 500 wells, meaning it actually provides almost no financial assurance whatsoever.
  • $46.4 million Amount spent by the New Mexico Oil Conservation Division to plug and reclaim 360 wells and associated infrastructure between 2019 and 2024.
  • 9% Percent by which the cost of plugging a gas well exceeds that of an oil well. Most of the wells in the San Juan Basin are gas wells.
  • $208 million Estimated cost to New Mexico to plug, remediate, and reclaim all existing orphaned and abandoned wells and infrastructure on state and private land.
  • $5.6 million Amount in financial assurance associated with orphaned wells or their operators, meaning most of the costs will be shouldered by the taxpayers โ€” either via the state reclamation fund or federal grants.
  • $66.7 million April 2025 balance of New Mexicoโ€™s oil and gas reclamation fund (which is funded by a portion of conservation tax revenues).
  • $6 million Tax revenue New Mexicoโ€™s 3,024 wells producing less than 1BOE/day would generate with the West Texas Intermediate oil price at $70/barrel (itโ€™s currently lower than that). Plugging and reclaiming those same wells would cost an estimated $531 million to $885 million. โ€œThe vast majority of the wellsโ€”87%โ€”are owned by private companies whose financial health is difficult for regulators to assess.โ€
  • $1.6 millionย Amount New Mexico paid in 2024 to plug six of Ridgeway Arizonaโ€™s wells under a 2023 settlement agreement with the company. Under the agreement, the state pays to plug 299 of the companyโ€™s wells, and the company reimburses the state $2 for each barrel of oil it sells, with a minimum payment of $30k per month. But at current rates, the total cost to plug the remaining wells could be $60 million or more, meaning it would take the company as long as 170 years to pay it off.

๐ŸŒต Public Lands ๐ŸŒฒ

By now youโ€™ve probably heard that Sen. Mike Lee pulled his public land sell-off provision from the budget reconciliation bill that the Senate just passed following intense backlash. And perhaps youโ€™re planning on celebrating the salvation of Americaโ€™s public lands on July 4.

Thereโ€™s so much BS in Leeโ€™s statement. How, for example, does selling public land to developers keep it from being ruined for the next generation? It doesnโ€™t, it just locks up that land for every generation except those that can afford to buy a house in the new subdivision that would go there. Public land is not โ€œlocked away from the people who live there.โ€ But it would be locked away if it was privatized. And while there is no property tax on public lands, there are federal payments in lieu of taxes, or PILT, which a county can use to fund schools and search and rescue operations. Plus, public lands generate billions in revenue for gateway communities through public land usersโ€™ sales and lodgers taxes and local spending.

Well, I hate to be Mr. Buzzkill, but while this victory may be sweet, it does little to offset the bitterness brought by continuing attacks on public lands, along with democracy, morality, decency, and, well, America, itself, this Independence Day week.

The โ€œBig, Beautiful Billโ€ perpetuates and amplifies the massive transfer of wealth from low- and middle-income and working-class Americans to the richest 10%. It will slash Medicaid and other vital programs Americans have paid into and rely upon, while also dismantling tribal sovereignty. And yet, it will also drive up the deficit by trillions of dollars due to additional spending on the military industrial complex, which is reaching its tentacles further into immigration enforcement, wildlife blocking border walls, deportations, and $450-million-per-year concentration camps. With Trump threatening to revoke citizenship from U.S.-born citizens whom he considers threats (e.g. Zohran Mamdani and Elon Musk), those camps may end up housing his political opponents. I really hate to make this comparison, but that is some severe Nazi-esque nastiness.

The Senateโ€™s bill gives more handouts to the oil and gas and coal industries, while revoking tax credits for wind and solar power, which could kill those industries when they are needed most.

And yes, some of you may cheer a weaker renewable-energy industry, since it will mean fewer utility-scale installations blanketing the desert. I get that. But it will also hurt rooftop solar and larger installations on big box stores, over parking lots, or in fallow agricultural land, brownfields or other appropriate sites. A western Colorado farmerโ€™s plan to install solar panels to generate electricity and shade his crops, for example, is imperiled by the GOPโ€™s plans.

This at a time when strain on the power grid is exponentially increasing due to the outsized demand of more and more AI-powering, hyperscale data centers. That power will come from somewhere, and if itโ€™s not solar or wind or batteries, then itโ€™s likely to be from pollution-intensive coal and natural gas (mined and drilled from public lands), fish-killing hydropower, or new nuclear reactors (that will require uranium mined from public lands).

And keep in mind, oil and gas leasing and mining claims represent a sort of quasi-privatization of public lands. Sure, the government retains title to the land, but the corporations get access to the minerals within, can rip the land apart to get to them, and can cut off public access with the necessary permits. With its accelerated 14-day โ€œenergy emergencyโ€ permitting process, the Trump administration is making it a heck of a lot easier for corporations to mine, drill, and otherwise develop public lands, sans public input. The latest beneficiaries include:

  • NorthWestern Energy, which was given the Bureau of Land Management green light to build aย 74-mile natural gas pipelineย between Helena and Three Forks, Montana.
  • Ormat got the BLM go-ahead to move forward on three separate geothermal projects in Nevada:
    โ€ข Exploration work at theย Diamond Flat projectย near Fallon;
    โ€ข Upgrades at theย McGinness Hills projectย in Lander County;
    โ€ข Exploration drilling at theย Pinto Geothermal Projectย near Denio.

Iโ€™m not suggesting that these are horrible projects that shouldnโ€™t have been approved. Geothermal holds a lot of potential as a relatively clean, round-the-clock baseline power source, and these are merely upgrades and exploration, not full on developments. Still, geothermal development and even exploration have impacts and can affect groundwater aquifers, springs, and wetlands. Land agencies should have as much time as it takes to adequately analyze potential effects, and tribal nations should be consulted and have time to do their own analysis. And if itโ€™s happening on public lands, then the public deserves to know about it and have an opportunity to weigh in. None of that is possible under this 14-day permitting process.

So, yeah, happy Fourth of July, yโ€™all and welcome to the Divided States of Project 2025. And on that note, the Land Desk will be taking the rest of the week off.


๐Ÿ“ธ Parting Shot ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

Just getting into the olโ€™ July Fourth spirit with this picture of Raymond “Squeekโ€ Huntโ€™s signs near his mutton meat slaughterhouse and shop in Waterflow, New Mexico. I mean, it does have an American flag in it, after all.

Western public land sale axed from Senate budget bill: #Utah U.S. Senator Mike Lee withdraws a plan that could have auctioned more than a million acres — Angus M. Thuermer Jr. (WyoFile.com)

This map shows land owned by different federal government agencies. By National Atlas of the United States – http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/fedlands.html, “All Federal and Indian Lands”, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32180954

Click the link to read the article on the WyoFile website (Angus M. Thuermer Jr.):

June 28, 2025

Utah Sen. Mike Lee withdrew his land-sale provision from the Senate reconciliation budget bill Saturday evening.

โ€œI was unable to secure clear, enforceable safeguards to guarantee that these lands would be sold only to American families โ€“ not to China, not to Blackrock, and not to any foreign interest,โ€ Lee posted on X. โ€œFor that reason, Iโ€™ve made the decision to withdraw the federal land sales provision from the bill.โ€

The Republican had sought to require the sale of Bureau of Land Management property โ€” owned by all Americans โ€” to help Western communities resolve affordable housing worries. Critics said existing laws allow such sales and that the measure violated a core western value โ€” public access to public land.

More than one million acres of public land were at stake. The provision required the government to auction the property rapidly and with curtailed public involvement.

Conservationists, hunters and anglers and outdoor recreation businesses erupted in virtual applause after Lee conceded. Opposition across the West stirred thousands to rally in support of continued ownership of and access to their publicly owned property.

โ€œPublic lands are the cornerstone of our conservation legacy,โ€ Chris Wood, president and CEO of Trout Unlimited said in a statement heralding the provisionโ€™s demise.

Others were less reserved.

โ€œTotal faceplant,โ€ wrote Land Tawney, co-chair of American Hunters & Anglers.

โ€œHe rewrote his scheme multiple times,โ€ Tawney said of Lee. โ€œAnd tonight? He yanked his own language from the bill,โ€ Tawney wrote in a statement.

Al Gore: Why #climate action is unstoppable โ€” and “climate realism” is a myth

Can fracking #wastewater be reused?: #NewMexicoโ€™s legislators are eager to repurpose โ€œproduced water,โ€ but environmental organizations say that there is no safe way to do that — Shi En Kim (High Country News)

A DEQ worker collects samples from Alkali Creek below where produced water from the Moneta Divide Field is discharged. (Wyoming DEQ)

Click the link to read the article on the High County News website (Shi En Kim):

June 9, 2025

On Oct. 2, 2024, a geyser erupted in Toyah, a town in west Texas 50 miles from the New Mexico border. This was not a case of water miraculously appearing in the desert, a deliverance from the areaโ€™s long-standing drought. Rather, it was an environmental disaster: a blowout from an orphaned oil and gas well.

What gushed from the ground wasnโ€™t actually water, but rather a vile brine of heavy metals, radioactive substances, chemical additives and noxious organics โ€” the by-product of fracking. 

The Toyah incident is the latest of at least eight leaks over the preceding 12 months in the Permian Basin, a fracking hub across west Texas and southeastern New Mexico. It highlights the increasingly urgent challenge of what to do with frackingโ€™s wastewater โ€” what fossil fuel companies euphemistically call โ€œproduced water.โ€ But some New Mexico legislators have a solution in mind: For the last few years, theyโ€™ve proposed reusing the wastewater off the oil field for industrial purposes, such as data center cooling and hydrogen production.

Part of their argument is that New Mexico desperately needs water. More than 90% of its residents live in areas facing drought. In the next 50 years, the already-arid state will see its ground- and fresh water sources shrink by 25%.

Political pressure is mounting on New Mexicoโ€™s lawmakers to tap into fracking wastewater as a new resource. Environmental groups, however, strongly oppose the idea, arguing that there is still no way to make the wastewater safe for off-field use. Year after year, the New Mexico Legislature finds itself at a crossroads.

โ€œWe are, as a state, very beholden to oil and gas,โ€ said Carlos Matutes, the New Mexico director at the advocacy group GreenLatinos thatโ€™s part of the coalition opposing produced water reuse. Any bill that sanctions produced water, he said, โ€œis almost guaranteed to come back.โ€

PRODUCED WATER is an existential dilemma for the oil and gas industry. Fracking involves blasting underground rock with water to free up trapped oil and gas, but when that water returns to the surface, it is laden with contaminants it picks up from the earth. Every barrel of hydrocarbons reaped also generates up to 10 barrels of contaminated water. In 2021 alone, New Mexico was spewing 147 million gallons of toxic wastewater daily.

Drilling companies usually dispose of wastewater in dedicated injection wells. Water, however, does what water always does: It flows where it wishes, heedless of human-drawn boundaries. And it can travel for miles underground, then burst forth from improperly sealed oil wells, as it did with Toyah. (So far, no company has claimed ownership of the well, though its use dates back to 1961.) Even wastewater that stays underground finds ways to revolt โ€” by triggering earthquakes. As fracking operations have ramped up over the last decade, so too has the tally of tremors. In the past year alone, New Mexico experienced over 2,500 quakes, most of them concentrated in the southeastern corner of the state, where fracking is most flagrant. In comparison, only 45 tremors rumbled the state in 2017.

Currently, most of New Mexicoโ€™s produced water is either injected underground or transported across state lines for disposal elsewhere. By contrast, neighboring Texas permits repurposing treated wastewater for other uses or discharging it into the environment.

Produced water. Graphic credit: U.S. Department of Energy

In late 2023, New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham floated a strategic water supply proposal to follow in the footsteps of its neighbor. Initially, she proposed investing $500 million of state funds in treating produced water. But that measure dried up in legislative budget negotiations. In subsequent revisions, Lujan Grisham has watered down the funding allocation, from $250 million in 2024 to $75 millionin 2025. Each time, pushback from environmental groups helped flush produced water treatment from the proposals altogether.

Even if the plan had sailed through, though, it would not have recouped a significant amount of water, said Rachel Conn, the deputy director of the water conservation organization Amigos Bravos. Removing contaminants from fracking wastewater requires copious energy to boil off and squeeze fresh water from dissolved toxins. Her team estimates that it costs at least $2 to treat a barrel, twice as much as it costs to send it down an injection well. The total amount could easily top $1 billion a year. (In Texas, oil companies pay more, as much as $10 per barrel for treatment.) Given the high costs, Conn said that the amount of water the strategic water supply could afford to treat would meet no more than 1% of New Mexicoโ€™s water needs โ€” a literal drop in the bucket.

Additionally, environmental organizations like Amigos Bravos have raised concerns about the safety of fracking wastewater, whether itโ€™s treated or untreated. Radioactivity levels around several injection wells in Ohio and West Virginiaexceed the federal safety limit by several hundred-fold; and in one Pennsylvanian river, radium still persists among mussels even five years after the last discharge of produced water.

The complex cocktail of chemicals found in produced water makes it hard to characterize, said Bonnie McDevitt, a research physical scientist at the U.S. Geological Survey. Companies usually guard the chemical additives in their fracking fluid as a trade secret. Toxicity requirements cannot cover every contaminant present, essentially leaving some questionable compounds completely unregulated. That means that even if the treated wastewater technically meets drinking water standards, it may not necessarily be safe to drink. Environmental advocates are calling for testing limits on 600 compounds potentially found in fracking wastewater before it can be used off fracking fields.

But the fossil fuel industry insists that the treatment technology is ready; Ryan Hall, the director of technical operations at NGL Energy Partners, said, โ€œWe can treat to any spec.โ€ As one of the nationโ€™s largest handlers of the industryโ€™s wastewater, his company manages 2.5 million barrels from the Permian Basin, mainly by disposing of it in injection wells. NGL Energy has also explored wastewater treatment in some states, and Hall said it is eager to start in New Mexico once authorities give the legislative greenlight.

The New Mexico Produced Water Research Consortium, which is partially funded by oil and gas companies, is currently leading the effort to develop purportedly safe and affordable treatment methods. The instituteโ€™s recent projects include advancing various separation technologies and studying the health impacts of produced water on indicator species, like aquatic microbes and plants. โ€œIโ€™m with the environmental groups,โ€ said Pei Xu, the instituteโ€™s research director and an environmental engineer at New Mexico State University. โ€œWe also want this water to be very safe. I think we have made a lot of very good progress.โ€

THE BATTLE BETWEEN industry and environmental groups is heating up. In April, New Mexicoโ€™s Water Quality Control Commission announced that it would allow pilot treatment projects to discharge up to 84,000 gallons of wastewater into groundwater daily. Environmental groups filed court briefs and staged a protest outside the Capitol, and 27 state legislators wrote a letter to the commission urging it to reconsider. In a follow-up hearing on May 13, the commission rescinded its April decision and reinstituted the ban.

What environmental groups want, ideally, is to end fracking altogether. But thatโ€™s unlikely to happen anytime soon: New Mexico is economically dependent on oil and gas, ranking second in the nationโ€™s top fossil fuel-producing states. Industry has a solid grip on politics here โ€” roughly 60% of Lujan Grishamโ€™s 2017-2022 campaign contributions came from the stateโ€™s largest oil corporations.

At the very least, environmental groups say, taxpayer dollars shouldnโ€™t be used to solve a problem of the industryโ€™s own making. โ€œIt should be the industryโ€™s responsibility to clean up that produced water,โ€ Conn said. Her suggestion: Reuse the wastewater for future fracking. About 60% of wastewater is recycled on oil fields; Conn says bumping the rate to 90% could save 4 billion gallons of fresh water โ€” more than all the produced water that the strategic water supply proposal would treat.

Active Permian Basin pumpjack east of Andrews, Texas. By Zorin09 – Own work, CC BY 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=14607474

Meanwhile, drilling shows no signs of slowing down. Across the Permian playa, pumpjacks rise like giant birds pecking at the ground. Strewn alongside these steel flocks are miles-deep injection wells, each designated by a comparatively squat wellhead that often comes in the shape of a cross โ€” a headstone for an otherwise unmarked grave for the vast refuse that refuses to go quietly.

Environmental groups protest outside New Mexicoโ€™s Capitol after the state announced it would allow pilot treatment projects to discharge up to 84,000 gallons of wastewater into groundwater daily. Courtesy of New Energy Economy

#Utah U.S. Senator Mike Lee pulls his public land sell-off bill after serious backlash — Jonathan P. Thompson (BlueSky)

Sen. Mike Lee pulls his public land sell-off bill after serious backlash. That's what happens when you try to hand Americans' land to developers.

— Jonathan Thompson at the Land Desk (@landdesk.bsky.social) 2025-06-29T04:23:31.940Z

โ€˜Like taking Smokey Bear away from the Forest Serviceโ€™: President Trump’s Administration proposes consolidating wildland firefighting into single agency — Summit Daily News

The Grizzly Creek Fire burning along the Colorado River on August 14, 2020. By White River National ForestU.S. Forest Service – https://www.facebook.com/GrizzlyCreekFireCO/posts/128313015469678, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=93777078

Click the link to read the article on the Summit Daily News website (Ryan Spencer). Here’s an excerpt:

June 26, 2025

[Colorado U.S.] Senator John Hickenlooper is looking into the proposal to create a U.S. Wildland Fire Service and what it could mean for wildfire response and resources

President Donald Trumpโ€™s 2026 budget proposal outlines plans to create a new U.S. Wildland Fire Service by combining the wildfire assets currently distributed between the U.S. Forest Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the Bureau of Land Management and the National Park Service. The budget request states that the โ€œdispersed natureโ€ of the federal wildfire program โ€œcreates significant coordination and cost inefficiencies that result in sub-optimal performance.โ€ It would house the U.S. Wildland Fire Service in the Department of Interior. But in a letter to the Senate earlier this month, a nonprofit group representing thousands of U.S. Forest Service retirees, including seven previous chiefs of the agency, raised concern that consolidating federal firefighting operations would be โ€œa costly mistake.โ€

โ€œWildfire management is more than extinguishing fires,โ€ National Association of Forest Service Retirees Chair Steve Ellis wrote in the letter. โ€œThe critical linkage between fire suppression and forest management, including fuels reduction and prescribed fire, must be maintained. Severing forest management and forest managers from fire suppression will make firefighting less safe and put communities at greater risk.โ€

In addition to relocating firefighting operations, Trumpโ€™s budget request for the Forest Service asks Congress to zero out millions of dollars of funding, including for forestry research and grants that support state, tribal and private forestry efforts. It also proposes cuts of $392 million to the Forest Service management budget and $391 million to forest operations…Ellis, who worked for the federal government for 38 years in both the Forest Service and the Bureau of Land Management, said โ€œthe fire program is integrated into almost everything the Forest Service does.โ€ From forest thinning to prescribed burns, prevention and suppression, Ellis said strategies have to be integrated into the broader forest management goals. By removing firefighting operations from the Forest Service, the proposal could divorce firefighting from land management, he added…

When asked about the U.S. Wildland Fire Service proposal, White House Assistant Press Secretary Taylor Rogers pointed to the Los Angeles wildfires that killed 30 people, forced 200,000 to evacuate and burned 57,000 acres earlier this year…But Ellis questioned whether a consolidated federal firefighting agency like the U.S. Wildland Fire Service would have done anything to prevent or lessen the impacts of the Los Angeles fires. In his experience, Ellis said the fire program in the United States is โ€œpretty seamlessโ€ with different agencies not only working with each other but also collaborating with state and local partners to combat wildfires.

Romancing the River: The Empire Strikes the Public Lands, Part 3 — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com)

Credit: Sibley’s Rivers

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

June 24, 2025

There it is again โ€“ the invocation for most of the 20th century. But โ€“ wait: arenโ€™t we in the 21st century? Well, really โ€“ not yet in any way that matters. President Biden tried, through his big beautiful legislative acts (two of them), to nudge and cajole us into the early 21st century: beginning to commence to proceed to address the scientific reality of a climate that our created realities have been inadvertently changing for the worse, and the socioeconomic realities of an increasingly inequitable society that unbridled private capitalism has been advertently imposing on us all. But Bidenโ€™s acts no longer address our official realities.

The new official reality, which wants to take us back to the good old days of the mid-20th century, includes a full restitution of the fossil energies (including beautiful clean coal) that, a mere seven months ago, we were told we needed to stop using as soon as we possibly could for the sake of our continued existence on the planet. Trump may have missed a couple โ€˜first dayโ€™ promises โ€“ low grocery prices and peace in the Ukraine โ€“ but one first-day promise he did fulfill was issuing an executive order on January 20, 2025 for โ€˜Unleashing American Energy,โ€™ colloquially known as โ€˜Drill, baby, drill.โ€™

Therein, Trump explained that โ€˜in recent years, burdensome and ideologically motivated regulations have impeded the development of these (fossil) resources,โ€™ inflicting โ€˜high energy costs upon our citizens โ€ฆ driving up the cost of transportation, heating, utilities, farming, and manufacturing, while weakening our national security.โ€™ Trump proclaimed that this constituted a โ€˜National Energy Emergencyโ€™ caused by President Biden and other liberals obsessed by a โ€˜climate crisisโ€™ that is now, almost magically, no longer an official part of American reality.

Biden-era policies, according to this MAGA narrative, kept energy development off of the public lands by โ€˜locking the lands upโ€™ for conservation, preservation and recreation, making Bidenโ€™s administration responsible for our high gasoline and home-heating prices. And the Trump administration was going to reverse that by reopening the public lands for the O&G industry to drill new wells, increasing the supply of gas and oil to both bring down O&G costs and re-establish Americaโ€™s global energy dominance โ€“ a dominance in O&G production that we already in fact have.

Trumpโ€™s Interior Secretary Doug Burgum followed this up February 3, 2025 with a seven-page order revoking all of President Bidenโ€™s energy-related executive orders dating back to 2021, and replacing them with orders specific to โ€˜drill, baby, drill.โ€™

But there is a problem they are not acknowledging, however: is the O&G industry really going to get out there and โ€˜drill, baby, drillโ€™? The truth, as usual with Trump, lies elsewhereโ€ฆ.

Letโ€™s take a look at how the leasing process goes, on our Bureau of Land Management lands (with similar rules on the National Forests):

  • First, someone from the public โ€“ usually someone from the O&G industry โ€“ expresses interest in a piece of land for oil or gas production. The BLM then has to prepare a lease sale for that land. Biden rules put in force last year (now rescinded) restricted this to lands with some probability of actual O&G resources in the land.
  • Once requested lands are mapped into lease units (maximum lease 2,560 acres in the lower 48 states, 5,760 acres in Alaska), the BLM holds quarterly auctions to lease the mapped units. The 2024 rules (now rescinded) raised the minimum bid from $2/acre to $10/acre, and also declined to sell the leases when there was no competitive bidding.
    The leases are for 10 years (renewable in some cases), with rental at $3/acre for the first two years, $5/acre for the next six years, and $15/acre for any year thereafter โ€“ obvious incentive to get a lease into production.
  • Before leaseholders can do anything on the land, they need to put up a bond to cover the cost of closing-off and site reclamation when they abandon the well (after 4 years with no action). The minimum bond was increased in 2024 from $10,000 to $150,000, making forfeiture painful (now rescinded).
  • When leaseholders are ready to โ€˜developโ€™ a lease, they apply for a drilling permit. If their drilling plan is approved by the BLM (more than 95 percent are), they pay a permitting fee (minimum $10,000) and can then โ€˜drill, baby, drill.โ€™ Biden rules (now reduced again) charged a 16.67 percent royalty to the government on what they produce.
  • Oil wells can be operated as long as they are profitable, with lease extensions. When they are no longer producing enough to profitably cover lease rent plus operating expenses, the company owning the lease is responsible for closing down the well and restoring the land.

Did the โ€˜Biden-eraโ€™ government โ€˜shut downโ€™ this leasing and permitting process, โ€˜locking outโ€™ energy development, as the Trump administration and the O&G industry claim? Hardly; thatโ€™s just more Trumpty-Dumpty fake news. Anyone with a cultural memory that goes back further than 2025 will remember that environmental interests were constantly haranguing the Biden administration to stop the leasing on public lands, since it undermined the administrationโ€™s other efforts to address the climate crisis, which was then officially part of our reality, like it or not. It is also part of our reality, however, that our need for gasoline and natural gas has not diminished much, and Biden had to work for a balance no one liked. Anyone wanting to revisit the kind of pressure from both sides that Biden and his Interior Department encountered on such issues could look at this AP story about leases in Alaskaโ€™s far frozen north.

Thereโ€™s a more important fact (remember โ€˜factsโ€™?) to keep in mind about the leasing situation, however, and Trumpish complaints that the government is blocking our energy dominance on the planet: 25 million acres of public land are currently reserved in O&G leases, but at least a third of that, maybe more, is in leases that have not been developed. Let me say that again: the O&G industry already holds several thousand leases that it has not begun to bring into production.

Two questions rise: Why are they not developing these leases on which they are paying rent? And why are they agitating for even more leases?

The answer to the first question is the most obvious: they do not want to bring more wells into production because the price of a barrel of oil has been dropping below their industrial break-even price of around $65/barrel. Energy production is governed to some extent by a calculation called the ER:EI โ€“ โ€˜Energy Return on Energy Investment.โ€™ In the good old days of 30-cents-a-gallon gasoline, oil was โ€˜gushingโ€™ abundantly from wells. The ER:EI of oil then ranged from 20:1 upward, depending on how fast it flowed and how far it had to go to market โ€“ meaning 20 barrels were produced for every barrel-equivalent of energy invested.

The miracle of โ€˜frackingโ€™ opened up vast new regions from which oil could be squeezed, but fracked oil does not gush; instead it has to be freed from rock formations with complex and expensive drilling and pumping procedures. The ER:EI of fracked petroleum and natural gas is 5:1 or often lower. The O&G frackers need barrel prices above $65 to even begin making a profit.

Recent rumors of war in the Mideast have pushed the price up to the $70-75/barrel range, but that is a fluctuating situation that will not be reflected at the gas pump. And that may be countered by the OPEC+ nations (all the Arabian nation-states plus Russia and a handful of other non-Arabian states), who just upped the ante. They still have oil they can access at an ER:EI significantly above that of the United States frackers โ€“ and they recently voted to increase their production June 1 by an additional 411,000 barrels a day, which pretty well insures that the global prices of a barrel will not go up to where United States frackers will want to start developing the thousands of leases they are paying rent on. Unless, perhaps, Trump decides to put a tariff on OPEC oil and gas, with all the political chaos that would create โ€“ including driving up the price of gasoline and heating gas here.

So therein lies the truth about who is responsible for persisting higher gas prices: it wasnโ€™t the Biden administration shutting off opportunities; it was the O&G industries refusing to develop low-cost public-land opportunities they already owned โ€“ not wanting to produce oil and gas at a loss as a patriotic MAGA gesture. America has no more โ€˜cheapโ€™ oil with the massive profitability of a high ER:EI.

But at any rate, if we do actually have a โ€˜national energy emergency,โ€™ it is certainly not going to be resolved by putting a lot more public land up for leases to โ€˜unleashโ€™ Americaโ€™s fossil energy, with more than a third of the public land already leased but not developed due to low energy prices. A January lease offer โ€“ Bidenโ€™s last โ€“ in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge had no bidders.

So why the big push for more public lands leasing?

Well, in Trumpland it may not be about lower prices for consumers at all, but about industrial control in the public lands. An O&G lease, so long as the rent is paid โ€“ pocket change for the industry โ€“ amounts to a priority use on public lands managed for multiple uses. So long as a lease remains undeveloped, it canโ€™t be fenced; it is open for grazing cattle, hikers, bikers and other โ€˜multiple-usersโ€™ to wander over. But the O&G company has the priority use on the land, and if it decides to develop the lease, the surface land needed for the drilling and pumping operations becomes single-use land, with a road leading into it โ€“ no longer really โ€˜publicโ€™ or โ€˜multiple useโ€™ for so long as the well operates.

As noted in the leasing and permitting process outlined above, the drilling company has to put up a bond assuring that it will properly shut down and plug the well and reclaim the area when the well runs out. The historic $10,000 bond was so low that companies found it cheaper to just forfeit the bond and leave it leaking methane into the atmosphere, polluting the underground water table, and surrounded by the refuse from the fracking operation. The Biden administration raised the bond for a permit to drill to $150,000, about twice the current average reclamation cost, and enough to make some miners/drillers to think twice about just abandoning the well. Now, of course, that Biden-era move toward good sense is being rescinded.

How many โ€˜orphaned wellsโ€™ are there (abandoned with little or no reclamation)? No one seems to know for sure. The EPA estimates there are as many as four million abandoned wells nationwide, most plugged to some degree with known owners and operators; but some 100-150 thousand of the abandoned wells are orphaned โ€“ no financially solvent owner-operator can be found, and many of those are not plugged, and are emitting methane into the atmosphere and oil and toxic fracking fluids into water tables. Those numbers are more guesstimates than estimates, and no one really knows how many of the orphaned wells are on public lands, but we taxpayers will end up paying to plug, clean up and maintain the orphans, as (chronically inadequate) budgets allow (2024 information).

There may be another rationale behind the O&G industriesโ€™ desire for more leasing and permitting, when they arenโ€™t developing a third of what they already have. There is a huge overlap between the 90 percent of BLM land that is open for O&G leasing at the request of the industry, and the BLM land that is suitable for the development of the massive solar, wind and geothermal renewable energy resources that will be needed when American reality again encompasses the climate crisis. Leasing processes have been worked out for renewable energy development โ€“ somewhat more rigorous than those for the O&G industry โ€“ and many of the suitable sites find an O&G lease right in the middle of them, with its undeveloped use priority. The developers of the renewables have to buy surface-use waivers from the O&G leaseholders โ€“ unless the O&G leaseholders donโ€™t want to give up the chance to develop their non-renewables.

Well โ€“ enough said on this. I hope this disabuses you of the Trumpty-Burgumty nonsense about a โ€˜national energy emergencyโ€™ that can be resolved through a wide-open assault on our public lands. Thatโ€™s the good news; the bad news is the fact that gasoline at the pump is probably never going to go down much, so long as a barrel of oil has to bring more than $70 to the fossil-fuel producer.

An intelligent and forward-looking society would be working to gently and fairly phase out the truculent O&G industries, and phase in the renewable energy resources with a lot of job creation โ€“ which the Biden administration, now seemingly maligned by everyone, was actually trying to do with the two big beautiful infrastructure acts that the Trumpty-Burgumties are trying to rescind as thoroughly as possible, for no discernible reasons other than their own โ€˜creative reality,โ€™ and of course, with Trump, vengeance on his enemies.

The Trumpty-Burgumty teams have come up with some other plans for the public lands, including selling off some of them โ€“ a lemon from which it might actually be possible to squeeze some lemonade, depending on how it shakes out. More about that in the future, when we see if it stays in the Big Piggy Billโ€ฆ.

Next post โ€“ back to the Colorado River where, believe it or not, things are pretty much still where they were a year ago โ€“ which is to say โ€˜a standstillโ€™ โ€“ at least in terms of a new management plan for the post-2026 era. Stay tuned.

Oil and gas infrastructure is seen on the Roan Plateau in far western Colorado. (Courtesy of EcoFlight)

The secret double life of americaโ€™s public lands: And why you should know about it if you drink waterโ€ฆ — ย John Zablocki (AmericanRiver.org)

Middle Fork Snoqualmie River, Washington | Monty Vanderbilt

Click the link to read the article on the American Rivers website (John Zablocki):

January 21, 2025

Public lands are the birthright of every American. One of the great privileges of living in this country is the ability to access hundreds of millions of acres to enjoy the great outdoors โ€” all for free.

People care about and use public lands for many reasons. From hunters and anglers to miners and ranchers, hikers and mountain bikersโ€”there is something for almost everyone on public lands. But what if you live in a city and never set foot on public lands?  Why care about them then?

Log Meadow, California | Maiya Greenwood

Not everyone hunts, fishes, mines, ranches, hikes, or bikes; but everyone, truly everyone, depends on clean water. The big secret about public lands is that they are arguably the countryโ€™s single biggest clean water provider. According to the US Forest Service, National Forests are the largest source of municipal water supply in the nation, serving over 60 million people in 3,400 communities across 33 states. Many of the countryโ€™s largest urban areas, including Los Angeles, Portland, Denver, and Atlanta receive a significant portion of their water supply from national forests.

Healthy forests and grasslands perform many of the functions of traditional water infrastructure. They store water, filter pollutants, and transport clean water to downstream communities. And they do it naturally โ€” essentially for free. When rivers are damaged from land uses on public lands, we all pay the price โ€” literally; we all pay more in taxes and utility bills to clean up the water.

What happens on the publicโ€™s land also happens to the publicโ€™s water. The importance of managing public lands for the benefit of public water is so fundamental, it has been a pillar of public lands management agenciesโ€™ missions since their inception over a century ago. For example, The Organic Act of 1897[1]ย that created the US Forest Service stated:

As Wyoming protests, public land sell-off โ€˜just getting startedโ€™: #Utah U.S. Senator Mike Lee trims plans, calling targeted BLM land โ€˜unused,โ€™ โ€˜mismanagedโ€™ and โ€˜only appropriate for housing.โ€™ — Angus M. Thuermer Jr. (WyoFile.com)

A two-track road cuts through Bureau of Land Management property west of Pinedale in April 2024. (Mike Koshmrl/WyoFile)

Click the link to read the article on the WyoFile website (Angus M. Thuermer Jr.):

June 25, 2025

In the face of a backlash, Utah Republican Sen. Mike Lee has revamped his public land sell-off measure to target only Bureau of Land Management holdings while also declaring, โ€œweโ€™re just getting started.โ€

A reconciliation budget proposal revised by Leeโ€™s Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee targets BLM land within five miles of undefined โ€œpopulation centers.โ€ It puts checkerboard BLM holdings back on a priority list for his โ€œmandatory disposalโ€ measure and takes lands under permit for grazing off the auction block.

