
Here’s the release from the Eagle River Coalition (Matthew L. Moseley):
November 20, 2026
A broad chorus of voices has expressed opposition to Aurora Water’s proposed 95,000-acre-foot Wild Horse Reservoir application following the November 19 deadline for public comments to the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE).
Across the Western Slope and beyond, water agencies, municipalities, metropolitan districts, state legislators, businesses and individual residents raised serious concerns about the application, particularly the lack of information about the project’s water sources.
“We appreciate the outpouring of support to protect the Eagle River Basin rivers from Aurora Water’s plan,” said Vicki Flynn, executive director of the Eagle River Coalition. “People know additional water from transmountain diversions is a 19th-century solution to a 21st-century problem. We have just faced the worst water year on record in Eagle County, and this is not the time or the place to take more water across the Continental Divide that will never return.”
Among those expressing opposition or serious concerns were the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District, Berry Creek Metropolitan District, the Town of Avon, Fishpond and numerous other organizations and businesses. Also notable are letters of opposition from national and state organizations, such as Trout Unlimited, Audubon Society, Sierra Club, American Rivers, Western Resource Advocates, Conservation Colorado and Wilderness Workshop.
Bipartisan and bi-basin concerns were also reflected in comments from state legislators, including Sen. Marc Catlin, Sen. Dylan Roberts, Rep. Meghan Lukens and Rep. Lesley Smith, who represents Boulder and Clear Creek counties on the Front Range. Their participation underscores that the questions raised by Wild Horse extend beyond one watershed or one region of Colorado.
A central concern throughout the public response was the lack of a clear accounting of how much water the project would require from the Colorado River Basin, including the Eagle River and Homestake Creek, when that water would be diverted and how the project could affect existing streamflows and downstream water users.
Aurora Water has previously acknowledged to the Vail Daily that it is “difficult to provide specifics” about how much Homestake water would be needed for Wild Horse. The Coalition believes that uncertainty is precisely why the application should not move forward as submitted.
“The people and communities of the Western Slope deserve answers before decisions are made that could affect our rivers for generations,” Flynn said. “Existing water rights do not eliminate the need to understand the impacts of moving and storing water. We need a full accounting of the water sources, diversion operations and cumulative effects on our watersheds.”
The Eagle River Coalition maintains that CDPHE should reject the application as currently submitted and require a complete evaluation of its water sources, potential changes to transmountain diversion operations, environmental impacts and consequences for downstream communities.
The Coalition thanks everyone who took the time to participate in the public process and make their concerns known. The strong response demonstrates the importance of protecting healthy rivers and ensuring that the interests of Colorado’s water-producing communities are considered in major water-management decisions.
About the Eagle River Coalition
The Eagle River Coalition advocates for the health of the Upper Colorado and Eagle River watersheds through research, education, and projects.
