Seven statesโ€™ #ColoradoRiver negotiators, all at same conference, didnโ€™t meet together: โ€œTensions are extremely highโ€ — Elise Schmelzer (The #Denver Post) #CRWUA2024 #COriver #aridification

Las Vegas has reduced its water consumption even as its population has increased. (Source: Southern Nevada Water Authority)

Click the link to read the article on The Denver Post website (Elise Schmelzer). Here’s an excerpt:

December 6, 2024

Policymakers, academics, irrigators and water attorneys gathered in the Nevada desert this week to discuss the future of the highly contentious river that makes modern life possible for so many people across a vast swath of the American Southwest. The current guidelines that dictate how water is shared among the seven Colorado River basin states are set to expire at the end of 2026, and government leaders must create a new plan before then.

Udall/Overpeck 4-panel Figure Colorado River temperature/precipitation/natural flows with trend. Lake Mead and Lake Powell storage. Updated through Water Year 2024. Credit: Brad Udall

To do so, they must decide who will get less water โ€” and when โ€” as climate change shrinks the riverโ€™s flows.

โ€œThe tensions are extremely high this year,โ€ said Tanya Trujillo, water policy advisor and deputy state engineer for New Mexico. โ€œOf the 20 years Iโ€™ve been coming to this conference, this is the one with the least-good relations among the states.โ€

[…]

Carly Jerla speaking at the Colorado River Water User’s Association Conference December 5, 2024. Photo credit: USBR

The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, which operates Lakes Mead and Powell, must create a new operating plan for the reservoirs before current guidelines expire at the end of 2026. The bureau is halfway through the process, said Carly Jerla, senior program manager at the agency. The bureau must complete environmental analyses of potential operating guidelines, take public comment and make a final decision by August 2026, she said.

โ€œWe need to be moving, as a basin, a lot faster in this second half than we did in our first halfโ€ of the process, Jerla said…

Upper Basin negotiators believe their basin should be exempt from mandatory water-use cuts imposed by the federal government because water use in the basin is already restricted by the amount of precipitation. While the Lower Basin can use water stored in Mead and Powell in dry years, Upper Basin states do not have large upstream reservoirs and must instead rely on snowpack and rainfall. Historically, the Upper Basin has never been able to use its full allocation of water, negotiators from the basin said. Water users in Colorado have their water cut off every year because there is not enough, Mitchell said. The Lower Basin must acknowledge those losses and recognize that the Upper Basin has been living with the impacts of climate change for years, she said.

Lake Powell key elevations. Credit: Reclamation
Lake Mead key elevations. Credit: USBR

Effort continues to win Wild and Scenic designation for #DeepCreek in Eagle County — The #Vail Daily

The bottom of Deep Creek is a unique area of Eagle County. A large group of stakeholders has been working for years to obtain federal Wild and Scenic Rivers designation for a roughly 15-mile stretch of the creek between Deep Lake and the Colorado River. Photo credit: BLM

Click the link to read the article on the Vail Daily website (Scott N. Miller). Here’s an excerpt:

November 29, 2024

Deep Creek is one of Eagle Countyโ€™s most remarkable places. Years-long efforts continue to preserve that western Eagle County landscape. A 15-mile stretch of Deep Creekย nearly a decade agoย was found suitable for preservation under the 1968 Wild and Scenic Rivers Act.ย That actย aims to preserve streams that are free-flowing and have โ€œoutstanding, remarkable values.โ€ Part of the criteria also includes lack of dams or reservoirs along the stream. Deep Creek would seem to meet those criteria, especially given that it has unique geological features in its canyon and unique plant life in some stretches…

But like any federal status, thereโ€™s a long to-do list to accomplish, and designation takes an act of Congress. The Deep Creek designation also has a lot of interested parties. The creek is in two counties โ€” Garfield and Eagle. The portion of the creek eligible for designation is all on federal land, but authority for that land is split between the Bureau of Land Management and the U.S. Forest Service. The creek also sits in two congressional districts, Coloradoโ€™s 2nd and 3rd. The 3rd will be represented in January by Grand Junction Republican Jeff Hurd. Boulder Democrat Joe Neguse represents the 2nd. Smith is the Bureauโ€™s liaison to a large stakeholder group named Deep Creek Wild and Scenic Stakeholder Group, which began meeting in 2017. The Colorado River District is part of that group, in part because the district hopes to augment the creekโ€™s flow in the spring runoff season…

While many of us see Deep Creek from the overlook along Coffee Pot Road on the way to Deep Lake, the headwaters of the creek, there are trails to the canyonโ€™s bottom. Smith has hiked in and noted Deep Creek has โ€œcompletely naturalโ€ hydrology, with a โ€œglobally rare ecosystem.โ€ In addition, there are caves among the canyon walls and other features for those willing to put in the work.

Public land protectors are ready for a fight — Jennifer Rokala (WritersOnTheRange.org)

The Citadel, Bears Ears National Monument, Dave Marston photo

Click the link to read the article on the Writers on the Range website (Jennifer Rokala):

November 18, 2024

President Donald Trumpโ€™s first term was a disaster for Americaโ€™s public lands. While the prospects for his second term are even more bleak, Westerners across the political spectrumโ€”even those who voted for Trumpโ€”stand ready to oppose attempts to sell off Americaโ€™s public lands to the highest bidder.

As for Trumpโ€™s pick for Interior Secretary, North Dakota Governor Doug Burgum: If Burgum tries to turn Americaโ€™s public lands into an even bigger cash cow for the oil and gas industry, or tries to shrink Americaโ€™s parks and national monuments, heโ€™ll quickly discover heโ€™s on the wrong side of history.

Public lands have strong bipartisan support in the West. The annual Conservation in the West Poll, last released by the Colorado College State of the Rockies Project in February 2024, found that nearly three-quarters of votersโ€”including Republicansโ€”want to protect clean water, air quality and wildlife habitats, while providing opportunities to visit and recreate on public lands.

Thatโ€™s compared to just one-quarter of voters who prefer maximizing the use of public lands available for drilling and mining. According to the poll, which surveyed voters in Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyomingโ€”80 % of Westerners support the national goal of conserving 30 % of land and waters in America by the year 2030.

Bipartisan support for more conservation and balanced energy development has been a cornerstone of the pollโ€™s findings since it began in 2011. Under the leadership of President Joe Biden and Interior Secretary Deb Haaland, the current administration has made progress over the past four years in bringing public land management in line with the preferences of Western voters. That includes better protecting the Grand Canyon, increasing accountability for oil and gas companies that operate on public land, and putting conservationโ€”at lastโ€”on par with drilling and mining on public land.

The President-elect may find it hard to immediately block what Westerners want. After Trump took office in 2017 promising to transform public land management, his team was unprepared and used its power to benefit its own interests, ignoring the wishes of the American people.

Trumpโ€™s first Interior secretary, Ryan Zinke, misused his position to advance his dream of owning a microbrewery in Montana. Trumpโ€™s second Interior secretary, oil and gas industry lobbyist David Bernhardt, put his finger on the scale in the interest of a former client. Trumpโ€™s choice to run the Bureau of Land Management, William Perry Pendley, served illegally without being confirmed by Congress.

We worked hard to shed light on this corruption and defend public lands from Trumpโ€™s attacks. Still, Trumpโ€™s Interior department allowed oil and gas companies to lock up millions of acres for bargain basement prices.

In his second term, Donald Trump will attempt to shrink national monuments like Bears Ears in Utah and permit drilling and mining in inappropriate areas. The president-elect has already committed to undoing President Joe Bidenโ€™s energy and environmental policies.

Project 2025, the policy handbook written by former Trump officials, clearly lays out a plan to gut the Interior Department and remove environmental safeguards that ensure the health of our public lands.

Project 2025 would give extractive industries nearly unfettered access to public lands, severely restrict the power of the Endangered Species Act, open millions of acres of Alaska wilderness to drilling, mining and logging and roll back protections for spectacular landscapes like Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante national monuments. It would also remove protections for iconic Western species such as gray wolves and grizzly bears.

What can we do about this assault? The law and public opinion are on our side. Public land protections are stronger today than ever, thanks in large part to the grassroots efforts of Tribes, local community leaders and conservation organizations.

We know much of whatโ€™s in Trumpโ€™s public lands playbook, and we will fight back. Weโ€™ll continue to shine a light on corruption within the Trump administration and hold it accountable.

Our partners will work in Congress to stop bad policies and projects from going forward. We are ready to take action in the courts and in the streets. And weโ€™re not waiting until Inauguration Day to start.

Jennifer Rokala is a contributor to Writers on the Range, writersontherange.org, an independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about Western issues. She is executive director of Center for Western Priorities, a nonpartisan public lands advocacy group.

#ColoradoRiver Water Leaders Release Recommendations for Augmentation Projects — Water Education Foundation (@WaterEdFdn) #COriver #aridification

Click the link to read the article on the Water Education Foundation website (Trevor Birt, Fernando Castro-Alvarez, Dennis Davis, Clarence Fullard, Alexander Funk, Daniel Galindo, Marnie Kremer, Dylan Mohamed, Annalise Porter, Noe Santos, Cora Tso, Rachel von Gnechten):

November 14, 2024

The 2024 Colorado River Water Leaders cohort completed its seven-month program with policy recommendations involving โ€augmentationโ€ โ€“ projects that increase the availability and supply of water โ€“ as the Colorado River Basin grows hotter and drier.

The cohort of 12 up-and-coming leaders included engineers, lawyers, resource specialists and others working for public, private and non-governmental organizations from across the riverโ€™s basin. The cohort had full editorial control to choose its recommendations.

Their report provides a roadmap to promote a purposeful, continuing dialogue around the deployment of water augmentation projects, such as seawater and brackish desalination, water recycling and cloud seeding. The report outlines ways to reduce barriers to implementation through strategies that enable consensus around goals, information sharing and funding support.

The report recommends the formation of an inclusive Water Augmentation Community of Practice that would:

  • Commit to continuousย formal discussions on the future of augmentation in the Colorado River Basin.
  • Create a system to identify and prioritize the most promising augmentation projects.
  • Endorse a comprehensive, durable funding structure, supportedย by a wide group of contributors, to finance the launch of augmentation projects.

Click here to read the full report.

Cohort members presented their recommendations in September at the Water Education Foundationโ€™s biennial Colorado River Symposium, an invitation-only event in Santa Fe, N.M., whose audience included key water managers, state and federal officials, tribal leaders and other interested groups throughout the Colorado River Basin.

Our biennial Colorado River Water Leaders program is modeled after our California Water Leaders program, which deepens the participantsโ€™ knowledge of water, enhances their leadership skills and prepares them to take an active, cooperative approach to decision-making on water issues. Leading experts and policymakers served as mentors to cohort members.

The next Colorado River Water Leaders cohort will be in 2026.

2024 Colorado River Water Leaders cohort in front of Hoover Dam during the Foundationโ€™s Lower Colorado River Tour in March 2024.

Acidic mine drainage haunts Western rivers — David Marston (Writers on the Range)

Reid Christopher in font of textile bags, mining ruins in background, Gladstone Treatment Plant, San Miguel County, CO. Dave Marston

Click the link to read the article on the Writers on the Range website (David Marston):

October 28, 2024

It was the summer of 2015 when the Animas River in southern Colorado turned such a garish orange-gold that it made national news.

This image was taken during the peak outflow from the Gold King Mine spill at 10:57 a.m. Aug. 5, 2015. The waste-rock dump can be seen eroding on the right. Federal investigators placed blame for the blowout squarely on engineering errors made by the Environmental Protection Agencyโ€™s-contracted company in a 132-page report released Thursday [October 22, 2015]

The metallic color came from the Gold King Mine, near the town of Silverton in the San Juan Range. The abandoned mine had been plugged by an earthen and rock dam known as a bulkhead, behind which orange, highly acidic drainage water accumulated. But after a federal Environmental Protection Agency employee accidentally breached the plug during an unauthorized excavation, 3.5 million gallons of additional runoff rushed downstream.

The worker and the EPA came in for a slew of outrage and blame. Alarmed Tribal Nations and towns halted drinking water and irrigation operations; tourists fled the region during the height of tourist season.

The โ€œBonita Peak Mining Districtโ€ superfund site. Map via the Environmental Protection Agency

But hereโ€™s the surprising opinion of Ty Churchwell, the mining coordinator for Trout Unlimited: โ€œLooking back, this can be taken as a positive thing because of what happened afterward.โ€ He sits on a community advisory group for the Bonita Peak Mining District, a Superfund site that contains the Gold King mine.

โ€œWeโ€™ve got federal Superfund designation, and itโ€™s the only tool at our disposal to fix this problem,โ€ he said. The โ€œproblemโ€ is unregulated hard-rock mining that began 160 years ago.

โ€œI know this isnโ€™t conventional wisdom,โ€ Churchwell said, โ€œbut no fish were killed in Durango (30 miles downstream) because of the spill. It was ugly and shocking, but a lot of that orange was rust, and the acidic water was diluted by the time it hit Durango and downstream.โ€

Cement Creek aerial photo — Jonathan Thompson via Twitter

EPAโ€™s website points out that over 5.4 million gallons of acid mine runoff enters the Animas River daily.

The way Churchwell tells it, water quality and numbers of fish had been declining in the Upper Animas River since the early 2000s. Thatโ€™s when the last mining operation ended and closed its water treatment plant.

Six months after the news-making spill almost a decade ago, EPA geared up to make sure untreated mine waste would not head for the river again.

Reid Christopher, a 62-year-old former electrician and mountain guide, became the Gold King Mineโ€™s restoration whiz, taking over an old wastewater treatment plant in the area in 2019. Now, he said, only treated water leaves the 11,439-foot elevation mine. 

This July, Christopher took me on a tour of the wastewater plant. In a nutshell, cleanup begins when the constantly flowing wastewater gets shuttled into settling ponds.

Christopher then pumps hydrated lime into the water, boosting its pH to 9.25. The high pH unlocks the heavy metals from suspension, and an added flocculant causes the heavy metals to clump together inside football field-sized textile filtration bags.

Clearโ€”surprisingly cleanโ€”water streams from the bags into Cement Creek, Christopher said, and the process is so effective he said heโ€™d like to treat the drainage from other major mineshafts in Bonita Peak.

Meanwhile, the Environmental Protection Agency remains gun-shy about talking to the press. It was deluged with bad publicity following the 2015 blowout, though as Churchwell points out, โ€œit wasnโ€™t the EPA that mined the San Juan Mountains and left their mess behind.โ€

Bonita Mine acid mine drainage. Photo via the Animas River Stakeholders Group.

The messes from abandoned mines, at Gold King and around the entire West, have never received much attention from Congress. Until the Biden administration passed the Inflation Reduction Act, the EPA depended on annual appropriations. That meant for almost four decades, the agency never got enough money to thoroughly clean up the heavy-metal mine waste flowing out of hard rock mines like Gold King.

And because the mess was buried deep in the mountains at elevations from 10,500 feet to over 12,500 feet, the agency couldnโ€™t compete for federal dollars until it grabbed all the environmental disaster headlines of summer 2015.

Even now, said Churchill, and despite available funding, โ€œThe EPA has 48 mine-impacted locations in the Upper Animas River and only so many dollars to work with. They have to get the most bang for their buck.โ€

David Marston. Photo credit: Writers on the Range

Commercial use of metals in the sludge might possibly make some money for the EPA. The Colorado School of Mines has taken water samples to see whatโ€”if anythingโ€”can be retrieved from the mine waste.

But even if mine sludge is worthless, cleaning acidic water at the top of the watershed is worthwhile for every living thing downstream.  

For now, Christopher is always looking to hire locals for dirt work and hauling. He said the jobs could last a lifetime.

Dave Marston is publisher of Writers on the Range, Writersontherange.org, the independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively debate about Western issues. He lives in Durango.

Prior to mining, snowmelt and rain seep into natural cracks and fractures, eventually emerging as a freshwater spring (usually). Graphic credit: Jonathan Thompson

R.I.P. Phil Lesh: “Lately it occurs to me. What a long, strange trip it’s been.”

Click the link to read the obituary on The New York Times website (Jim Farber). Here’s an excerpt:

Oct. 25, 2024

Phil Lesh, whose expansive approach to the bass as a charter member of the Grateful Dead made him one of the first performers on that instrument in a rock band to play a lead role rather than a supporting one, died on Friday. He was 84. His death was announced onย his Instagram account. No further information was provided. In addition to providing explorative bass work, Mr. Lesh sang high harmonies for the band and provided the occasional lead vocal. He also co-wrote some of the bandโ€™s most noteworthy songs, including ones that inspired adventurous jams, likeย โ€œSt. Stephenโ€ย andย โ€œDark Star,โ€ย as well as more conventional pieces, likeย โ€œCumberland Blues,โ€ย โ€œTruckinโ€™โ€ย andย โ€œBox of Rain.โ€…

The Grateful Dead in 1970, in a rural setting โ€“ Bill Kreutzmann, Ron “Pigpen” McKernan, Jerry Garcia, Bob Weir, Mickey Hart, and Phil Lesh By Herb Greene – Billboard, page 9, 5 December 1970, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=27041998

Mr. Leshโ€™s bass work could be thundering or tender, focused or abstract. On the Grateful Deadโ€™s studio albums, his lines held so much melody that one could listen to a song for his playing alone. At the same time, he shared his bandmatesโ€™ love for unusual chord structures and uncommon time signatures. In constructing his bass parts, he drew from many sources, including free jazz, classical music and the avant-garde…He had formal training in those last two areas, having played both classical violin and trumpet, composed music for orchestras and studied with the avant-garde composerย Luciano Berio, all before taking up the bass and joining the Dead. His work with the band held such value for a significant portion of its massive following that devotees at concerts would position themselves in the โ€œPhil Zone,โ€ an area named for โ€œthe proximity to Leshโ€™s position onstage,โ€ according to the 1994 Grateful Dead guidebook โ€œSkeleton Key: A Dictionary for Deadheads.โ€

Grateful Dead โ€“ Truckin’ (Tivoli Concert Hall 4/17/72) | Meet Up At The Movies 2022. The sixth show on the Grateful Dead’s famous Europe ’72 tour was a return engagement to the Tivoli Concert Hall in Copenhagen, Denmark, on April 17, 1972.

Feds rule that next round of #drought relief funding wonโ€™t cover tribesโ€™ unused water: Tribal and state officials say Reclamation walked back support for forbearance payments — Heather Sackett (@AspenJournalism) #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Lake Nighthorse, near Durango, Colorado on May 26, 2023. Both of Colorado’s tribes, the Southern Ute Indian Tribe and the Ute Mountain Utes have water in Lake Nighthorse they haven’t been able to access. CREDIT: MITCH TOBIN/THE WATER DESK

Click the link to read the article on the Aspen Journalism website (Heather Sackett):

October 4, 2024

Tribes in the upper Colorado River basin are still struggling to get compensated for water to which they are entitled but arenโ€™t using.

Tribes had hoped to be included in a new round of federal funding through the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation aimed at conservation programs in the Upper Basin and possibly get paid for their water that they arenโ€™t using. But it appears that will not be the case, Lorelei Cloud, vice chair of the Southern Ute Indian Tribe, said on Sept. 20. 

โ€œReclamation agreed to include tribal forbearance programs under the B2W program where we were looking forward to announcing and working on a proposal,โ€ Cloud said. โ€œOn Sept. 18, the state of Colorado informed the Southern Ute Indian Tribe that Reclamation has reconsidered its position and will no longer include tribal programs in the B2W program. This decision needs to be reversed.โ€

The comments came during a panel discussion at the Colorado River Water Conservation Districtโ€™s annual seminar in Grand Junction. Cloud put out a call to action for attendees to help them plead their case to federal officials. She noted that the title of the panel was โ€œDoes History Repeat Itself?โ€

โ€œWe havenโ€™t changed anything,โ€ she said. โ€œNo matter how tribes are trying, we havenโ€™t changed anything.โ€

Becky Mitchell, Coloradoโ€™s representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission and the stateโ€™s lead negotiator on Colorado River issues, has advocated for more tribal inclusion. She said Colorado officials were notified by phone that Reclamation would not fund forbearance with B2W money. 

โ€œBoth the tribes and the states thought that this was an option for the use of that funding,โ€ Mitchell said. โ€œThere are commitments that have been made, not just in this last year, but in the last 200 years, and itโ€™s time to make good. โ€ฆ Weโ€™re going to continue to work with the tribes to pursue federal funding in an effort to correct these historic injustices.โ€

Native America in the Colorado River Basin. Credit: USBR

Trump and Harris have clashing records on clean energy, but the clean power shift is too broad for any president toย control

Intersect Powerโ€™s Oberon Solar + Storage Facility in Riverside, Calif. Michael Slider, U.S. Department of Energy/Flickr, CC BY-ND

Daniel Cohan, Rice University

Although Vice President Kamala Harris touts clean energy and Donald Trump makes misleading assertions and false claims about it, neither candidate has set forth a comprehensive energy plan. Even if they do, a gridlocked Congress would be unlikely to pass it.

Instead, the next presidentโ€™s greatest influence on clean energy will come through their handling of legislation and regulations put in place since 2021 under the Biden-Harris administration. As an environmental engineer who studies energy and climate change, I expect that Harris, who has strongly supported these policies, would follow through on them, while Trumpโ€™s record as president suggests that he would try to roll them back. Trade policies toward China, the leading producer of clean energy technologies, will also be key. https://www.youtube.com/embed/hoycdE1G0C0?wmode=transparent&start=0 Donald Trump and Kamala Harris discuss clean energy policy during their presidential campaign debate on Sept. 10, 2024.

Legislation and regulations

Three bills passed by Congress under Biden and Harris โ€“ the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, the Inflation Reduction Act and the CHIPS and Science Act โ€“ have transformed U.S. energy policy. The three bills allocated hundreds of billions of dollars for building infrastructure, providing incentives for clean energy manufacturing and purchases, and funding clean energy research.

None of these measures is likely to be completely overturned, since each funds numerous projects in red states. But implementation by the next administration will determine how effectively they stimulate clean energy growth.

For example, the Treasury and Energy departments will decide which projects can receive incentives and loans. Other agencies, such as the Advanced Research Projects Agency-Energy, known as ARPA-E, will allocate clean energy research funding.

The Environmental Protection Agency will also play a crucial role. Under the Biden-Harris administration, the EPA issued its most stringent regulations ever for controlling emissions from fossil fuel power plants and motor vehicles. Those rules could accelerate the transition to clean electricity and electric cars.

However, a Trump-led EPA could reverse course, much as it overturned Obama-era regulations designed to reduce carbon emissions from power plants in 2019 and weakened vehicle emissions rules in 2020. Trump also appointed three Supreme Court justices who voted to constrain EPAโ€™s power to reduce emissions.

The role of market forces

Whatever policies the next president sets, domestic energy trends will depend largely on market forces. Both Trump and Biden oversaw a boom in domestic oil and gas production. At the same time, as the costs of wind turbines, solar panels and utility-scale batteries have plummeted, these technologies have dominated new electricity generating capacity.

Currently, the U.S. has a backlog of nearly 2,600 gigawatts of projects waiting to be added to the nationโ€™s electricity grids. Thatโ€™s roughly eight times the amount of wind and solar generating capacity on U.S. grids today.

However, Congress is deadlocked over competing proposals for streamlining permitting rules. State and local governments and regional grid operators also play key roles and are not easily swayed by federal action.