The revision would shift 15% of revenue to local governments and conservation. The bill would appropriate $5 million to carry out the mandatory sales, which are designed to be offered within 60 days of passage and regularly thereafter.

Lee has not said or mapped how much land must be sold, ostensibly for affordable housing.

โ€œWe havenโ€™t put out maps because there are a whole bunch of criteria established by the legislation, and those criteria are very difficult to reduce to a map,โ€ Lee told conservative radio host Charlie Kirk in a video posted on X.

But opposition to Leeโ€™s measure comes from โ€œall walks of life,โ€ said Land Tawney, former president and CEO of Backcountry Hunters and Anglers. That includes โ€œDemocrats, Independents, Republicans, hunters, anglers, bird watchers, kayakers, ranchers [and] loggers,โ€ he said Wednesday at a roundtable hosted by Democratic U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico.

Heinrich excoriated Leeโ€™s measure.

โ€œEighty-five percent of the money from these sales would go to pay for tax cuts,โ€ Heinrich said. โ€œThat means that folks like Elon Musk, who already own[s] 4,400 acres of land in Texas [worth] some $3.4 billion, will make money off the public lands that should belong to the American people.

โ€œThatโ€™s horseshit,โ€ Heinrich said.

A spectrum of opposition

Leeโ€™s plan to include U.S. Forest Service land in the โ€œmandatory disposalโ€ provision flunked a parliamentarianโ€™s rules test that limits reconciliation budget measures to relevant budget matters. The revised provision must undergo the same scrutiny, Democrats say.

Heinrich poo-pooed the notion that Leeโ€™s measure would result in affordable housing. โ€œAn out-of-town billionaire can show up, buy a 100-acre parcel and throw a trophy home on it,โ€ he said.

Powell resident Mike Tracy criticized Leeโ€™s linking of public land and affordable housing.

โ€œIf you put those two concepts in the same sentence,โ€ he said of Leeโ€™s proposal, โ€œit makes them seem somehow related, maybe even somehow causal.

โ€œIt makes people not feel comfortable speaking out against it because who wants to be against affordable housing?โ€ he said at the roundtable. โ€œI donโ€™t think itโ€™s proper to say that theyโ€™re related.โ€

U.S. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto, a Democrat from Nevada, had a message for Lee. โ€œDonโ€™t come into our states and dictate what should be done.

โ€œIt is clear theyโ€™re trying to sell this public land to pay for this reconciliation package, which gives tax cuts to billionaires,โ€ she said. โ€œThatโ€™s what this is about.โ€

โ€œRight now, we are pissed,โ€ said hunting advocate Tawney, who represented American Hunters and Anglers. โ€œThey want to defund, dismantle and then divest,โ€ he said of President Donald Trumpโ€™s administration.

Native American tribes are upset, too, said Hilary Tompkins, former solicitor for the Department of the Interior.

โ€œThe Southern Ute Indian tribe in southwestern Colorado is concerned because they have off-reservation hunting and fishing rights on an area that includes BLM lands,โ€ she said. โ€œThey have not heard from anyone who is advocating for this proposal about the impact on those off-reservation treaty rights.โ€

Wyoming Gov. Mark Gordon sees opportunities to resolve the stateโ€™s challenges with the checkerboard land ownership pattern along the Union Pacific Railroad line, said Jess Johnson, government affairs director with the Wyoming Wildlife Federation.

โ€œI want to figure out how we do this in a Wyoming way,โ€ she said of the checkerboard conundrum. โ€œThis budget reconciliation is not it.โ€

Not sensitive lands?

Wyomingโ€™s U.S. Sens. John Barrasso and Cynthia Lummis, Republicans who continue to support Trumpโ€™s agenda, did not respond Wednesday to requests for comment about the backlash. โ€œIt is clear that our congressional delegation isnโ€™t in it for Wyoming,โ€ the stateโ€™s Democratic Party chair, Lucas Fralick, said in a statement.

Lee, however, explained some of his thinking.

โ€œIโ€™m working closely with the Trump administration to ensure that any federal land sales serve the American people โ€” not foreign governments, not the Chinese Communist Party, and not massive corporations looking to pad their portfolios,โ€ he said in a post. โ€œThis land must go to American families. Period.โ€

In the radio interview, he said opposition was ginned up.

American Enterprise Instituteโ€™s proposed Freedom City sites on BLM land near Grand Junction, Colorado.

โ€œThe left is working overtime to dupe conservatives about my federal land sale bill,โ€ he said. โ€œThis is just basically surplus land thatโ€™s suitable for housing because itโ€™s right next to where people live.โ€

He characterized critics as having an agenda. โ€œWhat Iโ€™ve heard is that people on the left generally want people moving from rural areas into urban areas, more suburban areas and from single-family housing into multi-family housing, higher density housing units,โ€ he said. โ€œThey believe that thatโ€™s good for them, perhaps for Mother Earth, or whatever their reasons might be.

โ€œThese are not sensitive lands,โ€ Lee said of the targeted BLM parcels. โ€œThey are not lands that are out there, that are part of an environment thatโ€™s appropriate for hunting, for hiking, for fishing, etc.โ€

Wyomingโ€™s Johnson challenged that notion at the roundtable. She said she arrowed her first mule deer on public land near town.

โ€œI was on this amazing parcel of public land โ€” tiny,โ€ she said. โ€œItโ€™s little. Itโ€™s one to three miles from Lander. Itโ€™s BLM. Itโ€™s really nothing special to look at, except it is everything to me.โ€

This map shows land owned by different federal government agencies. By National Atlas of the United States – http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/fedlands.html, “All Federal and Indian Lands”, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32180954

Tribal leaders rally support for Chaco Canyon, citing threats from President Trump’s energy policies — AZCentral.com

An image of the ruins of Chetro Ketl in Chaco Canyon (New Mexico, United States); shown is the complex’s great kiva. By National Park Service (United States) – Chaco Canyon National Historical Park: Photo Gallery, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=1536637

Click the link to read the article on the AZCentral website (Arlyssa D. Becenti). Here’s an excerpt:

June 25, 2025

Key Points

  • The National Congress of American Indians passed a resolution seeking new protections for Chaco Canyon in New Mexico.
  • The group says the Trump administration wants to rescind an administrative order that created a 10-mile buffer around Chaco Canyon, barring oil and gas drilling for 20 years.
  • The resolution has renewed a rift between other tribes and the Navajo Nation, which says the 10-mile buffer could cost local residents royalties from gas and mineral extraction.

The oldest and largest organization representing tribal governments is urging action to protect Chaco Canyon from oil and gas leasing, amid what its leaders say are growing threats from the Trump administration’s energy policies. The National Congress of American Indians passed a resolution urging action to restart efforts to protect Chaco Canyon and the public lands surrounding it, and to pass the Chaco Cultural Heritage Area Protection Act, which would create a permanent 10-mile buffer zone around the site restricting oil, gas and mineral extraction. Trump has ordered federal agencies to prioritize energy and mineral extraction on public lands. Supporters of the buffer say that a shift in policy risks damage to Chaco Canyon, but residents with land allotments in the region argue that the buffer could deprive them of an income. With the resolution, the NCAI joins other tribes, elected officials and environmental organizations opposing a proposal to revoke Public Land Order 7923, which withdraws approximately 336,404 acres of federal land from new oil and gas leasing within a 10-mile area around Chaco Canyon for 20 years…

On June 6, New Mexicoโ€™s senators and congressional delegation sent a letter to Interior Secretary Doug Burgum expressing support for the 10-mile buffer zone around Chaco Canyon. Sens. Martin Heinrich and Ben Ray Lujรกn, along with Reps. Melanie Stansbury, Teresa Leger Fernรกndez, and Gabe Vasquez, all Democrats, signed the letter, which voiced concern over the Interior Department’s move to begin revoking the public lands order…The letter said Interior has yet to adequately consult tribal nations on Chaco Canyon protections. A May 9 letter from the Bureau of Land Management, an Interior agency, announced a general tribal consultation for May 28, 2025, which gave less than 30 daysโ€™ notice and was short of the departmentโ€™s own consultation standards. The letter also claimed that many affected Pueblos were not directly notified, and that BLMโ€™s informal virtual presentation lacked the detail and structure needed for meaningful dialogue or informed tribal input According to the bureauโ€™s own estimates, the 10-mile withdrawal area protects approximately 4,730 documented archaeological sites while oil and gas operators forgo development of only a few dozen wells, stated the letter.

The Navajo Nation is embroiled in a lawsuit against Haaland and the Interior Department, filed in a New Mexico federal court three days before President Donald Trump took office. The suit argues that Interior’s plan to withdraw land from new oil and gas leasing violated the law and could cost land allottees millions of dollars in royalties.

The official National Park Service map for Chaco Culture National Historic Park. By United States National Park Service – http://www.nps.gov/chcu/index.htm, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=111458973

BREAKING: #Utah Senator Mike MAGA Lee changes public land sell off bill — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Condors perched on steel girders some 450 feet above the Colorado River. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

June 24, 2025

๐ŸŒต Public Lands ๐ŸŒฒ

Sen. Mike Lee, the Utah Republican and Trump sycophant, has slightly backed off on his proposal to sell-off public lands, but only slightly. 

Lee posted the following on X/Twitter at 5:42 a.m. today:

Big sigh of relief? Nope. Sure, itโ€™s great heโ€™s removing Forest Service land from the pool of land eligible for โ€œdisposal.โ€ This means the Hidden Valley/Falls Creek areanear Durango is out of danger, as are parcels near Flagstaff and Boise and Santa Fe that could have ended up on the auction block under the original provision. The 5-mile limit from population centers will also take some remote BLM parcels out of consideration โ€” parcels that wouldnโ€™t have been prioritized, anyway. 

The change reduces the size of the pool of available land, and presumably also reduces the amount of land that would be sold to between 1.25 million and 1.9 million acres. Thatโ€™s still a crap-ton of public lands that will be privatized, cluttered up with houses and roads and cul-de-sacs and power lines and so forth, and to which the public will lose access. If this goes forward, you can plan on houses popping up on some of your favorite hiking, trail-running, or biking areas. 

And it still includes places like:

  • Animas Mountain and upper Horse Gulch near Durango;ย 
  • swaths of BLM land near Naturita and Nucla, Colorado;ย 
  • BLM land, including wilderness study areas, near Moab (wilderness study areas and areas of critical environmental concern are not exempted from the sell off);
  • parcels that abut Zion National Parkโ€™s boundaries (within five miles of Springdale and Rockville);
  • the lower slopes of Jumbo Mountain near Paonia;ย 
  • parcels on Las Vegasโ€™s fringe, along with tracts around Mesquite and Moapa that the Freedom Cities folks have their eyes on;ย 
  • other Freedom City-proposed parcels near Fruita and Grand Junction;
  • the list goes on and on. (To get an idea just check out the Wilderness Society map, ignore the green areas, and look for โ€œpopulation centersโ€ around the brass-colored areas to see what might be eligible).

Freedom Cities are back! — Jonathan P. Thompson

Lee says he will protect ranchers, which may or may not mean his provision would again leave out land that is in active grazing allotments. He doesnโ€™t explain what the hell he means by โ€œFREEDOM ZONES,โ€ except to imply that he wouldnโ€™t let any foreigners buy the land(?). Lee once again doesnโ€™t mention a damned thing about affordable housing, meaning heโ€™s just fine with public lands being used for luxury developments or even multi-million dollar mansions. 

Oh, and then thereโ€™s that little aside about the Byrd Rule. Yeah, that might get in Leeโ€™s way. See, the Senate parliamentarian ruled that the public land sell off provision, along with several other sections relating to energy development on public lands, were subject to a 60-vote threshold. This means they would likely be dropped from the reconciliation bill altogether, since leaving it in could sink the entire โ€œBig Beautifulโ€ whatever. Still, the GOP has a thing about ignoring the parliamentarian and the usual rules, and Lee indicated he would push on with this concept in one form or another. So now is not the time to back down. 


The public lands sell-off provision has generated a huge amount of outrage and public push back, which is clearly working (after all, why else would Lee make those changes?). But itโ€™s not the only or even the worst thing the MAGA folks are inflicting on the American publicโ€™s lands. 

For example, yesterday Agriculture Secretary Brooke announced that the U.S. Forest Service plans to repeal the Clinton-era Roadless Rule, which blocks roadbuilding and other development on about 58 million acres of Forest Service land. If the rollback survives inevitable legal challenges, it will open up a lot of forest to logging.


Glen Canyon Dam, January 2022. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
๐Ÿฅต Aridification Watch ๐Ÿซ

To be a Colorado River watcher is to ride a slow-motion emotional roller coaster. We reached extreme highs during the late 1980s and into the 1990s, fell into a two-decade depression beginning in 2002 โ€” with ebullient spikes in 2005, 2008, 2011, 2019 โ€” and then the bountiful winter of 2023 came along and was followed up by a not-so-sad 2024.

It was enough to convince us we were recovering, and we could quit therapy, cut back on the meds, and stop worrying (all figuratively, of course). During this period of relative abundance, all of the studies about climate heating diminishing snowpacks and threatening the Westโ€™s lifeline seemed a bit abstract: Scary, sure, but we still had years and years before it manifested itself.

Yeah, no. It turns out that 2023 was just another manic and anomalous episode that falsely lulled us into complacency. And now that it has past, weโ€™ve been sent spiraling back down into a deep aridification-sparked depression (somewhat figuratively speaking).

The snowpack-meagre 2025 winter delivered the first buzzkill to the Upper Colorado River Basin, followed by a warm and dry and dismal spring. Now, Lake Powellโ€™s surface level is flatlining just as it should be shooting upward, an indicator that the river is back to its new normal. That is to say it is once again shrinking, and the gap between how much water has been allocated to the riverโ€™s users and whatโ€™s actually in there continues to grow. Which is to say, weโ€™re still f&$#ed, and getting even more so with each passing year.

In fact, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s latest projection has Lake Powell possibly dropping below the minimum power pool, or the level at which hydropower production shuts down, as soon as the end of 2026. Mind you, thatโ€™s their worst case scenario, but these forecasts often lean towards optimism. Most notable is how dramatically the forecast has changed since April, a difference that is visible in the graph below.

Inside #Utahโ€™s PR campaign to seize public lands: Utah used actors, AI, stagecraft and NDAs as it sought to sway public opinion and take control of 18.5 million acres of federal public land — Jimmy Tobias (High Country News)

Part of a promotional video the campaign ran last year.ย Stand For Our Land Utah/YouTube screenshot

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Jimmy Tobias):

June 17, 2025

This story was published in partnership with Public Domain.

Last year, as Utah prepared to file a federal lawsuit aiming to take control of millions of acres of federal public land within its borders, state officials sought help swaying public opinion in their favor. So they turned to a group of public relations professionals at Penna Powers, a media and branding firm based in Salt Lake City. 

Backed with a commitment of more than two million in tax-payer funds, the firm sprang into action. One of the early orders of business was studying the opposition. In June 2024, an assistant attorney general sent an email to numerous state government colleagues and Penna Powers staffers that contained a video from the Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership (TRCP) in which the well-known hunter and media personality Randy Newberg described the dangers of transferring federal land to state control. โ€œIt doesnโ€™t matter how many promises are made,โ€ warned Newberg, โ€œthe financial realities would force states to sell off our public lands.โ€ 

Noting that organizations like TRCP are good at connecting with โ€œtraditionally conservativeโ€ audiences, the Utah official told his colleagues that โ€œour PR efforts will largely depend on how well we can anticipate and effectively respond to these expected criticisms.โ€ 

โ€œThat definitely helps us know what we need to counter the opposition,โ€ added Redge Johnson, director of Utahโ€™s Public Lands Policy and Coordinating Office, or PLPCO, which has played a central role in organizing the stateโ€™s campaign to seize federal land.  

Throughout 2024, Penna Powers put together an elaborate PR and media campaign to do just that โ€” counter the opposition and build support for Utahโ€™s efforts. They churned out videos, newspaper ads, social media spots and more. They hired actors, ran focus groups and helped prominent Utah politicians write talking points. In at least one instance, Penna Powers relied on AI to help create voice-overs in videos. In another instance, PLPCO staffers warned Penna Powers not to use too much scenic imagery in the campaign for fear it might undermine their efforts. They called the campaign โ€œStand for Our Land,โ€ and those who worked on it were required to sign non-disclosure agreements. โ€œThe Office of the Attorney General is taking this NDA extremely seriously,โ€ wrote one government official. 

Hundreds of records reviewed by Public Domain shed light on the key players involved in this campaign and the strategies they used to persuade the public in their favor. Among other themes, their campaign relentlessly portrays the federal government as an absentee landlord that mismanages land and cuts off access to the public domain. Utah, on the other hand, is painted as a benevolent force working to ensure public land access. The campaign โ€” like the lawsuit it was meant to support โ€” seeks one principal outcome: federal land disposal. Utah has identified some 18.5 million acres of federal land within the stateโ€™s boundaries that are currently administered by the Bureau of Land Management on behalf of all Americans โ€” and it wants those lands for itself.  

Penna Powers, meanwhile, landed a big pay day. The contract between the PR firm and PLPCO runs until 2029 for a total cost of some $2.6 million. 

In response to queries, PLPCO in a written statement said that,โ€œUtah believes in protecting access to public lands for all users of all ages and abilities, and we are committed to actively managing these lands for generations to come. Utah is home to five national parks, several national monuments, and many other natural wonders. The state has always welcomed, and will continue to welcome visitors from around the world to visit and enjoy all that this great state has to offer.โ€ Penna Powers did not respond to requests for comment. 

Meanwhile, critics of the Utah PR effort called it a โ€œpropagandaโ€ campaign meant to mislead Utahns and the general public. 

โ€œPenna Powers worked hand-in-hand with the state of Utah to craft a misleading message about the stateโ€™s land grab lawsuit,โ€ said Kate Groetzinger, communications manager at the Center for Western Priorities, a conservation group. โ€œThey made it seem like forcibly taking ownership of public lands would help recreationists and ranchers, when the real goal of this lawsuit was to increase extraction and privatize national public lands in Utah. This campaign is the very definition of propaganda โ€” misleading political messaging paid for by taxpayers.โ€

UTAHโ€™S EFFORT TO take control of federal lands kicked off in earnest in 2012, when Utahโ€™s then-Governor Gary Herbert signed into law the Utah Transfer of Public Lands Act, demanding state control of the majority of federal public land in Utah. โ€œThis is only the first step in a long process,โ€ Herbert said at the time, โ€œbut it is a step we must take.โ€ In 2018, Senator Mike Lee, a leading proponent of the land transfer movement, shared similar sentiments during a speech to the conservative Sutherland Institute in Salt Lake City. The campaign for land transfer, he said, โ€œwill take years, and the fight will be brutal.โ€ Indeed, just last week, Lee put forward a proposal in the GOPโ€™s massive reconciliation bill that would force the sell off of millions of acres of federal land in the Western U.S. 

Utahโ€™s actions to seize control of federal land have only grown more aggressive as the years have progressed. In August last year, it filed a lawsuit directly with the Supreme Court seeking to strip federal ownership over some 18.5 million acres of BLM land within Utah. It claims these lands are โ€œunappropriated,โ€ a novel argument meant to create a legal distinction between national parks, forests and monuments, and large swaths of BLM land across the West. If successful, Utahโ€™s lawsuit would deprive the vast majority of Americans of their ownership stake in such BLM lands. Tribal nations, meanwhile, have been staunch opponents of Utahโ€™s lawsuit, which the Ute Indian Tribe described as an โ€œexistential threatโ€ to the tribe and its reservation lands. 

In January this year, the Supreme Court declined to hear Utahโ€™s case. It remains unclear whether Utah will refile its lawsuit in lower court, but its efforts to seize federal land are a generational project. 

Regardless, Utah, faces a major public opinion hurdle. A large majority of Western voters are opposed to the idea of state control over federal public lands, according to Colorado Collegeโ€™s annual polling. Even in Utah, some 57% of voters oppose public land transfers. That is where Penna Powers comes in. The firm worked to reshape public opinion in the stateโ€™s favor, with a focus on building support among Utah residents as well as key decision makers at the national level. 

โ€œThe Stand for Our Land public education campaign is informing Utahns about the management of public lands, and how federal agencies are restricting access to public lands and ignoring local concerns,โ€ wrote PLPCO in a statement. โ€œThe Bureau of Land Management closed over 2,000 miles of Utah roads on public lands in the past two years.โ€

A centerpiece of Penna Powersโ€™ effort has been glossy videos that portray federal land agencies as an exclusionary force bent on keeping people off the public domain. In one video, Penna Powers and PLPCO hired a voice actor to portray a  โ€œdisabled camperโ€ in a wheelchair on a camping trip with her family. โ€œBecause of my disability I need to reach campsites in a motorized vehicle,โ€ the actor said. โ€œIf I lose road access, I lose the ability to do something I love with my family. Thatโ€™s why I think Utah should be managing Utah land.โ€ The actor who was selected to voice the video does not appear to use a wheelchair or mobility aid in social media posts and other records reviewed by Public Domain. PLPCO appears to have had many of those involved in its video shoots also sign NDAs. A talent agent for the actor in question did not provide comment at the time of publication. 

Redge Johnson, the executive director of PLPCO, was particularly keen on the โ€œdisabled camperโ€ storyline, among others. He asked about a video that combined the โ€œdisabled camperโ€ story with one about an off-highway vehicles  business. โ€œI really want that video in the folder, it tells a great story,โ€ he wrote to Penna Powers staffer Allyse Christensen, who worked on the Stand for Our Land campaign. 

Others, like disability community advocate Syren Nagakyrie, said Utahโ€™s use of a โ€œdisabled camperโ€ storyline to promote its political agenda is โ€œdisingenuous.โ€ 

WESTERN PUBLIC LANDS ARE HABITAT FOR ARIDLAND BIRDS This map shows the cumulative range for 30 aridland bird species in North America, with the vast majority of that range falling within the boundaries of federal and state public lands. Source: Aridland bird data from Bird Conservation Regions, Bird Studies Canada and NABCI. Public lands map from GISGeography.com.

Trump appointee, a Jackson Hole consultant, IDโ€™d pitfalls of #Wyoming managing its federal land: Tapped for Bureau of Land Management post, Brenda Younkin will report directly to agencyโ€™s acting director, Jon Raby — Mike Koshmrl (WyoFile.com)

Brenda Younkin was tapped for a Bureau of Land Management post in the Trump administration. (photo illustration by Tennessee Watson/WyoFile)

Click the link to read the article on the WyoFile website (Mike Koshmrl):

June 20, 2025

Not unlike the current moment, roughly a decade ago a political push to do away with large swaths of federal lands in the West was gaining steam. 

Utah Republican U.S. Rep. Jason Chaffetz ran a bill at the time that would have transferred 3.3 million acres of the federal estate to state ownership. The bill was later pulled, and the representative resigned his congressional seat after the proposal whipped hunters and anglers into a fury. 

The movement crossed state lines into Wyoming. During state lawmakersโ€™ 2015 general session in Cheyenne, a legislative committee drafted a bill that demanded the transfer of vast tracts of federal lands to Wyoming. Later, the measure was amended to require a study of Wyoming managing federal lands, not owning them.

The Wyoming Office of State Lands and Investments was ultimately given $75,000 for the study, and it picked Jackson-based Y2 Consultants to complete the analysis. When the 357-page study was completed the following fall, state land managers and lawmakers were warned that they lacked staff and resources to take over control of 25 million acres of Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Forest Service and Bureau of Reclamation property that fell within state boundaries.

A two-track road cuts through Bureau of Land Management property west of Pinedale in April 2024. Such tracts of public land could be on the chopping block because of federal budget reconciliation text that seeks to sell between 2-3 million acres of the federal estate. (Mike Koshmrl/WyoFile)

โ€œUltimately, without significant changes to federal law, the greatest challenge would be that the state would be inheriting the same bureaucratic maze of overlapping, entwined, often conflicting federal mandates established in the labyrinth of laws and directives laid out by Congress,โ€ the 2016 Y2 Consultants report stated. โ€œThe land management trials, conundrums, and conflicts encountered would largely be the same for the state that exist under present [federal] management.โ€

The first author listed on the report, a slot that typically denotes the lead, was Brenda Younkin, a natural resource specialist who co-founded Y2 Consultants with her husband, Zia Yasrobi. 

On Wednesday, Politicoโ€™s E&E News publicized that Younkin had been appointed by the Trump administration and had started working in a senior advisor post at the Bureau of Land Management, where sheโ€™d report to its acting director, Jon Raby. Trumpโ€™s first pick to lead the BLM, Colorado oil and gas advocate Kathleen Sgamma, withdrew her bid after it was revealed that sheโ€™d written a memo expressing โ€œdisgustโ€ for โ€œPresident Trumpโ€™s role in spreading misinformation that incitedโ€ the Jan. 6, 2021 riot at the U.S. Capitol. 

WyoFile was unable to reach Younkin for an interview Friday, but an auto-response from her Y2 Consultants email address confirmed a โ€œleave of absenceโ€ because of a new gig with the U.S. Department of the Interior, the BLMโ€™s government parent.

The Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s 245 million surface acres, depicted in yellow in this map, account for about 10% of the United Statesโ€™ landmass. (Library of Congress)

According to her biography and past interviews, Younkin has worked in the public lands and ranching sphere her entire career. 

In statements made to the Cowboy State Daily, U.S. Sens. Cynthia Lummis and John Barrasso both lauded Younkinโ€™s appointment. 

โ€œThe more Wyoming voices we can have in the room, the better off we will all be,โ€ Barrasso told the outlet. 

Younkin joins a handful of other Wyoming residents whoโ€™ve gone to work for the Trump administrationโ€™s Interior Department via political appointments, or who have been nominated for positions. 

Wyoming Game and Fish Director Brian Nesvik speaks at a Game and Fish Commission meeting in Douglas in September 2024. (Mike Koshmrl/WyoFile)

In early February, former Wyoming Game and Fish Department Directorย Brian Nesvik was nominated to directthe U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, though four months later his appointment has still not cleared the Senateโ€™s confirmation process. Cyrus Western, a former Republican statehouse representative, wasย picked to helm the U.S. Environmental Protection Agencyโ€™sย Region 8 office, based in Denver. Cheyenne attorney Karen Budd-Falen was alsoย selected as the acting deputy secretaryย under Interior Secretary Doug Burgum.ย 

Last, southwestern Wyoming big game hunting advocate Josh Coursey was appointed to a Fish and Wildlife Service post, pulling him away from the Muley Fanatic Foundation, which he co-founded. That group has since gone on record opposing a provision expected to be yoked into the so-called โ€œOne Big Beautiful Bill Actโ€ that would mandate the sale of an estimated 2-3 million acres of federal land in 11 western states. 

โ€œPublic lands need to stay in public hands and the Muley Fanatic Foundation opposes anything or anyone that threatens our lands that we hold dear for personal use,โ€ President and CEO Joey Faigle told WyoFile in a written statement. โ€œThe public land sales being included in the reconciliation needs to stop now.โ€

If the public land sale mandates donโ€™t stop, the amount of land that Younkin, the Jackson Hole consultant, will be tasked with overseeing at the Bureau of Land Management will shrink. 

The disposal language in the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources legislative text demands selling between 0.5% and 0.75% of the BLM and U.S. Forest Serviceโ€™s 438 million surface acres within the next five years. Although just a fraction of the agenciesโ€™ overall holdings, itโ€™d translate to doing away with public lands that collectively add up to an area no smaller than Yellowstone National Park.

War, Inflation and Now #Drought Are Hitting Global Food Supplies: Staples including wheat, beef and coffee are all being affected by the lack of rainfall. In some cases, prices are climbing to record highs — The New York Times

Egeria Creek [May 2017] flows into the Yampa River. Photo/Allen Best

Click the link to read the article on The New York Times website (Somini Sengupta). Here’s an excerpt:

June 21, 2025

War, tariffs and inflation are not the only things driving up the price of food. Widespread drought is also looming over what people around the world eat. In Brazil, parched coffee farms have affected latte prices everywhere. In the Midwestern United States,ย years of poor rainshave led ranchers to cull cattle herds and have raised beef prices toย their highest levels ever. In China, one of the nationโ€™sย key wheat-producing regions,ย the Yellow River Basin, is withering under unusually hot, dry conditions. Germany had itsย driest spring since 1931, though rains in recent weeks have allayed concerns about its wheat and barley crops. Ukraineย andย Russia, rivals on the battlefield, are also facing the threat of drought for their wheat crops. Both countries are breadbaskets for millions of people far and wide. Morocco, for instance, now in its sixth year of drought, has relied increasingly on wheat imports from Russia. Droughts are part of the natural weather cycle but are exacerbated in many parts of the world by the burning of fossil fuels, which is warming the world and exacerbating extreme weather. Droughts can be particularly risky as the production of important foods becomes increasingly concentrated. For example, much of the worldโ€™s coffee comes from Brazil, cacao from Ivory Coast and Ghana in West Africa, and corn from Brazil, China and the American Midwest…Around the world, most people get their calories from three staple grains โ€” rice, wheat and corn โ€” which means that weather hazards to places where they are produced can have big repercussions for food security. Bad weather in one or two of those regions can destabilize the global supply…

Sandwiches, instant noodles, rotis. Wheat, in all its forms, has become one of the worldโ€™s most commonly eaten grains, second only to rice. That makes it one of the most closely watched crops in the era of extreme weather. Wheat is also often closely guarded. Take India, for instance. Prompted by an intense heat wave in 2022, the Indian government banned wheat exports in order to stockpile it at home…

Summer barbecue season is approaching just as the price of beef has topped records. Ground beef in the United States is close to $6 per pound, and steak is nearly twice that…A few factors are driving the price rise, including soaring insurance costs for farmers and the abiding demand for beef. But central to the rising cost of beef is a drought that has stretched across the Midwestern United States over the past several years. The conditions have dried up a lot of grazing land. Cattle herd numbers are at their lowest in 70 years.

#Utah U.S. Senator Mike Lee revives public land sell-off bid: A parcel near you may one day be covered in houses — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Hidden Valley on National Forest land near Durango, Colorado. This is the type of parcel that could be on the auction block if Sen. Mike Lee gets his way. Photo credit: The Land Desk

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

June 13, 2025

It is not hyperbole to say we are living in dark times.

The U.S. President is about to hold a multi-million-dollar, taxpayer-funded, dictator-style military parade โ€” for his frigging birthday. He activated the national guard and the marines to violently quell non-violent protests in Los Angeles. A U.S. senator was tackled, thrown to the ground, and handcuffed for deigning to ask a question of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem during a press conference in which she admitted that federal troops were in Los Angeles not to stop rioting, but to โ€œliberate the city from the socialists and the burdensome leadership that this governor and that this mayor have placed on this country.โ€ Oh โ€ฆ

American democracy, morality, empathy, civil liberties, and the rule of law are all under attack, and the assailants are none other than the President, his administration, and a vast majority of congressional Republicans.

So when Sen. Mike Lee, the Jello-slurping Utah MAGA-ite, proposed selling off a mere one half of one percent of the nationโ€™s public land, it might not seem worth squandering whatever remains of oneโ€™s outrage on. But we โ€” as in the American people โ€” stand to lose a lot from this latest push to take public lands out of the publicโ€™s hands.

Lee installed his amendment into the Energy and Natural Resources section of the so-called โ€œBig, Beautiful Bill,โ€ which proposes to rescind environmental protections on millions of acres in Alaska, slash royalty rates for oil and gas, and revive noncompetitive leasing, among other mining- and drilling-friendly provisions.

Leeโ€™s provision would require the Interior Secretary to โ€œselect for disposal not less than .50% and not more than .75% of Bureau of Management land, and shall dispose of all right, title, and interest of the United States in and to those tractsโ€ and the Agriculture Secretary shall select for disposal .50% to .75% of National Forest System.โ€ Lands in national parks, monuments, or conservation areas, wilderness, wildlife refuges, and other protected areas would not be eligible for disposal.

While thatโ€™s a tiny fraction of the nationโ€™s public lands, it adds up to between 2 million and 3.2 million acres, which on the upper end is about equivalent to Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments combined. The amendment would apply to every Western state except Montana, which was probably exempted in the hopes of winning Rep. Ryan Zinkeโ€™s support.

While the amendment is purportedly to free up more land for affordable housing, there is nothing in the text restricting the end use of the land after itโ€™s sold or transferred. It only requires someone nominating a parcel to specify what they plan to use land for and the extent to which development of the tract would address local housing needs (including housing supply and affordability).

It would prioritize tracts for disposal that are:

  • nominated by states or local governments
  • adjacent to existing developed areas
  • have access to existing infrastructure
  • suitable for residential housing
  • would reduce checkerboard land patterns
  • inefficient to manage.

At first glance, this appears relatively harmless: It would merely consolidate private holdings on the urban fringe, and ease the management nightmares of checkerboard land-ownership. But this is where I urge you to think about your favorite public land-adjacent community and consider what might parcels might be prioritized for disposal.