Still, the next president can influence policy through his or her selection of commissioners to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which regulates interstate transmission of oil, gas and electricity. Presidents also can push Congress to pass permitting reforms.

Trade policy

As fast as U.S. clean energy manufacturing and deployments have grown under the Biden-Harris administration, that increase is dwarfed by Chinaโ€™s output. Chinese companies manufacture over three-quarters of the worldโ€™s solar cells and modules, more the half of the worldโ€™s wind turbines and three-quarters of the advanced batteries needed for electricity storage and electric cars. China also sells more electric cars than the rest of the world combined. https://www.youtube.com/embed/rkxMdmipYqM?wmode=transparent&start=0 Chinaโ€™s dominance in clean energy manufacturing poses challenges for nations wary of relying on Chinese components.

Like it or not, Americaโ€™s ability to rapidly deploy clean energy and electric cars will require importing at least some materials from China. After falling behind for decades, thereโ€™s simply no way to scale up U.S. manufacturing fast enough to meet national climate goals. Even if solar panels, batteries or electric cars are assembled here, theyโ€™ll depend upon critical minerals that are mostly refined in China.

As president, Trump waged a trade war with China. He has vowed to extend existing tariffs to other products from China if he is elected to a second term.

Biden and Harris have also tried to tilt the playing field to favor U.S. companies. The administration is offering loans and incentives for domestic manufacturing, and has also imposed a 100% tariff on electric vehicles and a 50% tariff on solar cells from China.

Such policies may shelter domestic manufacturers for a while, but are unlikely to make them competitive on global markets that are pivoting to electric cars and solar energy.

U.S. standing under the 2015 Paris climate agreement, a legally binding treaty that sets targets for curbing climate change, will also be key. Countries around the world have pledged to shift to clean energy to reduce emissions. The European Union is enacting carbon border tariffs that will penalize imports from high-emitting producers.

If Trump were to withdraw the U.S. from the Paris Agreement again, as he did in 2017, and roll back emissions rules, U.S. manufacturers could face new hurdles in exporting their products overseas. For her part, Harris has supported the Paris accord and criticized Trumpโ€™s decision to withdraw the U.S. from it.

No reversing the revolution

Markets worldwide are rapidly transitioning to renewable energy and electric cars, which are becoming cheaper, cleaner and more appealing than their fossil-fueled alternatives. Popular subsidies for clean energy would be difficult to claw back. Chinaโ€™s dominance in clean energy technologies will not soon be shaken, whatever trade policies the next administration adopts.

Based on their records, Harris could be expected to build on the legislation and regulations passed under the current administration, while Trump would be likely to roll back some but not all of its advances. Neither candidate is proposing policies as transformative as the ones enacted in the past several years. Whoever is elected will govern within a clean energy landscape that has been reshaped by those policies, and by market forces that are beyond the control of any president.

Daniel Cohan, Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Rice University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

U.S. House passes Curtisโ€™ #GreatSaltLake Stewardship act — #Utah News-Dispatch

The shores of the Great Salt Lake near Syracuse are pictured on Tuesday, May 21, 2024. (Photo by Spenser Heaps for Utah News Dispatch)

Click the link to read the article on The Utah News Dispatch website (Kyle Dunphey):

September 25, 2024

The U.S. House of Representatives passed a bill sponsored by Utah Republican Rep. John Curtis on Tuesday that includes the Great Salt Lake in the federal governmentโ€™s Colorado River water conservation plan, possibly freeing up federal funds to help the Beehive Stateโ€™s beleaguered saline lake. 

The Great Salt Lake Stewardship Act tweaks the Central Utah Project Completion Act, which takes water from the Colorado River basin in eastern Utah, and through a system of reservoirs, rivers and pipelines, diverts it to the Wasatch Front where itโ€™s used for municipal and industrial use. The project is described by the Department of Interior as Utahโ€™s โ€œlargest and most comprehensive federal water resource development project.โ€ 

Now, the secretary of the department can use their budget authority to take water conservation measures โ€œwithin the Great Salt Lake basin,โ€ according to the bill text.

Curtis says this will give water managers greater flexibility when making conservation decisions regarding the Great Salt Lake, allowing them to take steps to protect โ€œUtah and the West from the economic and public health risks of an ecological disaster.โ€

โ€œUtahns have worked tirelessly to protect the Great Salt Lake, but persistent drought conditions now threaten its long-term viability. Recognizing the urgency of this issue, the Great Salt Lake Stewardship Act would expand the Colorado River water conservation program to include the lake,โ€ Curtis said in a statement. 

The bill was co-sponsored by members of the Utah Delegation, including Republican Reps. Celeste Maloy, Blake Moore and Burgess Owens. 

Utahโ€™s Great Salt Lake Commissioner Brian Steed said the bill could have โ€œa huge impact on the lake and its future.โ€

โ€œIt is great to have partners in Congress who recognize these issues and are willing to collaborate to create innovative and effective solutions,โ€ Steed said in a statement.

Water levels at the Great Salt Lake have been in steady decline since peaking in May โ€” currently the south arm of the lake sits at about 4,192.5 feet, with the north arm, separated by a railroad causeway, at about 4,191.8 feet. 

Thatโ€™s a far rosier outlook than years prior, when the lake hit a historic low of 4,188.5 feet in November 2022. 

Still, according to the Great Salt Lake Strategic Plan released earlier this year, the lake needs between 471,000 and 1,055,000 acre-feet of additional water delivered each year for it to reach 4,198 feet in elevation, which is considered the โ€œlow endโ€ of the healthy range. An acre-foot is almost 326,000 gallons. 

Curtis, who has represented Utahโ€™s 3rd Congressional District since 2017, is not running for reelection, instead vying to replace outgoing Utah GOP Sen. Mitt Romney.

River advocates say promises broken on state-funded #RioGrande dam safety project — Jerd Smith (Fresh Water News)

Rio Grande Reservoir

Click the link to read the article on the Water Education Colorado website (Jerd Smith):

September 12, 2024

Four years after a high-profile dam restoration project was completed in the scenic headwaters of the Rio Grande, promises to deliver water for fish during the winter and other recreational benefits have not been met, environmental groups charge.

The Rio Grande Reservoir Project was funded by state loans and public grants provided by the Colorado Water Conservation Board, which often bases financing approvals, in part, on a projectโ€™s ability to serve multiple purposes, including water for fish, habitat and kayakers.

โ€œThe Colorado Water Conservation Board โ€ฆ provided $30 million in the form of loans and grants to complete the project,โ€ the CWCB said In aย project updateย posted on its website. โ€œBenefits include: instream flow enhancement; channel maintenance; outdoor recreation opportunities; terrestrial and aquatic wildlife habitat; irrigation, augmentation; and storage to comply with the Rio Grande Compact between Colorado, New Mexico, and Texas.โ€

The public-private project was completed in 2020.

The CWCB declined an interview request for this story, but said in an email that there were no specific conditions in the loans and grants tied to providing environmental benefits.

โ€œCWCB does not have the ability to impose extra terms on the recipients of funds that are not articulated in the funding agreements. In the case of the Rio Grande Reservoir Rehabilitation, the final deliverable was completion of the project,โ€ a spokesperson said.

Still Kevin Terry, southwest program director for Trout Unlimited, said the project would likely never have been funded without assurances that the dam would be operated differently to help the river, including releasing water in the winter to aid the fish and changing the time water is released throughout the summer to keep the river cooler and healthier during prime fishing and kayaking season.

โ€œThere were lots of environmental benefits touted before the Colorado Water Conservation Board and the roundtable,โ€ Terry said,  referring to the Rio Grande Basin Roundtable. The roundtable is one of nine public groups across the stateโ€™s major river basins that help address local water issues and funnel state grants to projects they approve.

The San Luis Valley Irrigation District, which owns and operates the dam, serves farms around Center and has delivered water from the dam since 1912, according to its website. Neither District President Randall Palmgren nor Superintendent Robert Phillips responded to numerous requests for comment.

The district uses the reservoir to store water for irrigators. Trout Unlimited and others arenโ€™t asking for any water, they say, just that existing water that would be released anyway be sent downstream at times that are beneficial to the river.

Screenshot from Google Maps

Among key complaints by environmentalists is that the irrigation company is not allowing water to flow out of the rehabilitated dam during the winter, something that would benefit young fish and allow them to grow larger for the next fishing season.

Terry said the irrigation district has said it canโ€™t deliver that winter water because it is difficult to operate the new equipment in freezing winter weather. But Terry said he doesnโ€™t understand how the project could have been built without the ability to deliver in cold weather, something that occurs routinely in other reservoirs in the valley.

Jim Loud, a Creede resident and avid angler who lives on the river, said he and others are tired of waiting for the river to receive the benefits many believed would have been delivered by now.

โ€œAll we want is to get them to do what they said they were going to do,โ€ said Loud, citing numerous CWCB documents dating back several years outlining the environmental benefits of the project. Loud is part of the Committee for a Healthy Rio Grande.

Rio Grande and Pecos River basins. Map credit: By Kmusser – Own work, Elevation data from SRTM, drainage basin from GTOPO [1], U.S. stream from the National Atlas [2], all other features from Vector Map., CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=11218868

The old days werenโ€™t fun

The conflict comes as the Rio Grande Basin, which begins high above Creede and flows south to the Gulf of Mexico, continues to struggle with declining aquifer levels due to heavy agricultural use and low stream flows due to drought and climate change. In Colorado, the Rio Grande waters a potato industry that is one of the largest in the nation.

The last days of the potato harvest. Photo credit: The Alamaosa Citizen

Creede local Dale Pizel, who owns a ranch on the river and caters to the fishing community, said river conditions have improved some since the dam was rebuilt. Prior to the project, the irrigation company would routinely dry up the river for weeks during the high summer tourist season to make repairs to the dam.

โ€œThat doesnโ€™t happen anymore,โ€ Pizel said. He too serves on the Rio Grande Basin Roundtable, which also approved some grants for the project.

โ€œI voted for that project knowing it would have environmental benefits, and it did,โ€ Pizel said, because there is no need for the irrigators to dry up the river to repair a failing dam anymore.

Still, he said, if environmental promises are being made publicly, the state needs a better way to make sure they are kept.

Trout Unlimitedโ€™s Terry said for years he was hopeful that the rehabilitated dam would serve as another multiuse storage project in the water-short valley helping farmers and the environment.

โ€œWe are so disappointed in the delivery of what was promised and the lack of the CWCB holding the irrigation district accountable in any way,โ€ he said.

Altering the damโ€™s new equipment so that winter releases can occur will likely require spending about $5 million, according to Terry.

Pizel and others hope a resolution between the farmers and the environmentalists can occur without legal action.

โ€œWe donโ€™t want to start thumping each other in the chest,โ€ Pizel said. โ€œThatโ€™s the way it was in the old days. It was not fun.โ€

More by Jerd Smith

Jerd Smith is editor of Fresh Water News. She can be reached at 720-398-6474, via email at jerd@wateredco.org or @jerd_smith.

Climate Change Indicators in the United States: Fifth Edition — Environmental Protection Agency

Click here to access the report on the EPA website:

The fifth edition of Climate Change Indicators in the United States documents how climate change is impacting the United States today, the significance of these changes, and their possible consequences for people, the environment, and society.

Using EPA’s climate change indicators and relevant scientific literature, the report groups indicators into eight themes that help to show interconnections, cause-and-effect relationships, and how physical changes in the atmosphere affect people and the environment. Indicators related to human health and societal impacts of climate change cut across chapter themes and are integrated throughout the report. Each theme includes information on why the changes matter, as well as examples and discussion of the unequal impacts of climate change. The report also provides examples of what people and communities can do to address climate change, and what actions are already underway.

As the #RioGrande runs dry, South #Texas cities look to alternatives for water — The Texas Tribune

By Berenice Garcia, The Texas Tribune

July 18, 2024

“As the Rio Grande runs dry, South Texas cities look to alternatives for water” was first published by The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans โ€” and engages with them โ€” about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

Subscribe to The Yโ€™all โ€” a weekly dispatch about the people, places and policies defining Texas, produced by Texas Tribune journalists living in communities across the state.


EDINBURG โ€” The Rio Grande is no longer a reliable source of water for South Texas.

Thatโ€™s the sobering conclusion Rio Grande Valley officials are facing as water levels at the international reservoirs that feed into the river remain dangerously low โ€” and a hurricane that could have quenched the area’s thirst turned away from the region as it neared the Texas coast.

Although a high number of storms are forecast this hurricane season, relief is far from guaranteed and as the drought drags on.

For now, the stateโ€™s most southern cities have enough drinking water for residents. However, the regionโ€™s agricultural roots created a system that could jeopardize that supply. Cities here are set up to depend on irrigation districts, which supply untreated waters to farmers, to deliver water that will eventually go to residents. This setup has meant that as river water for farmers has been cut off, the supply of municipal water faces an uncertain future.

This risk has prompted a growing interest among water districts, water corporations and public utilities that supply water to residents across the Valley to look elsewhere for their water needs. But for several small, rural communities that make up a large portion of the Valley, investing millions into upgrading their water treatment methods may still be out of reach.

A new water treatment facility for Edinburg will undoubtedly cost millions of dollars but Tom Reyna, assistant city manager, believes the high initial investment will be worth it in the long run.

“We see the future and we’ve got to find different water alternatives, sources,” Reyna said. “You know how they used to say water is gold? Now it’s platinum.”

For Edinburg, one of the fastest growing cities in the Valley, the need for water will only grow as their population does. While the city hasnโ€™t faced a water supply issue yet, the ongoing water shortage in South Texas combined with the growing population has put local officials on alert for the future of their water supply.

The Falcon and Amistad International reservoirs feed water directly into the Rio Grande. And while water levels have been low, cities and public utilities have instituted water restrictions that limit when residents can use sprinkler systems and prohibits the washing of paved areas.

Cities have priority over agriculture when it comes to water in the reservoirs. Currently, the reservoirs have about 750,000 acre feet of which 225,000 acre feet are reserved for cities.

A resaca near agriculture fields near Los Fresnos, on Wednesday, July 17, 2024. The Rio Grande Valley is facing a drought, greatly affecting farmers in the region.
A former channel of the Rio Grande, or resaca, winds through agriculture fields near Los Fresnos, on Wednesday. The Rio Grande Valley is facing a drought, greatly affecting farmers in the region. Credit: Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

Of those 225,000 acre feet, each city or public utility or water supply corporation can purchase what are known as โ€œwater rightsโ€ which grants them permission from the state to use that water.

But without water for farming, more and more of the water that they own is being lost just in transporting the water to their facilities and thatโ€™s directly due to the loss of water for farmers.

This relationship with the agriculture industry arose because irrigation districts were created here first. Cities came after and because they used less water, they were set up to depend on irrigation districts.

Water meant for residential use rides atop irrigation water to water treatment plants. Without irrigation water, cities start to use water they already own to push the rest of their water from the river to a water treatment facility. Itโ€™s referred to as โ€œpush water.โ€ Much of that water is lost for this purpose.

When water levels at the reservoirs got dangerously low in in the late 1990s, the average city would only get about 68% of the water it owns because the rest would be used as push water, according to Jim Darling, board member of the Rio Grande Regional Water Authority and chair of the local water planning group, a subset of the Texas Water Development Board.

The board is tasked with managing the stateโ€™s water supply.

Darling, a former McAllen mayor, has been trying to get cities to think of ways to increase their water supply.

As cities try to temper water demand by issuing restrictions on water usage, Darling said public utilities need to think about the drought not just from the standpoint of managing demand but also by increasing supply.

Jim Darling, chair of the Rio Grande Regional Water Planning Group and former mayor of McAllen, points at rivers and tributaries shown on a map at the South McAllen Water Plant, in McAllen, on Monday, July 15, 2024.
Jim Darling, chair of the Rio Grande Regional Water Planning Group and former McAllen mayor, points at rivers and tributaries shown on a map at the South McAllen Water Plant, in McAllen, on Monday. Credit: Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

Darling has been floating the idea of creating a water bank of push water so that water districts can get by without having to go through the process of obtaining approval from the state for more water.

These discussions have been ongoing with the watermaster from the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, who ensures compliance with water rights. The talks are still preliminary, but a conversation with the watermasterโ€™s office in early July revealed that three or four of the Valleyโ€™s 27 irrigation districts were out of water.

โ€œSomething needs to be done,โ€ Darling said.

Edinburgโ€™s proposed water plant is still in the early planning stages, but the goal is to stave off water woes by turning their attention to water sources underground.

Their plan is to dig up water from the underground aquifers as well as reuse wastewater. The two sources of water would be blended and treated through reverse osmosis.

Reserve osmosis consists of pushing water through membranes, large cylinders that filter the water. This is done several times until the water is pure and meets drinking water standards set by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality.

This method isn’t new.

By implementing this practice, Edinburg is following in the footsteps of the North Alamo Water Supply Corporation, a utility that supplies water to eastern Hidalgo County, Willacy County, and northwestern Cameron County.

Filtered groundwater is desalinated through reverse osmosis at the SRWA Brackish Groundwater Treatment Facility in Brownsville, Tx, on Monday, July 15, 2024. The SRWA facility treats water to distribute to its five partners, including the Brownsville Public Utilities Board, its main customer and is seeking funding to expand the facility in order to address the regionโ€™s drought and water shortage.
Filtered groundwater is desalinated through reverse osmosis at the Southmost Regional Water Authority brackish groundwater treatment facility in Brownsville on Monday. The facility treats water to distribute to its five partners, including the Brownsville Public Utilities Board, its main customer and is seeking funding to expand the facility in order to address the regionโ€™s drought and water shortage. Credit: Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

After the drought in 1998, North Alamo turned to reverse osmosis in the early 2000s.

Their facilities currently treat about 10 million gallons of water per day through reverse osmosis which represents one-third of all the water they treat. The rest is surface water from the river but they aim to switch that split, treating two-thirds through reverse osmosis and have a third of surface water.

“We’ve got that mindset that we have to get away from the river,” said Steven P. Sanchez, general manager of North Alamo. “We have to start going to reverse osmosis.”

Hidalgo County officials are trying to take a more “innovative” approach to the area’s water problems.

In April, county officials touted a proposed regional water supply project, dubbed the Delta Water Reclamation Project, that would capture and treat stormwater to be used as drinking water.

The project, expected to cost $60-70 million, started off as a project to mitigate flooding by drawing water away from a regional drainage system. But now, plans include a water plant that would take daily runoff and treat it through reverse osmosis.

โ€œWe are the first drainage district to do something like this and of course thatโ€™s an exciting thing for us, to be able to do something thatโ€™s so innovative and green,โ€ said Hidalgo County Commissioner David Fuentes who sits on the drainage district board. โ€œBut it comes with a lot of obstacles and a lot of unknowns.โ€

One challenge will be financing the water plant. Drainage districts are limited on the bonds they can issue in exchange for a loan. Obtaining funds from the Texas Water Development Board would also be an uphill battle since a drainage district doesnโ€™t fit the usual metrics that a water supply corporation does.

County leaders made the case for their project before a Texas Senate committee hearing in May on water and agriculture, requesting that legislative leaders direct the water development board to give a higher consideration to projects like theirs or to provide a grant program their project would qualify for.

The county drainage district already completed a pilot test of the project and those results are now under TCEQ for review. They expect TCEQ will give them the green light as well as instructions on how to design the plant and steps they need to take to ensure water quality.

Fuentes said they expect that review to be completed early in the legislative session, which would give them a better idea of what they need to ask legislators for.

If the project becomes a reality, the county would sell to water corporations like North Alamo.

Members of the public listen to Cameron County Judge Eddie Treviรฑo Jr. as he begins to lead a water conservation meeting with various stakeholders across the Rio Grande Valley at the county courthouse on Tuesday, July 16, 2024, in Brownsville, Tx.
Members of the public listen to Cameron County Judge Eddie Treviรฑo Jr. as he begins to lead a water conservation meeting with various stakeholders across the Rio Grande Valley at the county courthouse on Tuesday in Brownsville. Credit: Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

In Cameron County, located on the east end of the Valley, the Brownsville Public Utilities Board was also motivated by drought conditions to reduce their dependence on the river. With help from their partners in the Southmost Regional Water Authority, the public utilities board spearheaded the construction of a desalination facility that also employs reverse osmosis.

Despite its growing popularity in the Valley, desalination has its drawbacks. The process has faced pushback from environmentalists over the disposal of the concentrated salts and because the process requires a lot of energy.

Southmost and North Alamo hold permits from TCEQ to discharge the concentrate, or reject water, into the Brownsville Ship Channel and a drainage ditch that flows to the Laguna Madre, respectively.

Representatives for both entities said the salinity of the concentrate is less than the salinity of the bodies of water that are receiving that discharge.

โ€œAll the aquatic life thatโ€™s there, the plant life and everything that feeds off that water is not being harmed at all,โ€ Sanchez said. โ€œWe monitor that.โ€

Sanchez said other solutions would be drying beds, a process of evaporating the water into sludge, and injecting the water about 20,000 feet back into the ground.

North Alamo has also made improvements to their energy consumption. In May, the water corporation upgraded their 16-year-old water filtering equipment, reducing the amount of energy used to create the pressure to push the water through their filtration system.

Sanchez said reverse osmosis has also been more efficient for North Alamo.

North Alamo Water Supply Corporation General Manager Steven P. Sanchez at the NAWSC water treatment facility in Edinburg, on Tuesday, July 16, 2024.
North Alamo Water Supply Corporation General Manager Steven P. Sanchez at the NAWSC water treatment facility in Edinburg, on Tuesday. Credit: Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

Their surface water treatment plant treats about 2.7 million gallons of water daily while the reverse osmosis plant treats 3 million gallons. It’s also become cheaper in the last few years. Treatment of surface water costs them $1.21 per thousand gallons while reverse osmosis costs $0.65 per thousand gallons, according to Sanchez who said RO would still be cheaper even with depreciation.

This wasn’t always the case, he said, but the high cost of chemicals is driven up the cost in treating surface water. But where surface water treatment is cheaper is in the initial cost to establish it.

Sanchez estimated that the initial capital investment for reverse osmosis treatment capable of treating a million gallons per day would conservatively cost about $6-7 million while a surface treatment facility of the same capacity would cost $3-4 million.

Southmostโ€™s plans to double their plantโ€™s capacity would cost an estimated $213 million.

Reyna, the Edinburg assistant city manager, agreed that the initial investment would be the biggest cost for the city but believes it will end up paying for itself.

Not all cities have that as a viable option, though. That initial cost can be an insurmountable hurdle for smaller, rural communities that leaves them unable to invest in solutions. The state could possibly alleviate some of that cost.

During the last legislative session, lawmakers established the Texas Water Fund with a billion dollar investment that will go to a number of financial assistance programs at the Texas Water Development including one that has never had funding before called the Rural Water Assistance Fund.

This will be additional state funding to help rural communities with technical assistance on how to decide what kind of design and what kind of assistance is best for their community. This will help them navigate the process of applying for funding.

Rigoberto Ortaรฑes looks at a rising pool of water, flooding the excavation site, as a crew works on upgrading pipes and valves at a North Alamo Water Supply Corporation water plant in Donna on Thursday, July 18, 2024. In order to increase the amount of water the plant is able to distribute, pipes were upgraded and replaced, connect to the plantโ€™s existing facility with the newly expanded infrastructure.
Rigoberto Ortaรฑes looks at a rising pool of water, flooding the excavation site, as a crew works on upgrading pipes and valves at a North Alamo Water Supply Corporation water plant in Donna on Thursday. The utility company supplies water to eastern Hidalgo County, Willacy County, and northwestern Cameron County. Credit: Eddie Gaspar/The Texas Tribune

Plans for how the water development board will allocate funds to these new financial assistance programs will be released in late July.