I went through this exercise somewhat inadvertently recently as I rode my bike on a trail through a place known as Hidden Valley on National Forest land north of town. The valley floor is nearly perfectly level, having been carved by a glacier many millennia ago, and bounded on two sides by bone-white sandstone cliffs. Up until the fifth century A.D., Pueblo people inhabited and farmed the valley, and the area continues to hold cultural and archaeological significance. Grass โ€” green during this time of year โ€” covers much of the valley. Cattails, nourished by the waters of Falls Creek, jut from the northern end.

Durango folks come up here to walk and seek solace from the din of humanity. They walk and bike and in the winter even ski and snowshoe here and coexist โ€” sometimes uneasily โ€” with bears and mountain lions and deer and elk and even rattlesnakes.

That this tract of public land would be sold off for development is almost unthinkable. And yet, it fits all of the criteria: It is just a few miles from town, is sandwiched between existing residential areas, is easily accessible and quite buildable, and infrastructure is already in place. Durango is grappling with a severe housing affordability crisis and Hidden Valley could theoretically support hundreds of housing units, alleviating some pressure on the real estate market. Unthinkable to you and I, yes. But keep in mind that it would be the Trump administration calling the shots on this one.

There are hundreds of other Hidden Valley-like tracts of land across the West, pieces of public land near communities that provide all kinds of benefits to wildlife and humans and the ecosystem and solitude. And if Mike Lee has his way, 3 million acres of these special places would go on the auction block, ultimately to be covered with homes, affordable or otherwise, and other development.

This map shows land owned by different federal government agencies. By National Atlas of the United States – http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/fedlands.html, “All Federal and Indian Lands”, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32180954

Spring #runoff peaks, winners announced: Also: About that energy dominance thing — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

San Juan Mountain foothills and sunset from the window of a plane. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

June 10, 2025

๐Ÿฅต Aridification Watch ๐Ÿซ

Iโ€™m calling it! Spring runoff appears to have peaked on most Western streams โ€” and almost definitely has done so on the streams in this yearโ€™s Land Desk Super Predict the Peak Contest. 

The good news is, the runoff was later and bigger than a lot of folks โ€” including myself โ€” predicted it would be. The bad news is that the flows were still downright pathetic compared to other years, even though in most cases the peak snowmelt was supplemented by heavy rain, meaning the runoff numbers donโ€™t necessarily reflect a healthy snow year. Which is to say: The megadrought persists across much of the Western United States, with extreme conditions in the Southwest. 

Here are the results:

Unfortunately, we had very few entries this year, possibly because these things are really hard to predict. That said, it looks like Andrew High has a winning formula, at least on a few of these stream segments. Here are the winners and their predictions:

  • Animas:ย Andrew High, 2,710 cfs on May 21.
  • North Fork:ย Andrew High, 1,260 cfs on June 7.
  • Rio Grande:ย Jim Oโ€™Donnell, 1,150 cfs on May 15.ย 
  • San Miguel:ย B Frank, 692 cfs on May 15.ย 
  • Colorado:ย Andrew High, 13,160 cfs on June 13.

Congratulations, winners! Andrew, B, and Jim, please send me your mailing address and t-shirt size at landdesk@substack.com and Iโ€™ll get your prizes in the mail ASAP. 

Now, on to the not so happy news. What a difference a year can make. Last year at this time, the West seemed to be on its way to being drought-free, with the exception of New Mexico. Now? Not so much. Itโ€™s looking downright grim for New Mexico, Arizona, and southern Nevada, even though the Las Vegas area received a healthy dose of rain in May.

Source: National Drought Monitor.

And, after a couple years of respite, itโ€™s time once again to start worrying about Lake Powell โ€” the barometer of the Colorado Riverโ€™s health. Thus far this year, the volume of water flowing into the reservoir has been far lower than last year, which already was below normal. Judging by the runoff patterns so far, it appears as if Juneโ€™s inflows may be even lower than Mayโ€™s. If the rest of June is hot and dry, prompting greater evaporation from the reservoir, it could actually draw reservoir levels down this month during a time when water levels normally would rise.

The black bars show inflow volumes for the 2025 water year compared to the red bars for 2024. Source: USBR.
Normally Lake Powellโ€™s surface level would jump substantially over the next month or so before dropping later in the summer after all of the mountain snowpack has completely melted. While reservoir levels are currently rising, it likely wonโ€™t continue for long. Source: Lake Powell Water-Data

But one of those truths about the West, is that aridification provides no buffer against flooding โ€” especially flash-flooding. Some hikers found that out the hard way last week when a flash flood ripped down Big Horn Canyon in Utah, stranding them on the opposite side of the arroyo from their vehicle. They called for help and Bureau of Land Management rangers and Garfield County deputies responded and rescued the folks, according to the BLMโ€™s Utah office. The Escalante River nearby jumped from 0 cfs to 1,200 cfs in just minutes around the same time. You can see some video of the flash flooding here: http://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1036784068519285


๐Ÿ“ˆ Data Dump ๐Ÿ“Š

As long as weโ€™re doing the graphs and charts thing, we might as well check in on that olโ€™ Trumpian โ€œenergy dominanceโ€ thing. The rig count โ€” which is a snapshot of the number of rigs actively drilling at any given time โ€” is the most accurate indicator of the oil and gas industryโ€™s enthusiasm to extract the fossil fuels. And that verve appears to be waning under Trump. The number of rigs operating in the West has dropped since Trump took office, and is down significantly from the most recent peak in 2023 when, yes, Joe Biden was president and was supposedly waging a โ€œwarโ€ on fossil fuels.

The red and blue shades indicate Republican and Democratic administrations, respectively. Source: Baker Hughes.

MAGA intensifies its assault on public lands — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Public lands in Bears Ears National Monument. The Trump administration has indicated it may attempt to shrink the monumentโ€™s boundaries once again, potentially removing this area near White Canyon from heightened protections. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

June 4, 2025

๐ŸŒต Public Lands ๐ŸŒฒ

Even before public lands lovers were still celebrating one small victory โ€” i.e. killing a budget bill amendment that would have sold off a half-million acres of federal holdings in Nevada and Utah โ€” the MAGA/Trump/GOP launched a multi-pronged assault on the places Americans hold dear.

The blows come from all three branches of the federal government and seem to be designed to unravel the nationโ€™s framework of environmental protections that have been developed over the last 50 years and more. Meanwhile, the Trump administrationโ€™s proposed 2026 budget would gut the agencies that oversee public lands and the programs aimed at stewarding them. Hereโ€™s a breakdown of just some of the attacks:

Oak Flat, Arizona features groves of Emory oak trees, canyons, and springs. This is sacred land for the San Carlos Apache tribe. Resolution Copper (Rio Tinto subsidiary) lobbied politicians to deliver this National Forest land to the company with the intent to build a destructive copper mine. By SinaguaWiki – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=98967960
  • The Supreme Court rejected Apache Strongholdโ€™s bid to block a land swap at Chiโ€™chil Biล‚dagoteel, akaย Oak Flat, in central Arizona, clearing the way for Resolution Copperโ€™s massive mine on sacred ground.
  • SCOTUS also overturned a lower courtโ€™s decision to block federal approval of a proposed Utah railway that would ship Uinta Basin oil alongside the Colorado River and across multiple states to larger markets. More significantly, the ruling also limited the scope of federal environmental reviews to the direct impacts of a proposed project. This means the relevant federal agency need not consider effects of upstream oil and gas drilling facilitated by the railway, or those of processing and burning the oil downstream. The ruling will make it easier for corporations to build pipelines, highways, major oil and gas projects, and so forth.
Excerpt from the Supreme Courtโ€™s decision on SEVEN COUNTY INFRASTRUCTURE COALITION ET AL. v. EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADO, ET AL.
  • The U.S. Interior Department egregiously fast-tracked its approval of the Velvet-Wood Mine in Utahโ€™s Lisbon Valley and promised to do the same for similar projects on federal lands to address a purported โ€œenergy emergency.โ€
  • Interior alsoย expedited permittingย for geothermal energy developments on federal lands, beginning with three projects in Nevada.
  • Interior Secretary Doug Burgum โ€” whose original appointment was endorsed by none other than outdoor retailer REI (remorsefully, it turns out) โ€” moved to roll backย protections on 13 million acresย of wilderness-quality lands on Alaskaโ€™s North Slope, reopening it to oil and gas drilling, mining, and other development.
  • Sen. Mike Lee, the Utah Republican who apparently still holds Jell-O socials in his office every Wednesday, said he plans toย revive the public land sell-offย provision in the budget bill. So much for dodging that bullet!
  • The Trump administration has granted FAST-41 status to Laramide Resourcesโ€™ proposedย La Jara Mesaย andย Crownpoint-Churchrockย uranium mines in New Mexico. The designation is aimed at streamlining permitting for the contested projects in the Grants area. However, the FAST-41 program does not compress the environmental review or licensing process as radically as the BLM did for the Velvet-Wood mine. The Environmental Impact Statement likely wonโ€™t be completed until next November.

Public land sell-off amendment is a test — Jonathan P. Thompson

And then thereโ€™s the Trump administrationโ€™s proposed 2026 budget. A while back I gave a more general overview of the budget and the deep, deep cuts to almost everything except for defense, border security and Trumpโ€™s golf trips. Now we have more detail in the form of the Technical Supplement to the 2026 budget.

Just like the overview, it would would tear apart the nationโ€™s social safety net, set back science, destroy Americaโ€™s global standing, erode education, eviscerate the federal workforce, rob communities and low-income households of vital funding, gut dozens of federal agencies, generally weaken regulatory oversight, and even transfer some national park units to states. You can read my take on that one here.

The Trump Budget Blues — Jonathan P. Thompson

Yet the budget still increases the federal deficit โ€” even Elon Musk calls it an โ€œabominationโ€ (harsh words coming from the guy who brought us the vehicular abomination known as the cybertruck) โ€” because it would hike spending to more than $1 trillion for the military industrial complex and the Department of Homeland Security. It would slash funding for nuclear energy research, but spend an additional $11 billion annually to build more nuclear weapons.

This time, Iโ€™ll focus on public lands (and related bureaus under the Interior Department and the USFS) because we only have so much space in these emails, and I only have enough self-medication to handle so much outrage and anxiety. Comparisons are between the 2024 actual expenditures and proposed spending for 2026. This is merely a sampling of some items that really stood out.

Cuts for the Bureau of Land Management:

  • 1,157 full-time-equivalent staff positions (or about 20% of the entire full-time workforce)
  • – $216 million for personnel compensation
  • – $45 million for recreation management
  • – $17 million for energy and minerals
  • – $65 million for workforce and organizational support
  • – $30 million for aquatic resources management
  • – $114 million for wildlife habitat management
  • – $45 million for national monuments and national conservation areas

National Park Service

  • -$980 million (yes, you read that right: The agency that oversees Americaโ€™s โ€œBest Ideaโ€ is having its budget slashed by nearly a billion buckaroos โ€ฆ).
  • – 5,518 full-time-equivalent employees (โ€ฆ and the agency is losing over 40% of its full-time workforce).

U.S. Geological Survey

  • $563 million budget cut for the agency
  • – $281 million from ecosystems programs
  • – $46 million from natural hazards programs
  • – $74 million from water resources programs
  • – 2,067 full-time-equivalent employees (44% of the permanent workforce)

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

  • $149 million from the National Wildlife Refuge System
  • – $50 million from conservation and enforcement programs
  • – $16 million from habitat conservation
  • – $9 million from science support
  • – $33 million from state and tribal wildlife grants
  • – 1,785 full-time-equivalent employees (27% of the workforce

Bureau of Indian Affairs

  • $120 million from public safety and justice
  • – $625 million from gross outlays
  • – 282 full-time-equivalent employees

Bureau of Reclamation:

  • $253 million from water and energy management and development
  • – $51 million from fish and wildlife management and development

National Forest System

  • 4,636 full-time-equivalent employees (or 33% of the workforce)

Other notes

  • The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management would have its renewable energy program zeroed out, along with $51 million in cuts for its environmental programs. The Bureau would slash about 10% of its workforce.
  • The Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (which regulates offshore oil and gas operations on the Outer Continental Shelf) would see its budget cut by $150 million.
  • The Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcementโ€™s budget would be reduced by $15 million.

The strikes are coming so rapidly, and from so many different directions, that it has become difficult to keep track, let alone to fight back. That is by design, of course. Advocates can take to the courts to block some regulatory rollbacks, but they have little recourse against Supreme Court decisions. Citizens may be able to convince their congressional representatives to block public land sell-offs, but that draws attention away from lawmakersโ€™ efforts to make it easier to drill and develop public lands.

The attacks will only intensify. The resistance must meet it with equal, opposing force.


๐Ÿ“ธย Parting Shotย ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

Sacred Datura in Utah. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.
Sacred Datura in Utah. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

On May 29, the Supreme Court โ€“ minus Justice Neil Gorsuch, who recused himself โ€“ decided the case of Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County, #Colorado — Westword

A coal train travels along the Colorado River north of Gypsum in Eagle County on June 12, 2023. (Chase Woodruff/Colorado Newsline)

Click the link to read the article on the Westword website (J.B. Ruhl). Here’s an excerpt:

June 8, 2025

Getting federal approval for permits to build bridges, wind farms, highways and other major infrastructure projects has long been a complicated and time-consuming process. Despite growing calls from both parties for Congress and federal agencies to reform that process, there had been few significant revisions โ€“ until now. In one fell swoop, the U.S. Supreme Court has changed a big part of the game. Whether the effects are good or bad depends on the viewerโ€™s perspective. Either way, there is a new interpretation in place for the law that is the centerpiece of the debate about permitting: theย National Environmental Policy Act of 1969, known as NEPA…

Decades ofย litigation about the scope of indirect effectsย have widened the required evaluation. Asย Iย explain it to my students, that logical and legal progression is reminiscent of the popular childrenโ€™s bookย If You Give a Mouse a Cookie, in which granting a request for a cookie triggers a seemingly endless series of further requests โ€“ for a glass of milk, a napkin and so on. For the highway example, the arguments went, even if the agency properly assessed the pollution from the cars, it also had to consider the new subdivisions, malls and jobs the new highway foreseeably could induce. The challenge for federal agencies was knowing how much of that potentially limitless series of indirect effects the courts would require them to evaluate.

The Uinta Basin is shown on this map, along with existing rail terminals in Carbon County, Utah, where limited amounts of the basinโ€™s waxy crude is loaded into train cars. A proposal to create a direct rail link to the basin would provide shippers with enough transportation capacity to quadruple output.

Supreme Court puts Utahโ€™s oil train back on the rails — Lisa Song (High Country News)

The proposed Uinta Basin Railway could traverse through part of the Ashley National Forest in Utah, seen from above.Ken Lund / CC via Flickr

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Lisa Song):

June 4, 2025

This article was originally published by Inside Climate News.

The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled in favor of a controversial Utah railway project that critics say erodes the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), a bedrock of environmental law for the past half century.

The case centered on a proposed 88-mile railway that would connect the oil fields of northeastern Utah to a national rail network that runs along the Colorado River and on to refineries on the Gulf Coast.

The waxy crude oil is currently transported by truck over narrow mountain passes. Project proponents said shipping the fossil fuel by rail โ€” as many as 10 trains daily โ€” would be quicker and revitalize the local economy by quadrupling the Uinta Basinโ€™s oil production, ICN previously reported, 

In 2020, the Seven County Infrastructure Coalition applied to the U.S. Surface Transportation  Board for approval of the railroadโ€™s construction. Under NEPA, the board was required to conduct an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) to evaluate possible harms from the project and consider how they could be mitigated.

Environmental groups and Eagle County, Colorado, opposed the railway project. They cited the potential for derailments and spills into the Colorado River, the drinking water supply for 40 million people. Opponents were also concerned about increased air pollution in the Uinta Basin, where oil fields emit high levels of methane, a potent planet-warming greenhouse gas, as well as volatile organic compounds, some of which have been linked to increased risks of cancer. 

Gulf Coast communities would also be harmed by air pollution when the crude oil was refined, opponents argued. The increased oil production and associated emissions would also drive climate change and its disastrous global effects: hurricanes, floods, droughts and extreme heat.

The Center for Biological Diversity, among the groups that had sued the Surface Transportation Board, said in a prepared statement that the ruling โ€œrelieves federal agencies of the obligation to review all foreseeable environmental harms and grants them more leeway to decide what potential environmental harms to analyze, despite what communities may think is important. It tells agencies that they can ignore certain foreseeable impacts just because they are too remote in time or space.โ€

In 2021, the board issued a 3,600-page EIS, which identified numerous โ€œsignificant and adverse impacts that could occur as a result of the railroad lineโ€™s construction and operationโ€” including disruptions to local wetlands, land use, and recreation,โ€ according to court documents. 

The board nonetheless approved the railroad construction, concluding that the projectโ€™s transportation and economic benefits outweighed its environmental impacts.

Opponents, including EarthJustice and Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment petitioned the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District Columbia. They argued the boardโ€™s environmental review excluded impacts of the project on people living near the oil fields, as well as Gulf Coast residents.ย 

The appellate court agreed. It ruled that the boardโ€™s EIS impermissibly limited the analysis of upstream and downstream projects.

โ€œThe appeals court had ruled that the federal agency that approved the railway failed in its obligations to consider the regional consequences of massively increased oil extraction on the Uinta Basin, the increased air pollution for the communities in Texas and Louisiana where the oil would be refined and the global climate consequences,โ€ said Dr. Brian Moench, president of Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment. 

The Seven County Coalition and the railroad company then appealed to the Supreme Court.

โ€œThe Supreme Courtโ€™s ruling will allow all these consequences to unfold without meaningful restraint,โ€ Moench said. โ€œThis court has made a name for itself making rulings that mock science and common sense and fail to protect the common good. This unfortunate ruling fits that same pattern.โ€

The Uinta Basin lies in the northeast corner of Utah and has seen oil and gas development since 1925. The proposed railway could take one of three potential routes โ€“ the favored of which would run through 390 acres of state lands and 401 acres of roadless U.S. Forest Service lands. James St. John/CC via Flickr

NEPA has been federal law since 1970. It doesnโ€™t prescribe specific environmental decisions, but it does establish a process to ensure federal agencies follow proper procedure in permitting. It can be a laborious, time-consuming process, but requires an agency to be thorough in assessing potential environmental impacts while giving the public adequate opportunity to comment.

NEPA doesnโ€™t necessarily halt projects but it can force project developers to pursue alternatives that protect environmentally sensitive areas and communities.

In his first term, Trump rolled back some aspects of NEPA, including weakening requirements to consider cumulative impacts of a project and the effects of climate change. Shortly after taking office this year, Trump signaled he plans to further streamline NEPA to expedite its approval process, especially for energy projects.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh, who was appointed by President Trump in his first term, wrote the opinion on behalf of four other members of the court. โ€œNEPA has transformed from a modest procedural requirement into a blunt and haphazard tool employed by project opponents (who may not always be entirely motivated by concern for the environment) to try to stop or at least slow down new infrastructure and construction projects,โ€ Kavanaugh wrote.

Courts should โ€œafford substantial deference and should not micromanage those agency choices so long as they fall within a broad zone of reasonableness,โ€ Kavanaugh wrote. โ€œNEPA does not allow courts, under the guise of judicial review of agency compliance with NEPA, to delay or block agency projects based on the environmental effects of other projects separate from the project at hand.โ€

The 8-0 decision excluded Justice Neil Gorsuch, who recused himself because of his close connection to billionaire Philip F. Anschutz, who would economically benefit from the project.

In a concurring opinion, Justice Sonia Sotomayor differed with Kavanaugh on his rationale for the ruling, but agreed on the outcome. She wrote that NEPA didnโ€™t require the board to consider the effects of oil drilling and refining because those activities were outside its authority. โ€œEven a foreseeable environmental effect is outside of NEPAโ€™s scope if the agency could not lawfully decide to modify or reject the proposed action on account of it.โ€

Justices Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson joined Sotomayor in the concurrence.

The coalition was represented by Jay Johnson of Venable LLP, who said the ruling โ€œrestores much-needed balance to the federal environmental review process.โ€ 

Keith Heaton, director of the Seven County Infrastructure Coalition, the projectโ€™s public partner, said the decision affirms the years of work and collaboration that have gone into making the Uinta Basin Railway a reality. โ€œIt represents a turning point for rural Utahโ€”bringing safer, sustainable, more efficient transportation options and opening new doors for investment and economic stability.โ€

Wendy Park, a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity, said despite the courtโ€™s ruling, โ€œweโ€™ll keep fighting to make sure this railway is never built.โ€

Uinta Basin Railway project proposed routes.Credit:Surface Transportation Board

US Supreme Court paves way for controversial Uinta Basin rail project that would haul crude oil along #ColoradoRiver: Unanimous ruling narrows the scope of a decades-old environmental review law — The Sky-Hi News #COriver

Uinta Basin Railway project proposed routes.Credit:Surface Transportation Board

Click the link to read the article on the Sky-Hi News website (Robert Tann). Here’s an excerpt:

May 30, 2025

In aย 36-page ruling, Supreme Court justices said the Surface Transportation Board, a federal agency that oversees rail transit, had sufficiently considered the proposalโ€™s environmental impacts when it approved the plan in 2021.ย Justice Brett Kavanaugh, writing the opinion for the other justices, said the board โ€œidentified and analyzed numerous โ€˜significant and adverse impacts that could occur as a resultโ€™ of the railroad lineโ€™s construction and operation โ€” including disruptions to local wetlands, land use, and recreation.โ€

[…]

The planย had been on holdย after a lower appeals court in 2023 ruled in favor of a lawsuit brought by Eagle County and five environmental groups that claimed the transportation boardโ€™s review had underestimated the railwayโ€™s environmental impact.ย  The lawsuit garnered support from a coalition of local governments, including Pitkin, Routt, Grand and Boulder counties, the cities of Basalt, Avon, Minturn, Red Cliff, Crested Butte, Glenwood Springs and Grand Junction, and the Northwest Colorado Council of Governments…

At the heart of the lawsuit and the question before the Supreme Court was whether the transportation board had sufficiently followed the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA,ย  when it approved the railway…The 55-year-old law requires federal agencies to consider the environmental impacts of their decisions, and the transportation board issued a 3,600-page environmental analysis as part of that review.ย 

Energy dominance harms our public lands — Barbara Vasquez (Writers on the Range)

Click the link to read the article on the Writers on the Range website (Barbara Vasquez):

May 26, 2025

I live in Jackson County, in northern Colorado, where hundreds of inactive and abandoned oil wells litter the landscape. Not only are they an ugly sight, they are also just a few of the estimated 2.6 million unplugged wells across the country that leak methane, benzene and other toxic substances. 

The reality is that long after Iโ€™m gone, most or all of those wells will remain unplugged. The companies and people who once owned them will have been allowed to walk away from their responsibility to clean up their mess.

Uncapped wells are what happens when the federal government enables the fossil-fuel industry to dominate energy policies, as is happening again now, both in the Interior Department and Congress. The policies emerging would allow companies, including many foreign ones, to profit from public lands and minerals that all Americans own. They would also leave taxpayers holding the bag for cleaning up leaking wells.

These abandoned wells already have consequences for wildlife, air, water and rural people. Kirk Panasuk, a rancher in Bainville, Montana, said: โ€œI have personally experienced serious health scares after breathing toxic fumes from oil and gas wells near my property. And Iโ€™ve seen too many of my friends and neighbors in this part of the country have their water contaminated or their land destroyed by rushed and reckless industrial projects.โ€

Republicans and Democrats in previous administrations and Congresses took pains to reform this historically biased federal energy system because of the damage done to rural communities and American taxpayers. Now, the federal government is rolling back those reforms.

Recently, the Interior Department announced that โ€œemergency permitting proceduresโ€ were necessary when carrying out NEPA, the National Environmental Policy Act. Timelines for environmental assessments for fossil-fuel projects were changed from one year to 14 days, without requiring a public comment period. The timeline for more complicated environmental impact statements was cut from two years to 28 days, with only a 10-day public comment period.

In May, the House Natural Resources Committee unveiled its piece of the House budget bill, which enables the federal government to expedite oil, gas, coal and mineral development. It gives Americans basically no say on whether those projects should move ahead, while keeping taxpayers from receiving a fair return on the development of publicly owned lands and minerals. 

The administrationโ€™s justification for expediting permits is that we face โ€œa national energy emergency.โ€ No such emergency exists. The United States is currently the worldโ€™s biggest exporter of liquified natural gas and is producing more oil than any other country on Earth.

Both the House billโ€”just passed and now before the Senateโ€”and the Interior Departmentโ€™s policies, ignore the long-standing mandate to manage public lands for multiple uses. Instead, the new policies:

  • Drastically reduce the publicโ€™s role in the permitting process.
  • Allow large corporations to pay to evade environmental and judicial review.
  • Exempt millions of acres of private lands with federal minerals and thousands of wells on these lands from federal permitting and mitigation requirements.

The House bill would also slash the royalty rate for oil and gas production from 16.67% to 12.5%, depriving state and local governments of funding they depend on for schools, roads and other essential services. An analysis by Resources for the Future found that the proposed lower royalty rates would result in a loss of nearly $5 billion in revenue over the next decade. 

The Interior Departmentโ€™s emergency permitting procedures and the House bill are assaults the federal government has waged on public lands since January. The public has been shoved to the side as oil and gas drillers enjoy their energy dominance throughout our public lands.

Barbara Vasquez. Photo credit: CWCB

Now, itโ€™s up to the Senate to strip out these gifts to the fossil fuel industry, and itโ€™s up to us tell our elected Senate representatives that these policies ignore the wishes of Westerners. We have told pollsters innumerable times that we support conservation, not exploitation of public lands for private interests. Whatโ€™s happening now is radically wrong.

Barbara Vasquez is a contributor to Writers on the Range, writersontherange.org, an independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about the West. A retired PhD biomedical researcher and semiconductor engineer, she is board chair of the Western Organization of Resource Councils and a board member of the Western Colorado Alliance.

Romancing the River: The Empire Strikes the Public Lands, Part 1 — George Sibley (SibleysRivers.com)

Click the link to read the article on the Sibley’s Rivers website (George Sibley):

May 20, 2025

We are an empire now, and when we act, we create our own realityโ€ฆ. And while youโ€™re studying that realityโ€”judiciously, as you willโ€”weโ€™ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and thatโ€™s how things will sort out.โ€™

That is indeed the way things seem to be sorting out today, in imperial America, under the imperious Trump, breakers of things. โ€˜The administrationโ€™ breaks a law in the process of creating Trumpโ€™s still vaguely formulated imperial reality. Citizen groups bring suit against his action, and the action is studied by judges in the context of the Constitutional rule-of-law, part of our existing (recently existing?) triumvirate reality of legislate-execute-evaluate, checks-and-balances, et cetera.

The judges tell Trump that he is exceeding his Constitutional authority, and he must undo most of what he has done. But by then he has distracted us from that by breaking something else in his chainsaw massacre of 250 years of American evolution, another action the judges must study and pass judgment on, thanks to suits brought by groups faithful to Constitutional reality.

But Trump ignores all of their judgments by appealing them, as he continues to commit actions reshaping reality and warranting further judicial study. And the Constituttional reality weโ€™ve taken for granted for 250 years suddenly begins to seem somewhat less real than it was back in good old 2024. When we should have known better โ€“ but those damn grocery prices, and Trump promised that on day oneโ€ฆ. Well, fool us once, shame on the fool; fool us twice (or fifty or a hundred times), shame on us.

So on to damage control. Today I want to look at the unfolding situation with the nationโ€™s public lands โ€“ always a sore spot with many true conservative Republicans from western states as well as Trumpโ€™s Repugnicans. The map below shows the situation โ€“ more than 630 million acres of public land, most of it by far in the West: small dots and patches of it east of the Great Plains, but vast swaths west of the plains. This land is our land, as the song says, but how the composite โ€˜we the peopleโ€™ can or should relate to and live with this land has been an ongoing debate at all levels of governance for more than 250 years.

Youโ€™ll quickly note from the map above that public land is almost half of what we call the โ€˜Intermountain Westโ€™ โ€“ the region between (and including) the Rocky Mountains on the east and the Sierra-Cascade ranges on the West. The importance of these particular public lands and their resources extends well beyond their actual geography. Most all of the water for the Colorado River, for example, starts on public lands in the green areas (National Forest lands) in the states of Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming, and nurtures the entire River Basin and some out-of-basin extensions all the way to southern California. Coal trains continue to rumble eastward from Wyoming, Utah and Colorado carrying low-sulphur coal to the remaining back-east coal-fired power plants โ€“ and the Trumpsters want to make coal great again (โ€˜clean, coalโ€™ of course). Trucks roll down from the publicโ€™s mountain forests carrying 150-year-old spruce logs like we will not see again for four or five generations, if then, destined for suburban housing โ€“ and the Trumptsters want to increase logging from those lands by 25 percent.

But what I want to focus on today is the yellow land on the map, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) land that makes up around half of the Intermountain West, and a large portion of the Colorado River Basin, mostly below 8,000 feet elevation. The BLM is a bureaucracy in the Interior Department, Iโ€™ll remind you, charged with managing all of the public lands that have not yet been designated for more specific uses, like National Forests or National Parks.

This gets the BLM nicknamed the โ€˜Bureau of Leftover Management,โ€™ but that misses the real picture. The BLM lands do include a lot of brown or just barren land that makes one think nature is still trying to figure out what to do with it. But the BLM lands also include a very diverse and often spectacularly beautiful array of ecological landscapes from which areas are regularly designated (and sometimes undesignated then redesignated) as National Monuments (28 of them now on former BLM land), Wilderness Areas (221), and more than 600 others areas designated as part of the National Conservation Lands, including National Scenic Rivers, National Scenic and Historic Trails, and,refuges for various threatened and endangered species. There are treasures yet to be discovered, and either used or protected from use, in the BLM lands.

Significant segments of this land made the news recently when my congressman, Jeff Hurd of Coloradoโ€™s Third District (the West Slope, headwaters of the Colorado River), introduced a bill for a โ€˜Productive Public Lands Act.โ€™ Rep. Hurd, I will note, occasionally behaves more like a true Republican than a Repugnican. He was one of the few Republican congressmen brave enough to voice disapproval of Trumpโ€™s pardon of all the January Sixth rebels. Most recently, he was the only Republican to vote against the suspicious sale of some BLM lands in the vicinity of โ€˜growth hot spotsโ€™ in Nevada and Utah. He has shown some spine in not drinking all of the Trump koolaid.

But the โ€˜Productive Public Lands Actโ€™ bill, and the language used to sell it, are pure Trumpish bullshit. I will let Congressman Hurd speak first for it: โ€˜This bill would force the Bureau of Land Management to reissue nine Biden-era Resource Management Plans (RMPs) which locked up access to viable lands throughout Colorado and the West. A reissuance of [the Trump-era] RMPs will put us on a path to energy dominance allowing for a more secure and prosperous United States.โ€™

A colleague in the Western Republican Caucus, California Congressman Doug LaMalfa, chimes in: โ€˜The Biden Administration was hell-bent on locking up public lands, threatening the prosperity of rural economies across the countryโ€ฆ. Fortunately, a new era has dawned, and we have the opportunity to reverse these lockups and reinstate the multiple-use mandate on Americaโ€™s public lands.โ€™

Thatโ€™s raw meat to the Trump base, but itโ€™s also disinformation of the sort that sounds good to the uncommitted but under-informed โ€“ and most of us are somewhat under-informed on the public lands. โ€˜Multiple useโ€™ โ€“ who can object to that? Especially if Joe Biden was trying to โ€˜lock upโ€™ the pubic lands and threatening our rural prosperity!

But as usual the barefoot lie has legs and runs off in all directions while the truth is still pulling on its support hose. The nine Resource Management Plans in question wereย notย created by President Biden and his โ€˜deep stateโ€™ cronies in Washington; they were created in accord with the rule of law, in this case, the Federal Land Policy and Management Act. (FLMPA), passed in 1976 in a couple of remarkable decades of what might be called โ€˜eco-populismโ€™: a nation of people deeply concerned about the growing impacts of a century of unbridled industrial capitalism supercharged by fossil-fuel technology โ€“ acid rain killing the forests, industrial pollution killing the rivers, out-of-sight-out-of-mind buried barrels of unidentified stuff killing people drinking from aquifers. The people elected Congresses in the 1960s and 70s that โ€“ imagine this! โ€“ actually addressed the peopleโ€™s concerns with legislation that began to change the game; tempering the enthusiastic power to change the planet with a growing sense of responsibility for the changes being wrought, and their consequences.

American Progress (1872) by John Gast is an allegorical representation of the modernization of the new west. Columbia, a personification of the United States, is shown leading civilization westward with the American settlers. She is shown bringing light from east to west, stringing telegraph wire, holding a book, and highlighting different stages of economic activity and evolving forms of transportation. By John Gast – This image is available from the United States Library of Congress’s Prints and Photographs division under the digital ID 09855.This tag does not indicate the copyright status of the attached work. A normal copyright tag is still required. See Commons:Licensing for more information., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=373152

Passage of the FLMPA in 1976 marked a major step in the evolution of public land management โ€“ which did not even exist overall until after World War II. From the 1780s until 1946, all of the new nationโ€™s undesignated lands were under the U.S. General Land Office, which essentially had one purpose: to get as much of that land as possible into private hands as soon as possible, through vehicles like the 1864 Homestead Act, the 1872 General Mining Act, and others going back the 1787 Northwest Ordinance. The American expansionist vision was a land full of rugged American individuals, farming, mining, logging, stockgrowing, all with their own piece of land, and all living in modest decentralized self-sufficient communities that would be the safely dispersed foundation of American democracy.

But by 1900 we were beginning to take ever-larger segments of the public lands out of Land Office control, realizing that cheap land was often getting treated cheaply. Congress began setting aside National Parks and Monuments, beginning with Yellowstone in 1872. In the 1890s presidents began establishing โ€˜Forest Reservesโ€™ to protect valuable forest land from โ€˜timber minersโ€™; early in the 20th century these became National Forests, and were moved administratively to the Department of Agriculture, with rangers to protect them and set up grazing fees and timber sales.

Charging for uses on the unclaimed public lands that had basically been used free was not popular (still isnโ€™t), but there was a grudging acknowledgment that management was probably necessary. This was affirmed in the 1930s when a group of Colorado ranchers worked with their congressman Edward Taylor to create the 1934 Taylor Grazing Act, and 80 million acres were withdrawn from General Land Office disposition to be managed by a new Grazing Service โ€“ with fees for users.

That paralleled another big cultural change happening in America through the first half of the 20th century: rural Americans were moving to the cities; around 1920 the growing urban population passed the declining rural population, and while the nation still paid lip service to the โ€˜family farm,โ€™ there were few people going out to homestead on the public lands. Instead, an increasingly well-off and mobile urban โ€˜middle class,โ€™ with two-week paid vacations, rediscovered the public lands as a resource for recreation, relaxation and renewal; they wanted the public lands to stay forever beautiful, spectacular, adventuresome โ€“ and accessible.

These two changes led to the Grazing Service and the General Land Office being quietly combined in 1946 into the Bureau of Land Management โ€“ with the Land Office gradually fading into irrelevance: the United States were no longer in the business of selling off national treasures cheap.

What we see in this evolution is a nation of people gradually waking up to the reality of needing to begin taking responsibility for the consequences of a century of enthusiastic exploitation. The final step came 30 years later with the Federal Land Management and Planning Act in 1976 noted earlier โ€“ following the foundational National Environmental Policy Act of 1970. NEPA mandated that any project involving federal funding would be preceded by a full environmental impact analysis: we will look before we leap. And if it involved public land, it would have to fit in with developed Resource Management Plans, and some larger projects would have to do their own RMP. This was tedious, difficult, often contentious work โ€“ but essential to serious democratic governance. Impatience with this hard work is the first seed of submission to tyranny.

The Resource Management Plans for public lands are all required to have two components. One is planning for multiple uses โ€“ all the uses practiced or potentially practiced on the land in question had to be fit into the overall purposes of each plan. The other requirement is public participation at every stage of the process, from all groups with a practical or potential use interest in that land.

โ€˜Multiple useโ€™ does not mean โ€˜everything going on everywhereโ€™; it means determining how much of every use represented at the table can go on with reasonable accommodation to every other use, and where in the planning area it should happen. There are land and resource uses that are compatible with other uses, and there are uses destined to be the only thing happening in specific places. Mining/drilling, logging, and intensive farming are obviously single uses on any given piece of land, while grazing and hiking and some conservation uses can all go on in the same area, with reasonable accommodations to each other. And the โ€˜mandatedโ€™ public participation means that all would-be users will be heard from in the planning process โ€“ participate or shut up.

A Gunnison sage-grouse hen leads her chicks in the Gunnison basin during the summer of 2019. Some private landowners have undertaken habitat restoration projects on placed conservation easements on their property in an effort to protect the bird. Photo credit: Greg Petersen via Aspen Journalism

I canโ€™t speak to all nine of the Resource Management Plans that Hurd and LaMalfa want to repeal, but I am quite familiar with one of them: โ€˜The Gunnison Sage-Grouse Record of Decision and Approved Resource Management Plan Amendment, dated October 2024.โ€™ This is a RMP to try to save a species of Sage Grouse that has been listed as โ€˜Threatenedโ€™ by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, under the Endangered Species Act. Without going into the multiple decades of detail, this plan was worked out among ranchers, outdoor recreational users (both motorized and unmotorized), fishermen, environmental organizations, scientists, local government representatives, state and federal agencies, industrial reps when relevant, and citizens just interested.

There are places in the basin where some of the single-use land users are indeed โ€˜locked outโ€™ for restoration needs, but this is not โ€˜Joe Biden locking them outโ€™; this is the people establishing priorities based on difficult efforts to balance economic and ecological needs, in places at least as dependent on recreational uses as extractive uses. Bidenโ€™s only relationship with the whole process was to give the rule of law (FLMPA/NEPA) his blessing, and the time and space it warrants to get it hashed out down on the ground where the problem shapes lives.

To hammer the point home, in case you donโ€™t get it โ€“ This is not an absence of โ€˜multiple use planningโ€™; it is a stellar example of it. The RMP has been worked out over the past two decades by multiple users of landscapes shared with a threatened species who are all willing to try to live with the plan โ€“ the kind of local governance that was once celebrated by โ€˜Main Street Republicansโ€™ (as opposed to โ€˜Wall Street Republicansโ€™). I expect the other eight plans have somewhat the same rooted authenticity.

So long as we have the legal mandate to do this, and the local patience and will to work it out in our down-on-the-ground reality, we have not yet fully succumbed to the imperial โ€˜created realityโ€™ that Trump and our local Congressman want to impose on us.

The next logical step here is to ask whether the poor oppressed oil and gas industry, which the Repugnicans want to โ€˜liberateโ€™ through the Productive Public Lands Bill, really needs liberating โ€“ which requires looking at what they can and cannot do now, and whose fault that is or isnโ€™t. But Iโ€™ve taken so long here in providing some background for that discussion that itโ€™s time to give you a breather. Iโ€™ll be back with the rest of the story in a couple weeks. Stay tuned.

Meanwhile, Iโ€™ll leave you with this irrelevant reflection on Trumpโ€™s rejection of the low-flow showerhead:

An anti-BLM sticker (referring, presumably, to the federal land agency, not the Black Lives Matter movement) at another Phil Lyman rally against โ€œfederal overreachโ€ and motorized travel closures in southeastern Utah back in 2014. Photo credit: Jonathan P. Thompson/The Land Desk

Public land sell-off amendment is a test: Will the GOP stand on principle, or bow to President Trump? — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

La Sal Sunrise. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

May 9, 2025

It appears that Republicans are actually serious about taking Americaโ€™s public lands out of the publicโ€™s hands.

During a late night-early morning move this week, Republican Reps. Mark Amodei of Nevada and Celeste Maloy of Utah sneakily added an amendment to the House reconciliation bill that would open the door to selling off thousands of acres of Bureau of Land Management parcels (and some U.S. Forest Service land) in Utah and Nevada. Revenues would be used to help offset proposed tax cuts for the wealthy. The bill passed through committee, despite strong opposition from Democrats, but has not been voted on by the whole House yet.

The amendment will serve as an important test for Republicans who have condemned or remained ambivalent about public land transfers in the past. Rep. Ryan Zinke, the Montana Republican and Interior Secretary under Trump I, has said public land sales are his โ€œred lineโ€ he refuses to cross, which makes sense since his constituents โ€” and the general public โ€” tend to be opposed to this sort of transfer1. Weโ€™ll see. The question is whether the GOPโ€™s urge to pass a โ€œbig, beautiful billโ€ for Trump will erase that line for him and others. And if the amendment does pass, it may break the seal, so to speak, and open the door to much larger land transfers.

The whole deal has been wrapped in confusion, due to the rush of adding the amendment and lack of transparency around it, along with its vague language, which points to parcels on maps that are also a bit unclear. But it appears that it includes about 11,000 acres of BLM land in Utah and 200,000 acres or more in Nevada.

At least some of the land earmarked for โ€œdisposalโ€ (bureaucratese for selling, giving away, or transferring public land) ostensibly would be used for housing. The amendment specifies that parcels in southern Nevada and in Washoe County be made โ€œavailable at less than fair market value for affordable housing.โ€ And parcels marked for disposal near Mesquite and Mormon Mesa in Nevada overlap with the American Enterprise Instituteโ€™s target areas for its Homesteading 2.0 and Freedom Cities initiatives. The Utah land is all in Washington and Beaver counties, the former of which is one of the nationโ€™s fastest growing areas. The land is all on the urban fringe, meaning developing it would lead to more sprawl.


Freedom Cities are back! Jonathan P. Thompson: Read full story


The Great Basin Water Network notes that some of the Washington County parcels also follow the path of the proposed $2 billion Lake Powell Pipeline, which would pull up to 28 billion gallons of water from the reservoir, use huge amounts of power to pump it across 141 miles of mesas and valleys to southwestern Utah, where it would water lawns and golf courses and irrigate alfalfa. Other parcels are long skinny segments that follow roads.

While some news reports and environmental groups have suggested that the proposed transfer is aimed at facilitating oil and gas drilling, itโ€™s highly unlikely, as none of the parcels are in oil and gas-rich areas.

I did a mashup of the various maps for the Washington County, Utah, parcels, with the maroon and fuchsia indicating transfers requested by Washington County and St. George, and the dark blue by the water conservancy district. (To see a larger version click on it and go to the Land Desk website).

The fuchsia parcels were apparently requested by Washington County, and include the proposed path of the Lake Powell pipeline as well as what look to be parcels intended for housing or commercial development, including one on the border of Zion National Park.
The pink indicates BLM parcels that would be disposed of under the amendment and total about 65,000 acres. If the land were transferred, it would allow for a major expansion of Searchlight, a small former mining town, and Mesquite. It would provide enough acreage for a whole new sprawling city in the Moapa Valley.

๐Ÿฅต Aridification Watch ๐Ÿซ

Thereโ€™s really no avoiding it now: This yearโ€™s spring runoff is going to be pretty piddly (in some cases this is in the past tense, since peak runoff has already come and gone). The winter started out pretty strong, and for some areas continued to be average into early spring, but then it all went to hell in a handbasket, despite early May storms.

Hopes for a continued recovery of Lake Powell levels this year are pretty much dashed. The Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s latest 2025 water year unregulated inflow forecast for the reservoir is a meagre 6.78 million acre-feet, or 71% of normal. That would mean Lake Powell will continue to shrink over the next 12 months.

๐Ÿ“ธ Parting Shot ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

I browse through old newspapers quite often to research the history of things. And lately, when I was looking into wolves in Colorado and Utah, I stumbled across a bunch of ads with a similar theme. And I couldnโ€™t help but be reminded of some of the crazy spam that clogs up my email and social media feeds. These are from the late 1800s and early 1900s, and here merely for your amusement.


1 Letโ€™s just be clear about something here: Zinke and others may express opposition to full-on land transfers, but they strongly support de facto land transfers, i.e. oil and gas and coal leases and mining claims. While they donโ€™t transfer title of the land to the lessee or claimant, they do transfer the American publicโ€™s minerals and hydrocarbons to the corporations for little or no cost. And access can be cut off from the land while itโ€™s being drilled or mined, and those activities can not only wreck the land, but also preclude future uses even after mining and drilling has ceased.

#Colorado governor visits Dillon Reservoir to sign package of bills meant to bolster stateโ€™s water security: Legislation focuses on improved #snowpack data collection, increased funding for water projects — #Aspen Timesย 

Colorado Governor Jared Polis

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Times website (Robert Tann). Here’s an excerpt:

Perched above the Dillon Reservoir on the side of a mountain road in Summit County, Gov. Jared Polis on Thursday signed into law three bills aimed at bolstering the stateโ€™s water infrastructure.ย  The measures come amid the backdrop of chronic drought and increased water demand in the West which have made finding a path towards water sustainability more urgent. Speaking amid on-and-off snow flurries and bouts of sunshine, Polis said the bills signed on Thursday will help โ€œbuild a sustainable, livable futureโ€ by โ€œsecuring our water for the state of Colorado.โ€

Hereโ€™s what the new laws do: 

Better snowpack mapping 

To better measure Coloradoโ€™s primary source of water supply,ย House Bill 1115ย establishes a new statewide programย for tracking snowpack…HB 1115 charges the Colorado Water Conservation Board with deploying newer methods such as light detection and ranging technology, also known as LiDAR…The technology has already been used by entities like Denver Water, Northern Water and the Colorado River Water Conservation District in recent years…The law directs roughly $250,000 from an existing cash fund over the next two years to help the program establish initial staffing and data systems. Lawmakers have acknowledged there will likely need to be additional rounds of funding in future years…

More money for water projects 

State votersโ€™ decision to approve a tax on sports betting in 2019 has provided a critical funding source for water projects, delivering as much as $30 million a year for infrastructure and conservation efforts.ย  House Bill 1311ย takes that a step further by eliminating a tax exemption for revenue generated from free sports bets…

A view of the popular Pumphouse campground, boat put-in and the upper Colorado River. Photo credit: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

Finding solutions to funding woes

While taxes on sports betting have helped shore up state spending on water projects, its other key funding streamย risks running dry…Underย Senate Bill 40, the state will commission a nine-member task force within the Department of Natural Resources to study the future of severance tax revenue and come up with solutions to better fund the stateโ€™s water needs.ย The task force will be required to submit a final report to the legislature in July 2026, with lawmakers hoping to turn those ideas into policy.ย 

Grays and Torreys, Dillon Reservoir May 2017. Photo credit Greg Hobbs.

#Boulder/Boulder County #ClimateChange lawsuit gets green light: #Colorado Supreme Court says Boulder/Boulder County lawsuit can be heard by a state court and is not pre-empted by federal laws. But, there was dissent — Allen Best (BigPivots.com)

Boulder. Photo credit: Allen Best

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

May 13, 2025

By a Colorado Supreme Court vote of 5 to 2, Boulder and Boulder County won the right to move forward with their lawsuit against two fossil fuel companies. their climate change lawsuit on Monday in the Colorado Supreme Court.

But if the vigor of the writing were the deciding factor, the dissent authored by Justice Carlos Samour Jr. with concurrence of Justice Boatright would carry the day.

Thatโ€™s not how the law works, of course. The written opinion โ€“ echoing what was verbally decided several weeks ago โ€“ found that federal law did not preempt Boulderโ€™s claims under state law in this case. In other words, the argument by the city and county against Exxon Mobil and Colorado Suncor can be heard in a Colorado district court.

โ€œWe express no opinion on the ultimate viability of the merits of Boulderโ€™s claims,โ€ said the majority in an opinion written by Justice Richard J. Gabriel.

Many similar lawsuits have been filed in the United States by local jurisdictions, and this is only the second one, after a Hawaii Supreme Court decision in 2023 โ€“ that has been deemed to move forward. In New York, justices ruled against a similar climate change lawsuit.

Boulder and Boulder County along with San Miguel County originally sued Suncor and Exxon in April 2018. They allege they have and will continue to incur costs and losses as a result of climate harms, such as increased costs for wildfire abatement, and for decades of misinformation.

A state district court rejected the attempt by the two companies to have the lawsuit dismissed. Exxon then directly petitioned the Colorado Supreme Court to overturn the result.

San Miguel Countyโ€™s case in Denver District Court has been on hold, although this decision sets a precedent for it.

The lawsuit pivots upon several arguments, most notably the federal Clean Air Act, the law passed by Congress in 1970. In dispute was whether this law precludes efforts in Colorado to seek claims from the fossil fuel companies.

Boulder alleges that it has incurred and will continue to incur millions of dollars in costs to protect its property and residents from the impacts of climate change.

Along with the county, it asserts that the fossil fuel companies, โ€œbecause they knowingly caused and contributed to the alteration of the climate by producing, promoting, refining, marketing and selling fossil fuels at levels that have caused and continue to cause climate change,โ€ should be forced to share the costs.

They also accuse the two companies of โ€œconcealing and/or misrepresenting the dangers associated with fossil fuelsโ€™ intended use.โ€

The local jurisdictions also have various public nuisance, private nuisance and trespass claims. Under the latter heading is the โ€œinvasions of its property in the form of floodwaters, fires, hail, rain, snow, wind and invasive species.โ€

But again, this case did not decide the merits of those complaints. It was to decide whether a district court in Colorado had standing to hear the case. The oil companies argued that the Clean Air Act preempted state authority in the matter.

As in other cases heard in other states, the district court judge in Colorado found no language in the Clean Air Act that expressly pre-empted state common law tort claims. Nor, said the justice, did that federal law completely occupy the field of greenhouse gas emissions.

The Suncor refinery lies northeast of downtown Denver. Photo/Allen Best

Congress has the power to preempt state law โ€” on that the two factions of the Colorado Supreme Court agree. Their disagreement come down to whether the Clean Air Act expressly allowed for state authority in this area of pollution โ€” or even whether it needed to offer a green light. Indeed, according to the majority opinion, the federal law itself makes clear that โ€œair pollution prevention โ€ฆ and air pollution control at its source is (sic) the primary responsibility of states and local governments.โ€

The majority opinion goes on for nearly three-dozen pages, so you might want to read it yourself. Hereโ€™s a key passage:

โ€œAt root, defendants appear to be arguing that a vague federal interest over interstate pollution, climate change, and energy policy must preempt Boulderโ€™s claims,โ€ it said. But a 2019 U.S. Supreme Court opinion had held that โ€œinvoking some brooding federal interest or appealing to a judicial policy preference should never be enough to win preemption of a state law; a litigant must point specifically to โ€˜a constitutional text or federal statuteโ€™ that does the displacing or conflicts with state law.โ€

Did the oil companies point to a federal state or constitutional text that preempts Boulderโ€™s claims? No, said the state justices.

True, in New Yorkโ€™s Second Circuit ruled otherwise. But that court had engaged in backwards reasoning, said the Colorado state justices.

The arguments also involved whether Boulder and Boulder County are trying to set foreign policy, which is a no-no. Again, the majority of the justices found that the arguments of the oil companies fell short.

In his dissent, Justice Samour, who was joined by Justice Boatright, came to different conclusions in almost every point.

โ€œWe are but one individual nation. Yet, the majority in this case gives Boulder, Colorado, the green light to act as its own republic,โ€ he wrote in a nod to a colloquial reference to Boulder. โ€œMore specifically, the majority concludes that Boulder may prosecute state-law claims that both effectively regulate interstate air pollution and have more than an incidental effect on foreign affairs. And, alarmingly, the majorityโ€™s decision isnโ€™t cabined to Boulder โ€“ all other Colorado municipalities may bring such claims. Indeed, at least one (San Miguel County) already has.โ€

Added Samour in a later section. โ€œI am concerned that permitting Boulder to proceed with its claims will interfere with both our federal governmentโ€™s regulation of interstate air pollution and our federal governmentโ€™s foreign policies regarding air pollution.โ€ This has produced a worry that โ€œwe are headed for regulatory chaos.โ€

Samourโ€™s dissent is fun to read as he talks about Bolder whistling past the federal-common-law graveyard, or the attempt by the Boulder jurisdictions to โ€œtreat federal common law as chopped liver.โ€

His bottom line is that the question is not whether   the Clean Air Act expressly allowed states to have authority in this area. It did not, he says. Itโ€™s a flip side of the coin of the majority opinion.

In a footnote, he says that he would not rule out the possibility that Boulder could bring suit under Colorado law to recover damages allegedly caused by emissions resulting from the energy companiesโ€™ activities within Colorado. โ€œBut thatโ€™s a far, far cry from what Boulder is seeking to do here โ€“ with the majorityโ€™s blessing, no less.โ€

Again, it comes back to the Clean Air Act. It does not, he says, gives states authority to independently regulate or otherwise control out-of-state sources of pollution.โ€

Going electric with Fred and Wilma — Allen Best (BigPivots.com) #ActOnClimate

The shiny new cold-weather air source heat pump installed during summer 2023 at Coyote Gulch Manor.

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

May 12, 2025

A Boulder County couple โ€” weโ€™ll call them Fred and Wilma โ€” decided to live their values and reduce the carbon footprint of their house. This is what they did.

This was originally published in the Boulder Weekly on April 16.

Fred and Wilma (not their real names) take climate change very seriously. For the last several years, they have been members of Citizensโ€™ Climate Lobby, an organization that advocates for a tax on greenhouse gas emissions.

Yet like most of us, they were burning natural gas to heat the space and water in their 2,800-square-foot house near Niwot. Last year, they decided to live their values. They set out to go nearly all electric.

You, too, can be like Fred and Wilma. Hereโ€™s how.

Step 1: Assess

Energy audits provide great value in guiding investment choices. They can be had for $190 after rebates.

Even more valuable are blow-door tests. Most effective in cold weather, they provide visual images of heat escaping a house. Many Boulder residents can expect to pay $60 to $150 for a conventional blow-door test. In other jurisdictions, these advanced tests typically run $200 to $450.

EnergySmart

For Boulder County residents, EnergySmart is an excellent place to start on this journey. Itโ€™s a partnership of Boulder County, Boulder and Longmont with Xcel Energy and Platte River Power Authority.

Advisors can address everything from building insulation to solar panels to the needs of electric vehicles.

Efficiency Works (Longmont Power)

An Efficiency Works assessment will cost Longmont residents $60. While funds last, assessments are free of charge for rental properties in 2025.

Xcel Energy 

The stateโ€™s largest utility provider currently offers two options for audits:

Stuart Cummings, a former pilot, and others created Go Electric Colorado with a goal of sharing their knowledge with homeowners who wanted to figure out ways to reduce the greenhouse gas emissions associated with their homes. Here Stuart Cummings explains heat pumps to an audience in East December. Photo/Allen Best

Go Electric Colorado coalesced in 2023 after Stuart Cummings, Julia Moravcsik and Nick Stevens met and realized how many people were interested in electric cars but remained fearful about ranges and reliability. They suspected the same was true about suppressing emissions in buildings.

Abundant information about home electrification can be found on the internet. But, as Moravcsik points out, โ€œpeople kind of donโ€™t know what they donโ€™t know.โ€

โ€œEven in Boulder, where people know a lot about this kind of stuff, most people knew nothing or next to nothing about home electrification,โ€ she says.

Go Electric Coloradoโ€™s volunteer counselors have now provided nearly 400 consultations, about half in Boulder County, with others ranging from the eastern plains to the desert valleys of the Western Slope.

Step 2: Getting started

Insulation: Fred, who recently retired after several decades as a home remodeler, knew insulation was the most important thing in reducing energy use, no matter the fuel source. He and Wilma hired Net Zero Insulation to boost the attic insulation to R-60, the gold standard. (The R-value is the capacity of an insulating material to resist heat flow. The higher the R-value, the greater the insulating power.)

It cost $3,200, and the impact was immediate. The house stayed warmer in winter, cooler in summer โ€” and lowered their utility bills.

Windows and doors: Many older houses have single-pane windows, which have an R-value of 1. Replacing them with double-pane windows can cost $10,000 to $20,000 depending upon the house size and number of windows. Some newer homes have triple-pane windows. Windows produced by Alpen High Performance at its Louisville factory can get up to R-11. They are also far more pricey.

The federal Energy Star program allows you to claim 30% of product cost up to a maximum of $600.

In the basement of their 1967 home, Fred installed six small double-paned windows at a cost of $2,000. Upgrading a single-paned patio door cost $3,200.

Go Electric Coloradoโ€™s Paul Bousquet counsels caution before upgrading from double to triple-pane windows. He instead advises having an energy auditor use an infrared camera to find imperfections in seals around windows.

Heat pumps: Heat pumps can replace gas-burning furnaces. Using electricity, they milk the heat from outdoor air then feed it into the buildingโ€™s interior. During summer, the reverse process can replace air conditioners and swamp coolers. Heat pumps can also use the same process to produce hot water in lieu of natural gas.

Metro Denver-Boulder has several companies that specialize in heat pump installation. Xcel Energy has a list of contractors registered with the company. So does Energy Smart. Go Electric Colorado endorses a handful of contractors; Bousquet advises getting at least three bids.

Fred and Wilma used Elephant Energy for the air-source heat pump to warm and cool their house and heat their 50-gallon water heater. The $22,000 cost (after rebates) included an electrical upgrade. The Flintstone house stayed comfortable in January even when the temperature dipped to 9 below. Fred strongly advises finding a company that knows all the rebates.

(For example, Superior has a host of rebates for projects that serve up to four residential units, everything from insulation to electric induction cookstoves).

Kitchen stoves: Going electric also means replacing the kitchen gas-burning stove with an electric model. Plus, studies have shown that gas fumes while cooking the tamales can be unhealthy to cooks and others.

Boulder County offers an induction cook-top lending program for people who are curious about switching to an electric range: rebuildingbetter.org/induction-resources.

While roof-top solar is abundant in this Jefferson County housing development along Highway 93 between Golden and Arvada, Go Electric Colorado counselors say it should not be the first, second or even third investment for homeowners wanting to shrink the carbon footprint of their buildings. Photo/Allen Best

Solar: Going all-electric in your house may not get you 100% clean of fossil fuels. You might achieve that by investing in solar and battery storage, a path that Go Electric Colorado can also help with.

Locally, Boulder-based Namaste Solar โ€” an employee-owned co-op โ€” offers free quotes. Federal tax incentives can cover up to 30% of the cost of solar panels and battery storage.

Fred and Wilma, however, decided against going with rooftop solar. Solar farms can generate electricity at scale, and roof-top solar is a long-term investment.

That has also been the advice of Go Electric Colorado. Nice, they say, but itโ€™s not the first, second or even third priority.

Getting electricity from the utilities will include some fossil fuel. But that should diminish to near zero during the next 15 to 25 years.

Fred says that upgrading their house was a reflection of their resolve to be a part, if a small one, of the climate solution. โ€œYou can tell how much people care by what they do,โ€ he says.

Friday Fast Takes: Dust on snow, too many houses?, Trump ticker, more…: Dust is melting #ColoradoRiver snows — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org) #COriver #aridification

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

May 2, 2025

๐Ÿฅต Aridification Watch ๐Ÿซ

A new study finds that airborne dust deposited on snow in the Upper Colorado River Basin speeds up spring snowmelt. Regular readers of the Land Desk wonโ€™t be surprised by this conclusion, as there are regular mentions here regarding the effects of dust-on-snow in the San Juan Mountains. This study, however, is the first to quantify the effects across the entire Colorado River Basin.

When dust, lifted up from the lowlands by spring winds, falls on mountain snow, it decreases the snowโ€™s albedo โ€” the measure of a surfaceโ€™s reflectivity โ€” causing the snow to melt faster. That adds another variable into the water forecasting mix, since about 85% of the Coloradoโ€™s flow comes from snowmelt.

Dust events have been occurring for thousands of years on the Colorado Plateau and in the San Juan Mountains, but picked up significantly following the white settler-colonist influx of the mid-1800s, and peaking in the first few decades of the twentieth century, when volumes of dust were five times higher than they were prior to colonization.

The new study, โ€œDust on Snow Radiative Forcing and Contribution to Melt in the Colorado River Basin,โ€ by Patrick Naple, S. McKenzie Skiles, et al, used daily remotely sensed images (MODIS) from 2001 to 2023 to observe dust-on-snow impacts. Findings include:

  • The lowest dust-on-snow impacts occurred in the northern Uinta in Utah and the Wind River Range in Wyoming, while higher and more persistent effects were seen in the central and southern Rockies.
  • Dust impacts tend to be largest in the lower alpine elevations (8,000 – 10,000 feet).
  • The researchers observed greater dust effects in the first part of the observation period (2001 to 2014) and lesser after that, โ€œproducing a slight but statistically significant decreasing trend over the record.โ€ And the patterns donโ€™t necessarily align with drought intensity, โ€œindicating that there is not a straightforward relationship between aridity and dust.โ€
  • The reason for the decreasing trend arenโ€™t clear, but researchers hypothesize that it relates to a combination of increasing surface roughness (vegetation) and decreasing wind speeds related to climate variability.

The good news for the San Juans is that dust events have been relatively mild this spring, according to the Center for Snow and Avalanche Studiesโ€™ April 29ย report,ย which has helped keep the meagre snowpack around a while longer. At least for now: A storm is forecast to move into the San Juans this weekend and early next week, likely bringing both dust and snow to the high country, which could throw off some of our Predict the Peak guesses, for sure.

***

Fire season has arrived in the Southwest. It feels early, but then, who the hell knows anymore? Maybe last yearโ€™s fire season is simply continuing on. Theย Stronghold Fireย has scorched a little over 2,000 acres in the east edge of the Dragoon Mountains in southern Arizona, forcing evacuations in the rural sprawl. As of May 1, it was 62% contained and fire activity had ebbed. And theย Otero Fireย burned through 494 acres of the Rio Grande Bosque adjacent to Socorro, New Mexico.

The outlook is for a hot, dry, maybe smoky summer for a good swath of the West:


๐Ÿ  Random Real Estate Room ๐Ÿค‘

I stumbled upon an unexpected headline in the Las Vegas Review-Journal today: โ€œInventory flooding Las Vegas Valleyโ€™s home market with no buyers in sight: Zillow.โ€ Say what? For I donโ€™t know how long, weโ€™ve been hearing that Las Vegas was suffering a severe housing shortage โ€” i.e. demand was far outstripping supply โ€” and that the only solution was to sacrifice surrounding public lands to housing developers.

Yet now Zillow is saying there are too many houses for sale? And whatโ€™s also interesting is that home prices continue to rise alongside inventory. Thatโ€™s right: There are more homes available for sale, and yet the median sales price continues to increase, showing that the laws of supply and demand donโ€™t always apply to housing (and showing that the push to bulldoze federal land for affordable housing is a sham).

I checked out Zillow for myself and found about 1,600 homes listed for less than $300,000 for sale in the greater Las Vegas area. I decided to look around the region a bit, too, and it actually seems like there are more sub-$300k homes/condos available now than during my previous scans over the past four years. Oh, and I found this tiny home in the sprawling metropolis of Ticaboo, Utah. A little overpriced, but the location? Heck yeah!


๐Ÿคฏ Trump Ticker ๐Ÿ˜ฑ

Sigh. That guy is still president, and continues to do his darnedest to wreck everything that makes America great. Wes Silerโ€™s Newsletter is reporting that the National Park Service plans to fire another 1,500 employees in coming days, bringing total Park Service staffing losses through resignations, firings, and layoffs to 5,000 under Trump. Meanwhile, year-to-date visitation at Zion National Park is at near-record levels. The combination of more visitors and fewer staff could get messy.

And all Interior Department employees (which includes the Park Service, BLM, and so forth), have been ordered to submit their resumes โ€” i.e. reapply for their existing jobs โ€” in preparation for significant job cuts and an expected complete overhaul of the department and its agencies.

Firing thousands of people from what seemed like secure jobs will not be good for the economy, which is already struggling mightily due to Trumpโ€™s policies. And on that note, if youโ€™re interested in tariffs and how they might affect things, Iโ€™d urge you to read this smart take from Aaron Smith at his Ag Data News:


๐Ÿ“ˆ Data Dump ๐Ÿ“Š

WildEarth Guardians just released their first quarter โ€œOil & Gas Waste Watchโ€ report tallying up industry and regulatory failures in New Mexico. Findings include:

  • 307/330ย The number of oil and gas facility incidents/spills reported during the first three months of the year in New Mexico.
  • 78,858 barrelsย Volume of liquid, including 22,927 barrels of wastewater in addition to crude oil, condensates, and other materials, spilled in those incidents. Some of the material was recovered.
  • 118ย Number of spills involving crude oil or condensates.
  • 292/36ย Number of spills in the Permian Basin/San Juan Basin, respectively.

๐Ÿ“– Reading Room ๐Ÿง

Shaun Griswold has a great essay about the Cybertruck in the latest High Country News and on the website. Hereโ€™s a little outtake, but do go read the whole thing. You wonโ€™t regret it.

๐Ÿ“ธ Parting Shot ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

โ€ฆ a little reminder that I was knocking on Cybertrucks before it was cool!