Sarah Kirkle, the director of policy and legislative affairs at the Texas Water Conservation Association expects the state will provide interest rate reductions for loans that will be used on expensive projects.

However, the $1 billion allocated to the Texas Water Fund will not get very far.

“The needs for implementing this state water plan are something like $80 billion and those are outdated numbers that we’re looking to update in the new water planning cycle,” Kirkle said, adding that the plan doesn’t include the cost of wastewater or flood infrastructure.

She noted that the cost of water infrastructure is about two or three times what it was before the COVID-19 pandemic because of disruptions in the supply chain and additional federal requirements for federally-funded projects.

Many small communities also don’t have the resources to plan for their needs, Kirkle said, so many of them don’t participate in the water planning process, leaving no one to speak up for them.

“We really need to make sure that as we see additional water scarcity around the state, that our communities are engaged in planning for their needs and understand where they might have risks and where their water might not be reliable,” Kirkle said.

Reporting in the Rio Grande Valley is supported in part by the Methodist Healthcare Ministries of South Texas, Inc.


Big news: director and screenwriter Richard Linklater; NPR President and CEO Katherine Maher; U.S. Rep. Pete Aguilar, D-California; and Luci Baines Johnson will take the stage at The Texas Tribune Festival, Sept. 5โ€“7 in downtown Austin. Buy tickets today!

This article originally appeared in The Texas Tribune at https://www.texastribune.org/2024/07/18/rio-grande-river-drought/.

The Texas Tribune is a member-supported, nonpartisan newsroom informing and engaging Texans on state politics and policy. Learn more at texastribune.org.

Click the link to read the article on the

Mussel discovery complicates river recreation — The #GrandJunction Daily Sentinel #ColoradoRiver #COriver

Zebra and Quagga Mussels

Click the link to read the article on the Grand Junction Daily Sentinel website (Dan West). Here’s an excerpt:

July 26, 2024

Colorado Parks and Wildlife isnโ€™t wasting any time since the detection of zebra mussel veligers (larva stage) in the Colorado River and Government Highline Canal in Mesa County in getting the word out to boaters to clean, drain and dry their boats after being in the river. A mobile waterless boat cleaning station made by the company CD3 is now parked in Palisadeโ€™s Riverbend Park near Harkyโ€™s Launch Boat Ramp. CPW also has a stationary cleaning station at the Loma Boat Ramp.

โ€œWe started rolling out our education plan for zebra mussels and this is on top of all the sampling and things weโ€™re doing as well,โ€ said Northwest Region Public Information Officer Rachael Gonzales. โ€œWe are, throughout the Grand Valley, taking out our CD3, which is our waterless (boat cleaning station).โ€

The waterless cleaning stations have compressed air and a vacuum to help people clean smaller watercraft like kayaks and paddleboards, Gonzales said. There is a more elaborate system at Highline Lake State Park that uses hot water, but is intended for larger craft with motors. This year, Highline Lake is only allowing non-motorized craft. CPW shut down Highline to boaters after the decision was made to drain down the lake to attempt to eradicate its mussels infestation. Previous efforts using chemicals were unsuccessful after mussels were first discovered in Highline Lake in the fall of 2022. In addition to the new watercraft cleaning stations, Gonzales said CPW will have people out around the valley talking one-on-one with boaters and people using the river to explain the importance of cleaning everything from boats to fishing gear that go into the Colorado River.

Biden-Harris Administration Announces Nearly $66M for #Conservation Work with States, Tribes, Private Landowners as Part of Investing in America Agenda — NRCS

Photo credit: NRCS

Click the link to read the release on the NRCS website:

June 11, 2024

USDA also signs agreement with Western Governors to strengthen shared efforts to protect communities and resources

During a meeting of the Western Governors Association today, Deputy Secretary of Agriculture Xochitl Torres Small announced that USDA is investing nearly $66 million for projects to reduce wildfire risk, protect water quality and improve forest health across the nation as part of President Bidenโ€™s Investing in America agenda.

Deputy Secretary Torres Small also signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Western Governorsโ€™ Association, reestablishing the framework for cooperatively responding to the many challenges faced across western landscapes. The MOU, signed on behalf of the USDA alongside Governors Brad Little of Idaho, Joe Lombardo of Nevada, Michelle Lujan Grisham of New Mexico, Doug Burgum of North Dakota, and Mark Gordon of Wyoming, amplifies the scale of shared stewardship work between participating states and the USDA. It also fosters better integration of forest and rangeland health and wildfire risk reduction projects across different land ownerships.

โ€œPeople across rural America face growing wildfire threats to their homes, business, infrastructure, and resources,โ€ said Deputy Secretary Torres Small. โ€œThrough the investments announced today, President Biden is investing in state and local governments, Tribal partners, and private landowners to ensure our landscapes are healthy, our infrastructure is strong, and our communities stay safe.โ€

Of the total investment announced, $12 million is being provided through the USDA Forest Serviceโ€™s Good Neighbor Authority,  allowing the agency to collaborate with state forestry agencies, Tribes and counties to mitigate wildfire risk and enhance forest, rangeland and watershed health. This funding will support 22 projects across 13 states, thanks to funding from President Bidenโ€™s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law. Nearly $9 million of the total funding will be allocated to support projects in several states that are part of the Western Governors Association member states, including Arizona, California, Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Utah, Washington and Wyoming.

The Department is also investing nearly $55 million of the total funding to reduce wildfire risk, and improve water quality and forest health through the Joint Chiefsโ€™ Landscape Restoration Partnership. This collaborative effort between USDAโ€™s Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) and Forest Service aims to work with private, state, and Tribal landowners to conserve forests and agricultural lands alongside federally managed lands while safeguarding communities. The $55 million investment will support 41 projects — including 10 new projects — across 11 states. 

This program advances President Bidenโ€™s Justice40 Initiative, which sets a goal that 40% of the overall benefits of certain federal climate, clean energy, and other investments flow to disadvantaged communities that are marginalized by underinvestment and overburdened by pollution.

The NRCS and Forest Service are also now accepting proposals for Joint Chiefsโ€™ Landscape Restoration Partnership projects for fiscal year 2025 projects. Applications are due on September 13, 2024.  

โ€œThese projects are indicative of a growing movement of cooperation around natural resource issues for the betterment of us all,โ€ said Forest Service Chief Randy Moore. โ€œA keystone of the Joint Chiefsโ€™ projects is the people and the understanding that the healthier our forests, the healthier our nation.โ€ 

โ€œThe Joint Chiefsโ€™ Landscape Restoration Partnership enables NRCS and the Forest Service to collaborate with agricultural producers and forest landowners to invest in conservation and restoration at a big enough scale to make a difference in their communities,โ€ said NRCS Chief Terry Cosby. “Working with federal, state and local agencies at this scale, helps reduce wildfire threats, protect water quality and supply, improve wildlife habitat for at-risk species, and ultimately combat climate change.โ€ 

Todayโ€™s announcements also build on Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsackโ€™s announcement last week of $18 million for 23 new Tribal Forest Protection Act projects.

Background

Joint Chiefsโ€™ Restoration Partnership

Since 2014, USDA has invested more than $423 million in 134 projects in 42 states as well as Guam and Puerto Rico through the Joint Chiefsโ€™ Landscape Restoration Partnership. This program focuses on areas where national forests and grasslands intersect with privately-owned lands.

Good Neighbor Authority

Established by Congress in 2014, Good Neighbor Authority provides the Forest Service a straightforward way to enter into management agreements with states, Tribes and counties. The Good Neighbor Authority pools federal, state, Tribal, and county resources to complete more forest, rangeland, and watershed restoration work on national forests and grasslands. President Bidenโ€™s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law authorizes $160 million over five years for states and Tribes to implement restoration projects on federally managed lands through the Good Neighbor Authority and the Tribal Forest Protection Act. 
 

USDA touches the lives of all Americans each day in so many positive ways. In the Biden-Harris administration, USDA is transforming Americaโ€™s food system with a greater focus on more resilient local and regional food production, fairer markets for all producers, ensuring access to safe, healthy and nutritious food in all communities, building new markets and streams of income for farmers and producers using climate smart food and forestry practices, making historic investments in infrastructure and clean energy capabilities in rural America and committing to equity across the department by removing systemic barriers and building a workforce more representative of America. To learn more, visit usda.gov. 

Technical Report: Regulatory and Environmental Considerations for Floating Photovoltaic Projects Located on Federally Controlled Reservoirs in the United States — NREL

FPV system sited on a non-powered reservoir Illustration by Besiki Kazaishvili, NREL

Click the link to access the report on the NREL website (Aaron Levine, Taylor L. Curtis, Ligia E.P. Smith, and Katie DeRose). Here’s the executive summary:

June 2024

Executive Summary

To meet the nationโ€™s decarbonization goals, the U.S. Department of Energyโ€™s Solar Futures study forecasts that installed solar photovoltaic (PV) capacity must increase nearly tenfold, from 80 gigawatts (GW) in 2020 to approximately 760 GW cumulative installed capacity by 2035 (DOE 2021). Ground-mounted PV is expected to dominate future solar deployment and will require more than 3.5 million acres of land to meet annual demand projections (of nearly 45 GW) by 2030 (DOE 2021). However, various competing demands for land (e.g., agricultural production, conservation) and high land acquisition costs in specific locations could be challenges to meeting future PV demand solely with ground-mounted PV deployment (Wood MacKenzie 2023; DOE 2021; Oliveira-Pinto and Stokkermans 2020). Floating photovoltaics (FPV) may be an alternative in locations where ground-mounted PV is not feasible and aid in reaching the nationโ€™s PV deployment and decarbonization goals (DOE 2021; Oliveira-Pinto and Stokkermans 2020; Hooper, Armstrong, and Vlaswinkel 2020; Gallucci 2019).

FPV is a newer siting approach in which a PV array is affixed to a floating apparatus and sited on a water body like a reservoir behind a dam. FPV systems may be stand-alone or co-located a new or existing hydroelectric facilities or pumped storage hydropower (PSH) facility reservoirs. Co-located FPV systems may or may not be operationally paired and work in tandem with the hydroelectric or PSH facility (Gadzanku and Lee 2022; Gadzanku et al. 2021a, 2021b; Lee et al. 2020; Oliveira-Pinto and Stokkermans 2020; Spencer et al. 2018).

Although FPV deployment in the United States is nascent with less than 30 projects installed, significant potential has been identified at existing U.S. reservoirs (Chopra and Garasa Sagardoy 2022). A 2018 National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) study identified more than 24,000 manmade reservoirs (with a total surface area of more than 2 million hectares) in the United States with technical FPV potential; the largest opportunities were found at reservoirs owned by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and the Bureau of Reclamation (Reclamation). The NREL study estimated that, if fully realized, FPV systems on U.S. water bodies could have produce almost 10% of the nationโ€™s electricity generation in 2018 (approximately 786 terawatt-hours) (Spencer et al. 2018). A follow-on study completed by NREL in 2024 identified between 861 GW and 1,042 GW (corresponding to 1,221 terawatt- hours and 1,476 terawatt-hours) of technical resource potential across USACE, Reclamation, and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)-licensed reservoirs.

Current U.S. domestic FPV development is mostly limited to small-scale projects of less than 1 megawatt (MW) sited on closed-loop water bodies such as wastewater treatment plants, drinking water ponds, and irrigation water storage ponds (Chopra and Garasa Sagardoy 2022). Nevertheless, the versatility, potential benefits, and resource potential of FPV have led to growing investment in recent years, which is expected to continue as PV developers look to alternatives like FPV to meet growing demand (Wood MacKenzie 2023; Chopra and Garasa Sagardoy 2022).

This report provides novel analysis to understand the opportunities and challenges associated with developing stand-alone and co-located FPV projects on Reclamation reservoirs, USACE reservoirs, and FERC-licensed reservoirs in the United States. Specifically, the report explores potential environmental and energy benefits and environmental impacts associated with the siting, construction, and operation of FPV projects. The report also identifies and analyzes U.S. federal- and state-issued permits and authorizations required by federal laws to understand the licensing pathways and regulatory requirements for FPV projects sited on FERC-licensed reservoirs, Reclamation-powered and non-powered reservoirs, and USACE powered and non- powered reservoirs.

Of note, this report only analyzes the addition of FPV to reservoirs and does not consider FPV development on or above canal systems.

June was #Coloradoโ€™s 2nd or 3rd warmest ever: Centennial State lags global rise in temperature but all but one month of the last year have exceeded long-term averages — Allen Best (@BigPivots) #ActOnClimate

Palisade peaches ripening on the vine on June 5, 2024. Photo credit: Allen Best/Big Pivots

Click the link to read the article on the Big Pivots website (Allen Best):

July 8, 2024

June was a hot month in Colorado, among the two or three hottest Junes ever recorded.

Temperatures for the state didnโ€™t top those of June 2012, a very notable one with attendant repercussions for river flows on the Western Slope. But on July 1, with records still being tabulated, Russ Schumacher, the state climatologist, said that June ranked either second or third among records that go back to the 1880s. He expects to have the definitive report filed soon.

The heat of June came after a comparatively cool May. It was close to the long-term average across much of Colorado, but cooler than average across northwestern Colorado.

The 10 months prior to May, however, had all been warmer than the 20th century average.

You can study the precise temperature rankings for each month in Colorado (and every other state) at this website maintained by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the National Centers for Environmental Information.

Coloradoโ€™s coolish May and barn-burner June come even as NASA warns of a climate crisis after an unprecedented 12 months of record highs. Each of the 12 months had a global high.

The last 10 consecutive years have been the warmest 10 since record-keeping began in the late 19th century.

โ€œWeโ€™re experiencing more hot days, more hot months, more hot years,โ€ said Kate Calvin, NASAโ€™s chief scientist and senior climate advisor. โ€œWe know that these increases in temperature are driven by our greenhouse gas emissions and are impacting people and ecosystems around the world.โ€

Schumacher, a professor at Colorado State University, said the really extreme warmth during the last year or so has been over the oceans.

โ€œColorado and the western US have been warmer than average over the last year or so but not breaking records like the globe as a whole,โ€ he told Big Pivots.

NASA has put together a visualization of the rise in global temperatures that might fascinate you โ€“ or leave you unsettled.ย See that visualization here.

Aspinall Unit operations update July 10, 2024

Morrow Point Dam, on the Gunnison River, Aspinall Unit. Photo: Brent Gardner-Smith/Aspen Journalism

From email from Reclamation (Erik Knight):

Releases from the Aspinall Unit will be increased from 1600 cfs to 1900 cfs between Wednesday, July 10th and Thursday, July 11th.  Releases are being increased in response to declining river flows on the lower Gunnison River.

Flows in the lower Gunnison River have been dropping quickly towards the baseflow target of 1500 cfs. River flows are expected to continue to decline over the next couple weeks.

Pursuant to the Aspinall Unit Operations Record of Decision (ROD), the baseflow target in the lower Gunnison River, as measured at the Whitewater gage, is 1500 cfs for July and then drops to 1050 cfs in August.

Currently, Gunnison Tunnel diversions are 1050 cfs and flows in the Gunnison River through the Black Canyon are around 600 cfs. After this release change Gunnison Tunnel diversions will still be 1050 cfs and flows in the Gunnison River through the Black Canyon will be near 900 cfs. Current flow information is obtained from provisional data that may undergo revision subsequent to review.

#Drought news July 4, 2024: Heavy rainfall across parts of the Four Corners

Click on a thumbnail graphic to view a gallery of drought data from the US Drought Monitor website.

Click the link to go to the US Drought Monitor website. Here’s an excerpt:

This Week’s Drought Summary

East of the Rocky Mountains, there was a mixture of worsening and improving drought conditions this week. With the passage of a couple of frontal boundaries across the eastern contiguous U.S. (CONUS), in addition to a steady moisture flow from the southwestern CONUS into parts of the Central Plains, several areas across the eastern two-thirds of the U.S. received heavy precipitation. However, heavier amounts varied greatly from region to region and were highly localized east of the Mississippi River. Rates of evaporation of moisture from land and vegetation (known as evapotranspiration) are high across the eastern CONUS, due in large part to several days of excessive heat. Therefore, targeted improvements are depicted in regions picking up above normal precipitation (at least 1 inch above normal rainfall for the week) and where improvements to soil moisture and stream flows were apparent. Given the very dry and hot antecedent conditions leading up to this week, drought degradation is merely halted in most other areas receiving above normal rainfall, as indicators did not show marked improvements. Conversely, for locations receiving below normal rainfall, another week of degradation is warranted. In the West, the Four Corners region was the beneficiary of yet another wet week, aided by a couple of low pressure systems bringing an influx of moisture into the region. Elsewhere in the West, conditions worsened, with several pockets of abnormal dryness (D0) popping up and the expansion of drought conditions, particularly across the northern Rockies. A slight westward expansion of abnormal dryness and moderate drought (D1) in the Alaska Mainland and the introduction of abnormal dryness near the Kenai Peninsula is warranted, supported by short-term derived drought indicators and precipitation deficits. A status-quo drought depiction is depicted in Hawaii this week, but stream flows are slowly falling as the trade winds continue to lack meaningful moisture. Puerto Rico continues to remain drought-free…

High Plains

The High Plains region experienced a mixture of both deteriorating and improving drought conditions this week, which has also predominantly been the case over at least the last month. A couple of troughs of low pressure moved across the western and central U.S. this week, helping to tap into some moisture from the Pacific Ocean and draw it into the region. This resulted in heavy rainfall across parts of the Four Corners and extending eastward into the Central and Eastern Plains. Parts of Kansas and eastern Nebraska received well in excess of 3 inches of rainfall. Unfortunately, several locations across the western High Plains region were not so lucky and received below normal weekly rainfall. Temperatures were also unseasonably warm, running anywhere from 4ยฐF to 8ยฐF above average for the week in many areas, helping to exacerbate worsening conditions…

Colorado Drought Monitor one week change map ending July 2, 2024.

West

In the Western U.S., drought improvements were limited to southern parts of the region, where a couple of troughs of low pressure were able to bring some moisture from the Pacific Ocean northward into the Desert Southwest and Four Corners. Elsewhere across the West, conditions have slowly dried out in recent weeks. With another week of below normal precipitation and above normal temperatures, with much of the Great Basin running 4ยฐF to 8ยฐF above average for the week, conditions worsened…

South

Expansion of drought and abnormal dryness is warranted this week in the South, as much of the region experienced another week of hot and dry conditions, and this has been the case since the start of June for many locations. The only areas where improving conditions were observed is across northern Oklahoma, extending into Kansas, where another week of heavy rain fell (locally more than 3 inches in north-central Oklahoma). After a very wet May, precipitation has been lacking entirely across large parts of central and eastern Texas, extending eastward into Louisiana. Indicators have shown a drying trend and topsoil moisture has really started to dry out. These areas will bear watching in the coming weeks…

Looking Ahead

During the next five days (July 3 – July 7), High pressure is likely to build over the western U.S., leading to hot, potentially record-breaking temperatures and below normal precipitation. Farther eastward, East of the Rockies, temperatures are forecast to become more seasonal for the most part. In addition, parts of the Middle and Upper Mississippi Valley are likely to experience a couple of rounds of heavy rainfall. Rainfall in excess of 1 inch is favored across parts of the Ohio Valley, Mid-Atlantic, and Southeast.

The Climate Prediction Centerโ€™s 6-10 day outlook (valid July 8 – 12), favors enhanced chances of above average, potentially record-breaking, temperatures across parts of the Intermountain West, with above normal temperatures changes extending into the Western Plains, along the Gulf Coast, and into the eastern U.S. Below normal temperatures are favored in the interior central U.S. Near and below normal precipitation is likeliest across the western and north-central U.S., with above normal precipitation favored elsewhere. Eyes will be on the tropics over the next 6 to 10 days, with enhanced chances for above normal precipitation across southern Texas and the western Gulf Coast. Near to below normal temperatures and above normal precipitation is favored in Alaska and Hawaii.

US Drought Monitor one week change map ending July 2, 2024.

Just for grins here’s a slideshow of early July US Drought Monitor map for the past few years.

Multi-million dollar investment helps quench #ColoradoRiver basin #drought concerns — The #Craig Press #COriver #aridification

Map credit: AGU

Click the link to read the article on the Craig Press website (Ashley Dishman). Here’s an excerpt:

In a move to combat the drought crisis affecting the Colorado River Basin, the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) announced on Thursday an $11.1 million cooperative agreement with the Foundation for Americaโ€™s Public Lands. The partnership aims to enhance drought resilience in the region, which is vital for the millions of Americans who depend on the river for their livelihoods. The funding, made available through the Inflation Reduction Act under the Biden Administration, is set to bolster efforts to ensure the sustainability of the Colorado River Basin…The BLM, which manages more public land in the Colorado River Basin than any other federal agency, recognizes drought as the most critical threat to the region. The drought impacts various sectors, including agriculture, grazing, wildlife and fisheries, recreation, cultural resource uses, and power generation and distribution.

The Foundation for Americaโ€™s Public Lands, officially formed in 2022 and chartered by Congress in 2017, serves as the BLMโ€™s charitable partner. The Foundation operates to raise private funds and awareness, increasing access to and stewardship of over 245 million acres of U.S. public lands and waters. The cooperative agreement between the BLM and the Foundation spans five years and aims to undertake restoration projects on a landscape scale. This approach will cover multiple states and invest in local communities that depend on and manage the land. The agreement also allows the Foundation to collaborate with other partner organizations, bringing in technical experts to enhance the effectiveness of the projects.

Fast-growing northern #Colorado wins $250 million in loans for new dam, regional water project — Jerd Smith (Fresh Water News)

The Chimney Hollow Reservoir under construction in Colorado’s Larimer County, July 8, 2022. Credit: Jerd Smith, Fresh Water News

Click the link to read the article on the Water Education Colorado website (Jerd Smith):

May 23, 2024

Fast-growing northern Colorado won approval for two major water loans from the state this month that will help finance a new dam outside Loveland and a major regional water project northwest of Fort Collins.

Vetted by the Colorado Water Conservation Board and approved by a bipartisan group of lawmakers May 1, the $155 million for Chimney Hollow Reservoir and the $100 million for the Northern Integrated Supply Project, or NISP, are among the largest financing packages the state has approved in recent years, according to the board.

โ€œIs it a lot, yes,โ€ said Jeff Stahla, a spokesperson for Northern Water, the agency that is sponsoring the projects for a group of cities that includes Loveland, Broomfield, Erie, and Greeley. 

โ€œWe know that these were big asks, and we are grateful for the support. We also recognize that these projects are going to benefit hundreds of thousands of people in the fastest-growing part of the state right now,โ€ Stahla said.

The full costs of the water projects, $561 million for Chimney Hollow and roughly $2 billion for NISP, are being financed by water users, as well as the state, Stahla said.

The Northern Integrated Supply Project, currently estimated at $2 billion, would create two new reservoirs and a system of pipelines to capture more drinking water for 15 community water suppliers. An environmental group is now suing the Army Corps of Engineers over a key permit for Northern Waterโ€™s proposal. (Save the Poudre lawsuit, from Northern Water project pages)

The loans come as forecasts show the stateโ€™s streams shrinking as much as 30% due to the warming climate while the areaโ€™s population continues to grow.