The Silver Bullet goes head to head with a toaster โ€ฆ er, Cybertruck. Photo credit: Jonathan P. Thompson

Real #Climate Solutions Are Beneath Us: Itโ€™s time to accept that durable subsurface carbon storage, along with emissions reductions, must be part of the plan to mitigate the effects of #ClimateChangeโ€”and geoscience must play a central role — EOS #ActOnClimate

Calcite precipitated in basaltic bedrock, as seen here in Fort George Canyon, British Columbia, stores carbon durably. Credit: Peter Reiners

Click the link to read the article on the EOS website (Peter Reiners). Here’s an excerpt:

May 2, 2025

As the world blows pastย 1.5ยฐC of anthropogenic warmingย and looks increasingly likely to hit 2.6ยฐCโ€“3.1ยฐC byย the end of the century, plenty of controversy still exists, even among geoscientists, about how to slow, stop, or reverse the rapid climate change we are causing. As so many studies have documented, such warming will causeย inundation of many coastal cities,ย trillions of dollarsย in damage fromย extreme weather, widespreadย species extinctions, and unrelentingย heat waves. It will also fundamentally threatenย financial sectors and economiesย at all scales. One thing is clear: To mitigate these outcomes, humanityโ€™s first priority should be to drastically reduce its annual emissions of roughly 40 gigatons (billion metric tons) of carbon dioxide (CO2), the greenhouse gas most responsible for driving warming. Without this reduction, other measures will be only modestly effective at best. But unfortunately, at this point, theย scale of mitigationย needed toย keep warming to below 2ยฐCโ€“3ยฐCย goes beyond reducing annual emissions. We must also remove and store carbon that has accumulated in the atmosphere…

Not only has focusing on annual emissions over the past few decades failed to reduce them, but itโ€™s also not our annual emissions today (and into the future) that are causing theย 1.55ยฐC of warmingย weโ€™re witnessing. Itโ€™s how muchย CO2ย we have already emitted. Ourย cumulative emissionsย of 1.8 trillion tons (1,800 gigatons) of CO2ย from energy and industryโ€”heavier than the combined massย of all living things on Earthโ€”taken from geologic reservoirs and dumped into the atmosphere, will stay there (and in the ocean) for thousands of years. Even on that happy day when we finally start reducing emissions, we will be theย farthest we have ever beenย from solving the problem, and in fact, we will still be adding to it…

The biggest opportunityโ€”and perhaps the biggest responsibilityโ€”forย geoscientists to contributeย toย mitigationย is through facilitating durableย carbon dioxide removalย (CDR). Concerns are sometimes raised about CDR as a form ofย climate intervention, or geoengineering, yet it is far less risky than the centuries-long geoengineering experiment of using the atmosphere as a sewer. Indeed,ย removing gigatons of CO2ย per yearย is essential to net zero strategies and avoiding disastrous amounts of warming, as unequivocally stated by theย Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change,ย Energy Transitions Commission, andย American Physical Society. Three principlesย are generally considered fundamental to CDR. First, CO2ย already in the atmosphere must be taken out. This principleย distinguishes itย from point sourceย carbon capture and storageย (CCS), which simply reduces new CO2ย emissions from fossil fuel energy and industry sources while competing with clean energy…Many approaches to CDR exist.ย Direct air captureย (DAC), for example, is aย rapidly growingย method in which CO2ย is pulled straight from the atmosphere.ย Biomass carbon removal and storageย (BiCRS) methods capture a fraction of theย 480 gigatons of CO2ย that plants naturally absorb each year and prevent it from cycling back to the atmosphere by converting biomass to forms that can be isolated and stored. Other CDR approaches focus on managing ecosystems to stimulate more CO2ย removal than would occur naturally, the second of the three principles of CDR. Examples include various strategies forย enhanced rock weatheringย inย croplandsย orย forestsย and forย marine CDR, such as usingย nutrients to promote biomass growthย andย raising the alkalinityย of seawater so it pulls more CO2ย from the air. Third, and most important, is the fact that however CO2ย is removed, it must beย stored durably, with minimal likelihood it can return to the atmosphere for a long time. Using captured carbon to createย marketable stuffย like fertilizer and chemicals may seem economically savvy, but itโ€™s not a durable approach. The entire global industrial demand for CO2ย is less than 1% of our annual emissions, and much of this carbon goes right back to the atmosphere or is used for enhanced oil recovery (EOR) to extract more petroleum.

The Mammoth direct air capture facility in Iceland, operated by Climeworks, began pulling carbon dioxide from the air in 2024. Credit: ยฉClimeworks

Interior eviscerates public land protections, fast-tracks mining, drilling: Plus: National monument shrinkage appears imminent — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

An oil and gas drilling operation in the Chaco region checkerboard of northwestern New Mexico. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

April 25, 2025

๐Ÿคฏ Trump Ticker ๐Ÿ˜ฑ

For the past three months and change, the Trump administration, in a series of executive orders, has been working to dismantle the administrative state, or the framework of agencies, rules, and regulations designed to protect the nation and its citizens. For the most part, however, the Interior Department โ€” the sprawling agency that oversees much of the nationโ€™s public lands โ€” has been relatively (and suspiciously) quiet, refraining from big actions beyond merely repeating some of Trumpโ€™s orders.

That has rapidly changed in recent days as Interior Secretary Doug Burgum โ€” or perhaps Tyler Hassan, the DOGE minion Elon Musk appointed to reorganize Interior โ€” set off a figurative bomb that could demolish protections for public lands.

The most alarming move, so far, is the departmentโ€™s implementation of โ€œemergency permitting proceduresโ€ for oil and gas, uranium, coal, biofuels, and critical mineral projects on federal lands. Under this order, the department will compress the entire environmental review for these projects down to 28 days or less โ€” even for a full environmental impact statement.

โ€œBy reducing a multi-year permitting process down to just 28 days,โ€ Burgum said in a press release, โ€œthe Department will lead with urgency, resolve, and a clear focus on strengthening the nationโ€™s energy independence.โ€

If youโ€™ve ever skimmed through an EIS, you know how insane this concept is.

The Bureau of Land Management will be packing the entire process mandated by the National Environmental Policy Act, Endangered Species Act, National Historic Preservation Act, and other rules and regulations into an impossibly short timeframe.

By impossibly short, I mean that it is virtually impossible to comply with these laws and requirements โ€” which include tribal consultation, archaeological surveys and mitigation, environmental and endangered species reviews, socioeconomic impact analyses, and public comment periods โ€” in four weeks or less. So by radically compressing the timeline, Burgum is essentially telling his staff to skirt the requirements, i.e. violate the law.

Burgum uses President Trumpโ€™s claim that the U.S. is experiencing an โ€œenergy emergency,โ€ to justify the destructive rubber-stamping, and says fast-tracking project approvals is necessary to address that emergency.

Iโ€™ve said it many times, but I will say it again: There is no energy emergency. The U.S. is pumping more crude oil than ever before from the Permian Basin and other fields, it is the largest petroleum producer in the world, it is a net exporter of petroleum products, and liquefied natural gas exports are at an all-time high. The U.S. market is glutted with natural gas and the coal supply has been outpacing demand for nearly two decades. Lithium โ€” for electric vehicle batteries and grid-scale energy storage โ€” is so plentiful that prices have plummeted nearly 90% since 2022. Uranium shortage? Nope.

One could certainly argue that the power grid in the West is outdated, its operation balkanized, and that it is not up to the challenges posed by growing data center electricity demand. But aside from geothermal and hydropower (solar, wind, and transmission projects are not included), none of the categories of projects on the fast-track list would do anything to fix the grid. Even if they were, it would not justify truncating environmental reviews so severely โ€” or at all.

Environmental reviews can take a maddeningly long time, especially for big projects. But the way to speed things up is not to throw the laws and protections in the the trash bin. That will only lead to lawsuits, which likely will delay the projects even more. The only way to truly streamline permitting, while still safeguarding human health and the environment, is to beef up staffing, resources, and expertise. And thatโ€™s exactly the opposite of what Trump and Musk and Burgum are doing.

Pages from the Interior Departmentโ€™s 2026-2030 Strategic Plan Draft Framework acquired and published by Public Domain. Note that one objective is to โ€œrelease federal holdingsโ€ for housing. And that in the top one they want to โ€œreduce the costs for grazingโ€ on public land (can it go any lower?), while in the bottom one they want to โ€œincrease revenues from grazing โ€ฆ .โ€ Uh โ€ฆ okay?

But wait. It gets worse.

We might take some comfort in the fact that national monuments are off-limits to the extractive industries and Trumpโ€™s energy dominance agenda, right? Maybe not for long.

Earlier this week, the folks at Public Domain acquired a copy of the Interior Departmentโ€™s 2026-2030 Strategic Plan Draft Framework. The plan aims to, among other things: โ€œrestore American prosperity,โ€ โ€œassess and right-size monuments,โ€ and โ€œreturn heritage lands and sites to the states.โ€

The Washington Post, however, is reporting that Burgum is not necessarily waiting until next year to โ€œright-size,โ€ or shrink, national monuments. From the Post:

If they go through with the shrinkage of any or all of these national monuments, it would open up additional lands to oil and gas leasing and new mining claims, which would then be subject to the fast-tracked permitting.

Baaj Nwaavjo Iโ€™tah Kukveni-Ancestral Footprints of the Grand Canyon is especially rich in high-grade uranium deposits, and the White Canyon area in Bears Ears might also be targeted for uranium if the monument were shrunk. Grand Staircase-Escalante includes a large coal deposit on the Kaipairowitz Plateau, but itโ€™s exceedingly unlikely that anyone would be interested in mining it given the faulty economics of coal.

One thing you can be sure of is that none of this will go unchallenged. The tribal nations that proposed the designation of Bears Ears and other national monuments will sue to keep them intact, and advocacy groups and land and water protectors will support them and take the administration to court over its flouting of environmental laws.

A look across Glen Canyon National Recreation Area and into Bears Ears National Monument from the Little Rockies. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

๐ŸŒต Public Lands ๐ŸŒฒ

For many people, the mention of Glen Canyon National Recreation Area evokes images of Lake Powell and all that entails: boats plying the blue-sky-reflecting waters and the sandstone cliffs and formations that rise up from the murky depths. That makes sense, given that the national park unit was established because the reservoir was there in 1972.

Yet the reservoir makes up just 13% of the 1.25 million-acre recreation area. The remaining 87% contains some of the more remote and spectacular country in the lower 48, shares borders with a half-dozen other national parks and monuments, and makes up the core of the Moab to Mojave Conservation Corridor.

So, the manner in which the area is managed matters โ€” a lot. And for five decades after the recreation areaโ€™s establishment, off-road vehicle travel went virtually unmanaged, allowing for a destructive free-for-all along shorelines and in remote parts of the recreation area. In 2018, the Park Service released a plan that more or less codified the pre-plan anarchy. Environmentalists sued and forced the Park Service back to the drawing board.

This January the Park Service finally issued an amended rule celebrated by conservationists for adding protections to some of GCNRAโ€™s more sensitive areas from motorized vehicle travel (this does not affect boating, by the way). It bars OHV-riding yahoos from roaring around the lakeโ€™s shore unheeded, and restricts motorized travel in the Orange Cliffs area on the north end of the recreation area adjacent to the Maze in Canyonlands.

The off-road vehicle lobby, however, was unhappy with the added restrictions, and they took their victim-complex grievances to the Utah congressional delegation, all of whom appear to have a fetish for fossil-fueled combustion-engines. Now the plan and the recreation area are being put in jeopardy by โ€” you guessed it โ€” those same Utah politicians. Sens. John Curtis and Mike Lee, along with Rep. Celeste Maloy, are asking Congress to revoke the rule under the Congressional Review Act and to prohibit the Park Service from implementing similar protections in the future.

๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ Messing with Maps ๐Ÿงญ

The National Parks Conservation Association created a nifty map showing active mining claims and mines near national parks and national monuments. It gives a good sense of how vulnerable some areas might be to new mining claims and projects if the Trump administration goes ahead with shrinking the aforementioned national monuments. You can look at the interactive version here.

One note of caution: An active mining claim โ‰  a valid mining claim. An active claim simply means it has been located and filed, and that the claimant has paid their annual maintenance fee. The validity of a claim, on the other hand, depends on the discovery of a valuable mineral deposit there, which must be demonstrated. Rights to mine are only attached to valid claims.


Parting Poem

Hereโ€™s another one from Richard Sheltonโ€™s Selected Poems, 1969-1981.

A Grim Signal: Atmospheric CO2 Soared in 2024 — Bob Berwyn (InsideClimateNews.org)

Jรคnschwalde Power Station in 2004. Note two 300 meter chimneys, which have since been demolished. By Ra Boe – Own work DigiCam C2100UZ, CC BY-SA 2.5, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=307842

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Bob Berwyn):

April 24, 2025

Scientists are worried because they canโ€™t fully explain the big jump, but they think it might mean that carbon absorption by forests, fields and wetlands is slowing downโ€”a major problem for the world.

The latest anomaly in the climate system that canโ€™t be fully explained by researchers is a record annual jump in the global mean concentration of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere measured in 2024.

The concentration, measured in parts per million, has been increasing rapidly since human civilizations started burning coal and oil in the mid-1800s from the pre-industrial level of 280 ppm. 

In recent decades, the increase has often been in annual increments of 1 to 2 ppm. But last year, the increase measured by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administrationโ€™s Global Monitoring Laboratory was 3.75 ppm, according to the labโ€™s early April update of atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations.

That brings the annual mean global concentration close to 430 ppm, about 40 percent more than the pre-industrial level, and enough to heat the planet by about 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit (1.5 degrees Celsius). Climate researchers have noted that the continuing increase of global CO2 emissions means the world will probably not be able to reach the Paris Agreement target of limiting warming to 2.7 degrees Fahrenheit above the pre-industrial level.

โ€œItโ€™s definitely worrying to see such a large jump in 2024,โ€ said Berkeley Earth climate researcher Zeke Hausfather. โ€œWhile itโ€™s not surprising to set new records given global emissions have yet to peak, and there are generally higher ppm increases in El Niรฑo years, 2024 was still anomalous for just how large it was.โ€

El Niรฑo refers to the warm phase of a tropical Pacific Ocean cycle thatโ€™s formally called the El Niรฑo Southern Oscillation. During other recent El Niรฑo phases, like in 1998 and 2016, the annual CO2 increase was about 3 ppm, Hausfather said.

โ€œBecause we know the magnitude of emissions and the ocean sink does not vary that much year to year, this has to reflect a weakening of the land sink,โ€ he said, referring to the amount of carbon absorbed by terrestrial ecosystems like forests and wetlands. Those ecosystems did still take up some carbon last year, he noted, but the land sink was the weakest since 1998, when it touched zero, and 1987, when it was a net emitter of CO2.

Even if the growth rate slows again in 2025, he said, โ€œthe worry is that this yearโ€™s jump might include [non-El Niรฑo] factors like temperature responses from soils and vegetation that might persist or intensify as the Earth warms.โ€

The unprecedented increase of atmospheric CO2 is just one of several red lights flashing on the climate dashboard. 

This graph shows the annual mean growth rates of carbon dioxide, with decadal averages shown as horizontal lines across the bars. The largest spike shown in 2024, represents an annual increase of 3.75 parts per million of carbon dioxide in the air. It is the largest yearly increase since measurements started in the 1950s. Credit: NOAA

Others include the 2023-2024 spike of the global average surface temperature, which has also not been fully explained, and the fact that Earthโ€™s average temperature has stayed above a 2.7 degree Fahrenheit temperature target set by the Paris Agreement for 20 of the last 21 months. Additionally, the combined sea ice extent in both polar regions has dropped to record or near-record lows the last few years, which means Earth is losing some of its biggest heat shields.

In recent years, NOAA publicized the annual updates to the global greenhouse gas index with press releases and explanatory articles on its website, and the agency was set to do the same this year, said Tom Di Liberto, a former NOAA public affairs specialist who was fired by the Trump administration in late February along with hundreds of other NOAA staffers.

โ€œThat article was written, and then it was taken down by the current political communications leader of NOAA because it would not make the administration happy,โ€ he said. โ€œNOAA is likely to still be doing the work internally, but itโ€™s very unlikely you will see stuff coming out of NOAA like you had in the past.โ€

NOAA did not provide answers to Inside Climate Newsโ€™ questions about this yearโ€™s increase.

Climate scientist Michael Mann, director of the Center for Science, Sustainability & the Media at the University of Pennsylvania, said the CO2 spike may reflect the post-COVID emissions bounce as economies restarted after lockdowns, but he said the general expectation is that emissions will start to plateau this year, largely driven by decarbonization by China and other countries. 

โ€œIโ€™ve seen the claim made that decreased uptake by natural sinks and wildfire emissions might have played a role,โ€ he said. โ€œBut my view is that this may be a misinterpretation of the fleeting impacts of extended, major El Niรฑo events like 2023-2024.โ€

James Hansen, an adjunct professor at Columbia Universityโ€™s Earth Institute and director of the Program on Climate Science, Awareness and Solutions, said the 2024 CO2 increase is not surprising, given continued record-high emissions from fossil fuels, as well as the record-warm oceans.

โ€œSimilar increases have occurred with lesser emissions, but stronger El Niรฑos,โ€ he said. โ€œItโ€™s not all gloom and doom. The airborne fraction of emissions has actually trended downward over the past several decades, so once we begin to reduce emissions, we should be able to get the growth rate of CO2 to decline.โ€

As President Trump pushes public land sales, advocates rally: Broad support for public lands in the West is forcing some Republicans to break with the White House — Zoรซ Rom (High Country News)

Juan Bautista de Anza National Historic Trail goes through lands managed by the Bureau of Land Management in Arizona. Bob Wick/BLM

Click the link to read the article on the High Country News website (Zoรซ Rom):

April 23, 2025

Selling off federal public lands, once a fringe idea, is now gaining traction among Republicans in Congress, the courts and in the White House. President Donald Trump has proposed using the money from such sales to offset the cost of extending his 2017 tax cuts, which would massively increase the federal budget.

In March, the U.S. Senate narrowly voted down an amendment that would have banned selling public land to balance the federal budget. Around the same time, the House adopted new rules that, opponents say, quietly lowered the bar for disposing of such lands.

โ€œRepublicansโ€™ plans to sell off our public lands to pay for tax handouts for their billionaire donors is an outrageous slap in the face to all of us,โ€ New Mexico Sen. Martin Heinrich, D, who sponsored the amendment blocking those sales, told High Country News in a statement.

Under the revised rules, legislation authorizing the sale of land managed by agencies such as the U.S. Forest Service, Bureau of Land Management and National Park Service would no longer require assigning a dollar value to the property first โ€” a change that would make it much easier for lawmakers to introduce and pass such bills without triggering fiscal scrutiny. All this comes at a time when recent mass layoffs have further destabilized the agencies tasked with managing public lands.

โ€œThe threats have never been higher,โ€ said Land Tawney, executive director of American Hunters and Anglers, a nonpartisan network of public-lands advocates. โ€œPoliticians are saying things out loud about divesting our public lands with more vigor and publicly. The threats are real.โ€

Canyons surrounding the Owyhee River, Oregon, on BLM land. Bob Wick/BLM

But even as these ideas gain traction in the GOP, most Americans, regardless of their political belief remain largely united in their love for the nationโ€™s public lands, especially in the Western U.S. This has forced some Republicans to break with the national party on the issue, setting the stage for what could become an unusual political alliance.

THE ATTACKS ON public lands began immediately after Trump took office in January. Staffing cuts implemented by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) have disproportionately impacted land-management agencies. Critics say these staffing reductions are part of a deliberate strategy to undermine the agenciesโ€™ ability to manage their lands effectively, thereby paving the way for privatization.

โ€œIโ€™m really concerned about what I see as a deliberate effort to set federal land management agencies up to fail. Once they fail, itโ€™s not such a stretch to say, โ€˜Well, someone else could do a better job,โ€™โ€ said Susan Brown, a lawyer at Silvix Resources, a nonprofit legal group that focuses on public lands and environmental governance. [ed. emphasis mine]

The Trump administration โ€” working with Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner โ€” has launched a joint task force to identify โ€œunderutilizedโ€ federal lands suitable for residential development, arguing that selling off these acres could help solve the nationwide housing shortage.

Critics argue that this idea is simply an excuse to open the door to privatization, as well as being a poor solution to the housing crisis. A new report from the Center for American Progress found that in the 10 Western states with the most BLM-managed land, less than 1% of that land is located within 10 miles of a population center, and much of it is unlikely to be suitable for sale or development.

Opponents also note thatย the Republican-led effortsย risk alienating a bipartisan base that supports public lands. Recent polling from Colorado College shows that 72% of Westerners prioritize conservation over development regardless of political affiliation. Public opinion has been consistent on this for years.

Over 70% of Republicans and more than 90% of Democrats agree that public lands are essential for their stateโ€™s economy, according to the same poll. Even in conservative-leaning states like Wyoming and Utah, strong majorities oppose the idea of selling public lands or reducing their protections. Another recent poll, this one from YouGov, found that 74% of Americans oppose the sale of public lands, including 61% of the Trump voters polled.

Portrait of Congressman Mike Simpson. By Mike Simpson U.S. House Office – Public Domain

The knowledge that so many of their constituents favor keeping public lands public has put Western Republicans at odds with the administration and the national party. In March, Montanaโ€™s Republican Sens. Steve Daines and Tim Sheehy voted with the Democratic minority in the unsuccessful attempt to block sales of federal land. Around the same time, Idaho Rep. Mike Simpson, a Republican, introduced the Public Lands in Public Hands Act, a bill that would prevent the Department of the Interior from selling or transferring public lands. His co-sponsors included Montana Republican Ryan Zinke as well as New Mexico Democrat Gabe Vasquezโ€‹.

This isnโ€™t Zinkeโ€™s first defection on the issue. In 2016, the former Interior secretary withdrew as a delegate to the Republican National Convention, citing his objection to the partyโ€™s platform, which proposed transferring federal public lands to state control.

Colorado Republican Lauren Boebert of Colorado told HCN that she is trying to strike a balance on the issue. โ€œI stand with the far majority of Coloradans who see and believe in the value of protecting our public lands,โ€ she said in a statement provided by her office. At the same time, Boebert added that she rejected โ€œthe idea that these public lands must be completely locked up from reasonable economic development and responsible energy exploration.โ€ Utah Sen. Mike Lee, chairman of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, did not respond to HCNโ€™s requests for comment.

Across the West, Democrats and conservation advocates have used the threat of public land transfers to galvanize support. Protests against potential sales have erupted in various state capitols, including Idaho and Colorado, as well as at Arches National Park. Meanwhile, major outdoor brands are trying to rally recreationists around the issue. Earlier this month, more than 70 businesses launched an initiative called Brands for Public Lands, headlined by Patagonia and Black Diamond. The group is helping people contact their congressional representatives and urge them to oppose public land sales.

โ€œThe overwhelming majority (of Americans) want to keep public lands in public hands. Itโ€™s where we hunt, fish, gather berries, mountain bike, hike, float and just go escape,โ€ said Tawney. โ€œItโ€™s all of our backyards, and I have confidence that the people will stand united.โ€โ€‹

This map shows land owned by different federal government agencies. By National Atlas of the United States – http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/fedlands.html, “All Federal and Indian Lands”, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32180954

Despite DOGE at Interior, Yellowstone staffing โ€˜higher than last yearโ€™ — Angus M. Thuermer Jr. (WyoFile.com)

Yellowstone park workers help search for a lost hiker on Eagle Peak in 2024. (Cam Sholly/Yellowstone National Park)

Click the link to read the article on the WyoFile.com website (Angus M. Thuermer Jr.):

April 22, 2025

Oilfield executive takes charge of consolidating workforce of 70,000 at national parks, BLM, Fish and Wildlife Service.

Five days into the Trump administrationโ€™s DOGE takeover of the Department of Interiorโ€™s policy, management and budget, Yellowstone National Park staffing is โ€œhigher than last year,โ€ an Interior Department spokesperson in Washington, D.C. said Monday.

โ€‹โ€‹Yellowstone Park confirmed the increase. โ€œGoing into this year, we should have a total of 769 NPS employees,โ€ park spokeswoman Linda Veress said in an email, up from 748 last year. During the parkโ€™s record year for visitation in 2021, the parkโ€™s workforce numbered 693 permanent and seasonal workers.

โ€œWe had an outstanding opening weekend, and it was great to see everyone enjoying the park,โ€ Yellowstone Park Superintendent Cam Sholly said in an email Monday. โ€œThe plow crews are working hard to clear the remainder of the parkโ€™s roads from snow, and we are on schedule for our normal sequenced opening in the upcoming weeks, including the Beartooth Highway.โ€

After personally greeting the seasonโ€™s first visitors at the West Entrance on Friday, Sholly reported the opening weekend drew 8,324 vehicles from there and the North Entrance at Mammoth, the only two entrances that have opened so far. Thatโ€™s an increase of more than 11% from last year and put the weekend rush, unofficially Sholly said, at 21,642.

The staffing and opening weekend updates came as Secretary of the Interior Doug Burgum put an oilfield executive in charge of โ€œconsolidation, unification and optimization of administrative functionsโ€ at the 70,000-person agency last week. Burgum, earlier this year, named Tyler Hassen as assistant secretary for policy, management and budget. Now Hassen will oversee Burgumโ€™s consolidation order as the Trump administrationโ€™s DOGE plan to shrink the size of the federal government advances.

Burgumโ€™s appointment of Hassen and the consolidation order sparked worries in the conservation community, including at the Center for Western Priorities. The Denver-based nonpartisan conservation and advocacy organization accused the secretary of abdicating his responsibilities by not reserving any authority over firings or requiring any reporting by Hassen.

โ€œIf Doug Burgum doesnโ€™t want this job, he should quit now,โ€ said Jennifer Rokala, executive director of Western Priorities. โ€œInstead, it looks like Burgum plans to sit by the fire eating warm cookies while Elon Muskโ€™s lackeys dismantle our national parks and public lands,โ€ she said in a statement.

โ€œWarm cookiesโ€ refers to a report in The Atlantic that Burgumโ€™s chief of staff told political appointees to learn to bake cookies for their boss.

But potential visitors to the worldโ€™s first national park need not worry, said J. Elizabeth Peace, a spokesperson at Burgumโ€™s office.

โ€œVisitors can expect the same great service they had in years past,โ€ Peace wrote in an email Monday. โ€œ[I]n some National Parks, like at Yellowstone National Park, staffing numbers are higher than last year.โ€

Peace made her reassurances as regional business owners fret over the upcoming tourism season in Yellowstone, at neighboring Grand Teton and across Wyoming. Overseas traveler numbers to the U.S. dropped 11.6% in March after Trump tariffs, tariff threats, indiscriminate DOGE firings, resignations and economic turmoil battered expectations.

Oilman

The order Burgum issued Thursday gives Hassen, now an assistant secretary, authority over the departmentโ€™s Working Capital Fund, an office that in 2023 provided $119 million for department functions. Hassen will be able to rewrite manuals outlining employee responsibilities and may transfer funds, programs, records and property, according to the order.

Burgumโ€™s order described his actions as furthering Trumpโ€™s February initiative for โ€œimplementing the presidentโ€™s โ€˜Department of Government Efficiencyโ€™ workforce optimization.โ€

In addition to great service at national parks, Bureau of Land Management lands in Wyoming remain welcoming, Peace wrote. โ€œVisitors to BLM-managed public lands can expect continued access and service across recreation sites, trails and campgrounds,โ€ her email reads. โ€œWe are implementing necessary reforms to ensure fiscal responsibility, operational efficiency and government accountability.โ€

Burgum and DOGEโ€™s โ€œunification effortโ€ will accelerate technology, enhance the mission to preserve parks and historic sites, serve Native American tribes and manage department holdings in Wyoming, Burgumโ€™s order states. All told, the Department of the Interior manages 2.34 million acres of national park system lands, 18.4 million acres of BLM property and 70,000 acres of Fish and Wildlife Service reserves in the state. 

In Wyoming, Interior-managed land accounts for a third of the stateโ€™s area or about 21 million acres.

Hassen, a Deerfield Academy prep and Princeton grad, was CEO of Basin Energy, a Houston-based international oilfield services company, according to his LinkedIn profile. Before that, he worked for Wenzel Downhole Tools, Basin Power, and served as chairman of the associate board of the nonprofit Cancer Research Institute in New York. He was an associate involved in global energy investment banking at Morgan Stanley in New York and London from 2005-2008, according to his profile.

He emerged on the DOGE scene after the Los Angeles fires in January when President Trump said California Gov. Gavin Newsom compounded the firefighting problem by not diverting water to southern California. Critics said DOGE conflated agricultural diversions, needs of the endangered Sacramento-San Joaquin Estuary delta smelt and firefighting. 

Unqualified?

Western Priorities said DOGE efforts assign inexpert people to inappropriate positions.

โ€œSince Elon Musk is now effectively in charge of Americaโ€™s public lands, itโ€™s up to Congress and the American people to stand up and demand oversight,โ€ Rokalaโ€™s statement reads. โ€œDOGEโ€™s unelected bureaucrats in Washington have no idea how to staff a park, a wildlife refuge, or a campground. They have no idea how to manage a forest or prepare for fires in the wildland-urban interface. But Doug Burgum just gave DOGE free rein over all of that.โ€

This map shows land owned by different federal government agencies. By National Atlas of the United States – http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/fedlands.html, “All Federal and Indian Lands”, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32180954

With future funding of #Coloradoโ€™s water projects uncertain, lawmakers begin to hunt for solutions — The #GlenwoodSprings Post Independent

A view of the popular Pumphouse campground, boat put-in and the upper Colorado River. Photo credit: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

Click the link to read the article on the Glenwood Springs Post Independent website (Robert Tann). Here’s an excerpt:

April 21, 2025

With a critical source of funding for Coloradoโ€™s water projects facing an uncertain future, lawmakers want to task a group of experts with providing recommendations for solutions.ย  Severance taxes, which are imposed on nonrenewable energy extraction like oil drilling and coal mining, have long served as a key source of revenue for water-related initiatives. The funding stream, however, is also one of the stateโ€™s most volatile due to extreme swings in the energy market. Over the past two decades, tax revenue hasย gone from skyrocketing one year to plummetingย the next. The issue has compounded in recent years due to state budget writers siphoning some of the money to help balance the stateโ€™s spending plan. In response, a bipartisan group of lawmakers is advancing legislation that would commission a study on the future of severance tax revenue and ways the state can better fund its water needs. Senate Bill 40ย [SB25-040] would create a nine-member task force within the Department of Natural Resources to find answers to the question. The measure is sponsored by Sens. Dylan Roberts, D-Frisco, and Cleave Simpson, R-Alamosa, as well as Reps. Karen McCormick, D-Longmont, and Matthew Martinez, D-Monte Vista.ย Roberts said the group will consider any and all ideas,ย not just around severance taxes, for how to make Coloradoโ€™s water funding more stable. The task force would then submit a final report in July 2026 to help create potential bills or recommendations for the Joint Budget Committee in future legislative sessions.ย 

President Trump looks to make the BLM the Bureau of Livestock and Mining Again: Plus: Clearing up confusion over oil and gas lease reviews — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Located in a remote area of the Vermilion Cliffs National Monument (Arizona), White Pocket area is a hidden treasure of swirling, twisting Navajo sandstone. Photo credit: Department of Interior Facebook page

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

April 18, 2025

๐ŸŒต Public Lands ๐ŸŒฒ

In what came as no surprise to just about anyone, the Trump administration moved this week to rescind the Bureau of Land Managementโ€™s Conservation & Landscape Health Rule. The Public Lands Rule, as it is commonly known, was implemented last year by the Biden administration to put conservation on a par with other federal land uses, such as energy development, grazing, and mining.

The administration announced the intention to revoke the rule quietly at reginfo.gov rather than, as is its wont, with some inanely named executive order, and it doesnโ€™t give any specifics as to how or under what authority it would eliminate the rule. Yet if Trump were to issue a specific order, it might be titled: โ€œMAKING THE BLM THE BUREAU OF LIVESTOCK AND MINING AGAIN!โ€

Yet it is not at all clear what effect the rollback might have on the ground, chiefly because the impacts of the rule, itself, remain unclear since there hasnโ€™t even been time to truly implement it yet.

When the rule was first proposed in 2023, it was met with mixed reactions from the environmental community, some of who saw it as largely ineffective, and harsh rebukes from the livestock and energy industries and their political enablers.

The National Cattlemenโ€™s Beef Association called the rule a โ€œcapitulation to the extremist environmental groups who want to eradicate grazing from the landscape,โ€ and Sen. John Barrasso, the Wyoming Republican, compared the bureaucrats who wrote the โ€œdecreeโ€ to the tree-spiking eco-warriors of the 1980s.

Yet it is hardly radical. In essence, the rule simply reiterates and reminds us of what Congress intended when it included the multiple-use mandate in the Federal Land Policy Management Act of 1976, the law that created the modern framework for modern public land oversight (and that endeavored to rid the BLM of the โ€œlivestock and miningโ€ monicker).

Multiple use, according to the law, is public lands management that โ€œwill best meet the present and future needs of the American peopleโ€ and allows for โ€œa combination of balanced and diverse resource uses that takes into account the long-term needs of future generations โ€ฆ including โ€ฆ recreation, range, timber, minerals, watershed, wildlife and fish, and natural scenic, scientific and historical values.โ€

So, yes, the BLM is required to accommodate recreation, grazing, and mining, but also, must manage the land for the sake of watersheds, wildlife, and natural values โ€” i.e. conservation.

The rule aims to carry out this mandate by:

  • directing the agency to prioritize landscape health in all decision making, which is what itโ€™s already supposed to do when assessing grazing allotments;
  • creating a mechanism for outside entities โ€” states, tribes, or nonprofits โ€” to lease public land for restoration projects, much as a rancher or oil and gas company might lease BLM land (but only on parcels that arenโ€™t already leased/claimed for other uses);
  • allowing firms to lease land for mitigation work to offset impacts from development elsewhere (again, these would not override existing, valid rights);
  • clarifying the designation process for areas of critical environmental concern, or ACECs, where land managers can add extra regulations to protect cultural or natural resources; and,
  • directing the agency to incorporate Indigenous knowledge into decision-making, particularly when considering ACECs.

Really it is more of a tool than a rule. That is, it gives third parties and agency state and field office staffers a mechanism to step up conservation on some lands, but does not create any new restrictions that would interfere with other uses. And thereโ€™s simply no way this tool could be used to โ€œeradicateโ€ grazing or drilling or any other use, as the hyperbolists claim, even if BLM personnel wanted to โ€” and history shows they do not. In fact, the mitigation leases could be used to facilitate other development by allowing, say, solar or oil and gas companies to โ€œoffsetโ€ the damage inflicted by utility-scale arrays or drilling projects.

So rescinding the rule really amounts to tossing a brand new tool out the window before it even got used. On the one hand, weโ€™re not necessarily going to miss the tool. But simply discarding it is also totally senseless and a waste that benefits no one, even Trumpโ€™s oil and gas executive buddies. But as weโ€™ve pointed out before, Trumpโ€™s haphazard policymaking is more about spite, vindictiveness, and cruelty than common sense. [ed. emphasis mine]

***

Drill rig and Raplee Ridge. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Last week, a friend sent me an email with the subject line: โ€œnot a fan of bureaucracy, but this is not good.โ€ย In the message, she had cut and pasted this headline fromย National Parks Traveler:

Yes, it is bad. No, itโ€™s not as bad as the headline makes it sound (though the confusion is understandable).

The story came from a brief Interior Department press release announcing it โ€œwill no longer pursue lengthy analysis for oil and gas leasing decisions in seven states.โ€ That sure sounds like they are dropping environmental reviews for all oil and gas leases in the West. And plenty of news outlets and social media posters interpreted it as such.

Thatโ€™s not the case. At least not yet.

The press release was referring to the revocation of a specific environmental review for 3,244 oil and gas leases that date as far back as the Obama-era. The leases were issued as the result of 74 lease sale decisions between 2015 and 2020. Environmental groups filed multiple lawsuits, saying the original environmental reviews were inadequate. The courts agreed, remanding the decisions back to the BLM for more thorough reviews that included analysis of greenhouse gas emissions, social cost of carbon, and other impacts. .

In January the Biden administration decided to lump all of the leases together and prepare a new, comprehensive environmental impact statement for the whole lot that would incorporate current science and public input.

Trumpโ€™s Interior Department decided the review went against the administrationโ€™s โ€œenergy dominanceโ€ agenda and related executive orders, so it cancelled the EIS. According to the press release, the BLM is now โ€œevaluating options for compliance with the National Environmental Policy Act for these oil and gas leasing decisions.โ€ What that means isnโ€™t clear, even to BLM officials, and the industry is confused as well.

If the agency issues the leases without further review, you can bet the same groups that sued โ€” and won โ€” the first time will go for a repeat performance. Meanwhile, environmental analyses are ongoing for future oil and gas lease sales (I checked). Thatโ€™s not to say that they will be adequate, however.


๐Ÿ—บ๏ธ Messing with Maps ๐Ÿงญ

The Center for American Progress has put together a nice, but disturbing, interactive map illustrating the myriad ways DOGE is slashing federal spending and harming communities across the nation. You can click on a congressional district and get a list of specific grants that have been revoked and leases that have been cancelled.

๐Ÿคฃ๐Ÿ™„๐Ÿค”๐Ÿคช

I went down the oddest wormhole the other day when I stumbled upon the Google reviews for none other than the Cholla coal power plant near Joseph City, Arizona. That an industrial facility even has starred reviews is weird enough, and possibly yet another sign of the apocalypse. But this one, I happened to notice in passing, has 138 reviews with an average four star rating. Obviously I had to check them out.

And let me tell you, they are something. Each and every one is really special. I have no idea which ones are sincere and which ones ironic. All I know is that read together, it is an epic poem. You should look at them all, but for now Iโ€™ll share some of my favorites.

Data Dump: Making coal “beautiful” again: President Trump’s efforts to restart the dirty and declining industry won’t work again — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Dragline at the Navajo Mine in New Mexico. The Navajo Nation-owned Navajo Transitional Energy Company owns the mine along with two mines in the Powder River Basin. Navajo Nation Buu Nygren was on hand to cheer on Trump as he signed the pro-coal executive orders. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

April 11, 2025

The News: This week, President Donald Trump signed a slew of executive orders that wipe away environmental protections in the name of saving โ€œbeautiful, cleanโ€ coal from what Trump and his minions call a regulatory โ€œwar on energy.โ€ The purpose, he says, is to make the grid more reliable and to ensure there is adequate generating capacity to meet AI-powering and cryptocurrency mining data centersโ€™ burgeoning power demand.

The orders:

  • Designate coal as a โ€œmineralโ€ so that it qualifies for regulatory relief under Trumpโ€™s pro-mining executive order, and suggest designating coal as a โ€œcritical materialโ€ due to its use in steel making. (As if thatโ€™s going to do anything?)
  • Orders the secretaries of Interior, Agriculture, and Energy to identify coal resources on federal lands and any impediments to extracting them, and propose โ€œpolicies to address such impediments and ultimately enable the mining of such coal resources by either private or public actors.โ€ (Publicย actors? Does this mean what I think it means: The feds are going to start coal mining? Maybe theyโ€™ll just nationalize the industry โ€”ย Hello comrade Trump!ย โ€” to wipe away all so-called impediments, of which there are very few, by the way.)
  • Orders the Interior Secretary to lift barriers to mining coal on federal lands, including definitively ending an Obama-era moratorium on new coal leasing and the Biden-era halting of new leases in the Powder River Basin. (These are only speculative โ€œbarriersโ€ because existing leases hold enough coal to meet current levels of demand for another 40 years โ€” and demand is likely to keep dropping, meaning coal companies probably would never be affected by the leasing freeze).
  • Encourages coal exports. (Umm, yeah, you should have thought about that before all of this tariff talk, dude.)
  • Looks to identify regions where โ€œcoal-powered infrastructure is available and suitable for supporting AI data centers and assess โ€ฆ the potential for expanding coal-based infrastructure to power data centers โ€ฆ .โ€
  • Exempts some coal power plants from Biden-era Mercury and Air Toxics Standards for two years.
  • Looks to prevent large power sources โ€œfrom leaving the bulk-power system or converting the source of fuel of such generation resource if such conversion would result in a net reduction in accredited generating capacity.โ€ (He wants to block utilities from retiring or converting or old coal plants to run on cheaper, cleaner fuels.)

The Context: Letโ€™s just get a couple things straight right off the bat. First, there are no significant regulatory barriers to mining coal. Arch, Peabody, Navajo Transitional Energy Company, and a handful of other companies have leases on and essentially unfettered access to billions of tons of coal at their gargantuan Powder River Basin mines. They could continue tearing apart the earth for decades before needing to lease more land, making Bidenโ€™s freeze on future leasing โ€” and Trumpโ€™s unfreezing of it โ€” speculative and symbolic.

In Bidenโ€™s case, it symbolized his desire to do something about the climate crisis and to cement a legacy as an environmentally minded president; for Trump itโ€™s all about fossil fuel fetishization.

Coal mine production has been dropping due to declining demand: Utilities simply arenโ€™t burning as much coal as they used to, in part because itโ€™s dirty, but mostly because the shale revolution โ€” i.e. โ€œfrackingโ€ โ€” has resulted in a natural gas supply glut, bringing the cost of the slightly cleaner-burning fuel below that of coal. More recently, increasingly affordable wind and solar power have also been displacing coal โ€” and gas โ€” generation from the grid.

So rolling back regulations on mining is useless if youโ€™re trying to spur production. The only way to do that is get utilities to go against their own financial interests and burn more coal.

Thatโ€™s where some of the other provisions in the orders come in. By exempting coal plants from the MATS rule for two years, Trump is opening the door for facilities such as the Colstrip coal plant in Montana to continue to operate without expensive new pollution control equipment. Colstrip is considered one of the dirtiest facilities in the nation, spewing harmful emissions from its smokestack and in the form of coal combustion waste.

The Cholla coal plant near Joseph City, Arizona. Trump said his executive order would save it from destruction. But its operator has already shut it down and shows no interest in burning coal there. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Trump mentioned the Cholla coal plant near Holbrook, Arizona, as one that he would โ€œsaveโ€ from โ€œdestruction,โ€ adding, โ€œWe’re going to have that plant opening and burning the clean coal, beautiful clean coal, in a very short period of time.โ€ But its operator, Arizona Public Service, said it has already procured cleaner, cheaper replacement generation for the plant, and indicated it has no desire to keep burning coal there. Meanwhile, even before the orders, PacifiCorp backed off on plans to retire some of its coal plants in the next several years, citing projected increased demand and easing regulations.

The big question mark is how the provision aiming to prevent coal plants from shutting down will play out. It seems illegal to force a utility to keep a power plant running, but then that hasnโ€™t gotten in Trumpโ€™s way before. Still, the most all of these efforts can hope to achieve is to slow the decline of the coal industry for a few years. Itโ€™s certainly not going to bring back the Navajo Generating Sation, the Nucla Station, the San Juan Generating Station, the Escalante coal plant, or the Mohave plant from the dead.

Now for the data! Click on the images to see a larger version.

The rise and fall of the U.S. thermal coal industry. For five decades, coal consumption was directly tied to electricity generation, with both peaking in 2007. But the financial crisis slowed electricity demand, and opened the door for burgeoning new supplies of increasingly affordable natural gas to dethrone King Coal from the energy mix, decoupling coal consumption from electricity demand, and itโ€™s been downhill for the industry ever since, with the steepest declines coming during the first Trump administration. Data source: Energy Information Administration. Graphic: Land Desk.
Coal fueled the colonization and industrialization of the Western U.S., but by the 1950s it was in serious trouble as locomotives switched to diesel, homes and businesses chose to cook and heat with natural gas, and utilities opted for hydropower. Government intervention helped spur coalโ€™s revival (see next graph for Wyoming figures and annotations). Source: USGS and EIA. Graphic: Land Desk.
One of the reasons folks like coal is because itโ€™s labor intensive and offers relatively stable, high-wage employment to a lot of people in rural areas without too many other opportunities. But coal industry employment doesnโ€™t always match up with production thanks to automation and efficiency upgrades. Annotations are below. Data Sources: Wyoming State Geological Survey, EIA, Wyoming Workforce Services. Graph: Land Desk.
  1. 1920: Wyoming coal industry hits peak employment, with 9,000 employees working in coal mines during a time when less than 200,000 people lived in the state. A few years later, a Wyoming newspaper noted: โ€œNext to food, coal and iron are of first importance to mankind.โ€
  2. Drilling for natural gas gets underway in New Mexico and Texas, and the gas is piped into towns for heating and cooking, displacing coal. A 1927ย Steamboat Pilotย headline about a gas pipeline from Texas to Denver, Colorado, read: โ€œNatural gas would injure coal industry.โ€
  3. 1940: Electro Motive Division of General Motors unveils a diesel freight locomotive, but it is slow to catch on and in 1944 the steam engine still dominated, with the railroad industry consuming 152 million tons of coal per year.
  4. Heightened industrial activity during World War II briefly drove up coal consumption and production.
  5. Late 1940s: Development of high-voltage transmission lines that can carry electricity long distances, which will ultimately be a boon for coal power.
  6. 1950s: Coal consumption in the West plummets by 40 percent as highways replace rails, and diesel locomotives replace coal-fired ones. More long-distance gas pipelines are built from Texas and New Mexico oil fields to population centers, making it easier for residents and institutions to ditch coal for heating and cooking. More than half of the Westโ€™s electricity is generated by hydroelectric dams, with coal only providing 10%. The coal industry had made a lot of cash and built up a lot of political power over the years, however, which they used to lean on government to look for new markets for their product.
  7. 1952: Bureau of Reclamation releases A Study Of Future Power Transmission in the West, calling for the buildup of large coal-fired power plants in the Interior West, which would then send electricity to faraway population centers. It said, โ€œโ€ฆ the growth of power in the West will be so great that increasing dependence on its main fuel resource, coal, is inevitable.โ€
  8. 1960: Congress establishes the Office of Coal Research โ€œto encourage and stimulate the production and conservation of coal in the United Statesโ€ฆโ€ and to โ€œmaximize the contribution of coal to the overall energy market.โ€
  9. Sierra Club, Friends of the Earth and other environmental groups join with the coal industry and coal-state leaders in opposition to new hydroelectric dams. The Sierra Club actively supports the construction of Navajo Generating Station as a preferable alternative to a new dam in the Grand Canyon. Several other coal-fired plants are built across the West.
  10. The Clean Air Act is passed, actually helping Western coal because itโ€™s low in sulfur, and therefore emits less sulfur dioxide when burned.
  11. Energy Crises erupt, spurring calls for โ€œenergy independence.โ€ This includes mining for coal and government subsidies to develop synfuels, or gasoline or diesel from coal and other materials, like oil shale.
  12. 1977: ARCO opens Black Thunder mine in the Powder River Basin. It will become the largest coal mine in the world and the first to transport 1 billion tons of coal.
  13. 1978 Industrial Fuels Power Act more or less kills the construction of new natural gas power plants, locking in coal as the fuel of choice for electricity generation for the long-term.
  14. Even as coal production climbs, the number of employees in the industry drops due to mechanization and the migration of coal-mining from more labor-intensive underground mines to larger, surface strip mines such as those in the Powder River Basin.
  15. Reagan opens up foreign markets, kills subsidies, stops price controls and government prop-ups. Oil, natural gas, and uranium development crash, spreading economic malaise across the West. Coal falters in many parts of the West, including Wyoming, but the mines of the Powder River Basin continue to produce steadily.
  16. 1987: The Industrial Fuels Act is repealed, allowing for the buildup of natural gas plants. This doesnโ€™t have an immediate effect on coal because natural gas is still far more expensive, but it sets the stage for utilities to switch fuels in the decades to come.
  17. Clean Air Act amendments of 1990, which limit emissions of acid rain-causing sulfur dioxide, give a big boost to Western coal because of its relatively low sulfur content. Wyoming surpasses Appalachia as the nationโ€™s number one coal producer.
  18. 2001: Demand for electricity, and therefore for coal, climbed steadily nationwide for 50 years, experiencing just a few small hiccups in 1982, 1986 and, most dramatically, in 2001, due to a national recession. But it quickly recovered.
  19. 2008: The national financial crisis hits, putting a huge dent in consumption of both electricity and coal. At the same time, the price of natural gas plummets when the market is glutted with newly accessed gas from shale formations in Texas, North Dakota and the East.
  20. 2011: Wyoming hits peak coal-mine employment, even though electricity demand and coal consumption has yet to rebound.
  21. 2012-2016: Although electricity demand has plateaued, coal production goes into freefall as utilities start getting more and more power from natural gas plants and solar and wind. Mass layoffs hit Wyomingโ€™s coal industry, including in the Powder River Basin.
  22. 2018: U.S. electricity demand finally bounces back to pre-2008 levels. It doesnโ€™t help coal at all.
  23. 2017-2024: Despite the efforts of the Trump administration to prop up the coal industry by meddling in markets and rolling back environmental, public health and worker safety regulations, coal consumption, production and employment continue to fall. Bidenโ€™s โ€œwar on coalโ€ doesnโ€™t affect the slide.
Wyoming leaders cheered Trumpโ€™s pro-coal executive orders, in part because the industry plays such a large role in its economy. But things are changing, even in the Cowboy State. Construction, retail trade, health care, government work, and leisure and hospitality all outpace mining and drilling in terms of employment numbers. Graphic credit: The Land Desk


๐Ÿคฏ Crazytown Chronicle ๐Ÿคก

Yesterday, Kathleen Sgamma withdrew her name from consideration to run the Bureau of Land Management. Was it because the oil and gas lobbyist and advocate had a conflict of interest? Nope. Was it because she has spent much of her career battling the very agency she was chosen to helm? Nope.

Sgamma resigned because a watchdog group scandalously revealed that she actually has an inkling of morality. In the days following the Jan. 6, 2021, riots and invasion of the U.S. Capitol, Sgamma wrote that she was โ€œdisgusted by the violenceโ€ and โ€œPresident Trumpโ€™s role in spreading misinformation that incited it.โ€ She was hoping for a โ€œresurgence of sanity.โ€ That right there is enough to disqualify you from serving in this administration.

Iโ€™m anxiously awaiting to see whom Trump picks now.

Federal Water Tap, April 14, 2025: President Trump Signs Barrage of Water, Energy Executive Orders — Brett Walton (circleofblue.org)

Click the link to read the article on the Circle of Blue website (Brett Walton):

April 14, 2025

The Rundown

  • White House moves to cut funding for keystone federalย climate change reportย and targetsย โ€œunlawfulโ€ regulations.
  • President Trump signs an order to relaxย showerhead water efficiency standards.
  • Another order opposes state laws that impede hisย โ€œenergy dominanceโ€ visionย and seeks to invalidate them.
  • Yet another order requires agencies to put maximumย 5-year expiration datesย into existing energy and environmental laws.
  • EPA says it will review new studies of health outcomes fromย fluoridated drinking water.
  • Mexico says it will immediately release some water in theย Rio Grandeย basin.
April 1, 2025 seasonal water supply forecast summary. Credit: Colorado Basin River Forecast Center

And lastly, federal forecasts indicate a down year forย Colorado River runoffย and the riverโ€™s already depleted reservoirs.

โ€œThese State laws and policies are fundamentally irreconcilable with my Administrationโ€™s objective to unleash American energy.ย They should not stand.โ€ โ€“ย Executive orderย from President Donald Trump that takes aim at state climate change laws that limit carbon-emitting energy production. The order instructs the attorney general to identify state laws and policies that the Justice Department believes illegally impede energy projects, and then attempt to halt implementation of the laws. The order mentions nearly every type of energy source except solar and wind.

“The attorney general will prioritize investigating state laws that mention one of the administrationโ€™s many ideological bugbears: climate change; environmental, social, and governance initiatives; environmental justice; greenhouse gas emissions; and carbon taxes.:

Any merit to all this? No, says Ted Lamm of UC Berkeley School of Law. Accusations of state overreach in this arena are a โ€œmirage.โ€

By the Numbers

  • 67 Percent of Average: Most probable runoff into Lake Powell this year from the Colorado River, according to a federal forecast. The report covers the April-July period. The down year is not good news for Lake Powell (33 percent full) or Lake Mead (34 percent).
  • 4.1 Million Barrels Per Day: U.S. crude oil exports in 2024, a new annual record. Europe is now the biggest export market, after its decision in 2022 to ban Russian imports.

News Briefs

Rio Grande Water Negotiations
President Claudia Sheinbaum said Mexico would carry out โ€œimmediate deliveryโ€ of some water to the Rio Grande basin, an instance of trade politics influencing water policy, The Hill reports.

Under a 1944 treaty, Mexico is required over five years to deliver 1.75 million acre-feet from its side of the basin. It is far behind in the current cycle, even as deliveries have picked up this year in response to political pressure.

As of April 5, Mexico had delivered 512,604 acre-feet in this cycle.

Eliminating โ€œUnlawfulโ€ Regulations
Recent Supreme Court decisions โ€“ Sackett (wetlands), Ohio (air emissions), Loper Bright Enterprises (deference to agency expertise), among others โ€“ have curtailed the executive branchโ€™s regulatory powers. The White House now wants to institutionalize those rulings.

It will be action by subtraction, quickly.

Trump signed an executive order giving agencies 60 days to draw up a list of current โ€œunlawful and potentially unlawfulโ€ regulations and devise a plan to repeal them.

The order directs agencies to repeal these rules without public notice and comment periods, which are generally required by law. The order claims that because these unnamed rules are unlawful, getting rid of them merits an exemption from notice and comment.

Pressure Politics
Ticking a favored topic, Trump also signed an order to rescind Biden-era water conservation regulations for certain high-end showerheads.

The rule restricted multi-nozzle showerheads to a total flow rate of 2.5 gallons per minute, which has been the federal standard for showerheads since 1992. The flow rate could not apply to each nozzle individually, which would multiply water use.

The Trump administrationโ€™s previous attempt to allow multi-nozzle showerheads to flow at higher rates was criticized by the plumbing industry. IAPMO, a trade group, argued that plumbing systems in new buildings, which are built for conservation, could be undersized if higher water volumes are allowed.

Sunset Provisions
Another order seeks to cut existing and future regulations in a different way: by adding โ€œsunset provisionsโ€ that set an expiration date.

The order directs agencies to insert sunset provisions into bedrock environmental and energy laws such as the Energy Policy Act, Mining Act, Federal Power Act, and Endangered Species Act. The sunset dates are to be between one and five years after the provision is finalized. Regulations can be renewed โ€œas many times as is appropriate, but never to a date more than 5 years in the futureโ€ if they are deemed worthy.

Studies and Reports

Cutting Climate Research Funding
The Trump administration is cutting funding for the federal governmentโ€™s keystone report on climate change in the United States and its impacts, Politico reports.

The White House is cancelling a contract with the firm that oversees the U.S. Global Change Research Program, which conducts the National Climate Assessment. Ending the contract โ€œforever severedโ€ interagency climate change work, one senior official told Politico.

The National Climate Assessment is mandated by Congress, written by hundreds of academic and federal researchers, and summarizes the most recent science on climate change and its consequences for the country.

Coal Executive Order
To assist the dying U.S. coal industry, Trump signed a proclamation that gives coal-fired power plants a two-year reprieve from stricter air pollution standards.

U.S. coal production has fallen off a cliff, down more than half from its peak in 2008, according to government data. The reasons are structural and interrelated: higher production costs, stricter environmental controls, and cheaper competitors.

On the Radar

Fluoride
Lee Zeldin, the EPA administrator, said the agency will review scientific information about the health effects of fluoride as it considers potential regulatory action under the Safe Drinking Water Act.

The agency will produce โ€œan updated health effects assessment for fluoride.โ€

A federal judge ruled last year that the agency must update its fluoride regulations due to new research into health risks.

Cybersecurity Drill
The EPA will host a nationwide drill next month to prepare drinking water utilities for a cyberattack.

Sign up for the May 27 drill here.

Federal Water Tap is a weekly digest spotting trends in U.S. government water policy. To get more water news, follow Circle of Blue on Twitter and sign up for our newsletter.

Back to Romancing the River: Whatโ€™s Your Reality? — George Sibley (SibleysRiver.com) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Credit: USGS

Click the link to read the article on the Sibleys Rivers website (George Sibley):

April 2, 2025

Iย was chastised by a couple readers after theย last post: youโ€™re just giving the Trumpty-Mumpty dynamic duo what it wants by focusing on whatย itย is doing. Whatย weย want to know is what this is going to mean for us out here in the arid lands, and thoughts on what we should be doing about that. What does it mean here in the Colorado River region?

This led me to wonder: is focusing too much on what nasty people are doing just another form of surrendering to them? In chess, and probably all other competitive sports, thereโ€™s the matter of the โ€˜impetusโ€™: one player or team of players will achieve the point in a game where they are โ€˜calling the shots,โ€™ forcing the other player(s) to react to their strategies rather than pursuing the othersโ€™ own game plan. Players with that impetus will usually win, so long as they donโ€™t lose that impetus through some misplay of their own.

The Trumpty-Mumpties have certainly seized the impetus in Americaโ€™s 250-year โ€˜gameโ€™ of trying to work out a collaborative governance for the American nation-state; and our response so far has been railing editorially at them, or suing them, or just kind of watching in shocked silence as they break things. โ€˜Roll over and play dead,โ€™ was the recommendation of one prominent Democrat for his party; let the Repugnicans dig themselves into a hole they canโ€™t get out of, then get up and kick the debris in on top of them. The trouble with that is the fact that the debris will be our dismantled constitutional government, and as was the case when Humpty-Dumpty had his great fall, all of us (and our horsepower) may not be able to put it back together again. When one of Mumptyโ€™s โ€˜Space Xโ€™ rockets blew up shortly after blastoff a few weeks ago, his company described it as a โ€˜rapid unplanned disassembly,โ€™ a wonderful bit of euphemistic language. What we are watching happen in our government is a โ€˜rapid barely planned disassembly,โ€™ giving a little credit to the โ€˜Project 2025โ€™ planners who knew their Repugnican wet dreams only stood a chance if they hit the ground running and โ€˜flooded the zone.โ€™

So what can we do besides watch it happen, and express our dismay and horror? While we still can?

One thing we ought to do is to confront our own complicity in what is happening to us. American historian and philosopher Heather Cox Richardson started one of her daily columns (3/21/25) with the recollection of a really interesting commentary on our times reported twenty years ago by journalist Ron Suskind. A commentary that many of us may have encountered before, but it is really worth revisiting in the murky light of whatโ€™s happening today โ€“ hereโ€™s the paragraph from her column:

This is something for us to โ€˜study,โ€™ the 35-40 million of us who depend to some extent on the water of the Colorado River โ€“ First River of the Anthropocene Epoch. Suskindโ€™s unnamed presidential advisor basically articulated the attitude that drove the first century of the Early American Anthropocene โ€“ and the development of the Colorado River, one of several places where the imperial business of โ€˜creating a new realityโ€™ overriding the existing โ€˜discernible realityโ€™ began. (The Panama Canal and the Columbia River being two other sites for the โ€˜Early American Anthropocene.โ€™)

The history of the development of the Colorado River in the first two-thirds of the 20th century is the story of how we began to โ€˜create our own reality,โ€™ and that story is told in the evolution of the Bureau of Reclamation. The Bureau came into being as the โ€˜Reclamation Serviceโ€™ as part of  the โ€˜Newlands Actโ€™ of 1902. The Service had a modest mission, working with communities of desert homesteaders to develop the irrigation systems that would make their land arable.

The Reclamation Service came into being as part of the United States Geological Survey โ€“ very much what Bushโ€™s advisor called a โ€˜reality-basedโ€™ organization, grounded in the scientific belief that โ€˜people could find solutions based on their observations and careful study of discernible reality.โ€™ The USGS had essentially been given its operating ethos by John Wesley Powell, a consummate scientist whose observations and careful study of the arid lands led him to make policy recommendations as director of the USGS that fell afoul of the Westโ€™s industrial movers and shakers, and got him fired from that agency.

The scientists who had escaped the Powell purge, however, continued the โ€˜reality-basedโ€™ scientific discipline Powell had established for the USGS, and that was the science-based agency into which the Reclamation Service was placed in 1902. But the mission of the Reclamation Service was to help farming communities develop irrigation systems โ€“ essentially an engineering assignment.

The challenge in the Lower Colorado River deserts, for both the scientists and the engineers in the USGS, was learning to live with a water supply that ran in a flood for two or three months of the late spring and early summer, then became a comparative trickle the rest of year. The scientists and the engineers responded to that challenge in different ways. For the scientist, it was a challenge of adapting crops and plantings to what would grow in flood-mud, and spreading the muddy flood out accordingly. For the engineer, the challenge was to change the water supply, storing it to release it in more manageable full-season flows for growing whatever the farmers wanted to grow.

In short, the challenge was perceived to be either using science to adapt the human culture to whatever nature provided (however erratically), or using engineering and other related skill sets to adapt nature to provide whatever the culture needed or wanted. And in the early 20th century, with America just really learning how to use fossil fuels to construct an industrial civilization like the world had never seenโ€ฆ.  We are an empire now, and when we act, we create our own realityโ€ฆ.

Perceiving that choice, the Bureau quickly grew impatient with trying to adapt local community irrigation systems to the wild Colorado River. By 1905 they and their emerging technology were ready to spread their wings, take on the imperial challenge of changing the river. In 1905 they stretched their legislated local charge by taking on three projects with a regional scale: a large (for its day) masonry dam on the Salt River to control flooding and store irrigation water for growth in the Phoenix area; an irrigation weir almost a mile wide across the Colorado mainstem above Yuma, Arizona, to keep water levels up for late-season irrigation water; and a five-mile transbasin tunnel in the upper reaches of the river, carrying water from the Gunnison River to the Uncompahgre River valley.

In 1907, halfway through those larger, more regional projects, the Reclamation Service left the Geological Survey, and became the Bureau of Reclamation, an independent agency in the Interior Department. Basically, the engineers left the scientists to their methodological study of โ€˜discernible realityโ€™; they were ready to roll their own realities. They dreamed of the structures that would break the Colorado River to harness, and the other really big projects that would put the river to work making the desert bloom.

Eugene Clyde LaRue measuring the flow in Nankoweap Creek, 1923. Photo credit: USGS

This never really became a declared war between the scientists and the engineers, but there was a distinct tension. When the seven Colorado River Basin states sat down in 1922 to divide the use of the riverโ€™s waters among themselves, they found conflicting opinions on how much water actually flowed in the river on average. Bureau engineers, including Reclamation Commissioner Arthur Powell Davis, were a frequent presence at the Compact Commission meetings; they had a 25-year record of flows at Yuma going back to 1896, showing an average annual flow of just under 18 million acre-feet for that short period. Meanwhile, E.C. LaRue, a USGS hydrologist and geologist, had been working on that flow problem for years, and had done some early work on tree rings and desert evaporation, leading him to believe that flows between 12 and 14 million acre-feet ofย usable water were a reasonable long range expectation for the river.

LaRue volunteered his assistance to the Compact Commission, but Commission Chair Herbert Hoover (the federal representative on the Commission, and himself an engineer) thought that would be unnecessary, and the Colorado River Compact used Bureau numbers โ€“ and within a decade, certainly within the century, the willful river had demonstrated that scientist LaRueโ€™s stodgy old researched numbers were much closer to the real river we have contended with down to the present. River โ€˜elderโ€™ Eric Kuhn and journalist-historian John Fleck wrote a book,ย Science Be Dammed,ย exploring this tension between the scientists and the engineers in creating the Compact, for those interested in a more detailed account of that.

But for my story here โ€“ the Bureau did go on to โ€˜create its new reality.โ€™ The 1928 Boulder Canyon Act, as it unfolded, became a lamp in the darkness of the Great Depression. Private capitalism โ€“ probably ourย leastย democratic economic engine โ€“ had failed utterly to deal with the Depression, but federal funding coupled with private initiative under the direction of the Bureau put thousands of people to work, building not one but three big structures on the Colorado River mainstem: Hoover Dam capable of storing two yearโ€™s flow of the river, Parker Dam to provide water for a huge aqueduct to the Los Angeles-San Diego metropolis, and the Imperial Weir Dam and All-American Canal to carry water to the vast reaches of the Imperial Valley โ€“ and every drop of water through the dams generating electric power for the Southwest. The desert reality was transformed for โ€“ well, maybe not forever, but for the life of the dams, ultimately proscribed by the inflow of mud as the busy river continuedย itsย mindlesstask of reducing the Southern Rockies and the Colorado Plateau to sea level peneplains.

But the Bureau did not stop there. After the second World War, under the aegis of the Colorado River Storage Project, the Bureau continued to build big storage dams with canals to carry water out into the high orographic deserts above the canyons and the hot subtropical deserts below the canyons, remaking most of the river โ€“ mountain tributaries collected the melted snowpack into rivers, as with all rivers โ€“ but then it went into desert โ€˜distributariesโ€™ distributing the water to vast farms and rapidly growing cities in regions called โ€˜Death Marchesโ€™ by early explorers. That very little freshwater was left to โ€˜wasteโ€™ into the salty ocean was regarded as a victory โ€“ until it wasnโ€™t. Another story there.

What we have to confront today, in the Colorado River region (natural basin plus out-of-basin areas served), is the extent to which the engineered new reality is ultimately dragged down and even stalled by the scientistโ€™s dour desert realities the engineers thought could be transcended. It is unfair to blame the Bureau for the apparently unlimited growth of people moving into the riverโ€™s region, but the engineerโ€™s โ€˜Can Do!โ€™ attitude toward that growth has done little until very recently to bring us to confronting the unavoidable collision of unlimited demand on a limited resource โ€“ and now, a shrinking resource, given new concerns raised by those relentlessly reality-based scientists.

The Grand Canyon survey party at Lees Ferry. Left to right: Leigh Lint, boatman; H.E. Blake, boatman; Frank Word, cook; C.H. Birdseye, expedition leader; R.C. Moore, geologist; R.W. Burchard, topographer; E.C. LaRue, hydraulic engineer; Lewis Freeman, boatman, and Emery Kolb, head boatman. Boatman Leigh Lint, “a beefy athlete who could tear the rowlocks off a boat…absolutely fearless,” later went to college and became an engineer for the USGS. The Grand Canyon survey party at Lees Ferry in 1923. (Public domain.)

E.C. LaRue of the USGS warned us back in 1922 that storing the riverโ€™s water in big open reservoirs would reduce the supply of available water due to evaporation and bank-storage losses, but that seemed like a reasonable trade for water availability year-round over a river whose three-month flood was mostly lost to the sea anyway. The loss could be written off as โ€˜surplusโ€™ โ€“ until the relentless demand ate up the fictional โ€˜surplus.โ€™ Now it is suddenly necessary for the Lower Basin to count the ~800,000 acre-feet of evaporation from the Lower Basin reservoirs, canals and fields, as well as their half of the Mexican decree, against their Compact decreed 7.5 million acre-feet. Which they have reluctantly agreed to do โ€“ so long as the federal government pays them for not using what was not theirs to use anyway. (money that may be threatened by Mumptyโ€™s DOGE).

And on top of that, there is gradual, general, reluctant acceptance of the fact that the burning of fossil fuels that powers nearly all of our civilization, plus the vast tonnage of cooling concrete that has gone into our great works, plus the gases from an increasingly vicious cycle of expanding wildfires and melting permafrost, are adding gases and heat to our atmosphere that are raising temperatures around the planet and causing changes in the global climate โ€“ oops.

I forgot; โ€˜climate changeโ€™ and โ€˜global warmingโ€™ have been officially eradicated from the public discourse. We are  creating another new reality to pile on top of the old new realities weโ€™ve created over the past century plus: We have grown so accustomed to thinking like George Bushโ€™s advisors that we donโ€™t really notice that our newest new reality is just the childโ€™s belief that putting our hands over our eyes will make the real world go away.

So I think thatโ€™s what we can do, at least in the Colorado River region: uncover our eyes, and start adjusting our new realities (which are not entirely bad) with the natural realities that still constrain the engineers โ€“ as even most of the engineers seem willing to acknowledge. We need to acknowledge that Becky Mitchellโ€™s advice is now counterrevolutionary โ€“ โ€˜We must learn to plan for the river we have, not the river we wish we had.โ€™ To the Trumpty-Mumpties, thatโ€™s almost Unamerican, saints be praised.

Whatever we do along those lines, however, it seems necessary that the scientists and engineers work together on it: both acknowledging the wisdom in the scientist looking carefully before the engineers leap โ€“ but both also acknowledging that some leaps will be neededโ€ฆ.

***

Margaret Chase Smith in 1950:

President Trump’s administration thaws frozen IRA money: But will #Coloradoโ€™s electric cooperatives get all the money they were promised? The answer remains unclear — Allen Best (BigPivots.com)

The main street in Nucla, located in western Montrose County. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

March 28, 2025

Electrical cooperatives in Colorado were informed before Joe Biden left the White House that they would be getting about $3.5 billion from the federal government via programs funded by the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022.