Kirk Russell, the boardโ€™s finance section chief, said the two loans combined make up 20% of the agencyโ€™s $1.1 billion revolving loan fund. The program operates by providing cash to borrowers below market rates. The interest that is generated, in turn, helps finance loans for new borrowers as these are repaid.

The mega loans mean the state will have somewhat less to lend next year, Russell said, for the stateโ€™s 2025 fiscal year, which begins July 1.

โ€œI estimate we will have about $50 million to $60 million in loan funds available next fiscal year. Thatโ€™s about our average annual total [in available loan funds] for the last few years,โ€ Russell said via email.

The loan program is funded with cash generated by interest and loan payments, as well as federal mineral lease payments and severance taxes collected from oil and gas production, Russell said.

Among its other major loans in recent years is the Arkansas Valley Conduit in southeastern Colorado, which received a $90 million loan, and Auroraโ€™s Prairie Waters Project, which received a $60 million loan, according to Russell.

Rep. Karen McCormick, D-Longmont, said she and her fellow lawmakers are pleased the state has been able to provide the financial help. McCormick was one of the bipartisan group of lawmakers who sponsored House Bill 1435, the legislation authorizing the loans.

โ€œThese projects are super important, especially to my area of Colorado,โ€ McCormick said. โ€œTo have these new reservoirs completed is critical. A lot of different water providers are depending on this.โ€

The projects are not without controversy, however. Federal permitting for both began 20 years ago, according to Stahla, and each has been delayed numerous times after environmentalists sued over concerns about the impact on the drought-strapped Colorado River, the supply that will eventually fill Chimney Hollow, and the equally stressed Cache la Poudre River, whose flows will be used by NISP.

In fact, the Chimney Hollow loan grew from its original $90 million to $155 million in part due to the cost of litigation and increases in construction costs, Stahla said.

Though Chimney Hollow is under construction, NISP continues to face delays due partially to a lawsuit by Save the Poudre against the federal agencies that approved the deal. It was filed in January.

And it will also have to eventually win an OK from the City of Fort Collins, which has historically opposed the project. Mayor Jeni Arndt declined to comment on the state funding, but said the project would still have to undergo review by the city.

How quickly that might occur isnโ€™t clear…

More by Jerd SmithJerd Smith is editor of Fresh Water News. She can be reached at 720-398-6474, via email at jerd@wateredco.org or @jerd_smith.

#ColoradoRiver Flowing in Its Delta Again, But Restoration Hangs in the Balance — Audubon #COriver #aridification

Ridgway’s Rail. Photo: Robert Groos/Audubon Photography Awards

Click the link to read the release on the Audubon website (Jennifer Pitt):

May 21, 2024

The Colorado River is flowing again in its delta. While this is welcome news for birds and people, the long-term progress to keep the Colorado River alive in Mexico with habitat restoration and water deliveries depends on high stakes negotiations currently underway.

For the third time since 2021, the United States and Mexico are collaborating to deliver water to improve conditions in the long-desiccated delta. Environmental water deliveries began mid-March and will continue into October, ensuring the river flows through the summerโ€™s heat, making restored riverside forests and wetlands more hospitable to birds like Abertโ€™s Towhees and Crissal Thrashers and other wildlife including beavers and lynxes. We know that birds rely on water in the Delta as they migrate to locations all over the United States.

Restoration in the Colorado River Delta is implemented by Raise the River, a coalition of NGOs including Audubon, in partnership with U.S. and Mexican federal agencies. Funds, water, and collaboration for this work were committed first in Minute 319 and again in Minute 323, the United Statesโ€“Mexico treaty agreements that have been widely hailed for modernizing Colorado River management with a host of benefits to water users in both countries including rules for sharing water shortages, as well as work to use relatively small volumes of water to revive the delta for wildlife and people. The terms of Minute 323 sunset in 2026, but delta restoration efforts remain a work in progress.

The good news: the United States and Mexico are poised to negotiate a successor agreement to Minute 323 in parallel with new federal rulemaking in the United States for Colorado River management. Domestic Colorado River rules, like the binational agreements, have for decades been the result of consensus-based negotiations, in this setting between the seven Colorado River Basin States with concurrence of the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. This domestic rulemaking also has a 2026 deadline.

The bad news: at the moment, the Colorado River Basin states appear to be nowhere near consensus, with disagreements about which states, and which water users, will cut back when thereโ€™s not enough to satisfy all. These are difficult and high stakes negotiations. Failure to reach agreement increases the risk of water supply crises and could even throw the dispute in front of the U.S. Supreme Court.

That brings me back to the Abertโ€™s Towhees and Crissal Thrashers, the beavers and lynxes in the Delta. If the Colorado River Basin states fail to reach consensus, thereโ€™s considerable risk that the work of restoring the Colorado River in its delta comes to a halt. Delta restoration depends on binational consensus, and binational consensus depends on a U.S. domestic consensus. Itโ€™s an extraordinarily complex decision-making framework for governance of water supply for 40 million people. The failure to reach consensus may create problems for some people who use Colorado River water, but it is certain to create collateral damage in Colorado River ecosystems including the Delta.

Map credit: AGU

A once-promising #ColoradoRiver forecast is downgraded after mediocre April snowfall — AZCentral.com #snowpack #COriver #aridification

Click the link to read the article on the AZCentral.com website (Brandon Loomis). Here’s an excerpt:

May 16, 2024

A dry April around the Colorado River Basin melted hopes for a second-straight banner year of big runoff to swell Lake Powellโ€™s reservoir storage, government hydrologists say. The result is a likely holding pattern for drought responses over the next two years, according to the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation. Water levels in Lake Powell and Lake Mead are unlikely to rise as they did after the strong snowpack that accumulated over the 2022-2023 winter, but are also unlikely to tip the Southwest into a new tier of water austerity measures. The mountain snow season started out dry, came on strong in the middle, and came to an abrupt standstill in April.

With the exception of the Colorado headwaters and Arizonaโ€™s Verde River, most areas of the seven-state watershed experienced below-average April snow and rain, according to the Colorado Basin River Forecast Center. What had generally been above-average snowpack water content throughout the region in late-winter turned toward normal or below average as meltwater started flowing toward Lake Powell.

Snowpack numbers drop during a drier April

For the water year that began in October, total precipitation in areas flowing toward Lake Powell stood at about 97% of the 30-year average this month, he said. A relatively dry month above the big reservoir had reduced an April 1 snow-water equivalent reading that was 113% of the median to just 89% by May 1. Snow-water equivalent describes the amount of water that would result from melting snow.

Reclamation, which manages Powellโ€™s releases past Glen Canyon Dam, now predicts the water flowing toward the reservoir through the end of runoff season in July will come in at 81% of average, totaling 7.9 million acre-feet. With the agency set to release 7.48 million acre-feet toward Lake Mead this year, Powellโ€™s storage capacity is not expected to change much. It is currently 34% full and most likely will end the year at 37%, according to the agencyโ€™s calculations…

Within Arizona, the Salt River Projectโ€™s outlook for water supplies is strong for the second year in a row. The metro Phoenix supplier said its Salt and Verde watershed reservoirsย entered May at 93% of capacity.

Nathan Coombs elected chair of #Colorado Water Conservation Board — @AlamosaCitizen #SanLuisValley #RioGrande

Click the link to read the article on the Alamosa Citizen website:

May 16, 2024

Manager of the Conejos Water Conservancy District and fourth-generation farmer and will lead the nine-member board

Conejos Countyโ€™s Nathan Coombs was elected new chair of the Colorado Water Conservation Board this week. Itโ€™s a major role for the fourth-generation farmer who will lead the 15-member board for the next year. 

The Colorado Water Conservation Board includes nine representatives from each major Colorado river basin as well as the Denver area.ย 

โ€œIโ€™m honored to serve as chair of the CWCB, to bring in my experience working in the challenging landscape of the San Luis Valley, and lean on the experiences of the rest of the board,โ€ said Coombs.โ€ We face so many water challenges in Colorado, so itโ€™s critical we all come together to find creative solutions.โ€

The Rio Grande cutthroat is the only trout native to the San Luis Valley. Evidence suggests it was a native fish to Lake Alamosa 700,000 years ago. Photo credit: Ryan Michelle Scavo

Coombs serves as the representative of the Rio Grande Basin and is manager of the Conejos Water Conservancy District. In recent years, Coombs has partnered with biologists at Trout Unlimited to improve habitat for fish in the regionโ€™s rivers and streams. Coombs takes over as CWCB board chair from Greg Felt, representative of the Arkansas River basin and chair from 2023 to 2024.ย 

Lorelei Cloud, Vice-chair of the Southern Ute Tribal Council, and Southwest Colorado’s representative of the Colorado Water Conservation Board, which addresses most water issues in Colorado. Photo via Sibley’s Rivers

Lorelei Cloud was elected as vice chair. Cloud serves as the representative of the San Miguel-Dolores-San Juan drainage basin, and also serves as vice chair of the Southern Ute Indian Tribe. Cloud is the first tribal council member to join the board and is a leader in Colorado, bringing critical tribal voices to the table.

In March 2023, Colorado Governor Jared Polis appointed Coombs and Cloud to the CWCB to represent their basins.  

โ€œDirectors Coombs and Cloud joined as board members last March, and have made valuable contributionsย  over the last year,โ€ said CWCB Director Lauren Ris. โ€œWe are excited to see what they do in the next year in these leadership roles โ€“ from navigating tough conversations to leading productive brainstorming to listening to viewpoints from across the state.โ€

Will More Funding Be Directed to #Colorado Water Projects? — The Buzz

Central City back in the day

Click the link to read the article on The Buzz website (Floyd Ciruli):

May 2, 2024

Colorado voters may be asked to direct more sports gaming revenue to water conservation projects.

Jerd Smith of Fresh Water News reports on new legislation with bipartisan support including House speaker Julie McCluskie that will refer a ballot issue to voters in November. It will shift any gaming revenue over a $29 million cap in the original ballot proposition to water projects.

I said the measure should pass with leadership support and that voters are likely to be supportive.

  1. Voters are concerned about water conservation
  2. The measure would not expand gaming or increase taxes
    • Gaming interests (Fan Duel or DraftKings) are not opposed
    • Environmental interests appear supportive

โ€œWhile the original sports betting ballot measure received tepid support, the tax question, if it makes the ballot, may win broader support due to ongoing voter concerns about water conservation and protection and the high-profile crisis on the drought- stressed Colorado River, veteran pollster and political analyst Floyd Ciruli said.

โ€œI have not seen any polls that negate what we knew strongly back then, that water conservation and water protection are environmental issues that Coloradans care strongly about,โ€ he said.”

Link to article:ย Colorado voters may be asked to send more sports betting money to water projects

Trump will dismantle key US weather and science agency, climate experts fear: Plan to break up NOAA claims its research is โ€˜climate alarmismโ€™ and calls for commercializing forecasts, weakening forecasts — The Guardian #ActOnClimate

Meteorologists preparing a forecast, early 20th century. By NOAA Photo Library – wea01302, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=17970931

Click the link to read the article on The Guardian website (Dharna Noor). Here’s an excerpt:

April 26, 2024

Climate experts fearย Donald Trumpย will follow a blueprint created by his allies to gut the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (Noaa), disbanding its work on climate science and tailoring its operations to business interests…The plan to โ€œbreak up Noaa is laid out inย the Project 2025 documentย written byย more than 350 rightwingersย and helmed by the Heritage Foundation. Called the Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise, it is meant toย guide the first 180 days of presidencyย for an incoming Republican president. The document bears the fingerprints of Trump allies, including Johnny McEntee, who was one of Trumpโ€™s closest aides and is aย senior adviserย to Project 2025. โ€œThe National Oceanographic [sic] and Atmospheric Administration (Noaa) should be dismantled and many of its functions eliminated, sent to other agencies, privatized, or placed under the control of states and territories,โ€ the proposal says…

Thatโ€™s a sign that the far right has โ€œno interest in climate truthโ€, said Chris Gloninger, who last year left his job as a meteorologist in Iowa after receiving death threats over his spotlighting of global warming…The guidebook chapter detailing the strategy, which was recently spotlighted by E&E News, describes Noaa as a โ€œcolossal operation that has become one of the main drivers of the climate change alarm industry and, as such, is harmful to future US prosperityโ€. It was written by Thomas Gilman, a former Chrysler executive who during Trumpโ€™s presidency was chief financial officer for Noaaโ€™s parent body, the commerce department…

Gilman writes that one of Noaaโ€™s six main offices, the Office of Oceanic and Atmospheric Research, should be โ€œdisbandedโ€ because it issues โ€œtheoreticalโ€ science and is โ€œthe source of much of Noaaโ€™s climate alarmismโ€. Though he admits it serves โ€œimportant public safety and business functions as well as academic functionsโ€, Gilman says data from the National Hurricane Center must be โ€œpresented neutrally, without adjustments intended to support any one side in the climate debateโ€. But Noaaโ€™s research and data are โ€œlargely neutral right nowโ€, said Andrew Rosenberg, a former Noaa official who is now a fellow at the University of New Hampshire. โ€œIt in fact basically reports the science as the scientific evidence accumulates and has been quite cautious about reporting climate effects,โ€ he said. โ€œItโ€™s not pushing some agenda.โ€

[…]

Noaa also houses the National Weather Service (NWS), which provides weather and climate forecasts and warnings. Gilman calls for the service to โ€œfully commercialize its forecasting operationsโ€. He goes on to say that Americans are already reliant on private weather forecasters, specifically naming AccuWeather and citing a PR release issued by the company to claim that โ€œstudies have found that the forecasts and warnings provided by the private companies are more reliableโ€ than the public sectorโ€™s. (The mention is noteworthy as Trump once tapped the former CEO of AccuWeather to lead Noaa, though his nomination was soon withdrawn.) The claims come amid years of attempts from US conservatives to help private companies enter the forecasting arena โ€“ proposals that are โ€œnonsenseโ€, said Rosenberg. Right now, all people can access high-quality forecasts for free through the NWS. But if forecasts were conducted only by private companies that have a profit motive, crucial programming might no longer be available to those in whom business executives donโ€™t see value, said Rosenberg.

Specially designed hurricane-proof building constructed to house joint offices of the Houston-Galveston National Weather Service Forecast Office and the Galveston County Emergency Management Office. By Nsaum75 at en.wikipedia, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=8895755

The Upper Gunnison Water Conservancy District gives $260K to water projects — The Gunnison Country Times

Map of the Gunnison River drainage basin in Colorado, USA. Made using public domain USGS data. By Shannon1 – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=69257550

Click the link to read the article on The Gunnison Country Times website. Here’s an excerpt:

April 24, 2024

The Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District awarded $260,000 to organizations and individuals across the basin during its 2024 grant cycle. This year marked the water districtโ€™s 15th annual grant program, which uses tax revenue to support diverse water projects in the basin. Grant funds will be used for projects that improve irrigation water management and efficiency, restore degraded stream channels and aquatic habitat, support engineering and design and carry out basin water education. The district received requests for more than $315,000. All applicants were required to provide a 50% cost match…

The 16 projects funded this year include maintenance on the boardwalk bog bridge along the Rec Path in Crested Butte, as well as the installation of educational signage about the wetlands in the area. The district gave $25,000 to support the ongoing harmful algal bloom study at Blue Mesa Reservoir with the U.S. Geological Survey. Two Western Colorado University students will work with the National Park Service to explore the effects of toxic algal blooms on the foraging patterns of kokanee salmon. An Arch Ditch automation project will allow the diversion to fully operate remotely. This is the first one of its kind in the Gunnison Basin. The upgrade will reduce the labor needed to manage the diversion and conserve water. In Gunnison, $50,000 will help address irrigation issues at the Dos Rios Golf Club and reduce water use. The existing system is 40 years old, and uses roughly 65 million gallons of water per year. With the new system, the managers expect to cut water use almost in half.

Reclamation awards $1.9M for new water treatment technology

Desalination plant, Aruba

Click the link to read the release on the Bureau of Reclamation website (Chelsea Lair):

Apr 18, 2024

WASHINGTONย โ€“ The Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s Desalination and Water Purification Research program awarded eight projects funding totaling more than $1.9 million. Reclamation selected the projects from 80 eligible applications all submitting pioneering solutions toย desalination and water treatment technologies.

โ€œThese awards allow us to tackle the climate crisis by investing in development and application of advanced water treatment technologies that expand access to otherwise unusable water resources,โ€ said Research and Development Program Manager Ken Nowak. โ€œThese efforts increase water supply flexibility under the risks of long-term climate change and shorter-term drought.โ€

The Desalination and Water Purification Research Program provides financial assistance for advanced water treatment research and development, leading to improved technologies for developing water supply from non-traditional waters, including seawater, brackish groundwater, and municipal wastewater, among others.โ€ฏ 

Recipients of the project funding have provided an additional $1.4 million of non-federal cost share to further support these research efforts.

ARIZONA

Arizona State University: Funds awarded ($209,708 federal funding, $424,479 total project cost) for Nanobubbles as a Chemical-Free Fouling and Scale Control Strategy for Reverse Osmosis Project. This project proposes a chemical-free solution during water desalination.

COLORADO

Mickley & Associates LLC: Funds awarded ($117,700 federal funding, $235.400 total project cost) for the Updated Survey of U.S. Municipal Desalination Plants Project. This project aims to identify an estimated 50 to 70 facilities and gather detailed information about U.S. municipal desalination facilities that have been built since 2017 and will be built through 2024. The project will also determine that status of facilities included in past surveys as several older facilities are no longer operating.

University of Colorado: Funds awarded ($250,000 federal funding, $339,133 total project cost) for the Advancing Water Reuse Through Improved Diagnostic Tools for Corrosion Control Project. This project will develop a new method for proactively assessing the presence of toxic metal release in water systems and the susceptibility of release due to changing water conditions. Current methods are limited, because they do not link the presence of a toxic metal to the likelihood of release into potable water.

MASSACHUSETTS

Harmony Desalination Corporation: Funds awarded ($390,871 federal funding, $781,742 total project cost) for the Field Pilot Testing a Batch RO Process Using Electrically Conducting Reverse Osmosis Membranes Project. This project proposes extended field testing of a high recovery batch reverse osmosis process using innovative anti-scaling and antifouling electrically conducting membranes in comparison with conventional reverse osmosis membranes.

NEW JERSEY

New Jersey Institute of Technology: Funds awarded ($249,940 federal funding, $396,971 total project cost) for the Enhanced Coagulation for the Removal of Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances using Hydrophobic Ion Pairing Approach Project. This project proposes to utilize hydrophobic ion-pairing as a pretreatment to enhance the removal of both short-chain and long-chain per-/polyfluoroalkyl substances during coagulation/flocculation process.

New Jersey Institute of Technology: Funds awarded ($250,000 federal funding, $500,334 total project cost) for the Field-Effect Transistor Nanosensors for Testing Per- and polyfluoroalkyl Substances Impacted Water and Air Project. This project will fabricate novel field-effect transistor sensors, systematically examine the sensing performance, device stability, and reusability when probing per-/polyfluoroalkyl in synthetic water and air samples and conduct a field demonstration of the sensors.

NEW MEXICO

New Mexico State University: Funds awarded ($250,000 federal funding, $312,514 total project cost) for the Brine 2030: Enhanced Water Recovery with Mineral Valorization for Sustainable Cement Production Project. This project seeks to address two seemingly different problems: brine management and greenhouse gas emissions from cement manufacturing.

TEXAS

Texas State University: Funds awarded ($250,000 federal funding, $399,234 total project cost) for the Pilot Photobioreactor Development for Scalant Removal and Enhanced Water Recovery from Brackish Reverse Osmosis Concentrate Project. This project seeks to demonstrate continuous pilot photobioreactor operation using sunlight and reduction of the reactor footprint.

For more information on Reclamationโ€™s Desalination and Water Purification Research Program visit http://www.usbr.gov/research/dwpr.

#Colorado U.S. Senator Bennet Announces Nearly $130 Million for #Colorado Projects in First Round of Senate Appropriations Bills

Western State Colorado University Gunnison

Click the link to read the release on Senator Bennet’s website:

March 8, 2024

Bennet Secured Nearly $91.5 Million for 78 Colorado Projects

Washington, D.C.ย โ€” Colorado U.S. Senator Michael Bennet announced that he secured nearly $91.5 million for 78 Colorado projects through the congressionally directed spending (CDS) in the first round of Fiscal Year 2024 (FY24) Senate appropriations bills. In total, the six bills included nearly $130 million in funding for projects across Colorado. The Senate is currently working to pass another six FY24 appropriations bills which could include additional funding for Colorado projects.ย 

โ€œThroughout this process, Iโ€™ve sat down with municipalities, nonprofits, and leaders across the state to hear directly about the challenges their communities face and how Washington can be a better partner,โ€ said Bennet. โ€œIโ€™m glad we were able to support nearly eighty projects across thirty Colorado counties in this round of funding. From funding water infrastructure in Lamar to a business park in Craig and a housing affordability project in Fort Collins, these investments will help Coloradans meet the changing needs of their communities.โ€ 

Colorado projects secured by Bennet in FY24 Senate appropriations bills:

PROJECT TITLERECIPIENTFUNDING AMOUNTLOCATIONALSO REQUESTED BY 
211 Colorado UpgradeMile High United Way$500,000DenverHickenlooper, Crow
3rd and Knox Affordable Housing ProjectHabitat for Humanity of Metro Denver, Inc.$750,000DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
Auraria Early Learning Center and Mixed-Use DevelopmentAuraria Higher Education Center$2,000,000DenverHickenlooper
Breakthrough Program ExpansionBreakthrough$353,000DenverHickenlooper
Central CorridorRTD$850,000DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
Central Public Libraryโ€”RenovationCity of Aurora, CO$3,000,000AuroraHickenlooper, Crow
Chambers Avenue WideningColorado Department of Transportation$4,116,279Commerce CityHickenlooper, Caraveo
City of Aurora for Pressure Regulating Valve RelocationCity of Aurora$900,000AuroraHickenlooper, Crow
City of Aurora for Water System ImprovementsCity of Aurora$2,000,000AuroraHickenlooper
City of Evans for Waterline Replacement ProjectCity of Evans$677,000EvansHickenlooper, Caraveo
City of Gunnison for Water Treatment Plant ProjectCity of Gunnison$1,750,000GunnisonHickenlooper, Boebert
City of Lamar for Wastewater Treatment Plant ImprovementsCity of Lamar$1,800,000LamarHickenlooper
City of Longmont Micro Transit SystemCity of Longmont$1,000,000LongmontHickenlooper, Neguse
City of Westminster for New Water Treatment FacilityCity of Westminster$959,752WestminsterHickenlooper, Pettersen
Clear Creek Schools Foundation Childcare CenterClear Creek Schools Foundation$1,616,279Idaho SpringsNeguse
Colorado Rural Impact ProgramsCounty Sheriffs of Colorado$917,000Statewide
Colorado State University Multiuse UAS Airfield ProjectColorado State University$500,000Fort CollinsHickenlooper, Neguse
Compactor/Roller Attachments for Road SafetyColorado Department of Transportation$396,000GoldenHickenlooper
Cottonwood Pass Blue Hill ProjectColorado Department of Transportation$1,500,000Eagle CountyHickenlooper, Boebert
Deer Creek Water District for Water Meter UpgradesDeer Creek Water District$80,000ParkerHickenlooper
Denver Fire Station 40City and County of Denver$850,000DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
Denver International Airport Electrification PlanCity and County of Denver – Mayor’s office$300,000DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
DigitalBridge Colorado – Phase 2WRC – Connected Communities$270,000Grand County
Douglas County for Wildfire MitigationDouglas County$800,000Douglas County
Eagle County Regional Airport Federal Inspection StationEagle County Regional Airport$500,000GypsumHickenlooper, Neguse
Ecological Prediction Lab: Airborne Coverage to Inform Water and Forest Health ManagementRocky Mountain Biological Laboratory (RMBL)$975,000Crested ButteHickenlooper
Food Bank Distribution Center RenovationsCare and Share Food Bank for Southern Colorado$800,000Colorado SpringsHickenlooper
Former DPS Bus Barn RemediationCity and County of Denver$500,000DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
Fort Collins Affordable Housing PreservationNeighbor to Neighbor$1,000,000Fort CollinsHickenlooper
Gateway Domestic Violence ServicesAurora Arapahoe Battered Women’s Shelter, DBA Gateway Domestic Violence Services$1,616,279AuroraCrow
Greeley Neighborhood Safety ProgramColorado Department of Transportation$500,000GreeleyHickenlooper
Greeley Teen CenterBoys & Girls Clubs of Weld County$850,000GreeleyHickenlooper, Caraveo
High Plains Boulevard Iโ€“25 Arterial RoadColorado Department of Transportation$1,000,000Weld CountyHickenlooper, Caraveo
High-Temperature Fuel CellsColorado School of Mines$3,000,000GoldenHickenlooper
History Colorado for Fort Garland Geothermal & Weatherization ProjectHistory Colorado$164,000Fort GarlandHickenlooper
Holyoke Community Childcare InitiativeHolyoke Community Childcare Inititative$1,000,000HolyokeHickenlooper
Hope Center Facility RehabilitationHope Center, Inc.$2,000,000Denver
Huerfano County for Wastewater System ImprovementsHuerfano County$500,000GardnerHickenlooper
I-70 Interchange at 29 RoadColorado Department of Transportation$2,000,000Grand JunctionHickenlooper, Boebert
Idledale Water and Sanitation District for Water Infrastructure UpgradesIdledale Water and Sanitation District$959,752IdledaleHickenlooper, Pettersen
Janeโ€™s Place Multi-family Affordable Housing Solar ArraysChaffee County Government$300,000SalidaHickenlooper, Pettersen
Jefferson County for Forest Health Youth CorpsJefferson County Open Space$80,000Jefferson CountyHickenlooper
KidsPak Capital Improvements & EquipmentKidsPak$118,000LovelandHickenlooper
Kiowa County Hospital Replacement Facility: Phase 1Kiowa County Hospital District$1,917,000EadsHickenlooper
Lake County Community HousingLeadville Lake County Regional Housing Authority (LLCRHA)$850,000LeadvilleHickenlooper, Pettersen
Lookout Mountain Water District for Waterline ReplacementLookout Mountain Water District$959,752GoldenHickenlooper, Pettersen
Maple Street Bridge ReplacementColorado Department of Transportation$1,750,000FruitaHickenlooper
Mobile Facilities for Homelessness and Eviction AssistanceThe Community Firm (DBA Community Economic Defense Project)$840,000StatewideCrow
Moguan Aftercare Housing FacilityUte Mountain Ute Tribe$2,000,000TowaocHickenlooper
Nine Mile Pedestrian/Bicycle Bridge over SHโ€“83Colorado Department of Transportation$850,000AuroraHickenlooper, Crow
Open Soil Water SensorColorado State University$1,450,000Fort CollinsHickenlooper
Park Avenue InnColorado Coalition for the Homeless$4,116,279DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
Quebec Street โ€” 136th Avenue to north of 138th Avenue Widening DesignColorado Department of Transportation$850,000ThorntonHickenlooper, Caraveo
Regional Workforce Center for Career and Technical TrainingBuild Pagosa$1,000,000Pagosa SpringsHickenlooper
Residences on AcomaSecond Chance Center$1,500,000DenverHickenlooper
Riverside Educational Center RenovationRiverside Educational Center$168,000Grand JunctionHickenlooper
Rock Creek Affordable Housing & Associated InfrastructureSouthern Ute Indian Tribe$3,000,000IgnacioHickenlooper
Rural eConsult ExpansionUniversity of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus$402,785AuroraHickenlooper, Crow
San Luis Valley Health Workforce Housing ProjectLutheran Hospital Association of the San Luis Valley dba San Luis Valley Health$2,000,000AlamosaHickenlooper
Securing Southwest Colorado Police and Emergency CommunicationsMontezuma County$50,000Montezuma CountyHickenlooper
Social Fabric (Community Center)Colorado Asian Culture and Education Network (CACEN)$500,000AuroraHickenlooper, Crow
South Adams County Water and Sanitation District for PFAS Drinking Water Treatment Plant ProjectSouth Adams County Water & Sanitation District$959,752Commerce CityHickenlooper, Caraveo
Steamboat Springs WorkforceHousing Pedestrian and Bicycle Connection ProjectCity of Steamboat Springs$1,000,000Steamboat SpringsHickenlooper, Neguse
Teller County Water & Sanitation District 1 for Radium MitigationTeller County Water & Sanitation Special District #1$959,752Woodland ParkHickenlooper, Pettersen
The Commons Phase Two – Supportive HousingHomeward Pikes Peak$3,000,000Colorado Springs
The Craig Business and Industrial ParkCity of Craig$2,500,000CraigHickenlooper
Thornton Community Center Reconstruction ProjectCity of Thornton$1,000,000ThorntonHickenlooper, Caraveo
Three Lakes Water and Sanitation District Septic System UpgradesThree Lakes Water & Sanitation District$1,000,000Grand LakeHickenlooper
Timberline Fire Protection District Fire StationTimberline Fire Protection District$908,279Black HawkHickenlooper, Neguse
Town of Dolores for Water Distribution System Replacement Phase 2Town of Dolores$750,000DoloresHickenlooper
Town of Gypsum for Wastewater Infrastructure ProjectTown of Gypsum$959,752GypsumHickenlooper, Neguse
Town of Silt for Water Plant RenovationsTown of Silt$2,053,000SiltHickenlooper, Boebert
Training and Technical Assistance to Combat Human TraffickingThe Exodus Road$750,000Statewide
U.S. Highway 160/East Bayfield Parkway New Signalized IntersectionColorado Department of Transportation$1,547,000BayfieldHickenlooper, Boebert
Urban Agriculture and Education in WestwoodRe:Vision$800,000DenverDeGette
Vail Valley Affordable Home Ownership DevelopmentHabitat for Humanity Vail Valley$1,500,000Eagle CountyHickenlooper
Westwood Community Recreation CenterCity and County of Denver Mayor’s office$1,000,000DenverHickenlooper, DeGette
Workforce Training and Education SpaceCommunity College of Aurora$850,000AuroraHickenlooper, Crow

#Colorado State University scientist leads half of USDA update to methods for measuring greenhouse gas #ActOnClimate

Wheat on Arnsch Farms. (Lance Cheung/USDA/Public Domain Mark 1.0)

Click the link to read the release on the Colorado State University website (Jayme DeLoss)

April 2024

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has released updated methods to help farmers, ranchers and forest landowners estimate greenhouse gas emissions on their land. Three of the federal reportโ€™s six chapters were authored by Colorado State University scientist Stephen Ogle, one of the worldโ€™s top experts in greenhouse gas inventories.  

The report provides the best available science-based methods for estimating greenhouse gas emissions from land management decisions, updating a 2014 USDA report. Methods outlined in the report will be used to evaluate government conservation and climate-smart agriculture programs that encourage practices such as soil carbon sequestration.  

โ€œWe, as a group of authors, pulled the latest science and best information thatโ€™s available into these methods so that farmers will have a good tool for estimation and to know the benefit of what theyโ€™re doing on their farms,โ€ said Ogle, lead technical compiler for the national greenhouse gas inventory and professor of ecosystem science and sustainability in the Warner College of Natural Resources. 

Landowners can use these methods to gauge potential benefits from land management changes. The methods are incorporated into COMET-Farm, an online tool developed by CSU and USDA that farmers and ranchers can use to estimate soil carbon changes and greenhouse gas emissions on their land based on various management practices. 

โ€œWith growing importance of reducing emissions in agriculture through the new climate-smart agriculture program thatโ€™s been funded through the Inflation Reduction Act, this tool is likely going to be very important for farmers to estimate the benefit and for reporting,โ€ Ogle said. โ€œThe $19.5 billion climate-smart ag program is a significant investment by the U.S. government to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in agricultural systems, and these methods are pivotal in that policy.โ€ 

Ogle added that the new report includes details on how to implement quantification methods that havenโ€™t been released in previous reports. 

Ogle served as lead author for the croplands and grazing land systems, managed wetland systems and land-use change chapters and co-authored a fourth chapter, uncertainty quantification, with CSU Professor Emeritus Jay Breidt, who is now at the University of Chicago. Shawn Archibeque, professor of animal sciences, and Crystal Toureene, an agronomist and researcher in the Department of Soil and Crop Sciences, co-authored the animal production systems chapter.ย 

The 2024 update is the result of four years of work by a team of more than 60 authors, including USDA scientists, university researchers and experts from non-governmental organizations and research institutions, who have developed consistent metrics for estimating changes in greenhouse gas emissions and carbon sequestration for farm, ranch and forest operations. The updates to the report were reviewed by more than two dozen scientists, other federal agencies, the public and a panel of interdisciplinary experts. 

โ€œUSDAโ€™s updated greenhouse gas methods report represents a critical scientific consensus which ensures confidence in the benefits from climate-smart agriculture and forestry,โ€ Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack said in a USDA press release. โ€œThis report will help guide conservation efforts, improve our greenhouse gas estimation on U.S. farms, and support markets for carbon and climate-smart products nationwide.โ€ 

Read the report, Quantifying Greenhouse Gas Fluxes in Agriculture and Forestry: Methods for Entity Scale Inventory. 

Birdwatchers, boaters and families visit #LakeNighthorse on opening day — The #Durango Herald #AnimasRiver #SanJuanRiver #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

Lake Nighthorse and Durango March 2016 photo via Greg Hobbs.

Click the link to read the article on The Durango Herald website (Christian Burney). Here’s an excerpt:

April 13, 2024

Kayakers, bird watchers, trail hikers and parents with energetic toddlers were some of the first to visit Lake Nighthorse on opening day of the spring season Friday. The waters of Lake Nighthorse reflected pleasant, blue skies, although the reflection was elusive because there was hardly a trace of clouds above. Lake Operations Supervisor Sean Willis said six or seven vehicles were lined up at the entrance when the lake opened at 9 a.m. By 10:30 a.m., between 30 and 35 people had crossed the entrance.

Amanda White, co-vice president of Durango Bird Club, stood by a pier near the designated swim beach with her weighted tripod and spotting scope. She looked over the lake through the lenses with narrowed eyes with her dog Josie by her side.

She said the lake is a โ€œspectacularโ€ resource for migratory birds.

The inlet works to fill Lake Nighthorse under construction along the Animas River March 2014. Water is pumped to the reservoir from the Animas River. Photo credit: Greg Hobbs

10 visuals that show how #ClimateChange is transforming the Westโ€™s snow and water supply — The Water Desk

The Arkansas River and Sawatch Range near Leadville, Colorado, in March 2021. Photo by Mitch Tobin/The Water Desk.

Click the link to read the article on The Water Desk website (Mitch Tobin):

April 1, 2024

The latest National Climate Assessment warns of a shrinking snowpack and serious downstream consequences

A recent federal synthesis of climate change research paints a grim portrait of snowโ€™s future in the American West and warns that the fast-growing regionโ€™s water supply is vulnerable.

โ€œClimate change will continue to cause profound changes in the water cycle, increasing the risk of flooding, drought, and degraded water supplies for both people and ecosystems,โ€ according to the Fifth National Climate Assessment (NCA5) released in November.

The congressionally mandated report concludes there is โ€œwidespread consensusโ€ that warming will โ€œdecrease the proportion of US precipitation that falls as snow, decrease snow extents, advance the timing of snowmelt rates and pulses, increase the prevalence of rain-on-snow events,โ€ and transform the runoff that is vital for farms, cities and ecosystems. 

Climate change has already diminished the Westโ€™s snowpack, with warming global temperatures leading to earlier peaks and shorter seasons, especially at lower elevations and in areas closer to the coast.

In areas where snow is the dominant source of runoff, the volume of water stored in the snowpack may decrease by more than 24% by 2050 under some emissions scenarios, with โ€œpersistent low-snow conditions emerging within the next 60 years,โ€ the report said.

โ€œWhen we have less snow in the West, it can strain our water supplies,โ€ said report co-author Steph McAfee, regional administrator of the U.S. Geological Surveyโ€™s Southwest Climate Adaptation Science Center. โ€œWeโ€™ve tended to rely on the snowpack as a reservoir that didnโ€™t need to be built and it doesnโ€™t need to be maintained, so itโ€™s been a key place for storing water. Having less snow directly means less water stored for use in the summer.โ€

NCA5 stresses that climate changeโ€™s reshaping of the water cycle and other impacts will exacerbate inequalities in U.S. society and pose a special threat to some marginalized communities.

โ€œAll communities will be affected,โ€ the report said, โ€œbut in particular those on the frontline of climate changeโ€”including many Black, Hispanic, Tribal, Indigenous, and socioeconomically disadvantaged communitiesโ€”face growing risks from changes to water quantity and quality due to the proximity of their homes and workplaces to hazards and limited access to resources and infrastructure.โ€ 

NCA5 describes itself as the federal governmentโ€™s โ€œpreeminent report on climate change impacts, risks, and responses,โ€ though it is required to steer clear of policy prescriptions. 

The report is based on the latest science, but it is produced for decision-makers and the general public, so it is written in relatively accessible language, and data visualizations play a leading role in communicating the findings. 

Below I use 10 visuals from NCA5โ€”mostly maps but also charts, an infographic and a photoโ€”to help summarize the reportโ€™s conclusions about climate, snow and water in the West, focusing on the more arid parts of the region. 

Climate, snow and water

At one level, the story of snow and climate change is simple: in order for snow to fall and stick around, it has to be cold enough, so the warming of the planet is generally bad news for snow. 

โ€œI think the changes to snow and snowpack are changes that we have more confidence in than just about any other water parameter because of the direct effect of warming on snowpack and snow precipitation,โ€ said Elizabeth Payton, NCA5โ€™s Water Chapter Lead and a water resources specialist at the Western Water Assessment at the University of Colorado Boulder.

Co-author Ben Harding, senior water resources engineer at Lynker, summed up the reportโ€™s findings on snow this way: 

โ€œWeโ€™re going to see shorter periods of time with snow on the ground, the snow will start to accumulate later and itโ€™ll start to melt earlier,โ€ he said.

A smaller snowpack, a curtailed snow season and a new runoff regime will test the regionโ€™s complex water infrastructure of dams, aqueducts and canals, many of which were built in the early to mid-20th century, before climate change was recognized as a peril. The altered snowpack will also strain the Westโ€™s water laws and policies, many of which emerged in the 19th century, before some Western states were even admitted to the union. 

But while climate change has already shrunk the snowpack in most parts of the world and will continue to take a toll as temperatures climb, there are exceptions that buck the trend. Total global precipitation is expected to increase due to warming, including in places where the snowpack shrivels. NCA5 predicts there will be worse droughts and floods. 

For example, atmospheric rivers, which are pivotal for the Westโ€™s snowpack and water supply, are expected to strengthen in the years ahead. But beyond a certain point, warming makes it more likely that rain will fall instead of snow, even high in the mountains, raising the risk of flooding and a subpar snowpack. 

As temperatures keep rising, increasing rates of melting and evaporation will play a key role. Another critical factor is how much moisture gets sucked up by plants and then transpired into the atmosphere. Some snow never becomes snowmelt and is โ€œlostโ€ to the atmosphere through sublimation, moving directly from the solid to the gaseous phase. Soil moisture is yet another essential element of the water cycle, impacting drought, flooding, agriculture and ecosystems. 

But thatโ€™s not all. In Colorado, for example, dust-on-snow events are a big deal because the darker material reduces the snowโ€™s reflectivity and causes it to absorb more heat, accelerating the meltout. Climate change threatens to worsen the dust problem as it continues to aridify parts of the West.

Warming is adjusting the dials on all of these factors, and the magnitude of these changes matter, but thereโ€™s yet another crucial dimension: timing. In spring, farmers, water managers and dam operators not only care deeply about the volume of the snowpack that will fill reservoirs, canals, ditches and pipes, but also are keenly interested in when that water will be entering the system. 

โ€œHaving a pulse of snowmelt at the beginning of the growing season has been helpful to farmers and ranchers, and the timing of the snowmelt has been something that ecosystems have evolved to adapt to,โ€ Payton said. โ€œThe timing is going to be shifting dramatically.โ€

Warming has already taken a toll on the Westโ€™s snowpack

While much of NCA5 focuses on the future, the report also looks back at how climate change has already transformed the nation. The graphic below depicts how the Westโ€™s snowpack has shifted in recent decades, with red circles indicating declines, blue circles showing increases and the circle scaled to the size of the change. 

The figureโ€™s title says it all: โ€œWestern snowpack is declining, peak snowpack is occurring earlier, and the snowpack season is shortening in length.โ€

Map โ€œaโ€ shows changes in the volume of the snowpack on April 1, a key date for water managers as they plan for the runoff season. About 93% of sites have experienced a decrease in April 1 snowpack since the 1950s, with the decline averaging about 23%. Map โ€œbโ€ concerns the timing of the snowpackโ€™s peak, which has come nearly eight days earlier on average since 1982. Map โ€œcโ€ presents data on the length of the snow season, which has decreased by 18 days on average over the last four decades. (For more on these maps, including the underlying data, see this page from the Environmental Protection Agency.)

While the vast majority of circles in the figure are red, there are also some blue locations, such as in north-central Colorado. When I asked NCA5 co-authors about those sites, several noted that many of them lie at higher elevationsโ€”like those along the Continental Divide in Coloradoโ€”and the naturally colder conditions there can help preserve their snowpack in a warming world, up to a point. 

โ€œThere are some parts of Alaska or some very high elevations that might have more snow when the snowpack is at its largest,โ€ McAfee said. โ€œTheyโ€™re starting out really cold, so if it warms up some, itโ€™s still cold enough to snow. If it warms up enough, then thereโ€™s the possibility for snow melting earlier or more of those storms bringing rain than snow.โ€

While some high-elevation locations may see their snowpack increase in coming years, itโ€™s โ€œby and large definitely not enough to compensate or offset the widespread losses in snow that are occurring everywhere else,โ€ said co-author Justin Pflug, a scientist at the University of Maryland and NASA Goddard Space Flight Center.

How much warmer it gets will be crucial for the snowpack (and much else)

One of the challenges in producing a report like NCA5 is the uncertainty surrounding future greenhouse gas emissions. Innovation, geopolitics, consumer preferences and more make it hard to predict how rapidly the economy will decarbonize. As a result, scientists must use varying emissions scenarios, and it remains to be seen just how much temperatures will rise at a global level.

While the rate of future warming is uncertain, one thing thatโ€™s clear is that some parts of the planet will warm more than others and have already experienced much steeper temperature increases. 

The graphic below, which maps the projected change in temperatures at various levels of global warming, shows that the effects are expected to be uneven across the United States. For example, at 2ยฐC of global warming, parts of the Interior West would be more than 5ยฐC warmer. Across the globe, researchers have found โ€œgrowing evidence that the rate of warming is amplified with elevation,โ€ according to a 2015 paper in Nature Climate Change.

Locations in Alaska would be even hotter than that, mirroring a global trend of much more rapid warming in the Arctic. A 2022 study in Communications Earth & Environment is titled โ€œThe Arctic has warmed nearly four times faster than the globe since 1979.โ€

โ€œOne of the key messages for us in the water chapter is that temperature really matters for water,โ€ McAfee said. โ€œTemperature influences whether or not we get rain or snow. It influences when the snowpack melts. It influences how big a sip the atmosphere takes from the water and all of that. So we canโ€™t think about precipitation and we canโ€™t think about our water systems separate from temperature.โ€

When people hear about droughts and water shortages, they naturally think of a lack of precipitation, which remains the primary driver of such dry times. But as NCA5 notes, โ€œhigher temperatures can cause drought to develop or become more intense than would be expected from precipitation deficits alone.โ€

In a โ€œhot drought,โ€ the atmosphere demands more moisture and desiccates the landscape. Warmer temperatures also contribute to โ€œsnow droughtsโ€ (discussed below), โ€œflash droughtsโ€ that develop in a matter of weeks and โ€œmegadroughtsโ€ that can extend over decades. 

NCA5 also emphasizes two other messages related to temperature: the degree of change matters greatly, and how hot the planet gets depends on the choices society makes now. [ed. emphasis mine]

โ€œThe more the planet warms, the greater the impactsโ€”and the greater the risk of unforeseen consequences,โ€ according to the report. โ€œWhile there are still uncertainties about how the planet will react to rapid warming and catastrophic future scenarios that cannot be ruled out, the future is largely in human hands.โ€

Climate change is projected to increase global precipitation, but not necessarily in the Southwest

Scientists and their models can paint a much clearer picture of how temperatures will change compared to the projections for precipitation. That said, global warming is expected to increase overall precipitation on the planet because there will be higher evaporation rates and warmer air can hold more moisture. 

The figure below shows projected changes in annual precipitation according to four different levels of warming, with greens indicating increases and browns depicting decreases. The hatching shows areas where 80% or more of the models agree on whether precipitation will increase or decrease. 

Most of the country is expected to see more precipitation overall, with higher levels of warming generally leading to wetter conditions and more certainty about those changes. But in all of the maps, precipitation is expected to decrease in Southern California, much of Arizona, New Mexico and Texas, plus portions of Colorado.

โ€œPrecipitation changes also scale with global warming, but these projections vary by location and are less certain than temperature changes,โ€ according to NCA5. 

Payton said โ€œthereโ€™s not a very strong signalโ€ for total precipitation changes for the Southwest. โ€œThe atmosphere can hold more moisture when itโ€™s warmer,โ€ she said, โ€œbut that moisture has to come from somewhere, so over the Southwest, where itโ€™s already dry, is it going to be able to suck up that additional amount of moisture that it can hold?โ€

While precipitation projections are cloudier, Westerners should expect a shift from snowflakes toward raindrops in many parts of the region: โ€œit is virtually certain that less precipitation will fall as snow, leading to large reductions in mountain snowpack and decreases in spring runoff in the mountain West,โ€ according to NCA5.

Overall, NCA5 concludes that โ€œchanges in future precipitation and temperature are expected to exacerbate drought across large portions of the US,โ€ with projections showing โ€œthe strongest drying signal occurring in the Southwest.โ€

While drought and water scarcity are dominant themes in more arid parts of the West, these areas also contend with floods that can turn dry washes into raging torrents in a flash and threaten both lives and property.

โ€œWarmer air is thirstier air, and that really raises the risk of higher-severity precipitation events,โ€ Pflug said. 

Flooding can also be caused by snowmelt, especially in years with a big snowpack, rapid thawing in spring or when it rains on top of snow. 

โ€œDue to climate change, snowmelt-driven flooding is expected to occur earlier in the year due to earlier runoff,โ€ the report said. โ€œMoreover, atmospheric rivers, which have driven much of historical flooding in the region, are expected to intensify under a warming climate.โ€ 

The graphic below shows the importance of atmospheric rivers to extreme precipitation in the Pacific Northwest, especially in winter (see my previous post for more on climate change and atmospheric rivers).