Will they? U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke Rollins announced Tuesday that her department was releasing funds previously committed but also described a โ€œcourse correction.โ€ Just what constitutes a โ€œcourse correctionโ€ will likely not become fully apparent for weeks, perhaps months.

The release said that electrical cooperatives must first revise their project plans to โ€œremove harmful DEIA and far-left climate features.โ€ DEIA stands for diversity, equity, inclusion and accessibility.

The announcement by the USDA โ€”the department houses the Rural Utility Services, the agency that works with cooperatives โ€” also said electrical cooperatives would be asked several questions and would need to provide a short narrative description of any proposed changes in their projects.

The revised projects must also align with an executive order issued by President Donald Trump on Jan. 20 called โ€œUnleashing American Energy.โ€ Just exactly what those revisions need to look like remains unclear. In that executive order Trump rescinded a long list of executive orders issued by former President Joe Biden, including 10 that had to do with climate change.

Trumpโ€™s order made no mention of renewable energy but did order agency heads to identify actions that โ€œimpose an undue burden on the identification, development, or use of domestic energy resources โ€“ with particular attention to oil, natural gas, coal, hydropower, biofuels, critical mineral, and nuclear energy resourcesโ€ฆโ€

โ€œWe are as interested to find out as you are,โ€ replied Alex Shelley, who has the public information job at San Miguel Power Association, when I called him Wednesday afternoon. San Miguel expected to get a $9.8 million grant from the New ERA program to construct a 20-megawatt solar project in western Montrose County. That area of Montrose County includes Nucla, Naturita, and Uravan. Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association operated Nucla Station, a coal burning plant, until 2019.

In a statement posted on Jan. 23, Brad Zaporski, the chief executive of San Miguel Power, called the project a โ€œshining example of partnership in action to help bolster our rural communities.โ€

The project, said Shelley, is to be on private land that is not useful for agriculture or anything other than light industry.

Brighton-based United Power was to get $262 million for six solar projects in its service territory in northern Colorado and one other project involving hydroelectricity. About 40% of the service territory is in Wattenberg Field, Coloradoโ€™s primary oil and gas producing area.

โ€œI think the story is that the RUS wants to get the money moving to help rural communities,โ€ said Mark Gabriel, the chief executive. โ€œWe were given the opportunity to make any edits or resubmit, and we chose not to (make changes to our application).โ€

The original application, he added, made no mention of diversity or inclusion. It asserted the desire to make Unitedโ€™s members more reliant on local resources and with lower-cost electricity.

Tri-State G&T has the most skin in this game. It provides wholesale electricity for 40 electric cooperatives in a four-state area, including 15 in Colorado. Tri-State in 2024 said it was getting a financial package worth $2.5 billion, most of that in loans of less than 2%. Those low-interest loans will allow it to get out from under higher-interest financing as it prepares to close its coal units in Colorado and Arizona during coming years.

In an October announcement, Tri-State said New ERA funding would support financing for 1,280 megawatts of energy from solar, wind and wind-storage projects, and more than 100 megawatts of stand-alone energy storage.

The company also plans a natural gas plant, preferably in northwest Colorado or conceivably southwest Wyoming.

Tri State expects to reach 70% clean energy by 2030. Within Colorado, this will be an 89% reduction as compared to a 2005 baseline.

โ€œWe appreciate the work of Secretary Rollins and her team to advance the program, and we will be reviewing the USDAโ€™s guidance and look forward to continuing our work through their process,โ€ said Tri-State CEO Duane Highley in a statement posted on Wednesday.

In Fort Collins, Jeff Wadsworth was cautious about what the final tally will look like. Heโ€™s the chief executive of Poudre Valley REA, which is in line to get $9 million to help pay for two solar-and-storage projects. The grant was through Powering Affordable Clean Energy, or PACE, another program funded by the IRA.

โ€œWe are thrilled about this development and look forward to collaborating with the dedicated team at the USDA,โ€ he said initially when asked for a response. In a telephone conversation the next day, however, he said that the full story remains to be written.

Wadsworth is optimistic that Poudre Valley will get its money. Demand for electricity has continued to grow for multiple reasons, and these projects will help Poudre Valley meet that demand. But this grant is not the end-all, be-all for Poudre Valley as it moves forward, he said.

โ€œIt helps our ratepayers, who are part of rural Colorado, We are excited about that,โ€ said Wadsworth. โ€œBut our path is pretty clear as we move forward.โ€

Still another perspective comes from Eric Frankowski, the executive director of the Western Clean Energy Campaign.  He believes that despite the โ€œproblematicโ€ language of the announcement, the guidance that RUS has issued for the cooperatives has eased a lot of concerns.

โ€œIt appears that the process is completely voluntary and that co-ops do not need to do anything. The language says that RUS will NOT approve proposed modifications โ€˜that affect the scoring of projects that were competitively scored.โ€™ Since community benefits, decarbonization and lowering rates were all integral to how proposals were evaluated, I think we can take that as a good sign,โ€ he wrote in an e-mail.

That guidance can be found here.

โ€œThe guidance also says that if awardees do not respond within 30 days requesting a revision, โ€˜it will be considered that they do not wish to make changes to their proposals, and disbursements and other actions will resume after the 30 days.โ€™ (emphasis added) It also says that awardees can respond that they are not changing their proposal and processing of payments will begin immediately. Also good signs,โ€ said Frankowski.

โ€œThere doesnโ€™t seem to be a pathway where co-ops are punished for staying the course on their clean energy plans,โ€ he added. โ€œWho knows what happens after the 30-day window, but things seem good for now.โ€

Granby-based Mountain Parks Electric in January announced that it had executed a letter of commitment with the U.S. Department of Agriculture for a grant prog ram of $100 million across the next 20 years. The announcement said that the money will be used to help procure power through power-purchase agreements and to advance and promote scholarships and apprenticeship programs. The announcement was made two weeks before Mountain Parks left Tri-State and began getting its wholesale power from Guzman Energy in a 20-year agreement.

Sedalia-based CORE Electric Cooperative hopes for $225 million and Steamboat Springs-based Yampa Valley Electric $50 million. Grand Junction-based Grand Valley Power Lines also expected to get federal funds.

In his statement, Highley credited the work of U.S. Representatives Jeff Hurd, Gabe Evans, Lauren Boebert, all from Colorado, and Gabe Vasquez, of New Mexico, as well as Colorado Senators John Hickenlooper and Michael Bennet. Bennet, in particular, had gone to bat for the New ERA provision for cooperatives in the IRA. He spoke in October at Tri-Stateโ€™s headquarters when a finalized announcement was made.

President Trump’s U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright during #Golden lab visit doubles down on minimizing #ClimateChange — Lindsey Toomer (ColoradoNewsline.com)

U.S. Energy Secretary Chris Wright talks to reporters on April 3, 2025, at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden. (Lindsey Toomer/Colorado Newsline)

Click the link to read the article on the Colorado Newsline website (Lindsey Toomer):

April 3, 2025

Chris Wright said blaming Marshall Fire on climate change is โ€˜simply to not look at the dataโ€™

U.S. Secretary of Energy Chris Wright, returning to the Denver area Thursday after he was confirmed as a member of President Donald Trumpโ€™s cabinet, repeatedly minimized the consequences of climate change when speaking to reporters during a press conference. 

Wright, founder of Denver-based fracking services company Liberty Energy, spoke to employees at the Department of Energyโ€™s National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden for less than 10 minutes, touching on powering artificial intelligence, electricity production and growth, and supporting national labs. 

Talking to reporters after he spoke to staff, Wright said โ€œemotional, not-fact-based stuffโ€ like targeting hydrocarbons โ€” the main components of climate change-causing fossil fuels โ€” for reductions is โ€œdisruptiveโ€ and led to higher electricity and energy prices during the Biden administration. 

Wright said that attributing the Marshall Fire โ€” which in 2021 destroyed more than 1,000 homes in Boulder County, burned over 6,000 acres, caused more than $2 billion in property damage and killed two people โ€” to climate change is โ€œsimply to not look at the data.โ€ He said wildfires โ€œpeaked over 100 years agoโ€ and that the U.S. government could better manage wildfire devastation through forest management to control wood fuels. 

โ€œCalling climate change a crisis is just to say โ€˜Iโ€™m not going to look at the science, Iโ€™m not going to look at the economics, Iโ€™m just going to run with the politics,โ€™โ€ Wright said. 

Drier and hotter conditions in Colorado are widely viewed as having contributed to the severity of the Marshall Fire, making the potential for loss greater. Investigators said one of the fireโ€™s origins was a spark from an Xcel Energy power line, and the utility company has since faced several lawsuits.

Wright has previously expressed deep skepticism of the scientific consensus that climate change is a global crisis.

Department layoffs

The Department of Energy, along with many other federal agencies, laid off probationary staff members, and a judge then ordered the department reinstate them. The Trump administration asked all department heads to plan for additional cuts through a โ€œreduction in forceโ€ process. 

Wright did not say how many more employees within his department could expect to lose their jobs, but he said downsizing is an โ€œongoing processโ€ and that โ€œit would be downright irresponsible if we werenโ€™t doing this.โ€ He said department staff grew by 20% over the four years before he took over, and โ€œwhat we got out of it was a little bit more restrictions in energy production around the country.โ€ 

Energy Department leadership told workers this week it will undergo โ€œrestructuring.โ€ Wright said each department will undergo โ€œa very detailed organization, bottom up.โ€ 

โ€œEvery part of the government, we have to look at, how can we make government services as good as they are today or better, but at lower cost,โ€ Wright said. โ€œLike I do with my business, we have to look carefully at the business of where we are today and how can we deliver services at least as good as we are today at lower cost.โ€

In Wrightโ€™s talk to staff at the NREL, he applauded the work and dedication of the employees he spoke with and said their work is โ€œcritical.โ€

โ€œThe range of stuff I saw today, different people that spoke on different technologies, incredibly impressive, passionate, smart people that you can see from their heart that believe in what theyโ€™re doing, that love what theyโ€™re doing,โ€ Wright said. 

U.S. Energy Secretary Chris Wright, right, talks to reporters alongside National Renewable Energy Laboratory Director Martin Keller on April 3, 2025, at the NREL campus in Golden. (Lindsey Toomer/Colorado Newsline)

After he was appointed, Wright said one of his first moves was to bring together leaders of the national labs from around the country to ask what they needed to make their work more efficient. Last week, he issued a secretarial order making changes he said resulted from those conversations. 

Artificial intelligence is โ€œthe next energy-intensive manufacturing industry,โ€ Wright said in Golden, and the U.S. should not outsource that energy production to other countries. He said he issued a request for information Thursday to gauge developer interest in building on DOE land around the country to power AI.  

โ€œWe have land at all of our national labs and DOE sites around the country โ€” who wants to come build a data center, build (a) nearby energy system, use the technology and smarts we got at the national lab โ€ฆ Maybe donate some computing power to us, or some lease money for the lands thatโ€™ll help fund our research,โ€ Wright said. โ€œWeโ€™re trying to find different ways to make the labs faster, smarter, better and more self-sufficient, more funding from other sources as well.โ€ 

Wright said he would make โ€œa commercial arrangementโ€ with private data center companies that want to use federal land, because โ€œthatโ€™s where the capital is.โ€ 

NREL is responsible for researching and developing renewable energy systems and improving energy efficiency in the U.S. It has another campus in Arvada, as well as one in Alaska and in Washington, D.C., with 3,675 employees across the four locations.

10,000 years of CO2, during the time that human civilization arose. Credit: https://keelingcurve.ucsd.edu/

On President Trump & tirades; April 1 #snowpack update; Also, Oil executives blast White House econ policies — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Horse near Aneth. Photo illustration by Jonathan P. Thompson

Click the link to read the article on the Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

April 1, 2025

๐Ÿคฏ Trump Ticker ๐Ÿ˜ฑ

Last week, one of the Land Deskโ€™s more conservative readers cancelled his paid subscription. He wrote that he appreciated my passion for public lands, but was no longer interested in reading what he called a โ€œtirade against Trump.โ€

This type of thing happens all the time in this business, and, unlike Elon Musk, Iโ€™m not looking for your pity. But I was a bit saddened, given that this person had been a paid subscriber since the Land Desk was launched, and because I really do appreciate having readers and commenters from across the political spectrum.

Besides, while Iโ€™m prone to a rant now and then, I do think โ€œtiradeโ€ is taking it a little too far. Anyway, my point in telling yโ€™all this is to let you know that writing about Trumpโ€™s shenanigans every dispatch is just about the last thing I want to be doing with my time. Iโ€™d much rather be delving into old maps, getting into the nuances of Western water, exploring the history of floods and droughts and wildfires, taking contrarian views on the housing crisis, or dissecting the contradictions of oil and gas markets. And I will continue to do all of that.

At the same time, itโ€™s impossible for me to ignore the barrage of destruction, corruption, chaos, authoritarianism, and incompetence emanating from the White House. My passion for public lands โ€” and for justice, truth, reason, morality, decency, intelligence, and kindness โ€” demands that I document these egregious acts, and do my part to resist them, even if it is just by informing my readership about whatโ€™s happening.

I am not impartial, not by any means. I am partial to the planet and its survival, toward my fellow human beings, toward peace and justice and compassion and truth. [ed. emphasis mine] I am not, however, partisan: I will scrutinize Democrats and Republicans equally, fact-check the left and the right, and give credit where credit is due โ€” even to Donald Trump.

***

Hopi tribal members cross Havasu Creek. Photo credit: From the Earth Studio

And on that note: The Trump administration appears to have unfrozen nearly $4.2 million in federal funding to help the Hopi Tribe build a solar-powered microgrid to run two remote wells and associated infrastructure that will provide water to Upper and Lower Moenkopi. The funding was approved by the Biden Energy Department, Trump froze it as part of a larger stop on Infrastructure and Inflation Reduction law money, but now it has been released. So good on you, Donny!

Now, how about you direct your Environmental Protection Agency to release funding for the Walker River Paiute Tribe to expand access to clean water and electric power infrastructure, and for Navajo Powerโ€™s program to bring solar to off-grid homes.

***

Though it may be inadvertent, Trumpโ€™s economic policies may ultimately benefit the environment in some ways. The haphazard, on-again, off-again tariffs, for example, along with the gutting of the federal governmentโ€™s workforce, have sent the stock market into a tailspin. Meanwhile, the tariffs โ€” along with reciprocal tariffs levied by the U.S.โ€™s trading partners โ€” will increase prices on most consumer goods. People will buy less, travel less, which will mean less pollution and environmental impacts.

***

And yet more kudos for Trump! Seriously. Despite all of his bluster, Trump has managed to really piss off oil and gas executives โ€” the same ones that were throwing money at his campaign just a few months ago โ€” and possibly dampen drilling on public lands.

See, the thing about tariffs is that they very well may raise the price you pay for gasoline (depending on where your local refinery gets its crude oil), but the economy-dampening part of tariffs actually brings down the price of oil, while also raising the cost of steel pipes and other supplies. Thatโ€™s no bueno for petroleum companies, whose profit margins are directly proportional to the price of crude.

Many of these folks wonโ€™t criticize Trump in public, given his vindictive and authoritarian leanings, but give them the cover of anonymity, as a Dallas Federal Reserve survey did, and they go off on the White Houseโ€™s herky-jerky non-policies. Hereโ€™s a sampling:

There was only one mention of regulations getting in the way of the oil business, and that wasnโ€™t federal rules, but state ones:

Well, there you have it, folks.

***

Oh, and these oil companies might also be angry that the MAGAs are all buying Teslas โ€” or at least pretending to โ€” in order to โ€œown the libs.โ€ Which is pretty funny, given the amount of gibberish Trump devoted to dissing electric vehicles during his campaign rallies. Tesla also stands to benefit the most from Trumpโ€™s tariffs, another dig at the internal combustion fans.

***

Maybe the national parks will be a bit less crowded this summer, as well, as international travel ebbs.

Anyone whoโ€™s traveled the Western national park service knows that they are popular with overseas visitors. On a single grocery run at the Page, Arizona, Safeway recently, I heard no fewer than three different languages spoken, in addition to Navajo and English, and that was in the off-season. In 2018 (the last year that data is available), more than 14 million international travelers visited U.S. national parks and monuments. About 14% of the Grand Canyon National Parksโ€™ visitors were from overseas, with about 6% of Zionโ€™s visitation from overseas.

Tourism Economics is predicting that international travel to the U.S. will be down significantly this year, thanks not only to the administrationโ€™s hostile economic moves, but also โ€œpolarizing Trump administration policies and rhetoric.โ€ Also, thereโ€™s that thing where travelers have been detained at the border, even thrown in jail, simply for trying to get a visa. This decline undoubtedly will impact Western U.S. tourism and national park and monument visitation numbers. Not good for the tourism economy, but it might give the parks a much needed rest.

๐Ÿฅต Aridification Watch ๐Ÿซ

Itโ€™s first-of-the-month snowpack update time again, and this will likely be the last of the season barring some freak climatic shift over the next several weeks. Snowpack levels typically peak in mid-elevation areas in mid- to late-March, and in the high country in mid- to late-April, meaning we are now headed into spring runoff season.

Generally speaking, itโ€™s looking like runoff will be average to paltry, depending on which side of the snow-divide your watershed falls. It is a very jagged line, by the way, with places in the west and north having average to above average snowpack, while the southern-Interior West generally had a super dry winter. But even within those areas there are sort of outliers: The Grand Traverse ski race between Aspen and Crested Butte was canceled due to lack of snow for the first time in its 26-year history.

And thereโ€™s big variations over short distances. Red Mountain Pass is still just below median, for example, while the southern San Juan Mountains, just a few dozen miles away, are experiencing a severely dry winter.

Before I get to the graphics, however, a quick note. The snowpack and precipitation plots I run here come from the USDAโ€™s Natural Resources Conservation Service. Itโ€™s just one of the valuable services they provide. I havenโ€™t found any stats on whether DOGE has gone after NRCSโ€™s staff, yet. But the DOGE website says it has or will cancel the leases for the following NRCS offices. Whether they and their staffs will simply go away, be absorbed into another facility, or what, isnโ€™t disclosed.

  • Natural Resource Conservation Service offices slated for lease cancellations: Missoula, Montana; Wasilla and Fairbanks, Alaska; Logan, Utah; Gallup and Raton, New Mexico; Yuma, Arizona; Dayton, Puyallup, and Renton, Washington; Portland, Oregon; and Woodland, Yreka, Salinas, Oxnard, and Blythe, California.

Hopefully the staff of these offices and services they provide will endure.

Now to the snowpack plots. I included the plots for 2021 and 2023 because those were the most recent big and crappy years for snowpack.

The watersheds that feed Lake Powell are not in terrible shape, sitting at 88% of the median just six days before the typical peak. However, levels are lower than they were in 2021 at this time, and 2021 was not a good year for the Colorado River. Source: NRCS.
The North Fork of the Gunnison has followed a snow accumulation pattern similar to the Upper Colorado Riverโ€™s.
Red Mountain Pass is one of the few bright spots in the Four Corners region. Snow levels have tracked right around normal for most of the winter. Though itโ€™s now down to 90% of median, there are potentially still over three weeks left in the snow accumulation season, meaning an above-average season is still possible; snow is forecast for much of this week there.
This SNOTEL site, in the San Francisco Peaks north of Flagstaff, is the comeback story of the year, rebounding from ultra-dry to average over the course of several weeks. Itโ€™s one of the only sites in Arizona that received measurable snow accumulation this season.
The drought has spread and intensified over the last year.
And it doesnโ€™t look like it will get better anytime soon โ€ฆ

If you want to know more about the drought and the Colorado River basin, Iโ€™d suggest checking out theย Wright-Ingraham Instituteโ€™s interactive Drought Interfaces app. Itโ€™s super cool and informative.

Take your children out into these landscapes” — Kevin Fedarko

My friend Joe’s son and the Orr kids at the top of the Crack in the Wall trail to Coyote Gulch with Stevens Arch in the Background. Photo credit: Joe Ruffert

Kevin Fedarko was the keynote speaker at the symposium and he is as inspirational a speaker as you could ask for. It doesn’t hurt that the landscape that he spoke about is the Grand Canyon. He urged the attendees to, “Take your children out into these landscapes so that they can learn to love them.” He is advocating for the protection of the Grand Canyon in particular but really he is advocating for the protection all public lands.

Kevin Fedarko and Coyote Gulch at the Rio Grande State of the Basin Symposium hosted by the Salazar Rio Grande del Norte Center at Adams State University in Alamosa March 29, 2024.

What an inspirational talk from Kevin. I know what he is saying when he speaks about the time after dinner on the trail where the sunset lights up the canyon in different hues and where, he and Pete McBride, his partner on the Grand Canyon through hike, could hear the Colorado River hundreds of feet below them, continuing its work cutting and molding the rocks, because the silence in that landscape is so complete. He and I share the allure of the Colorado Plateau. Kevin was introduced to it through Collin Flectcher’s book The Man Who Walked Through Time, after he received a dog-eared copy from his father. They lived in Pittsburgh in a landscape that was industrialized but the book enabled Kevin to imagine places that were unspoiled.

My introduction to the Colorado Plateau came from an article in Outside magazine that included a panoramic photo of the Escalante River taken from the ledges above the river. Readers in the know can put 2 and 2 together from the name of this blog — Coyote Gulch — my homage to the canyons tributary to Glen Canyon and Lake Foul.

Stevens Arch viewed from Coyote Gulch. Photo via Joe Ruffert

Kevin’s keynote came at the end of the day on March 29th after a jam-packed schedule.

Early in the day Ken Salazar spoke about the future of the San Luis Valley saying, “Where is the sustainability of the valley going to come from.” Without agriculture this place would wither and die.” He is right, American Rivers and other organizations introduced a paper, The Economic Value of Water Resources in the San Luis Valley which was a response to yet another plan to export water out of the valley to the Front Range. (Currently on hold as Renewable Water Resources does not have a willing buyer. Thank you Colorado water law.)

Claire Sheridan informed attendees that their report sought to quantify all the economic benefits from each drop of water in the valley. “When you buy a bottle of water you know exactly what it costs. But what is the value of having the Sandhill cranes come here every year?”

Sandhill Cranes Dancing. Photo by: Arrow Myers courtesy Monte Vista Crane Festival

Russ Schumacher detailed the current state of the climate (snowpack at 63%) and folks from the Division of Water Resources expounded on the current state of aquifer recovery and obligations under the Rio Grande Compact.

The session about the Colorado Airborne Snow Measurement Program was fascinating. Nathan Coombs talked about the combination of SNOTEL, manual snow courses, Lidar, radar, and machine learning used to articulate a more complete picture of snowpack. “You can’t have enough tools in your toolbox,” he said.

Coombs detailed the difficulty of meeting the obligations under the Rio Grande Compact with insufficient knowledge of snowpack and therefore runoff volumes. Inaccurate information can lead to operational decisions that overestimate those volumes and then require severe curtailments in July and August just when farmers are finishing their crops. “When you make an error the correction is what kills you,” he said.

If you are going to learn about agriculture in the valley it is informative to understand the advances in soil health knowledge and the current state of adoption. That was the theme of the session “Building Healthy Soils”. John Rizza’s enthusiasm for the subject was obvious and had me thinking about what I can do for my city landscape.

Amber Pacheco described how the Rio Grande Basin Roundtable and other organizations reach out to as many folks in the valley as possible. Inclusivity is the engine driving collaboration.

Many thanks to Salazar Rio Grande del Norte Center director Paul Formisano for reaching out to me about the symposium. I loved the program. You can scroll through my posts on BlueSky here

Orr kids, Escalante River June 2007

President Trump hands public lands to the mining industry: Plus: Using public lands for housing — againย — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

March 25, 2025

โ›๏ธMining Monitor โ›๏ธ

Satellite image of a portion of the Morenci Mine in Arizona. Source: Google Earth.

Last week, President Trump signed an executive order โ€” his 150th so far this term, by my rough count โ€” invoking the Defense Production Act to expedite mining on federal lands. The wording of the order suggests that the aim is not just to cut through some of the red tape hindering proposed projects, but to incite the industry to mine areas that it may not have been considering previously.

The order has understandably alarmed public lands advocates, but it has also spawned some misconceptions, particularly concerning the 1872 General Mining Law.

Green River Basin oil shale deposits via the Bureau of Land Management

While Trumpโ€™s attacks on the nation and public lands have been of unprecedented scope and scale so far, his use of the Cold War-era DPA is not unprecedented or even all that unusual. The Carter administration used it to justify pouring billions of dollars of subsidies into โ€œsynfuelโ€ production as part of its quest for โ€œenergy independence.โ€ This sparked massive oil shale operations in western Colorado (which crashed spectacularly). And Biden used the Act to encourage mining for so called โ€œgreen metals,โ€ such as lithium, boron, and manganese. He also streamlined permitting for the proposed Hermosa manganese mine in southern Arizona, and loaned the contested Thacker Pass lithium mine in Nevada $2.6 billion.

But Trumpโ€™s order goes much further than Bidenโ€™s. He is expanding the list of target minerals to just about everything, including โ€œcritical minerals, uranium, copper, potash, gold, and any other element, compound or material as determined by the Chair of the National Energy Dominance Council, such as coal.โ€ While Biden wanted a survey of the nationโ€™s mineral production capacity, and promised to adhere to all existing environmental laws and consult with tribal nations, Trump is ordering his agencies to:

  • Compile a list of all proposed mining projects โ€œin order to expedite the review of those projects in coordination with the National Energy Dominance Council.โ€
  • Amend or revise land use plans under the Federal Land Policy and Management Act as necessary to โ€œsupport the intent of this order.โ€
  • โ€œIdentify as many sites as possible that might be suitable for mineral production activities that can be permitted as soon as possible.โ€
  • Prioritize mineral production activities over other types of activities on federal lands.
  • Provide financing, loans, and investment for new mines, including from a โ€œdedicated critical minerals fund established through the U.S. International Development Finance Corporation.โ€
  • โ€œNew recommendations will be provided to Congress regarding treatment of waste rock, tailings, and mine waste disposal under the Mining Act of 1872.โ€

Instead of adhering to environmental laws, Trump would simply alter them to support mining. He not only wants to help out proposed projects with regulatory and financial subsidies, but also wants to spur on new projects on โ€œas many sites as possible.โ€ And he is prioritizing mineral extraction over all other activities on federal lands, a blatant violation of the Federal Land Policy Management Actโ€™s multiple-use mandate.

That would mean not only that mining would take precedence over conservation and recreation, but also livestock grazing and other extractive uses. The OHV crowd thatโ€™s worried about the BLM closing a few roads to motorized vehicles around Moab might just find themselves ousted from a lot more areas by potash ponds, uranium mines, or lithium operations.

Trumpโ€™s recommendations to Congress likely will be to tweak the 1872 Mining Law to ensure that mining companies can store waste on public land mining claims that arenโ€™t valid, meaning that they have not proven that the parcels contain valuable minerals. This was actually the norm for decades until 2022, when a federal judge ruled that the proposed Rosemont copper mine in Arizona could not store its tailings and waste rock on public land. That ruling was followed by a similar one in 2023, leading mining state politicians from both parties to try to restore the pre-Rosemont Decision rules.

Itโ€™s around the General Mining Law that misconceptions have arisen. The folks at More Than Just Parks say the new order โ€œdoesnโ€™t create a new legal framework. It exhumes an old one โ€” a fossil from the 19th century โ€ฆ Itโ€™s the Mining Act of 1872, back from the dead, and now wearing body armor.โ€ Which is a nice way to put it, but the Mining Act never died, so this order canโ€™t revive it.

The other misconception appeared in Lands Lost, another great Substack focusing on public lands, which wrote: โ€œโ€ฆ there are no meaningful environmental safeguards in place because public land mining is a free-for-all governed only by an 1872 law thatโ€™s never been modernized.โ€

Itโ€™s true that the 1872 Mining Law is inadequate, allows mining companies or individuals to stake a claim to any public land without public input or environmental review, conduct exploratory work with a minimum of review, and pay no royalties on hardrock minerals they extract. However, the federal agencies do have additional regulations governing mining. Before a company can do any actual mining, it must get an operating permit from the Bureau of Land Management, U.S. Forest Service, or Department of Energy (depending on the landโ€™s jurisdiction), which includes an environmental review (either an EA or a more extensive EIS, depending on the scope of the project). A mine may also need a Clean Water Act permit for any water discharges, including draining adits, and many states require additional permits as well.

By ordering the agencies to alter the FLPMA land-use plans to accommodate mining, Trump is essentially doing away with these additional safeguards, which really is scary. That would take us back to a time when the 1872 Mining Law was the only federal regulatory framework, which would give mining companies a free rein to trash public lands. However, Trump canโ€™t do much about state requirements, except to try to bully them out of existence. [ed. emphasis mine]

The order applies only to federal lands, so mining projects that are on patented mining claims โ€” which are entirely on private โ€” would not be affected (although they might be eligible for the government handouts). 

Proposed projects this fast-tracking could affect include:

  • Resolution Copperโ€™sย proposed massive copper mineย at Chiโ€™chil Biล‚dagoteel, aka Oak Flat, in central Arizona.
  • Copper World Complexย nรฉe Rosemont Mine in the Santa Rita Mountains south of Tucson, Arizona. After a judge kiboshed Canada-based Hudbayโ€™s plan to dump mine waste on U.S. Forest Service land, the firm decided to base the initial phase on patented, i.e. private, mining claims and later expand to public lands.
  • South32โ€™s proposedย Hermosa Mineย in the Patagonia Mountains of southern Arizona. Biden already fast-tracked permitting for this battery-grade manganese mine, but Trumpโ€™s order could speed it along even more.
  • Energy Fuelsโ€™ Roca Honda uranium mine and Laramide Resourcesโ€™ La Jara Mesa uranium project, both onย Forest Service landย near Grants, New Mexico.
  • Anson/A1โ€™sย proposed lithium extractionย projects and American Potashโ€™s lithium and potash projects on BLM land east and north of Moab and south of Green River, Utah.
  • Lithium, copper, and uranium projects on BLM land inย the Lisbon Valleyย in southeastern Utah.
  • Numerous proposed uranium mining projects on Energy Department leases and BLM land in the Uravan Mineral Belt in western Colorado.
  • Atomic Mineralsโ€™ uranium prospects onย Harts Point, just outside the boundaries of Bears Ears National Monument.
  • Metallic Minerals is only doingย exploratory drillingย on its mining claims in the La Plata Mountains of southwestern Colorado, and have yet to make any mining plans public, so itโ€™s not clear whether Trumpโ€™s order would affect this contested project.
  • Learn more about these and other projects with theย Land Deskโ€™s Mining Monitor Map.

Those links up ^^ there? A lot of them are to paywalled Land Desk archives. Break down the paywall and support oligarch-free journalism by becoming a paid subscriber now.


Satellite image of Phoenix-area sprawl and adjacent BLM land. Source: Google Earth.
๐ŸŒต Public Lands ๐ŸŒฒ

Also last week, in a short-on-details Wall Street Journal opinion piece, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner unveiled a plan to transfer or lease โ€œunderusedโ€ public lands to states or localities for affordable housing. An Interior official then told Bloomberg Lawโ€™s Bobby Magill that the Bureau of Land Management is considering selling about 400,000 acres of federal land within 10 miles of cities and towns with more than 5,000 people for housing development.

This isnโ€™t surprising: Republicans and Democrats have both been itching to grab some public land for housing for a while. And the stated intent, to add affordable housing to increasingly unaffordable public lands-gateway communities, is noble.

And yet, the plan โ€” as scant in particulars as it is โ€” is still riddled with problems.

Burgum has made it clear that he distinguishes between โ€œspecialโ€ and โ€œour most beautifulโ€ public lands, i.e. those that are in national parks or national monuments, and the remaining โ€œunderused,โ€ โ€œinhospitable or unoccupiedโ€ lands. The lands on the urban fringes he intends to take out of the American publicโ€™s hands belong to the latter category, apparently.

But those same lands are valuable, especially to the nearby communities. They provide an easy-to-access refuge โ€” for humans and wildlife โ€” from the urban din, as well as recreational opportunities. In fact, the close proximity of these public lands makes the communities more desirable and therefore more expensive: think Animas Mountain in Durango, the Slickrock Trail in Moab, Jumbo Mountain in Paonia, the Lunch Loop trails in Grand Junction, the Buckeye Hills near Phoenix, or the Juniper Woodlands trails outside Bend. Now imagine them covered in houses.

Because BLM lands are almost always outside the urban boundaries, developing them will lead directly to sprawl and all of its impacts, including more traffic and associated pollution and safety issues.

So far, the Interior Department hasnโ€™t given any indication that it would require the land to be used for affordable housing. And, as Center for Western Priorities points out in a statement on the plan, the administration hardly seems interested in fixing the housing crisis, given that it is planning to eviscerate HUD and has frozen some $60 million in funding for affordable housing. 

Which leads me to think they are using Sen. Mike Leeโ€™s stalled HOUSES Act, which also calls for putting houses on โ€œunderutilizedโ€ federal land, as a model. But that legislation has no affordability restrictions and its density requirement โ€” a mere four houses per acre โ€” is just more sprawl.

Thatโ€™s because Lee and company are going with the supply side theory, which posits that simply building more houses will lower costs enough to make them affordable. While this theory does hold in certain cases, it does not apply to most Western public lands-gateway, amenities communities, where seemingly unlimited demand is always bound to outpace supply. And that means this plan is just another scheme to take public lands out of Americansโ€™ hands and give them to the private sector.