The Westโ€™s snowpack will store less water and runoff will change

The maps below depict how warming temperatures and changing precipitation patterns are expected to influence three crucial variables in the Southwestโ€™s water cycle, with the top row of maps showing projections for 2036-2065 and the bottom row showing 2070 to 2099, both relative to the 1991-2020 period.

The leftmost maps show projected changes in soil moisture, a critical factor for agriculture and a host of ecological processes. While drier soils are expected in many parts of the Southwest, and especially in portions of the Four Corners states, other areas are expected to see increases in soil moisture.

The center maps depict projected changes in the maximum volume of snow water equivalent, a measure of the snowpackโ€™s water content. Whereas the soil moisture picture is somewhat muddled, the story for snow is crystal clear: steep declines throughout the region, and especially in Californiaโ€™s mountains. 

The rightmost maps show expected changes to runoffโ€”the water that reaches streams, rivers, lakes, reservoirs and taps. As with soil moisture, the projections vary by location but many of the highest-elevation areas, such as the Sierra Nevada, the Southern Rockies and Utahโ€™s Wasatch Range, are expected to see decreases in runoff.

The reportโ€™s co-authors stressed that the interactions between soil moisture, snowpack and runoff are complicated, and there is still considerable uncertainty about future precipitation patterns. With soil moisture, for instance, earlier snowmelt may lead to wetter conditions in spring but drier conditions later in the summer.  

Because the changes will vary across the country, people should โ€œlook at results and data and projections for their own region and not necessarily take a message from elsewhere and assume thatโ€™s whatโ€™s happening where they live,โ€ McAfee said. โ€œClimate change will have different impacts in different places. So the fact that we might be concerned about reduced water supplies in the Colorado River doesnโ€™t necessarily mean we have the same concerns in every river basin.โ€

In the Colorado River Basin, research has shown that โ€œless snow means more evaporation, and this is because snow is really reflective,โ€ McAfee said. โ€œAnyone whoโ€™s ever been out skiing knows this: you can get that reflection up and the nose and chin sunburn, and if the snowpack melts early, the land gets more energy, which makes it possible to evaporate more water from the soils and streams and for the plants to get going earlier.โ€

One challenge for scientists and water managers is that itโ€™s tough to calculate how much snow is out there. Snow accumulation can vary dramatically on a single run at a ski resort, not only from top to bottom due to thousands of feet of elevation difference, but even from one side of the run to the other due to trees, shading, rocks and wind.  

Another vexing problem is tracing what happens to all those H20 molecules after theyโ€™ve fallen to earth. 

โ€œThereโ€™s still some uncertainties about where the snow is going hydrologically,โ€ Pflug said. 

In recent years, peak snowpack levels in the Rockies that were around normal have translated into below-average streamflows. Some scientists have pointed to deficits in soil moisture as the culprit for the disparity. Others are researching how warming temperatures are impacting sublimation, when snow converts directly into water vapor. A 2023 paper from Colorado State University scientists argued that spring and summer precipitation was important for explaining the discrepancy between snowpack levels and subsequent runoff. 

Hereโ€™s how NCA5 sums up the situation for the Colorado River, which supplies some 40 million people in seven U.S. states and Mexico while also irrigating millions of acres of crops:

โ€œColorado River streamflow over the period 2000โ€“2014 was 19% lower than the 20th-century average, largely due to a reduction in snowfall, less reflected sunlight, and increased evaporation. The period 2000โ€“2021 in the Southwest had the driest soil moisture of any period of the same length in at least the past 1,200 years. While this drought is partially linked to natural climate variability, there is evidence that climate change exacerbated it, because warmer temperatures increase atmospheric โ€˜thirstโ€™ and dry the soil. Droughts in the region are lasting longer and reflect not a temporary extreme event but a long-term aridification trendโ€”a drier โ€˜new normalโ€™ occasionally punctuated by periods of extreme wetness consistent with expected increases in precipitation volatility in a warming world.โ€

Some rural and Indigenous communities are especially vulnerable to the changing water cycle

The consequences of a thinner, less reliable snowpack and changing runoff patterns will be far-reaching, but they will be especially problematic for some rural communities dependent on farming and snow-related recreation. 

The infographic below illustrates some of the downstream effects on agriculture, with snow droughts contributing to the stresses facing the sector and its workers. Reduced snowmelt for irrigation may cause farmers to lose money, generate more dust that harms both farmworkers and the snowpack, and lead to increasing use of dwindling underground aquifers as agriculture shifts from surface water to groundwater.

While the graphic above focuses on agriculture, climate change will also affect the water supply for cities, suburbs and businesses, plus the innumerable species that have evolved to depend on the snowpack and snowmelt. 

Farmers who rely on direct flows from the river may have very senior water rights, but often they lack reservoirs to store the water, so as climate change shifts precipitation from snow to rain and starts the runoff season earlier, these water usersโ€”plus fish and other wildlifeโ€”face a growing risk of shortages later in the year. 

โ€œFor communities that have storage rights, theyโ€™re less sensitive to the loss of snowpack if you still are getting precipitation in some form or another,โ€ Payton said. โ€œThere are a lot of people and communities in the West who are just living on the edge, and they donโ€™t have the storage, they donโ€™t have the infrastructure to take advantage of when itโ€™s there and are very much dependent on the regime that theyโ€™ve been used to.โ€

NCA5 highlights that โ€œcommunity-based snow-fed irrigation systems in high-elevation watersheds of New Mexico and Colorado, known as acequias, are particularly exposed to the shortfalls in annual snowpack.โ€

While building more reservoir storage is a potential solution, that strategy has three problems, Harding said. โ€œOne is people donโ€™t like reservoirs, except for the people that are going to benefit and use the water. Two is theyโ€™re really expensive. And three is weโ€™ve used up most of the really good reservoir sites, so that seems unlikely,โ€ he said. 

Even without the influence of climate change, many Indigenous communities in the West confront major hurdles in securing safe and adequate water supplies (see this 2021 paper for more on incomplete plumbing and poor water quality in U.S. homes). 

The map below shows that many American Indian and Alaska Native homes already face serious problems with their water and sewer systems. At deficiency level 2, a water and sanitation system is in place but it needs upgrades or maintenance, while at level 5, the worst category, โ€œthereโ€™s absolutely no water supply, no sanitation system in at all,โ€ said co-author Heather Tanana, a visiting professor of law at the University of California-Irvine, in a webinar.

โ€œAs weโ€™re experiencing increased changes in the water cycle, the water quality and quantity impacts are further being exacerbated in part because of aging infrastructure,โ€ Tanana said. โ€œSo who is being the most affected? Again, itโ€™s our under-resourced frontline communities.โ€ 

There are two types of snow drought to worry about: dry and warm

The report highlights two kinds of โ€œsnow droughtโ€ that can afflict the West (this page offers updates on the current status of snow droughts). In a โ€œdryโ€ snow drought, a lack of precipitation diminishes the snowpack. Thatโ€™s what happened in Californiaโ€™s Sierra Nevada in the 2014/2015 winter, โ€œresulting in the shallowest snow volume ever recorded there,โ€ according to NCA5. 

That same winter, but farther north in Oregon and Washington, there was another snow drought, but this one was a โ€œwarmโ€ one. Winter precipitation was 77% to 113% of normal, yet because of higher temperatures, the precipitation shifted from snow to rain, leading to a reduction in the snowpack and higher winter snowmelt, but below-normal flows from April to August. 

The graphic below illustrates the streamflow for two locations: Washingtonโ€™s Ahtanum Creek and Californiaโ€™s Merced River. In each chart, the black line indicates flows during the 2015 water year (which began October 1, 2014), the gray lines show data from 1952 to 2021 and the dashed line plots the median for that period. The top chart shows that runoff spiked in February and again in March but was then mostly below average during the subsequent warmer months. By contrast, the Merced Riverโ€™s flow was below normal for nearly the entire runoff season. 

โ€œIn Oregon and Washington, irrigated cropsโ€”including valuable orchard cropsโ€”that depend on direct streamflow diversion water rights failed, but municipal water supplies that relied on storage rights that allow reservoirs to capture winter runoff were sufficient,โ€ according to NCA5. โ€œIn California, total water supply was limited, resulting in severe or complete cutbacks to junior water rights and contract holders.โ€ 

The September 2015 photo below from NCA5 shows an apple orchard in the Roza Irrigation District, near Yakima, Washington, suffering the effects of the warm snow drought and reduced irrigation.

Warming will make the landscape โ€œthirstierโ€ in many locations

NCA5โ€™s water chapter discusses a measure known as the โ€œannual climatic water deficit.โ€ In simple language, this metric describes the thirstiness of the landscape. 

โ€œThis is a measure that I advocated for because I think it integrates the effects of everything,โ€ said Harding, who defined the deficit as โ€œhow much water weโ€™d have to add to the system to fully satisfy the needs of the plants.โ€

As shown in the maps below, the climatic water deficit is expected to increase by midcentury across much of the nationโ€”and especially in the Southwest. Map โ€œaโ€ shows the average of the projections, while maps โ€œbโ€ and โ€œcโ€ report the average of the wettest and driest 20% of projections. 

The regionโ€™s increasing dryness threatens to reinforce snow loss by increasing the amount of dust that lands on the snowpack, thereby accelerating its melting. As a result, NCA5 cautions that โ€œunder increasing aridity, agricultural practices such as fallowing and grazing on rangelands will need careful management to avoid increased wind erosion and dust production from exposed soils.โ€

Adding insult to injury, NCA5 warns that those soils will be more susceptible to blowing around because hotter summers will โ€œdegrade protective desert soil crusts formed by communities of algae, bacteria, lichens, fungi, or mosses.โ€ 

Learn more

The Water Deskโ€™s mission is to increase the volume, depth and power of journalism connected to Western water issues. Weโ€™re an editorially independent initiative of the Center for Environmental Journalism at the University of Colorado Boulder.

As states butt heads over #ColoradoRiver plans, water experts gauge impacts to #Colorado — Fresh Water News #COriver #aridification

From left, J.B. Hamby, chair of the Colorado River Board of California, Tom Buschatzke, Arizona Department of Water Resources; Becky Mitchell, Colorado representative to the Upper Colorado River Commission. Hamby and Buschatzke acknowledged during this panel at the Colorado River Water Users Association annual conference that the lower basin must own the structural deficit, something the upper basin has been pushing for for years. CREDIT: TOM YULSMAN/WATER DESK, UNIVERSITY OF COLORADO, BOULDER

Click the link to read the article on the Fresh Water News website (Shannon Mullane):

March 13, 2024

Coloradoโ€™s water and reservoirs are in the thick of disagreements over Colorado River management in a drier future.

All seven Western states in the Colorado River Basin agree that climate change is exacerbating conditions in the basin, and water users need sustainable, predictable water management. They agree that the current rules, which expire in 2026, didnโ€™t do enough to keep reservoirs from dropping to critically low levels. They even agree that water cuts need to happen.

But theyโ€™re at loggerheads over how to share the pain โ€” and have been for years. Now, the Lower Basin officials have proposed a plan calling on all basin users, including Coloradans, to make sacrifices.

โ€œThis is not a problem that is caused by one sector, by one state, by one basin. It is a basinwide problem, and it requires a basinwide solution,โ€ John Entsminger, Nevadaโ€™s top negotiator, said during a news conference March 6.

Basin officials are negotiating Colorado River management in order to create new interstate water sharing rules that will replace the current agreements, which were created in 2007. The overburdened river system provides water to seven Western states, two Mexican states and 30 Native American tribes.

Basin states released competing proposals March 6, outlining their ideas for releasing, storing and cutting back on water use.

The Upper Basin proposal โ€” put forward by Colorado, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming โ€” only includes cuts to the Lower Basinโ€™s water use, although the four states would continue developing voluntary conservation programs.

The Lower Basin alternative โ€” from Arizona, California and Nevada โ€” looks at the amount of water stored in seven federal reservoirs. When that storage falls below 38% of total reservoir capacity, all seven states would conserve water to cut their collective use by 3.9 million acre-feet. One acre-foot roughly equals the annual water use of two to three households.

Thatโ€™s a no-go for Upper Basin states, where water supply fluctuates yearly because it primarily relies on mountain snowpack. In 2020, a particularly dry year, the Upper Basin used 4.5 million acre-feet โ€” much less than its legal allotment of 7.5 million acre-feet. In 2021, another drought year, the states had to cut back further.

Thatโ€™s without any additional water cuts, like those proposed by the Lower Basin.

โ€œWhen weโ€™re looking at those years, like 2021 when our uses in the Upper Basin were at 3.5 million acre-feet, that represents almost a 25% cut,โ€ Commissioner Becky Mitchell, Coloradoโ€™s top negotiator, said. โ€œTo cut further in a year like that could wreck communities and economies.โ€

Coloradoโ€™s role in the Upper Basin plan

The Upper Basin proposal calls for few changes in the upstream states.

The Upper Basin would keep taking steps to ensure Lake Powell, located on the Utah-Arizona border, could make its required releases downstream, and to reduce Upper Basin water use through voluntary, temporary and compensated cuts, like the system conservation pilot program.

The rest of the proposal is meant to offer guidance to the Lower Basin, Mitchell said.

In the past, officials have changed how water is stored and released at lakes Mead and Powell based on the reservoirsโ€™ elevations. The Upper Basin plan links operations more closely to each yearโ€™s available water storage, a high priority for Colorado officials.

In years when Lake Powell is less than 20% full, the Upper Basin states suggested releasing as little as 6 million acre-feet of water downstream. Upper Basin states are legally obligated to let at least 7.5 million acre-feet flow to Lower Basin states (plus some for Mexico) annually, as averaged over a rolling 10-year period.

If reservoir storage dropped to certain trigger levels, Lower Basin states would also cut up to 3.9 million acre-feet in a year.

The approach is designed to replenish depleted water storage in reservoirs, like Mead and Powell. These two enormous reservoirs โ€” which function like savings banks for water users โ€” drained to a third of their volume in the early 2020s, prompting a crisis response among officials and ramping up concerns about water availability in the future.

It would also protect Lake Powellโ€™s ability to release water downstream according to water law, Mitchell said.

โ€œThat protects Colorado users. That protects all the Upper Basin statesโ€™ users,โ€ Mitchell said. โ€œThe rebuilt storage protects all 40 million people โ€” thatโ€™s the way that we protect all 40 million is to have a safety net.โ€

A call for widespread cuts

The Lower Basin officials say that the entire Colorado River Basin โ€” including Colorado and the other Upper Basin states โ€” must cut water use.

In their proposal, Lower Basin officials said they would take responsibility for the structural deficit, which refers to water losses from factors like evaporation, by cutting back on their water use by 1.5 million acre-feet in some years.

Credit: Upper Colorado River Commisstion

In years when the total storage in the system drops below 38%, the Lower Basin says the Upper Basin states need to help out so the basin as a whole can cut 3.9 million acre-feet.

If this plan had been in place since 1971, the states would have started taking cuts around 2000. For most of the past 24 years, the Lower Basin would have taken annual cuts of 1.5 million acre-feet. The Upper Basin would only have faced shortages in 2020 and 2021, according to Lower Basin officials.

โ€œItโ€™s very easy to craft an alternative that doesnโ€™t require any sacrifice, but thatโ€™s not what the Lower Basin alternative does,โ€ said JB Hamby, Californiaโ€™s top negotiator, during a March 6 news conference. โ€œThe Lower Basin is home to three-quarters of the Colorado River Basinโ€™s population, most of the basinโ€™s tribes, and the most productive farmland in the country. Our proposal requires adaptation and sacrifice by water users across the region.โ€

What would the Lower Basin option mean for Colorado?

Officials have released written plans, but it will take modeling out many different water supply scenarios to understand the impacts of each proposal, according to water experts.

But under the Lower Basin plan, Colorado could be on the hook for cutting its use by hundreds of thousands of acre-feet, said Colorado water expert Eric Kuhn.

In one hypothetical low-storage scenario, the Lower Basin would cut its use by 1.5 million acre-feet, then the two basins would each conserve an additional 1.2 million acre-feet, Kuhn said.

If Colorado took on a third of the Upper Basinโ€™s obligation โ€” and this is a big โ€œifโ€ โ€” it would mean cutting water use by nearly 400,000 acre-feet.

โ€œIf Colorado ever agreed to absorb a certain percentage of the final โ€ฆ cuts, itโ€™ll have a big impact on the state,โ€ Kuhn said. โ€œItโ€™s not theoretical; it would be quite significant.โ€

For reference, all of the cities, towns and industries in Colorado use a combined total of about 380,000 acre-feet per year from multiple water sources, including the Colorado River, according to the 2023 Colorado Water Plan.

Mandated cuts could even send states into litigation, which is the worst outcome, said one Colorado official. Once the issue moves to the courts, state officials canโ€™t talk to each other, and their future could be in the hands of U.S. Supreme Court justices who may not have expertise in the complex realm of Western water law.

โ€œWeโ€™ll talk 1-to-1 cuts when theyโ€™re down to 4.5 million acre-feet,โ€ said Steve Wolff, general manager of the Durango-based Southwestern Water Conservation District, referring to the average amount of water used by Upper Basin states. โ€œWhen youโ€™re still using twice as much as us, why should we agree to a 1-to-1 cut?โ€

Peter Ortego, general counsel for the Ute Mountain Ute Indian Tribe, said basin tribes that have made agreements to share in future shortages could be impacted. Most tribal nations have senior water rights, which get water first in dry years and should be protected from most water cuts, he said.

Environmental groups say more needs to be done to protect rivers and freshwater resources, which provide vital habitat for wildlife in the arid West.

In recent, very dry years, Colorado trout fisheries, like the Yampa River, have been shut down because of low flows and warmer water temperatures in mid-to-late summer. If modeling shows that federal or state plans would leave less water in the rivers, that would be concerning, said Jennifer Pitt, Colorado River Program director for the National Audubon Society.

Going forward, Pitt and other water experts will be watching for updates from the Bureau of Reclamationโ€™s analysis. Thatโ€™s when theyโ€™ll know more about possible impacts to Colorado.

Until then, Coloradans need to keep one thing in mind, Pitt said.

โ€œThis is not Colorado against the rest of the West. This is Colorado, part of a river basin that is shared,โ€ she said. โ€œAll those parties need each other to get through some challenging conditions in the future.โ€

Map credit: AGU

Factcheck: How electric vehicles help to tackle #ClimateChange — Carbon Brief

Coyote Gulch’s shiny new Leaf May 13, 2023

Click the link to read the article on the Carbon Brief website (Zeke Hausfather):

Electric vehicles (EVs) are an important part of meeting global goals on climate change. They feature prominently in mitigation pathways that limit warming to well-below 2C or 1.5C, which would be inline with the Paris Agreementโ€™s targets.

However, while no greenhouse gas emissions directly come from EVs, they run on electricity that is, in large part, still produced from fossil fuels in many parts of the world. Energy is also used to manufacture the vehicle โ€“ and, in particular, the battery.

Here, in response to recent misleading media reports on the topic, Carbon Brief provides a detailed look at the climate impacts of EVs. In this analysis, Carbon Brief finds:

  • EVs are responsible for considerably lower emissions over their lifetime than conventional (internal combustion engine) vehicles across Europe as a whole.
  • In countries with coal-intensive electricity generation, the benefits of EVs are smaller and they can have similar lifetime emissions to the most efficient conventional vehicles โ€“ such as hybrid-electric models.
  • However, as countries decarbonise electricity generation to meet their climate targets, driving emissions will fall for existing EVs and manufacturing emissions will fall for new EVs.
  • ย In the UK in 2019, the lifetime emissions per kilometre of driving a Nissan Leaf EV were about three times lower than for the average conventional car, even before accounting for the falling carbon intensity of electricity generation during the carโ€™s lifetime.
  • Comparisons between electric vehicles and conventional vehicles are complex. They depend on the size of the vehicles, the accuracy of the fuel-economy estimates used, how electricity emissions are calculated, what driving patterns are assumed, and even the weather in regions where the vehicles are used. There is no single estimate that applies everywhere.

There are also large uncertainties around the emissions associated with electric vehicle battery production, with different studies producing widely differing numbers. As battery prices fall and vehicle manufacturers start including larger batteries with longer driving ranges, battery production emissions can have a larger impact on the climate benefits of electric vehicles.

Around half of the emissions from battery production come from the electricity used in manufacturing and assembling the batteries. Producing batteries in regions with relatively low-carbon electricity or in factories powered by renewable energy, as will be the case for the batteries used in the best-selling Tesla Model 3, can substantially reduce battery emissions.

Different studies find different results

A recent working paper from a group of German researchers at the thinktank Institute for Economic Research (ifo) found that โ€œelectric vehicles will barely help cut CO2 emissions in Germany over the coming yearsโ€. It suggests that, in Germany, โ€œthe CO2 emissions of battery-electric vehicles are, in the best case, slightly higher than those of a diesel engineโ€.

This study wasย pickedย upย in the international media, with the Wall Street Journal running an editorial titled, โ€œGermanyโ€™s dirty green carsโ€. It also engendered pushback from electric vehicle advocates, with articles inย Jalopnikย andย Autoblog, as well asย individual researchersย rebutting the claim.

There are also large uncertainties around the emissions associated with electric vehicle battery production, with different studies producing widely differing numbers. As battery prices fall and vehicle manufacturers start including larger batteries with longer driving ranges, battery production emissions can have a larger impact on the climate benefits of electric vehicles.

Around half of the emissions from battery production come from the electricity used in manufacturing and assembling the batteries. Producing batteries in regions with relatively low-carbon electricity or in factories powered by renewable energy, as will be the case for the batteries used in the best-selling Tesla Model 3, can substantially reduce battery emissions.

Federal court overturns Obama-era #coal leasing moratorium — @WyoFile #ActOnClimate

Arch Resources’ Black Thunder mine in southern Campbell County. (EcoFlight)

Click the link to read the article on the WyoFile website (Dustin Bleizeffer):

February 22, 2024

A federal appeals court has overturned an Obama-era moratorium for new coal mine leasing on public lands โ€” an โ€œunequivocal winโ€ for Wyomingโ€™s coal industry, according to Gov. Mark Gordon. Yet theย decision, which the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals handed down on Wednesday, likely will not result in a rush on new federal coal leases in Wyoming.

The three-judge panel even noted an apparent โ€œde facto moratoriumโ€ dictated by markets that has all but erased demand for major new federal coal tracts โ€” a trend that particularly applies to Wyoming coal, which has lost nearly half its market among coal-burning electric power producers in the U.S over the past 15 years.

Nonetheless, the courtโ€™s ruling does away with โ€œduplicativeโ€ environmental analysis introduced by the Obama moratorium and is a clear charge to the Department of Interior that it must be responsive to federal coal lease requests, according to Gordon.

โ€œThe Department of Interior now has one less excuse to thwart its federal coal leasing responsibilities,โ€ he said in a prepared statement Wednesday.

Volley among administrations

In 2016, then-President Barack Obama directed the Interior and Bureau of Land Management to issue a moratorium on federal coal leasing and conduct a review of the program to better account for a fair rate of return to taxpayers, as well as coalโ€™s impact on human health and the environment.

A coal train rolls out of Gillette in 2016. (Andrew Graham/WyoFile)

But then the Trump administration rescinded the order before the federal agencies completed the work. The conflicting administrative policies set off a series of legal volleys and prompted Wyoming to join the battle in support of the Trump administrationโ€™s actions on the matter.

The appellate court ruling this week nullifies a 2022 federal district court ruling that temporarily reinstated the original moratorium.

โ€œWith this ruling, important projects can once again advance and support the production of affordable, reliable power to the grid, while creating jobs and economic development across the country, helping federal, state and localities with necessary funding by contributing hundreds of millions each year in revenues to state and local governments,โ€ National Mining Association President and CEO Rich Nolan said in a prepared statement.

However, the Northern Cheyenne Tribe and several conservation groups that brought the lawsuit say the Biden administration can still take meaningful action regarding federal coal reserves.

A coal haul truck at Peabody Energyโ€™s North Antelope Rochelle mine heads to the pit for another load in July 2019. (Alan Nash/WyoFile)

โ€œAlmost 10 years ago under President Obama, we were promised there would be an honest conversation with the American people about the real costs of the federal coal program on our public lands and public health. Weโ€™re still waiting for that conversation,โ€ Wyoming Sierra Club Acting Director Rob Joyce said. โ€œNow we have less than a decade to make significant cuts to climate pollution to avoid the worst impacts of climate change. Instead of leasing coal to the highest corporate bidder, BLM needs to focus on helping coal communities transition to clean energy jobs and setting a conservation-minded course that preserves public lands for future generations.โ€

Dwindling demand

Wyoming became the nationโ€™s largest coal producer in the 1980s, and at its peak, in 2008, produced 466 million tons. The annual volume of coal thatโ€™s shipped out of state has fallen by nearly half since then. 

Powder River Basin mines, which account for the bulk of Wyomingโ€™s coal production, shipped about 230.4 million tons in 2023 โ€” a decline of 7 million tons compared to 2022, according to the Gillette News-Record. 

Demand for new federal coal tracts has followed suit.

The most recent large federal coal leases sold in the Powder River Basin went to Peabody Energy and Arch Coal (now Arch Resources) in 2012. Peabody paid $1.24 billion for the rights to mine 1.12 billion tons of coal to extend operations at its North Antelope Rochelle mine,ย according to the BLM. Arch paid more than $300 million for 222.67 million tons of federal coal for its flagship Black Thunder mine.

All told, some 2.5 billion tons of federal coal reserves were leased in the Powder River Basin during the first seven years of the Obama administration prior to the coal leasing moratorium in 2016.

Since then, coal producers in Wyoming โ€” responding to softening market demand โ€” have pulled back on earlier plans to acquire large tracts of federal coal to last them decades into the future. Aside from leasing small โ€œmaintenanceโ€ coal tracts at existing mining operations โ€” which was allowed to continue under the Obama moratorium โ€” there are just two pending lease applications for major new federal coal tracts in Wyoming, according to the BLM.

Cloud Peak Energy applied for a 441 million-ton federal coal lease in 2015, but the company filed for bankruptcy in 2019. Its Powder River Basin mines were acquired by Navajo Transitional Energy Company LLC, which still maintains the lease application. NTEC, however, has scaled back production at the mines.

A subsidiary of Arch applied for a 468 million-ton federal coal tract in 2005, a request that was not subject to the moratorium. However, Arch has also scaled back its mining operations in Wyoming andย plans to sell or close its mines in the state.

Mauna Loa is WMO Global Atmosphere Watch benchmark station and monitors rising CO2 levels Week of 23 April 2023: 424.40 parts per million Weekly value one year ago: 420.19 ppm Weekly value 10 years ago: 399.32 ppm ๐Ÿ“ท http://CO2.Earthhttps://co2.earth/daily-co2. Credit: World Meteorological Organization

Changing #Climate Behind Sharp Drop in #Snowpack Since 1980s: Study finds steepest drops in areas of the Northern Hemisphere reliant on snow for water — NOAA #ActOnClimate

Click the link to read the article on the NOAA website (Morgan Kelly):

January 24, 2024

Read the study

Scientific data from ground observations, satellites, and climate models have not agreed on whether climate change is consistently chipping away at the snowpacks that accumulate in high-elevation mountains and provide water when they melt in spring. This complicates efforts to manage the water scarcity that would result for many population centers.

Aย new Dartmouth studyย cuts through the uncertainty in these observations and provides evidence that seasonal snowpacks throughout most of the Northern Hemisphere have indeed shrunk significantly over the past 40 years due to human-driven climate change. The sharpest global warming-related reductions in snowpackโ€”between 10% to 20% per decadeโ€”are in the Southwestern and Northeastern United States, as well as in Central and Eastern Europe.ย The study wasย funded in part by NIDISthrough the NOAA Climate Program Office Modeling, Analysis, Predictions, & Projections (MAPP) program.

The Southwest and Northeast saw the greatest loss in spring snowpack between 1981 and 2020, raising concerns about water scarcity and economies reliant on winter recreation. The numbers at bottom correspond to the percentage of spring snowpack lost (red) or gained (blue) per decade, with losses concentrated in populated regions. Image by Justin Mankin and Alexander Gottlieb.

Dartmouth researchers Alexander Gottlieb and Justin Mankin report in the journal Nature that the extent and speed of this loss potentially puts the hundreds of millions of people in North America, Europe, and Asia who depend on snow for their water on the precipice of a crisis that continued warming will amplify.

โ€œWe were most concerned with how warming is affecting the amount of water stored in snow. The loss of that reservoir is the most immediate and potent risk that climate change poses to society in terms of diminishing snowfall and accumulation,โ€ said Gottlieb.

โ€œOur work identifies the watersheds that have experienced historical snow loss and those that will be most vulnerable to rapid snowpack declines with further warming,โ€ Gottlieb said. โ€œThe train has left the station for regions such as the Southwestern and Northeastern United States. By the end of the 21st century, we expect these places to be close to snow-free by the end of March. Weโ€™re on that path and not particularly well adapted when it comes to water scarcity.โ€

Water security is only one dimension of snow loss, said Mankin, an associate professor of geography and the paperโ€™s senior author.

The Hudson, Susquehanna, Delaware, Connecticut, and Merrimack watersheds in the Northeastern U.S., where water scarcity is not as dire, experienced among the steepest declines in snowpack. But these heavy losses threaten economies in states such as Vermont, New York, and New Hampshire that depend on winter recreation, Mankin syidโ€”even machine-made snow has a temperature threshold, one that many areas are fast approaching.

โ€œThe recreational implications are emblematic of the ways in which global warming disproportionately affects the most vulnerable communities,โ€ he said. โ€œSki resorts at lower elevations and latitudes have already been contending with year-on-year snow loss. This will just accelerate, making the business model inviable.โ€

โ€œWeโ€™ll likely see further consolidation of skiing into large, well-resourced resorts at the expense of small and medium-sized ski areas that have such crucial local economic and cultural values. It will be a loss that will ripple through communities,โ€ Mankin said.

In the study, Gottlieb and Mankin focused on how global warmingโ€™s influence on temperature and precipitation drove changes in snowpack in 169 river basins across the Northern Hemisphere from 1981 through 2020. The loss of snowpacks potentially means less meltwater in spring for rivers, streams, and soils downstream when ecosystems and people demand water.

Gottlieb and Mankin programmed a machine learning model to examine thousands of observations and climate-model experiments that captured snowpack, temperature, precipitation, and runoff data for Northern Hemisphere watersheds.

The researchers identified the uncertainties that the models and observations shared so they could hone in on what scientists previously missed when gauging the effect of climate change on snow. A 2021 study by Gottlieb and Mankin similarly leveraged uncertainties in how scientists measure snow depth and define snow drought to improve predictions of water availability.

โ€œSnow observations are tricky at the regional scales most relevant for assessing water security,โ€ Mankin said. โ€œSnow is very sensitive to within-winter variations in temperature and precipitation, and the risks from snow loss are not the same in New England as in the Southwest, or for a village in the Alps as in high-mountain Asia.โ€

Gottlieb and Mankin found that 80% of the Northern Hemisphereโ€™s snowpacksโ€”which are in its far-northern and high-elevation reachesโ€”experienced minimal losses. Snowpacks actually expanded in vast swaths of Alaska, Canada, and Central Asia as climate change increased the precipitation that falls as snow in these frigid regions.

But it is the remaining 20% of the snowpack that exists aroundโ€”and provides water forโ€”many of the hemisphereโ€™s major population centers that has diminished. Since 1981, documented declines in snowpack for these regions have been largely inconsistent due to the uncertainty in observations and naturally occurring variations in climate.

But Gottlieb and Mankin found that a steady pattern of annual declines in snow accumulation emerge quicklyโ€”and leave population centers suddenly and chronically short on new supplies of water from snowmelt.

Many snow-dependent watersheds now find themselves dangerously near a temperature threshold Gottlieb and Mankin call a โ€œsnow-loss cliff.โ€ This means that as average winter temperatures in a watershed increase beyond 17 degrees Fahrenheit (minus 8 degrees Celsius), snow loss accelerates even with only modest increases in local average temperatures.

Many highly populated watersheds that rely on snow for water supply are going to see accelerating losses over the next few decades, Mankin said.

โ€œIt means that water managers who rely on snowmelt canโ€™t wait for all the observations to agree on snow loss before they prepare for permanent changes to water supplies. By then, itโ€™s too late,โ€ he said. โ€œOnce a basin has fallen off that cliff, itโ€™s no longer about managing a short-term emergency until the next big snow. Instead, they will be adapting to permanent changes to water availability.โ€

Screenshot from the 2024 Climate Change in Colorado report

Article: Significantly wetter or drier future conditions for one to two thirds of the worldโ€™s population — Nature #ActOnClimate

a, b Box-whiskers plots of cumulative change in precipitation regime over a 120-year period across GCMs for selected countries with higher agreement and affected populations. c, d Selected countries ranked by drying and wetting multi-model agreement (vertical lines denote intra-country variability showing the 10th and 90th spatial percentiles). e, f Spatial distribution of drying and wetting multi-model agreement for states. Rectangles on f very high emissions panel focusing on regions with strong intra-country variability are shown in detail on panels for g South America, h North America, i Africa, and Europe. White regions indicate no substantial agreement for drying and wetting. Refer to Figs. S1 and S2 and Supplementary Data for seasonal agreement across all countries and states globally.

Click the link to access the article on the Nature website (Ralph Trancoso,ย Jozef Syktus,ย Richard P. Allan,ย Jacky Croke,ย Ove Hoegh-Guldbergย &ย Robin Chadwick). Here’s the abstract:

Future projections of precipitation are uncertain, hampering effective climate adaptation strategies globally. Our understanding of changes across multiple climate model simulations under a warmer climate is limited by this lack of coherence across models. Here, we address this challenge introducing an approach that detects agreement in drier and wetter conditions by evaluating continuous 120-year time-series with trends, across 146 Global Climate Model (GCM) runs and two elevated greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions scenarios. We show the hotspots of future drier and wetter conditions, including regions already experiencing water scarcity or excess. These patterns are projected to impact a significant portion of the global population, with approximately 3 billion people (38% of the worldโ€™s current population) affected under an intermediate emissions scenario and 5 billion people (66% of the world population) under a high emissions scenario by the centuryโ€™s end (or 35-61% using projections of future population). We undertake a country- and state-level analysis quantifying the population exposed to significant changes in precipitation regimes, offering a robust framework for assessing multiple climate projections.

Wet January helping #snowpack rebound — The #GrandJunction Daily Sentinel

Click the link to read the article on The Grand Junction Daily Sentinel website (Dennis Webb). Here’s an excerpt:

January 17, 2024

The National Weather Service in Boulder reported that from Friday through Monday, many areas in the central and northern mountains got 2 to 3 feet of snow, with some areas getting up to 4 feet, and wind gusts topping 100s mph in a few areas. Powderhorn Mountain Resort on Tuesday was reporting 8 inches over the past 48 hours. That was after it said it got more than 3 feet of snow over six days through last Thursday, including a whopping 24 inches in just 24 hours early last week. As of last week, all lifts and runs are now open at the resort. Vail Resorts is reporting seven-day snow totals at its Colorado ski areas ranging from 29 inches at Keystone Resort to 4 feet at Crested Butte Mountain Resort…Tom Renwick, a forecaster for the National Weather Service in Grand Junction, said the weekend storm produced about 50 inches of snow at Rabbit Ears Pass in the Steamboat Springs area and 51 inches at Green Mountain north of Vail, and much of the central mountain corridor got about 2 feet at higher elevations. In southwest Colorado, accumulations varied from about 4 to 8 inches in the foothills to a foot in higher elevations, he said. He said the Gunnison area had accumulations ranging from a foot to a foot and a half and Grand Mesa got around one foot in areas…

Snowpack in the Colorado River headwaters basin on Tuesday stood at 96% of normal for Jan. 16, with the Yampa/White/Little Snake river basins at 94% and the Gunnison River Basin also at 94%, according to the Natural Resources Conservation Service. The Upper Rio Grande River Basinโ€™s snowpack has increased to 71% of median from just 55% at the start of the month, the combined San Miguel/Dolores/Animas/San Juan basins stood at 84% of normal Tuesday and the Arkansas River Basin was at 85%.

Westwide SNOTEL basin-filled map January 19, 2024 via the NRCS.

The Pagosa Area Water & Sanitation District moves forward with rate study, sets public hearing — The #PasosaSprings Sun #SanJuanRiver #ColoradoRiver #aridification #COriver

Pagosa Springs Panorama. Photo credit: Gmhatfield via Wikimedia Commons

Click the link to read the article on the Pagosa Springs Sun website (Josh Pike). Here’s an excerpt:

PAWSD Business Manager Aaron Burns opened the discussion by ex- plaining that the board gave direction at its Nov. 14 work session for staff to look at other rates and fees beyond the districtโ€™s main water and waste- water rates, and attempt to use these to reduce the increases in water and wastewater rates. He stated that some of the areas discussed were availability fees, rates for waste haulers and rates at water fill stations. He added that staff from Stantec โ€” the company performing the rate study for the district โ€” incorporated the changes into the calculations, which made a โ€œsignificantโ€ differ- ence, particularly in wastewater rate increases.

Zac Koch of Stantec then presented on the rate study, highlighting the changes made from the previous presentation in November. For water rates, Koch explained that the primary change in the study was that, as suggested at the November work session, availability fees will now scale in accordance with the increases in water rates, with the expected decrease in the number of lots remaining the same…[Koch] stated that rate increases would remain at 5 percent annually between 2026 and 2029, with 15 percent increases occurring in 2030 and 2031 to cover the increased expenses for Regulation 35 compliance, and no increase in 2032. According to Kochโ€™s presentation, this would bring the projected monthly residential bill from $32.80 in 2023 to $89.11 in 2032, down from the $103.34 bill in 2032 indicated in the previous presentation…

Following a brief discussion, the board unanimously voted to accept the conclusions of the rate study and to set a public hearing on the rates for Jan. 25, 2024, at 5 p.m. at the PAWSD administrative offices at 100 Lyn Ave.

The San Juan Water Conservancy District Conservancy discusses next steps on reservoir — The #PagosaSprings Sun #SanJuanRiver #ColoradoRiver #COriver #aridification

View to the south into the snaking West Fork of the San Juan River as seen from US 160, halfway up to the summit of Wolf Creek Pass. By User:Erikvoss, CC BY-SA 3.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=61976794

Click the link to read the article on The Pagosa Springs Sun website (Josh Pike). Here’s an excerpt:

At a Nov. 16 meeting, the San Juan Water Conservancy District (SJWCD) Board of Directors discussed a report from Ehat Consulting and next steps on the districtโ€™s reservoir project. SJWCD board president Al Pfister opened the discussion, noting that the board previously discussed se- curing a grant from the Southwest Basin Roundtable to fund a project coordinator for the reservoir project, though SJWCD grant writer Renee Lewis subsequently advised the board that the roundtable does not typically fund staff and conversations with roundtable staff indicated that โ€œitโ€™s a very gray areaโ€ on whether the grant would be successful.

Pfister added that the effort to secure funding for the coordinator is โ€œongoingโ€ and that he also wanted to propose to the board hiring a contractor in 2024 to locate land for a land exchange with the U.S. Forest Service (USFS) to secure all the land necessary for the proposed reservoir. He added that he believes the board is making progress and that the SJWCDโ€™s volunteer board members should not be expected to oversee the entirety of the reservoir project without assistance.

First Water Flows Through #ColoradoRiver Connectivity Channel — @Northern_Water #COriver #aridification

Restoring a river channel in the Upper Colorado Basin. Graphic credit: Northern Water

Click the link to read the article on the Northern Colorado Water Conservancy District website:

November 7, 2023: In whatโ€™s been described as โ€œthe largest aquatic habitat connectivity project ever undertaken in state history,โ€ crews successfully tested the new Colorado River Connectivity Channel (CRCC) at the end of October. The new channel around Windy Gap Reservoir hydrologically and ecologically now reconnects two segments of the Colorado River for the first time in approximately 40 years. ย 

Northern Water staff were joined by Grand County officials, Windy Gap Project Participant Representatives, Colorado Parks and Wildlife representatives and others to watch the first flows go through the long-awaited channel. This new video captures the historic day and includes comments from the project participants and stakeholders who were present to witness the occasion.    

While water is now running through the new channel, there is still construction work to be done. Crews will continue putting the finishing touches on the project’s new dam embankment, diversion structure and other elements before winter weather brings activity to a stop in the upcoming weeks. Construction is expected to resume

next spring and wrap up later in 2024. Vegetation establishment along the channel will continue into 2025 and 2026, before the area is anticipated to open for public recreation in 2027.  

The new channel will enable fish and other wildlife to move freely upstream and downstream around what is now a smaller Windy Gap Reservoir. Meanwhile, the reservoir will continue providing a diversion point on the Colorado River for the Windy Gap Project during the high flows of spring and early summer.  

The CRCC is part of a package of environmental measures, valued at $90 million, associated with construction of Chimney Hollow Reservoir, which is ultimately where Windy Gap Project water will be stored once reservoir construction is completed.   

USDA Announces Availability of Nearly $50 million to strengthen forest products economy, forest sector jobs as part of Investing in America agenda

Trees marked for forest health initiative above James Creek in Jamestown, Colorado. Credit: Jerd Smith

Click the link to read the article on the USDA website:

WASHINGTON,October 18, 2023 –

Today, the Biden-Harris Administration announced the U.S. Department of Agricultureโ€™s Forest Service is making nearly $50 million in grant funding available for proposals that support crucial links between resilient, healthy forests, strong rural economies and jobs in the forestry sector. Made possible by President Bidenโ€™s Investing in America agenda, a key pillar of Bidenomics, this funding will spark innovation, create new markets for wood products and renewable wood energy, expand processing capacity, and help tackle the climate crisis.

โ€œA strong forest products economy contributes to healthier forests, vibrant communities and jobs in rural areas,โ€ said Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack. โ€œThanks to President Bidenโ€™s Investing in America agenda, we are investing in rural economies by growing markets for forest products through sustainable forest management while reducing wildfire risk, fighting climate change, and accelerating economic development.โ€

This announcement is part of President Biden’s Investing in America agenda to generate economic opportunity and build a clean energy economy nationwide. The grants are made possible by President Bidenโ€™s Inflation Reduction Act, the largest climate investment in history and a core pillar of Bidenomics, as well as President Bidenโ€™s Bipartisan Infrastructure Law, an historic investment to rebuild Americaโ€™s aging infrastructure.

The open funding opportunity comes through the Forest Serviceโ€™s three key grant programs to support the forest products economy: Wood Innovations Grant, Community Wood Grant, and Wood Products Infrastructure Assistance Grant Programs. The agency is seeking proposals that support innovative uses of wood in the construction of low carbon buildings, as a renewable energy source, and in manufacturing and processing products. These programs also provide direct support to expand and retrofit wood energy systems and wood products manufacturing facilities nationwide.

The Forest Service is requesting proposals from eligible entities in the private, non-profit, and government sectors including Tribes, local and state governments, businesses and for-profit entities, institutions of higher education, as well as public utility, fire, conservation, and school districts, among others.

These investments will support forest management projects to improve forest health and reduce wildfire risk across all land ownerships. Byproducts of these activities, like small diameter timber and woody biomass, have historically been of little market value. Thanks in part to these Forest Service grant programs, funding is available to support the use of this often-unused material in many types of wood products.

Businesses that are engaged in or support the forest products economy are eligible to apply for funding to expand manufacturing capacity. These businesses are vital employers in local communities, especially in tribal or rural communities.

The investments will also support the Forest Serviceโ€™s 10-year strategy to address the wildfire crisis in the places where it poses the most immediate threats to communities. The agency is investing in projects that source wood from activities that reduce risks to communities, like prescribed fire and mechanical thinning to reduce the vegetation that fuels wildfires.

Visit the Forest Service webpage for more information on funding for the Wood Innovations, Community Wood and Wood Products Infrastructure Assistance Grant Programs. 

Will #Colorado Fill the Gaps in the post-Sackett World? — Getches-Wilkinson Center (Andrew Teegarden)

Photo credit from report “A Preliminary Evaluation of Seasonal Water Levels Necessary to Sustain Mount Emmons Fen: Grand Mesa, Uncompahgre and Gunnison National Forests,” David J. Cooper, Ph.D, December 2003.

Click the link to read the article on the Getches Wilkinson Center website (Andrew Teegarden):

Introduction

Andre Teegarden. Photo credit: Getches-Wilkinson Center

The Supreme Courtโ€™s decision in theย Sackettย caseย earlier this year dramatically altered the regulatory framework for wetlands, ephemeral waters, and intermittent streams in the United States. Now, there is a two-step process in determining whether a water is subject to the Army Corps of Engineers (Corps) jurisdiction. First, find if there is a Water of the United States (WOTUS) that is a โ€œrelatively permanent body of water connected to a traditional interstate navigable waterโ€. Second, if a WOTUS is present, then the Corps must analyze whether the wetland at issue has a continuous surface connection to the WOTUS to the extent that they are indistinguishable from one another. This change to how WOTUS is interpreted will leave many wetlands and other waters unprotected from the impacts of dredge and fill operations. Colorado estimates that 54 percent of watershed areas within the state are affected by this ruling.1

States across the country, including Colorado, will now have to step up and fill the regulatory gap created by Sackett. They will have to decide whether and how to protect the watersheds within their borders that no longer fall within the jurisdiction of the Clean Water Act. And while the legal status of those gap waters may have changed because of Sackett, their vital role in ecological protection, agriculture, and recreation has not. This work is urgent. Before we know how to deal with these impacts here in Colorado, we need to understand where the law currently stands and what the state is doing to deal with this regulatory gap.

I. Before Sackett, Coloradoโ€™s wetlands were regulated at the federal level.

In Colorado, the Corps issues permits for dredging and filling of Waters of the United States (WOTUS) under section 404 of the Clean Water Act. The process requires individuals to apply to the Corps for a permit, and the Corps then determines if the water or wetland is subject to their jurisdiction, and in turn, if a permit for dredging or filling is required. Before Sackett, this permitting program applied across the state of Colorado to all waters considered to be within the Corpsโ€™ jurisdiction under the federal Clean Water Act.