On the housing supply-side theory JONATHAN P. THOMPSON SEPTEMBER 19, 2023: https://www.landdesk.org/p/on-the-housing-supply-side-theory


๐Ÿ“ธย Parting Shotย ๐ŸŽž๏ธ

LOVE windmill. Near Leupp, Arizona. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Tommy Beaudreau on โ€œThe Lords of Yesterday and the Imperatives of Nowโ€: Challenges to Energy Transition on Public Lands — Victoria Matson and Oliver Skelly (Getches-Wilkinson Center) #ActOnClimate

Tommy Beaudreau at the 2025 Schultz Lecture in Energy. Photo credit: Getches-Wilkinson Center

Click the link to read the article on the Getches-Wilkinson Center website (Victoria Matson and Oliver Skelly):

March 20, 2025

On Tuesday, February 25th, Tommy Beaudreau, former Deputy Secretary of the Interior, delivered the Schultz Lecture, offering a sobering analysis of the structural, legal, economic, and political hurdles to the energy transition on public lands. His talk, โ€œThe Lords of Yesterday and the Imperatives of Now,โ€ constituted a tribute to the late Charles Wilkinson’s coined phrase. Harkening back to Wilkinson’s work, Beaudreau traced these contemporary challenges to the legacy of westward expansion and Indigenous displacement, illustrating how outdated laws and entrenched interests continue to shape todayโ€™s energy policies.

American Progress (1872) by John Gast is an allegorical representation of the modernization of the new west. Columbia, a personification of the United States, is shown leading civilization westward with the American settlers. She is shown bringing light from east to west, stringing telegraph wire, holding a book, and highlighting different stages of economic activity and evolving forms of transportation. By John Gast – This image is available from the United States Library of Congress’s Prints and Photographs division under the digital ID 09855.This tag does not indicate the copyright status of the attached work. A normal copyright tag is still required. See Commons:Licensing for more information., Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=373152

Beaudreau framed public lands as a political flashpoint in the energy transition. While state and private landsโ€”particularly in North Dakota and the Southwestโ€”have played significant roles in the oil and gas boom, debates over renewables, permitting, and leasing disproportionately focus on federal lands. Ironically, legal tools once used to block fossil fuel projects are now being turned against renewables, complicating efforts to decarbonize.

Beyond regulatory hurdles, fossil fuel revenues remain deeply embedded in state economies, funding schools, public safety, and infrastructure. Many Tribal nations, too, rely on fossil fuel revenues, balancing economic interests with environmental concerns. Beaudreau stressed that a โ€œjust transitionโ€ must provide financial alternatives before communities can fully embrace renewables.

Outdated laws, like the 1872 Mining Law, remain a major obstacle to energy reform. Beaudreau highlighted the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) as a key step in shifting energy policy, but legal battles persist over leasing rights, mineral access, and state-federal control. He pointed to Louisianaโ€™s lawsuit over the Biden administrationโ€™s oil and gas lease moratorium, which raised critical questions about governmental statutory and commercial contractual rights in energy development.

Economic arguments also dominate the debate. Critics claim renewables are too costly for federal subsidies, mirroring past fights over offshore oil incentives. Meanwhile, global competitionโ€”especially Chinaโ€™s control of solar panel and battery supply chainsโ€”adds geopolitical complexity to the transition.

Despite these challenges, Beaudreau offered a measured note of optimism. He pointed to Western landowners and ranchers, historically conservation advocates, as potential allies in sustainable land management. Their interest in wildlife migration corridors and outdoor access could foster new conservation coalitions.

This map shows land owned by different federal government agencies. By National Atlas of the United States – http://nationalatlas.gov/printable/fedlands.html, “All Federal and Indian Lands”, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=32180954

Ultimately, Beaudreau underscored that energy transition requires modernizing laws, addressing economic realities, and building broad political consensus. As attendees left Wittemyer Courtroom, they carried with them a clear message: the road ahead is uncertain, but public lands remain central to shaping Americaโ€™s energy future and, as Wilkinson’s “lords of yesterday” remain, the imperatives of change have arrived.

The recording of the 16th annual Schultz Lecture can be foundย here.

Native land loss 1776 to 1930. Credit: Alvin Chang/Ranjani Chakraborty

From email from the Getches-Wilkinson Center (Annie Carlozzi):

Thank you for joining the Getches-Wilkinson Center and the Center of the American West for the Schultz Lecture in Energy on February 25th! We are so grateful to Tommy Beaudreau for making time in his schedule to spend lunch with our law students and the evening with all of our attendees in person and online.

We have a few things to share with you:

Conference Photos

Barb Colombo of 11:11 Productions Photography has provided us with wonderful images of the lecture with Tommy Beaudreau. Weโ€™ve added them to a Flickr album for easy viewing here.

Conference Recordings

The Law School IT Team has released the recording from the lecture.

GWC Blog
Current Colorado Law students Victoria Matson and Oliver Skelly shared their reflections on Tommy Beaudreauโ€™s visit to the Colorado Law School on the GWC blog. You can read their piece here.

Upcoming Event

We hope you will consider joining us for the annual Colorado River Conference co-convened by GWC and the Water & Tribes Initiative. You can find more information on our website regarding this yearโ€™s theme: Turning Hindsight into Foresight: The Colorado River at a Crossroads.

Photo credit: Getches-Wilkinson Center

How Wildfires Reshape Our Landscapes: Insights from Author Dr. Ellen Wohl

East Troublesome Fire. Photo credit: Northern Water

In this interview, Dr. Ellen Wohl describes her book, Landscapes on Fire: Impacts on Uplands, Rivers, and Communities. She explains the importance of an integrated approach to studying wildfires, bringing perspectives from across disciplines to understand how they reshape natural, biological, and human environments. Watch the full interview to find out more about the book. ๐Ÿ”— Browse or order Landscapes on Fire: http://lite.spr.ly/6006GDM0. ๐Ÿ‘‰ Access Landscapes on Fire via institutional subscription: http://lite.spr.ly/6008GDM2 ๐Ÿ“š Explore all AGU books: http://lite.spr.ly/6000GDM4#wildfire#climate#geomorphology#Rivers#EarthScience#STEM#Books#Publishing#AGUPubs

Walking the fine line of โ€˜all of the aboveโ€™: Two Republicans from #Colorado add names to letter calling for restraint in gutting of #climate legislation — Allen Best (BigPivots.com) #ActOnClimate

On March 13, 2025 Gabe Evans visited a five-megawatt solar installation near LaSalle. Photo courtesy of Rep. Gabe Evansย 

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

March 21, 2025

Colorado sends four Democrats and four Republicans to the U.S. House of Representatives. Of them, Jeff Hurd, a Republican from Grand Junction, and Gabe Evans, a Republican from Fort Lupton, will be the most interesting to watch during the next two years.

These two representatives, both new to Congress in January, were among 21 Republican signatories in the House to a letter calling for restraint in efforts to gut the Inflation Reduction Act.

The letter expresses concern about โ€œdisruptive changes to our nationโ€™s energy tax structure.โ€ The New York Times and Utility Dive both interpreted the language as a reference to the IRA, the landmark climate legislation adopted in August 2022. President Donald Trump, the Times notes, often talks about repealing the law.

Atlas Public Policy, a research firm, reported in February that 80% of funds authorized by the law have gone to Congressional districts represented by Republicans.

Hurd, an attorney who formerly was chief counsel for the Delta-Montrose Electric Association, essentially replaced Lauren Boebert in the Third Congressional District. Boebert was almost certainly headed for defeat had she tried to run against Aspenโ€™s Adam Frisch a second time in the Western Slope-dominated and Republican-leaning district after squeaking out just 50.6% of votes in the strongly Republican-leaning district. With a new home in Windsor, she easily won election in Coloradoโ€™s Fourth Congressional District.

While Boebert inevitably echoes Trump, Hurd signaled his measured distance from MAGA hat-wearing positions when he criticized Trumpโ€™s blanket pardon of rioters who had invaded the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021. At the same time, his bill, Productive Public Lands Act, rhymes with Trumpโ€™s drill-baby-drill slogan. Never mind that the United States has already been setting records for oil and gas extraction.

As long as he can survive Republican primaries. Hurd can probably return to Washington for a good many terms. His drill bill is likely part of that political dance.

Evans has a more tricky path to negotiate. He narrowly beat the incumbent Democrat, Yadira Caraveo, in the Eighth Congressional District. The district extends from the edge of Denver to the farm country of northern Colorado. Although a former police officer in Arvada, he nonetheless refrained from criticizing Trumpโ€™s pardons of  the rioters, as Denver TV newscaster Kyle Clark pointed out.

Most of Weld County lies in his district. The county delivers 82% of Coloradoโ€™s crude oil and 56% of its natural gas extraction. The district also has the Vestas factory in Brighton that produces nacelles for wind turbines. Vestas has 1,800 employees in Colorado between that factory and another in Windsor. Evansโ€™ district also has many solar energy installations.

On March 13, Evans visited the Vestas factory, a five-megawatt solar installation near LaSalle, and an oil installation. Bayswater, operator of the latter, proclaims itself a producer of โ€œsome of the cleanest energy molecules in the country and world.โ€

Invited to tag along, Channel 4 gave Evans the time to say that he favored an โ€œall-of-the-above safe, affordable, secure energy supply to bring costs down to consumers and jobs back to the United States.โ€

That โ€œall-of-the-above energy approachโ€ was a key element of the letter signed by Evans and Hurd. Combined with a robust advanced manufacturing sector, the approach โ€œwill support the United Statesโ€™ position as a global energy leader,โ€ the letter said. โ€œBoth our constituencies and the energy industry alike remain concerned about disruptive changes to our nationโ€™s energy tax structure.โ€

Tax credits adopted over the last decade โ€œallowed energy developers to plan with these tax incentives in mind. These timelines have been relied upon when it comes to capital allocation, planning, and project commitments, all of which would be jeopardized by premature credit phase outs or additional restrictive mechanisms such as limiting transferability.โ€

The Evans all-of-the-above tour was arranged by a former Republican state senator, Greg Brophy. Brophy grows watermelons north of Wray and operates an organization called The Western Way. Brophy has been a strong supporter of renewable energy for eastern Colorado and also has a presence on the Western Slope.

Brophy told me that he has organized a similar tour for another member of Congress from Colorado, but it has not been scheduled. He declined to identify the representative.

What if Trump succeeds in rolling back the federal energy tax credits? Energy Innovation, a think tank, estimates increased average household energy costs in Colorado of $180 per year by 2030.

Will other Republicans in Coloradoโ€™s congressional delegation join Evans and Hurd? After all, renewable energy didnโ€™t start out as a partisan issue.

Coloradoโ€™s energy industry has had a slightly rougher go of it, mainly because it specializes in natural gas, not crude oil, and methane prices have been low since the 2009 crash. Note to Jeff Hurd: Revenues were substantially higher under Biden than under Trump I. Just sayinโ€™. Source: ONRR via The Land Desk/Jonathan P. Thompson

We see the climate change in #NewMexico — Laura Paskus (WritersOnTheRange.org) #ActOnClimate

Click the link to read the article on the Writers on the Range website (Laura Paskus):

March 10, 2025

Here in New Mexico, our growing season has lengthened since the 1970s, even as stream flows have decreased. Fire season starts earlier, lasts longer, and in some years, ignites the forests into record-breaking blazes, like the gargantuan Hermits Peak-Calf Canyon and Black fires in 2022.

If you look at the last century in New Mexico, stretches of higher temperatures have lengthened; heat waves are hotter and nights, consistently warmer.

Rising heat and expanding aridity harm ecosystems and wildlife and hotter days are dangerous for anyone outside, especially people without housing or access to cool spaces. Extreme heat even interacts with certain medications people need for their physical and mental health. 

It should be no surprise that weโ€™re facing another crackly-dry spring, summer, and fall. Fans watching the March 2 Oscars on Albuquerque TV saw flashing red-flag fire warnings. The next day, high winds and dust storms blasted the state; near Deming, a haboob of fast-moving dust shut down highways.

West Drought Monitor map March 11, 2025.

As of early March, 92 percent of New Mexico was experiencing drought, with almost 30 percent of the state in severe to extreme drought, according to the U.S. Drought Monitor.

Arizona is in even worse shape: 100 percent of the state is in drought, with 87 percent in severe to exceptional drought. And the interior Westโ€™s three-month outlook is for warm, dry conditions โ€” especially in Arizona and New Mexico.

Here in New Mexico, the Middle Rio Grande Conservancy Districtโ€”which supplies water for farmsโ€”is warning runoff season will be short and river flows, low. The districtโ€™s leaders are urging farmers to plan for extended periods between irrigation deliveries and say that without summertime monsoons, they will not meet everyoneโ€™s needs this year.

During the 1900sโ€”including during the infamous 1950s drought and earlier in this centuryโ€”armers could often still expect full water allocations in a dry year.

Now, when farmers donโ€™t receive waterโ€”and the Rio Grande dries for long stretchesโ€”itโ€™s not only because there isnโ€™t enough snow melting off the mountains.  Itโ€™s also because consistently dry soils suck up any moisture, making both forests and croplands thirstier.

Not only that, but decades of persistent drought and warming temperatures have desiccated reservoirs along the Rio Grande and its tributary, the Chama River.

On the Chama River, Heron Reservoir is 14 percent full; its neighbors, El Vado and Abiquiu, are at 14 percent and 51 percent respectively. Further down the watershed, on the Rio Grande in southern New Mexico, Elephant Butte Reservoir is only 13 percent full, and its neighbor, Caballo, nine percent full. 

In New Mexico, some water users, including the irrigation district, rely on water piped from the Colorado River watershed into the Chama and then the Rio Grande. This year, most of that supplemental water wonโ€™t be there.

The view upstream on both watersheds is also troubling, especially in Arizona, New Mexico and southern Utah where the snowpack is โ€œbelow to well-below median.โ€ Last month, the Colorado Riverโ€™s two largest reservoirs, Lake Powell and Lake Mead, were 34 percent full, the lowest theyโ€™d been in early February for the last 30 years of records.

Iโ€™m alarmed by many things happening right now, including the disappearance of climate data from federal websites and the gutting of federal workforces and budgets. We need wildland firefighters, scientists, and the staffers who kept our parks and public lands functioning.

But as a reporter who has covered climate change and its impacts in my state for more than two decades, I take the long view along with a local view.

We have known for decades that the planet is steadily warming and that the impacts of climate change would intensify. And we must resist focusing solely on the current chaos of the federal government. [ed. emphasis mine]

Laura Paskus. Photo credit: Writers on the Range

Thereโ€™s never been a better time to become immersed in local politics or organizing, and to hold state and local leaders accountable for action on climate.

We can collaborate on local solutions and work together to better deal with the crises we face. Really, we have no choice.

Laura Paskus is a contributor to Writers on the Range, writersontherange.org, an independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about Western issues She is longtime reporter based in Albuquerque and the author of At the Precipice: New Mexicoโ€™s Changing Climate and Water Bodies.

#Colorado West Slope Letdown: U.S. Representative Lauren Boebert left, MAGA stuck around — Jonathan P. Thompson (LandDesk.org)

Sky with oil and gas infrastructure, Greater Chaco Region. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

Click the link to read the article on The Land Desk website (Jonathan P. Thompson):

March 15, 2025

Data Dump: Setting baselines to monitor “energy dominance” under Trump

When Republican Jeff Hurd was elected to represent Coloradoโ€™s third congressional district, I believe I heard a bipartisan, collective sigh of relief. Democrats may have been sad that their candidate didnโ€™t win, but at least the new guy wasnโ€™t Lauren Boebert. And, many of us hoped, Hurd would represent a return of the independent and pragmatic Western politician of old to western and southern Colorado.

We were wrong.

So far, Hurdโ€™s performance in office has pretty much followed Boebertโ€™s lead, politically, albeit without the gun-slinging and other outrageous antics. When one of his aides showed up to meet with constituents in Dolores, she fled after seeing the size of the crowd assembled there. Hurd, himself, chickened out from attending a town hall in Grand Junction for similar reasons. Instead of apologizing for refusing to listen to the people he represents, he accused the crowd of being George Soros-funded activists โ€” a false and worn-out, right-wing anti-semitic trope that really needs to be retired. In fact, the folks were his constituents, including members of Indivisible and the League of Women Voters. These werenโ€™t exactly molotov cocktail hurling radicals.

And when CPRโ€™s Ryan Warner asked him about the mass federal employee firings that have hit his district especially hard, Hurd gave mealy mouthed answers, saying efficiency is good, acknowledging he had no idea how many employees had lost their jobs, and lamenting the possibility that some good people may have been terminated, too, though it was also clear that he wasnโ€™t going to do anything about it, especially if it meant questioning or, God forbid, standing up to Musk and Trump.

Hurd introduced a bill that would move the Bureau of Land Management headquarters to Grand Junction because itโ€™s better to have management staff on the ground, yet he has not pushed back on DOGEโ€™s plans to close federal offices throughout his district, including the Bureau of Reclamation and Army Corps of Engineers offices in Durango. He has teamed up with Boebert to criticize Colorado for importing โ€œforeign wolvesโ€ into the state and has parroted MAGAโ€™s anti-immigrant hysteria in regards to Denverโ€™s tolerance.

Now Hurd has introduced the Productive Public Lands Act to โ€œunlock resource development on some of our most productive lands.โ€ It would toss Biden-era Bureau of Land Management resource management plans โ€” which he claims โ€œlocked up access to viable landsโ€ โ€” and replace them with fossil fuel-friendly ones with the aim of putting โ€œus on a path to energy dominance.โ€ Talk about inefficient: Those RMPs took years to develop and are the result of extensive studies, public input, and compromise. Trashing them is a perfect example of government waste. [ed. emphasis mine]

Note to Rep. Hurd: Public lands are not locked up. Quite to the contrary. Unfortunately Hurd โ€” like his predecessor โ€” has chosen to let MAGA ideology and disinformation blind him to the facts. Still, Iโ€™ve got to try, so here I go again: The United States is producing more oil and gas โ€” much of it from public lands โ€” than it ever has before, and is the worldโ€™s leader in hydrocarbon production. Read that again. Then again. And keep doing so until it penetrates your thick skull so that you can stop wasting all of our time with your โ€œwar on energyโ€ nonsense.

While drilling has shifted away from Colorado and is now centered on the Permian Basin, it has nothing to do with BLM regulations or resource management plans. Itโ€™s because western Colorado is rich in natural gas, not so much in oil, and thereโ€™s far less money in natural gas production than there is in crude oil. Nevertheless, oil, gas, coal, and carbon dioxide production from federal lands in Colorado (much of which are on the Western Slope) generated $205 million in revenue last year. Locked up? I donโ€™t think so.

***

As long as Iโ€™m on the topic of โ€œenergy dominance,โ€ I figured it would be a good time to set out some baseline data for tracking the progress of Trumpโ€™s โ€œdrill, baby, drillโ€ agenda. As has been established, the Trumps and Hurds of the world believe that energy production from federal lands has been โ€œlocked up,โ€ and that by โ€œunleashingโ€ it โ€” i.e. rescinding environmental protections โ€” the oil and gas industry will bring in a battalion of drill rigs, send oil and gas production through the roof, and bring down prices at the pump to make it cheaper to drive those gas-guzzling behemoths that now dominate the roadways.

Itโ€™s too early in Trumpโ€™s term to determine whether thatโ€™s actually happening or not, so letโ€™s just check in on where we are and what has happened over the last four years. And weโ€™ll keep updating these graphs periodically. Land Desk readers have seen some of these before. Sorry about that.

This one shows U.S. crude oil production. It was in steady decline until about 2009, kicking back up again just as Obama took office. Is that because Obama slashed regulations on drilling? No. Itโ€™s because thatโ€™s when horizontal drilling-multistage hydraulic fracturing, i.e. fracking, came into its own and oil prices increased. Production dipped at the end of Obamaโ€™s second term because OPEC decided to wage a price war on U.S. producers, glutting the market with crude in hopes of driving some U.S. companies out of business. And it dipped again at the end of Trumpโ€™s first term because of COVID. In December, while Biden was still in office, U.S. fields produced 418 million barrels of crude, an all-time record high. Source: Energy Information Administration.

Production goes up after drilling activity increases. Drilling activity generally responds to crude oil prices. When prices are high, itโ€™s more profitable to develop new oil and gas wells, so the drilling rigs are dusted off and head out into the fields. When prices are low, they are folded up and hauled back to the storage yard.

And lest you think that maybe all of that production is coming from private or state lands since, after all, the federal land has all been โ€œlocked upโ€ by Bidenโ€™s purported war on energy, check out the revenues from federal land resource production for New Mexico and Colorado. Funny how they shot up right after Biden was elected, no?

Oil production from federal lands in New Mexico generated $4.65 billion last year, down slightly from 2022 but still significantly more than during any other time during the last two decades. Source: Office of Natural Resource Revenue.

Coloradoโ€™s energy industry has had a slightly rougher go of it, mainly because it specializes in natural gas, not crude oil, and methane prices have been low since the 2009 crash. Note to Jeff Hurd: Revenues were substantially higher under Biden than under Trump I. Just sayinโ€™. Source: ONRR

The best way to get a feel for drilling activity is to check out the weekly rig count. So here it is. But a note to all you statisticians out there: The time intervals are uneven on this graph, in part due to my own laziness. But it still gives a fairly accurate picture of drilling activity over time, so it works.

This gives a good illustration of the level of drilling activity and where itโ€™s taking place. This shows the OPEC price war dip in 2015 and 2016 and the COVID dip in 2020. Again, these are driven almost entirely by the price of crude oil, which is determined by the global market. North Dakota dominated for a while, but never recovered from the 2015 crash. Instead, activity moved to the Permian Basin in New Mexico and Texas. The rig count for Western states remained remarkably stable during the Biden administration. Source: Baker-Hughes.

The thing about production and rig counts, though, is they donโ€™t really reflect White House policy. So how about the number of drilling permits approved by the Bureau of Land Management?

On average, Bidenโ€™s BLM issued around the same number of drilling permits as Trump I. This may have something to do with policy, but it is also driven by how many firms apply for permits and how well-equipped and staffed the field offices are to process those applications. Note that during the last four months of Bidenโ€™s term, the BLM issued over 1,300 permits. So far, the Trump II administration has issued 774 permits in just over two months. Source: BLM.

Now that we have a snapshot of where weโ€™ve been and where we are in terms of oil and gas development, we can track where we might be headed under Trump 2.0. My guess? Weโ€™re going to see all of the above indicators begin falling soon. Sure, rig counts are staying steady, meaning production will continue to rise for a few more months. But after that, lower oil prices are likely to kick in, dimming companiesโ€™ enthusiasm for drilling, which will hit the rig count first and then production.

Graphic credit: The Land Desk

Oil prices are dropping โ€” they hit sub-$70/bbl this week for the first time since 2021 โ€” because OPEC decided to start pumping more crude and because the economy is struggling, which will likely dampen demand. The economy is struggling because markets are reacting unfavorably to the chaos Trump, Musk, and company are wreaking from the White House. Turns out that tariffs, trade wars, and haphazard termination of critical federal employees is bad for the economy. Gasoline prices will likely fall, too, except in places that rely on Canadian crude, where they might increase. So there is that. Of course, if you lose all your money in the plummeting stock market, it wonโ€™t really matter much, I suppose.


Speaking of tariffs, remember when I wrote about Trumpโ€™s trade wars and predicted that American whiskey and bourbon makers would be casualties? Turns out I was right. Kentucky distillers, especially the small ones, are already feeling the pain, and even large ones are smarting from Canadaโ€™s retaliatory moves. I suppose Trump will claim the Canadians started the trade war, just as heโ€™s ridiculously asserting Ukraine invaded Russia.

๐Ÿ“ธ Parting Shot ๐ŸŽž๏ธ
St. Josephโ€™s Church, San Fidel, New Mexico. Jonathan P. Thompson photo.

#Colorado lawmakers eye new task force to boost water funding — Jerd Smith (Fresh Water News)

Republican House members recite the Pledge of Allegiance as Colorado lawmakers returned to the Capitol January 8, 23025, for opening day at the General Assembly. Photo credit: Fresh Water News

Click the link to read the article on the Fresh Water News website (Jerd Smith):

March 13, 2025

Colorado lawmakers, worried that a key source of money for water projects is too easily tapped for other programs, want to create a special task force to examine ways to stabilize and boost funding for things like new water pipelines and conservation programs.

Under Senate Bill 40, a nine-member panel would examine new options to replace severance tax money that is collected on nonrenewable resources, such as oil and gas and some minerals, and is highly variable. A portion of the revenue is used to help Colorado address looming water shortages.

According to state forecasts, by 2050 those shortages could be as high as 740,000 acre-feet of water, under a worst-case planning scenario, or much lower if growth slows and climate change impacts are less than expected. One acre-foot of water equals nearly 326,000 gallons, enough water to serve at least two urban homes for one year.

Like other Western states, Colorado is racing to shore up aging water systems and make existing supplies stretch further as drought and rising temperatures shrink water supplies.

The bill comes as lawmakers wrestle with how to cut $1.2 billion from a state purse hurt by slowing growth and revenue caps. 

The measure, sponsored by Sen. Dylan Roberts, D-Frisco, Sen. Cleave Simpson, R-Alamosa, Rep. Karen McCormick, D-Longmont, and Rep. Matthew Martinez, D-Monte Vista, is stalled in the Senate appropriations committee until the legislature completes its budget work, Roberts said.

Roberts said the current budget crisis and previous fiscal storms have resulted in severance tax revenue being tapped to help resolve budget shortfalls in nonwater programs, a situation that hits hard at the stateโ€™s ongoing efforts to ensure there is enough water to go around.

โ€œThe joint budget committee has swept severance taxes in the past. Not too often, but I worry that it will become a common practice. I and my cosponsors want to get the best minds together on how we better plan for the future,โ€ he said.

Lawmakers plan a new tax force to find ways to replace the stateโ€™s reliance on severance taxes. Credit: Colorado Legislative Council

The Colorado Water Conservation Board is the stateโ€™s primary water planning agency, and helps fund an array of water projects and planning initiatives. Its revenues come from interest on loans, money from the stateโ€™s general operating fund, sports betting tax revenues, and severance tax revenues, among other sources.

Late last year, Gov. Jared Polis proposed a budget that largely shielded water programs from major cuts, but it is lawmakers who will make the final decision on how the stateโ€™s budget will be balanced this year.

The severance tax has generated $412 million for the CWCB over the past 10 years, according to Kirk Russell, the CWCBโ€™s finance section chief. Most of that goes into a revolving loan fund that helps finance such things as irrigation ditch repairs and pipelines. It isnโ€™t typically used to finance the water agencyโ€™s operating budget.

But he said the severance tax fund experiences โ€œa great deal of variabilityโ€ from year to year.

A bright spot in the funding picture, according to Roberts, is the growth in revenue collected from gambling on sports. According to the Colorado Division of Gaming, sports betting has generated $98 million in revenue since May 2020, when sports betting became legal in Colorado. The majority of that money is now used to help fund the Colorado Water Plan.

Roberts said lawmakers are open to considering a range of options to stabilize water funding, and he said there may be potential to expand the revenue generated by sports betting. In January, the program hit a new high, generating $4.4 million. The previous high occurred in January 2024, when $4.1 million was generated, according to the Division of Gaming.

If the bipartisan task force measure is approved, members would be selected this summer and a final report would be due back to lawmakers by July 15, 2026.

#Colorado Will Require Oil and Gas Companies to Increase Water Recycling for Fracking — Jake Bolster and Martha Pskowski (InsideClimateNews.org) #ActOnClimate

Directional drilling from one well site via the National Science Foundation

Click the link to read the article on the Inside Climate News website (Jake Bolster and Martha Pskowski):

March 13, 2025

Freshwater use in oil and gas drilling has come under scrutiny in Colorado as the state faces a historic drought. On Wednesday, March 12, state regulators announced new rules that will require drillers to use more recycled water in their operations and, hopefully, relieve pressure on scarce freshwater resources.

As Colorado continues to produce fossil fuels at record pace, the Centennial State has become awash in a caustic, brackish and chemically-laden fluid known as produced water, a byproduct of the drilling and fracking process. 

Diagram of Hydraulic Fracking Machinery and Process. By Emiliawilkinson – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=132536012

This water can have high levels of salts, metals and other contaminants, making it more difficult and expensive to treat for reuse than for disposal. Oil and gas companies in Colorado typically dispose of produced water by pumping it back into old, out-of-service wells and other geological formations using injection wells, permanently severing it from the hydrological cycle. Meanwhile, freshwater demand for oil and gas production in Colorado is forecasted to rise in the coming decade as the industry drills deeper vertically and farther horizontally.

The oil and gas industry, whose activity in Colorado accounts for almost 4 percent of U.S. total crude oil output, uses about 11 billion gallons of fresh water annually in Colorado, according to data collected by the Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission (ECMC). Thatโ€™s comparable to the amount of water stored behind a small dam, but accounts for less than one percent of all fresh water used in the state. 

โ€œThings are changing quicklyโ€ for Colorado as climate change intensifies, said Harmony Cummings, a director of the Green House Connection Center, an environmental nonprofit party to the rulemaking. โ€œHow low the reservoirs are is terrifying to me.โ€

Turning Waste Into a Resource

In 2023, the Colorado state legislature passed HB23-1242 (Water Conservation In Oil And Gas Operations: Concerning water used in oil and gas operations, and, in connection therewith, making an appropriation), which required the ECMC to adopt rules โ€œrequiring a statewide reduction in usage of fresh water and a corresponding increase in usage of recycled or reused water in oil and gas operations.โ€

The bill also created Coloradoโ€™s Produced Water Consortium, a body of 31 people including regulators, industry representatives, environmentalists and scientists. The group is studying how produced water that comes to the surface during drilling can be reused in other oil and gas operations to reduce freshwater consumption, and its reports served as the basis for its recommendations to the ECMC. 

โ€œThe consortium started out with everyone coming in with an agenda,โ€ said Hope Dalton, the consortiumโ€™s director. โ€œThen they began to learn from each other and trust each other and really work to create these data-informed recommendationsโ€ฆI think the recommendations are very solid.โ€

Produced water is a catch-all term for water that flows out of oil and gas wells after conventional drilling or hydraulic fracturing, or fracking. This liquid waste can contain drilling chemicals injected into wells, toxic hydrocarbons like benzene, a known carcinogen, and water dislodged from deep underground that carries sediments, salts, metals like barium, manganese and strontium, and Naturally Occurring Radioactive Materials (NORM).

Oil and gas evaporation pond

The Produced Water Consortium compiled data on existing water practices in Coloradoโ€™s oil and gas industry to inform the rule-making. It found that water diverted for fracking in Colorado totals about 26,000 acre feet a year, or 0.17 percent of the stateโ€™s total water use. One acre-foot is 325,851 gallons of water, meaning the oil and gas industry holds rights to about 8.5 billion gallons of freshwater annually.

Between July 2023 and March 2024, according to the consortiumโ€™s findings, operators reported to the state that they disposed of 87 percent of their produced water and recycled the remaining 13 percent. Companies reported that 93.2 percent of produced water disposal was into underground injection wells. Much smaller volumes of water are disposed of in pits or discharged into state surface water bodies. The initial data on recycling rates is self-reported by the companies and only reflects the short period of time that reporting has been required.

The Denver-Julesburg basin, or DJ Basin for short, along Coloradoโ€™s Front Range is home to a vast majority of the industryโ€™s development and water demand. It is also home to the vast majority of the stateโ€™s population, including the metro areas of Denver, Boulder and Fort Collins. From 2019 to 2024, an average of two new fracking wells were completed daily in the DJ Basin, five-and-a-half times the industryโ€™s rate in other basins in the state, according to ECMC data.

Niobrara Shale Denver Julesberg Basin

Companies in the DJ Basin account for almost three quarters of the industryโ€™s total water use, according to ECMC data from 2022. In the DJ Basin, only 0.4 percent of that water is recycled. The Western Slope, which is more rural, has fewer drilling companies but a much higher rate of recycling produced water for operations, sometimes as high as 100 percent.

Under Coloradoโ€™s new regulations, by the beginning of 2026, oil companies must use at least 4 percent recycled produced water across their operations in the state. In 2030, that requirement increases to a minimum of 10 percent. 

The ECMC will convene again in 2028 to draft new benchmarks beyond 2030. If a consensus fails to emerge, minimum averages of 20 percent recycled water in 2034 and 35 percent in 2038, as recommended by the Consortium, will become law.

If an operator is unable to meet these thresholds, they would be allowed to purchase โ€œcreditsโ€ for excess produced water recycled by other operators, but only if those credits would be used in the same basin.

โ€œIncreasing recycling doesnโ€™t necessarily equate to a decrease in freshwaterโ€ use, said Cummings. If the rate of fracking in Colorado rises faster than the produced water recycling thresholds, itโ€™s possible that produced water reuse and freshwater use could both go up, she said.

Other new rules require oil and gas companies to make quarterly reports on what freshwater is used for, the total amount of water and produced water used in each basin, and figures on emissions from truck traffic, among other statistics. Operators will also be required to report how they would meet produced water reuse thresholds. The ECMC could issue penalties to companies that donโ€™t comply with the new rules.

But Cummings worried those penalties arenโ€™t onerous enough. There are โ€œno real teethโ€ in the enforcement mechanisms, said Cummings, who spent eight years working in the oil and gas industry. If given the proper combination of regulation and incentives, she is confident companies could recycle produced water at greater rates than Colorado is requiring.

โ€œIโ€™ve seen them do incredible projects when profits are on the other side of that,โ€ she said.