In reviewing applications for permits, the Corps must apply criteria established by the EPA known as the Section 404(b)(1) guidelines.2 The โ€œguidelinesโ€ are binding on the Corps and include the following requirements:

  • There is no practicable alternative that would have โ€œless adverse impact on the aquatic ecosystem;โ€
  • There is no violation of water quality standards or toxic effluent standards;
  • The discharge would not jeopardize a listed species or result in the destruction of adverse modification of critical habitat;
  • The discharge would not cause or contribute to significant degradation of the waters of the United States; and
  • The project must include โ€œappropriate and practicable stepsโ€ that โ€œwill minimize potential adverse impacts of the discharge on the aquatic ecosystem.โ€

The Corps also conducts a public interest review based on a range of factors and only issues a permit after weighing the proposed impacts against the potential benefits of the proposed activity.3 In addition, the Corps must comply with other federal requirements, including environmental review under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), Section 7 consultation under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), identification and consideration of cultural resources under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), as well as consulting with affected Tribes during the permitting process.

Following Sackett, these substantive and procedural protections no longer apply to the โ€œgap watersโ€ that fall outside the jurisdiction of the Corps under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act. The state program that is designed to fill the โ€œgapโ€ should be built upon a robust framework that addresses these key components of the Section 404 program.

II. The current law in Colorado is inadequate to fill the gap left by Sackett.

Currently in Colorado, the Water Quality Control Act (WQCA) provides for the protection of all watersheds by prohibiting the discharge of pollutants into state waters unless operators obtain a water quality permit from the agency.4 Colorado defines state waters as โ€œany and all surface and subsurface waters which are contained in or flow through the state, along with certain enumerated exclusions.โ€5 Colorado specifically recognizes wetlands and those other waters under the definition of state waters as โ€œthose areas that are inundated or saturated by surface or groundwater at a frequency and duration sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstances do support, a prevalence of vegetation typically adapted for life in saturated soil conditions.โ€6 The prohibition on discharge states, โ€œno person shall discharge any pollutant into any state waters from a point source without first having obtained a permit from the division for such dischargeโ€ which makes the dredging and filling of state waters illegal.7

The fundamental problem in Colorado, however, is that there is no state permitting program that applies to the discharge of dredge and fill material into state waters. Thus, a landowner has no way to get a permit that authorizes an activity that is plainly unlawful under the Water Quality Control Act. There is no funding mechanism for a permitting program authorized by the Colorado legislature. There are no substantive standards established under state law to guide the development and implementation of a gap waters permitting program. And there are no provisions for how the public would be involved in a permitting process.

These provisions do not exist under state law, because these kinds of permits have always been issued by the Corps under the federal Clean Water Act, until now. The Supreme Courtโ€™s decision in Sackett created a gaping hole in Coloradoโ€™s program for protecting and regulating discharge and fill activities, and the current state of the law in Colorado is inadequate to fill the gap.

III. Previous and ongoing efforts to develop a state-run regulatory program

 In 2020, the Colorado Department of Public Health and the Environment (CDPHE) began a stakeholder engagement process for designing and implementing a state-run regulatory program. At that time, the Trump Administration was attempting to shrink the scope of federal jurisdiction under the Clean Water Act by amending the regulatory definition of WOTUS (i.e., the Navigable Water Protections Rule). Recognizing that this process could leave a regulatory gap in Colorado, CDPHE convened stakeholder groups and produced two white papers discussing the impact of these developments within Colorado, summarizing the stakeholder engagement process, and identifying other potential issues to be considered in designing a state wetland permitting program.

Although the process started in 2020, it did not result in legislation moving through the Colorado legislature because the Navigable Water Protections Rule was enjoined by a federal court. The federal government therefore continued to implement the 2008 version of WOTUS in Colorado up until the Sackett decision earlier this year.

In response to Sackett, CDPHE issued a policy on โ€œEnforcement of Unpermitted Discharges of Dredged and Fill Material into State Watersโ€ in July of 2023. The enforcement policy states that the division โ€œdoes not intend to take enforcement actionโ€ against unpermitted discharges if owners and operators supply notice of the activity to CDPHE and the impacts do not exceed .1 acres of wetlands or .03 acres of streambed, or if the activity would not have originally required pre-construction notification to Corps regardless of size. Applicants must provide notice to CDPHE of their intent to dredge or fill and so far, the department has only received eight notifications since the policy was implemented.8 There are many other details, and parties should review the policy carefully if they believe their activities may be covered.

This enforcement policy is, at best, a short-term solution that suffers from potential defects or concerns, including the following:

Although the process started in 2020, it did not result in legislation moving through the Colorado legislature because the Navigable Water Protections Rule was enjoined by a federal court. The federal government therefore continued to implement the 2008 version of WOTUS in Colorado up until the Sackett decision earlier this year.

In response to Sackett, CDPHE issued a policy on โ€œEnforcement of Unpermitted Discharges of Dredged and Fill Material into State Watersโ€ in July of 2023. The enforcement policy states that the division โ€œdoes not intend to take enforcement actionโ€ against unpermitted discharges if owners and operators supply notice of the activity to CDPHE and the impacts do not exceed .1 acres of wetlands or .03 acres of streambed, or if the activity would not have originally required pre-construction notification to Corps regardless of size. Applicants must provide notice to CDPHE of their intent to dredge or fill and so far, the department has only received eight notifications since the policy was implemented.8 There are many other details, and parties should review the policy carefully if they believe their activities may be covered.

This enforcement policy is, at best, a short-term solution that suffers from potential defects or concerns, including the following:

Uncertainty for the regulated community: The enforcement policy does not result in issuance of a permit, authorize the discharge, or otherwise change the status of the activity prohibited by the WQCA. This uncertainty may complicate financing and insurance arrangements and create other uncertainties for owners and operators. The policy also applies only to a subset of relatively small projects and does not clarify how other kinds of activities will be regulated.

Lack of public participation regarding notice, permitting, and enforcement: The enforcement policy does not address how the public will be notified and involved in activities that affect state waters. There are no provisions for public notice of activities, or public involvement in the regulatory or enforcement processes, which are important components of the federal program under the Clean Water Act.

There is no funding mechanism to create additional administrative capacity: The enforcement policy does not address the long-term increase in staffing and other administrative capacity for CDPHE to effectively manage a regulatory program that had previously fallen within the Corpsโ€™ purview.

Lack of substantive standards and regulatory tools like mitigation: The enforcement policy does not establish substantive standards that guide review and authorization of proposed activities, nor does it authorize the kinds of regulatory tools like wetland mitigation that the Corps and other agencies have used to ensure a no-net loss policy.9

CDPHE has also submitted a request for funding this year to provide enforcement and compliance of gap waters not currently subject to federal regulation. The money will be used for 1 FTE to perform inspections, supply oversight of the coordinated efforts of the state and federal agencies, and to hire a consultant to formulate options for regulating dredge and fill activities at the state level. While this funding is certainly not a long-term answer, Colorado is hopeful that their non-enforcement policy will provide short-term solutions until a formal regulatory program is set up.

Addressing the permitting gap with our state waters and formalizing a plan that protects them from any further degradation is vital. Part of the plan must include legislation creating a state permitting program in Colorado that ensures robust public participation and includes the procedural and substantive safeguards that provide the foundation for the federal program. If we wait too long, we may jeopardize the ecological, social, and economic values that Coloradoโ€™s unique watersheds provide to the people of the state.


[1] Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, Dredge and Fill White Paper No. 1: Colorado Dredge and Fill Permitting Considerations in Response to the 2020 Navigable Waters Protection Rule (Jan. 29, 2021), at 6, 9-10.

[2] 40 C.F.R. Part 230

[3] 33 C.F.R. ยง 320.4

[4] Colo. Rev. Stat. ยง25-8-501(1).

[5] Colo. Rev. Stat. ยง25-8-103(19).

[6] 5 Colorado Regulations 1002-31.5

[7] Colo. Rev. Stat. ยง 25-8-501(1),

[8] Telephone Interview with Kelly Morgan, Water Quality Control Division, Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (October 3, 2023).

[9] No-net loss is a practical management tool requiring the creation of new wetlands in the same or similar size to the impacted area. Mandatory mitigation programs such as the no-net loss mandate are vital because of the important function wetlands provide in the natural environment.

Download a pdf of โ€œWill Colorado Fill the Gaps in the post-Sackett World?โ€

Kansas State University to lead climate change food-strengthening initiative

Photo credit: Barn Owl Drone Services

by Rachel Mipro, Kansas Reflector
October 31, 2023

TOPEKA โ€” Kansas researchers will turn their focus to wheat, millet and other crops in a federally funded attempt to tackle world hunger.

The U.S. Agency for International Development awarded Kansas State University $22 million to research how best to promote the growth of crops as climate change and global instability continues to derail the agricultural industry.

K-State will lead the Feed the Future Climate Resilient Cereals Innovational Lab, or CRCIL, focusing on sorghum, millet, wheat and rice as major world crops that need to be protected. The university will partner with several other state universities including Cornell University and Louisiana State University, along with international partners in South Asia, Eastern and Western Africa and Latin America.

Jagger Harvey, director of CRCIL and a research professor in the Plant Pathology Department at K-State, said the project will look at ways to make these crops more resilient, including researching seed modification to help double food production and crop durability as climate conditions worsen.

โ€œKansas farmers and researchers are no strangers to harsh climatic conditions impacting cereal production,โ€ Harvey said. โ€œThis makes K-State the perfect home for this new initiative.โ€

The funding will support collaborative research, along with using plant-breeding technology, such as DNA sequencing and genotyping, crop modeling and quicker growth methods, with the end goal of providing hardier crops to farmers around the world.

Dina Esposito, USAIDโ€™s assistant to the administrator for Resilience, Environment, and Food Security, said the initiative would help tackle problems of hunger and poverty.

โ€œAdvancing this work is critical to generating a pipeline of climate-adapted crops so we can strengthen the resilience of small-scale farmers and meet their current and future needs,โ€ Esposito said. 

Jared Crain, a K-State plant pathology department research assistant professor who will serve as the associate director of the innovation lab, estimated that more than 50% of the worldโ€™s caloric intake comes from cereal crops.

โ€œWith the exception of maize, CRCIL is dedicated to identifying and using genetic variation to improve farmersโ€™ production and consumersโ€™ acceptance of the top vital cereals,โ€ Crain said.

The $22 million award is the fifth award that K-State has received through Feed the Future, a federal initiative attempting to combat world hunger. USAID has invested nearly $128 million in K-State innovation labs for research into agricultural areas such as post-harvest losses and increasing harvest yields.

Kansas Reflector is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Kansas Reflector maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Sherman Smith for questions: info@kansasreflector.com. Follow Kansas Reflector on Facebook and Twitter.

Coyotes at Twin Lakes Park

Coyote wood carving “Moon Song” at Twin Lakes Park in Adams County, October 27, 2023.

Farm bill stalled amid U.S. House speaker battle, delay of spending bills — The #Kansas Reflector

Rows of soybean plants grow in the fields at Seidenstricker Farms, owned by Robert and Cathy Seidenstricker, in De Valls Bluff, Arkansas, on June 25, 2019. (USDA photo by Lance Cheung)

by Ashley Murray, Kansas Reflector
October 6, 2023

WASHINGTON โ€” As Congress faces another pressing deadline to fund the government and the U.S. House grinds to a halt without a speaker, the reauthorization of the nationโ€™s agriculture and hunger programs has taken a back seat.

But lawmakers tasked with shepherding the new version maintain their progress is โ€œin good shape.โ€

The previous farm bill expired Sept. 30 and its renewal, a process that occurs every five years, remains โ€œin the drafting stage,โ€ said Sen. John Boozman, the Arkansas GOP lawmaker and ranking member of the Senate Committee on Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry.

โ€œI know myself and Sen. Stabenow, our teams are working together to try and get ideas in the text. And so weโ€™re moving forward,โ€ Boozman told reporters Wednesday.

Stabenow of Michigan chairs the committee.

โ€œItโ€™s been difficult because the appropriations process has kind of sucked all the wind out. But weโ€™re in good shape. We donโ€™t need an extension until the first of the year. If we do need an extension, I think weโ€™ll be looking in the November time frame as we do the CR.โ€

The CR, or continuing resolution, is the funding compromise Congress struck last weekend just hours before a partial government shutdown. The temporary spending measure expires Nov. 17.

The farm bill and long-term government funding are completely different processes, but GOP House majority infighting over appropriations has stalled other priorities.

And, with the ouster of former House Speaker and California Republican Kevin McCarthy by a handful of far-right party members and all House Democrats, the lower chamber is frozen.

โ€œAs with every Farm Bill, there are forces and circumstances out of our control. What is always a complicated process has become a little more complicated, but our work continues to produce an effective Farm Bill,โ€ said Pennsylvania GOP Rep. Glenn โ€œGTโ€ Thompson, who chairs the House Committee on Agriculture, in an emailed statement.

Worries over lack of progress 

Thompson and fellow lawmakers have spent thousands of hours over the past two years collecting feedback from constituents on what they want to see in the multi-year bill, which is forecast to cost $1.5 trillion.

But some constituents say despite reassurance that the farm bill is progressing, they remain concerned about its delay, as well as funding for several of its programs, including the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, formerly known as food stamps.

As a mandatory program, SNAP will continue as long as Congress approves either temporary or long-term government funding.

โ€œThe delay in considering important legislation, such as agriculture appropriations and the farm bill, creates a great deal of uncertainty for farmers and ranchers. The 2018 farm bill already expired,โ€ Sam Kieffer, the American Farm Bureau Federationโ€™s vice president of public policy, said in a statement.

โ€œAll families, including those in rural America, face rising interest rates, high inflation and turbulence in the marketplace,โ€ he continued. โ€œThe farm bill provides certainty to those who grow this nationโ€™s food, fuel and fiber and is crucial to ensuring a safe and affordable food supply. Congress has always come through on a farm bill, and they must do it again. Every family in America is counting on it.โ€

The 2018 farm bill was not signed into law until Dec. 20 of that year.

The expansive agricultural and food policy bill covers farmer safety net programs, conservation and sustainability incentives, international trade, rural area development, and food and nutrition programs for low-income earners โ€” the last of which accounts for the largest portion of the bill. The legislation is one of Congressโ€™ omnibus packages, meaning itโ€™s made up of numerous provisions from many lawmakers.

Kansas Reflector is part of States Newsroom, a network of news bureaus supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Kansas Reflector maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Sherman Smith for questions: info@kansasreflector.com. Follow Kansas Reflector on Facebook and Twitter.

The latest #ElNiรฑo/Southern Oscillation (#ENSO) discussion is hot off the presses from the #Climate Prediction Center

Click the link to read the discussion on the Climate Prediction Center website:

ENSO Alert System Status: El Niรฑo Advisory

Synopsis: El Niรฑo is anticipated to continue through the Northern Hemisphere spring (with an 80% chance during March-May 2024).

In September, equatorial sea surface temperatures (SSTs) were above average, though positive anomalies weakened in the eastern Pacific. All of the latest weekly Niรฑo index values remained in excess of +1.0ยบC: Niรฑo-4 was +1.2ยบC, Niรฑo-3.4 was +1.5ยบC, Niรฑo-3 was +1.9ยบC, and Niรฑo1+2 was +2.6ยบC. Area-averaged subsurface temperatures anomalies decreased, but remained above-average, consistent with elevated subsurface temperatures across the central and eastern equatorial Pacific Ocean. Tropical atmospheric anomalies were consistent with El Niรฑo. In areas of the central Pacific, low-level winds were anomalously westerly, while upper-level winds were anomalously easterly. Convection was enhanced around the International Date Line, stretching into the eastern Pacific, just north of the equator. Convection was suppressed near Indonesia. The equatorial Southern Oscillation Index (SOI) and the traditional station-based SOI were both significantly negative. Collectively, the coupled ocean-atmosphere system reflected El Niรฑo.

The most recent IRI plume favors El Niรฑo to continue through the Northern Hemisphere spring 2024. Also considering recent observations and the NMME, the team favors at least a โ€œstrongโ€ event with a 75-85% chance through November-January (โ‰ฅ1.5ยฐC for the seasonal average in Niรฑo-3.4). There is a 3 in 10 chance of a โ€œhistorically strongโ€ event that rivals 2015-16 and 1997-98 (seasonal average โ‰ฅ 2.0ยฐC). Stronger El Niรฑo events increase the likelihood of El Niรฑo-related climate anomalies, but do not necessarily equate to strong impacts locally. Consider consulting CPC seasonal outlooks for probabilities of temperature and precipitation in the coming seasons. In summary, El Niรฑo is anticipated to continue through the Northern Hemisphere spring (with an 80% chance during March-May 2024).

5 Big Threats to Rivers: Human activities have imperiled our waterways โ€” along with almost one-third of freshwater fish and many other aquatic species — The Revelator #ActOnClimate

Dam on the Kennebec River in Skowhegan, Maine. Photo: Jimmy Emerson, DVM (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Click the link to read the article on The Revelator website (Tara Lohan):

If we needed any more motivation to help save our ailing rivers, it should have come with the findings of a recent study, which revealed that โ€œNowhere is the biodiversity crisis more acute than in freshwater ecosystems.โ€

Rivers, lakes and inland wetlands cover 1% of the Earth but provide homes for 10% of all its species, including one-third of all vertebrates. And many of those species are imperiled โ€” some 27% of the nearly 30,000 freshwater species so far assessed by the IUCN Red List. This includes nearly one-third of all freshwater fish.

How did things get so bad? For some species itโ€™s a single action โ€” likeย building a dam. But for most, itโ€™s a confluence of factors โ€” an accumulation of harm โ€” that builds for years or decades.

A high desert thunderstorm lights up the sky behind Glen Canyon Dam — Photo USBR

1. Dam Obstructions

One of the single largest threats to river biodiversity comes from dams, which provide humans with electricity, water reserves and other benefits but come with ecological costs. The loss of free-flowing rivers divides watersheds into unconnected fragments and changes water flow, quality and temperature. It also blocks the transport of sediment, and can obstruct the movement of animals, including migratory fish โ€” and the species like freshwater mussels โ€” which depend on those fish.

In the United States, dam-building has imperiledย Atlantic salmonย on the East Coast as well as many runs of theย West Coastโ€™sย five salmon species. But the ripple effects can extend to aquatic insects, birds and riparian plants.

If we needed any more motivation to help save our ailing rivers, it should have come with the findings of a recent study, which revealed that โ€œNowhere is the biodiversity crisis more acute than in freshwater ecosystems.โ€

Rivers, lakes and inland wetlands cover 1% of the Earth but provide homes for 10% of all its species, including one-third of all vertebrates. And many of those species are imperiled โ€” some 27% of the nearly 30,000 freshwater species so far assessed by the IUCN Red List. This includes nearly one-third of all freshwater fish.

How did things get so bad? For some species itโ€™s a single action โ€” likeย building a dam. But for most, itโ€™s a confluence of factors โ€” an accumulation of harm โ€” that builds for years or decades.

The Cuyahoga River on fire in 1952. The river caught fire at least 13 times and helped spur an avalanche of water pollution control activities such as the Clean Water Act. Photo via the Environmental Protection Agency

2. Pollution

What happens on land doesnโ€™t stay on land.

The Clean Water Act, passed 50 years ago, has done a lot to improve the water quality of rivers in the United States, as have similar regulations around the world. But we still have a long way to go.

Some waterways remain a dumping ground for toxic chemicals, even decades after those threats were identified. Others face new threats from pharmaceuticals that pass through water treatment facilities (after passing through our bladders) and accumulate in the bodies of aquatic animals. Fish full of antidepressants is no joking matter. Neither are PFAS, so-called โ€œforever chemicals,โ€ that end up in rivers โ€” and aquatic animals โ€” after leaching from industrial sites, military bases or incinerators.

The nutrients we use on farms and livestock operations also wash into rivers and streams. That runoff, full of nitrogen and phosphorus, fuels an overgrowth of algae which deprive the waters of oxygen, driving away or killing marine life in so-called โ€œdead zones.โ€ The situation is likely to get worse as climate change fuels stronger storms and warmer waters.

Beef cattle on a feedlot in the Texas Panhandle. Photo credit: Wikimedia

3. Grazing

Waste from animal feedlots pollutes rivers, but cattle that graze on millions of acres of public and private lands across the American West โ€” and in many other nations โ€” are a threat, too.

The livestock can overgraze and trample riparian areas, leading to the loss of plants, an increase in erosion and reduced stability of streambanks. A loss of vegetation along banks increases water temperature โ€” a detriment to cold-water fish. And the sediment โ€” and sometimes waste-fill runoff โ€” threatens water quality and fish, including native trout.

Updated Colorado River 4-Panel plot thru Water Year 2022 showing reservoirs, flows, temperatures and precipitation. All trends are in the wrong direction. Since original 2017 plot, conditions have deteriorated significantly. Brad Udall via Twitter: https://twitter.com/bradudall/status/1593316262041436160

4. Climate Change

The effects of climate warming are already being felt around the world, with rivers drying up in the United States, China, Germany, France and many other nations over the past few months.

Thatโ€™s only going to get worse: In the United States, where projections show western mountains will experience a significant loss of snowpack in the next 35 to 60 years. Less snow and an earlier snowmelt will alter river flows and groundwater, which will affect numerous plants and animals across the region.

Some of those same species are already suffering from other harms from human development. Salmon, for example, that have been cut off from cold-water upstream habitat by dams are now further imperiled as low water flows heat up the rivers to temperatures that endangered the fish.

A view of Foothills Mobile Home Park, which suffered a total loss during the September 2013 flood in Lyons. (Courtesy of town of Lyons)

Heavy rainstorms supercharged by climate change can also cause flooding that sweeps sediment, chemicals and other harmful runoff into rivers and creeks. These storms can cause municipal sewage systems to be overwhelmed and discharge untreated water into rivers.

Warming temperatures can also exacerbate droughts, limiting water for drinking, irrigation and maintaining healthy flows in rivers and streams to support wildlife.

Magpie river. Credit Boreal-River via The Conservation Alliance

5. Not Enough Protections

We may love our rivers, but we simply donโ€™t afford them enough protection. Laws and regulations offer piecemeal measures, and funding for river-conservation programs remains elusive. Efforts to establish legal โ€œpersonhoodโ€ for rivers havenโ€™t gained much traction and some of our existing tools havenโ€™t been utilized effectively.

In the United States, far less than one-half of 1% of the countryโ€™s river miles have been protected under the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act, established in 1968. The law can help protect rivers and their banks from new dams and mining claims, and often from logging and roadbuildling.ย New legislative effortsย in Congress to expand the program, including theย River Democracy Act, have yet to move forward. Other nations have proposed their own new laws, but whether theyโ€™ll pass โ€” or do enough โ€” remains to be seen.


Of course, the risks to waterways are as varied as the ecosystems themselves. To find out more about threats to our rivers โ€” and ways to protect and restore them โ€” check out this selection of stories from our archives:

Set It Back: Moving Levees to Benefit Rivers, Wildlife and Communities

A Historic Chance to Protect Americaโ€™s Free-Flowing Rivers

Another Dam(n) Extinction

Let Rivers Flood: Communities Adopt New Strategies for Resilience

Hundreds of Planned Dams Threaten Central Americaโ€™s Last Free-Flowing Rivers

What Happens to Wildlife Swimming in a Sea of Our Drug Residues?

Strengthening Mussels for Cleaner Rivers

Granting Legal Rights to Rivers: Is International Law Ready?

Is it Too Late to Save โ€˜Americaโ€™s Amazonโ€™?

Could Cleaning the Tigris River Help Repair Iraqโ€™s Damaged Reputation?

On the Clean Water Actโ€™s 50th Birthday, What Should We Celebrate?

Californiaโ€™s Reliance on Dams Puts Fish in Hot Water

โ€˜Thereโ€™s No Memory of the Joy.โ€™ Why 40 Years of Superfund Work Hasnโ€™t Saved Tar Creek